See, I've got not problems with the concept of a music video at all. In fact, I think they're a great idea. It's an excellent way to convey the emotions and the thought process that went into writing a piece of music. I just think people have been horribly abusing music videos. Take almost any rap, hip-hop, pop, or mainstream rock song and the music videos are just garbage. We need more creativity and heart put into them. Tool and NIN are good examples of what I'm talking about.
haha missy contraband! so funny lol omg i loooooove this song and the concept behind the lyrics, trent is so clever :) great song when you're pissed off lol empowering
omg how can you not like this song!!! it's better live!!! i'm presuming you've seen him do it live? even on dvd? it sounds rubbish on this vid. one of the cleverest songs he's done, it's true there is no YOU there is only ME, as in the big me US :) collective!
I've heard that they had really big problem witht he apple that was supposed to move (in the end of the video). Do you know how they did that? And why it was such a big problem?
FAKE
h0b0ch1c 2 months ago
there is no spoon!
RX1603 8 months ago
aaaarrgghh that angry face! :D
0Zero0San0 9 months ago
this was the best music video of 2005
JohnnyLovely2 1 year ago
See, I've got not problems with the concept of a music video at all. In fact, I think they're a great idea. It's an excellent way to convey the emotions and the thought process that went into writing a piece of music. I just think people have been horribly abusing music videos. Take almost any rap, hip-hop, pop, or mainstream rock song and the music videos are just garbage. We need more creativity and heart put into them. Tool and NIN are good examples of what I'm talking about.
Makonu2 1 year ago 11
David Fincher = Genius
dhritimanbatchu 1 year ago 4
thats so fuckin weird
skateNappreciate 1 year ago
Always fascinated by what I can find on youtube. I always wondered how they made this video and viola! that simple...not, cool vid :)
modernlover0rosalyn 1 year ago 5
I have one of those pinart nailboard thingies.
Dltn97 1 year ago
I loooove it!
xRockinBabyDoll94x 1 year ago 3
1:17 yum
princesssookeh 1 year ago
1:48 - *melts* =)
AggieMaryann 1 year ago
I had no idea that the entire thing was generated. Whoo! Go Trent!
Angela514639 1 year ago 3
David Fincher made this video? Awesome!!!
KennHeston 1 year ago 2
Damn! I wondered how they did the pinboard... I never realized it was CG!! thats some good ass CG!!!
theXfaction 1 year ago
This vid is mind-blowing in its simplicity...a trip to watch.
dgareea31swtg 2 years ago 4
@dgareea31swtg hahahahahaha...this was released as a promo or something?????
servo1056 1 year ago
Now if only he put the same effort into the hand that feeds video that he put into this video.
Atak0fth3Umpalumpas 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm a huge David Fincher and NIN fan, but what a shit video...and for one of the best songs on With Teeth too...I was really disappointed.
dxanex 2 years ago
So everything was CG. oO
Impressive!
David Fincher also directed "Panic Room", this video remember me some effects from the movie.
carlsaraiva 2 years ago 4
the music made the pins move thats how!
Yellowhorn666 2 years ago
AWESOME!!!
Redzombie13 2 years ago 3
Well, I don't completly understand: how's the pin made? is it some kind of script that translates the video to pin movement? Shaders?
Tehstroyer 2 years ago
Soo digital : )
ckop6a 2 years ago 2
Thats so clever!
I always loved this video, and wondered how they did it.
Very clever! :)
pandorakun 2 years ago 5
Wow... That's amazing
stakleni00 2 years ago 2
holy balls thats probably one of the coolest things ive seen in a long while. im thinking of learning how to do some of that stuff myself =D
Pardelto 2 years ago 3
HOLY BALLS.
Someone else says 'holy balls' :D.
HIGH FIVE!
pointlesspeoplehere 2 years ago
learn about bump maps,. 256 shades of grey can give you height and depth when maped onto a 3d image,. damn, I have to get back into that 3D shit
TheLivingDeadOne 2 years ago 3
holy crap that CG is impressive, I thought the only cg was the nailboard
Killerclownmeat 2 years ago 47
David Fincher? He's the dude who worked on the Alien movies, right? I think he was the visual effects supervisor, or something... Suits 'im.
Blade3327 2 years ago
David Fincher directer Aliens 3, Fight Club, Se7en, Zodiac & Benjamin Button.
MissHxcfairy 2 years ago 4
Right, right. I didn't know he directed Benjamin Button, though.
Blade3327 2 years ago
me encanto! fue como preciso el video, dejarnos en claro fue que se hizo, no crei que usaran tanta tecnologia!
muy buen video ; )
lariren 2 years ago
thanks for sharing
gradam 2 years ago
I would have never thought that the whole thing was animated! lol
digyourowngrave666 2 years ago 2
i never expected it to be CG, maybe the pins in the glass case but not everything wow
adias06 2 years ago 3
it kinda fits the song though... since he "made" everything up
so the whole video is made up (CG), even though its a convincing reality
sicandbored 2 years ago 8
i get what you mean didnt think of it that way
adias06 2 years ago
awesome image work
I thought it was real, not a digital drawing
beside this it's a very clever concept for this song
Thiago1950 2 years ago
me too O_o awesome
nitesianka 2 years ago
whoa that looks very real! i didn't know the whole room was all done by computer. and the apple or the coffee!
this is awesome, seriously. damn.
michiimouse 2 years ago 5
the laptop... looks like Mac, its a mac or not?
e45ay 2 years ago
its a g4 powerbook.
kevasaurus 2 years ago 2
Why is it so important?:D
nandi8 2 years ago
why do they censor the 'fucking'? -.-
herrMaria 2 years ago 3
i think it's stupid, too.
everybody knows it's there... you even posted it right here.
almost1st 2 years ago 5
good question
nandi8 2 years ago
oh wow! i would never have thought the coffee was CG, it all looks so real
misscraptacular 2 years ago 6
the coffee was CG? no wonder it was all computery
ToOlOGT22 2 years ago
damn DIGITAL DOMAIN RULESSS!!
akutenshi69 2 years ago
one of the best music videos ever made...awsome work...
missbrainshaker 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
good song but boring video
poolboyinla 3 years ago
amazing
boobsteak 3 years ago 4
I thought that only the pins were animated! Even coffee was animated! Wow!
avelione 3 years ago 2
Thought exactly the same mate. Amazing piece of original work.
gutworm45 2 years ago 2
omg i thought they were just filming this at a real room with a little bit of help of a computer! it all looks so real!
karinalebedev 3 years ago
gotta love houdini :P
PaintMaryconley 3 years ago
Cool...
xXEmotionalxKillerXx 3 years ago 4
the thing where trents face comes out. whats it called?
the one with the pins and shit?
angeloftheblood 3 years ago
a pin cushion
sariusmonk 3 years ago
wrong man.
angeloftheblood 3 years ago
pin impression?
LittleDude490 3 years ago
Wait...What?
None of that was real
Holy Shit
iuscott01 3 years ago 3
i know i thought it was real too
uberari 3 years ago 4
So, because the false reclaim,
I lost this:
Nine Inch Nails - ONLY
Text Comments: 3,560
04:25 From: pablost07
Views: 2,246,390
The video response of ONLY - NINE INCH NAILS above is the original with sound that I uploaded again because of the note on the old video reclaimed.
Sorry, was not my fault. Thanx for the space.
pablost07 3 years ago
very realistic cg.
AyaxTelemonio 3 years ago
bah. figured it was CG. still, i like the concept of it.
TYsmite 3 years ago
that was f u c k i n g great.
Qnilla 3 years ago
i ONLY have 3 words my friend creepy, crazy, awesome. oh and 1 more thing trent reznor is a industrial/rock god.
giga0524 3 years ago
where is the creepy?
preoqpyddlusion 3 years ago
The video was directed by David Fincher,director of Seven,The Game,Fight Club etc.
Bye!
pablost07 3 years ago
rob sheridan is a fucking beast
KCOutlaw0 3 years ago
agree
REvaleKrauser 3 years ago
wow i was wondering how they did that...now i know
mindzombi3 3 years ago
Wow! Everything looked so real.
ryubaks 3 years ago
Holy shit, nice.
InnocentzRaptor 3 years ago
Lyrics say it all....creative video just exemplifies; such creative talent.
mrop4 3 years ago 5
lol @ munchkinwithaspork.
this vid is tiiight. but i like watching trent by himself on the green screen better. hah
teardwnyuridolz 3 years ago 5
Oh man I was thinking the same thing! Haha.
anthonykiedisbegod 3 years ago
badass
PatricRox 3 years ago
trent has so much money!
obscureface 3 years ago 4
yeah I mean we're just talking about one video.
Just look at The Slip and Ghosts I-IV
the man must really love his fans...
badluckshadow13 3 years ago 4
Nothing in this video is real , not even me!
MissyContraband 3 years ago 5
haha missy contraband! so funny lol omg i loooooove this song and the concept behind the lyrics, trent is so clever :) great song when you're pissed off lol empowering
pommepot 3 years ago 3
I love the lyrics myself!
"Theres a doorway trying to seal itself shut, but I climb through"
MissyContraband 3 years ago
There is no desk, there is only me!
munchkinwithaspork 3 years ago 69
@munchkinwithaspork
Haha nice.
spades4811 1 year ago
@munchkinwithaspork lol
bluebow23 1 year ago
wow
awesome
b3ts13 3 years ago
Interesting, but why this style
masterbobgood 3 years ago
Nothing in the goddamned video is real!
AHHHH!
But, it's amazing. :).
JustusDestruction 3 years ago
Absolutely incredible. I still can't believe my eyes :-D
NightVisitor101 3 years ago 5
the song isnt great but this is one of the most interesting videos ive ever seen.
derekchewie11 3 years ago
omg how can you not like this song!!! it's better live!!! i'm presuming you've seen him do it live? even on dvd? it sounds rubbish on this vid. one of the cleverest songs he's done, it's true there is no YOU there is only ME, as in the big me US :) collective!
pommepot 3 years ago 4
Thats true, ONLY is much better live, as shown on the BYIT dvd
MissyContraband 3 years ago
My first NIN song...
ratexla 3 years ago 7
Me too!!! was a while ago now though.
Ryno4269 3 years ago
one of the best videos I believe
clarad001 3 years ago
very cool
schemes16 3 years ago
I love this video, and I think Trent looks really good in pinArt!!! Definitely one of my favourite NIN songs/videos
rainelinden 3 years ago 5
kako je ludo covjece! :D great!
92zoe123 4 years ago
Fuckin' dope shit!
Spifficus 4 years ago
I remember watching this vid when it first came out. I always thought the desktop was real. Pretty good CGI.
PearlJammer07 4 years ago 3
God, me too... Incredible, isn't it? And the song's unreal too :)
briani4735263 4 years ago 4
All I can wonder is how long that took to render.
ZetalZ 4 years ago
Wow. Really interesting!
ros3h 4 years ago
i like his change of hair style. still keeps to his character.
nadaquefazer 4 years ago 4
Trent Reznor angst x video = visual drug
nadaquefazer 4 years ago 2
wow.... trent looks kinda chubby in that green scrren part... no wonder he went uberbuff...
aschen 4 years ago
Wow, the desktop looks so real in the actual video. I love that video.
bananabaconcake 4 years ago
awesome vid
AMXNIN 4 years ago
oooh emo hair back when it wasnt emo but hot.
galerandyaddict 4 years ago
Tough shit for deleting the "fucking" part.
Ok I know this is not about the song but the making of the vid.
Fucking interesting, though. Amazing how penetrating is Trent in silver.
TrentIsMine 4 years ago
Fascinating.
Now, I just have to understand what the hell all that jargon means XD
DZrache 4 years ago
I've heard that they had really big problem witht he apple that was supposed to move (in the end of the video). Do you know how they did that? And why it was such a big problem?
KingGulerod 4 years ago
I would assume the physics of an apple falling is hard to mimic... Just a guess though.
Seedr0 4 years ago 2
oh... i didn't know that everything in this video is made with the computer...but i like it
Kuehlschrank2 4 years ago