Added: 5 years ago
From: calmar
Views: 37,335
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (202)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • One of DT's best songs. It's so awesome, and dark.

  • Excellent, well played!

  • is so good but in 4:05 is the same chord but in other position with the other hand :S

    the rest of the song is same the original, excelent

  • what keyboard are you using?

  • Thanks a lot, This is DTs best song and I thoroughly enjoyed watching you play.

  • MASTER.

  • my favorite song on scenes, and you just made it better

  • Insane!!!!

  • Awesome!! Really, this was an amazing cover! Great! You are skilled?

    What keyboard should I get, the ES or the Korg Triton Extreme?

  • korg m3

  • Why?

  • Because it's basically a model of the oasys but less costly and it also has a great realistic feel to it. Out of all the synths ouut there I believe that yamaha make the worst feeling keys aswell despite being the only company that actually make real pianos. I'd check it out on there website and also ask someone in a local shop who you can trust and wont just try to sell you the instrument and will actually help you with your dilemma.

  • Sorry, It really isn´t impourtant, but in my Anthology 4:05 is played with two hands (-:

  • Perfect

    Yes 2:56 is great

  • I love those arps you add in at 2:56

  • hey ur awesome, from philippines.. haha

  • fucken awesome man, uve got insane skills!

  • Amazing cover! I'm sure Mr. Ruddess would be quite impressed :)

  • Really great! your ear for synthesis is awesome and your ability is outstanding!

    ! can i ask, what keyboard is that is, it motif xs ?

  • Motif es

  • wow te envidio xD lo voy a tratar de sacar

  • The left hand at 4:13 its cRAzy!!

    Amazing cover Calmar,

  • JODIDO GENIO

  • Fucking awesome keyboard solo, and you nailed it perfectly. Kudos!

  • You´re a machine!

    Perfect!!!

    Best wishes from Spain!!!

  • how old is this guy?

  • Good Job! this may be a bit too much to ask, but could you give me any sound design tips on how to make the 'percussive attack' sound you use at around 4:00 and the big rudess signature lead at the end?

  • very nice!! did you learn all this with the ear? or du you have notes? how can i practice to become this good?

  • There's a book for the songs he plays ;P

  • where can i get it?

  • my respects man really awesome playing

    hey do you have the notes???

  • Damn, I remember when I was this good.

    ...I could never play those damn double hand arpeggios (at 4:06) either though.

    Very nice!

  • how did you switch your sound...???

    did you use a foot MIDI controller...???

  • exelent...ahora quiero ver el solo de in the name of god ....please....

  • you move ur fingers in a funny way ^^ haha, nice man

  • very nice dude, im currently also working on it. but you have some errors in your left hand and the part at 5.50 isnt played very good, you have to highlight the top notes, but anyway, very nice except some errors :)

  • Someone could tell me where to get the scores?

  • Very well, but @ 4:06 it´s two handed.

    But very BIG RESPECT!!!

  • someone might have said this before but i noticed something odd just after 2 minutes...

  • Great master! How long have you been playing the keys?

  • fookin hell mate! that was tight as fuck!

    and u cudnt have picked a better DT song to cover.

  • PERFECT !!

  • what kind of keyboard do you have?

  • its a yamaha motif xs

  • Yamaha Motif Es 8

  • this is excellent !

    congrats David

  • good left hand.you are good

  • Double check the notes at 5:26, those sound different.

    Very good though.

    Solo = nailed.

  • Nice work! To bad we're so far apart. I'd love to be your John Myung ...

  • WHAT!?!

    WHAAATT?!?!

    Wow can you be in my band?

    =)

    Damn that was freaking amazing!

    I bow, i bow...

  • this just reminded me that there can be others besides jordan rudess to play this good. that's a very good performance. congrats

  • Hey dude, tu devrais essayer de jouer le solo de clavier dans Octavarium! C'est mon préféré, j'suis sûr que tu l'aurais à la perfection

  • PLEASE! UPLOAD MORE STUFF!

  • Very good job! You rock!

  • WTF! AWESOME! :D

  • AMAZING

  • theres plenty of homage to petrucci out there, but not so much for Jordan Rudess. Good on you!

    And well fuckin done! I'm a guitar player, but even I know that anyone who gets that close to Rudess is amazing!

  • yes yes i practice ^^ ... every day for about 5 hours...^^

  • Very nice ! I have a question

    The sounds, do you make them? Theyre veeery close to to the originals, if not, the originals o.O

  • wtf? oO.. nice nice nice.... fucking great job... i wish i will play well as you

  • Practice hard, and its all possible ^_^

  • Great keyboard playing man! You're fantastic! how are the yamaha motif es and xs keyboards to play with? Do you change sounds just with a footswitch?

    Great Playing!

  • Amazing! Love the part from you start playing organ and through 3:10. You're amazing, if Jordan quit, I want YOU for replacement!

  • incredible!

  • seriously..simply amazing..rudess would be proud! Where did you get the sheet music????

  • Niiiiice!

  • wow!!! no more words... wow!!!

  • BUY BIEN

    Para mi la cansion mas difisil que se me hace tocarla

    y a ti te sale muy bien

  • F*#%$*NG AWESOME

    thats my favorite song by DT and you nailed it 100%

    keep up the excellent work

    P.S. you should do a video of Trail of Broken Hearts by DragonForce

  • FLAWLESS! SO GOOD MAN! KEEP IT UP!

  • Excellent bro, you are awesome... I've got a question, I'm trying to recreate the Rudess' Liquid Lead... I've got one, but i like the one that you recreated... Could you help me with it?

  • I might have commented this before, but fuck it it deserves it. Sick. Ive just started learning this song on Guitar, its so fun

  • Pretty Nice.

  • PITCH SHIFTERS RULE LIFE

  • ahahhaah

  • how do you change sound?

  • most likely with a footswitch. that's pretty much the only way to keep it free of the little breaks when switching. many of the better keyboards allow you putting all your sounds into a chain and than stepping through.

  • You are a BAD MOTHER FUCKER!!!!!! Incredible!!!

  • respect gars !

  • wow, that was insane! awesome stuff =D

    x

  • is this the Yamaha Motif XS 8 ?????

  • no is this the Yamaha Motif "ES" 8..

  • thabite ou! on pourais jammé!

  • Props... the band im in is doing this song, and i needed to see how some of those keyboard runs were done, so thanks a bunch. Keep up the good work!

  • AMAZING GREAT !!!

  • i love you... that was fuckin amazing!!!

  • Son Of A BUTT MONKEY! That was INSANE!!!!

  • This was awesome man...loved the solo part..

  • great!

  • hey i really want to learn this song, by any chance do u have the score for this?

  • Hey guy! You GREAT!

    Could you add me on youtube... i'm trying to make a project with youtube musicians.. I think u would be interested :-)

  • Not bad but you have to practice your technique cause it's weak my friend.

  • Omg, you are a really great keyborder :) Good Jod!!!

  • 4.50-5.00 dkkları içindekli sağ ele dikkat edilirse montaj olduu belli oluo daaa parca parca çalmış arkadas olsun yine de çalmış :D montaj olması biras uzcu baştan sona çalamadıını gosterir olsun ekipman yeter :D:D

  • Great Great performance, it's a very hard song, and the solos ... ufff ...

    however, the unison at the end ... i think th e keys are different ... at the 5th measure ...

    it's amazing anyways, congrats!

  • Can't putt words on how good you are. You're great! And .. Were do you get stuff so you know how what to play? You know .. Hmm, notes. :b I can't remember the english word. (Im danish). But. You are very good. :D

  • To bad your key board doesnt swival. Rudes Rules

  • good man. love it

  • man, you are very fluent at playing. Let me guess, hours upon hours of scale work? lol. This is great, but Yamaha makes sucky keyboards, go Korg and Kurzwiel!

  • i dont like yamahas either.... i prefer the roland fantom X series but hey great job man!!

  • are you alien????

  • kind of hard to heard your playing but it looks right, ROCK ON!

  • just AWESOME, one of the best vids i've ever seen

  • that's totally amazing!

  • mierdaaaaaaaaaa

    oh shit man...

  • that's playing that will make you choke on your spinage

  • Man thats some amazing finger work ROFL, absolutely amazing

  • shit dude. fucking great job. u naiiiiiled it.

  • Very Very Good.

  • Very VERY impressive. This is my favorite song by DT. Keep up the good work man.

  • Why didn't you play Through My Words too? I always play them together D:

  • what for keyboard? MM6??

  • my sister has that key bored.

  • english: it's amazing

    chileno:es un loni rekl xD

  • And by the way, how did you learn the lead solo, did you have music? If so, can I have it?

  • Its in the official Keyboard Anhtology book. You can find it in online stores if you look for it.

  • Hey, at the part at 1:17, it looks like you skipped the G where you have to reach a 10th. I can't reach it either, so I don't blame you.

  • hey, would it be possible to get the notes for the part from about 2:56 to 3:09? thanks bro.

  • You should actually do that arpeggio-thing at 04:06 with your both hands.. :D

  • Damn I should buy that Keyboard Anthology but I don't have a normal credit card...

  • hey man u need to do more videos! i gotta see more and faster stuff! XD more!

  • you're my god !! :P crazy !!

  • You Really Need More Videos!!!

  • haha that's crazy!

  • very good man!

  • you play very well guy, if you live in brazil - recife you can join on my band of progressive metal. ;D

  • Yes let us know where you find the Keyboard parts (score/midi) that helped you in learning that.

    Thanks

  • The whole thing is in the Keyboard Anthology book from Dream Theater..can buy it off their site

  • can you make yourself louder in the mix?

    it's hard to determine which is you. looks great though, hard to make even moving your hands that fast look that convincing.

  • Very good performance, couple mistakes but last unison is completely wrong, you can find the correct midi file, or guitar pro tab on net... Keep going...

  • you rule man!

  • Need more videos! :(

  • awesome men!

  • I hate you. Lawl. Keep playing dude, you rock.

  • Nice playing!!!. Amazing stuff for a 16 year old!.

    Do you mind sharind the score/midi you use to lean playing this song??. Can`t find a good one on the net.

  • wow this is fucking perfect!! you rox!

  • Awesome dude....you're 16?

    I was watching DT <Majesty> in a local Bar before you were even Born!! woah.. I'm gettin' old.!

  • excelent solo and tecnique!

  • god youre dying you should eat more look at ur ankles!

  • Very good job.

  • you know what... i completely agree with all the guys that commented on your video.. you rule at keyboards, yo should be the next jordan rudess

  • wow u played all the guitar and sang just like dream theaterr tooo

  • You are a Realy Fuckin Bastard!!!!

    Im a keyborder too, and i love dream theater!

    One day i will put Caugth in a web made by me!

    I haven't a videocam but when i will have it, i will post it.

    Ps:Is Jordan Rudess your parent?:)

    Or maeby your teacher?:)

  • Great Job! Would be so cool to play with you sometime, though I live in Sweden. I play bass, and I know a good drummer who plays a lot of DT.

  • Oh my O_O Amazing ^_^ Love the keyboards

  • WOW ! I CANT  BELIEVE

  • WOW!...U are amazing,man!You shure kick ass =)

  • clap clap clap !!! xD Great

  • hey hey...who are you??

  • I like the way you play, brother. I just joined your subscriptions.

  • OMFG! you're fuckin amazing!! its just awsome! your great man.. \m/ dream theater rulles \m/

  • hey dude where are you from?, it'd be great to play together cuz i love DT and i guess you do too.

  • damn - you kick ass!! great !

  • Wanna jam? lol

  • VERY GREAT...THIS IS FUCKED ROCKERS!

  • A bit off at 2:00. :)

    But then afterwards....

    I got chills, man :)

    Fuckin' GREAT!!!!

  • Great!

    U have impressionant skills and MOTIF keyboard ... Im studying this song too but I'm having some problems with the solos. Do you have this music sheets?!

  • You kick basicly

  • Very well done my friend, keep it up

    great song

  • Fantasico!! I can't stop watching!

  • Amazing. I cannot believe my eyes. A very hard song to play! How long did it take you to learn this and what skill level do you consider this song? Also any insight into how long you've been playing? I see you've said you've never had lessons but how did you learn all your techniques, including your incredible speed and accuracy? Also if I could throw in a request can you do One Last Time including the awesome piano intro? THANKS!

  • AWESOME

  • ha very nice

  • GREAT STUFF !

  • you're very good man:)

    ur synth is very good too

    congratulations!

  • great ! do you wanna play in my band? :D

  • calmar, what keyboard is this??

  • CALMAR...congratulations! Don't hear the bad comment...a bad musician i think...

  • i think u must try to loosen up your like too stiff but its really cool u have it!

  • look at 2:03-2:04 the video cut and replays hmmm and the music contunue ..

  • That's because my camera can't film more than 3 minutes, and the audio was recorded in my computer, and was mixed all in one track after the video. hmmmmm

  • wow very nice !! im 15 and i play keyboard too, but i have a yamaha psr 303...a shit :(

    i have to practise some dream theater songs :)

  • amazing skill as in your other DT displays, these songs ARE NOT EASY to play. Hope you have lots of success in the future.

  • just amazing man only 16?? ... great player and great taste for music, keep playin!

  • OMG that's amazing!

    I'm 18, and I can't play like that =P

    I can play some parts of fatal tragedy but I can't get done the solos

    you are an amazing pianist

  • nice, im 16 too and im close to play this song on the drums

  • <