Added: 3 years ago
From: istillprefernoname
Views: 5,608
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (72)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • mariah because it's her song and she is just the best

  • mariah did sing this lively, check the anytime u need a friend thanksgiving 1993, very nice

  • at 1.03 was a horrible techinque. OMG

  • and mariah not good in live..

  • regine when she sing a song it will become bext version.. she is the bext singer in the world.. and so easy for her to hit a g#5 note here.. mariah.. in the paxt ix good but now we need to accept that she is sucks artixt.. when shex become a singer g#5 only is her highext note in chest and itx one time only.. but shex good in whistle..

    kyla ix good to..

  • @cleoalba its fucking annoying u regine fanatic fans try to compare her to mc n say mc sucks. in fact, the uploader of this vid might b a regine fan as well n chose the not-very-good live version of mariah. regine the best? go to hell

  • regine when she sing a song it will become bext version.. she is the bext singer in the world.. and so easy for her to hit a g#5 note here.. mariah.. in the pxt ix good but now we need to accept that she is sucks artixt.. when shex become a singer g#5 only is her highext note in chest and itx one time only.. but shex good in whistle..

    kyla ix good to..

  • Regine sounded sooooo ugly!!! Bwahahahaha!!! Mariah doesn't even have to sing high notes and she's still THE BEST. Kyla even did better. She didn't overdo the song like Regine. Hahaha, how funny!! Regine is officially the Growling Song Bird.

  • there are a lot of other live version of "anytime you need a friend" by mariah and this video is so bias that it picked the least beautiful rendition of hers. anyways, with her worst performance,she still standout. she's the original and the writer of the song anyways. :)

  • ang pangit ng growl ni regine

  • omg love this cover =D pls check out mines when you can xoxo

  • Regine did the orginal powerhouse version while Mariah did something different again to the song, she used more of her alto side the the soprano which neither Regine and Kyla is never comfortable with,... technically Regine did the best but this belongs ti MIMI cause it's her song, no one can put more passion and soul than her on songs she wrote,..

    Love all three of them.,...

  • Mariah sings..Regine screams..

  • Gosh..... how can you compare The Legend with the two copycats? Even this is Mariah's worst perfomance of AYAF, but this is MUCH BETTER then the other 2. Don't be so delusional.

  • argelmontemayor regine doesnt sound like celine and she will never will..an layo nga eh..hndi gnon ang boses ni celine. regine and kyla better stop singing mc songs..hndi bgay s knla mga gnitong knta!

  • regine!!! the best

  • regine sounded like celine dion here. especially dun sa "its alright! u know its alright!" part.

  • mariah is the real singer of this song, the other two are sounds like little girls learning how to sing...i like one comment here, that is so true mariah's range is so wide and shes very versatile and thats what makes her exceptional and incomparable...that exactly describes mariah...even regine knows mariahs better than her thats why she strive to sing like her...

  • i love comparisons... in this one its interesting how you've used what is probably regine and kyla's best performances but one of mariah's worst.... either way i think the fact that mariah actuall WROTE the song kinda predetermines the outcome of this comparison!!! :-) will someone post an unbiased comparison please???

  • Why did you put the worst live version of Mariah's performance? You should rather put the 1993 Thanksgiving version or in the Tokyo Dome. That will definitely standout.

  • MARIAH's high notes is very BEAUTIFUL.

  • i agree with azyardies, MARIAH's range is very wide and she's very versatile. THAT's what makes her INCOMPARABLE and EXCEPTIONAL

  • -- of course!!!!!!! no one can beat mariah!!! EXCEPT!!! MY IDOL!! REGINE VELASQUEZ!!!

  • Mariah. duh

  • Comment removed

  • regine

    kyla

    mariah?? i'll think about that..

  • cual es el gusto por tratar de igualar o imitar las canciones de otra persona, si vas a copiar por lo menos la idea es tratar de hacer una version propia, la verdad siento que estas niñas kyla y regine inspiran mucha lastima ya que quieren hacerse fama con creaciones de otras personas

    feliz o lamentablemente Mariah Carey es mucho mejor en todos sentidos tecnica, apoyo de voz, resonancia, vibrato, agilidad, tesitura etc.

    sin nada mas que decir, gracias

  • muy bien dicho.

  • kyla is good but mariah is better

  • what the hell was 1:02-1:05. Regine was growling up a storm and not singing any words. that was funny as hell.

  • i totally agree with you lol!!

  • Umm, I would have Libogzxh that Mariah show the least belting ability here on this one though she sound better on the verses.. But.. That was like Mariah's worse performance of Anytime you need a friend so it's not fair.. You should choose the one from her Music Box Tour 1993 or at least the one from Daydream tour 1996.. She's the best there

  • i'm a reginian, but i must say this song doesn't really fit regine's voice that much.

    her barks and growls sound very weak and too raspy. like what i've said a while ago, this songs requires breathy vocals and solid low notes. well you can't blame her if her low notes were that low and solid since she's a soprano compared to other two who have lower voice timbers

    but still, regine wins

    she's really the best

    but no one can beat mariah's studio version of this song. if only she can sing this live

  • YOu say, "but no one can beat mariah's studio version of this song. if only she can sing this live "...it just so happens that the version in this video IS IN FACT LIVE. So what are you talking about. No one beats MC in this song, Live or studio.....No one. She has so much flavor in her voice. So many different tones. She is incredible while the others, are just simply good....thats a big difference.

  • continuation...

    mariah rearranged the song. she lowered the keys and made it easier so she can sing and hit the notes. i love mariah, second to regine, but here she's the least. i hate it when she changes her songs too much. but she has the best and strongest low notes here. well, she's a contralto, that's why her low notes were clean.

    as for regine, she did hit the notes properly. very powerful, clear and everything was on their proper disposition. however, her barks were not that you know

  • 3)mariah

    2)kyla

    1)regine...

    why?

    at first before i heard kyla and mariah, i thought the worst version would come from regine 'coz this song requires so much texture(breathy vocals)in the vocals and i thought her voice won't fit this song. but when i listened to the other two, i could tell myself that regine is still superior.

    kyla's high notes were too tight and sound like squeezed from her throat. but i love her barks though i think they were misprojected.

  • I'm telling you man...regine sounds so terrible and her voice is too thin to be singing world's best singer Mariah Carey.

  • ikaw ang mag search...... may doubt ka kay regine..

    bobo lang may ganun...

  • well those girls looks so fake !!

    and mariah's version was on the david letterman show and she later commented that it was cold, n that's why she got some difficulty on that one...but it sounds so original or exciting...

    if you wanna compare mariah with the 2 girls, put this one (Anytime you need a friend - Soul convention mix) that'd be a lil *hot tamale* :)

  • hindi nila kaya yung version ko... may whistle.. wahahaha

  • why does Regine sing I'll be here kind of funny?

  • credits to mariah for writing the song!!!

  • hindi kaya ni regine ung part 2:50 and 2:58 ni kyla

  • ang tanga moh as if hndi porke walang ganun ung kay regine hndi nah nya kaya?bobo amf...

  • mas tanga ka,inamin nya kaya sa PPS na hindi nya kaya un,,BANGAG! try to research,,kahit minsan lang ha, ambobo,

  • i dont like regine's version,,,puro sigaw,,may time naman na msarap xa pakinggan,,pero from this song,,i dont think so.. i would prefer kyla,,

  • sino ba ang dyosa syempre c reg ang panalo super taas its alright.....................

  • Regine nailed the high notes, sana kantahin niya ulit to dahil years ago pa yang version niya na iyan.. Kyla was great but i dunno, there's something weird with her perf.. Mariah's perf here isn't good, she has other good perfs of this song anyway..

  • binaboy ni regine ung kanta

    lam nyo bkit????

    pati part ng back-up inagaw nya pa!!!

    sugapa

  • gago ka .. gago

  • hayop ka..

  • regines voice: humihiwalay sa back up masyado..

  • KYLA levelling up... she's brilliant and the other two are her idols.

  • i like regine! version!

  • iba pa rin pag rnb princess. the best!

  • kyla rules!!!

  • lupit ni regine at ni mariah, gayang gaya nila c KYLA! ASTEEG

  • @Accountancy hahaha.,

  • Mariah is definitely the best

  • this vid is a bit bias because istillprefer chose the worst performance of anytime by mariah. she has a lot better performances than this.

    anyway, all three of them are good.

  • i didn't know it's her worst. all her live performances are like this. her best, as always, is her studio version, but it would be unfair if i use it instead of her live performance.

  • no. this is the only live performance wherein she wasn't able to hit the high notes. she was able to do so at the tokyo dome and at the proctor theater.

    btw, when did regine sing this?

  • @istillprefernoname

    you cfould have usen her 93 thanksgiving special one

  • wat lang ha.. wag nating pagsabungin si kyla at si mariah.. alam nating lahat na super duper idol ni kyla si mariah. at sa tingin ko naman, this video was not made to show that kyla's version ids better than mariah. i think it was made to show how good kyla is in singing mariah songs.

  • *wait*

  • wait lang ulit. hehe.. kasama pala si ms. regine. basta ang point ko, wag natin masamain ang video na ito.. peace.Ü

  • yup. i'm a fan of all these 3

  • he/she put maríah's worst performance to show that regine hit the high notes properly, but I like the fact that mariah sang her own song in a different way.

  • regine!

    kyla!

    mariah!

  • kyla's *wink*

  • ang layo nun cd version at live version ni mariah

  • regine and kyla took the hardest version. mariah impriovised and made it easier. she has beautiful low notes though. kyla hit the hard notes but it sounded misprojected, and there was too much throat constriction. regine's high notes are clear, strong, and vibrant with better projection. refreshing and sweet voice quality. her growls and grunge though were not effective.

  • regine

  • I LIKE KYLA'S!!! WOOOOHOOOOOO

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more