Hurt

[ReidGirl1307]

Oh, this is lovely. I remember spending the latter part of my Jr. High years loving on this video before I fell out of the SW fandom; I'm so glad to see it again. This and your "Love Song Requiem" video were incredibly inspiring for some of my very first fanfics.

Anyway, I always, *always* tear up at the line "To look into your eyes/and see you lookin' back," because it's just so, *so* perfectly synched.

[TrekkieGirl12]

Wow... this video is pure magic. Sums up all of the times and trials between Obi-Wan and Anakin perfectly.

[KenobiSkywalkerFan]

I was trying very hard not to cry, it was that brilliantly done. Obi-Wan and Anakin are my favourite characters throughout the entire prequel. Five stars, no make that 100 stars.

[Selene467]

Wow this is one beautiful video. The song is indeed perfect for those two and giving both their own point of view in the vid and song was brilliantly done and the turnig back time thing also nice. I did not detect any gay vibes during the song, I think it all worked out perfectly. 5 stars!

[StopThisMadness]

One of the best Star Wars videos ever. :) Thanks for making it.

[JemsMovies]

wow, ok seriously this video is probably the best I've seen of obi wan and anakin's relationship...just really good work, and I hope to see more of your videos

[MasterTorn]

at 0:30 with Ben Kenobi leaning back, is that an effect or a transition? Could you tell me wich one it is, cause i can't seem to find it anywhere, and i would gladly use it in one of my vids...

[SmokeyFiizz]

@MasterTorn It's just effects. It's effects in Sony Vegas, you need to tracks with the same clip layered on top of each other. The bottom clip needs to the one that has light rays, or whatever you want on it, and you need to make the light rays move from right to left. You add a marker for that, I hope you know how to do that. On the top track you add a cookie cutter, and bring the transparency to appear in so it looks like it takes it away. Hope that makes sense.

[MasterTorn]

@SmokeyFiizz wow thx for the advice smokey, i'll try it out some time, but by the looks of it this isn't all that hard :D. btw I ADORE your vids!!

[lilyconnor]

Cool.

[Alice1155]

I wanna cry now!

[tierneybeckett]

This was amazing. I loved every minute of it.  Just absolutely outstanding.

[JaneRox22]

You did a wonderful job with editing! This video is great.

[inkenyo]

Fantastic video! I mean really, really great!

[TheGirlofLewis]

best anakin vid ever!! i love him hihi hayden is so handsome!

[cyhannah]

That was an excellent video. I'm glad someone finally captured both sides of this. The Obi Wan view, then the Anakin/Darth view. Totally rocks! On my faves!

[Madison32707]

wow that was so awesome!!!!!!!!!!!

[teenwitchlovergirl]

You know that part when Obi-Wan first meets Anakin. I cried!

[TheGirlofLewis]

best obi wan and anakin vid i have ever seen!!

[BatGirl229]

i have seen this video 5 times and i cry everytime!! good job!!

[Maaarcia27]

wow amazing vid:-)

[JasonsWolf]

OMG! that was the best! it really captured their relationship perfectly! fantastic job!

[phoenix113]

This is so sad. Really evoked the emotion! Once again, great job!

[fallenvidder]

This is incredible. It's so sad for Obi-Wan. And we can see the emotion in this video. Amazing!

[andielee87]

oh my goodness you are awesome, and not in the loose sense of the word that most people use. thank you please if you wish to make more , do so

[addiction911]

you and gone vidder are the truely best starwars makers!

[havok8811]

this is an amazing video! kudos

[JediElderNishmo]

Brilliant... just... brilliant. Excellent editing, excellent video... you are truely a master. Very good job, my friend.

[gr13v0u5]

don't mind about "hold you in my arms" thing, man ; two guys who hug eachother are not necessarily gay... are they ? :P

[grublet13]

This made me cry. Star Wars in general makes me cry. But this jus added to my feelings. I love it. I love the editing and the voice overs. How they are unclear and distant almost. This song does really fit them both. I really do love this. Favorite. 100/5.

[ChibiAriane]

it's the best obi/ani vid in the world, i think. i really love it. i cried.

[gr13v0u5]

I know it sounds weird, but I nearly cried watching this vid :'( great job, Smokeyfizz !

[PineH93]

wow :) this video is fantastic ... i very like the star wars episodes and you videos ;) very good job

[shelly872]

Your star wars videos are awesome. I especially like this one, its so touching...what a tear jerker! Your effects are stunning, you truly are a master!

[hobobagins09]

Man I'll tell you what I watched some of your other videos and I didn't really like them but I had to watch this one when I saw it was about Obi-Wan and Anikan. Nothing can make me cry except for star wars. Right there I almost burst out into tears....

I don't know weather I hate the movie or love it.

[nas02s]

OMG, that was really good. (wipes eyes)

[roxigyrl4]

amazing. beautiful. you people are amazing with your star wars vids. i seriously welled up with tears on this on

[Ronja06]

Oh wow... amazing. So beautiful and emotional. :'( You guys are truly gifted. I've watched all your SW vids now and they are all fantastic!!!

[roxigyrl4]

that was the most amazing thing ivr seen in a very long time!

[AN9wa9]

fucking good and touching video :')

[mergirl1]

I absolutely adored your dividing the songs into their two points of view, as well as the sequence you used towards the end to the "try and turn back time" part. Wonderful and extremely heart-felt. ^_^

[Smokeyfizz]

mergirl1 - Thanks alot, for commenting on our videos. We really like this video too and are pleased that you liked it as well. The song just seemed to work so well for the both of them, and we always say their friendship that way.

[verdict88]

Great job =)

what video editor do u use??

[Smokeyfizz]

... Sony Vegas. It says at the beginning.

[GalenMarak]

@Smokeyfizz whoah that was good!! favorite!! 5 Stars! or in this case i will like the video!!

[morrigane13]

The song is perfect! I always felt it was more a son/daughter to parent song, not a lover to ex-lover song. Great job!

[princessleia101]

ok I know this is like my 3rd comment here but now I have a request! You should do an Anakin video with the song Fallen by Sarah MaLachlan! That would be great!

[lauphenstaar]

Whoa... that was amazing... It really brought a tear to my eye! I thought you guys did a wonderful job portraying the friendship they had. Definately one of my favorites!

[starwarschick16]

Wow. This is just too amazing...I have to comment...AGAIN!!! lol. I just love how it points out how if Obi-Wan had been fully aware of Padme & Anakin's relationship...he would've been more than willing to help...and how Vader truly misses Obi-Wan. They had such a good relationship...even if it's not entirely exaggerated in the movies. Hmm. Beautiful video...the ending is beautiful. =)

[risingtrooper]

this is really good the song and the vid.they go hand in hand and i like how ur showing the flashbacks in it.

[Anakkin]

muy buen videoooo

ojala pudieras mandarme este video..

[aznman2000]

0.43 sec says it all..excellent job

[againtotal123]

I'm about to cry!!

[Jamo28hhh]

Wow!  Just...WOW!!

[princessleia101]

its been weeks since I first saw it and I'm still addicted. I think I posted once alredy but I had to post again. This is the best star wars vid I have seen. Every time I see it I feel like crying!

[starwars68]

why is it that only your star wars videos make me cry? this one is going straight to my favorites.

[Anakkin]

es el mejor video que he visto!

felicidades ^^

[RustyRyan5]

I love this song, only this from Aguilera....cool idea.Great job!

[4evernaday]

I love thee voices in the background! And the clips? You are a mastermind! So heart-wrenching! I am in awe! I love the transitions between clips! How long does it take you to make these?

[princessleia101]

wow! great job!the song matches them so well its so sad!

[Anakkin]

muy buen videooo me da penaa tristeza!

lo mejor que han hecho

felicidades!

[HARKNESSGIRL]

I have just wached this vid on my favorites again and i just had to leave another comment truly a great vid the best star wars vid i have seen 10/10.

[addiction911]

i can't stop watching it i have commented like 5 times...i love it!:)

[artdeco188]

This is amazing video!!! I love Star Wars I love Hayden Christensen and I love Christina Aguilera!!!! Good job!!!! 5

[Taramire]

This was an amazing video. The relationship between Anikan and Obi-Wan is pivital (sp?) to the whole story of Star Wars. Their relationship is full of both love and sorrow, you portrayed that well.

[HARKNESSGIRL]

oh that was so great made me cry well done.

[cody137]

WOOOOW, that was like perfect. the song went perfectly with the clips, the audio from the movie really added to the vid...ahhh sooo good. this is far by one of the best vids I've seen. this is one of my favs from you. 5/5 and to favs!

[shadowfax53]

wow this video is so good. in fact it's so good no matter how i try i can't stop myself from crying when i watch it. i love it! good job:)

[addiction911]

this is amazing!!! the best starwars video ! i can watch it over and over crying each time

i want you to make another one!! please! made all my friends cry to!

p.s check out my vids

[Smokeyfizz]

We have made plenty. Check out our channel, you will see the playlist of all the star wars videos we have made

-Gina & Diana.

[hazeleyes144]

I don't think I've commented on this vid yet and I love it! I love this song and the vid is beautiful. The song fits very well and the effects are perfectly placed. :)

[Briee1]

This vid was beautiful. And I love that you used the old and new stars clips for it, really gave it a complete sense. Also, sidenote here, thanks for the notes to the side explaining your vids, they always help! Fave parts: "If only I knew what I know today" the flash of the older Obi-Wan with the shots of Vader and Padme dead, so sad. "Broke inside" with the shot of Vader, "For everything I just couldn't do" with all the shots of all the things he couldn't stop or control, loved that.

[Smokeyfizz]

Briee1 - Thanks alot. We always thought this song would be perfect for them. We love all the comments you leave, they are always worth reading and then some.

-Gina & Diana

[hekategirl]

That was incredibly awesome! it has me on the verge of tears every time I watch it. Just one thing to critique though; the talking parts over the video were a little hard to understand..it kind of sounded like they were talking underwater...

I loved it though :)

[Smokeyfizz]

Thanks, glad you liked it. We added an echo effect to the audio. Thats probably why it was hard to understand. Thanks!

[lenkenobi]

That was so good!!! It was perfect interpetation of Anakin and Obi-Wan's relationship.

[cazzykay23]

I LOVE THIS VIDOE TI ROCK

[pacsi07]

Just another video that has left me on the verge of crying... One more video like this and I'll go suicidal.

Just kidding ;)

[jedijess210]

wow!! That was really exellent!!!

[chrisxjill]

i swear this video made me cry it is an awesome video it really does fit with the story and it is like they would say this at the end after everything that happened awesome!!!

R.I.P. Anakin and obi-wan probally the second best jedis there ever will be

[CLJ465]

geeze awsome agen i had to commet

[CLJ465]

that video is on my facorites :) i whant to see more!!!!!! awsome video

[Cariz94]

i LOVED the "I hate you!" "You were my brother Anakin, I loved you!" n vaders close up. :'( a tearjerker

[LukeSkywalkerInMe]

If I could find words to tell you how much I'm moved by this vid, I would. Thanks for making it. Thanks, thanks...

[Smokeyfizz]

LukeSkywalkerInMe - Thank you very much & no problem making vids is what we live for ;)

[KelleyH]

Yeah. That was really really sad....sorry, i'm like commenting every videos of yours. lol. but they're soo good!!

[Unicorn100]

Are you trying to depress me? Good video.

But the lyrics "Hold you in my arms" were kind of strange.

[xXWilleWaloXx]

AMAZING! i almost started crying !!! love it

[anya14]

Heartbreaking! But beautiful nonetheless.

Love your effects, esp. 1:18, 2:02, 2:32.

[wittyweasley]

that was amazing! this is only a suggestion but I think that the song One Thousand Apologies by Demon Hunter would be a perfect song for a Star Wars vid. though, again its only a suggestion. But anyway, very nice vid. ur vids are just wow, there great!

[Smokeyfizz]

wittyweasley - Thank you very much for the suggestion we wil take a listen to the song and see if it interests us in anyway. Glad you enjoy our videos hun! It means alot thanks for commenting :)

[domenico83]

wow your videos are perfect

[anya14]

Oh, that broke my heart!

Thanks for this video, it's pure beauty.

[FarAwayPolaris]

Hands down, my favorite music video on youtube, no contest. I watch this practically every day, lol! It's just THAT great, and never fails to make me tear up as well!

[Smokeyfizz]

FarAwayPolaris - Wow that really means alot. Happy you enjoyed it so much! Thanks alot hun

[Shegorulez76]

That was really good!,I was balling my eyes out!

[Micaburn]

That is so good and so sad

[Smokeyfizz]

Micaburn - thanks alot we are glad you like it :)

[xMelissaLadyVaderx]

this was soooo sad!!! i freaking cried!

[NEZiANHUNNiE]

absolutely beautiful!

[AlleySkywalker]

Oh, I've gotta ask since I love the edeting on this, what editor do you use?

[Smokeyfizz]

AlleySkywalker - we use sony vegas 6.0

[cherybery22]

this video is sooo sad! the song really does fit with anakin and obiwan. you did an awesome job.

[Smokeyfizz]

Cherybery22 - Thank you very much that is really sweet of you! We are glad you enjoyed it.

[AlleySkywalker]

Awesome! Geat song choice!

[AllanaSolo]

That was just too awesome!!

[akaryskywalker]

wow esta genial me gusto mucho y la edicion esta genial tambien

[wushogun3]

Absolutely Amazing 5 stars =)

[artesmeunome]

very beautiful!!!

[florencia87hc]

is for things like this that i'm a bigger fan of u and ur vids each day. i love this vid like the others u've made. Keep then coming, u have great talent girl!

[Smokeyfizz]

florencia87hc-Hey thanks alot We are glad that you liked them. Me and my sister actually vid together so it's not just one of us. Thanks again.

[laurenmcquilty]

i loved this video and i thought you did a really good job, i had an idea for another idea you could do if you want. The sing "You sexy thing" by Hot Chocolate and the clips are from Star Wars Espiode 2 and others like for example-the love pledge and arena scenes matching the clips to the word, i tried it on my tv and stereo, sounded good, let me know what u think of the idea

[Smokeyfizz]

laurenmcquilty-Hey thanks glad you liked the video would you please e-mail us the request/idea so we can keep track of it it would be alot easier.

[Gabitroncangry]

hey.. 1 question... You doo all these effects on Windows Movie Maker.. Right?

[Smokeyfizz]

Gabitroncangry- Hey no we got a new program for video editing called "sony vegas".

[Gabitroncangry]

really?  Sweet!

[anakinlover3hotmail]

That made me cry!!!I love Anakin!! WOW I really love your vids. Keep up the great work!!! 5/5 stars and put on my favs.

[Smokeyfizz]

anakinlover3hotmail- Thank you.Sorry about making you cry that wasn't our intention tehe. Thank you we are glad you enjoy our videos! :)

[starwarsgirlygirl]

when it was 43 sec, and obi wan is in the middle with two clips are next to him

how do you do that?

ps love the video :)

[Smokeyfizz]

Starwarsgirlygirl-Hey we use an effect called "cookie cutter" With sony vegas. Thanks glad you like it!

[MELISSAJENNIFER]

lol thanks im always straight forward...i guess thats why im such a bitch most of the time..haha

[Smokeyfizz]

You don't really seem to be a bitch. We like to be straight forward too.

[broadwaybound1029]

Great video, I've always invisioned Anakin and Obi-Wan's relationship to be very brotherly, so i didn't see anything wrong with the hold me in your arms part. Great editing as well. I loved the ending

[Smokeyfizz]

broadwaybound1029- Hey us to but on a previouse video when we had used that clip someone said it made them look gay and that it sucked. So we thought we would say that it wasn't our intention to make it look that way. Thanks alot glad you liked the vid.=D

[HighElrond]

Very nice vid. But I don't really like Christina Aguilera.

[Smokeyfizz]

HighELrond- THANKS :D we arn't much of her fans either but we fell in love with this song of hers.

[Apinklady]

I love this vid... i never thought of this song working for them two... i know what u mean about the gay bit.. maybe if that clip 'hold u im my arms' was a bit longer...Just a suggestion. I LOVED how u used the memory bit and the audio it all fitted so well, i almost cried..Oh i just love anakin so much!

[Smokeyfizz]

Apinklady- Hey thanks alot. We would have kept it in a bit longer but decided to take it off when she stopped singing the "hold you in my arms" bit. We are real glad you liked it with the audio clips. There was alot of audio we wanted to use but just cut it down to these few. We love anakin to ;) Thank you.

[petitevanou]

5 stars, amazing, and so sad .

[JangosAgony502]

I've seen your anxiety video but WOW!!! This must be the best I've seen yet!

[Smokeyfizz]

JangosAgony502-Hey anxiety is our fav vid! So glad you liked that one as well. Thanks alot we put alot of effort into this one.

[maluhan]

I think it was really really good! It touched my soul more than any other video i`ve seen before. It`s perfect! ;-)

[Smokeyfizz]

muluhan- Awee that's great that it touched your soul;) Hehe we are really proud thanks alot!

[laurenmcquilty]

This was so beautiful and i loved how you did the clip, got me teary eyed and i loved the colour/transition effort-how did u do it? i must have been hard work, good work!

[Smokeyfizz]

laurenmcquilty- Hey thanks alot! The colour effect was done with sony vegas Cookie cutter and light rays :) It was pretty hard actually, but it always pays off when we know that you guys all enjoy the video!. thanks alot hun.

[revengeofthesith8825]

Awesome video! The effects were great! I liked how you used the originals and prequels too!

[Smokeyfizz]

Revengeofthesith8825; thanks alot. It's supposed to be about them remembering it as Ben and Vader and regretting it.

[Zephyra]

For the last few months, I've fallen out of Star Wars and things that would have me sobbing and cursing Anakin at one point just made me shake my head and think what a duffer I was... but this... o. m. g. I broke down and SOBBED. Like lung wrenching sobs and snot and the whole water works. Wow... I can't even think coherently that was so hurtful. (no pun intended) I love the 'turn back time' part... just wow...

[Smokeyfizz]

Zephyra; you really know how to make us proud vidders. it's because of great comments like yours that we look forward to see what people have to say. I guess that is a good thing that we were able to make you cry again :) That must mean we put the video together just right; but not wanting to make anyone cry but to see the depth of it. For the turnback time we wanted to show that they both wanted just to be able to do it all over again. Thanks alot!

[lotusflower202020]

Beautiful. Howd you guys get so damn good at editing?

[Smokeyfizz]

Lol thank you! Well with over 70 videos under our belt we kind of got the hang of it lol.

[MissJedi]

Great video! I loved the effects. I think the song was good for Anakin and Obi-wan (but not like THAT.) =D Great, once again.

[Smokeyfizz]

What do you mean not like that? :S Thanks though; we really like it too.

[christensenislove002]

& also, watching this video made me appreciate & understand their bond a little more.

it just kind of got to me.

you obviously put a lot of thought into these videos.

they do inspire, i can tell you that.

i can't even stress how much i love them.

=)

[Smokeyfizz]

Yeah we understand what you mean; after watching lots of Vids of these two we appreciated their relationship so much more and after reading the book... it really is heartbreaking. Thanks alot hun. That means alot. We love to see that so many people enjoy watching as we do making.

[christensenislove002]

wow.

simply amazing.

your style is just too incredible & unique.

keep up the amazing work.

=)

[Smokeyfizz]

christensenislove002- Thanks alot! we are happy you liked it and thanks we are glad you noticed our video editing style's unique. We try!

[amidala2915]

I've seen this three times and still can't make it through without crying. This is a great O/A film! If Alec Guinness saw this, he would have been very proud. I don't have to say how wonderful your effects are :D Thank you so much for posting! I love it, love it, love it!!! 10/10!!!

[Smokeyfizz]

amidala2915-Awe! Your so sweet, NO PROBLEM we post for you guys! so we are so happy you enjoyed it hun.

[FrogPrincezz]

I have to say that was pretty good, from this POV you did. And I love the rewind parts. Just like mine I already did with my hurt video. :) good job.

[Smokeyfizz]

It's nice to know you thought it was "pretty good". We thought it would make sence to reverse to where they first met. We have used reverse alot of different times. This is not the first. Like we said we have been planning this video for a long time but just didn't have the original trilogy to work with it. Thanks glad you liked it.

[FrogPrincezz]

oh I remember you said you already had this project going. I just love rewinding the clips. makes it look so awesome, with coolness about it! great job! :)

[SMSLAX77]

great video! the song and the clips go together really good...great work

[Smokeyfizz]

SMSLAXX77- Thanks alot bud!

[Lusesita7]

perfect!

[MELISSAJENNIFER]

SHIT...THIS WAS GOOD!

[Smokeyfizz]

MELISSAJENNIFER-Haha love how your so straight forward. Thanks alot! :D

[mcbird13]

Wow. Wow wow wow. Your editing just keeps getting better and better! I think this is my fave video of yours so far. The voice-overs ae perfectly placed and the effects are powerful and you can tell you guys really know what you're doing. Definitely 5/5!

[Smokeyfizz]

mcbird13-THANK YOU! We try;) that was really awesome feedback and we are so glad you enjoyed it because we make the video's for you guys to watch.

[FieryGeniusVids]

That was very beautiful and it fit Anakin/Vader & Obi-Wan perfectly! (And I didn't think the "hold you in my arms" made them sound gay at all; just sounded sorta brotherly to me.) Beautiful editing, and good voice-over choices! Amazing job!

[Smokeyfizz]

Thanks alot. We tried to use voice overs that are hardly ever used; and there isn't really another part where they hug lol. Thanks alot Casey. It means alot coming from you.

[blondychik1]

beautiful editing, perfect clips, great song :)

[Smokeyfizz]

blondychik1-Hey thanks alot. Glad you liked it!