ABSOLUTELY LOVE IT JAY! You have gone so far! I've been watching your channel for years and I am so pleased you have not taken your music in that commercial crap! Keep on writing, keep on singing! You are making me smile, cry and laugh! :-)
I discovered this song only yesterday on the radio (oh yes, they DO play good music on the radio SOMEtimes) and have been listenting to it over and over again since. Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful...
I love love love this video! It's a gorgeous video. I do prefer the originl version of the song but this version is pretty damn good as well! Kudos Jay!!
I cannot stop listening to this song. Jay, your voice is truly angelic, and this song resonates with me more than any song I've heard in an extremely long time. This video is beautiful, and so are you. You amaze me, please never stop making music! <3
Jay- you are going to be something. Keep it up. Just bought a bunch of itunes songs. Bring success to all of us by bringing success to yourself- you're awesome!
No idea what's going on there are so many layers (particularly after watching the making of vid). doesn't really matter when it makes you feel through every character. such is life. it's so delicately told and, well, beautiful. your work is extraordinary!
I can't believe I'm late to the party! This song is incredible! The video poignant! The message relatable. I love the production, the strings.... Jay, I say this as a MAJOR compliment, you are giving Jason Mraz some strong competition in the songwriting and vocal department. I can not wait for your new album! :-D
I absolutely love Jay, and pretty much everything he does. However, I just wish he would have left this song in it's original form. The added remix really takes away from the song. :/
I'm one of the biggest Jay fans in the world, so it pains me to say I don't really like this newly mixed version. All the instrumentals and bass lines take away from Jay's voice. Give the guy a mic and guitar and let him sing!
Jay es tan emocionante verte crecer tanto!!! I send you positive energies. I love the video, i've seen it 300 times jeje CONGRATULATIONS!! XO XO Ramiro from Argentina
Oh shut up about the gay and straight shit. I'm a straight male who has appreciated Jay's MUSIC for years. I don't care whether he is gay or straight , that has NOTHING to do with the worth of his music, or my desire to listen to him. Don't box people, don't box music. Its universal, and thus, let it be universally enjoyed.
The original version moves me in ways that this video can't. I'm OK with the 'straight' thing and your music does not need to be overproduced. Simply put you and your guitar alone together are pure magic. I just need to tell you that Jay... <3's
Thank you so much for putting a story to this piece. A lot of people think it's about a girl loving a gay man even though you've frequently said it wasn't - so thank you for giving this song a new meaning.
I liked the original version better. Whoever arranged this tried putting too much variety into this song. You hear random fiddles coming in from nowhere playing music completely not fitting in with the rest of the music. It just isn't cohesive. As to the non-gay thing, I'm fine with it not being a gay based video but the video just doesn't fit again. It pains me to say all that.
Guys, Jay has always said he didn't intend it to be about a girl falling for a gay man. The story is universal, regardless of gender or sexual orientation! The genders of the people in the video do not change its meaning! Beautiful job Jay. :)
@TheAmnesiaGrrl Why is it that a "universal" story almost always ends up becoming "heterosexual" when it gets depicted in a visual medium? Not a criticism of Jay or the video, but just a point I'd like to raise.
@chpoof I think it would have remained universal had he chosen to have it be about two gay men, but Jay said the song wasn't about two gay men. I understand what you mean, however, because it is mostly heterosexual couples in the media whose love gets called "universal" which is unfortunate.
No No No.. I sort of don't like the new arrangement that changes the atmosphere of the song in a "happy ending" ballad.. totally different from the original version. And the video - i am not straight-fobic: a not returned love is still a not returned love - is a lost opportunity to tell a very common dynamic for the gay community (so many of us had a friend that fell for us ) and you had found the right words to describe it in such a sweet, delicate way. Why not being consistent with a video?
Jay, your music and sound has evolved and risen to a new echelon with the release of these new songs and arrangements! I REALLY love what I'm hearing so far! It's like the next newest incarnation for folk music, FolkPop!
oh i just remember him, i found this song a long time ago(at that time without this video), some comment calling him "gay brannan", doesnt matter anyway,i like his song "Can't Have It All"
jay we love the acoustic version you and that guitar or a piano .... your message and heart just seems to get buried underneath all that busy sound addition bull. you will make it
I love love love Jay Brannan and I'm glad this song finally has a music video. I think the acoustic version that came out forever ago on his "In Living Cover" album is my favorite song by him. Great to see he's got a new album coming out!
What a beautiful music video! Pre-ordering as soon as possible, I'm so excited you finally have a release date! Very much look forward to hearing the whole album!
Good song, although videos seem to take away from your music; it's just too abstract and intelligent to be saddled with pedestrian images and storylines.
"He was her long bright future in the middle of a wrong, dark road. He loved her, but he wasn't too sure if he could return the love she showed" #storyofmylife
I love this song and the new arrangement is taking some getting used to.. not really fond of it after the first listen -- but I *am* very attached to the original acoustic version. one of my favourite songs of yours ♥
AMAZING, I LOVE THE SONG, AND THE VIDEO!!!!!!! SEE YOU IN ROME JAY <3
hhhhhiiiidccch 9 hours ago
Jay, are you going to have any of your music available on Google Music soon? I keep checking but...
Would be great if I could easily buy through Android Market. I switched my entire music collection into Google Music and it rocks the house!
ElijahLynn 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
is this song about being suck in the "friendzone"?
theneedledrop 2 days ago
SO much with "i like the previous version"....
Just appreciate the new beat, the music, the vibe...
oldei 2 days ago
So different from your original, but i still love it. your voice is superb! (:
All of Seattle's Love!!!<333
countxthexshadowsx 2 days ago
ABSOLUTELY LOVE IT JAY! You have gone so far! I've been watching your channel for years and I am so pleased you have not taken your music in that commercial crap! Keep on writing, keep on singing! You are making me smile, cry and laugh! :-)
eljiah 2 days ago
production candy... never know what you're gonna get. sweet surprise Mr. Brannan, the music and video has honest to goodness - substance.
wilbirho1 3 days ago
PROMOTE YOUR MUSIC IN THE PHILIPPINES. MUSIC SCENE IS MORE FUN IN THE PHILIPPINES :D This one's beautifully done! xOx
PinoyRawTalents 4 days ago
I like
thearthurmonster 4 days ago
WTF!!! Let's get dressed before we go to bed! O_o
MrCeusie 5 days ago
I discovered this song only yesterday on the radio (oh yes, they DO play good music on the radio SOMEtimes) and have been listenting to it over and over again since. Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful...
tatia641 6 days ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
7 seconds in, and I hate it already.
KtheBand 1 week ago
<3
wilfreddekok 1 week ago
jay brannan is a beautiful man.
myass225 1 week ago
Le friendzone anthem.
dark1724 1 week ago 4
Its interesting having a more upbeat version but I do prefer the style of your previous music videos.
Belledemure 1 week ago
<3
paulinus007 2 weeks ago
My fave song! I like the less upbeat version but still so awesome!
Muahlovesjonasbros 2 weeks ago
I like the acoustic version of the song better, but the video is GREAT nevertheless. LOVE IT :-)
carocora3 2 weeks ago
I love love love this video! It's a gorgeous video. I do prefer the originl version of the song but this version is pretty damn good as well! Kudos Jay!!
crimsonvale42 2 weeks ago
I cannot stop listening to this song. Jay, your voice is truly angelic, and this song resonates with me more than any song I've heard in an extremely long time. This video is beautiful, and so are you. You amaze me, please never stop making music! <3
michaelabarryy 2 weeks ago
I literally cannot stop listening to this song. You're flawless Jay <3
xoLouieee 2 weeks ago
Jay- you are going to be something. Keep it up. Just bought a bunch of itunes songs. Bring success to all of us by bringing success to yourself- you're awesome!
inthepinkmoonlight 2 weeks ago
When I saw the girl the guy was actually with my first reaction was "Son of a Mother!"
crystalroze 2 weeks ago
No idea what's going on there are so many layers (particularly after watching the making of vid). doesn't really matter when it makes you feel through every character. such is life. it's so delicately told and, well, beautiful. your work is extraordinary!
Dane54T 2 weeks ago
I can't believe I'm late to the party! This song is incredible! The video poignant! The message relatable. I love the production, the strings.... Jay, I say this as a MAJOR compliment, you are giving Jason Mraz some strong competition in the songwriting and vocal department. I can not wait for your new album! :-D
DaveCondie 2 weeks ago
I absolutely love Jay, and pretty much everything he does. However, I just wish he would have left this song in it's original form. The added remix really takes away from the song. :/
nikitawita 2 weeks ago
love it love it love eetttt :)
medurox 2 weeks ago
Really goood voice!
lim4561 2 weeks ago
A+ for creativity :-)
Tolya1979 3 weeks ago
I love this song.
mzhang18 3 weeks ago
I got it :) Jay loved her...she loved him...he loved her... can't believe it took me two times to get the end -.-
SuckingItSince1992 3 weeks ago
Generic.
callum1131 3 weeks ago
*goosebumps*
AshleyBrightEyes 3 weeks ago
I'm one of the biggest Jay fans in the world, so it pains me to say I don't really like this newly mixed version. All the instrumentals and bass lines take away from Jay's voice. Give the guy a mic and guitar and let him sing!
dhillkc 3 weeks ago 3
@dhillkc Totally agree, the more instruments that are added, the less I like the songs.
snifftheflannel 2 weeks ago
Jay es tan emocionante verte crecer tanto!!! I send you positive energies. I love the video, i've seen it 300 times jeje CONGRATULATIONS!! XO XO Ramiro from Argentina
ramypotter 3 weeks ago
This is NSFW music because it is probably not safe to cry at work...
artistsComplex 3 weeks ago
good stuff jay. been watching since soda shop
RyanMontalvoMusic 3 weeks ago 2
Soooo glad you finally made a video! I absolutely love this song!!!
tgator272 3 weeks ago
YESYESYES. Finally.
spexile 3 weeks ago
oooft he looks good in a suit
08andrac 3 weeks ago
i have been listening to this for 2 years waiting for this moment! :D
brcodemocact12080101 3 weeks ago 3
i love the part where he touches her shoulder and she looks at him 1.58
Cindy37T 4 weeks ago
I love how this video/song illustrates unrequited love through different platforms. Tragically beautiful
PatronRick 4 weeks ago 17
Oh shut up about the gay and straight shit. I'm a straight male who has appreciated Jay's MUSIC for years. I don't care whether he is gay or straight , that has NOTHING to do with the worth of his music, or my desire to listen to him. Don't box people, don't box music. Its universal, and thus, let it be universally enjoyed.
accordingtolive 4 weeks ago 26
Охуенно!
Uebator4ik 4 weeks ago
"Beautifully" !
06Grem 4 weeks ago in playlist Nettwerk Featured Videos Playlist
I'm so excited to watch him become more and more popular. Congratulations Jay! I hope all your dreams come true :)
SailorAnthy 4 weeks ago 3
omg, finally a video!!
too bad the original version of the song is better
bryarworship 4 weeks ago
the voice of an angel :')
MandaBonita 1 month ago 2
this is wonderful. <3
karlyhashope 1 month ago
He's like... a skinnier and hotter version of Wentworth Miller...
6eloved 1 month ago
1:10 my fav part
xLoliChiDesuu 1 month ago
WHAT?? You changed the lyrics!!!! :/
sheelue 1 month ago
The original version moves me in ways that this video can't. I'm OK with the 'straight' thing and your music does not need to be overproduced. Simply put you and your guitar alone together are pure magic. I just need to tell you that Jay... <3's
Super123derek 1 month ago
i hope this song does well and gives jay some cash flow
twackingrecordings69 1 month ago
Thank you so much for putting a story to this piece. A lot of people think it's about a girl loving a gay man even though you've frequently said it wasn't - so thank you for giving this song a new meaning.
kittenkittycatlover 1 month ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
u stol cboses bitch u fag
lost4468yt 1 month ago
<3
Nickotine111 1 month ago
he got nice shot eyes
TheMukal 1 month ago
You're so awesome Jay!
ductapelosergirl 1 month ago
I liked the original version better. Whoever arranged this tried putting too much variety into this song. You hear random fiddles coming in from nowhere playing music completely not fitting in with the rest of the music. It just isn't cohesive. As to the non-gay thing, I'm fine with it not being a gay based video but the video just doesn't fit again. It pains me to say all that.
forvor 1 month ago 3
Guys, Jay has always said he didn't intend it to be about a girl falling for a gay man. The story is universal, regardless of gender or sexual orientation! The genders of the people in the video do not change its meaning! Beautiful job Jay. :)
TheAmnesiaGrrl 1 month ago 57
@TheAmnesiaGrrl Why is it that a "universal" story almost always ends up becoming "heterosexual" when it gets depicted in a visual medium? Not a criticism of Jay or the video, but just a point I'd like to raise.
chpoof 1 month ago
@chpoof I think it would have remained universal had he chosen to have it be about two gay men, but Jay said the song wasn't about two gay men. I understand what you mean, however, because it is mostly heterosexual couples in the media whose love gets called "universal" which is unfortunate.
TheAmnesiaGrrl 1 month ago
@TheAmnesiaGrrl Unfortunately it's also pretty common for gay male artists to concede to the media's message.
chpoof 1 month ago
i don't understand which part of the video clip was about the girl falling for a gay guy or does the video and song not match up
Cindy37T 4 weeks ago
@Cindy37T neither the video or the song is about that.
TheAmnesiaGrrl 3 weeks ago
@TheAmnesiaGrrl He has a nice voice. Irish last name no doubt. Forgot the Gaelic spelling.
MyPaulHenry 3 days ago
Not sure how I feel about this version yet...
I'm so glad it finally has a music video for it though, it's wonderful. <3
DangerousTemptations 1 month ago
No No No.. I sort of don't like the new arrangement that changes the atmosphere of the song in a "happy ending" ballad.. totally different from the original version. And the video - i am not straight-fobic: a not returned love is still a not returned love - is a lost opportunity to tell a very common dynamic for the gay community (so many of us had a friend that fell for us ) and you had found the right words to describe it in such a sweet, delicate way. Why not being consistent with a video?
FEDONE74 1 month ago
Comment removed
vkinna 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@FEDONE74 read jay's comment about the video here facebook.com/JayBrannan/posts/332620126770487
vkinna 1 month ago
I'm quite upset about how ungay this video is
remymartinextra2 1 month ago 2
@remymartinextra2 i totally agree
FEDONE74 1 month ago
D'aww! Sad, but lovely.
Mander451 1 month ago
@jesc5160
TheLifeandDay 1 month ago
i like the video, enjoy listening to the song and i love your voice :)
kleinesschokobunny 1 month ago
amazing.
dumachim 1 month ago
Love your music... But... a straight vid? Please don't sell your beautiful gay soul.
pozleo78 1 month ago in playlist Jay Brannan
@pozleo78 Idd, doesn't it kinda destroy the point of the song when the guy is in love with another girl :(
amanual4life 1 month ago
Your sound is so amazing !
jesc5160 1 month ago
hi Jay.. i like this am glad i stumbled onto.. wish you the best guy sure your music will take you far heard of you for the first time.
chasesome 1 month ago
I was hoping Jay would end up with the guy.
rjr81 1 month ago 66
Love it! I really love Jay Brannan's songs. I wish he'll get more famous, like crazy famous.
rlphjnmplq 1 month ago 8
d'awwww! Very nice!
evilaelf 1 month ago
its the official Friendzone song!
Dragostorm 1 month ago 4
that was very, um... straight. but great music
rvnclw13 1 month ago
True talent! Where is ur Glee call up LOL! Boy u get me every time! Love this version keep up the tremendous work.... can't wait for March ;D
johndragon16 1 month ago
Awwwww <3
xsencha 1 month ago
cant say I love this any more than the acoustic version =/
jord4067 1 month ago
UGHH. I have waited soooo long for this music video. Beautifully done. :D I cannot wait for more Jay Brannan music to add to my collection.
athao214 1 month ago
Jay, you look good in a suit. Rrr. Also this video is kind of cool.
donniesbox 1 month ago
Jay, your music and sound has evolved and risen to a new echelon with the release of these new songs and arrangements! I REALLY love what I'm hearing so far! It's like the next newest incarnation for folk music, FolkPop!
macavitymacavity 1 month ago
stevieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
notcalebkruzel 1 month ago
Someone should let Jay know; at 0:59, something is on fire behind him.
drakcloud85 1 month ago
oh i just remember him, i found this song a long time ago(at that time without this video), some comment calling him "gay brannan", doesnt matter anyway,i like his song "Can't Have It All"
TheMukal 1 month ago in playlist Nettwerk Featured Videos Playlist
this is a old song, im sure.so similar with this song, but i dont know where(in movie or video). *im sure my feeling isnt a deja vu*
TheMukal 1 month ago in playlist Nettwerk Featured Videos Playlist
Jay, I have loved your beautiful songs F***ing BEAUTIFULLY!!!!
hawskin 1 month ago
This version of the song is great. Different from the acoustic but just as good.
Mateomouse1 1 month ago
Bella, molto bella!!! ;)
vni75 1 month ago
jay we love the acoustic version you and that guitar or a piano .... your message and heart just seems to get buried underneath all that busy sound addition bull. you will make it
cody2earth 1 month ago
Personally I like the acoustic more <3
Griffinsfaves 1 month ago 3
best gift for my country 's new year ! Love you^^
tvquan8 1 month ago
STEVIE
TheFriskydog 1 month ago
AMAZING!
merino1434084 1 month ago
why 3692 views?
xenwenwu 1 month ago
I love love love Jay Brannan and I'm glad this song finally has a music video. I think the acoustic version that came out forever ago on his "In Living Cover" album is my favorite song by him. Great to see he's got a new album coming out!
leialover1 1 month ago
Love it. good job. I am happy for you
accordingtolive 1 month ago
Read a couple of comments, not going to bother watching the video.
GyThanksGd 1 month ago
I really love the change at the end, it gives it a lot more energy.
Nikoli311 1 month ago
Comment removed
choupinou69 1 month ago
Brilliant video, love it!
choupinou69 1 month ago
I hope you aren't beginning to sell out to a more straight image. Love the song though Jay.
dumdumsaregood 1 month ago
@dumdumsaregood from the beginning jay kept telling that he is a girl in that song, how is that selling out?
vkinna 1 month ago
Hearing your music before...expected it to end differently. Loved it all the same!
somonesomeday 1 month ago
Comment removed
somonesomeday 1 month ago
Why isn't this more gay?
jordanthomasmusic 1 month ago
Definitely prefer the original from In Living Cover.
koolzies 1 month ago
AWESOME! Brilliant. And other very positive descriptive words. Hx
hilmartonnesen 1 month ago
Oh Jay. It's a shame you have to share justin bieber's initials because you just prove what real talent youtube has to offer
Karlene7 1 month ago
@Karlene7 SO TRUE
keepl0vealive 1 month ago
What a beautiful music video! Pre-ordering as soon as possible, I'm so excited you finally have a release date! Very much look forward to hearing the whole album!
MichelleRCarey 1 month ago
This video ended up a lot less gay than I thought it would be. I always imagined the song being about the girl in love with her gay best friend.
sayke 1 month ago 3
This is the best JB song !
timothywaterschen 1 month ago
AMAZING! can't wait for the whole album to come out!
louisalime 1 month ago
love the video!
eveydel 1 month ago
Good song, although videos seem to take away from your music; it's just too abstract and intelligent to be saddled with pedestrian images and storylines.
foxm007 1 month ago
Great stuff!
NobodysOffTheHook 1 month ago
Jay, don't stop making music. Damn. (Well, we all know you won't stop!)
xmaster2 1 month ago
Wish I knew you in person :P
JOSEtheHELPER 1 month ago
@JOSEtheHELPER he is a self obsessed dick. his music is great though.
treeoftears 1 month ago
@treeoftears where did you get that from?
cinnamo1 1 month ago
@treeoftears I didn't get that from his videos, but I like cockiness anyway.
JOSEtheHELPER 1 month ago
u're just amazing
threesist3rs 1 month ago
really nice.
prizm555 1 month ago
Gorgeous. All counts.
shakeystearoom 1 month ago
That was gorgeous. And I loved the video!
KiraAli 1 month ago
Love you and your songs Jay! Just Amazing!!! <3.....
GBEAR525 1 month ago
Awesome Jay! I can't wait for the rest of the CD! :)
NekochanSpidermonkey 1 month ago
@NekochanSpidermonkey I second that :)
Verahoel 1 month ago
♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥
shrena9062 1 month ago
"He was her long bright future in the middle of a wrong, dark road. He loved her, but he wasn't too sure if he could return the love she showed" #storyofmylife
IreentjeI 1 month ago in playlist Meer video's van jaybrannan 16
Thank you, Jay, for allowing me to fall in love with this song all over again
insomniacproductions 1 month ago 42
Great job, Jay. You're always impressing me, buster.
taylorg0613 1 month ago
Wow! Awesome!
EKDTRIST 1 month ago
click like* click add to favorites* click share on fb now click replay again ^_^
taintedmyst 1 month ago
You just made me cry ;) Awesome job! Loving it!
hubertcumberdale2008 1 month ago
Beautiful song, my new favorite.
sujiai 1 month ago
I love this song and the new arrangement is taking some getting used to.. not really fond of it after the first listen -- but I *am* very attached to the original acoustic version. one of my favourite songs of yours ♥
n3llyphant 1 month ago 3
I wish my hair stayed in place in bed like that!
PennyDreadfuI 1 month ago
This song saved my life. Loving the new parts added to the song, and LOVE the video!! Fantastic job :)
saratrue10 1 month ago
Awesome as always, I love you Jay. Looking forward to new album, about time! LOL
flwrmn65 1 month ago
Great video! 3
rebelprinceone 1 month ago
Loved it :D good job Jay.
Nimoot 1 month ago
Man I love your voice O.O
This totally made my day X3
Yaoimonk 1 month ago
that was gorgeous. loved it.
Tblackfacebook 1 month ago
Another cracker! Why aren`t you in the charts?
Twombug1 1 month ago
ah fuckkkk. great job jay!
cinnamo1 1 month ago
Love following you, Jay. We love your work!
greggors74 1 month ago
I LOVET it!!
vkinna 1 month ago
Can't have it all is still my favorite music video but I enjoyed this :)
voldemortssidekick 1 month ago
Fantastic! I didn't think you could improve upon the first version, but...there ya' go :) Can't wait for the album!
branb03 1 month ago
I have been waiting forever for a music video to this song!!! I <3 it!!!
ginnypooh13 1 month ago
gently, touching, excellent, thank you))) inspiration 2 u )))
MrJemchug 1 month ago
Loved It.
terry0710 1 month ago
i love you Jay
conbocuoi1996 1 month ago
<3 Love it!
janboudestijn 1 month ago
your voice <3
Toyman6000 1 month ago
Great video - Always loved this song!!
Netti2nite 1 month ago
wonderful - looking forward to see you in Cologne in May.
Buschelhase 1 month ago
Jay <3
jooztk 1 month ago