I love it! This song is amazing and so is the video and the couple. Altogether- perfect:) I love the ending "She is returning" Another one of your amazing videos:)
The Doctor has good style but he is the Doctor so wut did u xpect u would need good style when u r a Timelord it would b rly cool but bad at the same time but i tihnk it would b rly good
All your Dr Who vids are fantastic! Would be great if you could do one with Sally Sparrow and the episode Blink. The BBC should be contacting you, thought you would of got the job for this years christmas special. Keep up the good work.
I love Donna. I really do. she knows his every emotion as well as Rose did and she complimented his every action with her own soothing reaction. they were both defenders of the earth and knew the Doctor perfectly. save one thing. Rose was love, and Donna was a perfect friendship.
I love how his memories are more vividly colored than what's going on in the present. I think that's a very nice twist on standard "black or sepia for memories." While that certainly works, I think it says something about how much the Doctor longs for the past.
And that was just one of the very many nice touches here.
WOW! I dont' think I've seen this one yet! I love the dancing memory... I've always been a little irritated by people using the kiss between the Doctor and Rose-Actually-possessed-by-Cassandra, the shot you have here of him remembering at Donnas wedding is brilliant!
The music at the end gave me the chills... *shivers* Excellento - god damn it, that word again!! Ah well, there is no other word to sum up how amazing your videos are!
I heart this! :) Seriously, I love love love the bit at the end where he runs back for the sonic screwdriver, you add in "shall we peek at the end" and finish up with that haunting theme music. Thank you for sharing!!
Yes, just before he works out why River had that sonic screwdriver the whole time. It's just perfect here with that little bit of the doctor's theme added over it. :)
I also like the flashback that you pieced together with the dancing, and the way Rose's face flashed across the pillar of the TARDIS counsol. Oh and the "peek at the end" bit.
i know, its almost cruel. in fact, it IS cruel. they deserve to be together.
i love how you put TRUE companion :L but you're totally right, there will never be another rose - i mean when river song was on the show, i like really disliked her! i was like 'he cannot fall in love again because it has to be rose'. childish, silly? i dont care. (:
Oh wow this is amazing. This song is perfect for the Doctor and Rose.
I dabble in writing Dr Who fan fiction sometimes, and I've had writers block for awhile now... but seeing this video is inspiring me to write some more! Just what I needed, as always; thank you!
Okay... every now and then, if I want to watch something really good on YT, I look through your videos cuz they never disapoint. Sometimes I watch the same ones I've seen before w/ realizing it, but this is the first time I've seen this one... and well... wow. Your editing is just wow-- but you know that already =) But I just GOT to comment on the bit between 0:55 and 1:11-- I mean, absolutly, bloody brilliant! Who's ever done that? Exactly! Very insightful. Good job, and thank you! =)
LatinFox: Thank you so much for your wonderful comment. And yeah, not quite sure why that scene hasn't been done before, but i am thrilled you noticed and appreciated it. :D x
Do I even need to compliment you on this?? You should know already that anything you make is too good for youtube. Keep creating and brightening up my day :-) 5/5
It's funny, I only joined about three hours ago. I typed "Doctor Who" in and suddenly you pop up all over the place. Has anyone ever told you're amazing at making videos? The editing, the music...the emotion. Oh lord, I'm going to have to subscribe. Please keep up the good work!
i luv this vid! Please don't ever take it down!! I saw the episode yesterday...little bit sad about the ending although it was good...i'm just not happy :(...atleast it all works out in a sort of way..but still it be awsome if rose came back FOR GOOD
I love the way you've added the ghostly image of Rose in that chair at the beginning. And where she turns the radio on. Once again, your video is mind-blowing. You never cease to amaze me :D You're absolutely brilliant, and such an inspiration :]
Oh, wow, seduff. You've just completely blown me away once again. Love, love, LOVE the way the vid starts out with Rose turning up the volume on the music, and I love all your understated, perfect effects even more. I mean, Rose on the TARDIS column? That's just *genius*.
You are so amazing with everything you do, and such an inspiration. Love the song, love the way you captured the Doctor missing Rose, love how you kept the Doctor's and Donna's friendship. Just love all around.
Why aren't you happy with this? Again, you make amazing videos. The scene from Runaway Bride where the Doctor sees the couple dancing and he normally remembers Rose collapsing from New Earth, you edited in the scene from Doctor Dances so perfectly I wish it had actually aired your way on television. You do such a fantastic job and should be so proud of yourself. And kudos to Donna. I LOVE Rose, but Donna is way better than Martha.
Forgive me Seduff.. Beth here :D.. But I think I am going a little bit mad..Is there someone on the chair in the Tardis Console at the start.. I can see blond hair. Its like a ghost!
Sorry if I am wrong but I am watching it over and over :p
Seriously talk to the BBC you could make trailers like this for a living on BBC. It would be a lot better then their ones i seriously recommend you call them or somthing =]!
GRR My stupid emails never tell me when you've updated anymore! HOW do you do this? How do you give every video such a beautiful, different emotion of its own? You are the MASTER! hehe. *sigh* I will never be as brilliant as you, but I'll try. :) The ending was gorgeous. AND AND AND the bit where he hears he laughing and theres just the briefest flash of her face in the time rotor. Gorgeous editing! xxx
FairyFlossHunny: Stupid email... :P LOL. Thanks so much for your lovely comments, as always. *beams* and don't say that! Your videos are brilliant and just keep getting better!!! 8P So glad you enjoyed this one. :D x
Thanks once again seduff.. Bloody fantastic stuff that you make!!! It sorta goes without saying now.. but i'll say it anyway..love all your videos..makes me that little bit more excited for rose's return-thought that wasn't possible :)
soor19: Thanks so much! So happy to hear that this one is getting you even MORE excited about her return.... tonight!!! :D Thanks again for all your lovely comments. :)
Yey! A new video and fanTAStic as usual. If they don't give the fans some sort of lovey dovey scene in series 4 I can always rely on your videos to fill the void. :D 5 stars.
Yet another masterpiece! Great to see one of your videos with scenes from the new series...good thing we don't have to wait to see series 4 on the ABC, ah... bless You Tube!
amazing. amazing. amazing. Really, that's all I can say. Your videos leave me breathless. You're so talented. And I'm so jealous! :-D Keep up the wonderful work!
This has got me so hyped up for next week's episode! Fabulous. River Song seemed liked Rose Tyler herself from the way you've structured this, which is an idea that I've been mulling about in my head, too. Just loved it!
This is spectacular, I swear to God the BBC should ask you to work them in Doctor Who, and when/if they make a movie, you should be the one who makes the trailer.
The sound and color of this is gorgeous, and I LOVE the beginning. I really wish they'd used that scene in The Runaway Bride instead of the one from New Earth, although I suppose it might have confused new viewers. The beginning reminded me how I really, really like the Nine/Rose ship. This whole video, somehow, felt like Nine/Rose rather than Ten/Rose. Not sure why. :) But... I think this may in fact be your best video yet, because of the ATMOSPHERE. So much atmosphere. Like a Moffat episode.
alzarianfox: "So much atmosphere. Like a Moffat episode." .... Oh wow! Now that IS a compliment. *blushes* thankyou so much. I am thrilled that you enjoyed it. :)
WOW. First of all..I have NEVER seen that clip from the Doctor Dances used. And it's just PERFECT there. <3 This video is amazing on toast. I love it.
I have seen this video twice now, and it is incredibly beautiful. The melding of the song and the scenes you chose is flawless. I adore VAST, but I've seen so many people use their songs recklessly. You did not make that mistake. You've actually made me think of the song in a different light. Thank you so much!
Aqueoua: I am so glad to hear that you feel i did the Vast song justice. I actually couldn't believe the song hadn't been used very much. ?? But i have seen a few others vast songs overused and not very well made at all. So i understand where you are coming from. Thanks again! :) x
wow, how can you not be 100% happy with this? Perhaps it's simply because I no nothing about film editing, but nevertheless, it's amazing. I have to agree with kryptonitegrace on this too, when the Doctor runs after the diary at the end... wow, gives me chills. Well done you!
Also ment to say i love your " Immortal" video its the best , so many people have used that song in videos for all sorts of shows but it just fitted perfect , i downloaded it and keep watching over and over lol think people are starting to worry about me !! xx
After hours and hours searching youtube i finally found your videos and now dont bother with any others ,they are wicked , so well edited just what i was looking for - im not sure what im looking forward to more , the episode Rose returns in or your music video once she has returned lol!! Keep up the amazing work , best doctor who videos out!! x
iijanineii: So glad to hear that you are enjoying my videos. :D x It's always so amazing to hear the stories behind how they get found, and what are your favourites. I love it, Thanks so much for your comments. ;D x
You never ever fail to impress me. The sound clips in this are brilliantly arranged, the song is perfect, the clips match and the editing is as unbelievable as ever.
Wow all ur video's r the best!! I watched this without blinking!! not on purpose its just that ur vid was so awsome i cudn't bare to mis a second of it! Your really great at making these vids. Keep it up!!
Seduff: you should never doubt your abilities as an editor, you are far and away, not only the best Doctor Who vids editor, but probably the outright best editor I have seen on youtube ever. Keep 'em coming.
WOW. Your videos never cease to amaze me. Brilliant job! You've tied in all the best elements of the series up to now so beautifully. I'm glad you were able to finish it and share it with all of us. Keep up the fantastic work! :)
Oh my goodness! So many wonderful comments... I'm not sure who to reply too! ... *goes left*... err... *goes right*... ummm... o.O?!
But seriously, WOW! @.@... I never expected to get so many amazing comments on this video. They are all so lovely and always make me smile. THANK YOU all SO MUCH. (and a special thanks to TPOM for pushing me to finish it!)
seduff x
(every time i leave one of these now i can't help but hear Donna's line... "with a Kiss?!" ...lol. ;D)
Seduff - in the immortal words of Bill S Preston, Esquire, and Ted 'Theodore' Logan; WHOA! What
This was magnificent. I can't imagine the amount of time you must put into finding the right scenes and sounds for each moment of your clip - I'll say it again, you're a genius at this! I loved the dancing - most people use the ducking transition with New Earth; you used Doctor Dances, and it was flawless - just perfect. Anyway - amazing as always, will stop gushing now ~ x gabbi
too bad that theory(rose being river) did not come true :(
MonicaJKelly 5 months ago in playlist More videos from seduff
I love it! This song is amazing and so is the video and the couple. Altogether- perfect:) I love the ending "She is returning" Another one of your amazing videos:)
immortaletternity 7 months ago
The Doctor has good style but he is the Doctor so wut did u xpect u would need good style when u r a Timelord it would b rly cool but bad at the same time but i tihnk it would b rly good
chaor875 10 months ago
What is the importance of the hand? I just started watching Doctor Who.
miyluv 1 year ago
@miyluv Ahh see, now that'd be spoilers. Keep watching, you'll find out :)
Musemistress 1 year ago
All your Dr Who vids are fantastic! Would be great if you could do one with Sally Sparrow and the episode Blink. The BBC should be contacting you, thought you would of got the job for this years christmas special. Keep up the good work.
dave5tesb 1 year ago
This is sooo heartbreaking and beautiful!
nowheresland 1 year ago
this is a brill vid
Wich episode is it were he looks roundthe empty tardis @2:02
TorchwoodxDoctorwho1 1 year ago
this was SO good. thank you thepowerofme for making it!!
omgihavenoidea 2 years ago
every video i watch is just amazing this is really brilliant all of your videos are brilliant WELLDONE! *claps*
Lexiechicklovesyou 2 years ago
Such a lovely video, :) you get to see The Doctor's more sensitive side and see how much he really misses rose :) THANK YOU!!
Twilighttruelove 2 years ago 2
Great video you rock
TheDavrosDude 2 years ago
"Amazing"
leginewol 2 years ago
I love Donna. I really do. she knows his every emotion as well as Rose did and she complimented his every action with her own soothing reaction. they were both defenders of the earth and knew the Doctor perfectly. save one thing. Rose was love, and Donna was a perfect friendship.
CrazyGood88 2 years ago 17
i absolutely love your videos! you've got MAD editing skills!
what program do you use for your editing?
2dark2die 2 years ago
Brilliant video once again, I got goosebumps when you made it look like the Doctor turns around sees the back of Rose and she disappears. 5/5
BREDoctorWho1 2 years ago 3
omg i love the dancing bit do you actually think the dw team did that on purpose cause it totally fits
great vid
CharmedHollz 2 years ago
I love how his memories are more vividly colored than what's going on in the present. I think that's a very nice twist on standard "black or sepia for memories." While that certainly works, I think it says something about how much the Doctor longs for the past.
And that was just one of the very many nice touches here.
SingularSensation1 2 years ago 4
"Fantastic, just fantastic."
warmingthesoul 2 years ago
i think i'm gunna cry :'( *sniff sniff* it was sooo beautiful!!!!!
davidtennantlovers 2 years ago
Nice editing with the sound at the beginning. Loved it!
snapecharmer 2 years ago 2
OMG I can't even count how many times I've watched this brillant video !
And guess what , I never get bored of it, I think among all of your amazingness that one is my favorite ^^
misscynthia17 2 years ago 7
misscynthia17: Wow. really? I haven't watched this one in such a long time. Glad you still enjoy it. :)
seduff 2 years ago
Yes really ^^ I jus love watching it from time to time ^^
misscynthia17 2 years ago
WOW! I dont' think I've seen this one yet! I love the dancing memory... I've always been a little irritated by people using the kiss between the Doctor and Rose-Actually-possessed-by-Cassandra, the shot you have here of him remembering at Donnas wedding is brilliant!
pippinfett 2 years ago 2
love it!
eating gum.
watching utube.
lovely!
ianamilett 2 years ago
actually amazing!!! so glad you included some 9 footage as well. xxx
christinedaae87 2 years ago
Your best video to date! That was spectacular! I like ALL of your videos so that was a hard choice for me!
GallifreyanVideo 2 years ago
Your videos give me goosebumps. It's thrilling, seriously.
<3
0RainbowProductions 2 years ago
That was so beautiful! I love your videos but this one is just so perfect for the Doctor and Rose.
dancingwithneville 2 years ago
The music at the end gave me the chills... *shivers* Excellento - god damn it, that word again!! Ah well, there is no other word to sum up how amazing your videos are!
TheMidnightMystery 2 years ago
I heart this! :) Seriously, I love love love the bit at the end where he runs back for the sonic screwdriver, you add in "shall we peek at the end" and finish up with that haunting theme music. Thank you for sharing!!
alsatia2 2 years ago
that is from the 2 parter "silence the the library" and "forest of the dead"
vimes95 2 years ago
Yes, just before he works out why River had that sonic screwdriver the whole time. It's just perfect here with that little bit of the doctor's theme added over it. :)
alsatia2 2 years ago
So sad
DoctorWhoLoveGirl 2 years ago
I also like the flashback that you pieced together with the dancing, and the way Rose's face flashed across the pillar of the TARDIS counsol. Oh and the "peek at the end" bit.
mantra4ia 2 years ago 3
(at the start with the dancing)
Seady93 2 years ago
oh that flash back was better than the one they acctually had
Seady93 2 years ago 3
Wow. Amazing!!!
sunnytyler001 2 years ago
That was absolutely fantastic!
I loved it, the editing was just ace!
CherryBlossomSmile 2 years ago 4
i know, its almost cruel. in fact, it IS cruel. they deserve to be together.
i love how you put TRUE companion :L but you're totally right, there will never be another rose - i mean when river song was on the show, i like really disliked her! i was like 'he cannot fall in love again because it has to be rose'. childish, silly? i dont care. (:
jeviennis 2 years ago 3
omg i absolutly loved the very end of this! awesome work as usual!
DeathByStereo17 3 years ago 3
very well edited
tigerdiosa86 3 years ago
i lvoe thsi video it os cute and sweet
kt27rule 3 years ago
One of the best montages I have EVER seen. Everything went perfect--it was simplistic yet layered, if that makes ANY sense, and hopefully it does. :)
ChristineRuud 3 years ago
wow...This is amazing editing! I can't get over it..
HeartPhantom 3 years ago
wow quite moving
Marillionmad 3 years ago
i loved the last minute or so i thout it was great
spazzymagi 3 years ago
that part where you see rose in the heart of the tardis, a-m-a-z-i-n-g. as are all yoru videos
emmabtvs 3 years ago 2
Dude , this was awesomely creatd!
SniperSam 3 years ago
this is a brilliant video!!!!
lovedd itt!!!
xxxx
xXTardisDreamerXx 3 years ago
Yes. He does. :) The reunion doesn't all go quite to plan, but if you get a chance you should definitely take a look at the end of Series 4.
seduff 3 years ago
Oh wow this is amazing. This song is perfect for the Doctor and Rose.
I dabble in writing Dr Who fan fiction sometimes, and I've had writers block for awhile now... but seeing this video is inspiring me to write some more! Just what I needed, as always; thank you!
rosetyler08 3 years ago
seduff how do you do so many great videos your a genious!
allyboyce111 3 years ago
Great vid as always. I love the River Song part at the end of the clip.
lilithkv 3 years ago
this vid is like a visual sweety shop , all my favourite people in one vid !!!!!
topliff12345 3 years ago
OH YES!!!! I LOVE IT!!!!
curlywavy18 3 years ago
Goooooooooosebumps :L
I suddenly craved to watch this vid, and now i crave it more :L
Fantastic, love it.
Floweeeerr 3 years ago
Beautifully done!!!
Queen0ftheCastle 3 years ago
I'm back on this one again lol
one of my fave you've done ^^
so love it and fell in love with this haunting song (well it is for me ^^)
GENIUS !!!!
misscynthia17 3 years ago
Okay... every now and then, if I want to watch something really good on YT, I look through your videos cuz they never disapoint. Sometimes I watch the same ones I've seen before w/ realizing it, but this is the first time I've seen this one... and well... wow. Your editing is just wow-- but you know that already =) But I just GOT to comment on the bit between 0:55 and 1:11-- I mean, absolutly, bloody brilliant! Who's ever done that? Exactly! Very insightful. Good job, and thank you! =)
LatinFox 3 years ago
LatinFox: Thank you so much for your wonderful comment. And yeah, not quite sure why that scene hasn't been done before, but i am thrilled you noticed and appreciated it. :D x
seduff 3 years ago
so beautiful
you know how to make peaople cry for the Doctor and Rose ...
you are really gifted !!!
misscynthia17 3 years ago
how did I miss this one!! made me cry :) but it was amazingly good :)
WhisperLuna 3 years ago 2
AMAZING.
FatalScene 3 years ago
Another brilliant vid!
akspila 3 years ago
BRILLIANT!!!
(:
x
shelovesthedoctor 3 years ago
beautiful but morbid
AshenSoul 3 years ago
Do I even need to compliment you on this?? You should know already that anything you make is too good for youtube. Keep creating and brightening up my day :-) 5/5
cookiect2003 3 years ago 6
I agree :)
adearerane 3 years ago
OMG as Always a very good work!
Cheers!
minvaineth 3 years ago 4
It's funny, I only joined about three hours ago. I typed "Doctor Who" in and suddenly you pop up all over the place. Has anyone ever told you're amazing at making videos? The editing, the music...the emotion. Oh lord, I'm going to have to subscribe. Please keep up the good work!
Teaspoon985 3 years ago 10
Awesome.
You are AMAZING.
XenaWillAlwaysRock 3 years ago 2
Wow, that was so awesome!
zotlot 3 years ago
WOO! The diary/spoiler idea was fantastic!! loved it xx
skulblaka92 3 years ago
it was so perfect! i love how u fitted in the whole thing with the spoilers and the diary! just amazing
totallyDT 3 years ago
ooh im impressed with the dancing twirl at around 1:07. good work
lostinlost 3 years ago 2
AHHH. I'm now addicted to your work. Because it's SO perfectly brilliant.
WOWOWOWOWOW! I'm just kind of in awe.
MontanaBohemian 3 years ago 3
Love it. Choice of song is wonderful.
curlygurl1190 3 years ago 2
Goosebumps.... Excellent work
bristow860 3 years ago 2
SPOT ON. *hugs* You know your stuff, m'dear.
blondecharger 3 years ago 4
It was a pleasure to watch
EternalDolor 3 years ago 5
i luv this vid! Please don't ever take it down!! I saw the episode yesterday...little bit sad about the ending although it was good...i'm just not happy :(...atleast it all works out in a sort of way..but still it be awsome if rose came back FOR GOOD
ILAGNA 3 years ago 7
Love this and i noticed Rose's eye in the TARDIS console (sp?) that was amazing editing as usual !! 5/5 favs x
xXxXxcozzaxXxXx 3 years ago 7
Ah! The very end! Love that
HappyAppleCider 3 years ago 2
This was absolutely brilliant!:D
Hats off!
NimphodoraTonks 3 years ago 2
Yur probs getting sick of me commenting on your vids now x]
But yeah, great vid (As always) This one sent shivers up my spine, especially the dialogue at the end :)
drwho10companion 3 years ago 4
I love the way you've added the ghostly image of Rose in that chair at the beginning. And where she turns the radio on. Once again, your video is mind-blowing. You never cease to amaze me :D You're absolutely brilliant, and such an inspiration :]
MCRazedperson 3 years ago 2
That was good!!!!
nlcauble 3 years ago
good god.
that was brilliant.
i loved the sound - the volume was fine!
wow, 1000 subscriptions. congrats!
thats 998 more than me!
.. not really anything to celebrate, but hey!
so anyhoo, well done, this is amazing!
where do you get your ideas from? (rhetorical question, can be answered if you want) ;]
jeviennis 3 years ago 2
Oh damn, I just love your endings (the whole vid, but escpecially the ending). It just puts you on the floor. How do you do it?
mantra4ia 3 years ago
I envy your talent! Iv'e never enjoyed Dr/Rose videos untill i saw your ones. Outstanding!
drantb 3 years ago 2
Oh, wow, seduff. You've just completely blown me away once again. Love, love, LOVE the way the vid starts out with Rose turning up the volume on the music, and I love all your understated, perfect effects even more. I mean, Rose on the TARDIS column? That's just *genius*.
You are so amazing with everything you do, and such an inspiration. Love the song, love the way you captured the Doctor missing Rose, love how you kept the Doctor's and Donna's friendship. Just love all around.
christinschebiensche 3 years ago 3
Why aren't you happy with this? Again, you make amazing videos. The scene from Runaway Bride where the Doctor sees the couple dancing and he normally remembers Rose collapsing from New Earth, you edited in the scene from Doctor Dances so perfectly I wish it had actually aired your way on television. You do such a fantastic job and should be so proud of yourself. And kudos to Donna. I LOVE Rose, but Donna is way better than Martha.
Janiqua 3 years ago 3
Really beautifully edited.Totally fantastic...
hippogriffs95 3 years ago
Oh another great vid...absolutly brill
DWaDDLJ 3 years ago
Forgive me Seduff.. Beth here :D.. But I think I am going a little bit mad..Is there someone on the chair in the Tardis Console at the start.. I can see blond hair. Its like a ghost!
Sorry if I am wrong but I am watching it over and over :p
GenesisArkProduction 3 years ago
Yay Beth! You noticed! That took me a long time, and so far only one other viewer has commented on it. :D She is there. :) xx
seduff 3 years ago
OMG I JUST saw the person on the chair!! awesome!!
FairyFlossHunny 3 years ago
wow, i only just noticed that XD id been lookin at the Doctor before... hehe find new stuff every time we watch it i guess =^_^=
CassandraMotou 3 years ago
omg! i see it!
wow, so subtle!
it makes loads of the beginning make sense to me now! cos thats when he starts reminiscing! my bad;]
jeviennis 3 years ago
What does she say at 0:41?
FairyFlossHunny 3 years ago
"Our song" XD
THEpowerOFme 3 years ago
Its a real pain that line isn't it! :D Didn't seem to matter how i changed it. XD
seduff 3 years ago
Oh no, I can understand it completely. :) It's a wonderful line!
THEpowerOFme 3 years ago
Oh well now that I know what it is, it seems so obvious! lol At first I thought she was saying awesome with a really weird accent hehe
FairyFlossHunny 3 years ago
I was hoping you would do something with the "she is returning" and the first sight of her in series 4. EEKKK i love it!!!!
HTLCarlisle 3 years ago
Seriously talk to the BBC you could make trailers like this for a living on BBC. It would be a lot better then their ones i seriously recommend you call them or somthing =]!
thesorrow777 3 years ago 3
GRR My stupid emails never tell me when you've updated anymore! HOW do you do this? How do you give every video such a beautiful, different emotion of its own? You are the MASTER! hehe. *sigh* I will never be as brilliant as you, but I'll try. :) The ending was gorgeous. AND AND AND the bit where he hears he laughing and theres just the briefest flash of her face in the time rotor. Gorgeous editing! xxx
FairyFlossHunny 3 years ago 3
FairyFlossHunny: Stupid email... :P LOL. Thanks so much for your lovely comments, as always. *beams* and don't say that! Your videos are brilliant and just keep getting better!!! 8P So glad you enjoyed this one. :D x
seduff 3 years ago
I'm crying now!
I NEVER cry at vids!
omg omg u terrible person.
This is a beautiful vid.
XxBlaidxX 3 years ago 2
Thanks once again seduff.. Bloody fantastic stuff that you make!!! It sorta goes without saying now.. but i'll say it anyway..love all your videos..makes me that little bit more excited for rose's return-thought that wasn't possible :)
soor19 3 years ago 2
soor19: Thanks so much! So happy to hear that this one is getting you even MORE excited about her return.... tonight!!! :D Thanks again for all your lovely comments. :)
seduff 3 years ago
absolutely beautiful video set to my favorite song by VAST.
itsmeyall 3 years ago 2
New stuff! New stuff! Who cares if I'm 5 days late, it's new stuff!!! :D
Lovely and freaking awesome new stuff too. I LOVED 1:07, WOWZA. Just LOVE here.
NEVER stop making vids, ever. EVER. See? Capslock!Me strikes again. That's a good thing. 8D
And sorry if I sound crazy, I just finished a 2.5 hour long exam. Dx Ick.
But love this!
CaptainJackForever 3 years ago 2
u made me cry , how o u do that?? lol
dwfan12 3 years ago 2
This is the best Doctor and Rose video I've seen!! 5*stars^_^ love what you did with the video, beautiful^-^
DarkAerislucy16 3 years ago 2
AWSUM!!!!!
torchwood95 3 years ago
Yey! A new video and fanTAStic as usual. If they don't give the fans some sort of lovey dovey scene in series 4 I can always rely on your videos to fill the void. :D 5 stars.
abstractvmilk 3 years ago
Oh thats beautiful, the sound is great!!!
DoctorWhoLoverTBCEDT 3 years ago
You're very welcome! Thanks for always making such amazing videos.
KLady3 3 years ago
Lovely video :D
Haydeez 3 years ago 3
how can you not be 100% happy wiv it ?
its brilliant!
1livi1rox 3 years ago
ive said it before, and ill say it again. you are a flippin goddess. seriously O_O
just... wow. there really are no words
CassandraMotou 3 years ago
CassandraMotou: As always, thanks so much for your lovely comments, They never fail to make me smile. :) x
seduff 3 years ago
Yet another masterpiece! Great to see one of your videos with scenes from the new series...good thing we don't have to wait to see series 4 on the ABC, ah... bless You Tube!
greengirl68 3 years ago 2
amazing. amazing. amazing. Really, that's all I can say. Your videos leave me breathless. You're so talented. And I'm so jealous! :-D Keep up the wonderful work!
dacrazifrog 3 years ago
Wow, that was super brilliant! And I just absolutely love that song so thanks for using it!
And I'm also a big fan of using original sound in videos! It all fit perfectly, well done :D
Padme0 3 years ago 2
wow that is really good clip well edited and everything !!! great work =)
funkyfreshers 3 years ago
This is totally amazing !! love the beggining and the ending !! && the rest for that matter :p 5/5 favs
please keep making amazing videos ! x
xXxXxcozzaxXxXx 3 years ago 2
This has got me so hyped up for next week's episode! Fabulous. River Song seemed liked Rose Tyler herself from the way you've structured this, which is an idea that I've been mulling about in my head, too. Just loved it!
starbrights90 3 years ago
amazing job well done
SeniAction 3 years ago
This is brilliant as is all your stuff!
ArkanDaUrsi 3 years ago
This is spectacular, I swear to God the BBC should ask you to work them in Doctor Who, and when/if they make a movie, you should be the one who makes the trailer.
EllenRebecca3 3 years ago 2
this is so beautiful
i dont even have words
amazing
amy2171987 3 years ago
The sound and color of this is gorgeous, and I LOVE the beginning. I really wish they'd used that scene in The Runaway Bride instead of the one from New Earth, although I suppose it might have confused new viewers. The beginning reminded me how I really, really like the Nine/Rose ship. This whole video, somehow, felt like Nine/Rose rather than Ten/Rose. Not sure why. :) But... I think this may in fact be your best video yet, because of the ATMOSPHERE. So much atmosphere. Like a Moffat episode.
alzarianfox 3 years ago
alzarianfox: "So much atmosphere. Like a Moffat episode." .... Oh wow! Now that IS a compliment. *blushes* thankyou so much. I am thrilled that you enjoyed it. :)
seduff 3 years ago
WOW. First of all..I have NEVER seen that clip from the Doctor Dances used. And it's just PERFECT there. <3 This video is amazing on toast. I love it.
Shifterred 3 years ago
Shifterred: I know, i have rarely seen that scene used at all, so i thought... Why not! "amazing on toast". oh i like that! LOL :D x
seduff 3 years ago
I have seen this video twice now, and it is incredibly beautiful. The melding of the song and the scenes you chose is flawless. I adore VAST, but I've seen so many people use their songs recklessly. You did not make that mistake. You've actually made me think of the song in a different light. Thank you so much!
I greatly appreciate all the videos you make!
Aqueoua 3 years ago
Aqueoua: I am so glad to hear that you feel i did the Vast song justice. I actually couldn't believe the song hadn't been used very much. ?? But i have seen a few others vast songs overused and not very well made at all. So i understand where you are coming from. Thanks again! :) x
seduff 3 years ago
Ever try trailers?
Sharingonsandninja 3 years ago
This is Fantastic! I love it. 5 stars
xxhelenclairexx 3 years ago
This video is amazing! I love it :) You should be very satisfied with it :D
kikuilu 3 years ago
Another amazing vid. The way you fold in different scenes and create these subtle effects are awesome.
karenc909 3 years ago
amazing how you did it you're so gifted for this!!
misscynthia17 3 years ago
wow, how can you not be 100% happy with this? Perhaps it's simply because I no nothing about film editing, but nevertheless, it's amazing. I have to agree with kryptonitegrace on this too, when the Doctor runs after the diary at the end... wow, gives me chills. Well done you!
ummmLiz 3 years ago
omg omg Sarah! This video is amazing! absolutely amazing how do u do it! your a g8 video maker girl! faving 1ne again!!! Rose next week!
Rosetylermad111 3 years ago
Awesome as usual! :) That very last scene, where he's running back to the book, gave me chills. Well done!
kryptonitegrace 3 years ago
Yet again you have excelled yourself! Brilliant!!
donna8721 3 years ago
Wow. Seduff, your editing never ceases to amaze me. (Did I spell ceases right?!) Especially that bit at 2:02! That was brill! ^_^
WerewolvesLoveMCR 3 years ago
ace! as usual!:)
louisesaunders 3 years ago
I love it well done 5* very mysterious! xxx
KeepTheLastDream 3 years ago
this is so great! very mysterious!! i love the ending..."shall we peek at the end?" YES!! PEEK...GO ON, YOU KNOW YOU WANT TO!!!
x
heffp1 3 years ago
Yes, that ending really got me, brilliant editing seduff. Well done, 5 stars :)
Sefulan 3 years ago
Wow! Just wow!
JenMalli 3 years ago
Also ment to say i love your " Immortal" video its the best , so many people have used that song in videos for all sorts of shows but it just fitted perfect , i downloaded it and keep watching over and over lol think people are starting to worry about me !! xx
iijanineii 3 years ago
After hours and hours searching youtube i finally found your videos and now dont bother with any others ,they are wicked , so well edited just what i was looking for - im not sure what im looking forward to more , the episode Rose returns in or your music video once she has returned lol!! Keep up the amazing work , best doctor who videos out!! x
iijanineii 3 years ago
iijanineii: So glad to hear that you are enjoying my videos. :D x It's always so amazing to hear the stories behind how they get found, and what are your favourites. I love it, Thanks so much for your comments. ;D x
seduff 3 years ago
I have a question - where is the clip of the doctor looking up from the tardis console and looking around (about the 2min mark)from?
Seduff - you NEVER disappoint! another beautiful beautiful video!!!
snowf86 3 years ago
You never ever fail to impress me. The sound clips in this are brilliantly arranged, the song is perfect, the clips match and the editing is as unbelievable as ever.
10MrsDavidTennant10 3 years ago
Wow all ur video's r the best!! I watched this without blinking!! not on purpose its just that ur vid was so awsome i cudn't bare to mis a second of it! Your really great at making these vids. Keep it up!!
ILAGNA 3 years ago
Good god, your videos are always so beautiful. Well done.
dbvixxen 3 years ago
seduff your videos are the best on Youtube and the web thanks for the adventure again i cant wait to see Rose return
Dan
bauer024 3 years ago
Seduff: you should never doubt your abilities as an editor, you are far and away, not only the best Doctor Who vids editor, but probably the outright best editor I have seen on youtube ever. Keep 'em coming.
pammcasso 3 years ago
WOW. Your videos never cease to amaze me. Brilliant job! You've tied in all the best elements of the series up to now so beautifully. I'm glad you were able to finish it and share it with all of us. Keep up the fantastic work! :)
lexana14 3 years ago
Oh my goodness! So many wonderful comments... I'm not sure who to reply too! ... *goes left*... err... *goes right*... ummm... o.O?!
But seriously, WOW! @.@... I never expected to get so many amazing comments on this video. They are all so lovely and always make me smile. THANK YOU all SO MUCH. (and a special thanks to TPOM for pushing me to finish it!)
seduff x
(every time i leave one of these now i can't help but hear Donna's line... "with a Kiss?!" ...lol. ;D)
seduff 3 years ago
Absolutely gorgeous. Excellent job!
JessiEvaS 3 years ago
Wow you are so amazing at making your videos!!!!
Sheliabluerose 3 years ago
Seduff - in the immortal words of Bill S Preston, Esquire, and Ted 'Theodore' Logan; WHOA! What
This was magnificent. I can't imagine the amount of time you must put into finding the right scenes and sounds for each moment of your clip - I'll say it again, you're a genius at this! I loved the dancing - most people use the ducking transition with New Earth; you used Doctor Dances, and it was flawless - just perfect. Anyway - amazing as always, will stop gushing now ~ x gabbi
gabbicav 3 years ago
gabbicav: WHOA... dude.:D I love bill and ted! :D Thanks so much for your wonderful comment. They mean a lot. :D x
seduff 3 years ago