Added: 5 years ago
From: corsairstw
Views: 66,023
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (429)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • stop hating, i'm sure they didn't get a say in how fast the accompanist could play, and that's actually how fast the song is supposed to go, it says in the sheet music

  • los hombres estan mur pesados, deben ser mas livianos para este tipo de canción, más "Atenorados"

  • its to fast. it was okayyy the soloist!:) it looks like none of you guys want to be their

  • We have to sing this later for our choir performance...luckily we don't have the shoddy drum job, just the nasty piano...

  • I'm sorry...but this is kind of terrible. 

  • 182 people hates Wicked & Glee.

  • i didnt think it was that bad..

  • @discobunny96 i didn't think so, either.

  • It's not very nice to criticize the piano player. The pianist sounds fine. The percussion is too prominent and the voices are not well blended. Get rid of the books and smile.

  • I just listened to the Chamber Singers at my highschool sing to this I was speechless at how they did...but this is such a peice of shit it shouldnt even be considered sing just regurgitating like a penis or something

  • yeah just ew. i my chorus we're forced to memorize our parts and are never allowed to perform with the sheet music. and they all look bored! my chorus would be BEGGING to sing this song! get into it a little!! look happy! gosh!

  • its not bad but if they dont know the lyrics why are they preforming this??? if they do know the lyrics then LOOSE THE FREAKING BOOKS!!!!! other than that it was good:)

  • no, this is not horrible!!!! The problem is just that the choir doesn't seem to enjoy it!! loose the books and have fun! and why is there a line of students standing apart from the rest???

    (well, im like 5 years late, but anyway..;-)

  • no, this is not horrible!!!! The problem is just that the choir doesn't seem to enjoy it!! loose the books and have fun! (well, im like 5 years late, but anyway..;-)

  • WOW that sucked!! my high school did this song and we were like a fraction of the size of this chior but we did a hell of a lot better than they did. unlike them we could get and stay on pitch and not play the i can sing the loudest game.

  • I just want to say that the chorus sounds awful because the middle school chorus is totally dragging the high school chorus down.

  • It's good (:

    It's different but it's got a good family quality!

  • EEW what are they, like, ten-year olds?? And why are the two choruses separate??

    The Soloist is good though. Shes TOO good for tht chorus. YUCK I usually don't hate but thats... eugh. Thats really weird with the band too.... push the tempo much? A LITTLE RUBATO PLZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • EEW what are they, like, ten-year olds?? And why are the two choruses separate??

    The Soloist is good though. Shes TOO good for tht chorus. YUCK I usually don't hate but thats... eugh.

  • HHAHAHAHAH red hair girl is like: "I should be doing the solo, biotch"

  • the drums and the arrangement is just awful. not a bad soloist though

  • they aren't bad....but they are WAY worse than my school's choir

  • wow... that was interesting... it wouldn't have been so uncomfortably strange if everyone looked like they wanted to be there. No one looked like they were having fun... it's like all the girls wanted the solo part and because they didn't get it, they had sour faces. they look bored. all of them. Stage left is ok, but wow... stage right needed to smile.

  • @sheldeen1001 This is exactly like it is. Additionally, most junior highers/high schoolers view chorus as a blow off class, so they don't try. It's a serious shame.

  • Ouch...

  • It was pretty decent, but one thing I noticed is that when the line "Too long I've been afraid of losing love I guess I've lost. Well if that's love, it comes at much too high a cost" comes up, the chorus sings LUV, not LOV. It doesn't matter who you are, if you are a chorus of any kind, you do not sing the word love as LUV.

  • the singers looks like they're not having fun

  • TERRIBLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Horrible arrangement.......ugh :/

  • not too bad. soloist was good, but the rest of the choir overpowered her when they joined in.

  • it wasnt that bad people leave them alone and i agree the soloist AMAZING!!!!!!!!!

  • no.

  • I loved the soloist! The choir could have been much beter and people need to learn how to stop moving while singing.(AKA the girl behind the soloist)

  • 1. They're more of yelling than singing

    2. would be much better if there weren't any children

    3. the women are too soft they should actually be MUCh Louder than the guys, really the guys are just there to support the women

  • mehh... choir wasnt very passionate .. especially at the end

  • ソロとバックの合唱がそれぞれを引き立てているところが素晴らし­い。ミュージカルの舞台ではこの曲が合唱される事が想像出来なか­ったが、混声合唱によって歌に厚みが出ていてこの曲の魅力が引き­出されていると思う。

  • Errrrr It's not meant to be sing by a choir but it was really good just every choir I've heard makes this mistake put the training side I don't care irf it's technically correct it should be graviDy for the sake of the song.

  • I've never seen singers look so bored

  • dude, we never use our music in choir. its called memorzing..

  • I thought the choir was a little overpowering for the instrumentalists, and I'm not really sure they needed a drummer, but the piano accompinament was fine. I have played a few piano accompinaments, and it is NOT easy, so considering this, I think the piano was fine. I think the soloist was really good though.

  • i don't think they needed a drummer...

  • the piano sounds very timid and sloppy. it should've been there for the soloist.

    and the choir coming in was super overbearing on the soloist.

  • Omg the soloist is so moving!

  • lacked emotion

    nice voices that weren't lucky with

    the instrumental thing

  • way too fucking fast

  • the soloist was very pretty, in both voice and expression

    the chorus wasn't too great

    I'm not a drummer, but it wasn't as terrible as they said, just, idt there should be fills during any choral piece, its too distracting, its an action packed song, so drums belong there no doubt, just tone it down a bit.

  • this isn't meant to be sung by a choir or a song for a chior

  • terrible. everything.

  • I Really liked it! I don't care what everyone else says!

  • Oh my god. I really try to not judge...but that was not good at all. Like, I'm convinced that when you sang that, I'm pretty sure whoever originally wrote this song had a migraine headache.

  • WTF??? this sucks...my ears are bleeding..i usually try not to hate, but damn

  • HORRIBLE!!!! (except the soloist...she has a lovely expression). But yeah.....HORRIBLE!!!!

  • terrible drummer.

  • i don't like the tempo...and some of them don't look very enthusiastic performing this song...

  • this is absolute rubbish!!!

    the men first of all, OVERSHADOWED everything else!!!

    and jus' wandering, but do you know how to keep a tune men??

    and that drumming is terrible...

    and it needs to be sped up more than you have it...

    like original tempo...

  • wow this is rly good!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • real professional. . . i kno its just a school choir but did they RLYneed to keep the music sheets!?

  • Well my choir is doing this and i think this one rocked so does my choir!

  • cheers, laira, great minds think alike :)

  • The soloist is good. But the rest of the choir really needs to do some blending.

  • shitty

  • You Guys Did An Awesome Job But This Version Does Not Do The Live Broadway Version Justice But I Guess Thats Normal GREAT JOB!

  • i dont like the chorus version of this song, doesnt do the musical justice!!!

  • Terrible. They were so bad. The sheet music was pointless, it sounds like you didn't even use it. I'm sorry, but you need some people that are more enthusiastic.

  • this was fucking terrible. it was too slow, the drummer thought he was the best thing that ever walked this fucking planet. the hoir realy sucked. the bitch at the start was holding her fucking sheet music in front of her. timing was shit aswell. you may aswell just give up in life its not like ur going any where with it

  • Wow thats almost the worst thing i've ever read!

  • Idina would be pissed haha and i was writing this during the beginning, and now my ears hurt...

  • This is terrible. The choir seems as enthused to be singing as they would be going to a funeral! I just heard Central Islip's version which is much, much more exciting than this. The soloist is nice however- she just had nothing to back her up!

  • the girl at the start should have kept singing.

  • I don't really think that a full on choral version of this song does the original justice. It's a tad robotic.

  • I like the solo,but you guys should have tried changing the time during the song to make it more interesting and work on timing, but good.

  • timing sucks a bit;

    but good cover :)

  • the girl's voice in the beginning was beautiful! then it got suckish....

  • Ugh... This song was meant for theater not choir or chorus. I hate it when they do it. And ur drummer was the one the needs to calm down!! But ur soloist... needs to stop with the yea's and woah's.

  • theres no reason you should have the sheet music in your hands...

  • That was mediocre

  • we did this for choir and we sucked

  • what a strange thing, to arrange this for choir.... doesn't make sense....

  • I don't think your piano player was to bad. The choir is what made it sound kinda crappy.

  • agreed, it looks un-practised with everybody holding the music. Also, there weren't many people smiling.

    But it sounded technically great

  • yeah, agreeing with what's already said-looks sloppy with you all holding the music.

    good effort guys, wonderful song ;)

  • I don't like the syncopation :(

  • I don't either....it's totally different. and not the best for that song...

    but good effort guys!

  • wow that was really good! :) good job you guys

    the soloist was good but the only thing i didnt like is that you were all holding the music.. it looked kind of tacky. other than that though it was good :D

  • Were yall at Wingate.

    but anyway ur soloist needs to back away from the mic with her woo woos and yea yeas like she needs to let the chior shine and do yall really need the lyrics cause it looked kinda messy.

    some ppl had books. some ppl had paper. but the sound was good

  • you all need green make up as well

  • oooo look its Marjorie Daws from Fat Fighters moving her arms frantocally in the air. Oh thats the conductor,

  • lol I like how you talk crap about the piano player but the drummer was way worse lol.

  • Yeah, the drummer need to calm the f*ck down.

  • so u have to have music? u can't memorize?

  • you guys are saying gravity. ew. it sounds weird. we say Gravidy. :D overall thought, nice job

  • I cant stand it when choirs do this song. It cant be arranged well for chorus. EEEEEk

  • the boys are... well you can hear them. what are they 5th graders come on. our show choir did a medley of wicked and it was sooooooo much better. soloist was ok. this is an exciting song so look like it even if you don't want to be there. four years of show choir had taught me this.

  • You have an amazing voice!!!!! keep it up!

  • you kinda changed the speed of the song at the begining bit. xx but still really good. well done x

  • My choir is doing this song too.

    So far we suck so bad D;

    You guys are really freaking good though. Nice job.

  • you put a part of the wizard and i in the song

  • no they didn't...that's how it's written -- its the alternative version.

  • yeah... that's weird how in the 'unlimited' bit the words are from the wizard and I... why aren't they the actual defying gravity words?

  • The soloist did a good job. We're singing this same version. Our guys sound more sure of the notes than the guys in this choir. The piano accompianist isn't very good. But overall good job.

    I'd also like to comment on the Calhoun high school version, here, because you can't on that page. That one is really bad!!! The soloist looks like she's psycho and the guy next to her looks like a stalker. Their choreography is really, really bad!!! You guys did a lot better, but my group did better.

  • really good but everyone looks sooo bored lol xx

  • WAUW!!

    REALLY GOOD.

    o my god its very strange but I have tears in my eyes?

    ( my english is not realy good sorry )

    I enjoyed it!!

  • OMG. I can hear the guys singing! You can't hear the guys at all in my chorus.

  • not to be mean or any thing. but i dont think your choir should sing this song ever. the choir didnt sound unified enough for it, and not at that skill level yet.

    the dynamics choir from mths tho is really good at this kind of stuff. they won an award on it actually.

    but yeahh, your choir is good and all, but just not for this song.

  • amazing job i wish our chorus would have done this song. Dont let anyone tell you your not great because you are!

  • I like that you guys tried to do it your way. It certainly sounds interesting and its not the same thing over and over again. But to be honest....it sounds like something off of Kidz Bop CD. Maybe if you guys were a little older to sing it, it would sound better. I'm glad though that you guys made this into your own thing. I don't see why people like the same version of this song over and over and over again....it gets boring after a while and I like it spiced up a bit. Nice job =)

  • who arranged the choral peice thats horrible its not ment for a male voiceeven though I am one

  • THAT IS NOT ELPHABA

  • really great...thanks for posting

  • wow! yall r good! my choir did that song this year tooo.well, not 2009,but 2008, like for our first concert in october i think or sept. but it waz just my 7th grade choir, but it waz good.!!! anyway, yall, ROCK!!!:D

  • our show choir did a medley of songs from Wicked this year and that arrangment was a lot better. we had the solo for elphie at the start of DF till the chorus then again at "so if you care to find me...". we were a lot better

  • I know, it's like an insult when other people try to sing it...=D

  • Just let Idina Menzel do it, please. No one else can do it justice.

  • Actually, I think Kerry Ellis did a rather amazing job with it.

  • I agree, I'm a little tired of ocd Idina fans that can't accept that she was FAR from the best person to sing this song, I love her with all my heart but Stephanie J Block, Kerry Ellis, Shoshana Bean, Nicole Parker, and Eden Espinosa, to name a few, are far more powerful singers than Idina and do just as much, if not much more, justice to the song than she was ever entirely capable of. Love her, but live she was like a box of chocolates, you never knew what you'd get with her.

  • Yeah . . . . the people in the choir look like they're at a funeral. Smile :D!

  • LOL

  • Miluju sborový zpěv... :-)

  • at least pretend to give a shit about what you people are doing.

  • The soloist is alright, the director is like bouncing round and the kids all look like someones died."/

  • great!

    i love it :D

  • 1 of 5 stars, if their was a 0 i would pick that, a solo song sung by a choir just sounds stupid, they look so retarded holding their musics, and they arent raising their soft palletes making the sound flat.

  • Soloist is great. But the director has more emotion than the choir.

  • lol....that's funny....

  • I like it. It was really good I think.

    Chris

  • She sings like Buddy's girlfriend from ''Elf''

  • Zooey Dechanel

  • I dont think she sounds like zooey dechanel at all...

  • the soloist was really good.

    the arrangement sounds so choppy and takes the emotion out of the song...but that's not the choir's fault

  • look at the girl at 1:46. she looks pissed to be there. lol

  • LOL!! she really does!!!

  • OMG yeah!

  • Totally!

  • wow, way to completely lack emotion (except the soloist).

  • Sorry to say it but it's true. I'm in a choir and one of our problems ins emotions. This sounds like us when we don't have any emotion in a song. It happens but it's fixable. Other than that, everything was wonderful. Soloist had a beautiful voice too.

  • wwooaah

  • it's sounds soooooo amazing!!!!!!!!!!!

  • this sucks

  • Oh, don't be a sour patch. :) It could have been much worse.

    The soloist was good. :p

  • lol i thought a choral version would be amazing but it seems like its in pieces. soloist was good, but i think she held back on the high notes.

  • We sang this at festival, the arrangement was very disappointing for anyone that worshiped the Original Cast Recording, like I did. x)

  • I'm not saying that you singers are bad, but i just don't like the choral version of this song. But i think you all did a good job!

  • i like the song but i dont like the choural version

  • my chorus did this, we did better but we did not hav percusion

  • whoooo Sloooooow down! Crack speed!!! Dear God! And they hired the wrong percussionists/have the wrong percussion equipment combined.

    I like the soloist. :D yes ma'am.

  • i love the soloist voice at the end, im not sure why it just sounds amazing

  • I still think the solist has the greastest voice ever.

  • You guys did great.. but I hate hearing this as a choral arrangement. Good job soloist! =)

  • I quite liked it! I love this tune anyway, so to hear it done in choral is ace!! Im quite impressed, this is only a young choir!

  • The soloist has a very unique voice, she could do wonders with it.

    I have a feeling that the choir didn't work on it as long as they should have before performing it. Maybe I'm just a stickler for perfection.

  • i didnt like the soloist

  • this is a really weird timing... it should be slower. the soloist sounds nothing like an elphaba but shes still good.

  • Soloist sounds nothing like Elphaba... Still very good though!

  • the choir i am in is singing this song... it seems like they are going too fast...

  • where did you get the sheet music for this song? my women's choir teacher would like us to sing this next year and asked me to find where to get the sheet music for it. i would appreciate it if you could tell me where.

  • great job on the performance! i just don't think this song works out of context. Maybe a solo/duet would have worked better. idk. It still was really good!

  • pretty darn cool! gr8 job!

  • What's The Name Of The Conductor? I Think I Might Know Her! lol!

  • wow good job!! i really liked it.

  • The soloist looks kinda like Emma Watson, lol.

  • or jenna fisher

    (pam from the office)

  • infact its just the guys lol it gets better midway through. x

  • lead singer - great, but harmonies from the choir are really off. Harmonies need to be rethought out and replanned tbh! Possibly it's just the direction by the conductor or whoever arranged the piece. x

  • lead singer is amazing but the thick texture when all the other guys come in ruins the feeling

  • i dont like the arrangement. ....  =[

  • I dont like it either, its not a very well together piece - doesnt do the song any justice!

    I love the sound that comes through from this choir, its lovely and clear :)

    Might I say though, that I couldnt help but notice at about 32 seconds, the girl behind the soloist turns away and does something with her hair? Eek! Please tell her that you cant do that kind of thing on stage, it looks really shabby.

    I also hate seeing choirs with sheet music when they're performing.

    Nicely sung though :)

  • OMG u guys r really good. I wish my choir was that big so we could do songs like that. GOOD JOB :D

  • the girl on the left behind the soloist at 1:19 looks like the girl who plays Wendy on Peter Pans

  • where are you from ? it sound bristish english !

  • Very Nice, my choir did this, but it was only the the  8th graders (3 years ago) and so i did not get to sing it, but it was a great song!

  • Cool to hear it w/harmony and stuff

  • Wow, y'all are great. Exspecially the soloist. She's an angel. Love her a lot a lot a lot. She probably knows it's me now though.