Isn't it great when an entire song's meaning can be based on how one wants to interpret it? Some may be convinced that she's saying "you", some that she says "he". Whatever it is, it's a beautiful song.
i LOVE this. id completely forgotten about it! regina says "he" its just hard to tell from the accent. her and jenny are really good friends cus they went to college or something together.
I clearly heard "you". "I don't know if that's you, because that didn't sound like you". that's what you say when you're sweet and know someone and notice that that person is not allright. whatever,It's up to you. important this is that they're so GREAT!
*-* Please come to Brasil !! (this will probably never get to her, but whatever!) (Yes, people, the real Brasil's written with S, and not Z, our capital is not Buenos Aires nor Rio de Janeiro, is a dry aired city called Brasilia, actually.)
I really like this song and I love Regina but I find her answering machine voice so distracting from the song I just can't listen to it much. Why couldn't they have just made a different version or put it at only the beginning and end?
Also I don't think any of the voices are Regina's except the first one. Just listen the accents are so different. And I think it's neat having Regina on voicemail but credit goes to Jenny for writing/playing/singing the song. It's a great song anyway is all I'm saying. Thanx for posting spektography :)
I heard this song thru Jenny Owen Youngs cos in London she is supporting Regina. So I got all Jenny's stuff too, since I have most of Regina's work( she's probably written another one as i type) and found the song and I am sure Regina says "P.S. I can't believe what YOU did" which makes sense to me cos Jenny & Bess et al who are on 'one more time with feeling ' podcasts are pretty crazy & love messing around. I think Regina sounds a little pissed off with her at the time. Friends do have tiffs?
I think the second an the last message are from the same Girl. And she talks deeper than Regina. Its sounds like an alto- voice and Regina is a soprano. I could be mistaken, but i think its another person
I have a theory about who the second girl on the machine is. Listen to the band "Gregory and the Hawk", and notice that after that message a light voice starts singing in the background...eh?EH? Haha. I got this song and love it.♥ Regina and Jenny rule.
I didn't write that my friend did. I have no idea who this chick is. she goes on our account. and she won't see your replies to her comment, so why even?
i love the first part, and when she goes "i dont know if thats you cause it didnt sound like you but you know its a funny world where machines could replace people..." SO GENIUS!!! i repeated the first part sooo many times !!,
ohhhh finally I know its her for sure I always couldnt figure out if she was saying regine or regina and if it was really her. And I thought she said PS I cant believe what YOU did but i guess im wrong??
I thought she said this also, there are no lyrics for regina's talking section, what I have written above is what I believe them to be. After listening to the rest of the lyrics it would make more sense for her to say "he did" as this would comply with the direction of the track, not needing a relationship/boyfriend around anymore...???? :) ??
it doesnt seem like she is talking about a boy. i mean I don't see it anywhere, and she says ive got your voice on tape and you only hear female voices on the recordings. (the last one doesnt sound like Regina to me btw) First time I heard this I thought Regina and Jenny were gay or something.
"I can't believe what HE did", not "you". So, she's talking about someone else, calling her friend in the middle of the night to talk about it. And I think that Jenny is sitting listening to the voicemail from her friend, but she's thinking about someone else's voice on tape.
It's like, she's got this guy's voice on tape, and it sort of symbolizes the way we get obsessive about relationships, making up what we want them to be instead of seeing them for what they really are. As long as it's on tape she can imagine whatever she wants. And her friends are reaching in with the real world, but she's screening the calls living in her own world.
Isnt this song about a lesbian relationship?
erbrown75 5 months ago
spektography i owe my life to you. i really mean it. you are an angel and regina will keep a spot for you in her heaven. love and fierce:):):)
alicepotter777 7 months ago
I used to listen to this on repeat in high school. I had no idea it was Spektor.
neffersions 7 months ago
Any tabs around for this?! Ugh.
socialscene183 9 months ago
her speaking voice is almost as beautiful as her singing voice
ogum536 10 months ago
could anything be more beautiful!?!?!
x1mastershake1x 11 months ago
Comment removed
taohuoocat 1 year ago
Meredith's voice is adorable towards the end. <3 <3 <3
Swoooon.
taohuoocat 1 year ago
Isn't it great when an entire song's meaning can be based on how one wants to interpret it? Some may be convinced that she's saying "you", some that she says "he". Whatever it is, it's a beautiful song.
gabitza913 1 year ago 6
"I can't believe what YOU did."
Believe me. I asked her.
brenwinkle 1 year ago
@brenwinkle Regina or Jenny?
lumrules 9 months ago
@brenwinkle shut yur face. you asked regina? about the song voice on tape? when? where? why, i mean of all the questions to ask her? tell me:):):)
alicepotter777 7 months ago
Hard to believe that's her.
STOPtheHORROR 1 year ago
Jenny is lesbian and probably Regina too, so "you" would make sense too ;)
thekook99 1 year ago
seriously a magnificent piece of work here such simple guitar work but great vocals beautiful and touching song
foxxlover15 1 year ago
I love the two of them so much :)
They're so good together.
ThanksButNoThankz 1 year ago
but you know, it's a funny world where machines could replace people.
ThisWeekTheTrendx 1 year ago 2
thank god for beautiful music :)
bhopperts 1 year ago
Love this song! Love Regina, just discovered Jenny Owen Youngs a few days ago, but I like her songs too. =)
Myrtje123 1 year ago 4
OMG!? I've listened to this song for how long and didn't realize it was my one favourite artist?! True facepalm moment. ^^;
goldfishinaglass 1 year ago
shi's lovely.
owtatowttowt 1 year ago
i just absolutely love this song
.... i don't need you physically
Marleeeeeeeeey 1 year ago
i LOVE this. id completely forgotten about it! regina says "he" its just hard to tell from the accent. her and jenny are really good friends cus they went to college or something together.
RoseIsSoFunny 1 year ago
NOTE: SHE SLEEPS WITH GIRLS, now apply that logic
satrinous 1 year ago
Dios... es tan hermosa <3 thanks for uploading the video! great song like the others
luisfranchu 1 year ago
I clearly heard "you". "I don't know if that's you, because that didn't sound like you". that's what you say when you're sweet and know someone and notice that that person is not allright. whatever,It's up to you. important this is that they're so GREAT!
*-* Please come to Brasil !! (this will probably never get to her, but whatever!) (Yes, people, the real Brasil's written with S, and not Z, our capital is not Buenos Aires nor Rio de Janeiro, is a dry aired city called Brasilia, actually.)
Isa0212 1 year ago
I really like this song and I love Regina but I find her answering machine voice so distracting from the song I just can't listen to it much. Why couldn't they have just made a different version or put it at only the beginning and end?
aasovj3w 1 year ago
This is amazing. I love reginas message. It's so emotional. And she's just wonderful. And jennys great too!
So good.
JNNikolas 1 year ago
at zonalGman92 first is definitly reg
BeatrijsBakker 2 years ago
omg, Reginas voice sounds like a little girls! Its so cute!! <3 First I didn't realize it was her, They're both so amazing <3
Hello2950 2 years ago 5
Also I don't think any of the voices are Regina's except the first one. Just listen the accents are so different. And I think it's neat having Regina on voicemail but credit goes to Jenny for writing/playing/singing the song. It's a great song anyway is all I'm saying. Thanx for posting spektography :)
zonalGman92 2 years ago 6
I heard this song thru Jenny Owen Youngs cos in London she is supporting Regina. So I got all Jenny's stuff too, since I have most of Regina's work( she's probably written another one as i type) and found the song and I am sure Regina says "P.S. I can't believe what YOU did" which makes sense to me cos Jenny & Bess et al who are on 'one more time with feeling ' podcasts are pretty crazy & love messing around. I think Regina sounds a little pissed off with her at the time. Friends do have tiffs?
zonalGman92 2 years ago 7
hey can you maybe please send me this song? My stupid german itunes doesn't sell it :(
gSaOcGgDhGiRl 2 years ago
@gSaOcGgDhGiRl
OMG i hate that thing about itunes too....
GUINEAMERIO 2 years ago
i love the way the recording at the start is so full of pauses, doubt, yearning and sorrow.
blackwarb 2 years ago 4
It´s a real answering machine message
LillybellX 2 years ago
is regina's part rehearsed or is it a real video message?
odieburger12 2 years ago
reginas voice is so beautiful):
wicked3lovely 2 years ago 4
when was this recorded?
odieburger12 2 years ago
a WHILE back..i first heard it like...2 yrs ago. (:
i still love it to this day
rebtar 2 years ago 3
Reginas voice is gorgeous.
So cute.
meeplesquadge 2 years ago 3
It does sound like Gregory! I love this!! REGINA ESPECIALLY :)
breandrach 2 years ago
I think the second an the last message are from the same Girl. And she talks deeper than Regina. Its sounds like an alto- voice and Regina is a soprano. I could be mistaken, but i think its another person
LillybellX 2 years ago
why wouldnt it be her?
mikjab14 2 years ago
OKAY. PEOPLE!
I have a theory about who the second girl on the machine is. Listen to the band "Gregory and the Hawk", and notice that after that message a light voice starts singing in the background...eh?EH? Haha. I got this song and love it.♥ Regina and Jenny rule.
aubschoosesjoy411 2 years ago 3
Never noticed that but I think I agree.
musbub 2 years ago
I've been listening to this song for a few months now, on J-O-Y's myspace page...how the HELL did I not know that was Regina Spektor??
haha, anyway, it makes me love the song even more =]
notgoodwithwords 2 years ago
The second voiceclip isn´t Regina, i think
LillybellX 2 years ago
I didn't write that my friend did. I have no idea who this chick is. she goes on our account. and she won't see your replies to her comment, so why even?
AsaGoneBad14 2 years ago
"i can't believe what he did."
...
?
MNBTM 2 years ago 5
regina´s soooooooooooooooooo great....
i love the first part, and when she goes "i dont know if thats you cause it didnt sound like you but you know its a funny world where machines could replace people..." SO GENIUS!!! i repeated the first part sooo many times !!,
love you regina.
kronologys 2 years ago 24
How is someone with a voice so beautiful like Regina, NOT singing in a song they're in!
But non e the less, great song.
jenyouwhine 2 years ago 4
her speaking voice is almost as beuatiful lol
bloomingauthor7 2 years ago
such a beautiful song
xalphabearx 2 years ago
so beautiful.
musbub 3 years ago 4
aw, love this so much
i'm SO glad they're friends
ballerinainatutu 3 years ago
ohhhh finally I know its her for sure I always couldnt figure out if she was saying regine or regina and if it was really her. And I thought she said PS I cant believe what YOU did but i guess im wrong??
AllyEmm 3 years ago 5
I thought she said this also, there are no lyrics for regina's talking section, what I have written above is what I believe them to be. After listening to the rest of the lyrics it would make more sense for her to say "he did" as this would comply with the direction of the track, not needing a relationship/boyfriend around anymore...???? :) ??
spektography 3 years ago 3
it doesnt seem like she is talking about a boy. i mean I don't see it anywhere, and she says ive got your voice on tape and you only hear female voices on the recordings. (the last one doesnt sound like Regina to me btw) First time I heard this I thought Regina and Jenny were gay or something.
CirclesInTheWater 3 years ago
"I can't believe what HE did", not "you". So, she's talking about someone else, calling her friend in the middle of the night to talk about it. And I think that Jenny is sitting listening to the voicemail from her friend, but she's thinking about someone else's voice on tape.
spektography 3 years ago 6
It's like, she's got this guy's voice on tape, and it sort of symbolizes the way we get obsessive about relationships, making up what we want them to be instead of seeing them for what they really are. As long as it's on tape she can imagine whatever she wants. And her friends are reaching in with the real world, but she's screening the calls living in her own world.
spektography 3 years ago 11
me too! jaja wishful thinking perhaps!
pato667 2 years ago
@AllyEmm if you turn it up and listen very carefully, it is "he". It does sound a lot like "you" on the first few listens though.
pri32us 1 year ago
Yeah, who is singing? That's not Regina.
crzynsproductions 3 years ago
...jenny owen youngs. its her song, not regina's. she's just the talking lady...and i can't believe i just said talking lady.
MNBTM 3 years ago 2
Haha, no, she's not JUST the talking lady... she's the life of this song! =P
Anyone know when this was recorded? Her SUNY days?
crzynsproductions 3 years ago
I have to agree. The song would be beautiful without her talking, but Regina's part just makes the song have an edge it didn't before.
musbub 3 years ago 3
@crzynsproductions I might go to SUNY :D I would be so happy if they accepted me :)))
BreannahelloFilms 7 months ago
where did you dig all these bad boys up from?!
dhdgjkdghjdghjdgdddd 3 years ago 12
Endless nights on the internet, forums, trading, all trying to complete the ultimate collection of music :)
spektography 3 years ago 2
oh man you have songs i dont even have and i have like 150 songs of hers on my ipod... this is lovely!!!!
sophiaclovee 3 years ago 3
I love Jenny. The song is called Voices on Tape, not Vocals, btw.
Your collection of Regina songs is outstanding. It is greatly appreciated.
caseydavid2 3 years ago 6
Thank you for pointing that out, I had re-arranged the title the other day and not done it correctly :)
spektography 3 years ago
It was correct in the screen and corrected in the title now ;)
spektography 3 years ago
who is singin?its a really nice song!
carolin988 3 years ago
never heard this one!
thanks for the post!
:)
rickypaulgriffin 3 years ago
WOW!! another Regina I haven't heard. It's really her?
AnthonyMinsky 3 years ago
The [----] is regina :)
spektography 3 years ago
[??? hope you could???but it's ok if, um???]
=i was hoping you could keep me company for the ride home, but it's okay if you're sleeping
[???I don't know if your a robot or what not but I just wanted to call to say hi but er???]
=I don't know if your a robot or what not but I just wanted to call to say hi and uh i think i might bring Marissa and Tracy up to Topeka
i hope this helps your head from exploding =)
tazzzling 3 years ago
tazzzling you are a star :)
I uploaded this late at night and couldn't have it on loud to get the lyrics 100% correct :)
spektography 3 years ago
aww thank you =)
you're a star for putting all these wonderful regina creations on youtube for everyone to hear and be amazed :D
tazzzling 3 years ago
Thank you for the positive feedback, not sure if you have read the information on the front page?
I worry about doing this, but at the same time I want to help share the love :/ confusing.
spektography 3 years ago
I cannot express the love i have for this woman. lol
guys like regina spektor too!
Nomkang 3 years ago
You better believe we do!!!! :)
AnthonyMinsky 3 years ago
Yes we do!
spektography 3 years ago
Never heard this before!! thx for posting
23Allie23 3 years ago