Added: 1 year ago
From: zpfxlrdnajs
Views: 157,735
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (161)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Meav was my favorite singer in Celtic Woman! :((( I miss you Meav!

  • Speaking of Celtic Woman...

    When do you think David Downes will invite Meav Ni Mhaolchatha, Orla, Fallon, Hayley Westerna, Alex Sharpe, and Lynn Hilary all back into Celtic Woman and invite them to perform and reunite with the group again??

    To me, Celtic Woman is DEAD without them, that's why :|

  • They should do more together and be their own group.

  • @vanessaluvsg: Well said!! Awesome duet!

  • Simply amazing ..

  • I Love there music i have all there CD's And Videos get a lot of comfort from there music

  • @LadyMandyism they're awesome, yes. but let's get real, either they're lip syncing in this video or this performance was re-recorded later in a studio making it appear that they're lip syncing. either way, i think its easier to respect their talent when viewing a performance that is raw and truly live

  • @jacob2289 the human voice is an instrument. go to a concert for your local orchestra and you will likely hear a close to perfect performance. in-tune, good dynamics, etc. just because it sounds good, does that mean it's a pre-recording? No, they practice, pracitce, and practice, for literally weeks/months before the concert. these women are no different. you think they -can't- sound good live, yet -can- sound good in a studio?? why? these aren't pop singers, they're classical artists

  • Greetings! Happy New Year from Angelina and family

  • One thing I find depressing about the holidays ending is that it means no more Christmas Carols(at an appropriate time) until next Christmas. Good thing beautiful singers like Meav and Orla make them such a treat to listen to!

  • @Philosphyfanatic i have 87 Christmas cd's in a 101 cd change of Christmas all the time i love Christmas music

  • some people r just plain stupid

  • just perfect! i remember seeing celtic women in ct a few years back and the papers said they were "too perfect". not sure i understand that. it was simply an amazing concert. voices of angels for sure. thank you for posting.

  • @LadyMandyism Exactly. Well said! ^__^

    (Maybe some people are just jealous. And/or possibly very unobservant. ^_~)

  • wow...beautiful voices....first time I ever heard these women....so breath taking

  • They are so amazing. :)

  • this is a very beautiful song & music :) 5/5 & fav.

  • Who reads negative comments, not me! Just pass them over after first couple words and off i go to next comment etc.

    This recording is lovely as so are the celtic ladies :)

  • Those vocals have a hell of a lot of Pitch Correction on them........

  • @LadyMandyism Because:

    A) DVDs are often dubbed over with the album recording

    B) People are idiots.

    b1) Youtube is pretty much the bottom of the food chain when it comes to internet idiocy.

  • SchwarzeWitwe2 the idiot is at the bottom of the food chain

  • @nakedBison69 Actually, the true cesspool of internet idiocy is Yahoo Answers. ;)

  • and why is that?

  • @nakedBison69 Try reading some of the stuff there - but not too much. 50% of posts are in internet-speak, or otherwise facepalm-worthy. A question I once answered that now seems to be popular is "What is President Obama's last name?" Oy vey.

  • his real last name is O'shitler

  • nice Haunches on the blue one! lol

    

  • why are their voice so hypnotic? :)

  • Do You Hear What I Hear was my fav song when I was a little kid :')

  • The singing is beautiful. Thank you for posting this. Let us all pray for peach this holiday season for those who are cold, hungry and have no place to call home.

  • @LadyMandyism That would be because people seem to think that EVERY popular group lip syncs.

  • there shouldnt be a dislike button

  • @LadyMandyism who said they lipsync? there amazing :D saw them last christmas and loved them and still loving them :D

  • There's a reason why these two were part of the original group, as evidenced by this performance. And as much as I adore the lovely ladies who succeeded Orla and Meav in Celtic Woman, I so miss these two as part of the group.

  • remember what Christmas and Christianity in general are all about, stop shopping, start loving.

  • This song has been a favorite for everyone. Sometimes people thought it was boring. What once was boring has been made absolutely perfect and addictive. Why anyone would hate this I have no idea at all. If they still say that it's boring then they have no taste in music.

  • @LadyMandyism Yes, and the proof is that on the few live videos other than the DVDs out there, they still sound great, but you can notice the difference between the performances... If they were syp-lyncing to a prerecorded track, there wouldn't be any differnces (which is the beauty of live music)... However, for those DVDs and TV specials, I think that the original performance was live, howver, as part of the post-production, they might or might not have rerecorded soem parts.

  • This is beautiful. Amazing voices, amazing women..... I love this!

  • a once annoying song has just become absolutely beautiful. Thank you for posting this. Celtic Woman without a doubt have some of the most beautiful voices I have ever heard.

  • Was this a Celtic Woman special or just Orla and Meav?

  • @voyagerfanatic This was a special by Orla after she and Maev left Celtic Woman. Far as I know it has nothing to do with Celtic Woman.

  • When I hear these two sing, I feel I have had a little glimpse of heaven. Their voices are so angelic.

  • The Celtic woman sings so well! Thanks for posting! : ))

  • WHY DIDI THEY LEAVE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I wish that Celtic Woman would have a reunion with everyone that has every been in the group and they sing a song together

  • Celtic Woman is one great group

  • Beautifully done!!!!

  • If music have a voice ... This is it

  • I was supposed to be named Meav... why did my parents decide to not give me the name of such an awesomely beautiful singer>

  • hold up, when did they leave Celtic Woman. That's crazy. They were my two favorite.

  • at 1:44, i love Meav's hip movment. Why did they both have to leave CW!? CW will never be able to replace them.

  • @orlastar They have families, and wanted to focus on their solo careers.

  • wait i didn't know orla and meave left. when did this happen....? NO!!!!!!

  • @lildemongirl1387 Meav left in 2007 and Orla left in 2008 :-( I'll give you a hint.. it was management issues, solo careers, and their families too. But hopefully they'll both reunite with "Celtic Woman" again soon because they're the best ones ever you know!!

  • YESSS!!!! :) 

  • OBOE OBOE OBOE <3 <3

  • Orla... Meav... Why did you leave...? :'(

  • When Meav started singing I got cold chills all over! I absolutely love her voice!!!!! :)

  • Breathless

    

  • Orla and Maev look AMAZING! love them!

    

  • WOW!!!! Just beautiful

  • I miss the old celtic woman when the two of them were in it. I prefer most of those songs. not that the other girls arent good. but I'd take orla and meav over them anyday.

  • Divine :)

  • I like Celtic Woman more. Be with Orla and Meav, be with Alex and Lynn, be with Lisa Lambe. Of course including the other three Chloe, Lisa Kelly and Mairead.

  • They sound like angels.

    Their voices are so beautiful.

    Thank you.

    George Vreeland Hill

  • these two were the jewels of celtic woman...

  • @vanessaluvsg Those two really are talented, seeing how successful Celtic Woman still is! They really were.

  • @vanessaluvsg I always loved mairead and lisa

  • these two wonderful irish girls :) i don't even know if they're irish, they just keep this feeling. miss them..

  • OoO WOW.

    This is such a beautiful version of Do You Hear What I Hear! <:D

  • I miss Meav and Orla. I'm really sad. Don't feel the Irish flavor to currently members. Now is COME BACK MEAV and ORLA, PLEASE!!! Original members is true Celtic Woman!!

  • im in heaven arent i?

  • Having a voice like that must be like flying! This is so beautiful!

  • omG ORLA & MEAV!!! old memories from celtic woman I <3 you girls!!!

  • I know that provably I will die like a fool wating for a woman that will give me the chills and the butterflies the same way Meav does. I just can't put it into words.

  • I love this video but it is unfair to say Celtic Woman is bad now and Orla and Meav probably would be displeased to hear people saying so. The ladies who filled in were lovely and they have a great knack of choosing lovely talented singers. I think as long as Lisa Chloe and Mearaid stay it can live on. Oh sorry for the spelling. It would be great if they did come back to them, but these two left on good terms. The schedule was a bit much. There was no ill will involved. We must respect it.

  • All though I do like Orla and Meav I think it's unfair to say Celtic woman lost their uniqueness. These ladies are lovely by Chloe Lisa and Mearaid are just as lovely too. Let's not down rate the others to boost two up.

  • Just Beautiful!

  • I miss these two majorly. They were my favorites. I still love Celtic Woman, but it saddens me that Órla and Méav aren't in the group any longer.

    This is a lovely rendition, by the way.

  • SO BEAUTIFUL

  • God, the first notes were awesome. Her voice sounds so relaxing. I could listen to it all day.

  • Now having said all of that, what a wonderful duet! I've played it at least a dozen times using the youtuberepeat function!

  • This is an excellent rendition of a beautiful carol, but I wish to say something. As a cultural bastard of celto-slavic heritage raised in an aftrican-american environment, I think we should say that these women took good musical arrangements, and took them to a whole new level. (I know about arranging--I have done a lot). However, I don't think their ethnicity had much to do with it. They are good, but they would be just as good in say, Italian or Russian. 'Celtic" = marketing schtick.

  • OMG old memories!!!! it's like i was seem celtic woman concert!!!! Y.Y

  • Thumbs up if you want the return of Orla and Meav in the Celtic Woman group!

  • they should have all of the previous celtic woman members in one special concert on DVD

  • I wish they were still a part of Celtic Woman!! The group sounds so different without them in it! These two were my favourite out of the group and now that they're gone they dont sound as good. I still love watching these two perform though! They are absolutely amazing and have very beautiful voices!

  • When I first saw Celtic Woman perform, Orla just caught my eye. I instantly picked out her voice and ever since, I mostly listen for her. I prefer to listen to Celtic Woman songs with Orla in them because of what she adds to the sound. She has always been my favorite.

  • Wow!!! I have always hated this song but now I don't think I'll ever be able to say that again. Wow!!!

  • This is why they were original members of CW. Simply enchanting and unique! Miss them!!

  • Just. Simply. Brilliant.

  • Perfect. Just awesome. Beautiful voices!! Angels on Earth I tell you.

  • Beautiful! Just stunning! Orla for some reason in this song reminds me of Celine Dion in this. I never noticed it before, but she kinda looks like her in her facial structure and her beautiful voice sounds very similar to Celine Dion. Does anyone know if that little girl they showed briefly if that was one of Meav's Daughters? She was really cute!

  • @kardancer1

    How dare someone try and put Celine Dion on their level! Teach Celine intonation and culture and maybe she could attempt to be among Orla and Meav's greatness.

  • Meav, you sweet darling angel..it's very hard for any mere woman these days to capture--and enrapture--me the way you have. I am a Master at picking & predicting beauteous women and although you're already established, I feel there's an even bigger Kettle of Gold waiting for you. This is your year--2011...I expect to see you in a major motion picture, you comely Goddess, you!! I will follow your voice from here on in... Good Health and Good Luck to You & Yours.

  • is it really that easy to sing so awesome without seeming to try!!!!!

  • i love them both since celtic woman and see they together again is just amazing to me! really!

  • This song brings a tear to my eye every time. Orla has such an amazing voice!

  • Nice to see and hear them together.

    I miss them in Celtic Woman!

  • Méav <3

  • i love this song. Orla fallon is my favourit. they did not leave on bad terms. They left to focus on their music career. they wanted to be solo.

  • I do wish that they'd return to the Celtic Woman. The group has never been the same since they've left.

  • @iamalittleitil True. Lynn and Alex are very good singers, but withnout Órla und Méav that Isn´t CW.

  • Sorry to shatter the illusion - I'm a big Celtic Woman fan - but Orla misses her lipsynch for an entire line at 1:26. Nonetheless, great arrangement between their voices - especially at the end.

  • @Gentlenesspact I think that was the choir's line because I heard another voice come in on the next line. I could be wrong though...

  • @Gentlenesspact ...It did not look like she did at all? I don't know what you're seeing. lol

  • @Gentlenesspact No, that was the choir's line, then Orla joined in again. It's common practice to choose backup singers with similar vocal styles, so the voices don't clash. Celtic Woman doesn't lip-synch.

  • @simplystreeptacular

    answers(dot)yahoo(dot)com/ques­tion/index?qid=20081206175557A­AB6oht

  • Do You Hear What I Hear was never one of my favorite carols.. but after this version.. <3 Their voices blend so gorgeous together!

  • Reviewing the total views of Celtic Woman's videos on Youtube as well as the position of CW's album on charts, I can claim that the most successful and flourishing period of CW is when Orla and Meav are still there. Why? Audience always prefer the Celtic heritage strongly shown through perfromance of both Orla and Meav and old CW. Nowadays the new CW lost that uniqueness with Disney songs. Lynn and Alex can't help boost the sales of CW's albums and views of new CW on Youtube.

  • @Tangerine258 I agree, but otherwise it makes me wonder.. it are often Lisa and Chloë who got and get the full praise with their solo-performances. I think CW's succes was because of the big contrast between the songs, now it's all much of the same. Still enjoyable, but not so unique anymore.

    I agree that I miss those two terribly... They were my favorites.

  • @Tangerine258

    CW will make more money with the Pop and Disney Songs than with irish music.

  • @inga1206 That is very untrue, their first two albums easily sold more than the one they just released

  • @JordanKerk99

    Yes maybe. I am curious in which direction Celtic Woman will develop in the future.

  • @Tangerine258 I know what you mean 100% percent! Celtic Woman seriously needs Orla, Meav, Alex, Lynn, and Hayley all back again RIGHT NOW. So let's all email David Downes and ask him to invite Orla, Hayley, Meav, Lynn, and Alex all back into Celtic Woman again. Alex and Lynn will sound much better with Orla, Hayley and Meav!

  • Orla seemed the 'most Irish' the group I thought in that you could hear her accent in her singing. All were great! Meav may have been the best singer in the lot. Miss 'em both!

  • Love them both....

  • I really miss them!! And because of the leave of Alex and Lynn.. this missing is just even more

  • Oh wow, amazing!! I really miss these two!! :'(

    Hope to hear more duets from them in the future!!

  • i love how she bounces with the music. i do that too haha

  • they are my 2 favorites

  • I miss them both so much! They're both so incredibly talented with very lovely and very unique voices. I'm glad to have Orla and Meav together again (even if its only just for this DVD)!!!

  • yeah i stopped watching CW after they disneyfied it with their damn cheoregraphy and americanized songs. I was so so so disappointed. But these two I stuck with. They seem to have emotion and depth behind their talent.

  • Wait did Celtic Woman split up?? Whats with the talk of the departure of Lynn??? :O

  • @Sunflowerdd2 Lynn has leaft yea but dars a new girl coming ist another Lisa and no thay ded not split

  • irishmusicassociation . com/phpBB3/ You can vote for Méav and Órla here! D:

  • her voice have similar to celine dion.......

  • @zyumendv112087 whos voice is similar to celine dion

  • @kilijin1233 orla has a little bit similar to her

  • I love this rendition. Meav, followed closely by Orla, was my favorite from Celtic Woman. The Irish flavor she and Orla lended to the group is unparalled.  Without them, I seldom watch the current group since I feel they have lost their uniqueness

  • @jorcha1960 Orla is better than Meav how dare you....

  • @UndercoverCracker 'better'? They both have totally different qualities and voices. They're impossible to compare.

  • @TheGeantrai Orla is better. 

  • Comment removed

  • @jorcha1960 I think that all of the girls in Celtic Woman have their own uniqueness

  • I never was a huge fan of either Meav or Orla, but I love them 10 times more now!

  • im crig i miss dam so mutch in the celtic woman

  • did meav and orla sing any other songs together?

  • @natasha678 They sang the final song together with the rest of the singers, and they performed O Holy Night together. (Orla played the Harp)

  • This is so beautiful!

  • @inga1206, I know, found out just a while ago. I posted before Lisa L was announced. Lisa L will still be welcome in the group, she has a very impressive biography.

  • Ai que saudade dessas duas no Celtic Woman!!!

    Boas recordações!

    E bem-vinda, Lisa Lambe!

  • Because of Meav and Orla...this is probably my new favorite Christmas song, next to Let it Snow and O Holy Night!!

  • It was awsome to see Meav and Orla sing together since Celtic Woman. We love you guys both. And I'm a new David Archuleta fan.

  • I love the oboe part in this song!! I miss those two singing with celtic woman :'(

  • I hope they both come to Celtic Woman in light of the recent departure of Alex and Lynn.

  • @MeMPW247 so do i orla was my favorite and she still is

  • @MeMPW247

    Celtic Woman has a new member, Lisa Lambe.

  • @MeMPW247 Neither of them would return. They both left the group on bad terms so it is not likely that they would ever re-join the group.

  • @BlackRaven87 They didn't leave the group on bad terms! Meav left because she wanted to concentrate on her solo career and her family. The touring simply took too much time from the family for Meav. That's also why Alex left. Orla left just before the Isle of Hope tour because she simply felt that she couldn't keep up with the touring schedule. Same thing with Lynn's recent departure. The current CW tour is over 80 stops, not including the summer German tour. Its hard on everyone involved.

  • @mattycakes117 I do not want to argue or cause problems but let me just say that I know a bit more about the group that the average person does. Also, I never said anything about Alex and Lynn leaving the group on bad terms, just Meav and Orla.

  • @BlackRaven87 yeah....well many people have claimed and still claim to know more than most...I choose to take the group members(be they former or current members) words over that of these people...

  • @MeMPW247 I doubt very much that will happen considering how CW management treated them. It was not a good situation.

  • @musigirl1986 I never knew why they left CW. They were both my favorites. :(

  • @musigirl1986 what happened?

  • @cwfannumber1 It's a pretty lengthy explanation, but in short, CW management wouldn't give Meav or Hayley a full time schedule in the tours: it was EITHER Meav or Hayley. Both are accomplished musicians and deserve to be heard. They did the same thing with Deidre, who also left in disgust because of it. Meav decided not to continue because she was not appreciated, but CW publicity management told the public that she wanted to spend time with her fam. Hayley left for the same reason.

  • @cwfannumber1 Orla did not like the way CW treated Meav, Hayley, or Deidre and left (wisely) to pursue a solo career. They are such tactful and ethical women: you'll never hear them talk even slightly down of CW. I suspect that this situation is the main reason CW has a hard time getting new vocalists now. Nobody stayed except Lisa K and Chloe. Lisa's husband works for CW somewhere so that's probably why she hasn't had problems. Idk about Chloe... I guess she's a fan fave so they give her alot.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more