Not bad for a youth orchestra. Beethoven is incredibly difficult to perform well. Congrats. It's still rough in some spots, but it is really good considering the level of difficulty of the piece and the level of the players.
This really needs the contrabassoon. Not to mention the piccolo though the part was replaced by a flute at least. Woodwind section had nice tone for the most part. At c.7:30 bassoon really shows up that French Horn. Perhaps a slower tempo would have been appropriate. The brass tonguing is a little slow, for example. 3/4 should be a little slower in my opinion regardless of how fast you can play it. Timpanist certainly is very eager. However a good version for such a young group.
hey they weren't that bad. I mean yeah they have some issues with intonation, but they're WAY better than my middle school band overall, these guys totally pwn my middle school band and orchestra. I give them props for pulling off the 5th symphony of Beethoven!
It's remarkable how students, especially violinists, complain about this piece because their arms are practically falling off at the end. This is why the Fifth Symphony is the one piece students have to master. What is even more ironic and amusing is that teachers tell their students, "you think 5th is hard? why don't you try the 9th?" It is true. Students should try playing the Ninth Symphony. Even professionals complain about it the same way students complain about the 5th.
Good Grief!! These are KIDS playing this. Wonderful. Magnificent. This is incredible that they should play such a monumental piece and do it well. This is really nicely done.
messed up:D
PP1969GR 6 months ago
Not bad for a youth orchestra. Beethoven is incredibly difficult to perform well. Congrats. It's still rough in some spots, but it is really good considering the level of difficulty of the piece and the level of the players.
IluvCCS17 8 months ago
wow. a LOT of off-tuned people in that violin section.
littledustball 8 months ago
Beethoven is turning over in his grave!
fadethetrade 8 months ago
Who's the really "Old" kid in the back row?
FlangeHead99 9 months ago
Who's the really "Old" kid in the back row?
FlangeHead99 9 months ago
What happens if a conductor for a youth orchestra conducts like Bernstein or Karajan
?
How would that turn out?
southwestguy223 11 months ago
@southwestguy223 It wouldn't matter,Beethoven would rollover in his grave hearing this with any conductor.Tosconinni wouldnt help!
fadethetrade 8 months ago
Yeah Orcha-Dorks!! Violin forever!!
Carrots4197 11 months ago
haha i feel like every youth orchestra plays this...this is definitely better than the one i played in, lol
weirdosrok 1 year ago
I think this orchestra did a fantastic job! As for volume, this isn't in a recording studio. School auditoriums don't give the same quality of sound.
Very few schools have orchestras any more. Sad.
grandmagrumpy 1 year ago
The brass is too loud you can't hear the violins at 1:10
cryora 1 year ago
I want to play this! I think it would be fun, for our high school symphony orchestra!
KiyoKenshin 1 year ago
I am currently in seventh grade and we're playing Finale right now.. It's coming along great. We have to play this at our concert in about a month!
iAddictingDrug14 1 year ago
thers like one only one old ass guy platin wit them
yomomma7520 1 year ago
Very good for a youth symphony i play bass but this song is very hard to play oustanding effort
Cw5110 1 year ago
I'm in 8th grade, and i played this in my youth symphony. :O It was fun :3
cometkitty123 1 year ago
So awesome :)
m2sbsahib 1 year ago
they really should learn how to use their full bow :P
MadeInKorea02 2 years ago
this is good shit man!
hsmddr 2 years ago
my school's playing this
emodrumerfromhell 2 years ago
brings back memories
ilikepie4527 2 years ago 2
This really needs the contrabassoon. Not to mention the piccolo though the part was replaced by a flute at least. Woodwind section had nice tone for the most part. At c.7:30 bassoon really shows up that French Horn. Perhaps a slower tempo would have been appropriate. The brass tonguing is a little slow, for example. 3/4 should be a little slower in my opinion regardless of how fast you can play it. Timpanist certainly is very eager. However a good version for such a young group.
Orpehus458 2 years ago
This is a wonderful performance in that i like how the musicians listen to each other, ergo they play in tune.
I played timpani 2 yrs in high school (a lot of Wagner & Rossini) and i know that this timpanist is "having a ball"............listen!
What exhiliration!
madero111 2 years ago
wow not bad at all for kids this age!!! I dont think i could've played this when i was in 8 the grade! well done great job!!!!
adaugo123456789 2 years ago
cool. wow theyre young i played thus in 9th grade
HIMspaz 2 years ago
I think the brass section needs a bit more practice - tone isn't good enough.
Strings are fantastic though :)
notanyoneyouknow 2 years ago 8
Pretty bloody good for a youth orchestra.
foxyfaefife 3 years ago 2
hey they weren't that bad. I mean yeah they have some issues with intonation, but they're WAY better than my middle school band overall, these guys totally pwn my middle school band and orchestra. I give them props for pulling off the 5th symphony of Beethoven!
mario54671 3 years ago
These guys are great my honor orchestra is going to play this!
mina8596 3 years ago
whats up with the older guy in the back? but these guys are GREAT!!!
shavannha 3 years ago
Where are the sring basses?
hatedcheerleader 3 years ago
but these are crazy.....
dermann1 3 years ago
well, soso
qxw66 3 years ago 6
wow. great. You should all feel privileged to be able to play such a piece.
sirdaveo 3 years ago
EXCELLENT performance!
Yes - I am aware of the flaws. But they are minor.
j97hou6 3 years ago 2
yall need more practice...
yellotheemcee 3 years ago 3
It's remarkable how students, especially violinists, complain about this piece because their arms are practically falling off at the end. This is why the Fifth Symphony is the one piece students have to master. What is even more ironic and amusing is that teachers tell their students, "you think 5th is hard? why don't you try the 9th?" It is true. Students should try playing the Ninth Symphony. Even professionals complain about it the same way students complain about the 5th.
zhangpianist 3 years ago
Good Grief!! These are KIDS playing this. Wonderful. Magnificent. This is incredible that they should play such a monumental piece and do it well. This is really nicely done.
octave4 3 years ago
I am playing this song by the Richard Meyers arrangement. I love both versions.
briontube 3 years ago
Do you go to Wilson Middle School? :]
I'm playing the same version :D
Well, actually we did already. Out concert was yesterday
HahaMelia 3 years ago
no HMS
briontube 3 years ago
That was wonderful! =)
Waterbender94 3 years ago
THIS SONG IS AWESOME!!!!
violinwizard01 3 years ago
Nice! :D My band is playing this. But it's the short version, no violins or anything (it's for concert band).
ymtisd 4 years ago
no bass??? sounds so empty
vlnmusic 4 years ago
Heh. My school is gonna play this song in April. We're like, 12 and 13. It'll be hard. It's fun, though. We already started practicing.
NarutoTeam7Fan12345 4 years ago
I don't think it'll be hard
violinwizard01 3 years ago
wow, if only we could get our youth symphony to sound like that! we played that last year as well.
firefly2009 4 years ago
Great job guys!!!
check out the Chapman Symphony Orchestra playing Dvorak 8th on you tube!
Chapman University is a private 4 year university in Orange County, CA
The Chapman Conservatory of Music has on its faculty many of the top players from the Los Angeles Philharmonic and Pacific Symphony.
harmo105 4 years ago 2