Lianto Tjahjoputro - Chaconne 1 - J.S. Bach(guitar)

[progressivelife]

it's a good performance. unlike most "musicians" today you actually say something with your guitar. Imho I do believe that some refinement will make it really amazing though, because it's a shame that the vague rhythm makes the energy drop completely and the fact that the notes are unclear makes it hard for us to hear what your trying to say. you have the musicality it's sad to see people misjudge you for such technicalities.

[miashred]

Lianto, I don't want to offend, but you are one of worst guitarists I've ever heard.

Your performances are embarrassing. Better if you remain in Indonesia. Here in Europe you can work in a circus as a clown, if you like.

Tell me honestly: do you think to be a talented musician?

[guitarwizard6]

Congratulations: you've managed to make a mockery of one of the musical monuments.

[nelson8gui]

Very good. You have a lot of talent et sencibility!!!

Continue Like this;-)

[aifosim2003]

è veramente triste essere testimoni di come un uomo possa aver sprecato in malo modo anni e anni della propria vita, è triste e ci indigna essere testimoni di come quella che un tempo fu una composizione musicale possa essere trasformata in un incomprensibile e inutile fastidio, sia per l'udito, sia per l'intelletto che per l'anima. Il povero Lianto non si rende neanche conto dell'orrore che produce, del raccapriccio, del totale vuoto che lo circonda. Fa pena.

aifosim2003 1 minuto fa

[aifosim2003]

è veramente triste essere testimoni di come un uomo possa aver sprecato in malo modo anni e anni della propria vita, è triste e ci indigna essere testimoni di come quello che un tempo fu una composizione musicale possa essere trasformato in un incomprensibile e inutile fastidio, sia per l'udito, sia per l'intelletto che per l'anima. Il povero Lianto non si rende neanche conto dell'orrore che produce, del raccapriccio, della totale vuoto che lo circonda. Fa pena.

[fenz4e]

my favorite song.

too many speed for you man

[TheTrooper424]

Beautiful piece of music.

[robby9212]

furthermore, you don't even hit all the notes from 3:16 onwards. it's riddled with mistakes. it's not even a song. oh my lord.. 4:20.. that's an utter nightmare. rather than picking each note you pull off like 3 fingers at a time very awkwardly and i can't hear anything but the soundtrack to a horror movie.

[robby9212]

with all due respect this is quite possibly the worst version of Chaconne played on the guitar I've ever heard. you rush way too much in the beginning, it's supposed to be a piece to dance to, and you turn it into something completely different. from 2:00 your additional notes make musical sense but it ends up dragging down the overall mood of the song, sluggish. when you hit that high note on 2:53 you don't let the melody sing, but rather rush into the next part.

[robby9212]

furthermore, you don't even hit all the notes from 3:16 onwards. it's riddled with mistakes. it's not even a song. oh my lord.. 4:20.. that's an utter nightmare. rather than picking each note you pull off like 3 fingers at a time very awkwardly and i can't hear anything but the soundtrack to a horror movie.

[robby9212]

furthermore, you don't even hit all the notes from 3:16 onwards. it's riddled with mistakes. it's not even a song. oh my lord.. 4:20.. that's an utter nightmare. rather than picking each note you pull off like 3 fingers at a time very awkwardly and i can't hear anything but the soundtrack to a horror movie.

[TwinkieRape]

@robby9212 true and all the apoyando sounds really harsh on this noble piece :(*

[ninaviolin6]

can you please stop tagging other professional players? it makes it quite frustrating looking for certain players and you come up. it isn't very professional. this is a good interpretation but please stop.

[robby9212]

@ninaviolin6 this is not a good version at all. see above comment.

[redmansounds]

Marvellous! Lianto you are wonderful....! What a player! You feel the music deep inside you, it's a joy to hear you, maestro. Love, Red x

[redmansounds]

Marvellous!

[OktoberStorm]

Det blir bare tull, for han kan jo ikke engang holde linja på noenting.

[faipas49]

i like your musicality, but i think the sound coming from your right hand is too thin. i also think you should focus in keeping your left hand more comfortable and with less tension, in difficult parts. but i guess this is just my point of view, and you have yours and your entire technique is already formed.. but it's just my opinion :p

[robby9212]

@faipas49 he's not musical at all, he sucks.

[posortiza]

fabulosa la interpretacion,nunca la habia escuchado gracias

[iankyoko]

I just watched him play Tocatta. Oh my God!

Instant fan I am!

But I agree with what someone else said here. I feel one fast passage didn't seem to work. But really, one shouldn't find fault.

I feel, overall, I am drawn along with his playing. He plays in a forceful and direct manner.

[1Freeman]

Nice stretch @ 5:16

[vetmath2]

your Chaconne is first-class, i think .

[farzamgt]

gooooooooooooooooooooood

[dresmith2]

The sound quality of the video doesn't do you justice... Very nice playing, even if someone else as said, the 32 nd notes are a bit sloppy. It's ok, this piece is tough on the violin, or any instrument for that matter.

[kikkom4n]

every instrument except the piano if it was just the violin version

[tetillaslorie]

Pero de donde ha salido el tio este. Es una ofensa a todos los estudiantes de guitarra. Por favor, no me extraña que no nos consideren como instrumento formal...

Post: piensen en ello

[rushwarp]

This is guy is a Segovia disciple. But he needs more work on his technique. Otherwise its pretty good.

[guitarwizard6]

The 32nd note scales are a mess and very unmusical. (I know how hard they are to play, though!)

[yandipur1]

you're correct ! it's really a pity that many beginners who gave the comment, couldn't hear that.... they only think that fast is good... but they forget that music is more than that.. music is not a race anyway....

[samuelkim1]

music would be disgusting if it was a race

[GinoTheSinner]

i want this on guitar pro

[az1zcolumbi]

i have it..

[toscallas]

Anyone who can play this piece live, is a great hero.

Your approach is very musical indeed and your technical level is of the highest order.

BRAVO !!

[yandipur1]

yang kasi komentar pemula semua ya, maka penilaiannya jadi kurang fair! menurut saya utk intepretasi permainan terlalu bebas, mungkin harus cari tahu dulu apa pengertian istilah chaconne itu & apa bedanya dengan passacaglia, pak?

[Liantotjahjoputro]

Biar tidak banyak mulut tapi gitarnya tidak bunyi. Gimana analisa hebatmu ttg Chaconne, Caprice 24 Toccata Fuga. Kaqmu mainkan di konser bersamaku aku babak pertama dan kamu yang mainnya lebih baik luarbiasa di babak ke 2. Atau masukkan aja mainmu Toccata Fuga dan masukkan ke youtube send ke aku. Seperti yang kulakukan akupun mengirim ke galina Vale, Yamashita dll Itu namanya Lianto tak banyak mulut tapi gitarnya masih bunyi.

[yandipur1]

Please don't be so childish, I want to know if you have a "certificate/diploma" from the Koeln music high school not just a "letter" from Eliot Fisk! Have you got it?????? You're not so welcome in Indonesia especially in Jakarta because of this. So don't tell the public lying anymore, okay ?

[Liantotjahjoputro]

I have never said to public that I had something like certificate or diploma. So, I have never lied to public, okay? ^ ^

[bloopcarder]

Hahaha, GRAMMAR much.

[RandomMocker]

How's your Indonesian grammar?

[Liantotjahjoputro]

@yandipur1 You are very proud about your Achens certificate, but in Indonesia, you even cant play anything than Adelita. How about recital duel meet with me? Lets play your five top difficult pieces and five tops mine. We each play ten pieces. Dont use any nickname. It just embarrasses your Achen.

[FirstMedia92]

nice big bro!

i like to watch awesome guitar concert...even i cant play guitar..TT

[Liantotjahjoputro]

I can not say anything. Thanks a lot for your attentions

[Liantotjahjoputro]

Thank you for your information for me. I will try better next concert if I play Chaconne again. I have many critic also if I saw my self in this performance to make better. Bye.....

[kikkom4n]

i feel that he plays a bit too fast.  just my opinion though.