Helloween - Giants (Live with Andi Deris)

[Noteinvito]

ANDI DERIS SUCKS AS SINGER

[alexandrerocker]

fuck you kiske's widows!!!

[somesz83]

Is Grapow on support vocal?

[00000047899]

@somesz83 yes



[pablocalderoni]

Que KISKE la chupe !!!!

[sonnic1995]

fuck both singer haters

kiske fanboy: deris sing like shit! (he just cant sing like him in the old songs)

deris fanboy: go hear kiske pop shit (kiske never make pop, just shit rock, but its ok, not very good but ok, and now he is in a band with kai hansen)

[00000047899]

@sonnic1995 You are a despicable and ignorant

[K7Ks]

this song seems to have been written for Deri's voice. he's singing very well...

[travoldas]

Andi was sent from God to Helloween..He is the reason why Helloween is a solid band today and since he joined the band he is also the main songwriter..Kiske said in interviews that he didn't wnat to do metal anymore.I agree that Kiske's voice is godlike but he is a disgrace for metal!!

[ggggggggg123joanna]

@travoldas I can't agree more with your words,this is so true!

[juanetoperez]

@travoldas Is Weiki the reason why helloween is a solid band, not Deris.

[ZapayodelsuR]

si genial version

[TheK1s]

Kiske Forever, Deris it's ok but this is another band for me, Helloween are Hansen Kiske Weikat Ingo And Markus

[jear501]

@TheK1s you got it!

[sonnic1995]

if they hate chameleon and pink bubbles go ape...why the hell andi sing this song and "number one, and 'mankind"

[farukool]

lol i want to hear kiske singin a deris song, he could probably sucks... obvious its a completely difference voice, soo change must be done

but infact i think it sounds really welll for deris tone

[pitbull1981gr]

Andi.. u are good.. but please DONT sing this song again! (We miss u Kiske)

[Metalfreaaakk]

@pitbull1981gr wrong you miss kiske

[FREEDONFOREVER]

queria saber de onde tiraram essa merda de vocalista descaracterizou totalmente o hellowen mas fazer o que né quando ouvi o master of the rings me deu nojoooooooooooo. acabou o helloween

[voodoovoodooo]

@FREEDONFOREVER

Pera aí cara pálida, quando você fala em descaracterização, você preferia o Michael Kiske? Haverá alguém quem diga que o Michael Kiske descaracterizou a banda pois era melhor com o Hansen.....

Pra mim nunca a troca de baterista e vocalista ao mesmo tempo foi tão benéfica quanto ao que aconteceu ao Helloween.

A banda finalmente ganhou um punch fantástico.

[tomnovolette]

Andi is the best he brought metal back to helloween

[BusterZaber]

por que mierda!!! muchos critican a deris y se la pasan disiendo que no canta bien las canciones de kiske!!!..... que kiske cante las canciones que a cantado deris aver que tal le salen!!!

[Dynieczka92]

he can't sing well kiske's songs, but Have you heard singing kiske deris's songs? Probably not. haha

[pitbull1981gr]

God sent Deris to earth to teach people what a good voice really means.....

.....and then Kiske said "I didnt send nobody" ;)

[nikychico85]

lo q kiske dejo? jajajajajaja no sea tonto ese tema lo iso Weikath no es para q se enojen pero kiske fue un 0 a la izquerda en la compocision con cuea tenia 2 temas q salvaban y todos los demas eran puro relleno para el disco xD

[SteelOfMetal]

Kiske, please, come back!!!!!!!!!!!!

[21code]

It's only Giants...what if he sing Twilight of The Gods, I'm Alive, How Many Tears, The Chance.....The more Andy sing the Kiske era, the worst he sounded

[billywitchdocter]

@21code Actually, in the mid 90's he sang The Chance and it was really good, and his version of Im Alive is awesome, and they played How Many Tears all the time and Ive never heard any complaints.

[nikychico85]

Giants es la mejor cancion de chameleon y sinceramente me quedo con la voz de deris le sale genial

[KeepsMeBurning]

Stop singing Michael Kiske´s songs please..its pain for the ears

[JudasPriest82]

They have to its what the fans want.

[slowpocket]

Para mi la canta genial...!!!

[esdras1910]

Derris is Terrible

[TheBaskerman]

penoso

[metalmania935]

hasta este tema que no es de los mejores de helloween más encima de uno de los peores discos de helloween, a deris le sale como el orto.

[schieese]

Deris is god.

[stogl]

deris is really very bad singer, it is weikaths song

[MaxPower230]

@stogl

I agree, michael is better...

[piperopiperos]

he sings it well (lets say) strangely enough for a kiske song

[anchounio]

I Want Andi Out !!!!

[abbath112233]

@anchounio lol, good one!

[quetedelavie]

One of their greatest songs!!!

[neobarockloki86]

Man, this song is soooo good. Ofcourse Kiske can sing it better, it's his song. Derris is very good also. All Helloween songs are great.

[brahipster]

I'm very happy that they're playing this songs again. I really love Chameleon album, one of the best, in my opinion. Too much creativity!

[GiannakarosMaiden]

giants and some other songs from chameleon ARE SO MUCH fucking underated.

[MURATHAN91]

GİANNA ithink we agree about deris's voice is not goof for concerts because when i listened i want out from deris i am starting laughing he is only for studio right

[metallerium]

kiske is good singer.. but deris is good singer too and great composer heavy metal songs... for me deris is helloween

[MURATHAN91]

deris is fucked up all kiske'S song except eagle fly free

[GiannakarosMaiden]

obviously, these songs doesn't match up to his style, which means he isn't a crap singer he's a good one listen to all other albums after kiske and u'll see

[MURATHAN91]

gianna i wanna say to you if a vocal is not enough good for live gigs he/she is not real vocalist ok because i am a vocalist in a rock band which we have founded it 1 months ago we are working on power metal songs and i am always listening helloweens bootlegs especially 1987-1988 era i have tons of bootlegs from that era kiske kicks ass you cant even talk about deris's live gigs heis not good in the concerts my opinion

[barretres]

Did you ever listen to Deris in the Pink cream 69 era live??...

look in youtube "Sign of danger live"

good voice

[live4sin]

It's interesting to listen to Deris performing these tracks, I like all Helloween eras.

[pitbull1981gr]

Kiske is soooo much better than Deris comeon!! Deris is great but he would suit better in.... Dream Theater than Helloween.

[darkdark123]

Dream Theater? James Labrie is high tenor, he uses same scale as Kiske. Kiske won't sing even simple song of DT

[wazzyman]

Andi's voice would fit First Time or Windmill better

[schieese]

Fantastic song in Andi Deris voice.

[warrioroneultimate7]

Really now???

Yet you have a website that trades helloween dvd and cd's??? You trade Andi with helloween DVD's??? Then if you hate him why have his dvd's??

I'll make sure nobody from here goes on you website and trades with you since your a DERIS HATER!!!! Idiot!

[Froizon]

lol what a stupid guy

Deris sucks and from Kiske and Ingo were kicked from Helloween this band would never be the same. With Hansen permission of course

Fuck you posser

Bye

[warrioroneultimate7]

.....AND YOU RIP PEOPLE OFF TOO!!!

[josuezel]

Fucking great

[hammerfallever]

fuck you Deris haters!!!

[xanthidis]

he is freaky

[carrissi]

On Hellish Rock Tour Deris showed that he can't sing any song from earlier eras, and I don't speak about Kiske era only, to hear him "barkin" songs for Walls era is just pathetic. He lost the voice he had on PC69. GR and Axxis were much better than the boring shows of Helloween.

[destruction44]

I don't like deris performance of course, but I think they have to play this song more! it's a classic!

[mariagarsua]

I can't stand this horrible voice!

[Necroukew]

with Andi on vocals ... it almost makes this song sound something that Pink Cream 69 would play.

[nnkyt]

Yap, agreed. :/

[melgarules]

nice to hear how nobody must sing this song! thanks

[Judezki]

First time hearing Andi's version, thanks so much!

[leavingrain]

Fa cagare...Deris non le deve cantare queste canzoni, fa ridere e basta!Questa canzone fatta da lui è solo una bestemmia!

[metalskuu]

Perfettamente d'accordo , Deris è un ottimo cantante sulle sue canzoni , ma quando si tratta di rivangare il passato delle zucche è inascoltabile... kiske rule!!!!

Povera Giants!!!!

[topolydoro]

unbelievable solo(studio version)!!!!!one of my best...

[migueldelongchamps]

Why? This is not necessary

[currucupaloma]

awful

[melgarules]

The real problem is Deris has a low voice, softly voice and it looks his voice was hoarse but that's life. His voice currently is worse 'cause he smokes... you can hear in all shows he's making. Even Kai Hansen has his voice in better shape. Great song anyway.

[carrissi]

great song poor vocal performance. thanx

[Mysticalili]

just wonderful. Didn´t know that they play this song live. =)

[RiiseRadzy]

something like metuaseii

[dadobu22]

it's difficult to hear something worse. good song anyway

[hello2helloween]

Doesnt sound horribile.

[wovenhood]

Yes it sounds

[carrissi]

I always think chameleon was a good album, not all songs, but i believe, longing, music, when the sinner, and of course giants is one of the best from this band. to hear deris singing that tune is like pain in the ass

[stokilomiv]

I agree, out off key but the worse it's he change the original melody with his pathetic low tones, he can't sing that, even can't sing hard rock. is a unbearable singer. worse ever.

[matuzalem44]

wtf! he sounds terrible bad! he can't sing worse!

[carrissi]

awful, out of tone in the whole song. poor

[Vandroy666]

and please don't write saying that Andi here is out of tune cause he's not, the whole song is 1/2 step down from the original. Do you even know what tune means assholes?

[ferrarifigos]

absolutely out of tune.

[Vandroy666]

ok tell me then, what tune is this song in??

and what tune is Andi singing??

[GunwallsJoBailey]

You are right, Deris has a better voice tone than Kiske has, too clean for my taste.

Also Kiske doen't sings as good as 20 years ago and Andi does, plus he is a fucking great frontman and Kiske not

[stokilomiv]

He sings 10000 times better than 20 years ago.

[Vandroy666]

I actually like Kiske too, he's got a great voice, I only get real upset because all of this fukin idiots talkin' about things they don't know, things like " he's out of tune" or "he change the original melody" fukin shitbrains. you all morons have no clue of what singin or music is.

[matuzalem44]

deris performances is a shame. he betraied the original melody with his awful vocal, fake falsetto and he's out of tune since the beginning. but it's deris, it will be strange to hear him singing well. Stop barking retarded!

[Vandroy666]

there is no point in arguing with you since you are like the blind talkin about light.

your opinions show your lack of knowledge 'bout music theory, you still missing a lot of things to give a valid argument, and your english is awfully bad. go to school first, and then talk to me ok?.arrivederci sciocco!!!!

[piguitit0]

a eso le llamo destruir una buena cancion

hey know to speak spanish??no right??

so stop talkin' about bad english,you should give thanx for people who speak another language and not stupids who only speak or talk her own language

[Vandroy666]

si, si hablo un poco de espaniol, italian, and li'l bit of german, lol. GOD!!!!! your english is even worst than this other fag called matuzalem. anyway, I don't see what your comment has to do with the song or Andi's performance. I'm outta here.

[matuzalem44]

you have not idea of music. you don't have ANY knowledge about music, you're absolutely deaf and retarded. I don't talk with you because you're a retarded monkey. this performance is out of tune. his "not-voice" sound awful and pathetic like you.

[Vandroy666]

LMAO!!!!!!!!!!! "not voice"??? what the hell is that whoa hahahahahahhaa!!!!

[doobs102]

Dude Deris sings Fine I saw him on the Hellish Rock tour and he did alright.

[Vandroy666]

You fuckin idiots first complained about the whole Chameleon album saying that it was too soft and it wasn't power metal. Now you say the song is awesome but only with Michael Kiske, fuckin retards you don't even know what you really want, barking to complain is all that makes you happy fukin shitbrains.

[theixxfactor]

I like Andi on this, even if he can hardly reach the higher tones, but who could sing this like Kiske? Andi is a very good singer, but more a hard rock singer!

[theprophecy11]

k merda

[Revontulet2]

The original version with Kiske on vocals is awesome, one of the most beutiful songs from Helloween! But this one is pure shit!

[SonataALasDerrotas]

Ok, la cancion estuvo bien... pero pussss como que a la hora de cantar temas de kiske no le sale (obvio no es kiske) pero como uno dijo unos comentarios abajo, es refrescante oir a un nuevo vocalista cantando estos temazos, ahora bien... la verdad... sigo prefiriendo la version de kiske en estudio (alguien la a oido en vivo con kiske??), pero cada quien.

[Meronhead666]

Si.. en el bootleg "Chameleon in the East" de 1993 y Kiske suena aburrido no solo en esta sino en todas las canciones, es patetico! Andi obvio no va cantar las canciones de Kiske exactamente igual, pero por lo menos le pone sentimento!

Yes, in the "Chameleon in the East" bootleg from 1993 you can hear Kiske sing this, and he sounds so bored during the whole show- it's pathetic! Of course Andi is not gonna sing Kiske songs exactly like him, but at least he puts feeling into them.

[Froizon]

Vaya comentario mas estúpido.Que Kiske canta sin sentimiento y para ello nos remites a una grabación pirata no? Te has lucido macho.Por cierto , el último disco de place vendome está de número 10 en las listas japonesas.Nada mal para un proyecto que tiene un cantante que canta sin sentimiento cierto?

Lo que hay que leer...

Deris apesta

[Peneck]

totalmente de acuerdo,ahora bien,Deris para nada apesta.Lo malo de este tio es que tienes que cogerlo muy fresco para verlo en un buen directo,pero hay que reconocer que es un gran frontman. Y en estudio suena muy bien.

Por cierto,el disco de Place Vendome,es brutal,este kiske es el mejor,tema por tema mejora.

[irongirl24]

sad to hear that

[cajsoza]

mejor le sale a deris que al saco weas de kiske

[7104324]

Pero que gran mierda es esto!!!!!

Que no le dara verguenza a este pendejo cantar lo que dejo kiske???

[GunwallsJoBailey]

Esto no lo dejo Kiske, lo dejo Weikath

[robinjudeo]

Se refiere a quien lo cantó.

[GunwallsJoBailey]

Si ya se.

Y no creo que le de vergüenza, Deris, a mi gusto canta muy chingon tambien, tiene la voz mas rasposa.

Y eso es mas dificil que alcanzar tonos agudos, porque estudias canto y ya le llegas, igual se que Kiske no estudio canto, pero cualquier pendejo que se anime se le puede poner al brinco a Kiske en voz y registro si se pone a estudiar canto.

Pero una voz rasposa y unica como la de Deris no la obtienes ni estudiando ni practicando canto toda tu vida, ademas Deris es bien versatil xD

[Wherther123]

Kiske é ótimo assim como Andi Deris e Kai Hansen também são, apenas diferentes, cada um tem um papel importante e que marcou o Helloween em um período, agora classificá-los por timbre ou tessitura vocal é ilógico, pois são pessoas totalmente diferentes, porém ótimos vocalistas em suas músicas e composições feitas de forma espcífica para eles!

[Wherther123]

Esses comentários de quem é melhor não levam a nada, o que interessa é que Helloween está na ativa até hoje, diferente de algumas bandas de metal que fazem sempre a mesma coisa e não tem a capacidade de reinventar o próprio estilo!

[psychooo4]

How sad that this guy is the singer of glorious HELLOWEEN...Kiske rulez ok!

[Jorgelloween]

Andi killed the song.

[giuntinipro]

awful

[carrissi]

WTF! this singer can't with this song! out of tone!

[692live]

this was truly horrible - they shouldn't have touched this song

[hundermarcus666]

metal metal metal metal

[schieese]

Great version.

[giuntinipro]

out of tone in the whole song. poor performance

[schieese]

in the same tone.

[campeaupwn]

i never knew this was ever played live.

[Meronhead666]

One of the best and most underrated Helloween songs. And with Andi singing it... Amazing!

[live4sin]

Don't forget Deris was a hard rock singer before joining Helloween, his style was loud and dirty, not the perfect match for a power metal band, anyway, it is quite refreshing to listen to a singer like him performing this style.

[jorgeamachi]

que pesima interpretacion, nincuna comparacion con la perfecta performance de Kiske.

[LuthorPR]

That song is one Helloween's best songs, Kiske gives an unbelievable performance in the studio. As always, this song is too much for Andi to perform live.

[MastersCall]

Well it's definately the best song on Chameleon, but you can't compare it with songs like Eagle Fly Free and Halloween

[LuthorPR]

I totally agree with that statement.

[ferrarifigos]

why not? it's a great song.

[MastersCall]

Yes it is, but you can't deny that the Keeper songs are on a different level in power metal

[ferrarifigos]

yes, but this is not power metal. classic metal/hard rock. a good song is a good song.

[MastersCall]

I see your point, and in one way you are right. But as mentioned, it's hard to compare a classic metal song with a power metal song.

[NeverendingAbyss]

I never thought they would play that song...