The first time I watched this, I hadn't even known what the clips were about. I think it's been two years since I first heard this song. When I watched Doctor Who, seriously, it was like a flip was switched and I was like, "Oh! That song fits PERFECTLY!"
I think that one of the reasons I love your videos so much is because instead of washing out the past and colouring the present, like so many misguided people do, you focus on the past being happy and bright, therefore coloured, and the present being dark and faded. Well, that and these videos are so kick ass.
Miss Ten. Though and more so as the change had to take place and it speaks for David Tennant that he chose to leave the series at the exact right point for HIS incarnation of the Doc. Matt Smith's great but I'm still a bit nostalgic time and again.
Miss Ten. Though and more so as the change had to take place and it speaks for David Tennant that he chose to leave the series at the exact right point for HIS incarnation of the Doc. Matt Smith's great but I'm still a bit nostalgic time and again.
This is wonderful! I was just looking for "They weren't there" and found this and was super happy! I love the doctor, David Tennant's my favorite, and Rose was by far my favorite of his companions. Thank you! :)
I'm just now turning into a Whovian, and I recently watched Rose's last episode (technically episodes, but you get the jist) and I CRIED like a BABY. Omigod. It's was so bittersweet. I now understand why the other fans hate Donna so much. I still kinda like Martha, but neither of them will ever be Rose. :'(
I got this song stuck in my head last night for no apparent reason so i decided to come watch your vid again since it was the first place i heard it. and i must say i'm a real sucker for this one. its just fits so well? i dunno. i just love it. my favourite bit is " they weren't stripped till they were bare of any bindings from the world outside that room" especially "that room" oh how i'm going to miss that room and that doctor :( just thought i'd let you know how much i still love this one :)
@seduff i watched the other video and i think i get it. i think im definitely going to have to start from the beginning cause rose's era looks like it will be amazing to watch. thanks!
@cycoG That's ok. :) Rose and the Doctor were fighting the Daleks and Cybermen at Torchwood (sucking them into the void) Rose lost her grip and was being pulled in too, but her alternate universe father saved her just before she was lost. However she ended up in the other universe, unable to return. It was heart-wrenching at the time. I have a video "My Immortal" which has a longer scene of it if you're interested. :P (see related videos) As that most likely made no sense whatsoever. lol.
It's incredibly sad that i got teary eyed watching this. I get really upset whenever i think of Rose, and this combined with this song, it kind of did it for me. Such a great video.
Ive watched this billions of times before, but i thought id just tell you that im boiling right now, but twenty seconds into the video and i had the shivers :)
i love this song, accept the fact that its about a guy kinda makes my stomach turn. straight and bi people only do...that to be cool. poor people, i pity them. there is really no such thing as straight...i feel so sorry that they stoop to such a level for popularity. love happens between a woman and a woman. men are disgusting!
this is one of my fav songs from missy, i wish more people would learn of her, cuz she deserves to be at the top of the charts, US, AUS & UK alot more & in some cases for the first time than she has been. she is brilliant, saw her live in america last year, wow!
@justcallmejoe It totally sucks this new youtube where if your in a certain country you cant watch this video or that & cant as you say upload a track over your videos with out youtube taking the track off or atleast banning it from some countries, Missy is a talent & should have world wide fame already. Youtube is a BIG key to that happening. I hope enough people just happen to find her stuff, like over this Dr who vid, ideal, Dr Who is massive. Many followers.
This song is so pretty! I love the piano playing. If I can get the sheet music, believe me, I will! My favorite part is from "But I was alive and now I've downed...all the way to...So I could say no."
This was the first video of yours I watched, such a long time ago. They get better and better, but this one will always be one of my favorites... and since I first heard it in your video, "They Weren't There" has been one of my favorite songs.
I've said this before about your videos (you probably don't remember, what with the sensational amount of (deserved) feedback you get!), but this really, really feels brand new. I used to watch it a lot and hadn't for a while until today, but it's just so fresh and amazing that it feels like you've updated it recently and changed things to give an even better impact.
I love this video so, so much. The lyrics of "They Weren't There" make me think that Missy Higgins MUST have got inspiration ...
... (continued) from Doctor Who. I can't listen to this song without thinking of Rose and her story. All of the words fit perfectly with the clips. I absolutely love the bit when she's running towards Jackie and the music gets a bit louder and it all slows down; it's so intense and makes me want to cry!
All-in-all, my favourite Doctor/Rose video. Truly.
I'm using this video as inspiration for a song. I have the sound off and am watching the imagery...and just playing along. I'll post a video response soon :) <3
AngelofSong89: Oh i hadn't even noticed. :) That's wonderful. Happy anniversary 'Rose's Story'... he he *throws confetti* (it's still one of my personal faves) x
I cried throughout the whole of that like a big baby! It was amazingly beuatiful and the song was simply perfect, it was one of them vids that as soon as it starts you know you'e going to end up crying to it. I was welling up as soon as he said Rose and i just started crying when they were standing there on that planet, just smiling at each other totally in love, thinking it would last forever.....
jEnNiFeRaNiStOnRoCkZ: Oh thanks so much. *passes tissues* This is one of my personal favourites. That song still even gets to me. It's just so very 'Rose' :)
Lol yeah totally, I got this song on ma ipod now, its one of ma favs, its beautiful. I've just watched this and I'm watching it again lol, the lyrics mean so much. I mean 'You breathed infinity into my world.' That alone has The Doctor and Rose written all over it. (: This is one of ma favs on youtube, its incredible xxx
I had to comment again... Before I watched this video I had never heard this song before, so I wwnt and listened to the song someplace else, and I realized that you had edited it. I must say, you did a fantastic job with that. I only notice because I know the lyrics.
Ever since i heard this song, i knew it was meant for Rose's Story. I mean... "you breathed infinity into my world"... who else could it be for. :) x Thanks again.
fireflyastori: *watches again to find out*.... Oh that shot is from Runaway Bride. Series 3 with the Arachnos. (i think that's how you spell it! ...lol) :) x
I was wondering if there is a different version of this song because I downloaded one but it had different lyrics and it was less accousticy than this version.
And they weren't stripped 'till they were bare of
Any bindings from the world outside that room.
And they weren't taken by the hand
And led through fields of naked land
Where any pre-conceived ideas were blown away...
So I couldn't say "no". "
How did you find such a perfect song? Just when I thought those Doctor/Rose vids were just the same in the end... beautiful, one notices you really felt with and thought about the story. Thanks, very beautiful!
FlickSarestes: What a wonderful comment thankyou so much. :) I don't get to watch this one much anymore. But when i do, i remember why its one of my favourites. I just had to make this to Rose. The words were so perfect, how could 'I say no'...
I think I've commented before, but I really have to again. Everyday I watch this video, it's like a tradition now! I love it so much! The audio effects, were, I don't know what to say! The word "Mindblowing" doesn't live up to it! But my paticular fave would be near the end with them laughing. The echo/fade effect there was amazing and gave it real dept and an almost dream-like effect. Altogether fantastic! *big Doctor grin!*
AsarathWitch: Thankyou so much! I love that you watch it so often. :) It is such a beautiful song for Rose ... i am glad i managed to do it justice. I love the look the Dr gives at 3.04... heartwrenching. Sarah x
10MrsDavidTennant10: I use Final Cut on Mac OSX. :D So glad you like it. I love this song for Rose. It's so beautiful in it's simplicity. (just like her) :) x
You truly have a gift when you came bring a person to tears in less than four minutes. Actually, less than that. I started crying half way through. No words can describe how beautiful this was.
This is so beautiful and sad, and yet, it leaves me with a smile for all the good times they had together. I always loved how they made each other a better person, and how they enriched each others lives. And I bow to you you and thank you for getting exactly that across so calmly and beautifully.
I just love this songs simplicity and had to match the images to that. I felt the song was perfect for her relationship with the Doctor. How could she say 'no' ? Eventhough it changed her life forever, she would never change a moment. xx :)
I quite agree about the song - I hadn't heard it before, but its simplicity and calmness is just so perfect. And I know exactly what you mean about Rose - it's one of the reasons why I adored her so much. She was always her own person. But I'll stop before I go on about this for hours again. ;-)
(I couldn't have said 'no', either. Who could? :-) )
OMG, simply amazing. So sad, so beautiful, so fitting... I love the whole video and I love the Doctor&Rose - they were just pure perfection, you captured their story incredibly well: all the sorrow and what they meant to each other... I think I'm going to cry now... Really great video! You're very talented!
Thanks so much! I really try to make them as pleasing to view as possible. Otherwise i would be sick to death of them by now! LOL Thanks again... Sarah :) xx
Wow way to go, this really fit Rose, and it got me all choked up. Keep making more videos, you have an awesome idea of what music and scenes to put together; it really pulls at the heart strings.
It really is amazing, you have such a talent! :) Yeah I can't believe it hasn't had more views, it deserves so many more, If u don't mind I'll put it on my video log, to advertise it, more people need to see this! xx
oh wow, this was just beautiful,. u even used the clips i thought would match in my head whenever i hear this. loved the editing, the fading to another clip effect. this is my fave vid with this song. :)
That was absolutely the most beautiful video I have seen of this duo- I have never cried in a video before and I am not ashamed that I did- this was perfect. Thankyou! What program do you use to edit- I use Sony Vegas but I couldn't really tell with yours, it was so seamless!:)
I'm getting worried that your going to get bored of me telling you that your video was awesometastically amazing. But....I'll say it anyways! It was awesometastically amazing!!! and I can't wait for you to make more! hmmm, you should use another Micha song, your last one was the best!
I sing this song all the time im thinking about puting this song on YouTube but me singing it.
tiddymcfiddy 4 weeks ago
the start looks like avatar when they change bodies o.0
heyAtom3 2 months ago
@heyAtom3 lol thats what i thought too 0.o
heyAtom3 2 weeks ago
Don't mind me. Just bawling my eyes out over here.
guitargirly66 2 months ago 2
i dont know if its this song or what, but every time i here it, i get so emotional and end up crying my eyes out
chloeLverc 3 months ago
Have you got a link for this song? It is so beautiful but i cannot find it ANYWHERE!!!:(
Salvatoredanceoholic 4 months ago
i never really liked rose, but omg did you make me cry D:
darkeyblade 5 months ago
Wow, I never even noticed how well this song fits with the Doctor and Rose. Great job! :)
YourSweetOblivion 8 months ago
I cried! They loved each other, but it shouldn´t be =(
Thanks for the video!
vanessahdepp1 9 months ago
So sweet! Even if I'm not a Rose fan... but I titally support the whole vid thing because it seems you're as pro Ten/Rose as I am Eleven/River.
BroadwayTimeTraveler 9 months ago
This is beautiful. It breaks my heart every time.
readingginbed 10 months ago
The first time I watched this, I hadn't even known what the clips were about. I think it's been two years since I first heard this song. When I watched Doctor Who, seriously, it was like a flip was switched and I was like, "Oh! That song fits PERFECTLY!"
Good job!
DassMorris 10 months ago
I think that one of the reasons I love your videos so much is because instead of washing out the past and colouring the present, like so many misguided people do, you focus on the past being happy and bright, therefore coloured, and the present being dark and faded. Well, that and these videos are so kick ass.
Thoroughbred17 1 year ago
This is perfect. I've watched it twice and have yet to stop crying. A perfect song for Rose and the Doctor. Brilliant!
Barrelburner37 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Miss Ten. Though and more so as the change had to take place and it speaks for David Tennant that he chose to leave the series at the exact right point for HIS incarnation of the Doc. Matt Smith's great but I'm still a bit nostalgic time and again.
FlickSarestes 1 year ago
Miss Ten. Though and more so as the change had to take place and it speaks for David Tennant that he chose to leave the series at the exact right point for HIS incarnation of the Doc. Matt Smith's great but I'm still a bit nostalgic time and again.
FlickSarestes 1 year ago
This is wonderful! I was just looking for "They weren't there" and found this and was super happy! I love the doctor, David Tennant's my favorite, and Rose was by far my favorite of his companions. Thank you! :)
waterpixie18 1 year ago
I'm just now turning into a Whovian, and I recently watched Rose's last episode (technically episodes, but you get the jist) and I CRIED like a BABY. Omigod. It's was so bittersweet. I now understand why the other fans hate Donna so much. I still kinda like Martha, but neither of them will ever be Rose. :'(
varietychick 1 year ago
@varietychick Donna's actually quite charming after she comes back as a companion. At least in my opinion. But Rose was great.
muppetnut 1 year ago
@muppetnut Yeah, I like her now that I've watched her more.
varietychick 1 year ago
Finally a song with the studio version of They weren't there. Thanks so much for posting this xxx
xForeverxDayx 1 year ago
"But they weren't there beneath your stare,
And they weren't stripped 'till they were bare of
Any bindings from the world outside that room. "
perfect. so perfect.
rasselas16 1 year ago
Wow, first time I've heard this song. Heartbreaking video <3
eighttimesacharm 1 year ago
absolutely beautiful. you are a gifted one Seduff for making these videos :)
MajorTom1993 1 year ago
Beautiful, thats all I can say. Beautiful.
blackdragonrider3 1 year ago
beautifull!!!!! =)
maudwezenbergg 1 year ago
LOL
so weird
TrappedNation 1 year ago
Anja, this one! Big tears and loud laughter and Miami:) WOW!!!
MiaMurrieta 1 year ago
this song is beautiful
EmilyIsCool09 2 years ago 3
I got this song stuck in my head last night for no apparent reason so i decided to come watch your vid again since it was the first place i heard it. and i must say i'm a real sucker for this one. its just fits so well? i dunno. i just love it. my favourite bit is " they weren't stripped till they were bare of any bindings from the world outside that room" especially "that room" oh how i'm going to miss that room and that doctor :( just thought i'd let you know how much i still love this one :)
0x3mmix0 2 years ago 2
@seduff i watched the other video and i think i get it. i think im definitely going to have to start from the beginning cause rose's era looks like it will be amazing to watch. thanks!
cycoG 2 years ago 8
total noob question, but i havent been watching since the beginning - why did rose have to go away to an alternate universe or whatever?
cycoG 2 years ago
@cycoG That's ok. :) Rose and the Doctor were fighting the Daleks and Cybermen at Torchwood (sucking them into the void) Rose lost her grip and was being pulled in too, but her alternate universe father saved her just before she was lost. However she ended up in the other universe, unable to return. It was heart-wrenching at the time. I have a video "My Immortal" which has a longer scene of it if you're interested. :P (see related videos) As that most likely made no sense whatsoever. lol.
seduff 2 years ago 7
It's incredibly sad that i got teary eyed watching this. I get really upset whenever i think of Rose, and this combined with this song, it kind of did it for me. Such a great video.
porcupine179 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
I love this song!
1cjl2 2 years ago
I favorited and bought this song immediately after seeing this video. I mean, it was MADE for DW. Seriously.
Love this video and all of your videos, keep on making them!
*watches this vid ten more times*
pinkchan831 2 years ago
Ive watched this billions of times before, but i thought id just tell you that im boiling right now, but twenty seconds into the video and i had the shivers :)
IXIrandomIXIgirlIXI 2 years ago 2
could you send this AMAZING song to me, please? This video rules, btw! x
xPrincessKx 2 years ago 2
missy higgins - wernt there x
FrancesscaJennings 2 years ago
amazing
i love billie!
zoaroonie 2 years ago
so beautiful...
nickbakermusiclover 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
i love this song, accept the fact that its about a guy kinda makes my stomach turn. straight and bi people only do...that to be cool. poor people, i pity them. there is really no such thing as straight...i feel so sorry that they stoop to such a level for popularity. love happens between a woman and a woman. men are disgusting!
TrinityBloodRox 2 years ago
That is your opinion.
jAMiiE3X0O 2 years ago 6
If that's your opinion, then fair enough. :) But personally, I don't think Rose was worrying about how popular she was when she cried on that beach.
xxDalekBreadxx 2 years ago 4
this is one of my fav songs from missy, i wish more people would learn of her, cuz she deserves to be at the top of the charts, US, AUS & UK alot more & in some cases for the first time than she has been. she is brilliant, saw her live in america last year, wow!
saucymare 2 years ago 21
@saucymare This is easily my favorite song from Missy.
On youtube for example, her tracks not allowed to be uploaded.
It is very tough promoting her music when her songs don't exist on youtube.
Youtube is THE key internet source for promoting one's music.
Those who hold the rights to her music, should really re-consider this.
justcallmejoe 5 months ago
@justcallmejoe It totally sucks this new youtube where if your in a certain country you cant watch this video or that & cant as you say upload a track over your videos with out youtube taking the track off or atleast banning it from some countries, Missy is a talent & should have world wide fame already. Youtube is a BIG key to that happening. I hope enough people just happen to find her stuff, like over this Dr who vid, ideal, Dr Who is massive. Many followers.
saucymare 5 months ago
@saucymare I agree.
However, this particular video slipped by them.
If they find it, they'll remove the audio track from it.
This version of the song is amazing, but its the Australian version that takes this song over the top.
This song comes with an attack of overwhelmingly amazing background vocals near the end of the song.
I wish i could show you what i mean, but the track does not exist on youtube.
justcallmejoe 5 months ago
This song is beautiful. Can you send the song to me?
snailrawkz 2 years ago 2
me too please :)
aah i love it <3
littlestrangy 2 years ago
Still my fave, Sarah, without a doubt.
AsarathWitch 2 years ago
This song is so pretty! I love the piano playing. If I can get the sheet music, believe me, I will! My favorite part is from "But I was alive and now I've downed...all the way to...So I could say no."
ScientificoPiano 2 years ago
This was the first video of yours I watched, such a long time ago. They get better and better, but this one will always be one of my favorites... and since I first heard it in your video, "They Weren't There" has been one of my favorite songs.
DoctorCharmer 2 years ago
does anyone have this song as an mp3? could they send it to me?
fionaelizabethx 2 years ago
Yep fionaelizabethx i can send you it, if you want. Have you got MSN or Yahoo IM?
MrsTeninch 2 years ago
Don't suppose you could send it to me too, could you? XD Sorry, shouldn't be bothering you.
I have an MSN IM and email.
AsarathWitch 2 years ago
Brilliant...again!
Moonlightshadow9314 2 years ago
WOW
XtremeChristian 3 years ago
Oh that's beautiful! You should do a video like this with Nine included, as well. <3
HeelsOverHeadxxx 3 years ago
Nice video.. But you repeated half of it in another video.. Got a little boring to be honest. Nice editing though.
Floweeeerr 3 years ago
This is one of my favourites from youtube it's beautilful
xXxXxcozzaxXxXx 3 years ago
Ahh you made me cry. Great video.
tanguera33 3 years ago
you got me crying. if a Doctor Who Video makes me cry that means it good. And yours was WODERFUL!!!!
curlywavy18 3 years ago
I've said this before about your videos (you probably don't remember, what with the sensational amount of (deserved) feedback you get!), but this really, really feels brand new. I used to watch it a lot and hadn't for a while until today, but it's just so fresh and amazing that it feels like you've updated it recently and changed things to give an even better impact.
I love this video so, so much. The lyrics of "They Weren't There" make me think that Missy Higgins MUST have got inspiration ...
sommersprechen 3 years ago
... (continued) from Doctor Who. I can't listen to this song without thinking of Rose and her story. All of the words fit perfectly with the clips. I absolutely love the bit when she's running towards Jackie and the music gets a bit louder and it all slows down; it's so intense and makes me want to cry!
All-in-all, my favourite Doctor/Rose video. Truly.
sommersprechen 3 years ago
I really love this one too
It inspired me for a pic with Rose ^^
thank you so much for the great work you do each time !!!
misscynthia17 3 years ago
magical!
topliff12345 3 years ago
I'm using this video as inspiration for a song. I have the sound off and am watching the imagery...and just playing along. I'll post a video response soon :) <3
tonjesml 3 years ago
There are just songs that say "doctor and rose" that's one of them.. Great Work on the vid!!
WhisperLuna 3 years ago
It's entitled "They Weren't There" from the album "The Sound of White"
iliveibreathe 3 years ago
I just noticed I watched this today exactly one year after it was posted. just thought i'd share. it's a beautiful vid. thanks.
AngelofSong89 3 years ago 2
AngelofSong89: Oh i hadn't even noticed. :) That's wonderful. Happy anniversary 'Rose's Story'... he he *throws confetti* (it's still one of my personal faves) x
seduff 3 years ago
The chorus is so so perfect for Rose... and the video is amazing!
zotlot 3 years ago 2
Love it. There is Rose's story in every word of the song. And you have once again fit the music and clips together in such a beautiful way...
merihaikara 3 years ago
I cried throughout the whole of that like a big baby! It was amazingly beuatiful and the song was simply perfect, it was one of them vids that as soon as it starts you know you'e going to end up crying to it. I was welling up as soon as he said Rose and i just started crying when they were standing there on that planet, just smiling at each other totally in love, thinking it would last forever.....
5/5 dosen't begin to cover it, awesome (: xx
jEnNiFeRaNiStOnRoCkZ 3 years ago 4
jEnNiFeRaNiStOnRoCkZ: Oh thanks so much. *passes tissues* This is one of my personal favourites. That song still even gets to me. It's just so very 'Rose' :)
seduff 3 years ago
Lol yeah totally, I got this song on ma ipod now, its one of ma favs, its beautiful. I've just watched this and I'm watching it again lol, the lyrics mean so much. I mean 'You breathed infinity into my world.' That alone has The Doctor and Rose written all over it. (: This is one of ma favs on youtube, its incredible xxx
jEnNiFeRaNiStOnRoCkZ 3 years ago
@jEnNiFeRaNiStOnRoCkZ Missys music is beautiful :)
saucymare 5 months ago
This was beautifully done the song goes really well and the right clips were chosen, well done keep up the good work x x x
CCSNO1FAN 3 years ago
i love this video. it makes me cry every time i see it. who sings this song? i just love how this song goes with the doctor and rose's relationship.
katebien 3 years ago
I had to comment again... Before I watched this video I had never heard this song before, so I wwnt and listened to the song someplace else, and I realized that you had edited it. I must say, you did a fantastic job with that. I only notice because I know the lyrics.
MissJedi 3 years ago
I have to agree--the editing is wonderful. And the song is amazingly perfect for Rose. This video is so beautiful.
AmaranthineSomnuim 3 years ago
I think that really fits Rose... It's just so perfect, describing how she was feeling and what it was like with the Doctor. This video is amazing.
MissJedi 3 years ago 2
Ever since i heard this song, i knew it was meant for Rose's Story. I mean... "you breathed infinity into my world"... who else could it be for. :) x Thanks again.
seduff 3 years ago
it was grate i think rose is the best and tomorro she is back in it cant wait o and i love david
nickg3865 3 years ago
Beautifully made (as usual). Love it! :-) 5/5
EllenRebecca3 3 years ago 2
wow that was beautiful! seriously! you are the best and i mean BEST video maker ever! honestly i mean that from the heart! :) this is amazing! x
Spoiltlilprincess 3 years ago 2
Great video. Faved and five-starred. Very good.
Though... something is bothering me... Where is 1:47 from? I can't recall that scene at all for some reason.
fireflyastori 3 years ago
fireflyastori: *watches again to find out*.... Oh that shot is from Runaway Bride. Series 3 with the Arachnos. (i think that's how you spell it! ...lol) :) x
seduff 3 years ago
close seduff, it was The Rachnoss
SDvsRaw2008Fan 3 years ago
he he he... well... i was thinking of arachnids. LOL...si i was on the right track :D x
seduff 3 years ago
hey :)
I was wondering if there is a different version of this song because I downloaded one but it had different lyrics and it was less accousticy than this version.
x
xmyonlyhopex 3 years ago 2
faved, 5 stars and downloading the song right now!
this is so perfect with rose, it really goes with her adventures!
i love all the effects and the way you made the song echo gave a really great effect!
"Just don't let it grow and you'll be stronger without him"
But oh, now, my world is at your feet. I was lost and I was found,
But I was alive and now I've drowned"
the words are so perfect! good job!
CrazyBoutBillie 3 years ago
CrazyBoutBillie: Thanks so much! I just adore this song, it is definitely fitting for Rose and the Doctor's story. :D x
seduff 3 years ago
maybe im going to watch all of your videos~ each video is so great. cool!!!
wbbest 3 years ago
You should! Her videos are mindblowing!
AsarathWitch 3 years ago
everything about this video is amazing! the song is perfection and sooo beautiful, your timing/editing! wow!
sommersprechen 3 years ago
This nearly made me cry....
I'm downloading this song NOW.
How are you so perfect?!
chipsandsecrets 3 years ago 2
how beautifully australian. that was so lovley it sent shivers down my spine. the editing was perfect too.
totallyDT 3 years ago 2
That was so beautiful. I can't word it any better than Flick Sarestes did. Just wow.
kryptonitegrace 3 years ago
"But they weren't there beneath your stare,
And they weren't stripped 'till they were bare of
Any bindings from the world outside that room.
And they weren't taken by the hand
And led through fields of naked land
Where any pre-conceived ideas were blown away...
So I couldn't say "no". "
How did you find such a perfect song? Just when I thought those Doctor/Rose vids were just the same in the end... beautiful, one notices you really felt with and thought about the story. Thanks, very beautiful!
FlickSarestes 3 years ago 3
FlickSarestes: What a wonderful comment thankyou so much. :) I don't get to watch this one much anymore. But when i do, i remember why its one of my favourites. I just had to make this to Rose. The words were so perfect, how could 'I say no'...
seduff 3 years ago
I hope you are happy, I am in tears right now!
Thanks for the vid, I love it.
I am downloading this song *tear*
XxxXTorchwoodFanXxxX 3 years ago
I think I've commented before, but I really have to again. Everyday I watch this video, it's like a tradition now! I love it so much! The audio effects, were, I don't know what to say! The word "Mindblowing" doesn't live up to it! But my paticular fave would be near the end with them laughing. The echo/fade effect there was amazing and gave it real dept and an almost dream-like effect. Altogether fantastic! *big Doctor grin!*
AsarathWitch 3 years ago
AsarathWitch: Thankyou so much! I love that you watch it so often. :) It is such a beautiful song for Rose ... i am glad i managed to do it justice. I love the look the Dr gives at 3.04... heartwrenching. Sarah x
seduff 3 years ago
Gave me goosebumps!
Always brilliant!
Cheers!
planetgallifrey 4 years ago
I think I've already posted on this... I dunno but this is incerdible.
And I love this song. It was almost wrote for them.
I love how you use your fading effects. It's Brilliant!
Do you use WMM?
10MrsDavidTennant10 4 years ago
10MrsDavidTennant10: I use Final Cut on Mac OSX. :D So glad you like it. I love this song for Rose. It's so beautiful in it's simplicity. (just like her) :) x
seduff 4 years ago
I know! Missy Higgins is an incredible vocalist!
Okay, thanks : )
10MrsDavidTennant10 4 years ago 2
Or whoever sings this song...
10MrsDavidTennant10 4 years ago
10MrsDavidTennant10:
Yeah It's Missy Higgins. And yeah, she's incredible!
iliveibreathe 3 years ago
yeah, but what song. i can't find it on any of her cds that i have.
katebien 3 years ago
you have such an amazing talent for this, seriously. that was beautiful
Bex111 4 years ago 2
Truely Beauitful, i love the little piano bit at the end it really adds to it cause i know thats not in the song.
LovesMrDavidTennant 4 years ago
love 2.57 and onwards
LollyMafia 4 years ago 2
Where's the clip at 2:49 from?
Love the video btw!
roxysinead 4 years ago
Thanks! The clip of Rose and her mum is from Doomsday. :) Or the clip after that is from Series One Episode 2. xx
seduff 4 years ago
I CRIED!!!
enigmagirl117 4 years ago 2
You truly have a gift when you came bring a person to tears in less than four minutes. Actually, less than that. I started crying half way through. No words can describe how beautiful this was.
CrimsonKitty 4 years ago 3
I absolutely love this, it brought a tear to my eye. The song completely suits The Doctor and Rose
Great job!!
sesaboo 4 years ago 2
Love the video =] It's caused me to be addicted to this song lol
Where was the clip at 1.48 from, i've been searching for it everywhere x
Rachaelx1234 4 years ago 2
Christmas Special Runaway Bride. :) So glad you like it. xx
seduff 4 years ago
Shot at 0:45... what's that from???
DoctorCharmer 4 years ago
The Age of Steel, Series 2. :) xx
seduff 4 years ago
Thanks. Great video, by the way. Found it today and now I can't get enough of your vids!
DoctorCharmer 4 years ago
This is so beautiful and sad, and yet, it leaves me with a smile for all the good times they had together. I always loved how they made each other a better person, and how they enriched each others lives. And I bow to you you and thank you for getting exactly that across so calmly and beautifully.
christinschebiensche 4 years ago 2
I just love this songs simplicity and had to match the images to that. I felt the song was perfect for her relationship with the Doctor. How could she say 'no' ? Eventhough it changed her life forever, she would never change a moment. xx :)
seduff 4 years ago
I quite agree about the song - I hadn't heard it before, but its simplicity and calmness is just so perfect. And I know exactly what you mean about Rose - it's one of the reasons why I adored her so much. She was always her own person. But I'll stop before I go on about this for hours again. ;-)
(I couldn't have said 'no', either. Who could? :-) )
christinschebiensche 4 years ago
this is amazing! you shud be a proffesional! lol
where did u get these clips from?
xxKT4EVAxx 4 years ago
OMG, simply amazing. So sad, so beautiful, so fitting... I love the whole video and I love the Doctor&Rose - they were just pure perfection, you captured their story incredibly well: all the sorrow and what they meant to each other... I think I'm going to cry now... Really great video! You're very talented!
bedfordgirl 4 years ago
you are so good at making these videos, every one i have watched so far i ahev rated 5star!
doctorwhofanatic18 4 years ago
Thanks so much! I really try to make them as pleasing to view as possible. Otherwise i would be sick to death of them by now! LOL Thanks again... Sarah :) xx
seduff 4 years ago
Aww I miss Rose and the song fits perfectly!
clairelovesmusic 4 years ago 3
she's coming back u kno. check the bbc website.
MaddieRosePotter 4 years ago
This. Is. Wonderful.
I usually don't like watching fanvideos, but this one is really great. A perfect song with perfect lyrics for Rose's story...
I can just say THANK YOU for your amazing work. :)
Ines43 4 years ago 3
Wow way to go, this really fit Rose, and it got me all choked up. Keep making more videos, you have an awesome idea of what music and scenes to put together; it really pulls at the heart strings.
RogueGuitar13 4 years ago 3
Absolutly fantastic.
Practically in tears.
This -is- Rose's song.
It's soo amazing.
Great job.
HogwartsHonorRoll 4 years ago 2
Thanks so much.... means a lot coming from such a great You Tuber... :) xx
seduff 4 years ago
lovely vid! but...what dose the song mean (the lyrics)
ILAGNA 4 years ago
love the night bit!!
pinktails6 4 years ago
that was AMAZING.
bamshizzle182 4 years ago
I LOVE IT I LOVE IT I LOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It's so beautiful... how have more people not seen this... ?!
sugar1987rush 4 years ago
That was great! Brilliant special effects!
Sapphirestar1 4 years ago
Omg... that was so beautiful. Really it was one of the most beautiful DW vids i've ever seen adn I have seen a LOT. So well made, brilliant job.
tenluver 4 years ago
Thanks so much :) xx This video is one of my personal favourites, but i don't think its really been 'discovered' yet. :)
seduff 4 years ago
It really is amazing, you have such a talent! :) Yeah I can't believe it hasn't had more views, it deserves so many more, If u don't mind I'll put it on my video log, to advertise it, more people need to see this! xx
tenluver 4 years ago
Oh my gosh
I'm on the verge of tears
GORGEOUS!
WOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOW!!
10MrsDavidTennant10 4 years ago 2
OMG I just had to make another comment right after the last one. That last clip with his face gave me CHILLS!! You are brilliant.
FairyFlossHunny 4 years ago
oh wow, this was just beautiful,. u even used the clips i thought would match in my head whenever i hear this. loved the editing, the fading to another clip effect. this is my fave vid with this song. :)
FairyFlossHunny 4 years ago
you make my favourite videos.
so beautiful
x
punkess13 4 years ago
I LOVE THIS VIDEO TI SO COOL
cazzykay23 4 years ago
This is WonderFull :) Sooo Sad But Beautifil .
Can you tell me if you used Sony Vegas how do you pan the clip ?? Like move it lol .
Great Video :)
xxelm0xx 4 years ago
That was absolutely the most beautiful video I have seen of this duo- I have never cried in a video before and I am not ashamed that I did- this was perfect. Thankyou! What program do you use to edit- I use Sony Vegas but I couldn't really tell with yours, it was so seamless!:)
angeliquegrace 4 years ago
I'm getting worried that your going to get bored of me telling you that your video was awesometastically amazing. But....I'll say it anyways! It was awesometastically amazing!!! and I can't wait for you to make more! hmmm, you should use another Micha song, your last one was the best!
Genne 4 years ago 2
I didn't want this video to end!!!!!!!! SOOOOO GOOD!!!
twinvortex 4 years ago
So sad but loved the duo they are the best.
DavidsGirl841444 4 years ago