Paul McDonald, Rocket Man, American Idol, 3/30/11

[CutePenguins101]

He's soooo cute!!!!

[Broadwaybabay1]

pauls my rocket man

[gooseblack12]

Paul is the shit!!! I miss him :( & he's not gay! Who cares if he was? Ugh, disgusting people!

[lindsaybindsay1]

I loved him I sad he's gone

[Neurosurgeryfuture]

Good but honestly nothing beats the version of David Fonseca, just youtube it!

[MrLemmy2000]

this guys voice sounds God awfull gay Im glad this homo is gone

[BiebersGirl136]

@MrLemmy2000 FUCK OFF BITCH IF YOU DONT LIKE HIM DONT WATCH HIM NOT ROCKET SCIENCE?!!!!

[zlzFUNNYMANzlz]

@MrLemmy2000 u hate it and yet u took the time out ur day to go on youtube look it up just to trash it fuck you fuck you Paul james and casey should have been the bottom 3

[chinesestar07]

Is he HIGH?????? he seems to be every time he sings!!

[RTLippy]

i liked paul until i realized he said he was from nashville since he actually got his start in auburn and lived across the street from me... now he thinks hes the shit and he absolutely ruined this song... way to sell out fag

[thedawgsarch]

This was awful I am sure EJ was mad that he wrote this for Paul to blotch this so bad.Paul's singing was trash he should have been gone long ago.

[gunter099]

Perfect song choice Paul, now blast the @#$% off!

[ILMcarolina]

I think it was SO much better than the original... I loved it♥

[2011marshmallows]

i lobe the tone of his voice

[marti810]

this guy is only on because he has a marketable look. His voice is god awful and he dances around the stage like a velociraptor.

[xxnwoxx]

@marti810 he reminds me of rod stewart voice wise.

[popupvids]

Haha, it is obvious that his singing is not "technical"ly perfect. But thats not what he's about. He's still awesome. Great artist.

[ApricotOfLove]

OMG he just looks like PAUL and that's all!!!

[dcat11114u]

lol does Steven even know he's supposed to be judging instead of just praising every dang contestant up there whether crappy or not? Shut up JLO !...GO PPPPPAAAAUUUULLLLLLL!

[leifer25]

This guy is so horrible at singing.

[patrick9648]

Looks like Kenny Loggins, sounds like Rod Stewart imitating the lead singer of The Fray.

[gabriela4516]

Now all the crazy obsessed Thia fans are mad because Paul got to stay and she is gone. Guess what, she was SO FREAKING BORING, I don't even know what she was doing on that competition. America didn't like her then (AGT) and we don't like her now (AI.) She was soooooooooooo blah! And people say she will have a huge career on Disney Channel... MY GOODNESS! Like Disney doesn't already have AMAZING talented young Asian girls, who can not only sing, but perform and have so much charisma. Thia sucked!

[ImaginaryKrystal]

I love his voice, its so different and unique, thats what draws me in. But if we are talking about looks here - which some of you are - i would say he looks a lot like Bradley cooper too, but for some reason his smile reminds me of Barry Gibb, that is if any of you know who he is ;)

[gamerguy5215]

@nycamelful wow. You probably listen to retarded music like Lady Gaga and Kesha. You have no sense of real music.

[billyjoeboomboom]

@gamerguy5215 Maybe nycamelful likes singers like Josh Groban (you know, ones that can actually sing on pitch and don't sound like the love child of Macy Gray and Donald Duck).

You probably listen to retarded music like The Grand Magnolias and Rod Stewart. How jejune...

[nycamelful]

I must be one of the ones who dont get this dude. Judging from the comments left here. most of his votes are going his way because people have a crush on him or he gets up there with this pitchy limited voice and does so confidently. Even the judges give him more propers than is singing talent deserves. I think next week he should wear a rainbow while riding a unicorn. So he can slide by for another week unnoticed. This guy sucks as far as singing goes.

[arenation99]

he smiles like Bradley Cooper...

[runescappee]

prtty awesome vid like it when he hits the high notes

[SouthernNYCgal]

I really like his style. He's really doing something different. 

[Roostermania2010]

Everyone has their favorite so there's bound to be sum bias - i understand that. Been checking out some of the others & listening to how they start out... re: Paul's Rocket Man= GREAT SONG FOR HIM!!  ...but they key is just a bit too high for his range... the BIG PLUS about Pauly Mac is the way he interprets a song= it's his vocal stylings that makes him stand out from the pack... too many of the gals trying to belt it like other power sirens= Mariah & Christina Ag come to mind... :) *Peace*

[Careiz14]

okay so i love him so much. he's like a mix of bradly cooper and some rugid hunk and his smile is just killer. i love him!

[missbecks89]

@Careiz14 Mix of Bradley Cooper and maybe Caleb Followill from Kings of Leon?

[Careiz14]

i can def see it! lol

[JatoAv8er]

Last winter a tabby cat nested in the engine bay of my Toyota pickup , one Saturday morning I started it up to make a run to the dump & the sound that poor cat made when it hit the fan blades reminds me of Paul McDonald singing!

[TheFear1611]

Paul is not gonna win.Sorry.

[charliee7100]

VOTE FOR PAUL!!

[joliejude]

love his unique voice, love his style... just love love love him!

[val8504]

love love love paul mcdonald...so cute

[germanshepherd435]

hes so cutee

[matthew68681]

He's adorableeee<333333333

[PuppyLove348]

hes the best!!