Nightwish - She Is My Sin (Philadelphia, PA) 10/16/07

[pasqualebrow1230]

I want this video on my XDA Stellar phone.

[SimoPepi11]

bla bla 

[quietus11]

roflmao!

captain obvious here! XDDDD

oh thats pretty obvious sheisnt tarja, parents chse to give her another name :DD

[Oomka]

She isn't Tarja anyway. IMHO.

[melnnix]

Anyone who thrash talk Nightwish now, should just stop listening, it's not like there's someone forcing you to listen.

Anette is great but if you don't like, by all means, don't listen, simple as that.

People wave their freedom of speech as if it was a war flag, i still am of the opinion of "You don't have nothing good to say, by all means, don't say anything" It's cruel and senseless what some people do with their umpleasing comments...

[demonianray]

Yeah...Anette sucks and that's why the people cheer... -_- damn... people are way to crybabies about this whole Anette-Tarja thing, Anette has gotten a whole lot better this year.

[SaharaNw]

tomalo o dejalo..

if u dont like annete dont listen to her =)

NIGHTWISH RULES!!

[andy119933]

dude i was right there

i was like feet away from you

great concert great band

[Arghina]

this just dosn't sound right...

[lullaluna]

Anette's voice does not suit Nightwish! It lacks epicness. It's 100% pop. Jessica Simpson could have sang in NW and I wouldn't hear the difference at all.

[Natteoenske]

Wow, lullaluna, you really have alot of baaaaad energy.. And what the hell do you mean with "or even Sharon" ??? Sharon has an fantastic voice, and so does Anette. You know, you don't have to sing classical to be in metal right?

[lullaluna]

Some other poster said that Nightwish could cover Evanescence now. They could. Why does Anette sound so totally different on stage compared to what she sounds like when she's on CD??? Nightwish should have thought more when they hired a new singer. But I suspect that they want commerciality, not quality. I am still loving Stargazers, Wanderlust and all the old songs that got me attracted to Nightwish. Anette's voice does not have the same depth as other metal vocalists. I get bored easily of it.

[lullaluna]

It may not be her voice that is the main problem. It may be her SINGING STYLE. It is too hip. Too mainstream. Too down-to-earth. Too normal. Too pop/RnB/hip hop/country whatever. And I feel that Anette doesn't have the same uniqueness as Tarja when it comes to style. Even if Tarja wasn't interested in metal (like a metal vocalist should be) she did at least give the band an unique quality with both her voice and her clothes. Anette is just "dressing up" to look metal (well. her clothes look emo)

[lullaluna]

Nightwish could have as well hired Beyonce or Christina Aguilera. It would not make a difference. They sing in the same way and style as Anette. The only difference is that Anette isn't promoting her sexuality the same way. This chest-voice singing does not suit the genre she is singing. I have heard some songs from Alyson Avenue (her former band) and she was much better there because her voice suited the music she was singing. And Anette ALWAYS fails to reach the right note. On every concert.

[lullaluna]

Shame on NW for hiring Anette! She is not BAD but she cannot compare to tarja, Floor, Simone, Sabine and even Sharon. The problem is not that she cannot reach the high notes or does not sing opera. The problem is that her voice COMPLETELY LACKS epic quality. It sounds plain and simple and it doesn't suit metal. It sounds too down-to-earth and it does not suit with fantasy, scifi, dark, gothic themed or epic lyrics. When I hear her voice I think love songs, songs about boyfriends breaking up etc.

[darkred83]

lulla, if they would have gotten a tarja copy you´ll be complaining about that!I like both of them, they are great in their own ways. And I am very glad nightwish had the courage to try something new. as I have said so many times,if you dont like it dont watch but let us enjoy without your moaning thankyouverymuch

[2insomniac3]

Excuse me... should anyone have Sleeping Sun from Philadelphia version? Couple of weeks ago there was an exelent and long version ( 4 minutes and good zoom and quality )here on Youe Tube but now there are gone... :((( help me please... maybe someone download this before...

[Thrivesweden]

Anette is very good! Sings like Mikael Kiske =D

[DonnieDarko1310]

Ok, Anette sounded very good on DPP.

Judging by this video though? She will sound AMAZING on the next album. You can hear her doing more little impressive technical things with her voice that show she's better than ever.

[SleetasSoul]

Ah shit no that wasn't Spam :D and forget that 'out-looking', I thought it was corrected... ^^

Oh I forgot, Tuomas IS and stays sexy *HRRR* ^^

[SleetasSoul]

Well, I (or the most) say she's good because at least I have an idea what singing is about... seemingly some here don't have. Otherwise they would know that Annette's doing a great job. She isn't trained as Tarja still she's not using her head voice. That's pretty impressive. It's okay if you don't like Annette but she DOES very well in this case. Must be very exhausting for her to sing at this stage. I must say, I'm very proud... out-looking... well, all of it I guess, she's amazing =)

[ValerioMean1990]

she is amazing!!!!!!!!

[floorjansen2]

you are so idiot, be still the old song, and the passion like before, tarja is the best, but she is out, and nightiwish live, with the old and new fans, this good version

[konczeizs]

just like a Scooter concert...terrible

[lacr1ma5]

nightwish is "dead"

[DOPO66]

No Nightwish was so good as dead in 2005. And the reason was Tarja. This is a serios attempt to bring the band alive again.

[xMrDonutx]

Emmpu is a sex beast XD

and All you who keep talking crap about Anette just lay off, you have to remember that shes not

Tarja, shes a different person, the songs still sound amazing. You have to remember that Anette isnt classicly ctrained like Tarja was. Shes still amazing.

[Baluh317]

Anette, please quit and save this band from dying

P.S. You sound like a dying frog

[kingaksu]

please save urself before u become an ugly bitch.

[tkny23]

OW OW OW OW OW!!!

my god that's painful!!!how can yall say she's good???she is beyond terrible!!!she's little miss screech!!!

~t

[normantteri]

absolutely fantastic :)<3

[VladimirSkaletsky]

Huh! Not half as bad as I expected! She'll be just fine, I think.

[darksideofthemoon28]

anette is pretty...

[VladimirSkaletsky]

Yep. I'd TOTALLY hit that.

[theavelfairy]

XD lol Emmpu.

[TheGorgo]

ouf !

ethsgrl lol I was about to say that I imagined it would have been worse but that was before listening the chorus.

I agree with you ! it was better with tarja !

[ethsgrl]

i really think people are crazy to say it's better now than with tarja.. even the guys won't say that, it's different with anette it doesn't mean it's bad and it doesn't mean it's better either... personally i like tarja better but anette is okay and in few months she'll be great :)

[noeliaelvenpath]

Nightwish tenía un sonido peculiar con la voz de Tarja, ahora es solo un grupo más con voz popera. Seguiré fiel a sus discos anteriores pero no a los nuevos, para mi es un grupo totalmente diferente

[kingaksu]

This is better than with Tarja so shut up u little mommy babies:(

[ancientWM]

badbones75

you nooob dude, fucked you self please!!!!

ты сука тупая, и скажу почему,тарью сука тупая не трогай! а то я бабла не пожалею и приеду к тебе где ты бы не находился и порву! вот и вали слушай свой опопсевшый найтвиш!

[ancientWM]

Tarja come back

Tarja come back

Tarja come back

Tarja come back

-----------------

[Vildenos]

MUHAHAHAHH YOU LOST :D

[Drankenstone]

horrible

[evangelition]

its truth, anette hasnt the voice to sing this song...hasnt the force enough...her voice is very thin

[Sexynails00]

Are you crazy??? this is the best song of nightwish! and only tarja can sing this song!

Anette not have the voice to sing this song!

[badbones75]

This version is better than the original with Tarja....I think that Nightwish has made a good singer choice...WELCOME ANETTE, I LOVE YOU

[Sidderzx]

I love Anette's voice. Especially in this song.

[p0lyn0]

Good job guys !

[Rakunya]

She is my Sin is one of two songs I didn't like from Wishmaster. Annette fixed that for me. Hooray for Annette!

Also, I'm somewhere in this view, I just can't quite find where...

[Fewere]

how many was in the crowd?

[narakuANGEL89]

it was a pretty small place, i was in the very front center so i didnt turn around much, but from what i could tell maybe in the 300's.

[tommycheesus524]

I was at this show, it was amazing! Haha and the dude who filmed this had his camera taken like halfway through the set.

[arcanadia]

This is really awesome! Anette suits this song quite well. I like it :)

[protoner]

HEY Sounds better than other songs....wow....i can give her a chance.

:)

[kimandclea]

her version is the best, love it, great quality video too, thanks for sharing

[ASNSWTANGL26]

I LOVE IT TOO!!!!!!

[sanshine12]

oh... this vocal... kitten's meow