張學友-最佳損友live

[yiaphwee]

张学友是我中学时期的偶像。

时隔二十年的现在在认真去听他各种大小演唱或cd（包括以前），­老实说一句，我不明白他是凭什么冠上“歌神”这称号！！比如这首­个他唱得声音直出，没一种内敛得声音，唱得硬又偏大声兼吵！！另­外，他的声音确实没什么低音，薄兼硬！！“爱与交响曲”都是唱得­硬兼过头大声，声音直出，没什么控制力！！张学友另一个问题就是­有鼻音，高音通常都是压着来唱，显得非常硬！！！

张学友的缺点实在太多，基本上是唱不出“尾音”与较为自然的柔度­！

歌神？？！！认真请问下他到底好在哪里？

[ozalice96]

@yiaphwee Please refer to 小城大事-張學友2007.

@princecharming and my comments to you still stand!

[somewherecome]

=.=早知解去到講分手果度好明顯有換氣...

[a544049483]

说没换气的那人。。真是无知- -

[rhododendronnami]

這首歌的旋律，意境還有張學友的演唱方式我都喜歡！



[kei928]

和音: 陳奕迅

邊有得輸呀

[rhododendronnami]

喜歡這個旋律w

[kennth27]

歌曲很不熟haha

[jackylst]

感情澎湃但係吾到位

[pointguard]

jacky's bridge has a v special tempo..but pitching was all over the place especially the last line..i love both singer, but we gotta be honest.

[PerfectDiver]

1:57 eason個眼神: 頂你咩張學友...唱得好聽過我咁多...

[namrak88]

學友 doesn't need to breathe? can't hear where he even took a break.

[d0ubled0uble]

@namrak88 He breaths through his nose and not big breathe. He maintains his chest cavity roughly the same size all the time. Eason still uses his lungs all the time and cracking his throat

[emailrandy]

Not fair to compare. One is the King and one is the Prince... Whatever song Jacky covers would sound heavenly.

[s777991a]

Eason好!!



[lonely1874]

学友的身材很棒咧。。



[abhksar]

好有自己嘅節奏 ~ :)

[fotfood]

好鍾意學友唱呢首歌

[yiaphwee]

学友的声音唱得有点过重(有一点over,,控制力欠了点) 带少许硬 低音也欠缺了点(偏高) 声音欠了感染力 (论唱歌的难度eason的唱法明显较难(很内练) 学友这种较为普通) 我觉得eason好!

[ozalice96]

@yiaphwee I beg to differ. Jacky's version is more melodious while

Eason's version sounds more like reciting his lines from a book

which you called subtle. Different artists have different interpretation

of the song and which version the audience prefers is just a matter

of opinion. I prefer Jacky's!

[s777991a]

@yiaphwee 我也這麼覺得



[kahang19870719]

你地係咪聽漏左

學友強項 貼住支咪都無抖氣聲

[kahang19870719]

係咪你地睇漏左

張學友強項 貼住支咪都可以無抖氣聲

[kahang19870719]

係咪你地睇漏左

張學友強項全程貼住支咪都可以無抖氣聲



[tmms6c36321]

好勁

[z33293891]

有時唔係一口氣唱哂就等於勁, 等於好聽既

況且一口氣過&一啖氣一句都有唔同既feel, 何必執著

[vandervarrt10]

@z33293891 唔係一口氣過&一啖氣既分別，張學友佢有換氣，不過係用丹田，換­左你都唔知，呢樣其實應該係歌手最基本的技巧，聽到依家既歌星每­唱一句都"下下"聲真係好剌耳。不過有好似你呢d咁無所謂既樂迷­d歌星都唔洗咁辛苦去練，個樣ok把聲好聽就行得出黎做。

PS:扯曬蝦黎唱果d真係唔知係咩feel，仲要首首歌都係咁

[d0ubled0uble]

@vandervarrt10 Agree! Jacky doesn't need to breath all the time, just need to reset his diaphragm position to maintain proper air flow. Eason....... keep squeezing his throat. 

[kawaihui]

Impressive, 2 different styles, both good at their own way~

[hyuanhan]

我覺得好有兒童歌曲feel

好似友共情咁0 0哈哈

[eugenecch]

我鐘意eason 10多年了,但學友唱:早知解散後各自有際遇作導遊

奇就奇在接受了各自有路走

卻沒人像你讓我眼淚背著流

嚴重似情侶講分手 eason一定做唔到 佢一口氣唱 還用真音 冇升降key 歌神才做到

[damnsorrow]

@eugenecch

你真係覺得佢係一口氣...?

佢係導遊同背著流後面都透左氣，只係好細聲姐

仲有各自有路走個走字走左音，同埋我覺得佢唱得好似想rap咁，­唔太鐘意個感覺

不過學友d震音真係好好聽，同埋佢把聲夠厚

[eugenecch]

我鐘意義eason 10多年了,但學友唱:早知解散後各自有際遇作導遊

奇就奇在接受了各自有路走

卻沒人像你讓我眼淚背著流

嚴重似情侶講分手 eason一定做唔到 佢一口氣唱 還用真音 冇升降key 歌神才做到

[eugenecch]

爆肺唱法 勁

[imkayfull]

我覺得唔好聽，唱得D音好作狀。。eason同kay唱得最好聽­！

[henrycheung]

 还是喜欢eason的版本

有那种经过岁月的磨砺，无可奈何的感觉。

[marioyu]

i personally think this is better than eason's...especially near the end....so much air

[marioyu]

jacky cheung totally took the spotlight

[901128]

一個識識整頂級鮑魚同魚翅嘅大廚, 必邊可以整得出鋪頭仔嘅特色小菜.

呢點放喺音樂到尤其適當, 亦正正係音樂好玩嘅地方.

冇人係無敵, 冇人永遠會比另一個人好. 你唱得幾勁都好, 總有歌你未必拿捏得好似人哋咁好.

張學友有佢唱得比人好嘅歌, 陳奕迅都有, 任何人都有. 咁所以我哋先需要咁多歌手喺呢個樂壇到.



[Caliphcheng]

学友唱得很完美 但是我还是更喜欢E神版的

[BestPlaceDavidMo]

两个都很棒，比喻

Jordan vs Kobe same as Jacky vs Eason

[hehehahawowawo]

雖然不停吹快

但真係勁震撼

首歌原本已經好正

但佢唱真係好...

真係好似飲醉酒然後好激動咁

而後「講分手」果度超正

而且佢全程用真音

把聲又紮實

好正牙!!!!!!

[013926018]

还是喜欢原版，不过学友的版本也很赞

[hobXD]

如果冇唔記得歌詞，咁就 PERFECT!!!!

[Caliphcheng]

两大歌神都很拉风啊 不过就这首歌来说E神的更好听

[ex822]

eason給人一種淡淡的哀愁 學友給這曲歌多了感慨與激動 二種不同的詮釋方法 其實都很好聽......都很喜歡

[phoenixj24]

Jacky is ust loud. Missed the irony in the song completely.  Eason has more tone varierty.

[MrBoscocho]

技巧當然係100分啦, , 但係一d感情都feel唔到....

[ngok01116]

Eason 比較熟呢首歌！ Jacky 版本有佢風格!!

[SRTOASRAK]

我先入為主左

我覺得E神唱得個FEEL正D-,-

[mankcpk]

不拿學友同Eason比,

總覺得學友這首歌唱不出平時的水準....

雖然...都是很好聽,

只是應該可以更好

[mankcpk]

不拿學友同Eason比,

總覺得學友這首歌唱不出平時的水準....

[kim069100]

E神版本較佳..

[MrHanghang]

兩個都好﹑

[kill106]

老實說

技巧一百分

不過我接受不了這樣的演譯方法...

[PPVISME]

@kill106

totally agree

[iamsupergirlon99]

張學友唱咩歌都係咁ge樣

[mo1990117]

如果冇唱錯歌詞 真係一絕 但唱錯 真係怪怪地 =_=

[W1313iY]

始終都係Eason唱嘅板本最正-3-

[pmkoola]

wtf

[aaronchnahkk]

1:43 嗰到個是, 變左個亦字

[Kafzo]

唱到好似rap咁..

[lichaksum]

勁甩咀同勁改歌詞

[KATE520Khalil]

係!!講得好岩真係!!真係只要eason只唱出令人心酸,掂到­內心戈種感覺

[icq23838]

學友係1:21「即使相處到」既「使相」走左音，「相」字走得勁­d，可能因為咁，影響到性格情緒化既學友係後面唱錯歌詞同甩嘴

[tongmizu]

3:14 :P

[samtohginleon]

If your friend betray you.. this will be the right feel to sing this song...sad with anger.... very SOLID Jacky !!!

[hatsya]

Eason和音good!

學友也唱得好

[niceday123321]

我就中意Eason版本多d

因為佢可以唱出首歌靈魂

令我有感觸及懷念朋友嘅感受

[Otwinklestar]

Bravo!

[andrewcwh]

jacky cheung forever !!!

[sa00123456789]

長氣袋-0-

[chan3824]

用他的唱法去唱,要多一個肺至唱得惦,輕到好似無透過氣咁...­

[kotiwan]

楼下说张学友唱歌缺少感情。。。。彻底惊呆了。。。您听过学友唱­歌么？

[shuraowen]

@death0400 You got it. I really think every singer has some trademarks. For this song, Eason is way better... I cries from beginning when Eason starts "friend, I was your one-second friend".

And actually Eason is more emotional.

[kane1228]

歌神真係歌神

[sos88626]

我係佢兩個fans

論唱功,學友的確勝一籌

但係論感情味道,我都係中意eason既版本多d

多左一份無奈

[eddytan82]

Wah~ very SOLID jacky cheung and bring out the feel

[Sexfeverca]

唱歌又唔係打擂台，有セ話邊個勁啲！兩個都唱得好好呀.

[forever2005]

真係好勁好勁...完全係呆了 ...

[garymok007]

搞笑~~ 唔記得歌詞

[leetszyung]

感覺學友的場境像是喝醉酒,陳奕迅像是在黑暗中的獨白,各有各好­~但我個人 還是喜歡陳奕迅靜默中的心痛~

[kevinlamisgood]

能夠做到好似eson同學友咁既功力既人好少......需然e­son唔係學友既對手...已經好好....希望垃圾歌手可以學­下兩位

[sunaw0912]

我中意eason 唱的味道

[funnybunny9396]

我就鐘意聽"歌神"這個版本多d

[kammoming]

雖然學友鋅係唱得好勁

可見功底

但我鐘意e神果個多d

果個感情

[nikewong]

bravo

[kamkakit]

真係令時下不少垃圾歌手慚愧

[peachlo]

eason已經唱得好好,以為無人唱呢首歌會好得過佢, 但學友真係學友, 一開聲真係見功力,好有味道!!

[canaduh]

thx for upload. He is the best!

[leewookie1]

歌神 - 張學友!

[heiloves]

好正呀!!

[limxinwei]

Jacky powerful....

[funnybunny9396]

jacky is the BEST !!!!

[Bryanluk2007]

其實學友係咪將首歌既key 升左 ?

[Bryanluk2007]

學友 ...

你的唱功 .....

太厲害

[96097193]

Eason唱得比較果個歌d味道

[shampooyuki]

有不同的味道^^

[leochan1993]

除左差d唔記得歌詞...記得都好好聽...。

佢全首用真音-___'

[tszkong]

所以我唔鍾意d人成日話eason唱得無學友咁勁 根本佢就用自己既方式去唱 無得比

[Pires520]

學友用了一種新的詮釋方法

原唱的Eason唱得比較傷感

但學友給了人一種正面的信息

Eason:唱得比較絕望,朋友真的沒有了

學友:給了人一種正面態度,朋友我們還會有明天

歌詞雖死,但歌者演繹的感覺卻是活生生的

兩者演繹方式雖有不同,但同樣能觸動人心

有需要作比較嗎?

[xz365421]

@Pires520 好!說的好!!



[mok002]

分手果到好癲呀!!!!!!

~.~

[iamtotallyshameless]

Jacky is good, but I still think this song belongs to Eason.

[tmc02086]

學友用冇咁傷感既feel唱...

可能亦反映學友對首歌既睇法

[stranger4135]

我一向認為學友唱得比eason好

但尼首歌..

真係eason好些

佢後面一些高音冇到位

[taki651227]

eason唱帶出尼個感覺好好多

真係可以勾起人地好多野既感覺

雖然學友係歌神

但係尼首歌除左eason

冇人可以演繹得更佳!!!!

[unitechtu]

Jacky cheung sing very perfect and powerful.. bring out deeply feel

[chingfungtse11111]

呢個版本學友有2次混淆左歌詞, 我聽果個版本無0既? 果個係eason演唱會?

[kahllee567]

學友的唱腔給人一種很特別的感覺啊

很切合這首歌,更加有味道

[Amen1020]

果然一山還有一山高....

[xcheeb]

both version have their own good and bad point. eason's version is of course more soothing and gives the "what a waste" feeling.

jackie' version is a bit too "powerful", though it helps to bring out the helpless feeling.

[shortshortdi]

well, theres a "music tailor" and this song fits only perfectly to eason' voice. Jacky is great, but only to his own songs. Cover is cover, cant replace the original. That happens to most of the cases.

[chingfungtse11111]

jacky! what a performance!

[myhairlosing]

I still prefer the original. Jacky's is a bit too strong and bright for this song.

[karyko92]

學友更有蘈feel. 個种飲左幾罐beer的感覺

[fung123890]

如果張學友有唱埋假音,就好啦

[harcnir]

因為佢真音太勁 習慣要更高佢先會用到假音

[johnny0415]

LOL, Jacky sings it like a rap battle.

[will1506]

Wow..Jacky, almost 50..such great control over this vocals still.

[wingwingstudios]

jesus!splendid jacky,i think that eason will get mad cause u sing his song better than him! thanks jackyfans80119!

[liondog81]

wow ur sad.

[mintoill02]

thanks thanks! since the last one was removed, have been trying to find this clip! thanks a lot!

[TimHowardII]

Jacky didn't miss the lyrics on the previous version though.

[ahdeeso]

好勁呀=口=學友~Nice

搶晒Eason把聲。

[KKL51244]

eason系度帮忙和声

所以5算抢声啊

不过都好中意两个敢有实力既歌手一齐合作！

jacky台劲啦

[ho1317]

eason 唱和音架喎呢首歌, 唔洗玩啦

[jacinthtw]

好強啊...最後強音轉弱...收的超漂亮

[jackyfans80119]

對阿!!

覺得學友唱出了這首歌的味道~

[tmc02086]

靚過CD D效果!!

[selenity08]

I love Jacky's rendition. I've been trying to find this. Thank you so much!

[jackyfans80119]

I found this film for a long time

I compare to like better the performance of jacky(This is just my opinion)