I don't think the black rock was a pirate ship, it was the ship that brought Richard to the island, A storm did bring it on also causing it to hit the serpant statue on the way in. but the ship was taking prisoners to their fate when storm hit. Richard was one of them and only one to live. but then you might of had this theory before that episode aired in season6
I think richard never ages because of electromagnetim (if you make a search on the web you will see that magnetism is curable) and Jacob (or the protecter of the island) can direct electromagnetism (or magnetism)
Great Post, There was a show on UK TV that went into the Narinia books containing stories on 3 levels. The Charlotte connection got me thinking about that. Nice theroy and I think there's something in it. Nice one
i will be favoritinf this..b/c you are very knowledgable. The thing is..LOST references all the books it uses ideas from (the book club). Why was CS Lewis never mentioned?
Dude..it's 3am here in PA...although i like your analogy....i have a good reason why you, and no one, will ever be right. First, the people who WRITE LOST have people who are hired to scan peoples theories...find connections...then, they write the opposite to shock the audience. They take all story possibilities and eliminate what is predicted by people like you who post stuff. That way..anything they write will never be predicted and foretasted. Thats is the LOST theory...
Except for the fact lots of people predicted that evil Locke is the smoke monster and it turned out that way, also heaps of people predicted that time travel would be the explanation for some of the mysteries. Sorry, just sayin!
@timlukanowski That's actually not true. The LOST writers have had the series mapped out since the beginning. The only plot points they hadn't totally fleshed out were those revealed in the final season. Otherwise it wouldn't be as tight as it is. Everything fits perfectly.
The best theory is that its 2 gods on the island one name Jacob and that black smoke Jacob says that people are bad people but Jacob says that they are good people the Others are Slaves to the God Jacob or something like that Dharma people knows that this island is special Answer to numbers = The numbers is the reason he will fly all the others have a reason too ((I mean The Lost People not The Other)) But anyway all is a test all the stuffs is Jacob and the smoke monster ...
hey, Great thought but..not really a "theory" It doesnt answer any questions or mysteries. Whispers/smokey/numbers/Jacob etc. I mean lost is about the charectors...the oceanic 6. This theory doesnt explain why they are all connected. Again..good find though and very interesting! Unvail more of your theory though!
I just realized that Charlotte was born 1979 yet in 1977 she was a little girl.??..... cool video It's cool to hear different theories,I personally think that lost is it's own show and just try's to put heaps of references in there of other program's but good thoughts.
it IS parkman from heroes! greg grunberg is his name to be exact, and he was actually supposed to take the place of the lostie leader (jack was meant to die in the premiere), but he ended up producing and starring in heroes instead.
interesting thoughts - I love reading all the different theories. I personally think the story of Jacob is tied to everything. I wil be totally LOST until Feb. 2010!
I like the idea of there being an eternal faith to the mantra of the show: possibly an spiritual, atlantean origin to the "others" born to the island by small people..
found it,,it's name is "locke'd out again" by Michael Giachinno..it was played on the episode in season 1 when boon died locke was crying and slaming his hands on the hatch door with scenes of him angry after his dad took his kidney,,great episode s01e19 "deus ex Machina"
found it,,it's name is "locke'd out again" by Michael Giachinno..it was played on the episode in season 1 when boon died locke was crying and slaming his hands on the hatch door with scenes of him angry after his dad took his kidney,,great episode s01e19 "deus ex Machina"
Another thing to consider as well is the fact that CS Lewis based all of his things on the bible. The island could be the garden of eden read the theories on that, cause i think they collide with that.
wait wait wait WTF charllote was born in 1979 how??? we saw her in 1977 in the dharma iniatiative THAATS PRETTY FUCKED UP I THINK THEY SCREWED WITH THAT PART AND FORGOT ABOUT IT
although not what i think lost is very interesting. You might wanna also think about the station the lamppost as this is what CS Lewis uses to mark Narnia in the books.
Like C S Lewis writings and countless other brilliant works throughout history, i think LOST is telling us something, WE are lost, we've forgotton who we are and when we are. Timelines, dharma, the wheel, creating our own reality, death is an illusion, collective conciousness, looking glass station. its all there, its screaming at us !! but needs more in depth discussion than there is room for here.
That is a very good theory..But who is Jacob? I'm starting to think that w/ this seasons time travel storyline, it will affect many thories that have been floated. Cool theory though.
i have a few theories on how it might end, but knowing the genius's behind LOST I'm sure I'll be wrong. Most of my theorizing has been thrown off by the recent episode but I definitely think Locke will lead the Others and that the Oceanic 6 will remain on the Island.
Good job! I know that you will not believe this, but I made this connection quite some time ago as I remembered the event from reading "Prince Caspian" years ago.
How about this theory. Remember a few seasons ago when you saw that four toed statue for a second? Now, in episode 2 or 3 in season 5 Sawyer steps on something in the jungle but nothing is said of it. Sawyer is going to get an infection, lose his toe, time travel back many many years and do something heroic. We will find out that the 4 toed statue is a monument of Sawyer.
It is my theory. Who is smolesuik? I was reading The Chronicles of Narnia, Prince Caspian in preparation for the upcoming movie since I hadn't read it since I was younger and I formulated the theory as I read.
Sorry, Lindquist! My comment was meant as a reply to chambalyn a bit further down the page (3 weeks ago). That the four-toed statue could be Sawyer. smolesuik said the same thing in his recap, but maybe he heard it here first, who knows? Check out his theories and recaps, they are very detailed and interesting. He has a channel here on YouTube, search for it! :-)
apparantly dharma (as in the dharma initiative) is indian 4 something like afterlife.
Also, my own little thoery is:
have u ever seen the movie 'The Truman Show' with Jim Carrey. Well maybe part of the dharma experimentation is that theyre seeing how humans react to it all (as in the people on the plane)
Yes producers have already admitted there ara alot of simarlaritys between the two even naming one of the characters c.s lewis. good observation losty
The comparison with Narnia does seem very deep but is quite believable, are there any links between timescale on the island and timescale in ther real world like in the book where 1 year is 100 years in Narnia Great theorey though
Very well done! And FindYourselfLOST that ice cave were Ben "moves" the island could not be the box because Locke asks Ben if it is and Ben tells him no
the box or "magical cave" could indeed be the frozen donkey wheel cave or the "casimir" as some people reffer to it as, great ideas BUT the outside world can reach the island as we saw in season 4, its not completly unreachable, just hard to get to
great vid and theory, since the characther of charlote apear on lost i think a lot of people stared thinking what u say. the whole thing with richard is so great and smart and really makes sence in the way u put it. im really gladd on how both the show lost and the movies narnias are coming out at the same time.
interesting,.. only problem i have is that "black box" was a metaphor, Ben even says that to John later on when he asks about it again.. He is saying that strange things enter the island, and too often to be a coincidence. Its true that mush of the writing is inspired by past novels, there are sooo many references to books and authors...
I don't think the black rock was a pirate ship, it was the ship that brought Richard to the island, A storm did bring it on also causing it to hit the serpant statue on the way in. but the ship was taking prisoners to their fate when storm hit. Richard was one of them and only one to live. but then you might of had this theory before that episode aired in season6
RANS87IROCZ 9 months ago
check this one out: youtube.com/watch?v=szfesDG5fRU
alienfos 1 year ago
I think richard never ages because of electromagnetim (if you make a search on the web you will see that magnetism is curable) and Jacob (or the protecter of the island) can direct electromagnetism (or magnetism)
samsationnel 1 year ago
whoa, awesome.....
Boulberhane 2 years ago
Great Post, There was a show on UK TV that went into the Narinia books containing stories on 3 levels. The Charlotte connection got me thinking about that. Nice theroy and I think there's something in it. Nice one
squire75 2 years ago
dude that charlotte part was rad.
woodworthguy 2 years ago 2
i will be favoritinf this..b/c you are very knowledgable. The thing is..LOST references all the books it uses ideas from (the book club). Why was CS Lewis never mentioned?
timlukanowski 2 years ago 2
Dude..it's 3am here in PA...although i like your analogy....i have a good reason why you, and no one, will ever be right. First, the people who WRITE LOST have people who are hired to scan peoples theories...find connections...then, they write the opposite to shock the audience. They take all story possibilities and eliminate what is predicted by people like you who post stuff. That way..anything they write will never be predicted and foretasted. Thats is the LOST theory...
timlukanowski 2 years ago 4
Except for the fact lots of people predicted that evil Locke is the smoke monster and it turned out that way, also heaps of people predicted that time travel would be the explanation for some of the mysteries. Sorry, just sayin!
CosmicUndeadElf 1 year ago
@timlukanowski That's actually not true. The LOST writers have had the series mapped out since the beginning. The only plot points they hadn't totally fleshed out were those revealed in the final season. Otherwise it wouldn't be as tight as it is. Everything fits perfectly.
ghostgate82 1 year ago
@timlukanowski how do you know this?
ziltiod94 1 year ago
Very cool , I like all theories that have to do with the greatest idea for television ever created.
MrOwen1974 2 years ago 2
haha its a nice theory
but i dont beleive its correct
good work!
danwood891 2 years ago
LOST IS AWESOME. Nice theory.
Jimbo4815 2 years ago 2
maybe its alien (the others) and jacob
facilia1 2 years ago
Dude did he change shirts in like one second?
Lucky4193 2 years ago
The best theory is that its 2 gods on the island one name Jacob and that black smoke Jacob says that people are bad people but Jacob says that they are good people the Others are Slaves to the God Jacob or something like that Dharma people knows that this island is special Answer to numbers = The numbers is the reason he will fly all the others have a reason too ((I mean The Lost People not The Other)) But anyway all is a test all the stuffs is Jacob and the smoke monster ...
Drelloddanziz 2 years ago
Narnia is completely nothing compared to lost , but anyway good vid !
LawrenceBarese 2 years ago 4
hey, Great thought but..not really a "theory" It doesnt answer any questions or mysteries. Whispers/smokey/numbers/Jacob etc. I mean lost is about the charectors...the oceanic 6. This theory doesnt explain why they are all connected. Again..good find though and very interesting! Unvail more of your theory though!
dubbue12 2 years ago
The numbers are the important numbers of an equation of when doomsday is. therefore adding all them together saves them.
BARCtroop 2 years ago
yes the producers have admitted that they pay reference to narnia in the show
tinkerin0 2 years ago
I just realized that Charlotte was born 1979 yet in 1977 she was a little girl.??..... cool video It's cool to hear different theories,I personally think that lost is it's own show and just try's to put heaps of references in there of other program's but good thoughts.
nell2727 2 years ago
time goes slower on the island!!!!!!
NewReChallengers 2 years ago
dude is that pilot Parkman from Heroes?
olcrowe 2 years ago
yeah he was reading Jacks thoughts right there
toddsmith00 2 years ago
dont let toddsmith be a dick to you...
it IS parkman from heroes! greg grunberg is his name to be exact, and he was actually supposed to take the place of the lostie leader (jack was meant to die in the premiere), but he ended up producing and starring in heroes instead.
lipphard 2 years ago
I like it
atrain2031 2 years ago
interesting thoughts - I love reading all the different theories. I personally think the story of Jacob is tied to everything. I wil be totally LOST until Feb. 2010!
maykaygal 2 years ago
Concured.
JLindquistBP 2 years ago
cool connection with charlotte dude
nailbiter504091 2 years ago
From watching the season finale your theory looks very plausible now.
ThrasherArt 2 years ago
swweeeet mountain dew shirt....even cooler lotr poster dude...how old are you? you are like 40!
IrisVollmer 2 years ago
hey this was a pretty fun theory.
paladinvash 2 years ago
where did u get the LOST music please answer.. =)
Subclimax 2 years ago
iTunes. They have the complete soundtracks from the seasons with Michael Giacchino's grand compositions.
JLindquistBP 2 years ago
nice
jj abrams is a freaking genius i love lost
Tboardbabe 2 years ago
I like the idea of there being an eternal faith to the mantra of the show: possibly an spiritual, atlantean origin to the "others" born to the island by small people..
drdwl76 2 years ago
whta is up w/ all the midgets in this show?
drdwl76 2 years ago
4 8 15 LOST 16 23 42
bobototox 2 years ago
sooooo wats up with all the whispers in garden of eden ... ???
ixgw 2 years ago
alpert was a pirate
ixgw 2 years ago
possible
OfficialDjBigB 2 years ago
i dont have a theory myself but lost is the greatest show on television. also you have to send this in to abc or jj abrams!
lifetaker1234 2 years ago
Holy cow...
that's a great theory!
Awesome find on the Chronicles connection.
Kudos to you!
theTRUTHgroup 2 years ago
God what song is that, they've used it a lot and it sounds very epic. I think they are going to end the series with that song
cannedhobos 2 years ago
found it,,it's name is "locke'd out again" by Michael Giachinno..it was played on the episode in season 1 when boon died locke was crying and slaming his hands on the hatch door with scenes of him angry after his dad took his kidney,,great episode s01e19 "deus ex Machina"
almadaa11 2 years ago
found it,,it's name is "locke'd out again" by Michael Giachinno..it was played on the episode in season 1 when boon died locke was crying and slaming his hands on the hatch door with scenes of him angry after his dad took his kidney,,great episode s01e19 "deus ex Machina"
almadaa11 2 years ago
Indeed it's quite a good song I listen to it often on my iPod. Michael Giachinno is a very talented composer.
JLindquistBP 2 years ago
Another thing to consider as well is the fact that CS Lewis based all of his things on the bible. The island could be the garden of eden read the theories on that, cause i think they collide with that.
taralengyel 2 years ago
wait wait wait WTF charllote was born in 1979 how??? we saw her in 1977 in the dharma iniatiative THAATS PRETTY FUCKED UP I THINK THEY SCREWED WITH THAT PART AND FORGOT ABOUT IT
ixgw 2 years ago
good point
tegulum1 2 years ago
although not what i think lost is very interesting. You might wanna also think about the station the lamppost as this is what CS Lewis uses to mark Narnia in the books.
taralengyel 2 years ago
Like C S Lewis writings and countless other brilliant works throughout history, i think LOST is telling us something, WE are lost, we've forgotton who we are and when we are. Timelines, dharma, the wheel, creating our own reality, death is an illusion, collective conciousness, looking glass station. its all there, its screaming at us !! but needs more in depth discussion than there is room for here.
awakening321 2 years ago
good theory...now pay attention to the egyptian culture ;)
everano14 3 years ago
THE BIG LOST VOTE! best male.............the vote has started! simply go 2 my page and follow the link:
THE BIG LOST VOTE! ..........best male.........
and vote for your fave male from lost
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
shakespeare19lost 3 years ago
What is your theory? You just stated information.
PerfectBeach21 3 years ago
I think that the Island in LOST could be the same Island referenced in Narnia.
JLindquistBP 3 years ago
That is a very good theory..But who is Jacob? I'm starting to think that w/ this seasons time travel storyline, it will affect many thories that have been floated. Cool theory though.
scrambuild 3 years ago
hey, do you have any theories on how the show is going to end?
JUKIO01 3 years ago
i have a few theories on how it might end, but knowing the genius's behind LOST I'm sure I'll be wrong. Most of my theorizing has been thrown off by the recent episode but I definitely think Locke will lead the Others and that the Oceanic 6 will remain on the Island.
JLindquistBP 3 years ago
my dad agrees with this theory you may be on to something
theWudgeMeister 3 years ago
lost is the best show ever
corlione2 3 years ago
lost is the best show ever
corlione2 3 years ago
Good job! I know that you will not believe this, but I made this connection quite some time ago as I remembered the event from reading "Prince Caspian" years ago.
excelsior1958 3 years ago
Good job on the Charlotte theory!!
Schechgirl 3 years ago
hi i like ur lost thoughts, if u have time go 2 my lost vid n c what u think xx
shakespeare19lost 3 years ago
What about this theory? dowdblog - dot - wordpress - dot - com
DowdBlog 3 years ago
Good theory. I love both Narnia and lost and it would be a good show if this turned out true.
BOjustinBO 3 years ago
Your right on!!! thanks
candlefire1 3 years ago
I think your right on
candlefire1 3 years ago
How about this theory. Remember a few seasons ago when you saw that four toed statue for a second? Now, in episode 2 or 3 in season 5 Sawyer steps on something in the jungle but nothing is said of it. Sawyer is going to get an infection, lose his toe, time travel back many many years and do something heroic. We will find out that the 4 toed statue is a monument of Sawyer.
chambalyn 3 years ago
Wow! Impressive theory! That is both plausible and probable. I applaude you.
JLindquistBP 3 years ago
I love sawyer...but i dnt want him 2 loose his toe...but dats good...
jindawindmaster808 3 years ago
But it's not really your theory, is it? smolesuik said the excact same thing in his recap.
Chrisbajs 3 years ago
It is my theory. Who is smolesuik? I was reading The Chronicles of Narnia, Prince Caspian in preparation for the upcoming movie since I hadn't read it since I was younger and I formulated the theory as I read.
JLindquistBP 3 years ago
Sorry, Lindquist! My comment was meant as a reply to chambalyn a bit further down the page (3 weeks ago). That the four-toed statue could be Sawyer. smolesuik said the same thing in his recap, but maybe he heard it here first, who knows? Check out his theories and recaps, they are very detailed and interesting. He has a channel here on YouTube, search for it! :-)
Chrisbajs 3 years ago
No worries mate
JLindquistBP 3 years ago
yeh it is
apparantly dharma (as in the dharma initiative) is indian 4 something like afterlife.
Also, my own little thoery is:
have u ever seen the movie 'The Truman Show' with Jim Carrey. Well maybe part of the dharma experimentation is that theyre seeing how humans react to it all (as in the people on the plane)
mintzl1 3 years ago
yeh it is
good theory. i heard that dharma (as in the dharma initiative) is indian 4 something like afterlife
but if they were all dead how did some of them get off the island??
mintzl1 3 years ago
Hey is the pilot Matt Parkman from Heroes?
gentlemouse009 3 years ago 2
yes, the actor who plays matt parkman and j j abrams are good friends and jj arbams finds little roles for him in all of his stuff
oasis735 3 years ago
Yes producers have already admitted there ara alot of simarlaritys between the two even naming one of the characters c.s lewis. good observation losty
tinkerin0 3 years ago
The comparison with Narnia does seem very deep but is quite believable, are there any links between timescale on the island and timescale in ther real world like in the book where 1 year is 100 years in Narnia Great theorey though
speedypilot1 3 years ago
You got me. This is the right theory.
ThatTrampGuy 3 years ago
Very well done! And FindYourselfLOST that ice cave were Ben "moves" the island could not be the box because Locke asks Ben if it is and Ben tells him no
NjWade15 3 years ago
the box or "magical cave" could indeed be the frozen donkey wheel cave or the "casimir" as some people reffer to it as, great ideas BUT the outside world can reach the island as we saw in season 4, its not completly unreachable, just hard to get to
FindYourselfLOST 3 years ago
wow, never really looked into Richard, but ya, he doesn't seem to age.
devigne 3 years ago
great vid and theory, since the characther of charlote apear on lost i think a lot of people stared thinking what u say. the whole thing with richard is so great and smart and really makes sence in the way u put it. im really gladd on how both the show lost and the movies narnias are coming out at the same time.
slickvic713 3 years ago
interesting,.. only problem i have is that "black box" was a metaphor, Ben even says that to John later on when he asks about it again.. He is saying that strange things enter the island, and too often to be a coincidence. Its true that mush of the writing is inspired by past novels, there are sooo many references to books and authors...
matthewhannan1 3 years ago
dont u mean "magic box"? ...still get whatyou mean though.
duoh59 3 years ago
Well done Josh, I think I understand what you were saying. Best theory!
claymil21 3 years ago
I love the theory bout Charlette. Not sure about the rest...but good stuff !!
spc73 3 years ago
Hey congatulations!! Nice thinking!! I agree with you!! Lost is the best show on TV!! It is a very good theory!!
vahonors 3 years ago 2
nice shirt change, for the better... i dont have much to offer as a lost or c.s.lewis theory... i liked it... :)
andebarry2990 3 years ago
sorry josh but lost is not that good
but your ideas are cool good thinking
that was pretty smooth changing shirts like that...
BAMFzfs 3 years ago