Simon Cowell apologized to Katharine McPhee

[InfiniteWhizBang]

Catherine's mom = milf

[ratgirlfancy1]

I bet Simon was paid to say that.

[firetopman]

simon changes into a demon the moment the video ends

[MiladyToxic]

@firetopman LOL

[brongers457]

Despite Katherine McPhee is good or not, I think she is pretty hot.....

[JaredKelso123]

That's why I like Simon, he is able to apologise and admit a wrong when he makes one even though he often is seen saying how bad a performance was, he's a good man.

[vidEvWill]

never had a problem with Kathrine McPhee, should have been a McPhee-Daughtry final, would have been a great battle between them. Best singers that year. Both could have put Taylor Hicks to bed.

[Rhstoned]

Katharine McPhee SUCKS!!!

[tedkawaii]

@Rhstoned oh shut the f*ck up!!

[Rhstoned]

@tedkawaii oh grow the fuck up

[tedkawaii]

@Rhstoned oh thought u cannot handle it, such a poor thing

[Rhstoned]

@tedkawaii what a loser

[tedkawaii]

@Rhstoned what a good-for-nothing bitch who envies with people's success.

[Rhstoned]

@tedkawaii I mean really?! I don't envy anyone's success and I sure the hell don't envy Katharine McPhee... And furthermore I don't understand why you picked a fight with me just because I think she sucks. Am I not entitled to my own opinion? Let's just agree to disagree...

[tedkawaii]

@Rhstoned okay the thing is that I surely am overreacting since I'm a huge fan of her and u have every right to express your opinion, but u can't just say such thing about her like she's a cheap singer with no talent and only the look. Whereas she had her moments and did such a good job at a time. This fight is stupid and how childish I'm sorry.

[Renzic18]

@Rhstoned RHSTONED SUCK....BITCH....GAY....

[Rhstoned]

@Renzic18 lol

[ilovebubblebears]

i think katharine was awesome - i think paula just continued judging with the flow. When Randy started criticizing, she followed. She had no self-opinion. 

[kelvinpyaeko]

@ilovebubblebears haha yeah, just like j lo now...they always follow what the previous judges have said with the flow

[babiiface009]

thumbs up if your gunna watch it back :D

[Rick123691]

Paula had it RIGHT ON THE MONEY, there were pitch problems and she was trying to rush parts of the song instead of slowing down and putting her grace to work. McPhee is quite capable of singing that song and blowing even WHITNEY away.

[MissFueledByCoffee]

@Rick123691 I don't know about blowing Whitney away, considering Whitney owned that song, in every sense of the word, but I am sure Katharine could of done better, but still the judges were harsh, and in a way I can see where Paula was coming from though.

[Pidaras005]

hehe looks like Katharine gave some good pleasure to Simon to make him apologize.

[LgFaver]

i really can't believe Katherine didn't win...

plus she looked so lovely back then.

[Krinisty]

HAHAHAHA @ 0:58 look at Simons face! hee hee hee hee!

[shezzallee]

that is great Simon! :)

[mrghantauke]

if simon eats shit randys gonna eat shit as well.

[kelvinpyaeko]

@mrghantauke lol..so true..and now that simon is out, randy is trying so hard to become a simon wannabe

[rinc1988]

randy is such a follower

[stupidzhangjiayi]

what happened? can someone send me a link of what the judges said?

[dman3334]

@stupidzhangjiayi just look for it on youtube. its right in the related videos

[stupidzhangjiayi]

@dman3334

which one though.

[SJluvre]

paula's a bitch...she should have apologized. EVEN SIMON COWELL apologized, so why didn't she?

[30SecondsToMarsJess]

@SJluvre maybe because she though that wasn't a real good time..

[stefydepp91]

Back when Idol was good..and Randy wasn't trying to be Simon.......

[ActorDudeDead]

still gotz the mcpheever

[MichaelKulow]

There was hope for simon yet!!!!!!!!

[Crape101]

He made world history, Simon Cowell apologized:0

[1katharinemcpheefan]

she deserved that

[strawberryseason]

Paula Abdul was 45 here .... looking fantastic!

[MsTreysongz1]

omg whether in american's got talent or bratin's got talent simon always have on that shirt or a shirt that looks like it in ever shows or adution ,,

he and his one shirts dnt he have money!

[edusuntrebor]

@MsTreysongz1 He's too cool for any other type of shirt.

A shirt with a brand name on it distracts you from the awesomeness that is Simon Cowell.

That's my appraisal on his thought process. That' will be $60 please.

XD

[MsTreysongz1]

@edusuntrebor lol well said , i will soon send ur $60

[bionicrat]

That show still was better with just Randy, Paula, and Simon. Now it's just STUPID AND NEEDS TO GO OFFFFF THE AIR.

[10respect]

@bionicrat you totally forgot Ryan -.- =)

[XxUnitedAsiansxX]

paula : hyahyahyahyah!

[StereoPurple]

paula not apologising, stuck up much thinking she's so good wtf!!

[landdcollection]

lol randy is like "she knows I love her more" xp

[376Strawberry]

wow that sis probaly the first time he ever said sorry lol

[spazbazzz]

Sounds like they got blowies the night before.

[karlskiii]

he wants in her pants

[CaptainCocaine]

@karlskiii who doesn't?

[divastarsarsoory2004]

they apologizes for the "i have nothing performance"?????????

cause they should have!

[1204311]

I luv how Paula laughs..

[MrRamazanLale]

stupid jew Paula

[1984rona]

@MrRamazanLale

אתה טיפש וגזען מה זה קשור שהיא יהודיה- אולי אני אכתוב עליך שאתה בלגי טיפש?

[DecemberWinter23]

Screw Paula! that was rude.

[TitaniumByFire]

simon getting desperate ? he's not the type to admit he was wrong unless there is something to gain from it.

[crimdell]

Can you believe that Taylor Hicks won over Katherine McPhee? Sometimes the voters just get it wrong.

[TitaniumByFire]

@crimdell who's mcpee ? a ghetto hoe ?

[pamibami]

dats soo crap of ryan to put paula on da spot like dat.."do you want to apologise too?"

[dazz100]

ryans an idiot and needs to die. that is all.

[uhesj]

she looked much better as a brunette.

[SubzeroedMind]

Someone got a decent BJ?

;)

[keb1969]

I could have sworn that this apology came in response to Katherine singing "Someone to watch over me".

[MrFaze09]

fuck me i never thought i would see the day simon says sorry.....somebody get simon commited immediately!!!!!!

i refuse to watch a 'soft' simon

[prootas]

really hate paula abdul. she's so fake and totaly wants to have attention everytime she stands up and clap. kara is way better judging than her. she always wants to be cute. sory..

[shannadrummer]

@prootas yesss!! I totally agree!

[Enferushostis]

The compare on this show is a big mouthed jumped fuck. He´s paid to compare and not for his opinion

[DaOriginalShanaiVeal]

Katherine McPhee is so wack; she is sooo blah and so 80s Broadway;

[babe1159]

Can any body tell me if Simon Cowell can play any musical instruments?

[Leryshka]

@babe1159 I really don't know if I cand find that interview right now... but I have watched an interview where simon said he can't play an instrument, he can't sing... but he knows what the public wants... so his job is to introduce in the music industry those who truly deserve it.. :)

[zainabzubairi]

yeah, Paula totally didn't admit that she had been harsh. would have been more graceful to apologize.

[MIZIZVOGUE]

Notice that Paula WOULD NOT apologize?

[carlos312]

paulas a cunt

[bella3987]

Why should she? She was RIGHT the first time. Sorry but Katharine may be able to hit high notes but they aren't the right notes. She was consistently flat that entire season.

[sometimesoonfan]

it really annoys me when these fuckers act like cocaine whore whitney houston is the best thing to come to this planet. She's not!

[theyeller111]

paula looks great in this...

[908211]

Her new album UNBROKEN comes out TOMORROW!

[luckyjamal]

Kurolchi > simon cowell and simon fuller sold the show to FOX , so simon does not own idol , fox does and they are the boses [ fact ] .

[NatTurnerJr]

mcphee had a nice body before she lost all that weight. thin ain't in!!

[luckyjamal]

Simon cowell was told to apologize

in my opinion

[Kurolchi]

How the fuck do you reckon he was TOLD to apologize seeing as he OWNS THE FUCKING SHOW?

[MonroseVila]

He doesn't own the network the show is on.

Please calm down, there's no reason to be so angry.

[HeyBoris]

@Kurolchi

The show is owned by Simon Fuller, not Simon Cowell. It's Fullers franchise.

[Introverder]

I actually think that Simon is a nice guy.. proved here that he has some distance to himself and people who say he's rude I think they are wrong judging themselves also..

[Johnsvolt]

Well done guy's

[WW618]

Simon ddi not have to do that...and his expression didnt tell he meant it !:-)

[lilwayne450]

hes prick

[Zenithson05]

he got paid for this

[losers0are0on0utube]

i know

[spirit0423]

simon can be harsh but usually hes right

randys okay, but half the time i have no idea wat hes talking about

Paula will be missed she always had a sweet spot

Ryan used to love him, but now i wish he was replaced by Ant and Dec

What season is this i haven't watched american idol in a while.

[theazn07]

paula makes everything seem good, but that's why she's full of crap lol

her opinion NEVER matters. she's just there to make things a little happier lol

[TheLartenCrepsley]

i like simon cowell

but him...APOLOGIZE! :O

simon cowell saying sorry means something is seriously up...

[steven220994]

prob got forced by the producers got they were gettin there asses fried from the public lol

[gabbiepumpkin]

Maybe he got laid?

[goldenblueswimmer35]

well at least he was nice!

[Wh73v3R]

you know what? shut up! lol :-D

[OMGIMWHITESHIZZLE]

Simon cowell apologizing= a sign of the apocolypse.

[sinistereb]

@OMGIMWHITESHIZZLE fcking genious

[pviv]

katherine is very pretty, SEXY and awesome voice. she's got everything.

[cool7654321]

And thats why he apologized to her.

[europrg09]

<3 hrth

[Zippyzah]

Does anyone else think Paula has a very freaky look about her?

[clarissa099]

yeah totally sry Zippyzah i accidentally put a thumbs down

[xxxxxxnicolexxxxxxxx]

no she doesnt...ur just jealous cos she is gorgeous and ur a ugly troll

[tobixcupcakes]

what did i say?

[xxxxxxnicolexxxxxxxx]

u said she looks like she has 40 face lifts

[tobixcupcakes]

well actuly it does lol

[lil1big2dude3]

<3

haha

[sbambic]

she went to my high school

[908211]

what was she like?????

[sbambic]

party girl

[LucyEmma123]

nothlithawk777 and nclysander are gay

[paulaslittlegirl101]

teeehee.♥

LOL.

[notthelastword]

If zI had 3 months to libe I would kill him

[seajayshore]

that ryan guy is a twat

[michaelsensation13]

this was such a horrible night.

my favorite, kellie, got eliminated this night ):

[YukonBloamie]

Paula needs to apologize to Corey Clark's penis.

"im sorry corey clark's penis, i enjoyed our time together when you had potential but now that you're worthless I'll be holding out for some Aquaman."

[sausagedogheaven]

Hey, I am Corey Clark's penis and I don't want your apology. Your unholy hole had alcohol as a natural lubricant and now I am old and wrinkled and nobody will look at me. I should just cut my foreskin and end it all, right now.

[DoubleDBlogXX]

that was so cool! i loved that! i love KATHARINE MCPHEE!

[keironlynch]

Ironically enough in the week of the top 10, Katharine sang ''the Voice Within' by Christina Aguilera and the judges praised her interpretation when we all saw (including myself) that it was a really poor performance, later that week, Katharine fell in the bottom 2. When she did ''I Have Nothing'' in the week of top 6 and the judges criticized it, we were all shocked cos it was an amazing performance! Later on that week Kat was in the Top 2 of the six.

Vice versa of the story. Such irony lol

[21yOsUrEsH]

its just twisted alot!

[nclysander]

She was OFF-KEY for large portions of the song! How that can make for an amazing performance I do not know.

[nothlithawk777]

Please do not put your un-educated opinions out here with nothing to back them up. She was most definitely NOT off-key. Anyone who knows anything about singing knows that.

[nclysander]

Please don't call my opinions un-educated or tell me to keep them to myself. Frankly, that's rude and childish.

[nothlithawk777]

Making untrue statements is rude and childish. If you truly do think that it was "off-key," then yes you must be un-educated in singing and throwing out phrases you do not know the meaning of. Obviously I can't demand that you stop, but the continuation of such comments will only serve to tarnish your own tenuous credibility.

[nclysander]

I do think I might have abused the term "off-key"; I did not mean to suggest that she was consistently singing in one key and the orchestra playing in another; I merely meant that she was flat and sharp in different portions of the song.  My mother,, who has her mater's degree in vocal performance, said that her performances were often pitchy.

[nothlithawk777]

I don't hear sharp, and there's only one part where I hear her almost go flat, but pointing out the minor flaws kind of undermines a masterful vocal technique. She has a natural way of breathing, and she navigates flawlessly between her registers, which she deserves more credit for. I think that people often mistake their distaste for her tone in the upper range as being pitchy. In actuality, there are no technical flaws. The quality of the tone is what should be attacked, not the technique.

[nclysander]

Hmmm, you express yourself very well, and there are some things I don't like about her "style" of singing that aren't related to technique, but I don't think it's her tone per se, because I remembered liking her early in the competition.  Looking at it again, she's not flat as often as I thought, though she certainly is at the very beginning. As you said, though, it can happen to the best. (Whether Katharine is part of that number is up to debate. :) )

[LucyEmma123]

no it wasnt me that was on my account everyone goes on it in this house..sorry ive never even watched this vid

[sabrinamom]

I don't think they were that harsh. I think they could have focused on her positives more because she did not sing BADLY she just did not sing it up to the song's potential. Randy was right. They were just a little harsh, that is all.

[wavular]

uh-Yeah-Duh-How the fuck is anybody gonna "wake up" and smell the motherfucking coffee already, if no-one say's a thing about it.but you're right

why do i bother? nobody in this spoiled over fed country of idiots is gonna do a thing, and when we all end up slaves for this satanic government-i hope everyone loves it.

[CRiZYxo]

Paula's so pretty heree :)

[MattRichards711]

I think Katherine is only the second person Simon has ever apologized to. The first time was to Diana Degarmo for saying she was too young all season. I'm not sure if he's ever apologized to anyone since.

[REALBTVSFAN]

what is Simon apologizing for? What song is he talking about?

[anherji]

for her "i have nothing performance" they sid that it was not as good as the original or something like that

[wavular]

it's really pathetic how impotant this shit is to americans that they actually waste a minute of thy're lives to phone in an opinion on a setup bullshit show like this ,while russia puts troops in cuba right under theier stupid noses.

[madnmas123]

And yet here you are taking the time to reply..lol

[rebecca1096]

i agree 1000000% with sweetietweety seriously

[uknowuluvkissa]

I know these people are judges but sometimes they are a bit too harsh and rude. I'd like to see all 3 of them go on a stage and have the world judge them on their singing.

[didoboy2]

simon can feel sorriness?...the world is coming to an end!nah jkz simon is awesome!

[twilight4evuh]

paula can sing rockinforjesus! she has sooooo many music videos u big oaf! so stfu

[xxchris]

fuck me katharine is so hot

[rockinforjesus]

i wish paula would sing, she is a judge, wait she can't

[BUMBAS33D]

fuck me, bet he got a right pay out 4 sayin that on tv. he didnt really mean that. simons a badman solider, brickwall, at least if u actually please the guy u know ur definatly good at singing or wat ever. boh selecta

[7777098]

that was wonderful, in anybody's book, what vigor in that song!

[Lidsey94]

Hes only saying that because he wants to shag her.

[junlongclcl]

SIMON COWELL IS A DOUCHE BAG~~

[bocher222]

katherine was better than the the grey haired guy

[sweetietweey]

Who? Taylor Hicks?

They only liked him because he was 'fun'.

[purpleglitterrox]

season 5 was the best

[oldParasiteSingle]

Figures. I bet David Foster tore Cowell a new one for his bias. That Simon guy probably buys a new ferrari as a tax writeoff every time his tires get slashed.

[rickyesparza]

Did Paula ever say anything good about Katharine's singing? I don't think so.

[purpleglitterrox]

well we dont know it never really made a whiole lot of sense

[thewhiteboy114]

i feel like paula was mean to katharine starting around this time of the competition...and basically refusing to say she did well on this performance is an example

[mellii101]

He only apologized because so many people called in and complained. They were all still really rude to her.

[marcosffhvi]

Judges were unfair. She was not trying to be LIKE whitney houston, she was just singing her song. and she did really good.

I feel bad for theses kinds of limited people.

[kalzx]

simon got a look at her ass that is why he did this

[TheDefunktPistol]

nah, as much as he likes the media to think, i doubt hes the top dog behind american idol..i spect he got an ass whippin by some producer of fox exec

[jdmans]

Simon it is really that you can't accept any criticism and you were covering for your bad judgment to begin with,just like when you did not want Chris Daughtry to even go to Hollywood for round 1

[hobyboy07]

I remember seeing this on TV when this originally aired. It was just as shocking even then.

[xmusician4lifex]

i love katharine. alott.

[JanAcklez88]

i have nothing

[sminxsmjs]

me neither... no clue to what she sang

[GamerGirl000]

duh,look @ the description!!!

[sminxsmjs]

what did she sing?

[GamerGirl000]

omg,did u even look?"i have nothing" by whitney houston

[javaverc]

which song did she sing "last week" ? i mean, for which performance are they apologizing??

[eeinky]

i have nothing