Actually it is both from this concert AND UABRS (the CD). Only 2 of the 8 songs (Gloria & Party Girl) were recorded at Red Rocks in Colorado. 5 songs including this one are from a German concert and one is from Boston. Check the liner notes of the CD.
@rovvy This was sung around the same time as their version on UABRS, so the audio would be similar. In UABRS, Bono did change one line in the lyrics when he sang "Under the thunder cloud and rain", instead of "Under a blood red sky" which I felt was the reason why they opted to go with this version on the CD instead of the one at Red Rocks.
@rovvy I disagree......if so, the lip syching & piano playing is a pretty darn good copy ... "rookie" bands" more or less in that era (and earlier) played as close to the record as possible for the fans sake ........ look at bands all the way from Booker T & the MG's all the way to the Subways .... I do agree that the length of the song is very close..... thats all ...... cheers, my friend.
Thank-You for posting xo
TheMissShevy 2 months ago
happy new year 2012 youtube fans
ogdjjohnnyflashback 2 months ago
damn good quality for its age.. its awesome..
JasonDrealdeal 4 months ago
was great in nyc when the apple rose...was there Brilliant
AWYMARI3HORN 5 months ago
muy buena calidad!
popo864 7 months ago
MUY BUENO!, VERY,VERY GOOD!..U2 TODA LA VIDA..
isabelsiete85 11 months ago
My mistake.............this was recorded at Red Rocks....sorry rowy..... I am as red as my sweater ! No excuses on my part !
dtsecofr21 1 year ago
Es la mejor version en vivo de esta epica canción, U2 live 4ever!
BlueSkyNighWind0104 1 year ago
ostias q pedazo de banda , unas de sus mejores canciones q mas me gustan
khune1974 1 year ago
a stos les tendrian k santificar U2 para siempre!!!
mollejin94 2 years ago
one of the best song ever
markomarkovic2008 2 years ago
Edge rocks! I like that he can play both keyboards and guitar in one song.
jastrebok 2 years ago
cooool!
BulatSa 2 years ago
This sounds like the audio from Under A Blood Red Sky. This audio is not from this concert.
rovvy 2 years ago
Actually it is both from this concert AND UABRS (the CD). Only 2 of the 8 songs (Gloria & Party Girl) were recorded at Red Rocks in Colorado. 5 songs including this one are from a German concert and one is from Boston. Check the liner notes of the CD.
cdeaner66 2 years ago
@cdeaner66 Correct !
Moonraker1974 1 year ago
@rovvy This was sung around the same time as their version on UABRS, so the audio would be similar. In UABRS, Bono did change one line in the lyrics when he sang "Under the thunder cloud and rain", instead of "Under a blood red sky" which I felt was the reason why they opted to go with this version on the CD instead of the one at Red Rocks.
Rometiklan 1 year ago
@rovvy I disagree......if so, the lip syching & piano playing is a pretty darn good copy ... "rookie" bands" more or less in that era (and earlier) played as close to the record as possible for the fans sake ........ look at bands all the way from Booker T & the MG's all the way to the Subways .... I do agree that the length of the song is very close..... thats all ...... cheers, my friend.
dtsecofr21 1 year ago
Great song, even greater performance!
LOL! I don't think he's naked
patrik1345 2 years ago
4:05 is there a naked guy at the back of the stage?? lmao
GREAT song!
eleduel 2 years ago