Thom is a gleeman... not much glee in Sam Elliot. Next to that ... Thom sings, ever heard Sam Elliot's voice. Also... Perrin needs to be broad shouldered, and tall... not some whelp. Some are dead on tho, I can see Clive Owen as Lan, just as long as he doesnt talk too much, however i'd like Liam Neeson more for the part. Last but not least of my suggestions... Aes Sedai have an ageless look... how the foosh is Helen Mirren gonna pull that one off?
Whoever plays Perrin needs to have a very bearish physique even before he's selected for the role, and even then, he'll probably need to get even bigger and stronger. If a first glance doesn't make you think, "I hope that guy has a slow temper," he's not Perrin. I'd start looking for bearded bouncers at rough Scandinavian bars.
Most of 'em were pretty good. Fain is perfect. I think you missed with Perrin, though, He's supposed to be big, bear-like. And he needs a beard. And Gawyn's a miss:
1) When I think of a responsible young ruler/protector/officer, I do NOT think of Ashton Kutcher.
2) Galad's older than Gawyn, shouldn't the actor look older, too?
@kaneandlynch123456 My words exactly...it's a good list, but gawyn's supposed to be blonde...with blue eyes...and a baby face. complete opposite of ashton kutcher.
I agree with this cast but my problem is with perrin-he should be freaking bigger not a sissy lol:D and btw i tottally agree with ur padan fain choice:D
Nice picks, for most of them. Viggo could do Lan or Elyas, same with Owen. But the last one. No real problem with the pick, though he might have to lose his Scottish accent. It's your spelling. I had to read your description to figure out the character. It's "Gareth Bryne" for future reference.
I am incredibly apprehensive about a Wheel of Time movie (too many books, all of which only encompass roughly four-five years, and the Ta'averen are all in their late-teens), but I would be incredibly happy, more than happy, with Samuel as Padan Fain. He is perfect for the role.
And Aragorn as Elyas is pretty cool, but that might just be type-casting him. Not a bad thing, but still.
Thank you for adding a list of names and your rationale to the information for this video. I think it improves the experience of viewing and generally makes the viewer more sympathetic to your opinions/selection. Great job.
Nice touch, although, like any others, I disagree with some choices: Lan is must be much older, as must Elias, and Elias must be quite beasty, like (have a look at the 13th warrior cast). But I must say Thom is spot on!
seems all pretty good, but i reckon the actor for elaida needs a smooth face and i didn't imagine tam being that old... perrin also needs more muscle and a wider frame. But other than that it's really awesome. What's the song?
i pretty much liked all your choices except perrin(james franco would be awesome in the movie, but not big enough for perrin...i can't put my finger on who he could be though) and morgase. Your fain and tom were the most perfect selections i've ever seen
I love your Mat he's one of my my favorite male characters.For Nynaeve I think Nora Salinas would be perfect (she's a Mexican actress but they don't have to be al Hollywoodian right?) and I always saw Sigourney Weaver as Elaida.I think you can put Hellen Mirren to play Bair in the following casts and Vanessa Redgrave as Sorilea would be a nice choice.
Sam Elliot as Thom is a great choice. I've always pictured Eliza Dushku as Nynaeve though and Portman was Egwene instead. Whose that for Padan Fain? I kinda see Kevin Spacey or Richard from Lost as him. I need to make one of these now :)
I knew Moiraine when I saw her. She would be perfect. Dennis Quaid =good. Alot of good characters, I disagree with someone. Im really not sure about wether Hayden could pull it off as Rand al'Thor. He could look the part I guess. But not play the part I think. I was impressed by Chris hemingsworth's role in Star trek. He seemed so natural. He is tall and muscular, blu/gray eyes, so on. I thought about Christopher Egan as Perrin, and Nicholas D'Agosto as Mat. But I liked Henry too.
You're right about Chris Hemsworth! I don't know about his acting skills, but he has the right looks. I'm thinking about changing my vid, haha... Thanks for the idea.
Eliaida should be a bit younger with black hair thats how i imagine tune to my channel to see my drawings
talentgirl16 6 months ago
I'd have Christian Bale as Matrim
TheCoolFlames 9 months ago
Thom is a gleeman... not much glee in Sam Elliot. Next to that ... Thom sings, ever heard Sam Elliot's voice. Also... Perrin needs to be broad shouldered, and tall... not some whelp. Some are dead on tho, I can see Clive Owen as Lan, just as long as he doesnt talk too much, however i'd like Liam Neeson more for the part. Last but not least of my suggestions... Aes Sedai have an ageless look... how the foosh is Helen Mirren gonna pull that one off?
Roadycore 1 year ago
Whoever plays Perrin needs to have a very bearish physique even before he's selected for the role, and even then, he'll probably need to get even bigger and stronger. If a first glance doesn't make you think, "I hope that guy has a slow temper," he's not Perrin. I'd start looking for bearded bouncers at rough Scandinavian bars.
littlebigman52 1 year ago
There's a fair number of guys with the look of mischief necessary for Mat, but my vote goes to Seann William Scott.
littlebigman52 1 year ago
excellent choice for Egwene!!!!! Actually pretty good cast overall
evolve991 1 year ago
Most of 'em were pretty good. Fain is perfect. I think you missed with Perrin, though, He's supposed to be big, bear-like. And he needs a beard. And Gawyn's a miss:
1) When I think of a responsible young ruler/protector/officer, I do NOT think of Ashton Kutcher.
2) Galad's older than Gawyn, shouldn't the actor look older, too?
randalthor766 1 year ago
@randalthor766 right! And Perrin needs some gold contacts lol
evolve991 1 year ago
very very accurate man,gj.send it to the director of the lotr to see if it works:D
Promaxos 1 year ago
oh and wtf? ashton kutcher as gawyn?:))
kaneandlynch123456 1 year ago
@kaneandlynch123456 My words exactly...it's a good list, but gawyn's supposed to be blonde...with blue eyes...and a baby face. complete opposite of ashton kutcher.
andXsoXitXis 1 year ago
I agree with this cast but my problem is with perrin-he should be freaking bigger not a sissy lol:D and btw i tottally agree with ur padan fain choice:D
kaneandlynch123456 1 year ago 2
Nice picks, for most of them. Viggo could do Lan or Elyas, same with Owen. But the last one. No real problem with the pick, though he might have to lose his Scottish accent. It's your spelling. I had to read your description to figure out the character. It's "Gareth Bryne" for future reference.
Raistlin3 1 year ago
I am incredibly apprehensive about a Wheel of Time movie (too many books, all of which only encompass roughly four-five years, and the Ta'averen are all in their late-teens), but I would be incredibly happy, more than happy, with Samuel as Padan Fain. He is perfect for the role.
And Aragorn as Elyas is pretty cool, but that might just be type-casting him. Not a bad thing, but still.
Blueruler182 1 year ago
Thank you for adding a list of names and your rationale to the information for this video. I think it improves the experience of viewing and generally makes the viewer more sympathetic to your opinions/selection. Great job.
dragonodare 1 year ago
Nice! Great job on all your pics! hopefully they take your advice when they make the movie ;)
cankzilla 1 year ago
Elayne is Jaime King ;)
GilraenPalantir 1 year ago
i'm dumb but who is Elayne? smokin!!
cankzilla 1 year ago
@cankzilla if you havnt read the wheel of time books you would have no idea
laxplaayaa 1 year ago
haha - love the Elaida pic! she's mean and evil...it don't matter about ageless when you're cruel!
cankzilla 1 year ago
your best pick: Sam Elliott as Thom, that is more or less EXACTLY how i picture him
worst pick: Elaida, she is supposed to look ageless lol, kinda a key point.
all together some really good choices though, except Viggo Mortensen should NOT play Elyas, he needs to play Lan.
vithzeral 2 years ago
Some really good choices here. Kevin R. McNally IS my idea of Bayle Doman.
But your text says "Christian Bale" as Logain, but the video is showing Billy Crudup.
RCHairbrush 2 years ago
Nice touch, although, like any others, I disagree with some choices: Lan is must be much older, as must Elias, and Elias must be quite beasty, like (have a look at the 13th warrior cast). But I must say Thom is spot on!
4kormi 2 years ago
Thank you all, btw, I never expected to get over a thousand viewers! :D
GilraenPalantir 2 years ago
The soundtrack is some version of Immediate Music's Serenata Immortale. If you look it up, you get a different version, but it's also pretty :)
GilraenPalantir 2 years ago
Anyone but Hayden Christiansen for Rand. He already destroyed one franchise for me.
kashbrook 2 years ago
seems all pretty good, but i reckon the actor for elaida needs a smooth face and i didn't imagine tam being that old... perrin also needs more muscle and a wider frame. But other than that it's really awesome. What's the song?
TrigTigTeeHee 2 years ago
switch gareth and geofram and i agree perrin needs to be bigger person
zerohour95 2 years ago
i liked pretty much everyone except Tam and Elaida. Everyone else I liked though. Especially Nynaeve. Briliant that!
peppermint71091 2 years ago
no aes sedai should be played be anyone older
EffingSmurf 2 years ago
personally i think Mat's jaw is to big but that is just me. :D
also i wouldn't be able to take Gawyn seriously. ahaha
and Goodness gracious is Nynaeve hot!
yourfisharemine 2 years ago
pretty good choices, what's the soundtrack?
joshsomebody57 2 years ago
galad and elaida wrong wrong wrong
jaKisAHUGElad 2 years ago
Comment removed
jaKisAHUGElad 2 years ago
Spot on with Fain. I can't agree with any of the over choices, but Fain more than makes up for that.
downRupLyB 2 years ago
i pretty much liked all your choices except perrin(james franco would be awesome in the movie, but not big enough for perrin...i can't put my finger on who he could be though) and morgase. Your fain and tom were the most perfect selections i've ever seen
UMDlax4 2 years ago
I love your Mat he's one of my my favorite male characters.For Nynaeve I think Nora Salinas would be perfect (she's a Mexican actress but they don't have to be al Hollywoodian right?) and I always saw Sigourney Weaver as Elaida.I think you can put Hellen Mirren to play Bair in the following casts and Vanessa Redgrave as Sorilea would be a nice choice.
I like these Wise Ones a lot.
NynaeveKali 2 years ago
hayden christensen as rand? it would be murder, he singlehandedly killed the last 2 star wars movies and it would be worse with these!
KillerCow449 2 years ago
Nah, Lucas killed 'em. Hayden could be decent just needs right director to push him.
TWheels94 2 years ago
Thanks for your responses, everyone. I'm working on my second video, for The Great Hunt, now, and I'm also going to check out your suggestions.
GilraenPalantir 2 years ago
Props. Your choices are on the mark. I can't wait for your next vid (if you continue making them).
Osdnaos 2 years ago
Sam Elliot as Thom is a great choice. I've always pictured Eliza Dushku as Nynaeve though and Portman was Egwene instead. Whose that for Padan Fain? I kinda see Kevin Spacey or Richard from Lost as him. I need to make one of these now :)
TWheels94 2 years ago
I knew Moiraine when I saw her. She would be perfect. Dennis Quaid =good. Alot of good characters, I disagree with someone. Im really not sure about wether Hayden could pull it off as Rand al'Thor. He could look the part I guess. But not play the part I think. I was impressed by Chris hemingsworth's role in Star trek. He seemed so natural. He is tall and muscular, blu/gray eyes, so on. I thought about Christopher Egan as Perrin, and Nicholas D'Agosto as Mat. But I liked Henry too.
capeboyboy 2 years ago
You're right about Chris Hemsworth! I don't know about his acting skills, but he has the right looks. I'm thinking about changing my vid, haha... Thanks for the idea.
GilraenPalantir 2 years ago
I love seeing choices for a cast of WOT. The one I liked the best and agree 100% is your Thom choice!
TheShnuz 2 years ago