Added: 4 years ago
From: Pogi667
Views: 158,265
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,125)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Steve Perry committed career suicide over a QUARTER OF A CENTURY AGO!! It's over.. It's done... He's done...Journey has moved on to play concerts all over the world and Steve has moved on to do.... NOTHING!!

  • @HISTORYDUDE2112 = MORON

  • You are comparing mastered audio from the released video against live "unbrushed" and acoustically imperfect stage performance...not fair Arnel is incredible but not better than Steve.. I don't think ANYONE is better than Steve actually...

  • Comment removed

  • I am A HUGS Journey fan and most importanty Steve Perry. No one will ever replace him, but let's give Arnel some credits. First of all it takes TRUE GUTS to do what he is doing, knowing full well he would be help up to scrutiny. Sure, he isn't Steve, he's Arnel, but his voice beautiful. Never will it be Steve, nor should it ge. It's just his way of paying homage to Steve and group that has meant so much to all of us. Remember, think positive people, life is too short!

  • The whole freakin' point is that HE'S COPYING STEVE!!!!! I'm a professional singer/musician here in Chicago and it doesn't matter how well you "cover" someone else. It's still a cover. All of my fellow musicians in here will agree with me that, for us, Originality is an axiomatic and indespensible quality. Without it? You're just another cover, copycat and a wannabe. Steve IS the original.....period.

  • @redmondsmusic Absolutely true. This is of course not to discredit Arnel as he's simply doing a job. But if we're to even consider pitting one against the other there is no comparison and I'd venture to guess Arnel knows that. Very good singer indeed, so not to take away from him, but come on people! There is but one Steve Perry. I learned many a song on drums because of Journey. Saw them live in the early 80s and was floored. Steve Perry, Steve Smith two of my all time faves for life.

  • @redmondsmusic After reading your comments I may make you my new BFF! lol

    Seriously, I totally agree with you on every point! :-)

  • I think it's a BIG mistake to compare the two. Steve Perry is Steve Perry, and Arnel is Arnel. It was a phenomenal run for Steve in Journey, but health issues sidelined the singer, and you have to admit, to maintain the standard and level of singing he had to do night after night on tour would burn vocal chords out. If you listened to his last entry in Journey, Trial By Fire, you could tell his voice was worn out and so was he. He had to move on, it was time. Arnel is good in his own right.

  • @nickellmw ......is Arnel really "Arnel?" Forgive me here, but I've never heard Arnel when he wasn't bustin' his butt and strainin' his pipes to sound LIKE STEVE. In my opinion, Arnel is simply not original. He's a cover and a copycat. Oh, he's great! Don't get me wrong. But to me, he's just a kid who's tryin' to sound like the Original.

  • @nickellmw Sorry, got to disagree with you on the TBF critique, it's my fav! Most of the songs called for him to sing in a lower key, unlike so much of his earlier work. I think "It's Just The Rain" was about as high as he got. And, I figure, "When I Think of You" was tough for him to sing because it's about his mom and we all know how much he misses his mom! He and his voice may have matured, but he's still great! Love that man!!!!!!

  • Arnel is not even close!!

  • they need him back!!!

  • No comparison. Steve Perry gives me chills when I hear his voice. Arnel gives me nothing. Steve Perry is the best. Journey is not Journey without him. The emotional depth and range Steve's voice has can never be imitated.

  • Close, but Steve has a crisper voice.

  • The sharpness of Steve is amazing... Steve is exceptional and I can tell without looking whose who.

    Sorry Arnel....but no comparison.

  • Here's a side by side comparison for you: Steve Perry is a Ferrari and Arnel Pineda is a Ford Pinto. Their names shouldn't even be used in the same sentence.

  • Why would they redo the Steve Perry songs. Let Arnel Pineda make his own if they think he is so good. Arnel is ok, Steve was and always will be "the Voice" in my opinion. I was trying to find some of the real Journey and keep finding the old songs redone by Pineda.

  • "The Voice Reincarnated"??? Ouch.... good video, but bad title. Arnel is good, but Perry can't be "reincarnated." Just sayin...

  • Ill take Steve, because Arnel just cant compete with the soul and power within Steve Perry. Steve can never be replaced in our hearts. I just wish he'd come back it would blow Journey's newest albums with Pineda out of the water. I agree Arnel still doesn't have the clarity, power, and control that Steve did and I doubt he ever will.

  • Arnel does not compare to Steve Perry..I can tell who is singing what and when...Steve Perry's voice is soooo powerful absolutely no comparision..I don't know how anyone can not tell the difference ....Truly the very young generation who has never heard Steve Perry sing thinks Arnel is as great..

  • how the fuck do u compare arnel and steve together? it doesnt make any sense..... steve perry rules and a legend. never compare newbies to legends, it doesnt work like that.

  • ill say this, this past summer i got to hear arnel sing, concert kicked much ass, Arnel sounds ever more amazing in concert, i was very impressed and was so damn glad i go to see Journey in concert. but Atlas i would of rather heard Steve, No voice like that ever. Yes Arnel is good but hes no Steve, and yes id go back again if Journey comes back through with Arnel~

  • @95yj ARNEL SUCKS

  • F!LiPiN0 PRIDE!

  • u guys are so stuck in the past then if u cant say if there was 1 single voice to take journey back to the top and that voice COULDNT BE SP.....then arnel takes it everytime...lets be fair u single track ppl lol its new years get over it :P

  • @AmidoS2011 When you have had the best .Why would you settle for a imitation?

  • Arnel is FINE and I admire how much both his voice and "showmanship" as a front man have improved since he joined Journey. But NO ONE can match what Steve Perry did and I can still tell the difference. Arnel still doesn't have the clarity, power, and control that Steve did. I wish them ALL well, but for me: no Perry=no Journey.

  • steve perry sound like a woman arnel sounds great

  • @escariolahug = PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint momo cabron

  • @escariolahug homo cock

  • @NoSteveNoPoint momo sound like a woman voice is been dead long time ago irene bean momo

  • @escariolahug POOR POOR MONGOLOID ERNIE

  • Little Mother Fucker can sing......

  • @savarulz = TONE DEAF

  • Below= ernie the PEDO

  • We just saw Journey last night in The Woodlands TX (they call it Houston, whateverrrr). The little dude Arnel was so audience friendly. You can tell he just loves his Journey "job". It was inspiring!!!!! And he was awesome.....

  • @settojet You must be TONE DEAF!

  • Arnel= COAT TAIL RIDER

  • NO!

  • Everyone knows Arnel is no Stev Perry, but the show muct go on - Steve Perry was so much better - but he is no longer with Journey so they have the next best thing!!

  • Butter verses "I Can't Believe It's Not Butter". Journey...please allow him to be who he is and was, and look for new songs. You're such a great band, but you need to find another way to highlight Pineda. Only the young or foreigners can't or don't hear the difference.

  • @janosek1957 Yeah Arnel SUCKS with Journey

  • @NoSteveNoPoint jealous u cannot step New Journey because we don't need cry baby like you too much drama in your LIFE that's why u have POPO in ur head. BUY ECLIPSE ALBUM IT REALLY ROCK NOT LIKE U MOMO u still have ur LP record or cassette running around that's obsolete everything is now CD or mp3 tell me WHO'S SUCK'S RIGHT NOW IS YOU IRENE BEAN

  • @escariolahug I'm not IRENE BEAN you dumb APE! Get an IP checker.. OH THAT's RIGHT, You're too DUMB to figure that out! LMFAO!

  • @NoSteveNoPoint we know who you are STFU momo fagget voice sound like a woman 

  • @NoSteveNoPoint tell me who you are I will shut up u need to peace urself like a woman

  • @NoSteveNoPoint love steve POPP or steve augeri RACIST momo

  • @escariolahug = PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint  steve old arnel rocks now listen

  • @escariolahug = PEDO

  • and Arnel is pitchy I'm gonna pull up auto tune and show you guys How on pitch Steve Perry is compared to Arnel it is sooo sad the difference.

  • No power for the kid, maybe a few more years, Steve is a Gifted genious.

  • both are gifted w/ 24k vox but i like arnel's quality of voice...it's thicker and fuller..more powerful, crispier, huskier and rockier....and fresher as compared to sp's finer, sorta girly sound, imho!..... i came to appreciate the beauty and rockin' sound of journey w/ arnel's renditions now...journey rocks and croons better now w/ arnel

  • @DonEnyo  SAME IP MORON

  • Arnel has the better voice, only racists disagree, and i am white

  • @MustangTerry you are also TONE DEAF

  • This is terrible, terrible, terrible. How can you even TRY to compare the two voices?

    Arnel is OK as a singer, but just OK! Steve Perry is the MASTER and THE VOICE! You cannot compare Steve Perry with anyone on this earth as far as I'm concerned!!!

  • @MsLacey709 of course its hard to compare because each of us is unique. But its not right to hate Arnel hes just doin his job show the talents that God has given to him

    

  • @ETerNity906 Where do you see the word "hate"? It's NEBs like you that cause problems. Don't put words in my mouth! And, why do you even bother to post a comment to something that was said seven months ago? Are you cruising YT to start trouble?

    It was, and still is, my opinion that there is no comparison to SP's voice. It is utterly unique. Arnel can sing whatever & whenever, but he'll never be a Steve Perry!

    I meant is as a simple a statement of fact, not a challenge to a duel!

  • hey asshole!!!! are you DEAF???? ARNEL IS BETTER THAN STEVE PERRY!!!

  • @jaitals88 I had the "A*******" surgically removed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol

    You're preaching to the wrong choir!

  • bad comparison. arnel pineda is live while steve perrys was a music video

  • @animemaster156 Arnel SUCKS either way! LMAO

  • @DelutedPerryfan198O ASHHOLES!!!

    

  • I stand by you...I'm forever yours....faithfully Steve 

  • Pineda doesn't have a chance...this song (music video) has the BEST of Steve Perry in it! The man is an angel!

  • Arnel wins. rock fan!

  • @NoJboysAPN0Journey NO MONEY

  • @DelutedPerryfan198O HA he has NO BRAIN either!! LMAO

  • WOW thanks for this.. steve wins.. But man they can both sing...

  • Steve Perry is my favorite. always will be. on that note. it could be a lot worse, they could have a singer that sounds nothing like Steve. its happened with other bands. bottom line - this would be the best case senerio for replacing a lead singer. "old journey" is my favorite, but i would rather see journey live than no journey. lets look at the fact that they recognize Steve perry for what he did for the band. they realize it more that you. Steve perry still my favorite. don't rip my head off

  • this greasehead sucks,steve perry is the only real voice of journey

  • below= PEDO

  • steve sounds so vagina. Arnel voice is so much better and solid than steve.

  • Comment removed

  • Not saying this guy can't sing but the voice reincarnated PLEASE. Noone can ever replace the Voice.

  • what ever psycho NoSteve said his a loser since 2007 he had no job to look on

    just sitting writing in you tube bs comments moron grow up want your job back sing with ME na naaaanaaa naaaaaaa I stop believin' myself na nananaaaaaaa

  • nostevenojourney first put your picture on your channel and then be courageous enough to still go on namecalling. pls stay away from Journey-vids with Pineda singing! thank you

  • nosteve you been replaced by STEVE AUGERI sorry moron don't be hater STFU keep crying wahhh want some milk?

  • ARNEL THE BEST VOCALIST NOSTEVE  STFU MORON NO CHANCE STEVE PERRY YOURSELF HUG YOUR ALBUM THAT'S WHAT YOU GOT

  • @escariolahug you must not be a true rock and roll fan...

  • @StevePerrytheAngelic HE IS ERNIEBAL12,, THE MORON WITH ALL THE PARROT ACCOUNTS LIKE TATTINA15,ETC A TRUE MONGOLOID

  • @DelutedPerryfan198O greg barness coward bastard love journey

  • @escariolahug  ernie suck greg barness!!! JA JA JA

  • @DelutedPerryfan198O wa waa wa moron still here your next  nosteve

  • @escariolahug STICK WITH ONE PARROT MORON

  • wow they almost sing alike but still steve perry is best arnel sing great dont misunderstood me

  • nosteve is steve perry himself self proclaim mongoloid idiot moron low class reject from journey cry baby want his job back no chance idiot

  • sorry to all the Arnel supporters. he might have a good karaoke voice, but he will never be close to Steve Perry.. Perry was the voice of Journey.. always will be..

  • @onsenman2008

    Good?!?! That's a fucking great karaoke voice.

  • Arnel has better sound than the old one.

  • @NoSteveNoJourney 'Where are the HITS" LMAOoooooooooooooooooooo

  • @NoSteveNoJourney thats hilarious good one LoL

    AP has absoluelty no hits with Journey and never will

    he simply butchers Perrys songs and Journey's classics

    If this guy was any good he would do his own songs

    But that was hilarious LMAOOoOOOOOOO

  • @InfinityNebula Arnel should stop singing this shitty faggot song. It's not good for him. Perry is just another boy george.

  • @NoSteveNoJourney so it's for you am i right? a fan who hates someone at the top. . . so jealous with an asian guy. . .

    crab mentality. . .

  • @NoSteveNoJourney filipinos are negroids not mongoloids you moron. did you even study preschool?

  • @NoSteveNoJourney monkey is wiser than pig!lols!

    fyi...journey hired steve, journey is already existing b4 they decided to hire steve..and steve made journey famous..with his voice..yes, we give him that credit..now that steve left, give the other members their rights to go on with their journey,this time with arnel.IT IS STEVEs DECISION TO LEAVE THE BAND ANYWAY! HE IS GOIN SOLO, SO WHY NOT SUPPORT HIM?AND LEAVE JOURNEY ALONE?

  • @NoSteveNoJourney

    NO ARNEL NO JOURNEY!

  • @NoSteveNoJourney omae bakero kai?temeee!shine!kudaranai koto bakari..kuneroo!

  • @NoSteveNoJourney and you are pathetic jobless sitting on your computer 24/7 hitting on people coz you are insecure...go on get a life or kill yourself...whatever!nobody cares!

  • thank god i could hear journeys song once more, n watch them live!they really amaze me..awesone band!

  • @NoSteveNoJourney Arnel has the best sound. No faggot sound and Arnel owns the song.

  • Steve Perry my idol sucks look like moron just like NoSteve=NoMoreJourney don't listen mental psycho idiot

  • wow, heaven sent Arnel!! Amazing, Journey rocks!!!

  • baluga?

  • @NoSteveNoJourney ikaw gago!!!

  • @NoSteveNoJourney NoSteveNoJourney @jeangrey65 #

    jeangrey65 @NoSteveNoJourney NoSteveNoJourney @jeangrey65 jeangrey65 @NoSteveNoJourney NoSteveNoJourney @jeangrey65 jeangrey65 @NoSteveNoJourney NoSteveNoJourney @quathar SEEK HELP MONGOLOID!

  • @NoSteveNoJourney NoSteveNoJourney @jeangrey65 jeangrey65 @NoSteveNoJourney NoSteveNoJourney @jeangrey65 jeangrey65 @NoSteveNoJourney NoSteveNoJourney @quathar SEEK HELP MONGOLOID!

  • @NoSteveNoJourney NoSteveNoJourney @quathar SEEK HELP MONGOLOID!

  • @NoSteveNoJourney Boooring. You are the weakest link. Goodbye.

  • @NoSteveNoJourney Broken record? Senility kicking in already? Homophobia? Perhaps you can't face your own desires of wanting to suck on Steves knob for an hour or so?

  • The guitarist for arnel's old band has such bad taste he shouldn't be allowed to play journey

  • @NoSteveNoJourney Wow, wordplay. You got me. Now come here, I need some tool to scratch myself in the ass with. Then you can go back to sitting around, asking your kids about how to use the computer, and generally just being old and stuff.

  • Arnel is 10000000 millions times better than the hom voice nostevenojourney

  • @NoSteveNoJourney You know that writing in caps only makes you seem like a complete tool?

  • @NoSteveNoJourney 40 is OLD you pathetic excuse for a human being. Yeah, I need help to understand how a 40-year-old person has so little in their life that they can manage time to spew garbage on an internet site about a bands choices, i.e. the band that make the music they supposedly are a fan of.

  • @NoSteveNoJourney I really hope you are not an old fan. It would be sad to see someone as old this much of a stupid douchebag. You really have nothing better to do? What a sad, sad, life.

  • @NoSteveNoJourney Seriously, that's your comeback? Are you really that stupid?

  • @NoSteveNoJourney Yes you are a mongoloid without a life. Thanks for telling us.

  • Arnel is to steve as Tommy is to Brad... As close as your gonna get

  • \m/ \m/ \m/

  • Please stop it - NoSteveNo Journey.

  • c'mon, yes perry is the original, but it gives me joy to listen to journey's songs once again, thanks to this guy,arnel

  • Perry had surgery on his throat, he isn't coming back..I do fall into the 30-50 age group and grew up listening to Perry..fell in love for the 1st time to Open Arms, my sister got married to Faithfully..Arnel is awsome. And since there is no chance of Perry coming back, for personal and medical reasons, Let Jouney have their comeback with this amazing singer

  • @angied22269 when? i just know that he had hip surgery, where did you read that?

  • @ArnelPinedaSucks gIVE IT UP sTEVE IS GREAT BUT HE NEEDS TO RETIRE .yUO ARE DRAGGING HI GOOD NAME INTO THIS.

  • @NoSteveNoJourney = You need to stick to watching SP vids and leave all AP vids for his own fans to appreciate. You probably fall in the 30 to 50 age group and to insult the new Journey singer on all his Youtube videos is just so immature. You've got no class at all!

  • I think Arnel is a great singer for Journey. He'll never beat Steve Perry.  Arnel is better then the other singers they have tried. And since Perry doesn't plan on coming back, Arnel owns it.

  • Pinoy=Eurasian

    Get it right ya stupid American

  • Yes we are Mongoloid, You have Down Syndrome

  • De-Generate Caucasoid

    CANADA FTW!!!

  • NoSteveNoJourney= Pedophilic, Balding, Syphillic, Microphallic, Corpulent, Racist American Fuck

  • Steve=has been!

  • oh guys you just envy. no matter how you tried your voice couldn't even get close to steve perry, only arnel pineda.

  • WOW~~~~~@NoSteveNoJourney ur an ASSHOLE!!!!!!!!!..........u know what.......itz really hard 2 find someone who has da voice like steve~~sOooo dont call ARNEL a COPY CAT..,,itz GOD who give us our own skill~....,,,,,

  • Arnel = KARAOKE!!

  • Steve = Legend!!

  • @Gregsynth Yup! And Pinoy = MORON!! LOL

  • LMFAO!

    I love how idiots say Steve couldn't do anything outside of Journey! LOL! Ever heard of Street Talk (2.5 million)? LOL

  • @Gregsynth LOL! These idiots don't know anything about Steve Perry! They never even knew a word to any of the songs before Arnel!

  • That's true!

  • People like you are why abortion should be retroactive

  • NoSteveNoJourney= GAY!!,., HAHAHA!!!,.,

  • no steve no journey eat ur own dick and swallow ur ballsssssssssss.bwahahahaha...­...