Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (2,703)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wow, i'm one of her avid fans also....

  • ¡Immmmmmpresionante!. Que pulmones tiene esta chica.

  • PEOPLE SHOULD STOP COMPARING ONE GREAT ARTIST WITH ANOTHER.

  • they're both very good.. so stop comparing these singers.. if u know hu's better then shut up becoz u can't sing like the other one.. ok????

  • Beyonce all the way, I'm a great admirer of Charice's singing but their pitch control is incomparable here.

  • Come on.. everybody can hear that Beyoncé has an much better voice!

  • LET US NOT COMPARE THE TWO GREAT SINGERS. They are singing for us, to bring happiness, and I hope neither one of them would not follow the path of our Angelic Singer Whitney Houston. Everyone has each own CHOICE. So let us respect them. I know that everyone is entitled to share their opinion but for sure neither of us would love to be compare with anyone.

  • Beyonce is far matured,a well experienced woman compared to Charice. B has fell in love,perhaps have thought of settling down as well.Those emotions would continually express on her face.The emotions will bring up to render a good way of singing. C as we all know have the voice, and she could actually express her feelings in her own way which I think is amazing for her age. If Charice had the experience of being a complete grown-up woman, am sure she could sing more,better than she sang before.

  • Leirnard04, take a break!!!! Charice has better singing voice... beyonce has the soul of being beyonce... in time, charice will keep up with beyonce's soul!!! but beyonce wud never keep up with charice's voice...

  • salma version is much better than charice.....watch this...Mentor 5 - Final - Salma - Listen

  • Now let me make this CLEAR: I AM NOT BEING RACIST HERE! But as I noticed, Filipinos have these impression that hitting d highest note makes you d best singer. Gosh! Now I'm not trying 2 diss Charice, I have nothing against her, but I think B's better. B has got more control of her voice and she's got a playful style of singing.

  • Y don't try comparing Charice's Listen to Regine's or Sarah's or Alexandra Burke's? That's when d real competition starts!

  • I don't undrtsnd y people r comparing cover versions 2 d original?! Is it bcoz Charice hits higher notes than B? So ignorant! You can never compare the original 2 a cover! I am a die hard B stan, but if B would sing Charice's Pyramid, I'd choose Charice's, because she's d best singer of HER song! Or if Whitney(RIP) ever sang Celine's My Heart Will Go On with higher notes, yes she could've given justice 2 it, But Celine's will always be better, will always be the best! That's just the way its!

  • As the italians said.. She didnt recieve a gift from God, she IS a gift from God. Beyonce have the merits, Charice has the voice.

  • tama ka abrorbek1900

  • Charice!

  • I say this Beyonce owns this song, but I think Charice just stole it. However with all respect to Beyonce, Charice can only beat Beyonce if she can have as many song hits as Beyonce, but I am pretty sure Charice will reach that level in the future.

  • charice is the beast

  • LOL people need to understand the difference between a God-gifted singer to a talented performer...the gifted singer only uses her voice and then blew the audience and then get a standing ovation...while the talented performer uses her body, wear a nice dress and then try to act live a diva and then get the appreciation from the crowd..

  • Charice is AMAZING but you can't compare her with Beyonce ! She has a lot to learn before being better than her... if she can

  • Beyonce is great but Charice is an EXPLOSION!!!!! love her version.....

  • This video simply shows me why Beyonce deserves all this respect the world has given her. <3 /tears up

  • It's strange how I never noticed before. Really, though. Her pitch control is absolutely spot on. I've never really been a huge Beyonce fan, but that was amazing. Charise is really good, but her pitch control needs years to develop :)

  • That first Beyonce solo was absolutely, absolutely flawless/

  • Love U Beyonce! U r Beautiful............

  • what's wrong comparing you (western) to us Asians !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?????.... or shall i say...you're nothing compared to Asians

  • @megabarado dear, as much as I'm proud to be an Asian, don't you think it's a bit too much to say they're(western) nothing compared to Asians?

  • Comment removed

  • nxt time hope you cracked your avs.. :)

  • Charice has a very good voice, but NO where near, not even fucken close to B hahahah,she has a better quality, Charice just tryna copy Bees vocals, she should try make the song her own.

  • @jbl01456 nu-uh. she ain't copying anything. that's just how she sings.

  • Beyonce = Studio version

    Charice = Live version

    Simple as that..

  • @archidexterous20 beyonce's was live you dickhead. Beyonce is a lengend and shouldn't be compared to some east asian wonder ok. Charice is good but she will never be on beyonce's level PERIOD

  • @s331052 LOL Calmdown Asshole ...it's my opinion , i don't care if beyonce is better to you WTF you saying Beyonce is Legend ? fuck that she's not even close to true singers like Whitney and Mariah.

  • @archidexterous20She's a fucking icon bitch She has sold over 125 million albums worldwide. How much has charice sold? none. I'm guessing your asain b/c it seems asains have problems with being too nationalistic. They think just cuz a singer is asain means their the best. Well that's bullshit and you fucking know it. Beyonce can't be considered a legend now because she is actually relevant in the music industry In 10 years she will be a legend You watch and see you hating bitch

  • @archidexterous20 I'M CONFUSED BECAUSE BOTH ARE PERFORMING LIVE AND THIS IS BETTER THEN THE STUDIO VERSION. PLEASE EXPLAIN...

  • look out B.....

  • omg charice is giving me goosebumps, she is a force 2 b reckoned with

  • I enjoyed Beyonce's performance better, but Charice is a good singer

  • Esta Musica Ficou Melhor na Voz d Charice de quer na Voz d Byonce ela conta d Mais Charice

  • it's amazing how someone can have so much talent and beauty; God definitely placed those attributes onto the right person. I'm not sure too many other indiviuals could remain as kind, humble, and graceful as she does.

  • lets be real. beyonce is a step below celine and whitney. Charice is The next celine and whitney.

  • beyonce is very famous, n talented...but for me charis voice much stronger...n don't forget that she is still young, if she keeps on it...when she gets beyonce's age she'll even more great than beyonce)

  • @Abrorbek1990 i dont think charice will get better.

    u can feel it in her voice that thats were shes supose to be

    sry for my english

  • @Abrorbek1990

    May be later but now I don't think her voice is stronger than Beyonce's one /: You may listen it again ^^'

  • @Abrorbek1990 i dont think stronger (shouting is not strong). i think beyonce is just in better control of her voice. shes the master, not the voice.

  • Charice rendition of this song, for me, far outshines Beyonce's version. BRAVO!!!

  • Charice is child with the same voice like that of Beyonce, Whitney, Celine so that makes her better!

  • @ambrosiana94 charice is great, she really is, but not that great!

    Beyonce wil always be better..

    And legends like Celine Dion and Whitney Houston can not be compared to any of these younger new singers. They are the ultimate Diva Legends!!

  • Just different but they both very good!

  • Charice is no Beyonce... but on the same note Beyonce is no Charice.

  • Let's not compare but just enjoy both performances, there's only one Beyonce and there's only one Charice, both are unique.

  • Plssss put this video up for mobile?? Im on an airplane and i have 16 hrs left!! Plssssss with cherry on top? :-))

  • If Charice was smokin hot then this wouldnt be a discussion. Looks is everything the music business

  • It looks like Beyonce's lip singing

  • @dianadylandd First of all, it's synching not singing. Second, beyonce never lip syncs!

    ever!

  • how old is Charice in this video?

  • charice is an incredible singer, she hits notes i cant even dream of! But Beyonce is Beyonce, and I think the original will always be the best. Beyonce FTW! ;D

  • well, Charice's ending alone beats Beyonce's,...period!

  • nothing beats the original...

  • im american and i think charice did it better i felt hers more

  • sana maka duet ko kayong pareho.. :)

  • It doesn't matter if Charice is a kid or not, american or not, we respond to this stupid comparing video as Beyonce's fans : Charice is a good schoolar singer, and Beyonce is an artist with feelings, personnality, and specific vocal range. So, we can't compare both of them.

  • @MyFrikky charice she start to sing at 4 or 5 years old age so we knew that shes good but u knw no 1 is perfect anyway i love beyonce but charice is better than beyonce

  • whats the song in the beginning???

    

  • Comment removed

  • just shut up everyone trying to figure out who is "better" than the 2! are U ALL that STUPID??? Both ladies have unique voices! amazing talent! There's never a "better" but just a "DIFFERENT"....so annoying reading your stupid comments!!

  • @ChristinaPimpTv ooooOOOOMG that is funny what u wrote there....lol

  • It's so stupid to read these comparisons. Charice is a kid! She's not American and yet she has won her place among international stars already....for all Americans here: do you have any idea how hard it is for a non-American to make it in an American-dominated international market? I LOVE Beyonce but I hate 90% of her assholic fans obsessed with demonstrating no one can beat her. It's so lame, fucking band of zombies. Cut it. It must be truth there are subliminal messages in Bey's music.

  • @itzaramaja r u racist????.. and so wat if Charice is not American???...

  • @miczcess wtf??? who's talking about racism here?? Read well, I'm not attacking her, on the contrary, I support her, and I have nothing against American singers neither. All I'm talking about is a real fact: the media worldwide are controlled by the USA, so it's much easier to become an international figure if you're American than if you're in another country. That's why Charice's accomplishments are even more amazing for me. She's so young and yet her talent has taken her far.

  • Beyonce is a big STAR and sings good but not a genius like the other girl.

    She is only 15 years old here and nobody else can top this performance any more.

    *amen*

  • @egynyilas

    Your comment doesn't make any sense : how can you say that Beyonce was not a genius ? She reached high notes from the age of 8... You just should go see her archive videos, she has a powerful and special voice since she was very young.

  • @MyFrikky but Charice also, in the age of 4 she reached already high notes!

  • i think charice will be one of the legends one day maybe 2020 lol cool

  • I'm sure most people will agree that Charice has a very powerful voice. But I think Beyonce is much more controlled and polished when it comes to singing this song. Beyonce is controlling the hell out of this song!!! She gives me chills!!! And she's not screaming or pitchy.

  • @jamesfriendbrown123 Beyonce's had like 15 years more than Charice to practice vocal technique and high belted tones.....maybe that's the reason she sounds more "controlled"?

  • a lot of people are on denial....

  • I'm not the big fan of Beyonce,but for me she's better.

  • esta niña es Geneal mis respetos, me encanta su pinche voz....... yo quiero el tip para poder sacar las palabras altas, por que me cuesta uno y la mitad del otro :S!!!

  • cmon, they r awesome <3

  • Charice has a great voice, but you cannot and I repeat CANNOT compare her to Beyonce. Beyonce is the Queen and that is something you just don't do.

  • @n1c9j0 You can compare voices they are both human beings

  • i think people need to stop comparing those two people... i think that Beyonce is beautiful and have good voice... but Charice is lacking on beauty but she's a better singer that Beyonce...

  • ela e uma diva como edy sex

  • Charise is really great,but Beyonce is the queen..There is no person who could ever sing this song better than Beyonce! :))

  • do we need to argue about this topic? it's obvious! beyonce is 1 million times better! 

  • love B and Charice!!♥

  • 好可怕的轉音阿[讚]

  • beyonce the queen ... charice my princess ..the best rendition

  • i am SO sorry but charice is no beyonce. yes she can sing VERY well for her age, but beyonce is the queen. she sang her OWN song like perfection because..it is HERS. beyonce has way more control over her voice and she doesn't struggle on high notes. you can understand beyonce 100% clearly when she is belting her notes..you can't understand charice as clearly.

  • cherice voice is better but still beyonce has star quality

  • You are an angle who always gives a chance to people. I see this clip and I absolutely admit that you are the super star.

  • beyonce sang like lipsing if you notice that ....

  • fuck they are amazing! *-*

  • BEYONCE IS FUCKING BEST BEYONCE IS THE QUEEN AND AMAZIING

  • One more thing, Beyonce has sold millions of records and writes her OWN songs!

  • Charice is a great talent, but give me a break, she is no Beyonce! Beyonce has been around for 20 years in the business. Almost unheard of these days. Don't compare these two. Let' just enjoy these two sensational singers!

  • @calroach1 I completely agree with you.Every singer has a particular performance. Don't compare and keep your idol in your heart.

  • charice is nothing COMPARE to BEYONCE.. QUEEN BEE ALL THE WAY ..

    charice cant even dance and perform like BEYONCE did..

  • Im a Beyonce fan. But Charice nailed it! No doubt.

  • charice all the way!

    God! she gave me goosebumps...

  • i don't think this is a fair comparison. they have totally different ages, are in totally different stages of their lives, are pursuiting different things, are leading their carreers in different directions. i'd totally vote for beyonce, though, her performance was so real! she has much more than a voice and she's a truly mature artist.

  • Beyonce sang it well, Charice perfected it!

  • B has too much reverb echo much

  • I'm not sure but it looks like Beyonce does lip sync here..am both Beyonce and Charice fanatic!!!!

  • @0129mhe i think this video has lag to it

  • amazing charice wow

  • чувств больше у Charice - она поет в живую!!!!а Beyonce под фонограмму!!!!Чарисе удачи!мега талант!)

  • BEYONCE performance was emotive and beautifully sung..everything else is just imitation

  • Amazing !

  • beyonce even though charice might have a powerful voice beyonce is a true artist

  • Beyonce better than Charice

  • go CHARICE :)

  • #TeamBeyonce~

  • i don't like that other girl..nothin special,no emotion..just singing. She has good voice but i don't feel the song.

  • Comment removed

  • is beyonce can sing tose songs of mariah carrey, whitney houston, celine dion, kelly clarkson, etc as good as charisce???

    i don't think so!!!

  • @eemmaannhh Are you kidding me? Beyoncé wouldnt even sing songs from Kelly Clarkson and Celine Dion lol. She's a legend.

  • CHARICE!!! <3

  • beyonce no tiene comparacion idolaaaaa tea amoooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!! :D

  • - I Love Beyonce, but I think Charice is better than her :D

  • @iAmRJ23 Well no offends but are you seriously saying Charice is better than B? Like I know Charice is awesome she really is and I love her but B is still the Queen for me. But sure maybe Charice could overcome her one day....

  • @BleSSingable NC :D

  • Beyonce! <3

  • beyonce la canta mucho mejor

  • Sorry Beyoncé, I'll let you finish, but Charice has one of the best and incredible voices of all time!

  • Both great talents!

  • charice best vocals hitting the notes so flawless and chills!!! :))) but doesnt mean i dont love beyonce she's beyonce...

  • i so love Bee...and im proud of Charice!

  • YEAH SHE GAVE ME GOOSE BUMPS RYT NOW! GRRRRRR

  • chariceeee!!you gave me goose bumbs

  • yaaaaaaaaa

  • CHARICE!!! OMG!!! You are amazing!!! You never fail to impress us! You are sooo great!!! xx

  • Wow!!! Charice

  • I got goosebumps only for the second part even though I thought Beyonce did better.

  • I think both are amazing, i just want to listen to their voice and enjoy their performance.

  • charice WOW!

  • sorry beyonce but charice is thousands of times better than your sorry

  • @1802fafa damn right

    

  • @chryzwreck just so you know, your suffering RETARD-ISM. get a life. nobody in the western lover SG, even in asia, she's only popular in the philipines. not that nobody havent heard of her, i did and some other did, i guess even david foster did, but nobody care to give her serious attention, not that she's not good, it's just that she's not spectacular. on the other hand, me and the rest of the worlds thinks and feels that charice is beyond amazing!

  • @chryzwreck btw, it's just rude to say charice is suffering dwarfism, if that's so i believe half of your country, and asian population are suffering dwarfism cuz charice's height is kinda normal amongst asian female.but nevermind, you're just a 'Typical pinoy', anyways says that charice is not good enough, she's just lucky, she's ugly, her english sucks,etc2. as if you pinoys are so great in every way. infact she's amazing! when the world can see that, but pinoy couldnt see. i wonder why. LOL.

  • @fashmark THUMBS UP!

  • theyre both amazing k?!

  • i try to fake a goosebumps on the 2nd half of the video..

    but failed to do so.

  • The thing with most artist these days is they use technology to make them sound better.... so when they perform live, you don't get the same sound you hear from the actual recordings. Charice on the other hand, can perform the same voice you hear from her songs and covers from other artist and hear a studio quality voice from a live performance with no autotune needed.

  • @PinoyPlaya4LifeTV

    Did you hear Beyonce live her voice is the Best when she sings Live.

  • GUYS!! IT'S BEYONCE'S SONG NO MATTER HOW MANY TIMES CHARICE TRIES TO SING IT. SO ... :))

  • woow Charice sounds 100 times greater than beyonce. just woow.

  • We're proud of you Charice....

  • beyonce is amazing...but when you just see her you kinda expect to hear such a a voice coming from her...but every time i hear charice i just stay dazzled... goosebumps all over my body...never get used to that voice coming from such a small body...

  • wow ,,,ang galing nmn.

  • good !

  • Why are people even comparing? Bey will always be the Queen people KNOW that and Charice is simply amazing.

  • .

    ..

    ...

    @RachyxRachy

    Why are people even comparing? Sarah Brightman will always be the Queen people KNOW that and the rest not.

    ...

    ..

    .

  • WOW JUST WOW TO CHARICE I am truly wowed....

  • Arrasou!

    

  • carolina soto chilean ..look..

  • I wish Charice will also cover Barbara Streisand songs...:) I wonder how she would nail them like she does with Celine, Whitney, and Mariah Carey songs. :) So exciting!