If you get a chance, please have a look at the tribute to the amazing Etta James I have just uploaded on my channel, I'd love to hear what you think. Thank you x
Cant compare to Etta RIP. She was the real deal.Most of todays stars wouldnt have made the cut back then. Without the mass media and the technology used to create artificial stars. She earned her way in the buisness as most did in the past.No disrespect to anyone but many of todays "stars" would be nobodys were it not for the marketing schemes used to promote and make millions. Too bad she didnt get to perform for Obama. No one will top her version!
Some of you hate to admit it but it was Beyoncé that made Etta James Relevant again, not being disrespectful but who in this generation knew about Etta's great discography? Beyoncé schooled the "youngsters" and showed them that Great music was made in that particular time period. So THANK YOU Beyoncé for showing me who Etta James was, her music was powerful raw and emotional, it touched my soul. So people stop bringing Beyoncé down. RIP Etta James, you will be missed. Your music will live on
Byonce and JayZ should keep to their Hood Tracks....and Fine them each time they fuck up a song....like this one....Rest In Peace Etta James 1/20/2012
give me a break miss arsenal!! i suppose the 18 in your profile is in ref to your age and thats probably why you say such senseless things? if its the case, unfortunatly your generation has been ridden from almost all quality wich concerns music thats why people like getta, black eyed p's and all these other wankers are considered geniuses now days. so sad for you guys!!!
Some of these comments smh..beyonce doesn't have soul? This woman gt a whole lot of soul! Just cuz she be singin up tempo songs alot and dancin..she don't have soul? Go and watch various performances when this woman takes you to church with her vocals! Etta I love BUT soryy all of your songs that beyonce sung, u myt aswell give them to her cuz she made them come alive in the way u didn't
Sounds like blacktree media is going to make this a racial issue. After reading what they have posted. This guy Chess was a Jew so therefore he was taking advantage of his singers. Bullshit, he created a record company to make money what is wrong with that? And he found some very talented singers who were black and he paid them handsomely. Just another person who screams racism or the sky is falling like chicken little. Get over it! he made alot of people very wealthy.
Better, guitar arrangements and engineering, then the original, much nicer mix, and Beyonc`e definitely gives Eta a run for here money, excellent portrayal.
DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE.HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT ON AT LEAST THREE VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN TWO DAYS.NOW YOU STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY.PUT THIS ON AT LEAST FIVE VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS
@trudywren Love any version of this song which of course was written by Mack Gordon and Harry Warren for the film 'Orchestra Wives' in 1941 and played by Glen Miller and his orchestra.
it depresses me a little to know that such an AMAZING singer has chosen to be a pop star singing mostly rubbish. When she could be singing stuff like this . Understandable but regrettable
both beyonce and etta james a phenomonal singers there should never be any anymosity if an artist pays tribute to another by doing a cover of their song its been done many times over the years and beyonce definatly has the talent to do the song justice..absolutly great
@ElodievandamXmj dont believe that just because someone sounds amazing live, it automatically means that they're lip syncing...shes not ashley simpson (:
You can really Tell who's the most talented , Etta dosent need to hide her voice in a quiver all the time. Etta just sing's :) But Beyonce sure wins on the looks all the same!
Beyonce rocks..... HATERS OMG (Get a life)..... Beyonce is a talented woman who has soul in voice..... Etta's verison is wonderful :) and Beyonce's..... Its ok to change things up sometime..... I <3 B....
If it were possible, and Beyonce had come before Etta and be the one to sing this first, I'm sure all the hate would be upon Etta. It's just a matter of having an already pre-established interpretation in mind. Both are great, IMO.
Adrien Brody is in this movie? lol he must have been bored or something.. he did this movie a favor by just showing his face though. Beyonce does her thing with this song she brings her own twist. Which is unique because her voice doesn't have too much character too me. Sometimes she just sounds the same with every song she does.So i get easily bored listening to her other than that kodus and Lets go back to when music had that depth and "feeling" to it please.
No way does beyonce do a better job than Etta! her version especially the one in concert is so so superior - beautiful rich tones sung with feeling and experience. whereas beyonce just goes through the motions - and gives dry performance. its so bad you wouldnt think she was married!! ETTA sings it best by far. she had very right to be angry! She singing for the president is cheeky and it wasnt even her song! I would wanna whip her ass too!!
@YourWorstNightmareDK I cant agree totally with you, because she did not cover this song as Beyonce, actually she covers this song by playing Etta, so I think its okay, especially there is no commercial thought by covering this song, but you are right that there are classics that no actual singers voice can even come close to.
Beyonce sings it more sweetly and distinctly, yet she's soulful. Etta has a gruffness to her voice. You can click on the link of Etta in the orange background to compare. You can see how Beyonce tries to stick closer to the original because of it being in the film. She wanted it to sound very similar to Etta's version. That's why she wasn't doing any screamfest version like Christina Aguilera. You notice Etta isn't screaming at the top of her lungs in her version the whole song.
The sound quality on this video isn't the best. I would actually look at the video of this performance elsewhere on YT.Also, it's definitely better than the screamfest that Christina Aguilera calls singing. Christina doesn't know anything about control, subtlety and phrasing sometimes. Everything is about screaming with her to "prove" that she can sing. That's why Christina's voice cracks so much in live performances.
Beyonce decided to be more faithful to the original version of the song, unlike Chirstina Aguilera. That's why Beyonce wasn't doing all the screeching and squealing that Christina did on her verison. If you notice Etta sings the song more like Beyonce than Christina's version. Beyonce was playing Etta so she wanted to based on her intepretation closer to the original. Beyonce's version is better than Etta's. I don't care who don't want to admit. Go listen and you'll see what I'm talking about.
If there was no Etta James, there wouldn't be a Beyonce. Or Christina Anguilera, or Janis Joplin etc the list goes on
giogarcia16 14 hours ago
anyone else notice the video was uploaded 3 years ago but Etta has only been dead for a week?! o.0
101PinkThink 2 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
VOLIM TE KRISTINA!!!!
-I love you Kristina.
:)
banovobrdo11030 2 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you get a chance, please have a look at the tribute to the amazing Etta James I have just uploaded on my channel, I'd love to hear what you think. Thank you x
elparisaofficial 3 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey I've uploaded a video of myself doing a cover of this song, please watch it and let me know what you think :)
star15615 4 days ago
It is possible to go change the name of the video..
HoneyBeeMonroe 1 week ago
Fuck beyonc she could never be better than the original! Rip Etta James
Haileeluvmusic 1 week ago
I apppreciate the quality of the post, but i am quite confused by R.I.P. I don't recall posting this and Etta James died yesterday.
Mmmousemaid 1 week ago
Hey ParanoiaGentleman, Im from Azusa...!
wickdly 1 week ago
i found a dream i can call my own RIP from el monte CA
ParanoiaGentlman 1 week ago
Why does it say "RIP Etta James" and this video was posted 3 years ago??? Etta James just died today. Idk....??
MsChocolateJones 1 week ago
@MsChocolateJones updated title
blacktreemedia 1 week ago 2
@MsChocolateJones she died yesterday from cancer at the age of 73
moveit1231 1 week ago
OF COURSE YOU WOULD COME TO A BEYONCE VIDEO AND TALK SHIT INSTEAD OF GOING TO ETTA JAMES'S VIDEOS TO MOURN HER... UNDERCOVER FANS KILL ME
10hooper 1 week ago
R.I.P etta james 2 lengends gone in the past 3 years michael jackson and now etta <3
moveit1231 1 week ago
R.I.P Etta.
Caermenpooh 1 week ago 2
Beyonce who? This autotuned trash a legend?
LOL.
ernest747 1 week ago
At least she respected Etta James verison and didnt try to put her on spin on it. Sounds good to me.
jleedawg 1 week ago
Cant compare to Etta RIP. She was the real deal.Most of todays stars wouldnt have made the cut back then. Without the mass media and the technology used to create artificial stars. She earned her way in the buisness as most did in the past.No disrespect to anyone but many of todays "stars" would be nobodys were it not for the marketing schemes used to promote and make millions. Too bad she didnt get to perform for Obama. No one will top her version!
mgebi1 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Some of you hate to admit it but it was Beyoncé that made Etta James Relevant again, not being disrespectful but who in this generation knew about Etta's great discography? Beyoncé schooled the "youngsters" and showed them that Great music was made in that particular time period. So THANK YOU Beyoncé for showing me who Etta James was, her music was powerful raw and emotional, it touched my soul. So people stop bringing Beyoncé down. RIP Etta James, you will be missed. Your music will live on
music5756 1 week ago
RIP Etta James, you where a pioneer & a legend, your music will live on. The word "MUSIC" would be incomplete without Etta James.
music5756 1 week ago
RIP Etta
partyspecialists 1 week ago 2
Byonce and JayZ should keep to their Hood Tracks....and Fine them each time they fuck up a song....like this one....Rest In Peace Etta James 1/20/2012
vmlenigma 1 week ago
perfectly
Scorpiael 1 week ago
beyonce wouldn't know what the f soul was if it wasnt for singers like etta!!
allmightyafro 2 weeks ago 2
give me a break miss arsenal!! i suppose the 18 in your profile is in ref to your age and thats probably why you say such senseless things? if its the case, unfortunatly your generation has been ridden from almost all quality wich concerns music thats why people like getta, black eyed p's and all these other wankers are considered geniuses now days. so sad for you guys!!!
allmightyafro 2 weeks ago
At Last. Beyonce is a Mother.
savannahhraynee 2 weeks ago
Beyonce just had blue ivy on Saturday
lkoonce7 2 weeks ago
Some of these comments smh..beyonce doesn't have soul? This woman gt a whole lot of soul! Just cuz she be singin up tempo songs alot and dancin..she don't have soul? Go and watch various performances when this woman takes you to church with her vocals! Etta I love BUT soryy all of your songs that beyonce sung, u myt aswell give them to her cuz she made them come alive in the way u didn't
missArsenal18x 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I LOVE THIS SONG
candyapple0811 3 weeks ago
i am young so i like this one better then that old lady edder what ever her name was.
SuperFirewire1 3 weeks ago
Beyonce cada vez mas se supera eu amo ela
wyanedarelle 1 month ago
even Etta dislike this
Galaxybeni 1 month ago
BOTH ARE AND ALWAYS WILL BE LEGENDS, SO STOP COMPARING, THEIR FROM DIFFERENT GENERATIONS OF TIME. STOP HATIN!
lmccann18 1 month ago 11
BEYONCE=BEST
ntshanga 1 month ago
Etta is the best!
j0m4r13 1 month ago
this awesome but she dont have that powerfull voice like etta
Jake11842 2 months ago
Arranger Riley Hampton, who orchestrated all of Etta's Chess hits, including "At Last," is not mentioned anywhere in the film. Wonder why?
mangledinal 2 months ago
Love Etta. This is very nice too. Shan't turn it off. Shame it doesn't quite go all the way to the end of the song though.
mcfahk 2 months ago
Love Etta. This is very nice too. Shan't turn it off.
mcfahk 2 months ago
LOVE, AS A BLACKWOMAM, AND AS A HUMAN BEING.
MrFdorsett 2 months ago
My god watching this woman act in this movie was so painful...
genericusername1221 2 months ago
@genericusername1221 jealous?
beyonce0440 1 month ago
@beyonce0440 Gotta love that logic you have there...
genericusername1221 1 month ago
@genericusername1221 good for you... :)
beyonce0440 3 weeks ago
MAGIC
mahaltony 2 months ago
Her voice is pretty
aldolp1t 2 months ago
That pissed Etta.
sashthesunshine 3 months ago
Beyonce version awesome, however Etta James sings songs a way that no one can. Etta james just Rock!
MissLuvinme1 3 months ago
Sounds like blacktree media is going to make this a racial issue. After reading what they have posted. This guy Chess was a Jew so therefore he was taking advantage of his singers. Bullshit, he created a record company to make money what is wrong with that? And he found some very talented singers who were black and he paid them handsomely. Just another person who screams racism or the sky is falling like chicken little. Get over it! he made alot of people very wealthy.
1998disco72 3 months ago 3
@1998disco72 What most people don't realize, is Chess actually bought them stuff, cars, homes, and anything, tons of things
He was a very nice guy
mirlin235 2 months ago
Comment removed
MidnightJazzer 3 months ago
Better, guitar arrangements and engineering, then the original, much nicer mix, and Beyonc`e definitely gives Eta a run for here money, excellent portrayal.
MidnightJazzer 3 months ago
beyonce voice sound better then etta james etta james voice sound like a bitter voice there
TheDewayne37 4 months ago 5
Sure, Etta James is better, but nobody beats Etta. Beyonce did an incredible job with this, so don't hate!
LatinaDancer101 4 months ago 60
her vocals are amazing!!!....she makes it look so easy....but ima big fan anyway=)
paigeperry1 4 months ago in playlist More videos from blacktreemedia
Thumps up if this baby is a Grammy award winner worthy for Best Traditional R&B Vocal Performance.!
jhengleone 5 months ago
I love this song omg! Nd the movie!!
100real7 5 months ago
whoa WTF shes so much better for blues what the hell is she singing right now anyways, girls run the world? hell no
Gchord86 5 months ago
This is insanely good. Simply sung, not overdone. Pure, angelic voice.
hayazi95 5 months ago
Every time I listen to beyonce sing I get goosebumps, her voice is just beautiful and so is she. I love beyonce.
andabreadwasmine 5 months ago 2
@andabreadwasmine listen to etta james and then listen again to beyonce and make the difference
rilejuro 5 months ago
That's the kind of music Beyonce should be singing all the time!
fakewalka 5 months ago 4
SWEET!
buffalowomyn 5 months ago
can not get enough. om addicted
INEEDANEWACCOUNTNAME 6 months ago
Her voice was better for the I'd Rather be Blind she sucks at this son
MsRita90292 6 months ago
DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE.HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT ON AT LEAST THREE VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN TWO DAYS.NOW YOU STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY.PUT THIS ON AT LEAST FIVE VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS
mrsjennapage 6 months ago
This song is just so perfect. "At Last" I have been blessed with the most wonderful man to share my life with!
sybilshepherd333 6 months ago
lovely wedding song
Peetibee 6 months ago 2
thats why she s the best
OLDMANBADGER 7 months ago
Very nice, very nice
sheilalenear 7 months ago
internet is becoming more and more like tv !!
koreanmarco 7 months ago 6
People who think she cant do this effortless, go and watch Barack and Michelle Obamas inguaration when she sung this at it!
horsemad04 7 months ago 3
hahaha miming ... but there are better version of Beyonce and this song on Youtube...
mralan1969uk 8 months ago
etta i love your song and the way u sing them, but let keep it real beyonce sang the hell out them.be proud
dkartlit 8 months ago
Beyoncé should stick to pop... she has minimal soul... if any. Not that she sings this song badly, but she doesn't do it justice whatsoever.
scbaldwin13 8 months ago
Incredible :P
Jfenix20 8 months ago
ONE WORD AMAZING
marializzy1 9 months ago
I think that she is not afraid of taking chances and she is a woman who knows her own strength. - Naked Lady Gaga. C0000M - -
addictedquota71 9 months ago
Much prefer the original by the original Etta James - so much more soul than Beyoncé
trudywren 9 months ago 26
@trudywren shes not the original singer tho...
LotsOfMusicInMyMind 3 months ago
@trudywren i dont think so... i think that there is more soul and emotion in this version. but we have each our opinion :)
beyonce0440 3 months ago
then again how objective can you be in this case with a profile name like that?
allmightyafro 2 weeks ago
@trudywren Love any version of this song which of course was written by Mack Gordon and Harry Warren for the film 'Orchestra Wives' in 1941 and played by Glen Miller and his orchestra.
nye1956 2 months ago
@trudywren Well beyonce sounds very good in this Genré ;)
VitalSoX 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
chciałbym by ktoś dla mnie tak śpiewał......czy ktoś śpiewał dla Ciebie tak? slavo
man32op 9 months ago
chciałbym by ktoś dla mnie tak śpiewał......czy ktoś śpiewał dla Ciebie tak?
man32op 9 months ago
No, no, no...I can only hear Etta's version.
SarahMarieShelley 9 months ago 5
i love this song
utami20 9 months ago
i'm so sorry...the song is sung pretty good but am i the ONLY one looking @ that beautiful man and his SEXY grin @ 1:48.....I LOVE ADRIEN BRODY!!!!
garyfrick03 10 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Amazing. But check this out: /watch?v=CwqTDqS3CR8
Skip to 0:29
M4T1JA 10 months ago
Check out my At Last cover!
lilcutiekiki16 10 months ago
Supr supr.....
se1234678 10 months ago
it depresses me a little to know that such an AMAZING singer has chosen to be a pop star singing mostly rubbish. When she could be singing stuff like this . Understandable but regrettable
blaizevincent 10 months ago 2
Pues miren.... q ella la canta mejor q Etta James. me gusta más.
piky777 10 months ago
πανεμορφο τραγουδι!!!! ολα τα συναισθηματα και πανω απο ολα ΕΡΩΤΑΣ!!!!
alexlimnos18 10 months ago 3
Jassupi911 true
whitebrinty 10 months ago
True ilr
whitebrinty 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I like this movie
Blockxhead85 11 months ago
ITS THE TRUTH BUT YOU GOT 2 BE OLD ENOUGH 2 UNDERSTAND IT OR RELATE 2 IT!!
marshaydavis77 11 months ago
to be honest (this is juts my opinion) but beyonce with blode hair makes her look like a man or a dyke. just saying
Jasupi911 11 months ago
both beyonce and etta james a phenomonal singers there should never be any anymosity if an artist pays tribute to another by doing a cover of their song its been done many times over the years and beyonce definatly has the talent to do the song justice..absolutly great
WorldWatcher9 11 months ago
gracias...de verdad
Mariaromina5 11 months ago
vos
TheCerroLopez 11 months ago
@TheCerroLopez
Mariaromina5 11 months ago
voz o vos???
Mariaromina5 11 months ago
Excelente versión....... hermosa voz....me encantó....gracias de nuevo
TheCerroLopez 11 months ago
me encanta...me seduce...
Mariaromina5 11 months ago
got chills <3 love u B!
stopanniee 11 months ago
looooooveeee ittt<3
babybritalldayevery 11 months ago
i think both women have an amazing gift of singing. two very different styles, one lovely and fenominal song :)
lola13mariola 11 months ago
Beyonce won a grammy for this song. So Suck that haters :)!
rtsproductionmanager 11 months ago
This recording sucks
coco97lewis 11 months ago
Beyoncé's version won a Grammy for 'Best Traditional R&B Vocal Performance' in 2010. Enough Said.
workhardholic 11 months ago
its amazing how she sings UNBELIEVABLe yet she makes it look so effortless
189274 11 months ago 91
@189274
thats kinda stupid
the reason that she makes it sound effortless is that shes not singing it life
this is lip sink
but shes still amazing
ElodievandamXmj 8 months ago
@ElodievandamXmj dont believe that just because someone sounds amazing live, it automatically means that they're lip syncing...shes not ashley simpson (:
189274 8 months ago
@189274 ashley simpson cant even sing for shit she lip syncs every time she attempts to sing
DaKurlz1 7 months ago
@189274
in the movie she was lip syncing, yes. all singers lip sync in movies so you don't hear oddities and unwanted noises during the song.
slayer3to10 7 months ago
@189274
i know beyonce is amazing life so thats not the reason
they usually do this for movies youknow
but i could be wrong
ElodievandamXmj 7 months ago
@189274 she is just opening her lips . she is not actually singing live there .
rilejuro 5 months ago
@rilejuro hahah i was thinking the same thing.
LotsOfMusicInMyMind 3 months ago
Umm beyonce sings way better than etta james , people are just too jelous of her voice
palangi01 11 months ago
did u guys see the Jew?
jaiBavet 11 months ago
You can really Tell who's the most talented , Etta dosent need to hide her voice in a quiver all the time. Etta just sing's :) But Beyonce sure wins on the looks all the same!
stuman06 1 year ago
@stuman06 the quiver is actually called vibrato and only the talented can do it
HoorahMonster 11 months ago 2
wonderful movie
govos 1 year ago
sing baby sing
JizzyJizz14 1 year ago
My God, I think Beyonce sings this great.
greenmonsterpuppies 1 year ago 2
She has a wonderful gift. She sings it so easy... Bravo!!!
Sarafilmlover 1 year ago
Mis. Etta james .. by far sings it way better..!!!!!!
ARES1503 1 year ago
if u had watched the movie you wouldve know why she singed it that way.. and you wouldve know it is....tinkeling :)
krista031 1 year ago
liebe dieses lied! es ist mein lieblings-song aller zieten!
amadeus2010era 1 year ago
@amadeus2010era Stimmt!
TwilightTown 11 months ago
Better than the Original !
mrbeam123 1 year ago
ahmmm..not..etta and christina way better i think...and the both love each other lol
xicobionico 1 year ago
@xicobionico HATER !!!!!!!!
itskennedymitchell 1 year ago
Beyonce sounds so much better than that old drug wh**E
carolb1970 1 year ago
eva cassidy's waaaaaaay better!
habbobaby1 1 year ago
Beyonce rocks..... HATERS OMG (Get a life)..... Beyonce is a talented woman who has soul in voice..... Etta's verison is wonderful :) and Beyonce's..... Its ok to change things up sometime..... I <3 B....
luvskysca 1 year ago
Jay-Z: Why is she always singing this shit? (lmao!)
YoYoBlazeShow 1 year ago
MY top #1 favorite song, by; Etta James NOT Beyonce, she should had sang the song to right way, Not her own way..
MrDoowop86 1 year ago
Both versions are beautiful! I got goosebumps from hearing both!:)
lindsayenrique 1 year ago
<3
jellybaby345 1 year ago
I love IT!!!
tibulinnu89 1 year ago
I prefer etta, but this was amazing x
Flowersintherainx 1 year ago
this will so be my wedding song lol... love it
Juiceymaori1 1 year ago
i hate the 102 ppl that didnt like this
dizzle006 1 year ago
è 1usignolo *__*
ale0988 1 year ago
Is Beyoncé playing the part of eeta - the original singer in this movie? :) Love this cover , beyoncé has the best voice out there! xxx
moll4596 1 year ago
@moll4596 yep she is lol she does :)
sazzo18 1 year ago
Comment removed
iamdylannn 1 year ago
Beautiful song. Beautiful woman. Beautiful voice.
aljobaris 1 year ago 94
This is soooooo beautiful, I love Etta, but maybe she is just jealous, ahah,
Elleyphant 1 year ago
If it were possible, and Beyonce had come before Etta and be the one to sing this first, I'm sure all the hate would be upon Etta. It's just a matter of having an already pre-established interpretation in mind. Both are great, IMO.
FernandoLopes0691 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Honest sexy Asian brides "busizz4me.info"
Abbielacy 1 year ago
Adrien Brody is in this movie? lol he must have been bored or something.. he did this movie a favor by just showing his face though. Beyonce does her thing with this song she brings her own twist. Which is unique because her voice doesn't have too much character too me. Sometimes she just sounds the same with every song she does.So i get easily bored listening to her other than that kodus and Lets go back to when music had that depth and "feeling" to it please.
YAHSNUM1 1 year ago
nice job. but the movie was really bad.
legallyinsane456 1 year ago
love you beyonce. but etta james owns this song.
ShmayleyAndShmoopey 1 year ago
really fond of this voice
megske9 1 year ago
No way does beyonce do a better job than Etta! her version especially the one in concert is so so superior - beautiful rich tones sung with feeling and experience. whereas beyonce just goes through the motions - and gives dry performance. its so bad you wouldnt think she was married!! ETTA sings it best by far. she had very right to be angry! She singing for the president is cheeky and it wasnt even her song! I would wanna whip her ass too!!
winiver77 1 year ago
@YourWorstNightmareDK I didnt know bout that one, thats very sad, but in this case youre absolutely right
TcAdA 1 year ago
@YourWorstNightmareDK I cant agree totally with you, because she did not cover this song as Beyonce, actually she covers this song by playing Etta, so I think its okay, especially there is no commercial thought by covering this song, but you are right that there are classics that no actual singers voice can even come close to.
TcAdA 1 year ago
Comment removed
garyfrick03 1 year ago
Comment removed
garyfrick03 1 year ago
The BASS Really Helps This Song Though.....
TamoanBoy 1 year ago
This is a wonderful song...I love it and once again Queen B did a great job...love u B
IMARAful 1 year ago
Just beautiful !
bjw1148 1 year ago
Simply beautiful
jasb673 1 year ago
i was expecting to get mad and hate this, but beyonce did a really good job
hotboysumer 1 year ago 2
fail
thesuperfe 1 year ago
@thesuperfe what is fail about this song it is music u facking hater -.-
MrLawajingo 1 year ago
u sound as dumb as ur display name (hater) lol..da name fits u well u damn fool
siesiechampion 1 year ago
>>>> Scream-Tina
kavatuz 1 year ago
!!!
gouromania1 1 year ago
simply amazing
molli23 1 year ago
ow my god just seen this and naw i sit and cry way way is that a song here i gess 2 tell the 1 you love haw much
benelone 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dad is alone need a help from you naneedj.info
bilanehasan 1 year ago
Beyonce sings it more sweetly and distinctly, yet she's soulful. Etta has a gruffness to her voice. You can click on the link of Etta in the orange background to compare. You can see how Beyonce tries to stick closer to the original because of it being in the film. She wanted it to sound very similar to Etta's version. That's why she wasn't doing any screamfest version like Christina Aguilera. You notice Etta isn't screaming at the top of her lungs in her version the whole song.
NyahStar1 1 year ago 2
The sound quality on this video isn't the best. I would actually look at the video of this performance elsewhere on YT.Also, it's definitely better than the screamfest that Christina Aguilera calls singing. Christina doesn't know anything about control, subtlety and phrasing sometimes. Everything is about screaming with her to "prove" that she can sing. That's why Christina's voice cracks so much in live performances.
NyahStar1 1 year ago
Beyonce decided to be more faithful to the original version of the song, unlike Chirstina Aguilera. That's why Beyonce wasn't doing all the screeching and squealing that Christina did on her verison. If you notice Etta sings the song more like Beyonce than Christina's version. Beyonce was playing Etta so she wanted to based on her intepretation closer to the original. Beyonce's version is better than Etta's. I don't care who don't want to admit. Go listen and you'll see what I'm talking about.
NyahStar1 1 year ago