American Idol7 - Top 9 Perform 4.1.08 - Recap (HQ) 11/11

[MsDominic20]

David Archuleta owned everybody that night!!

[snottydyck]

music just does not get worse than this shit!!! what a bunch of crap!1

[curlingiron7658]

For THIS NIGHT:

TIE FOR #1.Carly Smithson & Michael Johns

#3. David Cook

#4. David Archuleta

#5. Syesah Mercado

#6. Jason Castro

#7. Brooke White

#8. Ramiele Malubay

#9. Kristy Lee Cook

[tiarnantman]

Best night of the season for me. :) 1. Carly Smithson 2. David Cook 3. David Archuleta 4. Jason Castro 5. Kristy Lee Cook 6. Brooke White 7. Syesha Mercado 8. Michael Johns 9. Ramiele Malubay 9.

[AIChamp08]

Some comments for particular contestants from myself.

Brooke White: I can't believe I predicted she was going to be eliminated that week.

Kristy Lee Cook: I can't believe she was in the bottom 2. I thought she did a good performance.

Syesha Mercado: I felt like when I was at last years tour listening to Lakisha Jones perform that song.

David Archuleta and Michael Johns: They were in a league of their own that week.

[janice2440]

Michael Johns was totally awsome, no way he should be gone!!This man is amazing and so hot, such a stage presence and great aura.

[Toothart]

My top 5

1 David Cook

2 Carly Smithson

3 Michael Johns

4 Syesha Mercado

5 Jason

[davidarchangelfan]

Hello? Are you deaf - you forgot Archuleta!

[Toothart]

I have nothing against Archuleta but I do not like the way he sings and evidently that is not just me; I also sing, play the piano, play both electric & acoustic guitar. I have many musician friends who agree with me. You must be his dad!

[KaiDohSeSe]

my top 5

1 David cook

2 Michael Johns

3 Carly Smithson

4 Syesha Mercado

5 David Archuleta

[osahju914]

i hate to break it to you, but by thursday, your number one will be gone, if there is justice in the world! either he or, my number 1, your second favorite, brooke NOO!! my top 6 1.brooke 2/3 carly/syesha 4-6 4.jason castro 5.david cook 6.david archuleta guys (all kinda suck)

[alicat7855]

Syesha rocks! She's from my home town!!

[Baoao]

david a

michael j

david c

they're fantastic this week!

[qp48]

My Top 5 are the ff:

1. Michael Johns

2. David Cook

3. David Archuleta

4. Carly Smithson

5. Syesha Mercado

[domzruizo]

top 5:

david archuleta

david cook

micheal

syesha

carly

[tinytvfan]

lmao at your Kristy Lee comments!! :D My faves are David C, (take care of yourself, please!), Jason,(so adorable!), and after this week, Michael!

[FiFiForever]

haha thanks for posting but in particular the comments, esp on Dolly :D

I still love David Cook but I have to admit Michael rocked it.

[poppulla]

Like Michael Johns & Jason. They are different from the rest.

[cthomas57]

Great recap, thanks! I think Michael gave the best performance: soulful, sexy, bluesy! I love Jason too! Glad he's still in for a while.

[sandu85]

Thank you very much, MISS KNOWN UNKNOWN!!!

[4shnoogue]

I know, thanks so much for posting. I love it. I am in the west coast, don't own a tv and get to see A.I before most people do. Really cool, thanks.

[StaciinSF]

Yes, thank you- you are the best!

[winkinsmily]

1st ;)

GREAT playlist,

thank you so much MissKnownUnknown