It's actually both. TB sections should pronounce baTTle while the treble parts give a smooth baDDle, so this choir interpreted it wrong because the song should have a march feel to it, and the t's would make it much more percussive. The choir has a great sound though.
@petr1991 There are so many interpretations on how to enunciate this song. To judge this one "wrong" is just wrong. I think they did a very fine job.
btw, my church choir just did it yesterday (glorifying religious war on Easter in a progressive church, much to my chagrin) and the version we have uses corrected grammar "CAME tumbling down" and "battle IS in my hand". Is that wrong? Or is the older one? Neither.
I was perhaps a bit direct, I do agree with you that interpretation...just for the sake of the meaning of the word, cannot really be wrong. However, I'm not really concerned with how anything is pronounced; it just so happens that the result of the pronunciation has an effect on the song performance. It's supposed to have a march feel, and when you have the men pronounce battle while the women do baddle, it creates that effect and that's one of the huge points of the song.
Again, no disrespect to you or this group. Frankly, I think the group is fantastic ... but the question was asked by many people so I just answered based on how it's written.
I know moses hogan supposedly wanted it to be enunciated with the T's but along with many other interpretations on youtube (which doesn't make them right I know) we decided the d sound worked a bit better for us.
They're awesome. I agree that soprano was a little off... idk what happened there but otherwise they sounded great to me.
Amarisyearby 3 days ago
awesome :)
spazzattack307 4 months ago
them damn tenors r on point...great blend
jsu1king2 4 months ago
It's actually both. TB sections should pronounce baTTle while the treble parts give a smooth baDDle, so this choir interpreted it wrong because the song should have a march feel to it, and the t's would make it much more percussive. The choir has a great sound though.
petr1991 10 months ago
@petr1991 There are so many interpretations on how to enunciate this song. To judge this one "wrong" is just wrong. I think they did a very fine job.
btw, my church choir just did it yesterday (glorifying religious war on Easter in a progressive church, much to my chagrin) and the version we have uses corrected grammar "CAME tumbling down" and "battle IS in my hand". Is that wrong? Or is the older one? Neither.
Baritone45 9 months ago
@Baritone45
I was perhaps a bit direct, I do agree with you that interpretation...just for the sake of the meaning of the word, cannot really be wrong. However, I'm not really concerned with how anything is pronounced; it just so happens that the result of the pronunciation has an effect on the song performance. It's supposed to have a march feel, and when you have the men pronounce battle while the women do baddle, it creates that effect and that's one of the huge points of the song.
petr1991 9 months ago
@Baritone45
Again, no disrespect to you or this group. Frankly, I think the group is fantastic ... but the question was asked by many people so I just answered based on how it's written.
petr1991 9 months ago
The voices blend perfectly. But dynamics? /:
MissMetroful 10 months ago
I'd like to hear what this sounds like in our choir now
Godlyspirit50 11 months ago
ow the poor soprano, she wasn't in her best form :/
Ayauesca 11 months ago
2:06 - 2:10 are my favorite parts
abacus263 1 year ago
the tone of the notes is lovely, but there are no dynamics and the pronunciation sounds like middle schoolers.
musicisinmeforever 1 year ago
the soprano that hit the high c is flat..
GuitarNerd77 1 year ago
It seems very lifeless....
Zephler 1 year ago 3
no sole
romlizard 1 year ago
Where are the dynamics?
IHudson 1 year ago
I like the voices very much, but I think, it's too slow for this piece. Anyway, excellent!
Stimmbande 2 years ago
AWSOME!!! LOVE IT :D
NaruXHina4life 2 years ago
baTTle... or baddle?
CalebNihira 2 years ago 4
baddle
Glaesz28UwO 2 years ago
I know moses hogan supposedly wanted it to be enunciated with the T's but along with many other interpretations on youtube (which doesn't make them right I know) we decided the d sound worked a bit better for us.
Glaesz28UwO 2 years ago