I agree...civilian casualties of war are very unfortunate, and the first casualty of war is the TRUTH...what is this bitch reporter think she is doing? ..getting an award for best journalism. Of course these people are lying to discredit the Aussie troops.
Fuck you go out there while having civilian looking fucks shooting at you with ak's then make a split decision in .225 of a second if they are civil or not. Once bullets are whizzing over your head from or directions and have you pinned down make sure not to hit any civilians. Common Taliban is the real reason civilians die as they fight dirty rather then fair. If they grew some balls and made a frontline they would get wiped out in no time ,so they use guerrilla tactics and civis like cowards
@rangers11000 u have no idea what the fuck your on about.u sound like a fucken 12 year old.show some resect to the people that have died for our countries and ther families u dumb fuck
with a name like that u are a total idiot. Who thought of that yah dumb god fuch the koran and Allah i heard he takes it in the arse anyway. i wish i could dip my bullets in pig blood and then shoot you. U dont see any boats from our country landing on your shores do you. No thats right u all want to come here. My hat goes off to all the Aussie troops and its allies in this fight. I commend u.
with a name like that u are a total idiot. Who thought of that? yah dumb god. fuck the koran and Allah i heard he takes it in the arse anyway. i wish i could dip my bullets in pig blood and then shoot you. U dont see any boats from our country landing on your shores do you. No thats right u all want to come here. My hat goes off to all the Aussie troops and its allies in this fight. I commend u.
@308skippy Mate, I am Australian, and I don't understand the context of your arguement (Then again, an arguement on youtube is inevitable yes, why follow it?) And I have nothing but respect for the Aussie troops, the the degree where I've enlisted. But what you said was wrong. This episode is stupid, and full of bais, but man, you can't go round saying shit like that.
This story is light weight. When are media people going to be versed in the military art? Once upon a time, all Australian channels had well experienced war/security correspondents, not girls just out of school. They have to do more than report, they have to draw on learning and experience. An example in this is the questioning of the doctor.
He should have been asked the calibre of the rounds in the the dead and wounded, for the AK47 of the Taliban is not used by Americans or Australians.
who said Australia is allowed to have troops at all? Canada did a much much better job in Afganistan. Australians have absolutly no military backround, where the fuck were you when WWII happened.
open a fucking history book before you ask a stupid fucking question. We have one of the most successful military historys than any other country...u must b american..
Canadian troops were attached to Australian Units in WWI in the battle of Le Hamel. It was Australian AND Canadian troops who then went on to break the Hindenburg Line.
Australia was fighting the Japanese AND the Germans in WWII. We inflicted the 1st defeat on the *ENTIRE* German Army at the Siege of Tobruk we then shipped those same troops over to PNG and inflicted the 1st defaet of the Japanese Army in 400 years at the Battle of Milne Bay.
Anyways , I've been working with the Aus and as far as I can see Aus diffenetly need to work on their skills. I'm sure you have lost men which i fully respect that, but military skill is something you guys need to work on;however, I can be wrong.
The Battle of Le Hamel was the battle that broke the back of the Germans. It was commanded by, arguably the greatest general of WWI, Sir John Monash, the first general to be knighted in the field by the king of England in 500 years!
Lloyd George the English Prime Minister was going to appoint him the Chief of the General Staff over his English officers.
In two world wars the USA arrived in time for afternoon tea, and the first troops into Iraq in 2003 were the Australian SAS.
ha ha the first troops into iraq were the australian sas nahhhhh,have you never seen bravo two zero.andy mcnabb was sent into iraq before any other special forces including americans.the australians wernt even in iraq you idiot.
@rangers11000 Oh yeah and it went well for McNabb too didn't it mate? His team got fucked up by incompetence and he ran off to save himself. The guy is gutless.
and its the UK you idiot not england.you act like you know shit but you dont even know the name of the land she owns.idiot,.and the ozzy sas cant match up to the british sas,we fucking train you cunts,and nato has named the british sas the best trained special forces in the world.
australia doesnt have a great military history,it was britain who had a great military history and you were only fighting because the british owend you.
Australia was involved in alot of battles in WWII!
the first time the japs retreated in ww2 was fighting the australians,
the australians walked over the french foreign legion in beirut, you ever herd of the rats of tobruk? guess who they are...dude i could go on and on and on look it up ffs before saying stupid things...seriously im embarassed 4 u..
@rangers11000 gee mate thats going back along time ago,way to hang on to that one...besides if it werent for the americans ud be speaking german to me right now...all the british did was drink tea and get a daily load of V2 rockets in the face and tag along on american missions. good stuff
This female reporter annoys the crap out of me, she sounds very amateur. Civilian casualties and collateral damage are not what anyone wants, unfortunately it can happen in war. Sometimes we must call in air strikes to save Aussie troops lives. If the Taliban want to shoot at us, we'll shoot at them. All civilian deaths in war deserve an open and thorough investigation.
its all about hazaras.....we own the country....and when the dumb ass westerners realize that we are the ones .... we will teach you a lesson ...one by one...how a modern muslim democratic country really should work.....make dubai look like our sisters
I support the Western Armies. While I could not say I implicitly trust these governments to tell us everything that goes wrong when they attempt to engage hostile forces, I can say that I remember September 11th and how the Afghanis allowed their state to become a haven for terrorist masterminds and such goatf#@$ing morons as live in that region of the world. I believe it is wrong for innocents to die, or any one not bearing arms against Western troops or convicted of crimes...
not western armies, but it is the western governments who have been privatized. Now the governments are sending the brave armies of the people to protect corporate interests. and that is horrible. The people in the armies are not generally bad, it is the rich money worshippers in office who are bad
They bought it on themselves. If their government could police the country properly and rid it of all the terrorist scum then other countries wouldn't have to intervene and take the necessary steps to keep their own countries and people safe. They started this not the other way round. If they just blew themselves up and kept it within their own country we wouldn't be bombing the shit outta their country and shooting it up.
I'd like to know why Australia needs to have its troops besieging a country that poses no threat to Australians. Do you want to stop Afghani civilians getting killed? Get out of Afghanistan then.
The truth is that Australia is another US servant, that Russia has to be surrounded by countries allied to the US who are there to exploit Afghanistan's natural gas reserves to support the US - and only the US - and its standard of living from a looming energy crisis; nothing to do with 'democracy'
@mrg00ddude Wrong acronym! The Taliban is a creation of the Pakistani ISI, which has bankrolled fundamentalist Islamist outfits as military assets against India. The Afghan Mujihadeen and then the Northern Alliance were funded by the CIA.
the interesting thing about the website of human rights abuses in afghanistan actually contains more stories of (worse) atrocities committed by the taliban, despite what the journalist cunningly implies.
xen42, firstly, don't be a dick, you could have worded your comment nicer. Second, WE (United States) are responsible for more civilian deaths than the Australians, granted we have more soldiers there.. but that should negate the first part of your comment.
They are in Afghanistan because they are a "major non-NATO ally" of the US and UK. You must not know how allies work, so if they were attacked we would be there in a second, and vice versa. Both wars are horrible really, I just don't get it.
Okay, my bad. I didn't realize we had a pact. I don't think about such things as true, since our founding principles are against such things. For good reason.
Problem is, we were not attacked by the taliban. so, they dont need to back us up. unless, you count our soldiers and marines being killed there. So in that train of thought, it is nice that they are helping us.
But if you follow that logic, we are not being protected from attacks, we're getting attacked every day. so then its fubar.
because oz is a allie to the us. if someone attacked aus the us and the uk and other allies would be sending troops to australia in a second cause aus is an allie you moron
Another evidence in favour the fact that "fighting" is "fighting" and peace is peace. Those two terms are not related. Peace comes through NOT fighting! This war by the allies is not well organised at all. It's like puting a plaster on a wound instead of desinfecting it and letting it heal by the cool air.
I think that if civilians truly are being killed, and it would appear that they are, the bigger army in this matter (coalition forces) need to take responsibility and make serious inquiries in to such incidents. Caution should be taken when attacking near civilians because it can incite terrorists rage and Martyrdom.
If the US would have focused 100 percent of their attention on Afghanistan and the Pakistan border then we wouldn't be in such a conflict right now. Iraq was such a pointless conflict.
we already know how unfair the troops are to civilians i mean even here when Katrina struck u had coast guards beating up ppl who refused to leave their homes. Its sad to see how the US and their little minions UK n AUSTRALIA have given civilians a new name INSURGENTS. all british aussies and americans gotta stand up and make the pigs in control pay for the way they have managed this whole war so very poorly.
because you don't know what that woman has, granade or a homemade bomb. and after that, you cannot recognise, whos who, who is your friend and who is not, who will shoot and who will walk pass. they killed that guy not in purpose, but because he was suspicious and he didn't stopped, when he was asked.soldiers tried to save theirs and other asses. sorry for my english.
one of my friends was in Afghanistan during the Soviet Union war with Afghanistan, Jihad. he said, that enywhere where he was walking, toilet, shop, or whatever, he was allways high on weed, and his finger was allways on ak-47 triger. he told me, that when he was walking down the road in his first days in Afghanistan, he seen a woman and a boy, about 6 years old.sudenly, he pulled out granade? and what you guys would do? let that boy kill you or you kill a boy and a woman?
u sick bastard r u justifying the wiping out of whole families because ur afraid?? afraid they might kill u so u bomb babies? i wonder when taliban kills civilians they are terrorist but when usa bomb 86 woman and children they get a medal. i wiudnt want to be u once u die justice will cum mabye not in this life but in the next, thats for sure.
It is interesting to see a video by JourneyMan attacking its own (Australian) military for a change.
For those unfamiliar, this channel is well known for producing vast quantities of politically motivated short documentaries. Sort of in the vein of Fox News, but from the left.
Australia should withdraw all our soldiers immediately from this un-winnable war.
No progress has made to improve Afghans human rights or living conditions; the local people now hate Australians. Its another Vietnam - what are we fighting for?
Let me tell youwe are surrounding Iran to bring it under IMF control and install a Reserve Bank to bleed it dry. I protest that our troops are cannon fodder for the banksters
news media don't understand the nature of war yes civilian casualties are bad but they are not intentional how can you be so highly critical of your own government and won't to see your own compatriots be imprisoned for what they were told to do what do they have to gain from their reporting..the overthrow of the government and a new political system im just guessing cause i can't see any other reasons
if the enemie hides among civilians and beguin to shoot, of course if you don't stop like Razh Mohammad you will be shoot , remamber that is a tipe os suicide so the the ausies get balme because they shoot an unnarmed man is all for the stupid reporters to show the wolrd and then we loose the war via media!
Why are we in Afghanistan anyway? Poppy fields?!?!
It's taken over 30 years for the mainstream media to slowly come out of the closet and jump on the bandwagon, now that it's popular, to acknowledge the Vietnam War was based on lies.
I suppose it won't come any sooner to acknowlege that the wars in the Middle-east are based on fantasy as well and that the entire 'war on terror' has also been bases on exaggeration.
Maybe there's another aspect to it. Maybe there's more racism in the Australian army than we expect. We can't deny that those armies are mostly made of typical white bastards that represent modern racism in the west. Shithead rednecks that think they are the soldiers of Jesus or the gladiators of democracy. I can't even imagine what kind of bullshit they fill their heads with. Is there someone who didn't kick Aussie ass in this world?!
Besides Opiates, what has Afghanistan brought to this world?? Nothing. Sorry Khan Z that youre bitter that you live in such a worthless war-zone. Have fun jerkin off in your cave tonite
Are you saying that only people from Britain and Ireland are allowed to live there? I have a friend named Karla that moved over there from Massachusetts five years ago.
ahem, when i visited australia, i did not get the impression that they don't let foreigners in. The cities there seem to be flooded with Asian people, especially Chinese. I think Australia is an extremely multicultural society. (In the urban areas, that is. The outback is a different story)
I think most australians are friendly but their country has been facing a shortage of land as newly immigrants arrive and flock onto the small piece of land australians have left. For god sake man they barely have water "down under" Ive got an australian friend who told me in some areas you can't even water the garden without being fined, thats why they can be so fearful towards immigration.
I'm not defending the killings of civilians, accidental or otherwise, but it's easy for you to sit back behind your computer and say you would never make a mistake like that, however, these are young guys in a scary situation with guns, fighting people that hide among civilians. That is a gaurenteed combination for tragedy.
hurahman, as a Muslim I gotta say you're all sorts of fucked up. They're helping the population out but getting rid of the Taliban who twist the word and teachings of Islam. So un-fuck yourself.
So were fags for Afghan fighters is what you're saying? I doubt that...And what nuclear holocaust? Are you saying we should've nuked your shitty country into the worlds largest piece of glass?
here is a Canadian came a long to fight against Afghans LOL. I like Canadian ice-hockey, nevertheless i still payed attention on Canadian team as being a citizen of USSR. I know that after US success nuked on Japan you plant 25 nukes get on N-Korea , China and USSR at 1951, but we Soviets prevented your dreams by creating ten times bigger nuke than witch was delivered to Japan. As the matter of fact Soviets never was threatening Western with those deadly toys.....
Waw this is stupid. If Australian troops weren't their thousands of civilians would die. This is almost as dumb as when people say that the troops U.S. in Iraq are killing civilians. Of course their are some mistakes buts it's better then the chemical bombs that were being dropped on the Kurds when Saddam Hussein was in power.
The Iraq war today has killed over a million people...
the UN sanctions against Iran Killed over a million Iraqis half of them children.
What about the hundreds of thousands dead from the Iraq Iran war supported by the US.
Saddam Hussein was not a saint but neither are the US and the west.
Our governments tell that they're altruists working for the benefit of all and they would like you to believe that they would still be in the middle east if it's main export was broccoli.
omg they talk about murdering some guy?? but yet he did not stop when ordered wtf they supposed to do let them stroll in and then blow them up wtf!!! JMP bad show
You can't win a war when you can't see the enemy, #1 rule, I don't think I'd ever want to fight in that war, I may consider a military career, but I'd sooner join a war then this, we saw what happened in Vietnam, this is just a larger scale Vietnamese-type war
No no, I'm not comparing the tactics to Vietnam, I'm just saying the Americans were fighting an enemy they couldn't see, it's the same as in Afghanistan/Iraq. Aslong as there will be up and coming kids/men ready to fight for the Taliban, the war goes on. They'd have to somehow break their financial business or w/e you'd like to call it, or god forbid kill all the population which is totally wrong, so their kind of stuck between a rock and a hard spot.
Sure, now most casualties stem from mines or "I.E.D"s as they call it, and kamizikaze attacks and there is *really* no defense against either.
I think where we disagree is when it comes to countermeasueres, I have no problem with bombing everyone to bits like you =) However I don`t think it would be best approach just now.
yep your right. thats why we sent the DEA to Afghanistan do destroy the heroin trade, which is one of the main sources of revenue for the terrorists in Afghanistan
and the taliban prob put the cilivlians in the way thats there tactic not australian troops they dnt go in saying i kno we sit here behind the civilians , in any case i dont give two fucks
dude what are you talking about? i just simply said part of our goals in afghanistan is to stop the drug trade. because its the drug trade that hwlps fund the terrorists. im all for what we are trying to do in afghanistan.
Would the DEA even have any jurisdiction in Afghanistan? Are you sure they're not monitoring our troops trying to smuggle things back in? I realize it's probably the Taliban's main source of revenue but what could the DEA do exactly?
the DEA if anything is there to assist the coalition in the efforts of drug enforcements or interdictions. The DEA was in south america durring the drug contras and believe it or not they did seize large quantities of drugs. I know we cant stop drugs all together but they can make a dent in the drug industry
So if NATO troops found a huge drugs cache the DEA would seize and destroy it? It just seems weird to have a police force in a war zone when there's already soldiers.
hmm do your reserch about journeyman pictures would you ....my insecurities haha thats funny ....did i hit a nerve...there at war and every war has casulties its not my fault the taliban hide as civlillians ...wake the fuck up
Modern western soldiers are afraid to die. So in order for them to be able to fight an army of people that are ready to blow themselves up for almost nothing they need to call airstrikes, which often end up in killing a lot of civilians, which is the biggest problem in Afghanistan. The question is how do a bunch of "farmers" manage to bring trillions of dollars of military to their knees.
Afghanistan is Taliban territory, they live and breathe that climate and terrain, that's why Russia failed and that is why the West will fail. You are right about the fear of dying for western soldiers, the Taliban and fighters there live daily in the most of extreme conditions. You also have to remember you're not dealing with normal people, the Taliban are people that have executed and tortured men and women just for breaking the simplest of laws like listening to music or trying to learn.
so going up against such fearless people is going to bring nothing but death and failure. Although saying that, the methods in which the west seem to fight wars these days (with there air-strikes) is just proof that the Military are not prepared for combat. The only success they will have is the killing of countless more innocents, and thus the feeling of hatred for the west will grow even more supplying the Taliban with more fighters.
Alexander the great conquered it in 3 months, and it remained in selucid imperial hands (successor state to alexanders empire) till it was defeated by the Roman Reobulic.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
no ruler has CONTROLLED Afghanistan. coz we afghans can NOT be controlled and the cowards aussie bitches will withraw soon after kill some more of them pigs mark my words.
its hard to imagine life in afghanistan.. in america during 9/11 people everywhere in the country and the world were shocked. people with life long emotional scars from their experiences in newyork.
well, imagine a 9/11 everyday for a year, and thats still not the amount of civilians suspected of dieing in afghanistan.
war on terror? terror is a feeling, you cant fight terror with guns.
you cant use fear against people who have nothing to lose. this war will never end if continued like this
I agree...civilian casualties of war are very unfortunate, and the first casualty of war is the TRUTH...what is this bitch reporter think she is doing? ..getting an award for best journalism. Of course these people are lying to discredit the Aussie troops.
smokeybirdman 2 months ago
Fuck you go out there while having civilian looking fucks shooting at you with ak's then make a split decision in .225 of a second if they are civil or not. Once bullets are whizzing over your head from or directions and have you pinned down make sure not to hit any civilians. Common Taliban is the real reason civilians die as they fight dirty rather then fair. If they grew some balls and made a frontline they would get wiped out in no time ,so they use guerrilla tactics and civis like cowards
fpvshitsonhsv 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is the day for BBw women naneedj.info
blomahmartin 1 year ago
gringos hujos de puta
comunicaarte 1 year ago
@rangers11000 u have no idea what the fuck your on about.u sound like a fucken 12 year old.show some resect to the people that have died for our countries and ther families u dumb fuck
aussiesteve05 1 year ago
fuck austrialains pigs
shponkaie 1 year ago
with a name like that u are a total idiot. Who thought of that yah dumb god fuch the koran and Allah i heard he takes it in the arse anyway. i wish i could dip my bullets in pig blood and then shoot you. U dont see any boats from our country landing on your shores do you. No thats right u all want to come here. My hat goes off to all the Aussie troops and its allies in this fight. I commend u.
308skippy 1 year ago
with a name like that u are a total idiot. Who thought of that? yah dumb god. fuck the koran and Allah i heard he takes it in the arse anyway. i wish i could dip my bullets in pig blood and then shoot you. U dont see any boats from our country landing on your shores do you. No thats right u all want to come here. My hat goes off to all the Aussie troops and its allies in this fight. I commend u.
308skippy 1 year ago
@308skippy Mate, I am Australian, and I don't understand the context of your arguement (Then again, an arguement on youtube is inevitable yes, why follow it?) And I have nothing but respect for the Aussie troops, the the degree where I've enlisted. But what you said was wrong. This episode is stupid, and full of bais, but man, you can't go round saying shit like that.
reddyranga 1 year ago
THAT SPOKESMEN IS FULL OF SHIT
fuck the afgans if anything they should not care what happens to the innocent
theyre the ones trading information with the taliban
ISUPPORTTHEKKK 1 year ago
This story is light weight. When are media people going to be versed in the military art? Once upon a time, all Australian channels had well experienced war/security correspondents, not girls just out of school. They have to do more than report, they have to draw on learning and experience. An example in this is the questioning of the doctor.
He should have been asked the calibre of the rounds in the the dead and wounded, for the AK47 of the Taliban is not used by Americans or Australians.
SapperK9 1 year ago
GO AUZZIES!!!
blackbullet321 1 year ago
put an other shrimp on the barbie! ha good going fellas keep up the fight! no surrender!!!
hitmanhornster 2 years ago
who said Australia is allowed to have troops at all? Canada did a much much better job in Afganistan. Australians have absolutly no military backround, where the fuck were you when WWII happened.
attackonh3 2 years ago
open a fucking history book before you ask a stupid fucking question. We have one of the most successful military historys than any other country...u must b american..
dembo 2 years ago
No I am CANADIAN mr kangaroo
attackonh3 2 years ago
Canadian troops were attached to Australian Units in WWI in the battle of Le Hamel. It was Australian AND Canadian troops who then went on to break the Hindenburg Line.
Australia was fighting the Japanese AND the Germans in WWII. We inflicted the 1st defeat on the *ENTIRE* German Army at the Siege of Tobruk we then shipped those same troops over to PNG and inflicted the 1st defaet of the Japanese Army in 400 years at the Battle of Milne Bay.
were where we? we were fucking up the enemy.
semtex84 2 years ago
Anyways , I've been working with the Aus and as far as I can see Aus diffenetly need to work on their skills. I'm sure you have lost men which i fully respect that, but military skill is something you guys need to work on;however, I can be wrong.
attackonh3 2 years ago
You're a fucking wanker. My fucking ass you've been working with Aus, you fucking lying cunt.
Hendrixstrato 1 year ago
@semtex84 Yup.
The Battle of Le Hamel was the battle that broke the back of the Germans. It was commanded by, arguably the greatest general of WWI, Sir John Monash, the first general to be knighted in the field by the king of England in 500 years!
Lloyd George the English Prime Minister was going to appoint him the Chief of the General Staff over his English officers.
In two world wars the USA arrived in time for afternoon tea, and the first troops into Iraq in 2003 were the Australian SAS.
SapperK9 1 year ago
@SapperK9
ha ha the first troops into iraq were the australian sas nahhhhh,have you never seen bravo two zero.andy mcnabb was sent into iraq before any other special forces including americans.the australians wernt even in iraq you idiot.
rangers11000 1 year ago
@rangers11000 Oh yeah and it went well for McNabb too didn't it mate? His team got fucked up by incompetence and he ran off to save himself. The guy is gutless.
TheEddieoz 1 year ago
@TheEddieoz
yeah and german special forces made a right fuck up of munich too
rangers11000 1 year ago
@SapperK9
and its the UK you idiot not england.you act like you know shit but you dont even know the name of the land she owns.idiot,.and the ozzy sas cant match up to the british sas,we fucking train you cunts,and nato has named the british sas the best trained special forces in the world.
rangers11000 1 year ago
@dembo
australia doesnt have a great military history,it was britain who had a great military history and you were only fighting because the british owend you.
rangers11000 1 year ago
@rangers11000
Look it up douche.
Australia was involved in alot of battles in WWII!
the first time the japs retreated in ww2 was fighting the australians,
the australians walked over the french foreign legion in beirut, you ever herd of the rats of tobruk? guess who they are...dude i could go on and on and on look it up ffs before saying stupid things...seriously im embarassed 4 u..
dembo 1 year ago
@dembo
ha ha being in one war dude isnt a big achievment,and dont you remember the australians tried to rebel against us british and got your arses kicked.
rangers11000 1 year ago
@rangers11000 gee mate thats going back along time ago,way to hang on to that one...besides if it werent for the americans ud be speaking german to me right now...all the british did was drink tea and get a daily load of V2 rockets in the face and tag along on american missions. good stuff
dembo 1 year ago
Comment removed
noUturn1924 2 years ago
06:45 David Killcullen (counter isurgency expert) looks like a pig! oink oink
noUturn1924 2 years ago
Right on Austrailia!!
snottydyck 2 years ago
looks like a bunch of helicopter pilots hahaha
diggszEVARWARE 2 years ago
This female reporter annoys the crap out of me, she sounds very amateur. Civilian casualties and collateral damage are not what anyone wants, unfortunately it can happen in war. Sometimes we must call in air strikes to save Aussie troops lives. If the Taliban want to shoot at us, we'll shoot at them. All civilian deaths in war deserve an open and thorough investigation.
AussieDreamChaser 2 years ago
its all about hazaras.....we own the country....and when the dumb ass westerners realize that we are the ones .... we will teach you a lesson ...one by one...how a modern muslim democratic country really should work.....make dubai look like our sisters
hoo10j 2 years ago
im coming pakies...better be ready .... im in the coalition forces .....im gonna spit in all your faces....you dirty rodents!!!!!
'
hoo10j 2 years ago
Guess what faggot, Pakies are right here, in your own background, lets see what are you gonna do about.
zob79 2 years ago
pakistan is the worst... they are all like cockaroaches!!!kill ...killl
hoo10j 2 years ago
hmm, what Australians are doing in Afghanistan?
Commierific 2 years ago
I support the Western Armies. While I could not say I implicitly trust these governments to tell us everything that goes wrong when they attempt to engage hostile forces, I can say that I remember September 11th and how the Afghanis allowed their state to become a haven for terrorist masterminds and such goatf#@$ing morons as live in that region of the world. I believe it is wrong for innocents to die, or any one not bearing arms against Western troops or convicted of crimes...
MinisterAilingTongue 2 years ago
The Western Armies have been privatized, they are fighting to protect corporate interests
sansez 2 years ago
not western armies, but it is the western governments who have been privatized. Now the governments are sending the brave armies of the people to protect corporate interests. and that is horrible. The people in the armies are not generally bad, it is the rich money worshippers in office who are bad
kage574 2 years ago
Who gave this woman a video camera and a microphone?
Back in the kitchen wench do a documentary on how to bake a cake....
dandan26 2 years ago
They bought it on themselves. If their government could police the country properly and rid it of all the terrorist scum then other countries wouldn't have to intervene and take the necessary steps to keep their own countries and people safe. They started this not the other way round. If they just blew themselves up and kept it within their own country we wouldn't be bombing the shit outta their country and shooting it up.
dandan26 2 years ago
I'd like to know why Australia needs to have its troops besieging a country that poses no threat to Australians. Do you want to stop Afghani civilians getting killed? Get out of Afghanistan then.
The truth is that Australia is another US servant, that Russia has to be surrounded by countries allied to the US who are there to exploit Afghanistan's natural gas reserves to support the US - and only the US - and its standard of living from a looming energy crisis; nothing to do with 'democracy'
kidcalabria 2 years ago
so its the aussie who kills the innocent civilians and the US gets to share the blame
sahil156in 2 years ago
I cant believe this reporter still a live God Bless him for the truth about everything
Dia1Shalash 2 years ago
what is the aussies doin there??
sahil156in 2 years ago
1st the taliban was funded by cia
and alkiada does not exist out side the cia we are in Afghanistan to protect pipe line and strategic point to destabelize Pakistan and surround iran
all the rest is pr and a mind games
mrg00ddude 2 years ago 2
@mrg00ddude Wrong acronym! The Taliban is a creation of the Pakistani ISI, which has bankrolled fundamentalist Islamist outfits as military assets against India. The Afghan Mujihadeen and then the Northern Alliance were funded by the CIA.
Gramra 1 year ago
the interesting thing about the website of human rights abuses in afghanistan actually contains more stories of (worse) atrocities committed by the taliban, despite what the journalist cunningly implies.
theREALshafan 2 years ago
Why the hell is Australia in Afghanistan anyway? Did Taliban attack you? bored?
.
If you want to take out Taliban, you use covert methods, such as assassination, and helping opposition in total secrecy.
.
All this warring just makes the place shittier than before. And when you kill civilians, the civilians start to side with taliban.
xen42 2 years ago
xen42, firstly, don't be a dick, you could have worded your comment nicer. Second, WE (United States) are responsible for more civilian deaths than the Australians, granted we have more soldiers there.. but that should negate the first part of your comment.
They are in Afghanistan because they are a "major non-NATO ally" of the US and UK. You must not know how allies work, so if they were attacked we would be there in a second, and vice versa. Both wars are horrible really, I just don't get it.
zOMGLaserGunzPewPew 2 years ago
Okay, my bad. I didn't realize we had a pact. I don't think about such things as true, since our founding principles are against such things. For good reason.
Problem is, we were not attacked by the taliban. so, they dont need to back us up. unless, you count our soldiers and marines being killed there. So in that train of thought, it is nice that they are helping us.
But if you follow that logic, we are not being protected from attacks, we're getting attacked every day. so then its fubar.
xen42 2 years ago
because oz is a allie to the us. if someone attacked aus the us and the uk and other allies would be sending troops to australia in a second cause aus is an allie you moron
bb4jdmlude 2 years ago
So the USA was attacked?
xen42 2 years ago
yup on 9/11
bb4jdmlude 2 years ago
oh by the taliban? I didn't know that.
xen42 2 years ago
well now you know tube
bb4jdmlude 2 years ago
you know what? I checked it out, they're all from elsewhere, mostly saudi arabia. maybe you should go there.
xen42 2 years ago
pull the bullets out of their heads and see what guns they came from...
pmidz 2 years ago
Another evidence in favour the fact that "fighting" is "fighting" and peace is peace. Those two terms are not related. Peace comes through NOT fighting! This war by the allies is not well organised at all. It's like puting a plaster on a wound instead of desinfecting it and letting it heal by the cool air.
swissdanihaller 2 years ago
I think that if civilians truly are being killed, and it would appear that they are, the bigger army in this matter (coalition forces) need to take responsibility and make serious inquiries in to such incidents. Caution should be taken when attacking near civilians because it can incite terrorists rage and Martyrdom.
nnamdi247 2 years ago
If the US would have focused 100 percent of their attention on Afghanistan and the Pakistan border then we wouldn't be in such a conflict right now. Iraq was such a pointless conflict.
nnamdi247 2 years ago
is war realy worth ?
iComment17 2 years ago
86 woman and children killed and nobody charged, i wonder who the real terrorist are.
rippa17 2 years ago
we already know how unfair the troops are to civilians i mean even here when Katrina struck u had coast guards beating up ppl who refused to leave their homes. Its sad to see how the US and their little minions UK n AUSTRALIA have given civilians a new name INSURGENTS. all british aussies and americans gotta stand up and make the pigs in control pay for the way they have managed this whole war so very poorly.
cholorockabilly 2 years ago
If your house is full of rats, you should get rid of them before a few of them go out and bite a tiger.
Because the tiger may accidentally bite you if your rats make him mad!
groberson2007 2 years ago
so the rat is supposed to be the 86 woman and children bombed?? and the tiger r the usa??? ur sick i hope u go too moqadishu for holiday u bastard.
rippa17 2 years ago
Why doesnt she cover the "civilians" the Taliban kills. Stupid cunt.
mikey4u1984 2 years ago
YO, Word.
jinglemybells262 2 years ago
because for every one taliban kils 50 ur lot kill,
rippa17 2 years ago
what kind of sick mother fucker are you... Taliban are bad the world knows it... they kill civillians...
but ass lickers of america who claim to be responsible counteries are supposed to be in afghanistan to free the civillians not kill them
321roomi321 2 years ago
fuck of troll
mikey4u1984 2 years ago
well at least the reporter is hot
DivinoNino777 2 years ago
Chicks......................killing civilians
Thiseas1974 2 years ago
i mean a guy in the video
brauning 2 years ago
because you don't know what that woman has, granade or a homemade bomb. and after that, you cannot recognise, whos who, who is your friend and who is not, who will shoot and who will walk pass. they killed that guy not in purpose, but because he was suspicious and he didn't stopped, when he was asked.soldiers tried to save theirs and other asses. sorry for my english.
brauning 2 years ago
one of my friends was in Afghanistan during the Soviet Union war with Afghanistan, Jihad. he said, that enywhere where he was walking, toilet, shop, or whatever, he was allways high on weed, and his finger was allways on ak-47 triger. he told me, that when he was walking down the road in his first days in Afghanistan, he seen a woman and a boy, about 6 years old.sudenly, he pulled out granade? and what you guys would do? let that boy kill you or you kill a boy and a woman?
brauning 2 years ago
u sick bastard r u justifying the wiping out of whole families because ur afraid?? afraid they might kill u so u bomb babies? i wonder when taliban kills civilians they are terrorist but when usa bomb 86 woman and children they get a medal. i wiudnt want to be u once u die justice will cum mabye not in this life but in the next, thats for sure.
rippa17 2 years ago
kill more aussie pussies
khiljiauto 2 years ago
Comment removed
dandan26 2 years ago
when you can't tell your friends from your foes, its time to return home.
mathumma 2 years ago
Afghanistan will conquer all invaders.
MelanesianMerdeka 2 years ago
It is interesting to see a video by JourneyMan attacking its own (Australian) military for a change.
For those unfamiliar, this channel is well known for producing vast quantities of politically motivated short documentaries. Sort of in the vein of Fox News, but from the left.
Morris1962 2 years ago
journeyman does not make documentaries, read and delve into what you are watching before you judge to avoid looking like an absolute tool.
lol, common sense not so common in merca.
CohanDigitmatta 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Australia should withdraw all our soldiers immediately from this un-winnable war.
No progress has made to improve Afghans human rights or living conditions; the local people now hate Australians. Its another Vietnam - what are we fighting for?
Let me tell youwe are surrounding Iran to bring it under IMF control and install a Reserve Bank to bleed it dry. I protest that our troops are cannon fodder for the banksters
AwarEtec 2 years ago
""Hajil, a member of the Afghan parliament,
says We look to God for our security, not to these people.""
Thats why we are coming in!
Waiting for god is wasted. what a stupid fuck. God? pff
If u want to protect your civilians, drive the
people out that r using them as human shield or death toll propaganda.
drive the fucking religious talib-gaylords out of your beloved country!
u have to think about the nonsense journeyman makes out here.
& think about it for urselve. dont believe his propaganda.
SheitanClaus 2 years ago
news media don't understand the nature of war yes civilian casualties are bad but they are not intentional how can you be so highly critical of your own government and won't to see your own compatriots be imprisoned for what they were told to do what do they have to gain from their reporting..the overthrow of the government and a new political system im just guessing cause i can't see any other reasons
negkreyol21 2 years ago
angus houston you spineless puppet
genghis6l99 2 years ago
if the enemie hides among civilians and beguin to shoot, of course if you don't stop like Razh Mohammad you will be shoot , remamber that is a tipe os suicide so the the ausies get balme because they shoot an unnarmed man is all for the stupid reporters to show the wolrd and then we loose the war via media!
darsal123 2 years ago 2
jorneyman agin is turning in to a mouthpieace for the enemie!
darsal123 2 years ago 2
This reporter is shit.
mikey4u1984 2 years ago 2
fuck me fuck me "get the fuck down" lol
Jolinator 2 years ago
Why are we in Afghanistan anyway? Poppy fields?!?!
It's taken over 30 years for the mainstream media to slowly come out of the closet and jump on the bandwagon, now that it's popular, to acknowledge the Vietnam War was based on lies.
I suppose it won't come any sooner to acknowlege that the wars in the Middle-east are based on fantasy as well and that the entire 'war on terror' has also been bases on exaggeration.
...etc, etc. The corruption continues...
InfoWarriorMaverick 2 years ago
cause Obama promised to get them out of Iraq... so he moved them.
DimitriNakos 2 years ago
The Australian miltary spokesperson is a highly untrained liar.
He should visit Israel for some professional lying and deceiving classes so that he can cover up the crimes in a less blatantly obvious way.
umkh 2 years ago
Maybe there's another aspect to it. Maybe there's more racism in the Australian army than we expect. We can't deny that those armies are mostly made of typical white bastards that represent modern racism in the west. Shithead rednecks that think they are the soldiers of Jesus or the gladiators of democracy. I can't even imagine what kind of bullshit they fill their heads with. Is there someone who didn't kick Aussie ass in this world?!
lekotar 2 years ago
lekotar you sound like a typical black bastard?
IslamicTerd 2 years ago
I bet I'm more white than you lol. Pure european.
lekotar 2 years ago
What a load of shit.
LeftWingsR4Chickens 2 years ago
Besides Opiates, what has Afghanistan brought to this world?? Nothing. Sorry Khan Z that youre bitter that you live in such a worthless war-zone. Have fun jerkin off in your cave tonite
JonnyCobraKai 2 years ago
you are such a moron...
Afghanistan is not worthless, your hatred and ignorance is worthless
micahgee 2 years ago
Australia is a xenophobic country
They only allow immigrants from Britain & Ireland
"Aussie", ethnic descriptor
Aussie is used by Australians to identify people of the of Anglo-Celtic descent
sansez 2 years ago 2
Are you saying that only people from Britain and Ireland are allowed to live there? I have a friend named Karla that moved over there from Massachusetts five years ago.
boket5u 2 years ago
sorry, but not everyone wants their country to be completely swamped by refugees and migrants.
if nothing is done, in 50 years the third world would have completely overtaken and swamped the first world.
zlzgrom86 2 years ago
ahem, when i visited australia, i did not get the impression that they don't let foreigners in. The cities there seem to be flooded with Asian people, especially Chinese. I think Australia is an extremely multicultural society. (In the urban areas, that is. The outback is a different story)
bresophil 2 years ago
I think most australians are friendly but their country has been facing a shortage of land as newly immigrants arrive and flock onto the small piece of land australians have left. For god sake man they barely have water "down under" Ive got an australian friend who told me in some areas you can't even water the garden without being fined, thats why they can be so fearful towards immigration.
mralanv 2 years ago
@mralanv
"I think most Australians are friendly but their country has been facing a shortage of land ..."
That wasnt my point. I saying that is easier to people from Britain & Ireland to immigrate to Australia.
Favoring of one group over others with equal claims
sansez 2 years ago
I'm not defending the killings of civilians, accidental or otherwise, but it's easy for you to sit back behind your computer and say you would never make a mistake like that, however, these are young guys in a scary situation with guns, fighting people that hide among civilians. That is a gaurenteed combination for tragedy.
zOMGLaserGunzPewPew 2 years ago
Insert ignorant statement here to ignite a flame war. Blah blah blah.
GiantTarget 2 years ago
these NATO cowboys have no mercy. don't be fooled by their fancey rules and show off the human rights. they don't even have idea of human rights.
no wonder they r going to fail.
you are not welcome here so get the fuck out.
KhanZazai 2 years ago
what weapons do the Aussies move(ty aussies for all your hard work we appreciate you-USA)
psgchisolm 2 years ago
its a 3rd world country. The coalition is doing them a favor by killing anyone who calls that shit hole home
JonnyCobraKai 2 years ago
u r a third degree retard. fagget
KhanZazai 2 years ago
Taliban 4 Life
Fuck NATO
afgfam786 2 years ago
its ironic that you are a Youtube member when in fact the taliban would look down on your video watching.
zlzgrom86 2 years ago 2
afghanistan rules :D
2pac057 2 years ago
hurahman, as a Muslim I gotta say you're all sorts of fucked up. They're helping the population out but getting rid of the Taliban who twist the word and teachings of Islam. So un-fuck yourself.
swaed 2 years ago
PEACE
llailahaillallah 2 years ago
i hope the taliban KILL these MORTHERFUCKERS...go go taliban...kill all these invaders...fuck them!!
hurahman 2 years ago
ASSIES are FUCKING DIE...DIE DIE .....Face Pakistan U assies cowards
88a 2 years ago
Australia has no fuckin' business going around about killing people in this country of afghanistan!!! U aussie pigs... GET OUT NOW!!!
marumito 2 years ago
fuck these aussies white boys dnt know who they fucking with. afghans are the lions you fucks.
basak983 2 years ago
If Afghans are so brave, how come you live in New Zealand ballsack? Go join the fucking Taliban, coward
LeftWingsR4Chickens 2 years ago
.... Australians pansies better go home and practice on cangurus mommas waiting for you .!!!!
Vidas666 2 years ago
You are all western fags against Afghanistan fighter. You just can win that war by pushing a nuclear holocaust.
Vidas666 2 years ago
So were fags for Afghan fighters is what you're saying? I doubt that...And what nuclear holocaust? Are you saying we should've nuked your shitty country into the worlds largest piece of glass?
gandhicakes 2 years ago
here is a Canadian came a long to fight against Afghans LOL. I like Canadian ice-hockey, nevertheless i still payed attention on Canadian team as being a citizen of USSR. I know that after US success nuked on Japan you plant 25 nukes get on N-Korea , China and USSR at 1951, but we Soviets prevented your dreams by creating ten times bigger nuke than witch was delivered to Japan. As the matter of fact Soviets never was threatening Western with those deadly toys.....
Vidas666 2 years ago
US created a miff that Soviets preparing strike West first of just because increase a demographic interest on you morons .
Vidas666 2 years ago
Waw this is stupid. If Australian troops weren't their thousands of civilians would die. This is almost as dumb as when people say that the troops U.S. in Iraq are killing civilians. Of course their are some mistakes buts it's better then the chemical bombs that were being dropped on the Kurds when Saddam Hussein was in power.
gerard0949 2 years ago
Nope.
The Iraq war today has killed over a million people...
the UN sanctions against Iran Killed over a million Iraqis half of them children.
What about the hundreds of thousands dead from the Iraq Iran war supported by the US.
Saddam Hussein was not a saint but neither are the US and the west.
Our governments tell that they're altruists working for the benefit of all and they would like you to believe that they would still be in the middle east if it's main export was broccoli.
langbay2005 2 years ago 4
yet u forget to mention how many more dead there would of been if they didnt invade iraq , iran wouldnt be here they all be dead
UKimpact 2 years ago
finially some1 with an education :)
psgchisolm 2 years ago
its NONE Of your fucking buiseness you dumb ass motherfuckers. fiz your own goverment there is a person killed each min in usa.
basak983 2 years ago
omg they talk about murdering some guy?? but yet he did not stop when ordered wtf they supposed to do let them stroll in and then blow them up wtf!!! JMP bad show
andycats 2 years ago
You can't win a war when you can't see the enemy, #1 rule, I don't think I'd ever want to fight in that war, I may consider a military career, but I'd sooner join a war then this, we saw what happened in Vietnam, this is just a larger scale Vietnamese-type war
HillBillyDrew 2 years ago
I disagree with you.
Yes the "enemy" uses similar tactics but I think the doctrine on the allied side is lightyears away from Vietnam era doctrine.
Don`t get me wrong, I don`t say that NATO has cracked the Afgan code but to compare it with Vietnam? No way mate. =)
mrmorg79 2 years ago
No no, I'm not comparing the tactics to Vietnam, I'm just saying the Americans were fighting an enemy they couldn't see, it's the same as in Afghanistan/Iraq. Aslong as there will be up and coming kids/men ready to fight for the Taliban, the war goes on. They'd have to somehow break their financial business or w/e you'd like to call it, or god forbid kill all the population which is totally wrong, so their kind of stuck between a rock and a hard spot.
HillBillyDrew 2 years ago
Ah, got ya! Sorry.
Sure, now most casualties stem from mines or "I.E.D"s as they call it, and kamizikaze attacks and there is *really* no defense against either.
I think where we disagree is when it comes to countermeasueres, I have no problem with bombing everyone to bits like you =) However I don`t think it would be best approach just now.
Cheers!
mrmorg79 2 years ago
yep your right. thats why we sent the DEA to Afghanistan do destroy the heroin trade, which is one of the main sources of revenue for the terrorists in Afghanistan
808bourn11 2 years ago
here comes the invade for oil crap again ,
and the taliban prob put the cilivlians in the way thats there tactic not australian troops they dnt go in saying i kno we sit here behind the civilians , in any case i dont give two fucks
UKimpact 2 years ago
dude what are you talking about? i just simply said part of our goals in afghanistan is to stop the drug trade. because its the drug trade that hwlps fund the terrorists. im all for what we are trying to do in afghanistan.
808bourn11 2 years ago
Would the DEA even have any jurisdiction in Afghanistan? Are you sure they're not monitoring our troops trying to smuggle things back in? I realize it's probably the Taliban's main source of revenue but what could the DEA do exactly?
gandhicakes 2 years ago
the DEA if anything is there to assist the coalition in the efforts of drug enforcements or interdictions. The DEA was in south america durring the drug contras and believe it or not they did seize large quantities of drugs. I know we cant stop drugs all together but they can make a dent in the drug industry
808bourn11 2 years ago
So if NATO troops found a huge drugs cache the DEA would seize and destroy it? It just seems weird to have a police force in a war zone when there's already soldiers.
gandhicakes 2 years ago
destroy it? aahahhah you are a JOKE mate you are fucking taking the money in your country you fuck withs.
basak983 2 years ago
aussies use the ole aug steyrs too...nice
daragh89 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Fucking rich-mans war!
RISE AGAINST THE NEW WORLD ORDER!
piratakamrata 2 years ago
I don`t get it? Are they moaning about LESS then 1000 civvies dead last year???
How many civvies had to burn for a strategic bombing raid to be successful in ww2? 8000 pr raid?
mrmorg79 2 years ago
Unbelievably daft comment.
Vamavid 2 years ago
Why? Because it`s true?
You are boring me to tears mate, scoffer off.
mrmorg79 2 years ago
It would be more productive to go after the financiers of the Taliban. Go after money donators and heroin traffic leaders.
roachmobile 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
FUCK JOURNEYMAN PICTURES ITS PROPAGANDA WITH NO PROOF
make your own judgements....there at war
c4h6i2s 2 years ago
They are making their own judgment with evidences while you are shouting out your comment with emotional insecurities.
mikess 2 years ago
hmm do your reserch about journeyman pictures would you ....my insecurities haha thats funny ....did i hit a nerve...there at war and every war has casulties its not my fault the taliban hide as civlillians ...wake the fuck up
go hard Boys !!!
c4h6i2s 2 years ago
good work guys come home soon, this is way to negativetowards australian troops in life and death situations mistakes are made thats life
metho20 2 years ago 4
Modern western soldiers are afraid to die. So in order for them to be able to fight an army of people that are ready to blow themselves up for almost nothing they need to call airstrikes, which often end up in killing a lot of civilians, which is the biggest problem in Afghanistan. The question is how do a bunch of "farmers" manage to bring trillions of dollars of military to their knees.
lekotar 2 years ago
Afghanistan is Taliban territory, they live and breathe that climate and terrain, that's why Russia failed and that is why the West will fail. You are right about the fear of dying for western soldiers, the Taliban and fighters there live daily in the most of extreme conditions. You also have to remember you're not dealing with normal people, the Taliban are people that have executed and tortured men and women just for breaking the simplest of laws like listening to music or trying to learn.
RaindropsFantasia 2 years ago
cont...
so going up against such fearless people is going to bring nothing but death and failure. Although saying that, the methods in which the west seem to fight wars these days (with there air-strikes) is just proof that the Military are not prepared for combat. The only success they will have is the killing of countless more innocents, and thus the feeling of hatred for the west will grow even more supplying the Taliban with more fighters.
RaindropsFantasia 2 years ago
"No bastard ever won a war by dying for his country.
He won it by making the other poor dumb bastard die for his country."
- Attributed to General George Patton Jr
blackxavior 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the COURAGE of AFGHANS read the histroy no body has ever taken over afghans. you fuckers are next
basak983 2 years ago
Alexander the great conquered it in 3 months, and it remained in selucid imperial hands (successor state to alexanders empire) till it was defeated by the Roman Reobulic.
bladeere14 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no ruler has CONTROLLED Afghanistan. coz we afghans can NOT be controlled and the cowards aussie bitches will withraw soon after kill some more of them pigs mark my words.
basak983 2 years ago
Funny, People who kill themselves are cowards, and i dont see the aussies killing themselves to fight, unlike afghans.
boket5u 2 years ago
I agree with you,
Anyone who fights war in a video game role, UAV pilots shooting missiles from thousands of miles away with no risk to the pilot.
The same people call those willing to commit suicide, cowardly..
UAV's are the beginning of robotic combat in which civilians will be the side effects of US trial runs.
Calling in air strikes etc. result just ends up killing more innocent people than it protects.
The Talian in Afghanistan will not be defeated anytime soon. Unlike US/NATO forces!!
micahgee 2 years ago
There are an incredible amount of stupid comments on YT but yours stands out in the crowd. You must have really put effort into this particular one.
flyhead2 2 years ago
because australia isnt some ass whole shit country whos government is fucked
nesten1 2 years ago 4
Why do you expect spammers like
Basak983 to have actually read history?
Its pointless debating with people like that.
Just look at hes responses. There practical identical and have nothing than a rhetorical content.
Lobos222 2 years ago 2
its hard to imagine life in afghanistan.. in america during 9/11 people everywhere in the country and the world were shocked. people with life long emotional scars from their experiences in newyork.
well, imagine a 9/11 everyday for a year, and thats still not the amount of civilians suspected of dieing in afghanistan.
war on terror? terror is a feeling, you cant fight terror with guns.
you cant use fear against people who have nothing to lose. this war will never end if continued like this
lejink 2 years ago 8
ecco..........i portatori di pace
francospalvieri 2 years ago