Give gays the right to legal union, but it will never be marriage. Marriage = Man + woman. This doesn't deserve to be on the national agenda at all. This topic is used by leftist governments as a distraction from the poor job they are otherwise doing
And, stop shifting the focus of pedophilia to the Gays. You're placing less scrutiny on other pedophiles who happen to be straight, or have no adult sexual orientation. (Yes I know this is somewhat oversimplified) You're just enabling other pedophiles. Is the psychological well being of children less important than scaring other people into "hating" gays? Seriously?
Even if pedophilia is found to be "in born" they are harming children. Not the general Gay person. THAT is the difference.
I cannot believe some of the comments on this forum. Actually, being Youtube, I kind of can. It's hard for me to stomach that Christians, of all people, are in favor of oppressing people. Shouldn't you guys be out there working for charity and giving to the poor?
Also, an alarming comment suggested that because a man molested a young boy he was gay! Would like to point out that that is a common misconception. Adult sexual orientation often doesn't coincide with the attraction of the pedophile.
2:07 bullshit.. the opinion polls are rigged and fabricated as is the usual case by left side of politics. Take a poll anywhere outside of all the gay communities in the main cities. Typically this is why we have such a mess in this country with politicians and the media pandering to minority groups.
@MrBITS101 Funny how people claim that opinion polls are rigged when it supports gay marriage but opinion polls are evidence the government should be booted out because it says there is no support for the carbon tax. So which is it? You can't have it both ways.
@leptismagna10 We're following the Right Wing Americans for some reason. It's like we are afraid of evolving as a culture... oh wait I just evolution, that's why we aren't allowed to grow up.
@leptismagna10 Na bro most of Australia is fine with Gay marriage- unfortunately all countries however have some stupid fuckers who go around preaching their stupid creationist ideals on others. Dont judge all australians by these homophobes
When will we legalise consensual polygamy? I'm not gay and don't want to marry a man, but I think that having two or three wives would be fun and an enriching experience for all. Who is with me?
Gay, Stright.Bi, Lesbian, white.Black, Hell even diffrent religions Let them get married it's there life they have the right to choose if that other person make them happy then is say go for it congratulations. At the end of the day There not harming u by getting married and people who don't like it deal with it stuff in life happens that you don't like Its part of living.
Yeah, it's all about WHAT I WANT!!! right? The world would be so much better if we all just did WHATEVER I WANT!!! IT MAKES MEEEEE HAPPY SO IT'S CORRECT! Being gay is a sick side effect from a culture that screams ME ME ME!!! If you look into the past of every "gay" person. You'll find a reason they're acting this way. WHY, would we have "man" and "woman" if we are suppose to be gay??? Why in every culture, in every human society on earth, has this been SICK and WRONG to do??? Why?
@GuamKomudo Who are you to judge people if they are happy io really don't see how two guys or girls getting married affects you and if god makes everything then he must of made gays ^ ^
He did not create gays. He created human beings who have created their own cultures and mindsets. "Who are you to judge people" "How does it affect you?" THIS is what's wrong with this modern world... You people think it's all about "ME" "I FEEL GOOD" Being gay is a side effect of a culture that screams LOOK AT ME because my parents won't! Gay is NOT a natural thing, it is NOT accepted in ANY culture or country of ANY time period or species on earth, WHY??? Tell me why this is.
@GuamKomudo It's not just human's that are gay, pig's and chickens and other anmals have been known sometimes to be gay. honestly what has a gay person ever done to you. I am stright and part of being british american or modern cultures is the right to choose. I have gay friends and there exactly like my stright friends they still have feelings.
That's all bull. Pigs and chickens don't even have the concept of "love" They just do what they do to survive, so that's ruled out... You act like I hate gay people, stop playing the "Oh poor me! A Christian devil is hurting me! Oh no!!!" Seriously get over yourself I don't hate anyone, or treat gay people ANY differently than anyone else. This is what I'm hearing."I don't know the answer, but I do what I want, whenever I want and what feels good in the moment is right. I DO WHAT I WANT!"
Group rights are a nonsense. When the 'sex' in marriage doesn't matter...why should the number....why not fred and alan marrying steve, billy bob and sarah?? come on don't be such an Arithmophobe!!!!
anyway, must go...let me know when you find that naughty elusive gay gene!!!!!
I like Ron Paul's position on this. We don't have rights because we are gays, black, or any minority group, we have rights because we are individuals, We all have the right to do what we want as long as we don't harm anyone else.
Unfortunately I don't see the Republican party letting him support gay rights or some other minorites. It's not just the candidate's views, its also the party behind the candidate's views that matters.
I am honestly disgusted by the comments on this video. Most of you are a bunch of ignorant, minded fools who are scared of things that are different to them. If it were women fighting for equal pay I'm sure you would support it, equality between sexes is no different to equality in marriages.
@PeekyBooo are you so ignorant that you believe that being homosexual is a mental disorder? if we follow your logic, i think you shouldn't be allowed to have children or else they may end up just as ignorant and homophobic as you.
@samesides Explain why homosexuality isn't a mental disorder. ..and don't give me this tripe about science says so. Science is just a cash-for-comments fraternity these days. Also Kinsey was a paedophile so even he is no authority on the subject.
Faeces love is sickening and a disorder. The quicker people are helped the better not fostered in their disorder.
HEY JOSH, WHEN YOUR BALL'S DROP AND YOU GROW SOME PUBE'S AND GET SOME REAL LIFE EXPERIENCE, THEN MAYBE WE MIGHT TAKE SOME NOTICE OF YOU, UNTIL THEN SHUT THE FUCK UP.
Homosexuals are their own worst enemy! It is not natural and you know it. The fact that you have to use a condom to protect yourself from disease proves it is not natural. The safest natural sex is between monogamous male/female relationships. They don't need so much protection from diseases. This alone tells you that it is right and natural. Their may be rare insances of disease occurring for whatever reason but they are the safest sex practitioners.
@rplende As you are referring to anal sex can I just point something out! Homosexuality is not just about sex. some gay couples don't even engage in anal sex! Homosexuality means you are attracted to a member of the same sex, you have emotional feeling for them, you experience love. Plus anal sex is not just a gay practice, straight couples can do it to! and a lot do actually. Yes it might not be the most natural thing in the world but the fact we can do it says something about our evolution!
@rplende You're missing the part where straight people do anal and gay people perform fellatio. Saying that different gender pairings require different levels of safety doesn't make you right, just narrow minded.
Why do gay people, want to follow hetro people into something like marriage?? why can't gay people just be content with having a civil partnership, that includes the same legal rights as a marriage does for heterosexuals? i'll tell you why, because most gay people these days have no individuality or imagination, they are so influenced and controlled by mind-numbing political correctness, pop culture, celebrity worship and consumerism, that marriage seems almost exotic & desirable, how sad!
Josh Thomas, absolute genious! I really don't understand why gay marriage isn't legal, there is nothing wrong with it! Marriage should be because you love someone, it shouldn't be just between male and female... that is just so wrong if you ask me. It doesn't matter who you are, you should be able to marry any one you want. The law should be changed!
As for homophobia, it is as much a misnomer as it is a myth. A phobia is an irrational fear of something. Those that reject homosexual notions are not afraid of homosexuals and their rejection of such homosexual notions are not irrational. If anything is irrational, it is the belief that homosexuality is normal and good, when, in fact, homosexuality is a psycho-sexual disorder and homosexual behavior is abnormal and deviant.
@CatholicFaithInfo I really don't believe you can speak for all people who reject homosexual notions. There are PLENTY of people whose rejection IS irrational, and there are plenty who DO react to homosexuality in the same way an arachnophobe would react to a spider.
As for homosexuality being abnormal and deviant, that's only if you accept what you're proclaiming to be normal. Which frankly, isn't. Homosexuality has been around longer than Christianity.
@mb77sjd To accept homosexuality itself is irrational. Yes, homosexuality has been around longer than Christianity. That doesn't prove anything. Sin has been around longer than Christianity. Rape, theft and murder has been around longer than Christianity. So what? The point is homosexuality is a psycho-sexual disorder. For that reason, it is self-delusion and a disservice to oneself to call it good and normal. Human sexuality is meant to be expressed between a man and a woman in marriage only.
@CatholicFaithInfo And that "reason" no doubt would be somehow influenced by Christianity. So as a follower of Christianity, feel free not to be homosexual. Feel free in your faith not to have a same sex marriage. However, it should not impact you if people who want to have same sex marriages, can.
Clearly, not everyone shares your beliefs. If they did, then everyone would be opposed to marriage equality. But they're not, which is what this video is about. People want marriage equality.
@mb77sjd Actually, reason follows its own logic. By reason, we know that homosexuality is not normal, and homosexual behavior is deviant, and gay marriage is a perversion of true marriage which is only between a man and a woman. Unfortunately, many people don't want to be guided by reason. They only want to follow their own urges or lusts, regardless of the harm to themselves and others. The promotion/legalization of gay marriage is a grave disservice to society, and so, I speak out against it.
@CatholicFaithInfo the reason that we consider anything "normal" is because we are TAUGHT that it is so. Not because of reason. From a young age, girls are conditioned to like girly things, and boys are conditioned to be boys, for years and years, kids were told, because of your sacred text, NOT reason, that marriages should be between a man and a women. if anything, REASON is what's kicking in now, telling people that this is an injustice and marriage equality should exist.
@mb77sjd Male sexuality is only compatible with female sexuality. This is self-evident. This is normal. Male sexuality is not meant for another male sexuality or female sexuality for another female sexuality.
@CatholicFaithInfo If it wasn't "meant" to be, then why would it happen?
Legalising gay marriage IS about marriage equality, whether you believe it to be or not, because, this may have not have been apparent to you before, but not everyone believes what you do. :)
Legalising gay marriage has nothing to do with anything except for equality.
In my eyes, there's only one type of person who is a desservice to society.
@mb77sjd I did not use the phrase "meant to be". Theft, murder, lying, rape are things that happen. Just because something happens does not make it normal or right. Gay marriage will never be equal to traditional marriage because gay marriage is a perversion of true marriage which is the traditional marriage. Homosexual relationships can never be equal to heterosexual relationships because heterosexual relationships are normal, but homosexual relationships are abnormal.
@CatholicFaithInfo Thank you for your opinion. And what an opinion it is. An opinion with a strong base of opinion, smothered in a healthy dollop of opinion. Like an opinion tiramisu.
@CatholicFaithInfo I'm presuming your opinion on homosexuality is shaped around Aquinas' idea of natural law? If so, you would already know that this teaching is flawed as bisexual activity is rife within other species of animal.
@CatholicFaithInfo Clearly, what you class as "reason" is what you agree with. As far as I'm concerned, reason is what is telling people to think outside the box, go beyond what we've been told is "right" for centuries.
If gay marriage is legalised, the number of homosexuals is not going to go up... they're just going to be happier. Because they can proclaim their love like any other couple. Happier people could never be a disservice to society.
@mb77sjd Homosexuals are already living the homosexual lifestyle that they want. Legalizing gay marriage is not about equality. Legalizing gay marriage is about silencing and criminalizing any criticism of or opposition to the homosexual lifestyle. Gay marriage is a pretext for indoctrinating unwary children about homosexuality, and it's a pretext to justify anti-Christian bigotry. These things are a grave disservice to society.
@joshinho9 Truth, which is what I believe, is eternal, and so it will never crumble. Any victory you gain is temporary. It is bound to self-destruct as it is based on lies. Truth cannot help but emerge despite the lies that try to bury it.
I think the thing is, is that most people were brought up being told that when you love someone, you marry them. I'm sure very few parents added to that "... provided that the person you love is of the opposite sex"
I see people who get married on a whim, people who divorce & remarry multiple times to be far more an insult to the institute of marriage than the notion of gay marriage.
Marriage equality will happen one day. That's for certain.
Yes, jkdguy1 it's just your opinion is homophobic. By your logic Nazis are entitled to their opinion that jews should die... you should keep your hateful opinions to yourself... imo, which I am entitled to. btw, I am not gay.
Australia is a free country with a non religious government so why shouldn't gays be able to marry then? My main point in all of this is HOW DOES IT AFFECT YOU? it doesn't! You will still shit, eat, breathe and sleep the exact same. So maybe you should worry about whether your doing right by god as well as you possibly can, rather than innocent people who just want to be equal!
It's funny how you call it a perversion when the divorce rate only goes up more each year! The amount of married couples that practically get married for the sake of it these days is embarrassing. Now you have 2 women or men who want to be entitled to marriage to further express there love and devotion for each other and be entitled to the benefits of a marriage but you still believe it's only supposed to be between a man and a woman? How about, love and love?? Australia is
Also, I'm fairly sure that there are plenty of Christian who support gay marriage, are they hypocrites?
Samah Hadid is entitled to her own opinion, which may differ from what non-Muslims think a Muslim should believe.
If Samah Hadid did believe homosexuality was against Islam... that doesn't mean she can't speak in favour of gay marriage. Allowing gay marriage isn't going to force Muslims, or anyone to marry someone of the same sex.
@jkdguy1 Do you mean in general? Or during this discussion? Because I think it'd be inappropriate to try and be overly comedic in a situation as this. In general, well then I guess it depends on your taste?
Gay marriage is a perversion of the true concept of marriage which is between a man and a woman, as ordained by God. Homosexual relationships are immoral. Gay marriage should be opposed. Gay marriage is only a pretext to silence opposition to homosexual relationships by Christians and others. These gay people couldn't care less about marriage in itself. They only want to advance gay marriage as a tool to silence or criminalize any opposition to or criticism of their homosexual relationships.
@idaman12345 Actually, those pedophile priests came from the lot of homosexuals. That is yet another proof that homosexuality is a psycho-sexual disorder. It is a grave disservice to themselves when homosexuals deceive and delude themselves into thinking that homosexuality is good and normal. You can pretend all your life that there is no God. But you can never escape God's judgment. All of us will be judged by God and we will spend eternity either in Heaven with God or in Hell with the Devil.
@idaman12345 The pedophile priests were men and they molested boys. By the very definition of homosexuality, they were homosexuals. As for God's judgment, it will come at the end of our earthly lives. You are free, of course, to reject Heaven. Just realize that by doing so, you are choosing Hell for eternity. No one will force you to choose Heaven. And no one will force you to choose Hell. You make the choice for yourself.
@idaman12345 Apparently, they are homosexual pedophiles since they went after same-sex minors. I have no problem conceding that there are heterosexual pedophiles who obviously go after opposite-sex minors. But in the case of such pedophile priests who went after same-sex minors, that makes them homosexual pedophiles.
@idaman12345 What studies??? In any case, Catholic priests have access to both boys and girls. Such priests hear confessions of both boys and girls, which gives them access to both boys and girls. Yet these pedophile priests chose only the boys to molest, and not the girls, which, thus, debunks whatever studies you're referring to, and which proves that such pedophile priests were homosexual pedophiles.
@idaman12345 Clearly, you've run out of "seemingly" rational arguments, and so you've resorted to evasion and outright irrationality. You claimed such studies, so you ought to name them yourself. But if you can't, that's probably because such studies are either non-existent or they are thoroughly full of lies. So, "men of the cloth" can't be homosexual? Either you're honestly ignorant about avowed homosexual priests, or you're simply being outright irrational, without realizing it, of course.
Sammah is amazing and whether or not you agree with gay marriage, she stands for exactly what a muslim is; A beautiful person with a smart mind. She's no hypocrite, she's just not prejudice as I'm sure she has copped it all of her life.
@shotgundorothy as a muslim the answer is simple, we don't live in a shariah state so we cant implement shariah law, and samah is representing the wider communities beliefs and not her own.
I love how Sammah Hadid supports gay "marriage" when she's supposedly a muslim.
She's one of the UN's token "good little muslims" who's purpose is to try and make the rest of us forget that Islam is really a murderous religion of death.
In other words, what I'm trying to say is she's a complete hypocrite.
Western laws : allow gay marriage + allow wars against weak countries + allow drugs and alcohol + allow prostitution and pornography + allow relations between man and woman without marriage + allow have and sell weapons + allow kids to put their parents on old-house + allow racism and Nazism + destroy the planet and the nature by atomic tests + spying the calls + force the Usury + publish lies in medias = that is simply the law of devil
Auzubillah' that murtad munafiq so called' muslim' woman is the same girl who try argue agasint me on 60 mins.how dare she go AGAISNT what Shari'ah sais.HOMOSEXUALITY IS A MAJOR SIN OF THE MAJOR SINS. She is NOT Muslim. Ibrahim Siddiq-Conlon
The girl who said it's "what we all want." I disagree with, not everyone in Australia wants gay marriage to be legalised (I mean I do, I support it), but Josh said 63% of Australians support it according to polls and 74% of Labor voters want to see it, so not everyone wants it but a majority do.
@spogee its a common hyperbole on political issues to say "we all" when referring to the majority. it's a personal frustration of mine from this episode as well and I think it made what she said a little less valid, because she didn't clarify it...
but overall what she said is still accurate. The majority, especailly the vast majority of youth, are in support
Just because Josh Thomas is a comedian doesn't mean he's not entitled to have and share his opinion. Amazingly, comedians do think of things other than jokes.
Samah Hadid is an inspiration, also.
I'm glad my generation has people like these to represent us.
The Muslim here is bewildered when it comes to why we don't allow gay marriage. How odd... considering homosexual acts are worthy of death under Shari'ah law. Or will I be called Islamophobic if I call her out on this?
@nathanielscarlethawe Unsure if you are trolling, because of how ignorant your generalising comment is.
"The Muslim here" is Samah Hadid - look her up. She is quite well-known, and amazingly articulate and intelligent, and has achieved so much.
As much as it might surprise you with your limited worldview, there is more than one facet to peoples' personalities. Don't discriminate until you have actually had a look at the individual.
So yeah, I'm not calling you islamophobic. Just retarded.
@jackandrewl Oh please. Islam is as much a political ideology as it is a religion. I don't have to "know" her to understand her religion. This is NOT about personality. I have read the bigoted text she submits to.
@nathanielscarlethawe Lv 20-13 And if a man has sex relations with a man, the two of them have done a disgusting thing: let them be put to death; their blood will be on them
@thetruthisoutnow i cahhlenge u to say that front of ur Father at church or street : i challenge u to stop celebrating christian holidays : like ur own birthday
@mb77sjd - Samah says "they're not actually heeding what opinion polls are telling us". She supports the use of opinion polls when it suits her, then denies the polls on a carbon tax. Hypocrite!
How does one man putting his junk in another mans anus a right?
Sullivan9120 1 week ago
@Sullivan9120 how is a man putting his penis in a woman's vagina a right?
wanderlust342 4 days ago
also he's a lot smarter than he seems on other shows.
bellsxx7 1 week ago
"I just want a toaster..." hahaha so good!
bellsxx7 1 week ago
Give gays the right to legal union, but it will never be marriage. Marriage = Man + woman. This doesn't deserve to be on the national agenda at all. This topic is used by leftist governments as a distraction from the poor job they are otherwise doing
angus1000001 2 months ago
I'm a firm believer in minding one's own business. If gay couples want to get married, then why stop them? It's not going to kill you.
ecermusic 2 months ago
@ecermusic Thanks and God bless you :)
k283cst 1 month ago
And, stop shifting the focus of pedophilia to the Gays. You're placing less scrutiny on other pedophiles who happen to be straight, or have no adult sexual orientation. (Yes I know this is somewhat oversimplified) You're just enabling other pedophiles. Is the psychological well being of children less important than scaring other people into "hating" gays? Seriously?
Even if pedophilia is found to be "in born" they are harming children. Not the general Gay person. THAT is the difference.
randomaussiegurl1 3 months ago 2
I cannot believe some of the comments on this forum. Actually, being Youtube, I kind of can. It's hard for me to stomach that Christians, of all people, are in favor of oppressing people. Shouldn't you guys be out there working for charity and giving to the poor?
Also, an alarming comment suggested that because a man molested a young boy he was gay! Would like to point out that that is a common misconception. Adult sexual orientation often doesn't coincide with the attraction of the pedophile.
randomaussiegurl1 3 months ago 3
2:07 bullshit.. the opinion polls are rigged and fabricated as is the usual case by left side of politics. Take a poll anywhere outside of all the gay communities in the main cities. Typically this is why we have such a mess in this country with politicians and the media pandering to minority groups.
MrBITS101 4 months ago
@MrBITS101 Funny how people claim that opinion polls are rigged when it supports gay marriage but opinion polls are evidence the government should be booted out because it says there is no support for the carbon tax. So which is it? You can't have it both ways.
thuylinhvivien 3 months ago
Comment removed
unreal672010 6 months ago
@unreal672010
Make it official by law, by the law of an open mind, by the law of common sense.
We're lacking in the common sense department here, aren't we?
Technikian 5 months ago
@unreal672010 wow, you Australians are real rednecks aren't you?
leptismagna10 5 months ago
@leptismagna10 We're following the Right Wing Americans for some reason. It's like we are afraid of evolving as a culture... oh wait I just evolution, that's why we aren't allowed to grow up.
shotgunreaper 5 months ago
@leptismagna10 Na bro most of Australia is fine with Gay marriage- unfortunately all countries however have some stupid fuckers who go around preaching their stupid creationist ideals on others. Dont judge all australians by these homophobes
GOOdGuyGreg1 2 months ago
Has Samah seen the polls of what the Muslim community think of her stance?
seemoretube 6 months ago
When will we legalise consensual polygamy? I'm not gay and don't want to marry a man, but I think that having two or three wives would be fun and an enriching experience for all. Who is with me?
seemoretube 6 months ago
thumbs up if gay fags need to become extinct
SlideWaysAllTheTime 6 months ago
Gay, Stright.Bi, Lesbian, white.Black, Hell even diffrent religions Let them get married it's there life they have the right to choose if that other person make them happy then is say go for it congratulations. At the end of the day There not harming u by getting married and people who don't like it deal with it stuff in life happens that you don't like Its part of living.
XXanimeemoangelXX 6 months ago
Yeah, it's all about WHAT I WANT!!! right? The world would be so much better if we all just did WHATEVER I WANT!!! IT MAKES MEEEEE HAPPY SO IT'S CORRECT! Being gay is a sick side effect from a culture that screams ME ME ME!!! If you look into the past of every "gay" person. You'll find a reason they're acting this way. WHY, would we have "man" and "woman" if we are suppose to be gay??? Why in every culture, in every human society on earth, has this been SICK and WRONG to do??? Why?
GuamKomudo 6 months ago
@GuamKomudo Who are you to judge people if they are happy io really don't see how two guys or girls getting married affects you and if god makes everything then he must of made gays ^ ^
XXanimeemoangelXX 6 months ago
He did not create gays. He created human beings who have created their own cultures and mindsets. "Who are you to judge people" "How does it affect you?" THIS is what's wrong with this modern world... You people think it's all about "ME" "I FEEL GOOD" Being gay is a side effect of a culture that screams LOOK AT ME because my parents won't! Gay is NOT a natural thing, it is NOT accepted in ANY culture or country of ANY time period or species on earth, WHY??? Tell me why this is.
GuamKomudo 6 months ago
@GuamKomudo It's not just human's that are gay, pig's and chickens and other anmals have been known sometimes to be gay. honestly what has a gay person ever done to you. I am stright and part of being british american or modern cultures is the right to choose. I have gay friends and there exactly like my stright friends they still have feelings.
XXanimeemoangelXX 6 months ago
That's all bull. Pigs and chickens don't even have the concept of "love" They just do what they do to survive, so that's ruled out... You act like I hate gay people, stop playing the "Oh poor me! A Christian devil is hurting me! Oh no!!!" Seriously get over yourself I don't hate anyone, or treat gay people ANY differently than anyone else. This is what I'm hearing."I don't know the answer, but I do what I want, whenever I want and what feels good in the moment is right. I DO WHAT I WANT!"
GuamKomudo 6 months ago
Group rights are a nonsense. When the 'sex' in marriage doesn't matter...why should the number....why not fred and alan marrying steve, billy bob and sarah?? come on don't be such an Arithmophobe!!!!
anyway, must go...let me know when you find that naughty elusive gay gene!!!!!
ulsterscot 6 months ago
I like Ron Paul's position on this. We don't have rights because we are gays, black, or any minority group, we have rights because we are individuals, We all have the right to do what we want as long as we don't harm anyone else.
Why should Government define marriage at all?
LibertarianChristian 6 months ago 23
@LibertarianChristian
Unfortunately I don't see the Republican party letting him support gay rights or some other minorites. It's not just the candidate's views, its also the party behind the candidate's views that matters.
Marictdude 5 months ago
I am honestly disgusted by the comments on this video. Most of you are a bunch of ignorant, minded fools who are scared of things that are different to them. If it were women fighting for equal pay I'm sure you would support it, equality between sexes is no different to equality in marriages.
Your opinions are uninformed and ignorant.
samesides 6 months ago 14
@samesides sadly i'm prety sure a lot of these people don't believe it women's rights either.
sparksfly44 5 months ago
@sparksfly44 Womens rights? mate no time for jokes,this is a serious discussion here.
GOOdGuyGreg1 2 months ago
What people don't realise is Marriage is a spiritual event and not don't allow same sex.
A legal marriage is not a marriage it's a union recognized in law for benefits or cons.
What is dangerous is if gays are allowed marriage then they will be awarded the right to adopt and promote their mental disorder on the child.
PeekyBooo 6 months ago
@PeekyBooo are you so ignorant that you believe that being homosexual is a mental disorder? if we follow your logic, i think you shouldn't be allowed to have children or else they may end up just as ignorant and homophobic as you.
samesides 6 months ago
@samesides Explain why homosexuality isn't a mental disorder. ..and don't give me this tripe about science says so. Science is just a cash-for-comments fraternity these days. Also Kinsey was a paedophile so even he is no authority on the subject.
Faeces love is sickening and a disorder. The quicker people are helped the better not fostered in their disorder.
PeekyBooo 6 months ago
@PeekyBooo I pity you, all the people that know you and any child you have.
samesides 6 months ago
@samesides Don't be ridiculous.
PeekyBooo 6 months ago
@PeekyBooo fuck you
bellisthebomb 6 months ago
Rplende: your a narrow minded fool, locked in a box of bullshit. You have no idea what your talking about so shut the fuck up! Moron!
pjwhyte75 6 months ago
HEY JOSH, WHEN YOUR BALL'S DROP AND YOU GROW SOME PUBE'S AND GET SOME REAL LIFE EXPERIENCE, THEN MAYBE WE MIGHT TAKE SOME NOTICE OF YOU, UNTIL THEN SHUT THE FUCK UP.
suckmybigbootsa 6 months ago
gillard really knows how to make an equal society!
ligerindisguise 7 months ago
Homosexuals are their own worst enemy! It is not natural and you know it. The fact that you have to use a condom to protect yourself from disease proves it is not natural. The safest natural sex is between monogamous male/female relationships. They don't need so much protection from diseases. This alone tells you that it is right and natural. Their may be rare insances of disease occurring for whatever reason but they are the safest sex practitioners.
rplende 7 months ago
@rplende As you are referring to anal sex can I just point something out! Homosexuality is not just about sex. some gay couples don't even engage in anal sex! Homosexuality means you are attracted to a member of the same sex, you have emotional feeling for them, you experience love. Plus anal sex is not just a gay practice, straight couples can do it to! and a lot do actually. Yes it might not be the most natural thing in the world but the fact we can do it says something about our evolution!
babyfacerossy 7 months ago
@rplende You're missing the part where straight people do anal and gay people perform fellatio. Saying that different gender pairings require different levels of safety doesn't make you right, just narrow minded.
krusher00 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@rplende SHUT THE FUCK UP. Gays are BORN gay.
LoganStickly22 7 months ago
Do you support liberty + freedom? then it's alright to support gay marriage.
fabes0011 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why do gay people, want to follow hetro people into something like marriage?? why can't gay people just be content with having a civil partnership, that includes the same legal rights as a marriage does for heterosexuals? i'll tell you why, because most gay people these days have no individuality or imagination, they are so influenced and controlled by mind-numbing political correctness, pop culture, celebrity worship and consumerism, that marriage seems almost exotic & desirable, how sad!
ChaseTheDub 7 months ago
Josh Thomas, absolute genious! I really don't understand why gay marriage isn't legal, there is nothing wrong with it! Marriage should be because you love someone, it shouldn't be just between male and female... that is just so wrong if you ask me. It doesn't matter who you are, you should be able to marry any one you want. The law should be changed!
dogzloverz 8 months ago
@jkdguy1 I totally agree! I thought I would read in interesting discussion not mudslinging!
coconuts15 8 months ago
Great Points. Great Arguments. Great Anecdotes. There is no flaw in this argument.
twilightsoccer14 8 months ago
As for homophobia, it is as much a misnomer as it is a myth. A phobia is an irrational fear of something. Those that reject homosexual notions are not afraid of homosexuals and their rejection of such homosexual notions are not irrational. If anything is irrational, it is the belief that homosexuality is normal and good, when, in fact, homosexuality is a psycho-sexual disorder and homosexual behavior is abnormal and deviant.
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo I really don't believe you can speak for all people who reject homosexual notions. There are PLENTY of people whose rejection IS irrational, and there are plenty who DO react to homosexuality in the same way an arachnophobe would react to a spider.
As for homosexuality being abnormal and deviant, that's only if you accept what you're proclaiming to be normal. Which frankly, isn't. Homosexuality has been around longer than Christianity.
mb77sjd 8 months ago
@mb77sjd To accept homosexuality itself is irrational. Yes, homosexuality has been around longer than Christianity. That doesn't prove anything. Sin has been around longer than Christianity. Rape, theft and murder has been around longer than Christianity. So what? The point is homosexuality is a psycho-sexual disorder. For that reason, it is self-delusion and a disservice to oneself to call it good and normal. Human sexuality is meant to be expressed between a man and a woman in marriage only.
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo according to what?
mb77sjd 8 months ago
@mb77sjd According to God as contained in His Divine Revelation which has been entrusted to the Catholic Church and also according to reason.
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo And that "reason" no doubt would be somehow influenced by Christianity. So as a follower of Christianity, feel free not to be homosexual. Feel free in your faith not to have a same sex marriage. However, it should not impact you if people who want to have same sex marriages, can.
Clearly, not everyone shares your beliefs. If they did, then everyone would be opposed to marriage equality. But they're not, which is what this video is about. People want marriage equality.
mb77sjd 8 months ago
Comment removed
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@mb77sjd Actually, reason follows its own logic. By reason, we know that homosexuality is not normal, and homosexual behavior is deviant, and gay marriage is a perversion of true marriage which is only between a man and a woman. Unfortunately, many people don't want to be guided by reason. They only want to follow their own urges or lusts, regardless of the harm to themselves and others. The promotion/legalization of gay marriage is a grave disservice to society, and so, I speak out against it.
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo the reason that we consider anything "normal" is because we are TAUGHT that it is so. Not because of reason. From a young age, girls are conditioned to like girly things, and boys are conditioned to be boys, for years and years, kids were told, because of your sacred text, NOT reason, that marriages should be between a man and a women. if anything, REASON is what's kicking in now, telling people that this is an injustice and marriage equality should exist.
mb77sjd 7 months ago
@mb77sjd Male sexuality is only compatible with female sexuality. This is self-evident. This is normal. Male sexuality is not meant for another male sexuality or female sexuality for another female sexuality.
CatholicFaithInfo 7 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo If it wasn't "meant" to be, then why would it happen?
Legalising gay marriage IS about marriage equality, whether you believe it to be or not, because, this may have not have been apparent to you before, but not everyone believes what you do. :)
Legalising gay marriage has nothing to do with anything except for equality.
In my eyes, there's only one type of person who is a desservice to society.
mb77sjd 7 months ago
@mb77sjd I did not use the phrase "meant to be". Theft, murder, lying, rape are things that happen. Just because something happens does not make it normal or right. Gay marriage will never be equal to traditional marriage because gay marriage is a perversion of true marriage which is the traditional marriage. Homosexual relationships can never be equal to heterosexual relationships because heterosexual relationships are normal, but homosexual relationships are abnormal.
CatholicFaithInfo 7 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo Thank you for your opinion. And what an opinion it is. An opinion with a strong base of opinion, smothered in a healthy dollop of opinion. Like an opinion tiramisu.
CalmBlue 7 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo I'm presuming your opinion on homosexuality is shaped around Aquinas' idea of natural law? If so, you would already know that this teaching is flawed as bisexual activity is rife within other species of animal.
Phobixa 7 months ago
@Phobixa My opinion is based both on reason and divine revelation. I also would not regard animals as models for human conduct.
CatholicFaithInfo 7 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo Clearly, what you class as "reason" is what you agree with. As far as I'm concerned, reason is what is telling people to think outside the box, go beyond what we've been told is "right" for centuries.
If gay marriage is legalised, the number of homosexuals is not going to go up... they're just going to be happier. Because they can proclaim their love like any other couple. Happier people could never be a disservice to society.
mb77sjd 7 months ago
@mb77sjd Homosexuals are already living the homosexual lifestyle that they want. Legalizing gay marriage is not about equality. Legalizing gay marriage is about silencing and criminalizing any criticism of or opposition to the homosexual lifestyle. Gay marriage is a pretext for indoctrinating unwary children about homosexuality, and it's a pretext to justify anti-Christian bigotry. These things are a grave disservice to society.
CatholicFaithInfo 7 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo
Keep clinging to your beliefs as they crumble around you.
joshinho9 7 months ago
@joshinho9 Truth, which is what I believe, is eternal, and so it will never crumble. Any victory you gain is temporary. It is bound to self-destruct as it is based on lies. Truth cannot help but emerge despite the lies that try to bury it.
CatholicFaithInfo 7 months ago
I think the thing is, is that most people were brought up being told that when you love someone, you marry them. I'm sure very few parents added to that "... provided that the person you love is of the opposite sex"
I see people who get married on a whim, people who divorce & remarry multiple times to be far more an insult to the institute of marriage than the notion of gay marriage.
Marriage equality will happen one day. That's for certain.
mb77sjd 8 months ago
Yes, jkdguy1 it's just your opinion is homophobic. By your logic Nazis are entitled to their opinion that jews should die... you should keep your hateful opinions to yourself... imo, which I am entitled to. btw, I am not gay.
wonderdogsixtynine 8 months ago
Australia is a free country with a non religious government so why shouldn't gays be able to marry then? My main point in all of this is HOW DOES IT AFFECT YOU? it doesn't! You will still shit, eat, breathe and sleep the exact same. So maybe you should worry about whether your doing right by god as well as you possibly can, rather than innocent people who just want to be equal!
BiankaEliaz 8 months ago 2
@CatholicFaithInfo
It's funny how you call it a perversion when the divorce rate only goes up more each year! The amount of married couples that practically get married for the sake of it these days is embarrassing. Now you have 2 women or men who want to be entitled to marriage to further express there love and devotion for each other and be entitled to the benefits of a marriage but you still believe it's only supposed to be between a man and a woman? How about, love and love?? Australia is
BiankaEliaz 8 months ago
I don't see how people call samah a Muslim good or bad. Muslim is a person who submits to Gods words not following what you think is right....
Stop calling her a Muslim she dosent deserve that title..
TruthWithProof 8 months ago
Also, I'm fairly sure that there are plenty of Christian who support gay marriage, are they hypocrites?
Samah Hadid is entitled to her own opinion, which may differ from what non-Muslims think a Muslim should believe.
If Samah Hadid did believe homosexuality was against Islam... that doesn't mean she can't speak in favour of gay marriage. Allowing gay marriage isn't going to force Muslims, or anyone to marry someone of the same sex.
Just those who want to.
mb77sjd 8 months ago
@mb77sjd well, no one is being forced. You know what I meant.
mb77sjd 8 months ago
@jkdguy1 Do you mean in general? Or during this discussion? Because I think it'd be inappropriate to try and be overly comedic in a situation as this. In general, well then I guess it depends on your taste?
mb77sjd 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Gay marriage is a perversion of the true concept of marriage which is between a man and a woman, as ordained by God. Homosexual relationships are immoral. Gay marriage should be opposed. Gay marriage is only a pretext to silence opposition to homosexual relationships by Christians and others. These gay people couldn't care less about marriage in itself. They only want to advance gay marriage as a tool to silence or criminalize any opposition to or criticism of their homosexual relationships.
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo unless one of them is under 12 years old according to the church
MamaMario13 8 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo marriage has never and will never be ordained by a fictional creature
and you should rename it pedophilefaithinfo, fits just as well
idaman12345 8 months ago
@idaman12345 Actually, those pedophile priests came from the lot of homosexuals. That is yet another proof that homosexuality is a psycho-sexual disorder. It is a grave disservice to themselves when homosexuals deceive and delude themselves into thinking that homosexuality is good and normal. You can pretend all your life that there is no God. But you can never escape God's judgment. All of us will be judged by God and we will spend eternity either in Heaven with God or in Hell with the Devil.
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo ID love to see proof that those priests were homosexual
seeing as most were straight and most pedophiles are straight
As for gods judgement will that h the one on Oct21st
L the one that was on May 21wt
Homosexuality, unlike catholics, are good and normal
idaman12345 8 months ago
Comment removed
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@idaman12345 The pedophile priests were men and they molested boys. By the very definition of homosexuality, they were homosexuals. As for God's judgment, it will come at the end of our earthly lives. You are free, of course, to reject Heaven. Just realize that by doing so, you are choosing Hell for eternity. No one will force you to choose Heaven. And no one will force you to choose Hell. You make the choice for yourself.
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo actually by definition that makes them pedophiles
homosexuals go for consenting adults for relationships
idaman12345 8 months ago
@idaman12345 Apparently, they are homosexual pedophiles since they went after same-sex minors. I have no problem conceding that there are heterosexual pedophiles who obviously go after opposite-sex minors. But in the case of such pedophile priests who went after same-sex minors, that makes them homosexual pedophiles.
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo studies show that pedophiles go after children whom they have easy access to, regardless of gender
idaman12345 8 months ago
@idaman12345 What studies??? In any case, Catholic priests have access to both boys and girls. Such priests hear confessions of both boys and girls, which gives them access to both boys and girls. Yet these pedophile priests chose only the boys to molest, and not the girls, which, thus, debunks whatever studies you're referring to, and which proves that such pedophile priests were homosexual pedophiles.
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
@CatholicFaithInfo look up the studies Google it
They were men of the cloth
therefore heterosexual
you're just believing the lies your cult has brainwashed you into believing
idaman12345 8 months ago
@idaman12345 Clearly, you've run out of "seemingly" rational arguments, and so you've resorted to evasion and outright irrationality. You claimed such studies, so you ought to name them yourself. But if you can't, that's probably because such studies are either non-existent or they are thoroughly full of lies. So, "men of the cloth" can't be homosexual? Either you're honestly ignorant about avowed homosexual priests, or you're simply being outright irrational, without realizing it, of course.
CatholicFaithInfo 8 months ago
Sammah is amazing and whether or not you agree with gay marriage, she stands for exactly what a muslim is; A beautiful person with a smart mind. She's no hypocrite, she's just not prejudice as I'm sure she has copped it all of her life.
BiankaEliaz 8 months ago
@shotgundorothy as a muslim the answer is simple, we don't live in a shariah state so we cant implement shariah law, and samah is representing the wider communities beliefs and not her own.
akberymo 8 months ago
I love how Sammah Hadid supports gay "marriage" when she's supposedly a muslim.
She's one of the UN's token "good little muslims" who's purpose is to try and make the rest of us forget that Islam is really a murderous religion of death.
In other words, what I'm trying to say is she's a complete hypocrite.
shotgundorothy 8 months ago
@shotgundorothy No-one cares. Go be hateful somewhere else.
azyeennekun 8 months ago
Western laws : allow gay marriage + allow wars against weak countries + allow drugs and alcohol + allow prostitution and pornography + allow relations between man and woman without marriage + allow have and sell weapons + allow kids to put their parents on old-house + allow racism and Nazism + destroy the planet and the nature by atomic tests + spying the calls + force the Usury + publish lies in medias = that is simply the law of devil
EagleClawHere 8 months ago
Auzubillah' that murtad munafiq so called' muslim' woman is the same girl who try argue agasint me on 60 mins.how dare she go AGAISNT what Shari'ah sais.HOMOSEXUALITY IS A MAJOR SIN OF THE MAJOR SINS. She is NOT Muslim. Ibrahim Siddiq-Conlon
Sharia4Australia 8 months ago
The girl who said it's "what we all want." I disagree with, not everyone in Australia wants gay marriage to be legalised (I mean I do, I support it), but Josh said 63% of Australians support it according to polls and 74% of Labor voters want to see it, so not everyone wants it but a majority do.
spogee 8 months ago
@spogee its a common hyperbole on political issues to say "we all" when referring to the majority. it's a personal frustration of mine from this episode as well and I think it made what she said a little less valid, because she didn't clarify it...
but overall what she said is still accurate. The majority, especailly the vast majority of youth, are in support
anyankafan 8 months ago
@anyankafan Ah, thank you. :)
spogee 8 months ago
Gay, straight, black, white, marriage IS a CIVIL RIGHT
iampandaful 8 months ago 16
Go Josh! Well said. Also, I love how at the end of his spiel he did his classic nervous hair ruffle. :D
angiepie111 8 months ago 6
so, so, so much respect for him right now!
xooxGemmxoox 8 months ago 5
@jkdguy1 Shhhhhhhh, big people are talking now : )
DawnOfTheCrazy 8 months ago
Josh Thomas is absolutely wonderful!! :)
TheRedElephant12 8 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@jkdguy1 You're not very bright, are you
Lunchb0xbadger 8 months ago
I love that, "I just want a toaster!" But in all seriousness, it is a bit ridiculous that gay marriage still isn't allowed. Very well said, Josh.
amandajoyceisabella 8 months ago 2
i wish they would stop calling it "Gay Marriage"
it's MARRIAGE EQUALITY. Nothing gay about it.
it's time for Equal Rights... NOW.
TabloidJunk 8 months ago 4
I'm impressed.
gundamanda 8 months ago
I love Josh Thomas. he is amazing. He is hilarious, and after being there and hearing him, I know he is smart and I love him even more!
SnailSays 8 months ago
Well said.
gellybarbados92 8 months ago
@jkdguy1 you're a fucking narrow-minded idiot.
charlmeister1 8 months ago
@jkdguy1 your comment is a waste of space.
zuniguy1 8 months ago 2
Just because Josh Thomas is a comedian doesn't mean he's not entitled to have and share his opinion. Amazingly, comedians do think of things other than jokes.
Samah Hadid is an inspiration, also.
I'm glad my generation has people like these to represent us.
mb77sjd 8 months ago 60
The Muslim here is bewildered when it comes to why we don't allow gay marriage. How odd... considering homosexual acts are worthy of death under Shari'ah law. Or will I be called Islamophobic if I call her out on this?
nathanielscarlethawe 8 months ago
@nathanielscarlethawe Unsure if you are trolling, because of how ignorant your generalising comment is.
"The Muslim here" is Samah Hadid - look her up. She is quite well-known, and amazingly articulate and intelligent, and has achieved so much.
As much as it might surprise you with your limited worldview, there is more than one facet to peoples' personalities. Don't discriminate until you have actually had a look at the individual.
So yeah, I'm not calling you islamophobic. Just retarded.
jackandrewl 8 months ago
@jackandrewl Oh please. Islam is as much a political ideology as it is a religion. I don't have to "know" her to understand her religion. This is NOT about personality. I have read the bigoted text she submits to.
nathanielscarlethawe 8 months ago
@jackandrewl No she's not intelligent. She's a complete moron.
shotgundorothy 8 months ago
@nathanielscarlethawe Lv 20-13 And if a man has sex relations with a man, the two of them have done a disgusting thing: let them be put to death; their blood will be on them
EagleClawHere 8 months ago
@EagleClawHere -- Your God is fake so nothing you say holds any water!
thetruthisoutnow 8 months ago
@thetruthisoutnow i cahhlenge u to say that front of ur Father at church or street : i challenge u to stop celebrating christian holidays : like ur own birthday
EagleClawHere 8 months ago
@mb77sjd - Samah says "they're not actually heeding what opinion polls are telling us". She supports the use of opinion polls when it suits her, then denies the polls on a carbon tax. Hypocrite!
C3H8E30 7 months ago
@C3H8E30 She is a little shithead
imeqsmd 7 months ago
@jkdguy1 at least he's smart. unlike most of the political fucks they bring on most of the time.
2000Anthem 8 months ago 3
He is amazing.
BeckiieAnne 8 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Muslim support for gay marriage?
johndoe101088 8 months ago
Yes. He was a waste of space -_- He said incredibly smart things with facts to back them up. Definitely a waste Of space
anyankafan 8 months ago 46