Selena Gomez - Who Says Live in Hollywood, CA at Concert For Hope 3/20/11

[beiberfever73]

Maybe she can't sing but she's not the worst stop hating on her cuz she's doing wat she loves

[JRemixing]

She stood in front of 30 thousand people and had them singing the entire time. Don't comment saying she can't sing. Obviously she can because it wasn't no small town bar she was performing at. Amuses me how many people are so jelous of her power and ability that they need to slam her in any way possible. Who says your not worth it? I do, because haters gon' hate.

[mariaqintas]

C'mon guys she hasn't an amazing voice like Adele or Beyoncé but she can sing. I can't, and prbably you can't too. So shut up. She is doing what she loves. Stop hate.

[madyeful]

fuck bebeir



[madyeful]

fuck bebeir



[madyeful]

fuck bebeir



[madyeful]

beiber sucks



[BreatheOnMiley]

i like this song, i really like, but not in her voice. i came watch her, because i didn't knew if she can or not sing live, so i came watch, and, wow! she sucks

[BreatheOnMiley]

@CarebearAlyssa Oh, i dont have any reason to be jealous. i am not a belieber, what is your arrgument now, selenator?

[BreatheOnMiley]

@sellyluver MILEY CANT SING? Hahhahaha go kill your self bitch, go burn in hell, please.

[flyingbunny1115]

Its not that shes a bad singer, her music video is amazing! maybe its just the reception cuz her voice in this was a bit off key

[PilarArmely]

she is a horrible singer

[CarebearAlyssa]

@ BreatheOnMiley Shut up! Only reason you hate is because you are jealous!

[CarebearAlyssa]

"Who says? Who says your not perfect? Who says you not worth it? Who says you the only one that's heard it? Tell me who says? Yeah who says?"

Hannah Montana says! "Nobody's perfect! You live and you learn it even if I mess it up sometimes! Nobody's perfect!"

[Barbarossa1119]

Some of my friends said that Selena Gomez is not a good live sound. This is absolutely not true, of course, that other is a studio recording, concert and an amateur recording. The benefit of my friends to say that their favorite Justin Bieber, whom I, well, well ... Let it stay so far as to say the least that Justin was not sting.

[Sasjalove1]

She's so beautiful!

Every girl wants to be here!

Love her

End we will support here 4 ever

Nobody can hate her

And i will always be here fan!

xxx me

[BreatheOnMiley]

she cant sing, omg

[sellyluver]

@BreatheOnMiley FUCK OFF !!UR MILEY CANT SING.

[Ddmarryss]

she obviously cant sing.. and i dont like her music.. too childish..

[TeamCyrusTurkey]

@TheTanbar121 Don't worry, I'm enough clever to get that Selena can't sing live!

[1themusicgurl]

I think this is as good as it gets. I love her but she can't sing , she needs to stick to acting. She still doesn't know how to belt out and when she does the high notes her voice cracks... she's not that bad but i still think professional singers should be people that can REALLY sing... #JustSayin'

[MsChavez10]

I was there at that concert it was my birthday gift from my mom but they only thing that suck was that we were at the back row and i mean were we leave te concert but it was the best gift i have ever gotten i love my mom so much she gave me this bcuz she knows that i like selena but bcuz i earned it by buying her love but she was blesses right i would never say i want a diff mom!!!! Love yu mom!!:)

[Keellyy12]

she isnt a great singer? so what?? she could have just stuck to acting? thats when i loved her....

[ScarlettLopes]

Love Love much !

[godorahi]

She is a great singer!!!! Lol

[MrUniqueunknown]

she isn't just learning singing now , her singing career began years ago.

[demi123120]

even i can sing better than her :( but that dosent meane i don't love her :)

[MrsShiningSHINee]

She can't sing? Then what is this, talking with a melody?

[kittenlover23Flower]

Selena gomez taught me dont wish to be anybody else your perfect the way u are no matter what

[xxxobsessed]

i was there (:

[ceejaebeepee]

she's pretty..yeah! not doubt..... that's it... singing is not for u..

[TheJonasEmpire]

Ouch. That just hurt my ear. 

[biancacosta00]

ridicula



[tkdchick1219]

@mightylot are you unique?

[syedtalut]

My phone keeps freezing up!

[pvankitha]

wow awesome awesome

[angel1babe11]

LOOOOOOOOOOOOVE her voice. <3

[tkdchick1219]

@magnus588

I don't know who you are or what you believe but think about it, this world is full of amazing life! This world was intricately designed! How do think that happened?? If it was just a big explosion there would be no design, but there is! Can't you see all of the amazing life around you?! From trees to flowers to animals and people! Do you seriously believe all of that could have come from some random explosion?! If you do then you just need logic! And I can't help you there. I know

[mightylot]

@tkdchick1219 It's not intricately designed why do you think the other planets close to us have no life because we are all results from a large explosion.

[788cami]

ALL YOU HATERS LISTEN UP!!! IT'S NOT FUNNY OR RIGHT TOO PUT SOMEONE DOWN FOR WHAT THEY DO,PPL NEED TO BE TREATED THE WAY U WOULD WANT TOO BE TREATED,AND THATS CALLED RESPECT! LEARN IT! OR BE QUITE! CUZ NO ONE ON THIS EARTH SHOULD NEVER BE PRESSURED OR PUT DOWN,OR TRY TOO BE PERFECT FOR SOMEONE ELSES STANDARDS,OR EXPECTATIONS.CUZ THATS JUST RUDE! AND INPOLITE! SO THINK ABOUT WHAT U SAY BEFORE U SAY SOMETHING!

[Katy1616ful]

I went to that concert it rocked.

SELENA GOMEZ<3<3

[blakester624]

@magnus588 You ask us to explain without using our "divinity shit." I would like to ask you to explain without using the guys in the lab coats. Oh and you spelled trust wrong.

[ushiny]

Fucking haters get fucking lyf,,,:@

[ThePLH12]

Why would she want to be anyone else?

[ThePLH12]

She says we have every right to a beautiful life, but from that singing, its hard to believe....thumbs up if you agree

[xxstellalovesxoxo]

i like selena, but she needs more practice in singing, 0:19 , my ears died. -__-

[daedori]

Don't worry Selena we appreciate your efforts to be on stage and sing for us XD

[MrAlexandreShark]

At least she's singing about hope.

[GoBeliebers]

she's an amazing actor but a terrible singer ;)

[icarlyfan2221]

wow shes a good singer. i still dont get the whole thing with selena and justin, i mean whats with that? how could a great singer be dating the worst singer in history? thumbs up if you agree!

[flyingcookie101]

@icarlyfan2221 Oh please, even Justin is better than Selena... and I loathe Justin's music, but at least he can stay on pitch sometimes.

[maree345]

@magnus588 or what the heck your name is...your being extremely disrespectful...if you believe in God is your choice but to bash the people who do and God himself is extremely rude and uncalled for...Selena is a Christian and believes in God so you need to be a little more respectful and think about what you say before you say it next time

[Rosettasilver]

She sing the best much better than shakira

[Gabrielita1210]

SO BAD, and that's an easy songg

[411SingingStar]

Yall Stop Hatin Damn Selena Is Ahmazingg :) Andd This Is A Hard Song To Sing So Shut The Fuk UP

[anle2209]

she should stop singing. She makes me sick

[642398]

God, God said I wasn't perfect.

[magnus588]

@642398 god doesnt exhist he's a figment of imagination just something for people to believe in something that explains why you are here

[642398]

@magnus588 Your mom doesnt exist

[magnus588]

@642398 then explain how i am here without using some sort of divinity shit you conjure up in your head to explain something you cant and never will understand. please enlighten me. i think id rather turst the dudes in labcoats who arent demanding i get up every sunday to overdress and apologize for being human. nobody has the right to be more divine than you or me more powerful. nobody has the right to hoard power or misuse it like your false god is

[642398]

@magnus588 your here because god made adam and eve then after millions of years your stupid self was born

[magnus588]

@642398 i said explain without using your divinity shit explain without using god or adam or eve or anything religious or supernatural. you will find that you cant which in turn explains religion people need something to believe in they need to feel wanted like they are special that they have a purpose but hav you ever thought you were here just becuase you could be?

[LouRdesLeguizaa143]

say selena 5x clap 5x

post this to two other videos and listen to your voice

[dixiechic5]

Good job!!! Love @/3x

[Albinohengst]

omg she can not sing

[AysoSoccerChick]

@Albinohengst wen she sings at a concert she has to kinda like sing while yelling so ppl can here her.

[SpitOnYourPalm]

you aint beautiful shit bitch

[khanhtrang1999]

her voice is so bad!!

[Handalmyglitterpuke]

She's hot but she can't sing to save her life.

[Kikketta11ify]

una delle mia canzoni preferite !!!

[tristan66611]

slena krpp going like that ur a gd singer and yes haters fuck off

[cyclicnut1]

Notice the crowd got louder when she said "The songs Who Says"?

[Neejan1]

Lovely.

[SYNackyshadz]

Detuned

[myimaginarymind]

'who says that you're not presidential?' brb, dying.

[pinkaliciousprincess]

Why so many haters?



[alinarobles11]

Shes good

[CurlyChelsey]

She had a cold when she sand at dancing with the stars okay?! She even admitted that she was terrible and when all those haters made fun of her she cried herself in her mothers arms! Direct words from her mum to the press, thats how fragile her heart is. Grow some and stop hating!

[HonestlyIMeanIt]

It's true, her voice isn't exactly what I would call a strong voice but she IS doing a lot of voice training and she has actually gotten a lot better and with all her hard work you can just imagine how great she's going to be as she keeps getting older.

She's adorable, she's sweet, she's a good role model... what about that wouldn't go far?

[johnjammy80]

@HonestlyIMeanIt well, if she's a talented songwriter like taylor swift(who also doesnt have the strongest voice but makes up for it with her beautifully written songs) it wouldnt be so bad. Taylor, holder of several grammy awards. enough said.

[15Karlito]

Selena Gomez: Who Says I Can't Sing? Answer: Everyone :))) she is good actor but she is just learning singing so yet she isn't singer

[TheCutepuppygirl]

@15Karlito Thats so true selena= Horrible singer. And a maybe 5% of a actress

[NovesJemi]

@15Karlito she is the best she's not need a the best voice of the world for she be perfect.

[10djc]

@15Karlito jk



[hudsonbeecham9898]

holy. cow. Ive never heard a singer go that flat and out of tune on stage- thats pretty bad...

[anchina12]

I love you Selena ♥

[fightformyheart]

She has a low voice

[TheDiebee]

Hi I'm 12 years old and I can sing better than her live -.-

[ladyjustin21]

Maybe the reason why she can't sing this who says here was because she sang many of her song and then she lack out of her voice.. Even other singer can't sing continuously, they also uses vocals for them to hide that they can't sing the whole song.. :)

[94nesh]

I love her...but duuuude, she can't sing at all

[imgayandobese]

i love how she cant do the nanananana part

[pinksnowcone11]

no sick person

[staiks94]

now listen to christina grimmie's cover of that song and tell me who is better :)

[blueworldable]

Haters can shut up. Do you know how hard it is to sing live with the whole microphone and running around and stuff. Cut her some slack.

[starflower1080]

because u can hear the same exact pitch reused in who says chorus

[starflower1080]

part of the song is real voice other half lipsyncing

[jbiloveyou1996]

I don't hate her, but to be honest she can't sing live.. The most of the time she lets the fans sing.. But she is awesome and pretty.. :) #fact

[sandravd1972]

ilike her dress.

[VanneLiindaBebitha08]

Haaaaaaaaaaaaaay la amo0 y a zZu guiitharriizZtha =

[H4CK38]

i love!

[SuperTajana]

She sounds like shit. I love her, but yeah she does,admit it. :3

[MsBridgetElizabeth]

Stage*

[MsBridgetElizabeth]

She doesn't have a strong voice but at least she has fun on swags

[emilyhcu13]

she not the best but,i gotta say she sings WAY better than me:)

[bakkist1]

HATERSU SUCK

[audreyelizabeth90]

This is a Selena Gomez video incase you havent noticed. Why are people swearing and hating and talking about sluts haha! She's effing adorable. And I agree the point of a concert is to run around and dance and have fun. People pay to see her sing live and put on a show which she is doing, whether it is perfect or not.

[NikkiInHollywood]

@laravinson33 how is that rule 1 about singing live...its a live concert...she should be running around and going crazy...if people wanted perfection they would just listen to the album and not spend money to see her

[wizardfairy]

i think selena would be better at singing if she didnt move around too much it just makes her breathless...im not singing she's bad but she could be better...

[tedmolcin1124]

Rude is all I can say u guys r just jealous of her she is beautiful

[Ninjafire7494]

Um, I think her voice is edited when it's not live T_T and with 2:32 SHIT she's off -.-

[Ninjafire7494]

0:51 oh shit is fails..

[jackajacob]

CHECK MY YOUTUBE CHANNEL OUT AND WATCH THE MUSIC VIDEO I MADE TO THIS VIDEO. THANKS

[herreracristhel2]

ill her notes are bad she cant even catch her breath and yea they were screaming cuz of her voice

[billupskevin]

she smiled at your camera:) And shes amazing!

[CaroCookie101]

what?! shes no beauty queen?

[soadoylekowtak]

shes better then Miley Cyrus.....Miley Cyrus is a striper or slut

[UnknownSince1996]

she fights with the music :/

[gaelle21]

Look haters selena shes nice and beautiful what did she ever do to u so chut the fucking hell up u little bitches got it i hop because selena is talented she has a heart to and ur comments are realy mean and when she see them she starts crying so fuck u haters ur just loosers and jalous so back the hell of u little bitches :)

[Ajay1143]

fake bitch. 

[Ajay1143]

i hate her.

[MarissaNicole0143]

Haters can go away! You're rude comments are unwanted! Selena likes what she does. She isn't a Facebook status. You don't have to like her. Love you Selena. (: ♥

[thankvivianitsfriday]

@MarissaNicole0143 you used the wrong "your."

I wouldn't call myself a hater but what bothers me is that she is getting paid millions of dollars as a mediocre singer, while actual talented, hard-working people aren't able to get a record deal because they don't have connections or a popstar boyfriend like Selena.

[MarissaNicole0143]

@thankvivianitsfriday Oh. My bad.

And Selena was famous before she was dating Justin. It bothers me that people think she's only famous because of Justin. Selena was signed before she was even dating Justin. And Selena is super hard working. How about you go on tour, perform for millions of people, go on talk shows, have no privacy, and work your butt off everyday to make fans happy. Selena is hard working and her voice is progressing

Let it be.

[TheAlternativeLy]

@thankvivianitsfriday agree....but I think she's been into singing before she dated justin

[MaxymilianSkalski]

I like her and I don't think that she was singing bad but I don't think it was perfect. I hate people like Llhrtpskppr

[Llhrtpskppr]

Don't try singing selena cuz youre a bad singer i hate u! ! Frm:miley fan forever!

[9597Sisters]

Che Schifo! :S

[zheng1221]

if you have something bad to say, don't say it! whats the point of making people feel bad? I mean, like, how would you feel if somebody said those mean things to you? weirdoes.........

[turkeyluvsu9]

It's funny cause half the people who are saying she can sing, most likely sing like shit themselves.

[smile102699]

It's not THAT bad...

[Larrieklarrie]

I wouldnt notice she would be a bad singer if you guys didnt said anything about her...? Wow.. no she is not a bad singer, and she's pretty, so what?

[ChelseaBelle715]

She's pretty and good at acting but this is bad singing. She should stick to acting singing just isn't her thing

[DeniseHMusic]

I think you all should stop being rude. I mean.. she's not the best singer but who cares? She does what she likes and people like it. I'm not a Selena Gomez fan but I can't understand what it gives to you to be the number one comment with saying she can't sing. If you don't like it, don't watch it. If you like to sing and people like it.. how would you feel if people write rude, pointless comments on youtube about you. Think you shouldn't waste your time with hurting people.

[TheAmyisthebest]

stick to acting

[JakobRobert00]

i always thought the can´t sing

and now THIS is the prove

lol she doesnt hit the notes and she sounds very insecure

[annetkho]

she is rlly nice en good :))

[vanessa0426]

shes really pretty but singing is just really not her thing :/

[cellphonegirl360]

O.O.Sh

[smallworlds3212]

sssina what the heck r u saying shes better than anyone in the whole world she has her own free will to do what she wants and i truly think she made a right choice sticking to singing this is her life she is perfect the way she is *keep dreaming girls and boys keep trying and believing it will work*

[JustinBieberIlayda]

I think she should stick to acting!

i didn't say she sings bad but she can't sing very good

but i still like U selena xD

[2205oliwia]

Selena ist The Best :):):):)

[teacherLOURDZ]

at least she's not lip synching

[dizi13]

@teacherLOURDZ thats true i hate stupid people who comes to live videos comparing playbacks vs pure voice???? i mean come on !! not that im a big fan of her but she's ok

[emarald13]

I wouldn't say she was a bad singer just not the best out there...she doesn't have a strong voice hers is more soft and I agree her notes are not long enough she kind of cuts them but I she can sing just not her strongest point, she suits acting better.

[darrafallcoocoo]

You know what? at least she tried. you don't see a lot of celebrities using their real voices on stage right: as for instants Britney Spears comes to my mind! but using negative comments won't get us anywhere. at least what we can do is pray for her to get better. And I love Selena Gomez as Alex and as many other characters. And if she loves to sing, then let her sing. There is no point neglecting her about it. but to agree, she could a bit better. but that doesn't mean i don't love her. go sel

[beautyzazo]

Awesome!

[RebekahKealoha]

It's HER song, so she can sing it however she wants -

[steveismylover]

No offense to Selena, I love this song and her voice on recordings, though her real live voice could be improved like some of you said, but I've never seen a live video of her singing the 'na na na' part... I wonders if it's because she can't really sing it and covers it up by making it a crowd sing along.

[Baby1592486]

Who says you can sing,Selena ?

[LittleMissAngel29]

seriously. she's not as bad as everyone seems to think.

having said that, there is quite a lot of room to improve.

[aoiyamichan]

i seriously wonder if justin beiber thinks shes a good singer or if hes like most of us and knows shes amateur at best

[jessicaBieber52]

she is so amazing! 

[Rehanamjad123]

Im touched

[xXForgivexForgetXx]

not bad...... i guess...... not VERY good.....

[Samina1496]

Whats wrong with her voice lol :/ she can do better!

[23RESAMI]

She sucks !

[msselenaglover]

0:49 Ugh! Awful!

[msselenaglover]

I was a Selena fan until now...

[EmanNaj]

going to her concert front row she is gorgeous bro!!!