-.-'' didn't the germans shoot a cannon hit into the bridge after the fail???!! Ludwing was pretty idiot .. anyway this general didn't not exists his real name 's Heinz Harmel commander of the 10 SS PZ division Frundsberg into the 2nd SS panzerkorps of Bittrich
@Trashcansam123 yes but only just because it's a movie , while in real life , a panzer division like that could shoot with their cannons after the fail of explosive to destroy the bridge
one thing that was better about this movie was it showed the truth about the German Small arms situation. they've all got the KAR 98, unlike other movies, where every German had an MP-40.
@timebandit71 i know, that's the point i'm making. in most other War films of the 50's-70's, nearly all the germans have MP-40's, except (conveniently) sentrys and gate guards, who thus have to fumble with their rifles, while the cannon fodder can mindlessly spray bullets from their MP-40's, never hitting the hero. look at "where Eagles Dare" Hallway battle scene for a perfect example of this.
@timebandit71 MG-42's would also be used by non-com officers in the German army or Unteroffiziers...Also - 1:27-1:28 looks more like an MG-34 due to the sights and the barrel - plus ROF doesn't sound like the distinct 'linolen ripper' but I could be wrong - I get mixed up between the MG-42 and 34 on a few occasions :)
"Why must you do everything by the book"...so true, only if Gen. Patton was leading assault to Arnhem, he would have not stopped after capturing that bridge
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
WAY too much Praying Crap in this scene. NO ONE in battle has time to think about Reliion - except in the minds of writers and movie-makers that have never been there.
@resculptit Actually, it did take place. And, in the heat of combat is when all soldiers find religion, even if it is only for a second. "There are no atheists in foxholes."
@resculptit You dumb motherfucker read the book by Cornelius Ryan (if you can read you piece of shit). Julian Cook, the man they are showing praying, did pray out loud during the crossing. Dumb piece of shit!!!!!!!!
@resculptit actually the praying part of crossing the river is one of the only things that is historically accurate. It is said that the airborne troops actually did pray the hail mary while crossing the river because of the danger in crossing during daylight.
@resculptit Plus he's not even saying the Rosary correctly in the first place, he's just repeating the first line over and over again lol; probably just some protestant repeating what he'd seen in a movie with Bing Crosby as a priest. ;)
@resculptit Ooh really ? War could turn an atheist in a religious person. The only thing certain in combat is that you are going to get blown to bits or the other guy is.
@1994Topgear A BIG FAIL AT 5.08 HARDY KRUGER! SOMEONE I THINK CUT THE WIRE!- OR I THINK THE AMERICANS DID IT OR THE GERMANS FORGOT TO GROUND THE WIRE - WHO KNOWS!
Now that they didn't need to worry about the Germans shooting at them, couldn't they have just sent more 82nd troops across the river and they could be infantry support for the tanks? The Germans weren't the only ones with a fail that day...
@pablononescobar Did you miss the part where all those troops in the 82nd were killed just during the crossing? Besides, the 82nd had already spent most of its strength at Nijmegen, and worn-out paratroopers don't exactly make the best infantry support for an armored assault on a city -- which is kind of why paratroopers tend to parachute into cities from above, rather than make a frontal assault down a road, whether they have armor support or not.
I live near oosterbeek And Ede.Near the landing zones and fierce fightings.
i have also found many ww2 relics with my MD.But its forbidden to go metal detecting due to explosives.i have many german helmets,Insignes,bullets,and an MG 42.As for american items.A BAR a helmet,and a flare pistol
oh yeah the officer at 8:14 the british officer is Lord Carrington he got a MC awarded for his part in the capture and holding of a vital bridge in Nijmegen.he is the one saying no to julian.
@xwingclass understandable decision by Carrington, for all he knew there was a whole SS panzer divsion ahead of him, his vehicles would indeed be sitting ducks on the road even if there where only a couple of anti tank guns or panzers(in reality there was only 1 gun between them and Frosts men at Arnhem but this was unknown to the guards).
@Barre76 obviously you are right looking at history there were a panzer group there just out side arnhem. but the point i wanted to make is at least have a go to punch through i relise youdont have infantry for surport.
@Sabreur64 yes off course but the question still remains even if they did push ahead would they be able to hold long to there gains long enough without there needed infantry support, the guards took heavy losses up to this point with the germans constantly threatening to cut off there supplies..imo a push but wouldnt have been enough, frosts men where by than close to annihilation as well..
@Barre76 A question for you. If the positions had been reversed and it had been the Falschrimjager holding Arnhem bridge and the SS panzer divisions had been tasked with relieving them do you think the SS would have stopped for a moment to consider the situation or pressed on regardless of casualties?
@Sabreur64 good question and indeed i dont think the SS would hesitate but than again the SS where often reckless and this caused alot of unnescesarry casualties on there side.i am not defending the guards decision but i am trying to understand what the commander must have felt, but indeed it is a bit tragic to see what happend after the heroic capture of nijmegen bridge.but it is always easy to come to conclusions with hindsight, in 1944 things where alot different though.
@Barre76 Sometimes you need to be reckless. And given they were only 1 mile away from the bridge I think this was such an occasion. I guess we'll never know now what would have happened had they pushed on towards the bridge.
@Sabreur64 Well think about it, they had lost so many soldiers and tanks and resources by that time, and the most of the British were either surrounded or captured or had surrendered, so had they have made the push it would have probably been a very hollow victory, but then, they would have still captured Arnhem bridge, what was the key prize but i guess we'll never know.
You're just going to stop... and drink TEA!
RepublicAgent 2 months ago
ha ha Robert Redford just spends his whole time in annoyance dealing British pomposity lol
bluejeckett 2 months ago
Damn those 504th 82nd paratroopers are heroes...
mastermike95 2 months ago
Brilliant lads, give 'em hell 5:51
8Ball2221 2 months ago
-.-'' didn't the germans shoot a cannon hit into the bridge after the fail???!! Ludwing was pretty idiot .. anyway this general didn't not exists his real name 's Heinz Harmel commander of the 10 SS PZ division Frundsberg into the 2nd SS panzerkorps of Bittrich
Giampymike 3 months ago
@Giampymike Idiot? Hardly. And their was no cannon. The Germans tried using torpedos and mines to blow it up, but they couldn't
Trashcansam123 1 month ago
@Trashcansam123 yes but only just because it's a movie , while in real life , a panzer division like that could shoot with their cannons after the fail of explosive to destroy the bridge
Giampymike 1 month ago
@Giampymike Artillery sure! But in real life they didn't. Tank cannons don't do much against a span like that.
Trashcansam123 1 month ago
HAHA FAIL!!!
LittleFrenchy72 4 months ago
i hate the machine gun sound affects in this movie, german mg42 sound nothing like that....
timebandit71 5 months ago
one thing that was better about this movie was it showed the truth about the German Small arms situation. they've all got the KAR 98, unlike other movies, where every German had an MP-40.
Soundwave3591 5 months ago
@Soundwave3591 usually only squad leaders were issued with mp 40s, it was the mg 42. that the allies feared most....
timebandit71 5 months ago
@timebandit71 i know, that's the point i'm making. in most other War films of the 50's-70's, nearly all the germans have MP-40's, except (conveniently) sentrys and gate guards, who thus have to fumble with their rifles, while the cannon fodder can mindlessly spray bullets from their MP-40's, never hitting the hero. look at "where Eagles Dare" Hallway battle scene for a perfect example of this.
Soundwave3591 4 months ago
@timebandit71 MG-42's would also be used by non-com officers in the German army or Unteroffiziers...Also - 1:27-1:28 looks more like an MG-34 due to the sights and the barrel - plus ROF doesn't sound like the distinct 'linolen ripper' but I could be wrong - I get mixed up between the MG-42 and 34 on a few occasions :)
HeirofGojira91 2 months ago
"Why must you do everything by the book"...so true, only if Gen. Patton was leading assault to Arnhem, he would have not stopped after capturing that bridge
rahulbond3m 5 months ago
FAIL???
EPIC FAIL....
rahulbond3m 5 months ago
Like the FAIL
glasfurd31 6 months ago
Germanen Losers
Fail Good editing
TheKippetjetok 8 months ago
FAIL! brilliant piece of editing there!
Timmyboy505 8 months ago
LMFAO genius use of 'FAIL'.. hahaha literally made my day.
radiofoos 8 months ago
FAIL LMAO nice man lol that shoulda been in the movie too
ZiggyZaggy1369 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WAY too much Praying Crap in this scene. NO ONE in battle has time to think about Reliion - except in the minds of writers and movie-makers that have never been there.
resculptit 1 year ago
@resculptit You never know, you can't exactly see what every soldier is thinking.
ross79745 1 year ago 15
@resculptit Actually when shells are landing and bullets are flying alot of people pray to whatever god they believe in ;)
Raafje84 11 months ago 2
@resculptit Actually, it did take place. And, in the heat of combat is when all soldiers find religion, even if it is only for a second. "There are no atheists in foxholes."
ColdWarShot 10 months ago 4
@resculptit It wasn't praying, he was trying to set the tempo for the rowing. As good a thing as any under the circumstances.
trojanhorsealpha 9 months ago
Comment removed
trojanhorsealpha 9 months ago
@resculptit You dumb motherfucker read the book by Cornelius Ryan (if you can read you piece of shit). Julian Cook, the man they are showing praying, did pray out loud during the crossing. Dumb piece of shit!!!!!!!!
omegaman196601 8 months ago
@resculptit actually the praying part of crossing the river is one of the only things that is historically accurate. It is said that the airborne troops actually did pray the hail mary while crossing the river because of the danger in crossing during daylight.
MStrikerPictures 6 months ago
@resculptit Plus he's not even saying the Rosary correctly in the first place, he's just repeating the first line over and over again lol; probably just some protestant repeating what he'd seen in a movie with Bing Crosby as a priest. ;)
tjhoenecke 6 months ago
@tjhoenecke we are all god's children - Peace Out!
aloreburne 1 month ago
@aloreburne "Yes, but some of us are a little more childish than others." Father Francis Mulcahey, 4077 MASH :P
tjhoenecke 1 month ago
@resculptit You sure about that?
Clonetrooper1139 6 months ago
@resculptit Ooh really ? War could turn an atheist in a religious person. The only thing certain in combat is that you are going to get blown to bits or the other guy is.
AmersfoortTristan 6 months ago
@resculptit thats because you have never been shot at. You'd be surprised how many people turn to God when they are scared.
lionel200000000 4 weeks ago
Thanks for posting these. My all time favorite war film. And yes that was an epic fail:O
1994Topgear 1 year ago
@1994Topgear A BIG FAIL AT 5.08 HARDY KRUGER! SOMEONE I THINK CUT THE WIRE!- OR I THINK THE AMERICANS DID IT OR THE GERMANS FORGOT TO GROUND THE WIRE - WHO KNOWS!
moneybelt22 9 months ago
Now that they didn't need to worry about the Germans shooting at them, couldn't they have just sent more 82nd troops across the river and they could be infantry support for the tanks? The Germans weren't the only ones with a fail that day...
pablononescobar 1 year ago 5
@pablononescobar I know it was just a joke :L
ross79745 1 year ago
@pablononescobar Did you miss the part where all those troops in the 82nd were killed just during the crossing? Besides, the 82nd had already spent most of its strength at Nijmegen, and worn-out paratroopers don't exactly make the best infantry support for an armored assault on a city -- which is kind of why paratroopers tend to parachute into cities from above, rather than make a frontal assault down a road, whether they have armor support or not.
tjhoenecke 6 months ago
The sound the German soldier makes at 1:42 is heartbreaking.
NoJeanNoMoney1 1 year ago
where is the fail part?
Scottalator 1 year ago
I live near oosterbeek And Ede.Near the landing zones and fierce fightings.
i have also found many ww2 relics with my MD.But its forbidden to go metal detecting due to explosives.i have many german helmets,Insignes,bullets,and an MG 42.As for american items.A BAR a helmet,and a flare pistol
2008VauxhallVectra 1 year ago 4
To take something is easier than to retake.
Dimy761 1 year ago
I wish the Fail part was actually in the movie
Killerh4mster 1 year ago 19
hahahaha I almost soiled my underwear at the fail part XD
dougie159753 1 year ago 2
fail! :p
spoony2781 1 year ago
oh yeah the officer at 8:14 the british officer is Lord Carrington he got a MC awarded for his part in the capture and holding of a vital bridge in Nijmegen.he is the one saying no to julian.
xwingclass 1 year ago
@xwingclass understandable decision by Carrington, for all he knew there was a whole SS panzer divsion ahead of him, his vehicles would indeed be sitting ducks on the road even if there where only a couple of anti tank guns or panzers(in reality there was only 1 gun between them and Frosts men at Arnhem but this was unknown to the guards).
Barre76 1 year ago
Comment removed
xwingclass 1 year ago
@Barre76 obviously you are right looking at history there were a panzer group there just out side arnhem. but the point i wanted to make is at least have a go to punch through i relise youdont have infantry for surport.
xwingclass 1 year ago
@Barre76 A recce patrol could have answered that question don't you think?
Sabreur64 1 year ago
@Sabreur64 yes off course but the question still remains even if they did push ahead would they be able to hold long to there gains long enough without there needed infantry support, the guards took heavy losses up to this point with the germans constantly threatening to cut off there supplies..imo a push but wouldnt have been enough, frosts men where by than close to annihilation as well..
Barre76 1 year ago
@Barre76 A question for you. If the positions had been reversed and it had been the Falschrimjager holding Arnhem bridge and the SS panzer divisions had been tasked with relieving them do you think the SS would have stopped for a moment to consider the situation or pressed on regardless of casualties?
Sabreur64 1 year ago
@Sabreur64 good question and indeed i dont think the SS would hesitate but than again the SS where often reckless and this caused alot of unnescesarry casualties on there side.i am not defending the guards decision but i am trying to understand what the commander must have felt, but indeed it is a bit tragic to see what happend after the heroic capture of nijmegen bridge.but it is always easy to come to conclusions with hindsight, in 1944 things where alot different though.
Barre76 1 year ago
@Barre76 Sometimes you need to be reckless. And given they were only 1 mile away from the bridge I think this was such an occasion. I guess we'll never know now what would have happened had they pushed on towards the bridge.
Sabreur64 1 year ago
@Sabreur64 Well think about it, they had lost so many soldiers and tanks and resources by that time, and the most of the British were either surrounded or captured or had surrendered, so had they have made the push it would have probably been a very hollow victory, but then, they would have still captured Arnhem bridge, what was the key prize but i guess we'll never know.
ross79745 1 year ago
julian said later that the smoke didnt help at all there was more smoke if you had 20 odd men smoking a cig totally useless.
xwingclass 1 year ago
FAIL XD
GuiTheBest889 1 year ago