Lamento decir, que al menos para mi, Nightwish apesta sin Tarja.
Escuche 30 segundos de la canción cantada por Anette y tuve que cerrar la pestaña y venir a escuchar esta versión para recordar que es una maravillosa canción; claro esta, trate de hacerlo justo y escuchar versiones en vivo, pero Tarja la supera por mucho.
Is she lip syncing, or is the video/audio just out of sync? I know she can sing amazing live, but can't tell if it's the video or her that's out of sync. :P
Auch wenn es Playback sein sollte, Tarja singt trotzdem mit, weil sie das forever und this z.B. komplett anders betont, als in dem Aufgenommenen Song ;)
Anette is too bubblegum and do not look the part - Tarja took it to far at times and compared to Simone from EPICA, her voice sounds forced and did not always fit the melody - The band made them both - still do
@MariusMulder Kinda dissagree on the Tarja comment. Its not really forced, mainly vocal style and a hint of accent changes the sound a bit. Vocals are not always intended to get lost or to only interweave with the melody. You have to remember that the voice is just as much an instrument as a guitar and they break from the melody on lead or in solos.
It is true; this isn't live. But this was on a TV show and most TV shows will not let you play live, so you have to use playback. If it makes you happier, you can tell that they ae not used to playback. ;P Tarja usually does more, and if you watch Emppu, sometimes he doesn't even pretend to play the notes at all, he just holds the guitar. ;D
@tinmanluver35 As far as I can see, there are no cables, no drum mics and Toumas' keyboard - on top of that - is turned off xD awesome. There's a great Iron Maiden video where they showed how to deal with playback by just messing it completly up. But you need the balls for that...
@tinmanluver35 If they were doing playback, then why was Tarja singing differently than in the album version of the song?? :P At least she was singing for real even if the guys were not playing at all.
Anette rocks - but compare her to Tarja. god - compare her to fucking Tarja. TARJA IS AWESOME! ANETTE IS AMAZING! But Tarja WINS forever. anette dosent and dosent try to sound like Tarja but they should not cover the old nighwish songs - also the old nightwish has more feeling and more emotion into their songs.
Im gonna get flamed but I love Tarja... Anette sucks the lyrics to nightwishes new songs with anette suck they have no meaning or feeling like it was when tarja was in the band. They are pop lyrics with a pop sound and anette is mediocre at best. It gets me when people say the bands not the singer are yall stupid...theres no band without a singer!
@TrueGoth1 ....shes terrible live?! are u fucking kidding me? Tarja is beautiful and amazing when she sings...keep your lame ass comments to yourself. and dont comment on night wish music....we dont need to hear it.
@lunar05 Obviously youre not classically trained, from a purists point of yiew she does sound bad,. But, when she was singing Phantom of the opera, live she sounds great. I am actually a Nightwish fan. I was simply making an observation on the evidence in front of me.
@TrueGoth1 The only problem is that if you have some sort of musical training you should know that music is not an objective subject. You can't "tell the truth" on this because there isn't such thing in regards to musical taste. And what sort of insults are those? What are you? 12 or something? Seriously, are you aiming for a Darwin award or something?
@evan003daysgrace Well, can I asked you sth ?? Have you ever watched End of an Era (the whole thing I mean). I 've watched both the whole on DVD and parts of it on youtube. What I understand is that Tarja expresses her deepest emotions when she sings. Pick a song of that LIVE that's sung by her .... Any song. All her energy and emotions are in there ... She is sad at Creek Mari's Blood, sweet and hopeful at Ghost Love Score and wild and energetic at Wishmaster. Tarja wasnt fired for that reason.
@evan003daysgrace You sayed she didn't feel music and that's wrong..... As for money I do not believe she thought it was more important. That's what Tuomas says. Tarja says that Nightwish have always been a priority in her life. Someone who would try to uncover the truth would have to admit that one of them is lying. So I guess we 'll never learn what really happened... But you cannot say she didn't feel music anymore. Music has been and alwaying will be coming from her heart ...
@guitar4936 c'est une fausse video, synchronisation, on peut laaaargement le voir quand elle chante "Nemo sailing hoooome". A la base c'est un bon vieux playback in-de-ce-lable xD, une émission allemande il me semble si je me souviens bien. Trop pas grillé -.-
What did you change the vid? We can hear it at several moments, I know it's a pb, but it doesn't seem natural xD
@impvr1 Bumping the old posts is not nice but I mean that, hm..that maybe the uploader put End of an Era's audio to this video? Because the audio is soooo similar. I'm not trying to be an ass, sorry if it seems like it.
There was a long time ongoing problem between Toumas, the Songwriter, and Tarja, and Tarja said the next album would be her last with nightwish. The rest of the band appearently did not see any sense in keeping her in the band, and so after the (later named) end of an era concert they asked her to leave the band in an open letter( I think it's still on the NW homepage, if you want to read it). That's the story as far as I know it.
They are so cute! :)
patriota117 3 days ago
Το those saying that it was only Tuommas that made Nightwish, imagine this song without Tarja....
No further comments! Their EGOs ruinned such a rare, great band!
Tarja is going well as a solo artist though :)
GO ON TARJA!
77elvistheking 1 week ago
6 pessoas são da familia da Anette!
kaipsydranzer 2 weeks ago
@kaipsydranzer como puderam tirar a tarja da banda, acabou com a banda pois a anette e uma bosta!
clepuka 4 days ago
Comment removed
bFablin 2 weeks ago
Hey folks, stop discussing like fucking idiots about Tarja & Anette and tell me what happened with the live sound here 2:07 - 2:20
felima999 3 weeks ago
@felima999 is true, i hear it too, sounds like the cd and then again live that was strange
joelwish2 1 week ago
TARJA !!!
bajuum 3 weeks ago
Perfeição!
helenroballo24 3 weeks ago
Meravigliosa Tarja sei unica !!!!!!!!!
TheSilvan80 3 weeks ago
Se ve Hermosa!!!
GothikaMetalera666 4 weeks ago
Lamento decir, que al menos para mi, Nightwish apesta sin Tarja.
Escuche 30 segundos de la canción cantada por Anette y tuve que cerrar la pestaña y venir a escuchar esta versión para recordar que es una maravillosa canción; claro esta, trate de hacerlo justo y escuchar versiones en vivo, pero Tarja la supera por mucho.
11CarGom11 1 month ago 2
@11CarGom11 Pues me paso casi lo mismo sin embargo Annete no lo hace nada pero igualmente no se compara con Tarja.
dacamapo 2 weeks ago
6 people love Anette ! Каждому свое)))))
Cherrykimo 1 month ago
Tarja Goddess!!!!!!!!!!!!!
FranciscaJoplin 1 month ago
AWESUUUUUUM
Varmek 1 month ago
Tarja is the best female singer forever
CaueMS 1 month ago
not live. =)
vinicius25pe 1 month ago 2
Is she lip syncing, or is the video/audio just out of sync? I know she can sing amazing live, but can't tell if it's the video or her that's out of sync. :P
KieranMac17 1 month ago
@KieranMac17 I think it's the video. They only put on the playback on a few moments, like in the guitar solo and in the farthest end.
amandikaloka 1 month ago
она шикарно поет! лучше ее голоса нету!!!
zaur953 1 month ago
OMG tarja is the
best!
ATSPrefeito 2 months ago 2
fuking play back!!!!
454cristhian 2 months ago
It's not playback, if you listen to how Tarja is singing it's absolutly not like the album version !
romain12021996 2 months ago
@romain12021996 and album version is just only one version of this song. I think they recorded live version of this song to shows like that.
MrKukavain 1 month ago
Die Audiospur wurde nachträglich eingefügt. Das ist auf keinen Fall original so gespielorden.
GothSeiDank 2 months ago
Música mt perfeita s2
TheTleao 2 months ago
Auch wenn es Playback sein sollte, Tarja singt trotzdem mit, weil sie das forever und this z.B. komplett anders betont, als in dem Aufgenommenen Song ;)
JilTarja1717 2 months ago
Viva shows are always playback
keenhauberk 2 months ago
@keenhauberk not always, the many bands are already playing live in this show
AlexInFlames666 2 months ago
its play back...at least drums.... 0:54 - 1:00 you can hear cymbals but Julius doesnt hit any cymbal...love nightwish btw...
FanOfUlrich 2 months ago
Comment removed
J4ks0nDk2 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@FanOfUlrich :I dont know much about drums but i can see him hit the lower. !!! not the upper as u thought. !!!
J4ks0nDk2 2 months ago
Los Chicos: Perfecto Tarja: Desentonadisimaaa D:
La verdad que bueno que sacaron a Tarja, ya ni parecian una buena banda unida :C
flowerzofblood 2 months ago
Grandiosa epoca la de Nightwish ! con la mejor vocalista, la diosa Tarja !
ANGIEDRUZILA000 2 months ago 11
Mega HD =))
VictorsFilmStudio 3 months ago
dislike playback
MrApocallypse 3 months ago
it seems unnatural to see tuomas with only one keyboard - even if he isn't playing it...
oneover2many 3 months ago
Tarja brings heavy metal and classical music feeling/ What does bring Anette?
Killensuen 3 months ago
LOVE YOU TARJA!ª
EvadneBaal 3 months ago
Tarja the best!
DarkCamelotTheBest 3 months ago 2
SPYTHRILLER - Nemo HD [Nightwish Cover]
MariusMulder 3 months ago
Anette is too bubblegum and do not look the part - Tarja took it to far at times and compared to Simone from EPICA, her voice sounds forced and did not always fit the melody - The band made them both - still do
MariusMulder 3 months ago
@MariusMulder Kinda dissagree on the Tarja comment. Its not really forced, mainly vocal style and a hint of accent changes the sound a bit. Vocals are not always intended to get lost or to only interweave with the melody. You have to remember that the voice is just as much an instrument as a guitar and they break from the melody on lead or in solos.
assassnim 3 months ago
Pause at 1:07 *Droools!
Maggot2607 3 months ago
Comment removed
Maggot2607 3 months ago
Yes this is real Nightwish!!
Erja121 3 months ago
The most beautiful woman of the Metal.... I love her .....;)
natanclassic 3 months ago
playback. this sucks. she is singing, but with help of a recording. and i don't think they're playing anything.
Guilhermetmfranco 3 months ago
@Guilhermetmfranco
It is true; this isn't live. But this was on a TV show and most TV shows will not let you play live, so you have to use playback. If it makes you happier, you can tell that they ae not used to playback. ;P Tarja usually does more, and if you watch Emppu, sometimes he doesn't even pretend to play the notes at all, he just holds the guitar. ;D
tinmanluver35 3 months ago
@tinmanluver35 As far as I can see, there are no cables, no drum mics and Toumas' keyboard - on top of that - is turned off xD awesome. There's a great Iron Maiden video where they showed how to deal with playback by just messing it completly up. But you need the balls for that...
Leodooom 3 months ago
@tinmanluver35 If they were doing playback, then why was Tarja singing differently than in the album version of the song?? :P At least she was singing for real even if the guys were not playing at all.
Morgaine32 3 months ago
Anette and her mom found this video after all...
Porte87 3 months ago
I love this band :))
TheFoufoutos7 3 months ago
i love nightwish... but it's Playback!
leogalliano1 4 months ago
@leogalliano1 are you sure??? listen again
zjacobss 4 months ago
@leogalliano1 I'm not so sure... May be tarja's voice is strange, but tuomas, marco, jukka and emppu sound original for me...
lauv13 4 months ago
@lauv13 Bands always do playback on Tv sows
mantovan234 4 months ago
@leogalliano1 you fucking kidding me??? does she sounds singing opera in the studio? omg dont fuckin talk if you got no idea!!!
nickosmal 3 months ago
Is She From This Planet......?????
geosamy12 4 months ago 4
LA AMO SEÑORES LA AMO!
EvadneBaal 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
god shes ugly!
The61769 4 months ago
@The61769 god, she is one of the best looking women on earth!
psykosauron 3 months ago
honestly Anette fucking sucks!!!........and she's fat
Long life to Tarja Turunen and his voice!!!
DerekYeray 4 months ago
@DerekYeray her voice, no ? :p
Lo4an 4 months ago
@Lo4an hehe sorry.. my mistake XD!!
DerekYeray 4 months ago
tarja la mejor voz que pudo tener nitghtwish
theopendoor2008 4 months ago
anette is awful i love tarja
gmerty 4 months ago
Playback!
0:54 watch the drummer, he´s not hitting the cymbal you hear.
0:22, 2:00+: Lips a little bit asynchron to the voice you hear
Krapfenfreund 4 months ago
Anette rocks - but compare her to Tarja. god - compare her to fucking Tarja. TARJA IS AWESOME! ANETTE IS AMAZING! But Tarja WINS forever. anette dosent and dosent try to sound like Tarja but they should not cover the old nighwish songs - also the old nightwish has more feeling and more emotion into their songs.
corpsebridenightmare 4 months ago 45
@corpsebridenightmare
Anette sucks in comparison with Tarja.
Pity bro you can't see this CLEARLY.
VladGuardian 1 month ago
@corpsebridenightmare you are absolutely right! I prefer the original Sound of Nightwish,
no matter life must go on ......
MrAscona81 6 days ago
Im gonna get flamed but I love Tarja... Anette sucks the lyrics to nightwishes new songs with anette suck they have no meaning or feeling like it was when tarja was in the band. They are pop lyrics with a pop sound and anette is mediocre at best. It gets me when people say the bands not the singer are yall stupid...theres no band without a singer!
cemepee 5 months ago
Tarja vs Anette ? Marco Hietala is better XD
GabrielMafiazicca 5 months ago 3
Comment removed
JhonConnorT1000 5 months ago
@JhonConnorT1000 Then why the hell did you come here to watch her? -____-
MostlyghOstly661 4 months ago
i loved that look on her D:
AeOnPuNk 5 months ago
I love tarja she is great and beautiful!!!! <3
MarinFilth26 5 months ago
Shes terrible live!! Compared to a real soprano. Check Elin Manahan Thomas
TrueGoth1 5 months ago
@TrueGoth1 ....shes terrible live?! are u fucking kidding me? Tarja is beautiful and amazing when she sings...keep your lame ass comments to yourself. and dont comment on night wish music....we dont need to hear it.
lunar05 5 months ago
@lunar05 Obviously youre not classically trained, from a purists point of yiew she does sound bad,. But, when she was singing Phantom of the opera, live she sounds great. I am actually a Nightwish fan. I was simply making an observation on the evidence in front of me.
TrueGoth1 5 months ago
@TrueGoth1 Yeah, but this isn't classic, so, since you're not symphonic metal trained, please STFU...
costa200 3 months ago
@costa200 I was only telling the truth, Fuck face!!! Who the fuck are you?? GOBSHITE!!!
TrueGoth1 3 months ago
@TrueGoth1 The only problem is that if you have some sort of musical training you should know that music is not an objective subject. You can't "tell the truth" on this because there isn't such thing in regards to musical taste. And what sort of insults are those? What are you? 12 or something? Seriously, are you aiming for a Darwin award or something?
costa200 3 months ago
This was Nightwish....was....once
Samexciter 5 months ago
Tarja is soooooo beautiful...
skumpik666 5 months ago 2
♥ tarjaaa ♥
Kinzy48 6 months ago
i love tarja she is great
PARAMORKA94 7 months ago 3
Emppu Mega maravilha ♥
mariachystine 7 months ago
Tarja ROCKKKK
XGODX4S 7 months ago
Tarja is very amazing and so is Annete but Tarja got greedy and didnt FEEL the music anymore
evan003daysgrace 7 months ago
@evan003daysgrace Well, can I asked you sth ?? Have you ever watched End of an Era (the whole thing I mean). I 've watched both the whole on DVD and parts of it on youtube. What I understand is that Tarja expresses her deepest emotions when she sings. Pick a song of that LIVE that's sung by her .... Any song. All her energy and emotions are in there ... She is sad at Creek Mari's Blood, sweet and hopeful at Ghost Love Score and wild and energetic at Wishmaster. Tarja wasnt fired for that reason.
athens13kef 5 months ago
@athens13kef She started thinking money was more important then music
evan003daysgrace 5 months ago
@evan003daysgrace You sayed she didn't feel music and that's wrong..... As for money I do not believe she thought it was more important. That's what Tuomas says. Tarja says that Nightwish have always been a priority in her life. Someone who would try to uncover the truth would have to admit that one of them is lying. So I guess we 'll never learn what really happened... But you cannot say she didn't feel music anymore. Music has been and alwaying will be coming from her heart ...
athens13kef 5 months ago
0:57 OH!
Dobida3 8 months ago
Comment removed
Dobida3 8 months ago
Very Cool Friend! U Rock! :)
Daganerabus 8 months ago
Brutal live performance
dw1zzful 8 months ago
Tarja rox!
Kaniu14071988 8 months ago
@EpicTale2012 it is wtf..... anyway they rock even like this !!!
199122199 8 months ago
no dislikes amazing <3
Jennifer3mber 8 months ago 10
@Jennifer3mber there's two now, but we'll just ignore those to bastards
GreeceOTOT 4 months ago
Nightwish was never the same again after she left! HAIL THE GREAT TARJA!!!
x8EchoslaM8x 8 months ago
My god!! where is the slide from 0:06?
MrGonzr 9 months ago 3
damn tarja is fine as hell in this video!
cemepee 9 months ago
@EpicTale2012 it can't be, it's from 2004. end of an era was in 2005. i think it's another live recording. ;)
runawayflyaway 9 months ago
fap fap fap
Lexusstylie 9 months ago
@EpicTale2012 Seems so...
brucoshijada 9 months ago
Oh my<3
MrsLesleyOlivia 10 months ago
@guitar4936 c'est une fausse video, synchronisation, on peut laaaargement le voir quand elle chante "Nemo sailing hoooome". A la base c'est un bon vieux playback in-de-ce-lable xD, une émission allemande il me semble si je me souviens bien. Trop pas grillé -.-
What did you change the vid? We can hear it at several moments, I know it's a pb, but it doesn't seem natural xD
PingouinBleu1 10 months ago
Sans tarja, nightwish n'est plus nightwish, superbe video
guitar4936 10 months ago
te amo tarja ss mi vida
lorkvaster 11 months ago
yeah
templar1217 11 months ago
I miss the good old times!
Tarja please come back.
fuckcommercialmusic1 11 months ago
JUKKA RULES !!!
TheRevSRB 1 year ago
Fucking playback
LeSc373 1 year ago
Audio from "End of an Era", hm?
AngroDiti 1 year ago
@AngroDiti considering end of an era was her last performance, no
impvr1 11 months ago
@impvr1 Bumping the old posts is not nice but I mean that, hm..that maybe the uploader put End of an Era's audio to this video? Because the audio is soooo similar. I'm not trying to be an ass, sorry if it seems like it.
AngroDiti 5 days ago
I can't live without her voice :/
domiukas1 1 year ago 3
She looks really hot here
OushGisher 1 year ago
Emppu sucks/He didn't play during the video!
JHKHSVJSSRV 1 year ago
@JHKHSVJSSRV if he doesnt play doesnt mean he cant play stfu and go watch end of an era if u think he cant play
impvr1 1 year ago
@impvr1 But durig this video it was a phonogramm,not him playing.I just meant that,fool.
JHKHSVJSSRV 1 year ago
Why did they replace Tarja??
Syivris 1 year ago
@Syivris
Is that a rethorical question or do you really not know?
rockyblacksmith 11 months ago
@rockyblacksmith I really don't know D:
Syivris 11 months ago
@Syivris
There was a long time ongoing problem between Toumas, the Songwriter, and Tarja, and Tarja said the next album would be her last with nightwish. The rest of the band appearently did not see any sense in keeping her in the band, and so after the (later named) end of an era concert they asked her to leave the band in an open letter( I think it's still on the NW homepage, if you want to read it). That's the story as far as I know it.
rockyblacksmith 11 months ago
@rockyblacksmith Ooooh, Thank you :D
Syivris 11 months ago
Tarja for ever and longer, fuck anette, you suck!
LAURENdatbenik 1 year ago
tarja is so beautiful
mim1800 1 year ago 2
SHE'S OUR GODNESS<3
tfangirl46 1 year ago 2
the words dont go with the mouth :S!! 2:37-2:39
dnanything 1 year ago
excelente sonido, excelente video
!!!
TarjaPeru 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Tarja the one true Nightwish queen Anette watch learn and weep
lkirkup 1 year ago 60
@lkirkup grow up you dick! grow up between anette and tarja... your not a nightwish fan
DumbThingsMakeSense 9 months ago
@lkirkup shut up
bushpigification 9 months ago
*uuuuuu*
Alic3Cat 1 year ago
Awesome!
AmaranthxNightwish 1 year ago 17
Thanks for posting this video, this is the first time I see it and it was so great :D
Dorianedrums 1 year ago 5
das oberteil das sie an hat hab ich auch!
lunchboxcracker 1 year ago 2