Added: 5 years ago
From: byotch123
Views: 82,515
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (179)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i love her, OMG GONE GIRL, she is amazing ♥ 10/10

  • 1:20 is fab!

  • Damn girl! She sang the shit out of that!

  • That's how it's done folks.

  • Loving the way she sings it so differently live, God she's something! Just from looking at ratings for other artists, she has the fewest of ANY I've noticed yet!

  • I watched this on tv, and i think straight away, everybody can see the different between her and the contestants. the gap is huge.

  • @djobeat she had to grow up fast in everyway both personally and businesswize. And just think, there was more for her to break out of after this.

  • watch?v=YJ2sJH6HLLk

  • to me she will always be the best Idol winner, out of all the different countries Idols, she just always is amazing

  • Man she sounds amazing in this version...she killed it...she was the best idol winner...the girl has some serious pipes!!!!

  • she seems excited. but who wouldn't be if ur performing in front of an international audience.?

  • Kelly has gotten a lot better on this song as the years have gone by!! She looks like she was fighting for breath, lol, kinda like a fish. 3 = ) I LOVE HER THOUGH. I'm glad her voice has grown. Go Kell c:

  • @SwayIntheWind88 yeah i mean it was essentially the beginning of her career, and now she's a household name and has been about the only one to move beyond her AI title and be known as a GREAT artist

  • Wtf ?

    Did the camera man record this on his phone ?

    The only thing keeping me watching is kellys voice ..

  • Im thinking about going on australian idol but I dont really like the music that most of the idols realise

  • Kelly is  very good !

  • 1 of her best prformances EVER! Is it okay 2 say AMAZING?!

  • Comment removed

  • wow...she really brought shame on the Australian performers

  • Damnnn amazing performance I love it, especially 3:23 and beyond! The crowd are so excited by the end of it! :) Well done, Kelly! And love the new album.

  • 1:20 is my favorite part :) She's so beautiful

  • I really love her performance here, but it's a shame that you can barely hear the backup singers. The chorus sounds a little weird without them.

  • she is the best. love kelly

  • Kelly of course :-)

  • Very well done... :)

  • WHEN was this?

  • 2003 i think! guy.s era

  • Wow.. She really brought it in Australia..

    <33

  • 3:16 .. amazing, I like her voice.

  • She's very talented and beautiful too.Curvy figure , not like those anorexics girls around there.

  • Beautiful

  • Please don't say any yeapy yeapy things betwenn Christina and Kelly. They are so much different in music and i love them both.

  • shes got ass!

  • Kelly, YOU ROCK!

  • Incrívelllllllll

    a Kelly é demais...

  • LOL PLEASE aguilera aint shit to ms. clarkson,kelly clarkson owns this song THANK GOD i would not want to christina ruin it,i mean she is good but she isnt on kellys level,kelly would sing circles around her :)

  • completely true.

  • yeah dude so she can say oh yeah and vocalize a bunch that has nothing to do with the song?

  • yeah, in that kind of tone that sounds like she just drank a glass of milk? You know, singing from the back of her throat, making her sound like Marvin the Martian? Nah, I don't think that would sound to great for this song.

  • kelly did cover it well even though the ad lips aint working on the 1st chorus. haha. she proves she's the best american idol!

  • yeah kelly's a Pro!!! you guys should watch her sing Natural Woman on American Idol... now thats good!!!

  • i love it i was wondering is this when she was a contestant or after :d luve it ::D

  • this is after on austrailian idol

  • my song, lol

  • AMAZINGGGGGGGGGGGG!!!!!

  • did she forget or was that like a background vocal that she didnt have

  • no she didn't forget she was stopping her sentences so the backing vocals would've finished her lyrics that she broke off from singing... but there wasn't any back-up singers presents apparantly but there WAS a back-track or backing vocal of the actual song itself during the performance .. you can hear it in the performance if you listen carefully enough.. but the mixing of the back-track wasnt right or loud enough

  • why we keep judging kelly as a beginner she was profesinal then and she is profesional and an amazing singer and artist.

  • great, she sounds great!

  • here she is showing the aussies how its done.

    suck on that bitches.

  • This is POWER! xD

    Absolutely amazing.

  • yeah, she was a little off in the beginning with the chorus. she caught herself though and picked it back up

  • Wow this version is sexier than when she sang it on American Idol because her voice is sore. I like the ending.

  • i love her.

    shes susch a good singer, and shes so real.

  • she forgot some of the words lol

  • Singers do change the way they sing their songs...

  • jeez..you are an idiot

  • dam i love this song~~~ so much POWER!!! ^^

  • Christina did write a small part of this song, but the rest of it was written by Kelly and two other writers.

  • She lookz well diff now she lookz realli like older there:P x

  • kelly is soo hot from a womans point

  • She didn't forget the words. There were no background vocals or backup singers on this track and she had to sing everything herself.

    Also she wasn't sick. Kelly had vocal nodules from American Idol and the judges were amazed that she was even able to talk.

  • whats this mean?>vocal nodules from American Idol and the judges were amazed that she was even able to talk. :S ..i love her voice its so good!! i love her!!

  • What do you mean by 'whats this mean'? I think it explains its self.

    If you watch her performance of 'I Surrender' on AI, you'll hear the judges comments about her voice.

  • ok calm down it was just a question i did hear the judges comments on her prefromance of i surrender i just was asking what it meant because i didnt really know what they ment on that .. sorry?

  • Now what do you mean by calm down? All I did was ask what you do mean and say how I think my sentence explains its self.

    Google vocal nodules for more information.

  • What are vocal nodules?

    Just answer the question.

  • You took time to read my message and type your own when you could have looked it up for yourself.

    GET YOUR OWN ANSWER.

  • A vocal cord nodule is a small, inflammatory or fibrous growth that develops on the vocal cords of people who constantly strain their voices. These are also called screamer's nodule, singer's nodule and teacher's nodule. A vocal cord polyp is a small swelling in the mucous membranes covering the vocal cords. As they grow, they take on a rounded shape. They may run the whole length of the vocal cords or be localized.

  • A vocal cord nodule is a small, inflammatory or fibrous growth that develops on the vocal cords of people who constantly strain their voices. These are also called screamer's nodule, singer's nodule and teacher's nodule. A vocal cord polyp is a small swelling in the mucous membranes covering the vocal cords. As they grow, they take on a rounded shape. They may run the whole length of the vocal cords or be localized.

  • kelly is the best ! she is sooo pretty !

  • scary but good.....haha marsha was like full getting into it ehehhee

  • i love this song so much, im not sure i exactley understand the words going on and like what shes saying within the song, but i think thats what i love about her songs, is that u really have to think about the message behind them

  • during the chorus she sings the backing vocals and lets her bkacving track/vocalists sing the actual song!

    if that makes sense?

  • yeah you're right. its funny how people put thumbs down to your comment when you're the only person who is actually talking sense!

  • Kelly Brianne Clarkson is Amazing! her parents divoced when she was 6, she stayed with her mom. Mom remarried. She has a sister and a Brother. She won Idol in 2002. Her Birthday is April 24th 1982, and Her voice was found out in 7th grade by Cindy Glenn, her voice teacher. Who is Kelly Brianne Clarkson's Number 1 fan? Me! So just Step Off!

  • this is a truly brilliant performance! My favourite of her's is Aeosmith's Cryin'....it totally kicked ass!!!!! She should totally release an old school rock style album with influences of bands like bon jovi and aerosmith!

  • NO1 FAN OF KELLY WOOOOOOW

  • kelly & christina are 2 of my 3 fav singers so i love them both... kelly just a bit more though :D

    THAT WAS AN AWESOME PERFORMANCE!!

    and she'll be on Aus Idol on monday!!!!

  • she really is a worthy of her title, as the first Idol. She's awesome here, she rocked that song!

  • Kelly is amazing. I like her better then Xtina Kelly is hot as. Her voice is SEXAY

  • kelly rocks! natural talent!

  • Cool Kelly came to Australia, i must of missed that. .hmmm. She rocks yes!!

  • I don't think so, Kelly Clarkson is great and she doesn't over use liks like christina aguilera does. She actually puts feeling into her music, Christina just likes to show off her vocal aerobics, thats my opinion. But i'm not against anyone who likes christina. Like i said thats just my opinion. :-) not having a go

  • I agree with Heidiscope; both singers are amazing, but Kelly puts more feeling in. Although I think Christina has better control and accuracy; she takes care of her voice, which Kelly has neglected to do lately :(

  • different style~~~

  • Kelly did not steal MI; Christina half-wrote the song, then decided she didn't want it anymore, and the other writer of the song went and offered it to Kelly. Blame Christina for the "theft" if you must blame someone.

  • I love how she did the end. I like that she changed it up a bit, it sounds great!!

  • OK...EVERYONE SHUTUP!!!thats just how some people do their own songs...everyones supposed to have their own style and heres hers, plus u try and sing that high and hard and then just switch into something soft and low...its HARD!!!!...Dont critisize KELLY !!!!!!

  • How can you say that? Kelly has an amazing voice!! So what she has to sound like Christina to get creditability?? Christina wrote that song for her. If she wanted to sing it herself she would have.. Plus Christina has had vocal training since she became famous.. Give Kell another few years and she will be the same!!

  • Kelly has been trained classically. Haven't you ever heard footage of her warming up? Amazing!! Her arpegios and scales are like that of an opera singer. The girl CHOOSES to sing the way she does, and she turns it off and on at her disposal. Perhaps people do have to be musicians to get this stuff, I don't know. I read so much wrong crap about her voice. Not saying your post was bad, just letting you know she has just a good of a voice already, she just chooses to use it differently.

  • chrisangelo2k7: and yu cant compare kelly clarkson to someone shes not.

  • Brilliant!!!

  • she did not forget her words , i know the lyrics, the parts where she delayed, she did it on purpose( maybe for backstage singers.) she still rox

  • she's amazing!!

  • luv her singing voice here!! luv kelly she rocks

  • Sometimes they leave some words out of the song to make it shorter. But I don't know if they did it here. Kelly is the best.

  • god, what are you guys saying. this is one of her best performances, her voice sounds perfectly clear and loud and high and i love her so much.

  • what are you talking about??? she can not control her voice?! oO maybe you should watch another video and then you can critizes her -.-

  • lol..are you deaf? You obviously are not a muscian.

  • lmao!  What the hell are you talking about?

  • hmm...that is why randy and simon keep saying that she is more talented, in a different league..hmm...yeah, I think you need to suck it up and admit you don't know crap about vocals. You are really off the mark.

  • no she didn't she did that on purpose

  • .. she forgot her words on purpose?

    yeah, i see your logic there.

  • Whatever, she's ok..she doesn't have big thighs and if she did so wat, it doesn't matter if you didn't c her on AUS idol and ++ yes..rock doesn't suit her voice....

  • she seems to have caught flu in this live version

  • Kell rocks. She is so pretty!

  • she should stick to this type of music and give up the rock.

    Rock doesnt suit her voice.

  • wow the best performance!! i luv her voice here....songs strong and clear!!

  • she sounds bad.

  • no offence but, her thighs look alil big on da show, but i still lvoe her voice xD

  • i watch AustralianIdol religiously and i don't remember kelly clarkson ever performing on there. i would if she did coz kelly clarkson is my fave artist of all time and miss independent is 1 of my fave songs of all time, but the sign does say Australian idol and throughout the performance you can see the australian idol judges mark, marcia and dicko.

  • She was just performing in that show. Like she did on other Idol shows.

  • if you fought war with your singing voice, kelly would have conquered most of the world.

  • I thort this was american idol? Wait.. The sign says australia... I don't get it.

  • she's performing for the Australian Idol final i think;)

  • she sounds like she has a cold but shes still GREAT...Im from her HOMETOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • SHES GREAT

  • I love Kelly and Carrie.Their my favorite idols.

  • Awesome!

  • ahahah

    American idol.. not Australian idol

    check out Anthony CAllea...he's frm Australian idol

    and hes awesome!!!(Y)

  • OMG she is so awesome... her and p!nk are my fav female artists.... man they almost catchup to metalica nd breaking benjamin but in a different way, and thats saying something lol

  • I think she's got a cold! Her voice is a bit salty...

  • Kelly Is Great ... But I LOVE Carrie Underwood

  • nobody care whether U like carrie underwear or not.

  • lol

    KELLY CLARKSON ROX!

  • lovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeeee her voice!

  • Big news! It was announced on 04/26/07 that Kelly is going to tour North America in the Summer of 2007!

  • love that girl. :)

  • her voice was so weird in here. not bad but weird. i've never heard her sing like this. she kinda tried to make her voice something that it's not.

  • she sounds kinda sick... like she has a cold or something

  • yep.but she's still great. so.

  • she probably had a million performances to do, what explains her sore throat..

  • yep, i´still lo´ve her to death.

  • doesn't matter if she has a sore throat.. listen to little parts.. it was so perfect..

  • she changed some parts. very cool.

  • kelly is sooooo good live. :D

  • She sounds different here. She sounds good.

  • I like her voice, is so strong and has power, and match with her rosk style while singing, she is the best Idol because she has conquer a lot of fans around the world, greetings from southamerica.

  • Was this creatied by Simon Fuller and Nigel and them?

  • OH my god she was good. . .but I don't think she can do better than the aol version. . . I hope she hasn't lost her voice. . may be she hasn't. . .but her voice is always that. . unclear now

  • I remember watching this, i heard miss independent before but wasnt really into it until i saw this episode. was this her first trip to Australia? And yeah it was season one.

  • this is the same thing as American Idol but different ppl exept Kelly

  • Now that's what i'm talking about. Man she's sooooooo damn good. I love her rich sultry voice. Beautiful!!!! Gr8 post!

  • ITS CAUSE SHE CAN ACTUALLY SING

  • Um...since when did American Idol winner go on Australian Idol?? I never saw this on Aussie Idol!

  • why is she at Australien Idol, didn´t she won american idol?

  • This was after her win on American Idol!!! She is singing her first hit from her Idol debut!!!

  • thanks SO much for posting this.. I missed this episode and I was so cut about it! She is definately the best idol ever.. She blows me away everytime she performs something. I was crying at her concert cause it was amazing!! YAY KELLY!!! Love you heaps from Aussie!! xoxoxoxox

  • This was season one. The lights were configured differently in season two (they were moved into a diagonal spike arrangement, in season one they were in horizontal clusters like you see here.)

  • christina aguilera have written that songs with kelly!!

  • acually it was season 1, with guy and cosima and all that coz i remember coz i have a mag wif her and all the contestants behind the scense.

  • filochikstah, that was season 2, i know that coz i was overseas at the time and thats y i dont remeba seeing this

    i think kelly is awesome! SHE WOULD HAVE TO BE THE BEST IDOL EVA! that was an absolutley dynamite performance.

  • No, no, season 1 2003, which was when Kelly came to Oz to promote her debut album, around the time when this song was released.

  • she sounds quite raspy and out of breath lol... but yet good lol

  • no she doesn't.

  • smooothhhh!!!!