No. I hate people who try to make their own rendition of the song. It's only meant to be an ORIGINAL piece....not a replica, shows how uncreative you are.
I've got one thing to say... wow! I've been playing piano for 13 years - this piece for about the same time and I've never heard such an awesome arrangement! Plus an amazing voice to go along with! From a music major... very well done!
Beautiful!!! The piano sounds overwhelmingly amazing!!! You do a fabulous job!! I don't know what these other smart pants are talking about! All I know is they're absolutely jealous. I hear no mistake in your music! Please keep posting! Absolutely wonderful!!!
Thank you so much for your flowering compliment. My playing is far from flawless, but I do try to play from my heart. I'm glad you enjoyed it! Best wishes.:)-M
You make the same mistake as so many other piansist/singers. You fail to play in an accompaniment style so your voice ends up competing with your melody line on the piano.
I have to agree with this man here. Nice performance, but many performers tend to play melody via voice and instrument, leading into competition, negation, and rendition (Some parts, negative; others, positive).
Great rendition. I noticed that from time to time you used measures of 4 while playing the piece in 3. Just wondered if that was planned or just part of the natural performance.
Nice piano playing, though the key you're singing in appears to be a strain for your range. Maybe try it in another key if you're able to transpose the song for voice. Good luck.
yeah, hitting a high e on the first note is a little tough. Thanks for your view and for your suggestion. I probably should have transposed it in the first place. Best wishes
Diana Krall does a version of this song I could listen to over and over again. This performance, is easily right next to hers. AMAZING job! I love your voice and the piano together
Hi Jan and Susan, thank you for watching my video and for taking the time to comment. Thank you Michael for being so kind to share my video. My very best to all of you.
this is by far the worst , and i mean the worst rendition of this song EVER!!!!!!!!!
MrBlackwater44 1 year ago
@MrBlackwater44 mean..
artiebarnes 3 months ago
GLORIOUS RESONATION OF THE PIANO
MichaelBoryAlis 1 year ago
beautiful
vonversace 1 year ago
bravo...
irish89055 1 year ago
No. I hate people who try to make their own rendition of the song. It's only meant to be an ORIGINAL piece....not a replica, shows how uncreative you are.
Zmario116 1 year ago
I love this masterful rendition. I wish I can improve playing this piece, saved best for the Christmas season.
jdmrchem5 1 year ago 2
nice
zozarbuddies111 1 year ago
٠•●♥ Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ ♥●•٠• Very nice, 5 stars ★★★★★
ErikaRagazzi 1 year ago
That was beautiful!!!!
pianogirl98 2 years ago 6
Best thing I heard this Christmas so far,very nice open sound Melanie,I think I'm falling in love with you
gat1240 2 years ago 5
Just lovely...thank you for giving me an lift on such a terrible day!
poltallach 2 years ago 5
You are truly an angel brought down from heaven...what a wonderful voice
AntonSoup 2 years ago 3
I've got one thing to say... wow! I've been playing piano for 13 years - this piece for about the same time and I've never heard such an awesome arrangement! Plus an amazing voice to go along with! From a music major... very well done!
casteratedsilence 2 years ago 3
wow so beautifull :D!!! ur vioce is so awsome! please post more song of charlie brown XD!
akamea10 2 years ago 3
WOW!!! I can tell you were playing from the heart....a mark of a true musician! LOVE IT!! *STANDING OVATION*
Grandhoohah 2 years ago 6
What a thoughtful message! I'm so glad you felt it come from my heart! That is what music should do. Best wishes!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
This really gets me in the xmas spirit and teary eyed. VERY BEAUTIFUL!!!!!! MERRY CHRISTMAS TO YOU MELANIE!!!
32nikral 2 years ago 3
she could have have left the singing out....lol
Ahmun1 2 years ago
Beautiful!!! The piano sounds overwhelmingly amazing!!! You do a fabulous job!! I don't know what these other smart pants are talking about! All I know is they're absolutely jealous. I hear no mistake in your music! Please keep posting! Absolutely wonderful!!!
ChristianLevite1 2 years ago 2
Thank you so much for your flowering compliment. My playing is far from flawless, but I do try to play from my heart. I'm glad you enjoyed it! Best wishes.:)-M
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Thanks Mel, have a Merry Christmas!!
ChristianLevite1 2 years ago
You make the same mistake as so many other piansist/singers. You fail to play in an accompaniment style so your voice ends up competing with your melody line on the piano.
SteveFallon1 2 years ago
I have to agree with this man here. Nice performance, but many performers tend to play melody via voice and instrument, leading into competition, negation, and rendition (Some parts, negative; others, positive).
Chrismonchan 2 years ago
Great rendition. I noticed that from time to time you used measures of 4 while playing the piece in 3. Just wondered if that was planned or just part of the natural performance.
conroto 2 years ago 2
I subbed btw XD
sk8erkid2007 2 years ago
AMAZING
sk8erkid2007 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Whoa, don't quit your day job.
Jmusicman25 2 years ago
Great job on a christmas classic.
blackcavalier 2 years ago
Thank you very much!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Nice piano playing, though the key you're singing in appears to be a strain for your range. Maybe try it in another key if you're able to transpose the song for voice. Good luck.
avalonmystic 3 years ago
yeah, hitting a high e on the first note is a little tough. Thanks for your view and for your suggestion. I probably should have transposed it in the first place. Best wishes
melaniejsnow 3 years ago
You are so flattering, thank you. I hope you had a wonderful Christmas!
melaniejsnow 3 years ago
I agree. This truly does remind me of Diana Krull's cover version. You're absolutely wonderful!
Arnie3659 3 years ago
Thank you for posting such a kind comment! I guess I should check out who Diana Krull is, Happy Holidays to you and best wishes!
melaniejsnow 3 years ago
Diana Krall does a version of this song I could listen to over and over again. This performance, is easily right next to hers. AMAZING job! I love your voice and the piano together
NikonPhoto07 3 years ago
Hi Mark, Thank you so much for such an encouraging comment. It means a lot to me. Happy Holidays!
melaniejsnow 3 years ago
Same to you Melanie!! Hope you have a chance to do some more holiday songs before Christmas :)
NikonPhoto07 3 years ago
Thank you to reliablebow for sharing your wonderful Christmas video! Stars and hugs..Jan and Susan.x
weeyin1155 3 years ago
Hi Jan and Susan, thank you for watching my video and for taking the time to comment. Thank you Michael for being so kind to share my video. My very best to all of you.
melaniejsnow 3 years ago
Hi Michael, What an encouraging comment to wake up to this morning. Thank you for your support. I hope you have a wonderful holiday season.
melaniejsnow 3 years ago
WOW! Lovely...beautiful...stirring...classic...ThankYou
reliablebow 3 years ago