Guy Pratts gestures e.g. 1:22 are strange, what does he want to show? that he could much better then Roger Waters, that he is bored or unchallenged that he is the genious of the band?
I can understand what you mean, but I don't think it is so. Being a Bass player myself, sometimes I let go of the bass after hitting an open string. It is just something that comes naturally.
Guy pratt does not need to show off....you on the other do with this stupid comment of yours. I know it have been 1 years ago . But do mind you, that a garage punkband your in properly. IS FAR from the artists in this video..who are you to judge there skills?!
You should be learning from them...the luckly do not need that from you!
I think people tend to downrate Final Cut because it's considered (consciouly or not) too much of a RW solo album. I find it close to Pros and Cons than to a Floyd album. Otherwise I love it.
Just joined and in a short time, I assume that this is one Mr. Richard Wright......not sure when this was made, but God bless David for adding an "original" to a sone like Echoes. How F'n awesome.........!
ok, it may not be seen as the floyd's greatest work but why do all floyd fans have to have a "favourite era" and hate everything else? I love all pink floyd era's, that's what makes the pink floyd what they are, if you are a true floyd fan you'll love then barrett days, the waters days & the gilmour days all equally :-)
I didn't think you could do that. Both parts are almost twenty minutes when combined. I didn't think Youtube would let you post a video over 10 minutes or 1024 MB.
Why are you saying all this insulting things about me? I am very offended by you, and I want you to apologize... David Gilmour would be very unhappy if he knew his admirers talks the way you do...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I think he would be very flattered that someone worships him to the level of orgasm.. You know what I think? I think you are a Troll.. and all you want is delicious food, and I'm not going to feed you... I don't think you like David Gilmour at all, I believe that you are a Christina Aguilera fan, who's all his dreams are to be kicked in the balls by her, you perv...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
actually gilmour is my favourite musician.. i just like to wind soft fucks like you up to the point of Intellectualism. [refering to your recent comment] p.s best not to reply.. Gilmour wouldn't like you fighting to much now.. would he : D
People are complaining that this performance is without roger waters - I probably could'nt tell he was missing if I did'nt know it was from 2006. Not like he sings on Echoes or really has much of a signature bass style (maybe a whole lot of octave notes if anything). Pink Floyd still sounds great without him.
definitey agreed he was a great composer, although his final compositions with floyd (basically the final cut) were lousy...probably better that they went on without him
IMHO, Waters' compositions on The Final Cut were fantastic - the music was a litlle subtle, but the lyrics were beautiful and I think the songs fit together very well to form a captivating concept. Very emotional.
I have to say i never listened to The Final Cut all that much...i kinda listened a few times after i bought it as a teenager and never picked it up again. ...maybe i'll give it a few more listens before i write it off completely...appreciate the comment
i know it's pink floyd, i know those guys create this one of the best songs ever, but i don't like this performance, i guess is too much rithm, the drumer make some arrangements that i just don't get, i know, the pompei version of this song, make me cry, but this mm, sorri.
Unfortunately, I've never seen Pink Floyd live, but I was at the first night at the Royal Albert Hall with David Gilmour's concerts. One of the best nights of my life!
Well I'm just surprised that people try to make somethin' outta nuthin'. All I can say, is that I enjoy the variety.. without the constant worry of what other ppl think! Fuck the critics.. enjoy the music.
Ok.. no Gilmour isn't better than Hendrix. No one is better than Hendrix. But I'd say Dave is #2! And for the ppl that claim Roger Waters is Pink Floyd... wtf?! Waters' lyrics are irreplaceable, but Gilmour is the sound you heard through the years! Nothin' compares to the original band, and it's something we all must get used to.. although it may suck immensely!!!
fuck ppl stop comparing guitarist! they are all great in their own ways and thats why we dont have one god of guitar on the radio or one person making albums. many ppl contribute to music as a whole and no one is superior over the next
You are 100% right...you can't say one guitarist is the best...you can't compare all guitarists against each other...how do you compare Gilmour to a Santana, or Brian May to Hendrix...they are each unique, hence their greatness...otherwise they'd just be technicians, good studio sessionists but ultimately forgettable
People are always gonna compare guitarists and so they should. I think Gilmour is the better guitarist although I do love hendrix too however Gilmour's sound is so clear, every note played with precision whereas sometimes I felt Hendrix could put too many notes into a space... less is more.
Look, as much as Roger claimed he didn't need the other 3, and vice versa, they were all full of shit. They needed each other to make that Floyd sound. Roger was the visionary and the other 3 were the vessel.
for all those people going against roger waters or david gilmour, they are all as good as eachother, rogers song writting and davids kick ass solo's, just because at one point in their lives they were at eachothers necks dnt mean you should pick sides, they are all great rock stars!
uhh... David Gilmour wrote Dogs of War if thats what you are refering to, Roger had nothing to do with that album wasn't with the band anymore at the time for near 4 years
I cant wait to get the dvd remeber that night. im alos goin to the movie theatre to see the preview. Gilmour is underated, clearly better than hendrix
Was David and Rick, note that the band drummer looks like Mason where he was young at the 60's, jajaja, but he is an american new drummer (I don't know his name, but plays well the Nick's notes).
Great song, thank you bibirossa, I'm repeating the betotony88's words "blow my entire fucking mind, i love this song... ", (isn't sarcasm, really are the right words!!)
yes that's true! i said on one of his videos "SIR DAVID" and some idiot replied "he's not a sir cos he's not been knighted so don't call him SIR! but to me he is sir! and probably god! the man is truly amazing! i wish i could play half as good!
Like the 500th time I've watched this past few weeks, this here was simply said Awesome, personally I prefer Live version the best, because it put them to the teswt, and they walked it down easily, Some Bad crazy Awesome Mofo's up there playing this Masterpeice of Music!
It kind of sounds like the Live in Pompeii version. Personally, I like the studio the best from the album Meddle. Personally if you want my opinion about PF's best album it would be Meddle. It rocks!!!
I will not need to press this as I am sure true Floyd fans will agree, Roger is still awesome as is the rest of Floyd, althoguh their not together, If you got an ear, every peice of new music they lay out still plays true to Pink Floyd of Old, Rogers got his thing Gilmour has his, as does Nick and Rick. they all rock, and all their music is Great, including solo albums
This gets a little crazy and strays a bit. When Floyd toured during the 70's they sometimes played songs completely losing any recognizable hint of the song as recorded on the album. Sometimes it worked. Sometimes it didn't. I heard a live recording of Brain Damage using guitars without any synthesizers believe it or not. It made me think the keyboards had broken or they lost the prerecorded loops at the last minute.
He plays the first solo in the style of a MLOR or Divison Bell song. The original solo, especially the version on live at Pompeii, was much spacier. Other than that, this is a smokin version.
also wanted to point out that there is another video version of this i have on VHS...way older ..it was the Live at Pompei video! very hard to find..or at least it was several years ago
i gotta agree with the previous post..i gotta say Echos is a personal favorite..i think meddle was my favorite album..San tropez...another great...its so hard to decide....other albums had their greats too. dogs,pigs, sheep..LOL...pink floyd...amazing group..its funny, but when i attended my classes at Berklee, my music theory class actually harmonically analyzed alot of pink floyd songs as well as the beatles,but floyd is my fave.
hahahaha meddle 2k showed bolla what's up...tell people to think before they speak when you don't even know what you are talking about yourself...gilmours solo albums all came post pink floyd...he had a brief spell in jokers wild, as was previously stated...i enjoy some songs on all his solo albums but not all of them and division bell i think is stil his best work
best pink floyd song ever? i dunno, either this or dogs are my personal 2 favorites and i'm if someone comes on here who's only heard there radio hits and says what about comfortable numb and money i won't take you seriously...great songs but only say they are your favorites if they are your true favorties after you have heard all of which the phenomenal pink floyd has to offer
My first thought after leaving the concerts in New York was, "I hope to god he is recording one of these shows for DVD" I couldnt stand the thought of never experiencing those shows again. In the mean time its great that many people placed these recordings on UTube of all of us to enjoy. I would love to here some discussion on achieving great tone. Ive been a long time Gilmour fan and just recently started playing. Id be interested to know what other guitarists have to say.
OMG . . . I cannot wait for the release of the DVD "Remember that Night" slated for September 2007. It was recorded at Royal Albert Hall. Yes, "Echoes" should be included. Confirmed are also "Comfortably Numb" and "Arnold Layne," BOTH featuring David Bowie. The "Two Davids" should rock!!!
To Mahapurusalaksana, the song is called Echoes, and it is from the album 'meddle'. There is an excellent version of it split into two parts on the DVD "pink floyd, live in pompei" if you're a fan, check it out. It was recorded just prior to Dark side... being released. This concert version is quite good, I hope it comes out onan offical release.
It's water, they would never drink coffee on stage, if they did, it would be tea since English folk typically don't like American coffee...and they have to have water on stage...if you ever played live you would know that.
Really how far u think pink floyd would of got without gilmour.not sayin that they would of sucked by no means but...he added alot the the band..his guitar playin alone
rick wright also added unique keyboard/piano/organ sounds to the band that make it pink floyd, as well as nick's drumming style. roger waters has average bass playing nothing special but really good songwriting talent.. in other words everyone plays an equal part in making this band what it is.. an awesome band
In the 70's this song must have been really heavy!
I love and adore PF, they are my favouritte band!
And stop comparing Gilmour and Rogers. Rogers was good on guitar, lyrics and sound-experimenting while Gimour was a excelent player on guitar and ok on lyrics.
Rick is great...I'm really glad I was there for one of the last times...
giuliolgf 5 months ago
BEAUTIFUL, what a cool lesson for other shits, whith their rap Ahahahah :p But One Of theses Days..... !!
molopard 8 months ago
it must be undescribable having gilmour and richard few meters from you.
japasetelagoas 1 year ago
Love this song.. Gilmour and Wright singing together <3<3<3
crazydiamond1991 1 year ago
Super nice! Thank you for posting. I miss these guys. : (
But I hope that we get to see them play a little more before the end.
--
Luna
HeliGirl 1 year ago
Guy Pratts gestures e.g. 1:22 are strange, what does he want to show? that he could much better then Roger Waters, that he is bored or unchallenged that he is the genious of the band?
lordhurga 1 year ago
@lordhurga maybe he just wants to show that he's playing an open A string?..))
dzub93 1 year ago
@lordhurga That you do not know how to use then & than
bleekblock 1 year ago
@lordhurga
I can understand what you mean, but I don't think it is so. Being a Bass player myself, sometimes I let go of the bass after hitting an open string. It is just something that comes naturally.
PinkFloydGuitarist 9 months ago
@lordhurga
Guy pratt does not need to show off....you on the other do with this stupid comment of yours. I know it have been 1 years ago . But do mind you, that a garage punkband your in properly. IS FAR from the artists in this video..who are you to judge there skills?!
You should be learning from them...the luckly do not need that from you!
Secondlifecreator 5 months ago
I think people tend to downrate Final Cut because it's considered (consciouly or not) too much of a RW solo album. I find it close to Pros and Cons than to a Floyd album. Otherwise I love it.
cbaltatescu 1 year ago
omg you got pink
paulayork 1 year ago
Can't repeat this experience no more :( sounds different but it's the same thing as it was in the 70's or at Pompeii, chemistry !
soropalnita 1 year ago
Just joined and in a short time, I assume that this is one Mr. Richard Wright......not sure when this was made, but God bless David for adding an "original" to a sone like Echoes. How F'n awesome.........!
scribe3s 2 years ago
nice but too digital
bigcheese2001 2 years ago
The best solo in the entire tour!
LexSeifer 2 years ago
FANTASTIC !!!! Whatever Floyds do becomes a masterpiece. David and Rick are just beautiful in this composition. We miss You Richard...
ComfortablyNumb7411 2 years ago
The Final Cut is one of the greatest listens ever from start to finish
kfender1969 2 years ago 5
I agree, final cut is totally underrated
ok, it may not be seen as the floyd's greatest work but why do all floyd fans have to have a "favourite era" and hate everything else? I love all pink floyd era's, that's what makes the pink floyd what they are, if you are a true floyd fan you'll love then barrett days, the waters days & the gilmour days all equally :-)
flanaj2 2 years ago 11
Io c'ero ciao
11kry08 2 years ago
its funny how people still complain when the're seeing things for free
mikecappa 2 years ago 4
this guy blows my fuckin mind in these moment, god bless david gilmour and pink floyd for god sake
raulishoogallagher 2 years ago
masterpiece...........
2564angelina 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
If your not going to show the who song at once. Then dont bother. Humans are so fucked up..
sixstringfender 3 years ago
I didn't think you could do that. Both parts are almost twenty minutes when combined. I didn't think Youtube would let you post a video over 10 minutes or 1024 MB.
IntelligentInfect 3 years ago
I think Gilmour's midichlorian level is higher than Anakin's.
Mahapurusalaksana 3 years ago 36
jajajajjajaja
alago85 3 years ago
ha ha ha ha ha,...yeah
pinkoplat 3 years ago
this tune (both parts) is so fuckin amazing musically, just inspiring me tp play music anytime i watch it
sirdiablos 3 years ago 5
Love it.
It is funny to me that the video was added to youtube (8/17/06) before it happened (12/08/06).
mgriffis38 3 years ago
I think the date "12/08/2006" is written as Day/Month/Year so it was added 5 days after it happened. Good eye :P
gomdolii 3 years ago
good bye richard wright good bye syed ...man the masters are leaving one after the other ...who is gonna sing the echoes like richard ...
masterofthenight0 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
its sid not syed. don't make him sound arabian now...
her0indragon 3 years ago
It's Syd...
PLuTTzor 3 years ago 18
great tune i love it.really good camera man you caught the moment there you should get as job as one.lol 10/10
robnbob 3 years ago
perfect ,rest in peace richard you will never be forgotten my friend i'll see u in the dark side of the moom.
tatometal 3 years ago
does he ever bend wrong?
luizantgomes 3 years ago 2
Vive Pink Floyd!
Echoes is one of the best psychedelic-prog-rock song ever. The guitar play can truly be the epitome of this band.
Hope see that in concert before i die...
aragorn252525 3 years ago
If I was at stage when David THE GOD Gilmour set his holy hand on the guitar in the first solo, I would've probably cum in my underpants...
blumItamar 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you would faggot
TheConquistor 3 years ago
Why are you saying all this insulting things about me? I am very offended by you, and I want you to apologize... David Gilmour would be very unhappy if he knew his admirers talks the way you do...
blumItamar 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
do you think he would be happy if you cummed your pants near him?
TheConquistor 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think he would be very flattered that someone worships him to the level of orgasm.. You know what I think? I think you are a Troll.. and all you want is delicious food, and I'm not going to feed you... I don't think you like David Gilmour at all, I believe that you are a Christina Aguilera fan, who's all his dreams are to be kicked in the balls by her, you perv...
blumItamar 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
actually gilmour is my favourite musician.. i just like to wind soft fucks like you up to the point of Intellectualism. [refering to your recent comment] p.s best not to reply.. Gilmour wouldn't like you fighting to much now.. would he : D
TheConquistor 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I just lisened to David Gilmour plays Shine On You Krazi Diamond and I nearly came..
blumItamar 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ok, good for you.
TheConquistor 3 years ago
I love how true they are to the original material.
hanscarter 3 years ago
this is the best pink floyd song ever
shoebert357 3 years ago
I love how Dave and Rick are playing off each other.
zledhalen 3 years ago 2
R.I.P. Richard Wright :(
Great Song, Great band :)
lullo456 3 years ago 3
yeah it sounds bad ass but its not roger waters on bass or nick mason on drums so it could be better
terminalshock87 3 years ago 2
Great to see this song back in the live setting after all these years. This is my personal favorite Pink Floyd song.
larrystarstruck 3 years ago 2
the pink floyd must go on
pinkfloydthirst 3 years ago 5
Powerful, plenty of balls, but just wish the mix all maybe the camera pick up had the base pumping, as in Live at Pompei.
Ninyae1 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Pink Floyd wrote "Dogs".
BrokenChair88 3 years ago
fuck this guys are fucking, masters of the music long live david guilmore
fradas02 3 years ago
Damn, Dave & Rick were dueling so hard during the funk section...
Brock2097 3 years ago 6
People are complaining that this performance is without roger waters - I probably could'nt tell he was missing if I did'nt know it was from 2006. Not like he sings on Echoes or really has much of a signature bass style (maybe a whole lot of octave notes if anything). Pink Floyd still sounds great without him.
VBshredder 3 years ago 8
I have to agree,though Roger was a great composer there was a big change in the way albums were put together after he was gone.
scott0860 3 years ago
definitey agreed he was a great composer, although his final compositions with floyd (basically the final cut) were lousy...probably better that they went on without him
VBshredder 2 years ago
IMHO, Waters' compositions on The Final Cut were fantastic - the music was a litlle subtle, but the lyrics were beautiful and I think the songs fit together very well to form a captivating concept. Very emotional.
But I definitely respect your opinion.
dufortrph 2 years ago 3
I have to say i never listened to The Final Cut all that much...i kinda listened a few times after i bought it as a teenager and never picked it up again. ...maybe i'll give it a few more listens before i write it off completely...appreciate the comment
VBshredder 2 years ago
nice pink floyd fans respect XD..
mezcalineboy 2 years ago
i have actually played both these songs and guitar and waters part is alot harder to play than people think
mer54gull 3 years ago
richard wright is amazing him and the master divid gilmour
masterofthenight0 3 years ago 4
i know it's pink floyd, i know those guys create this one of the best songs ever, but i don't like this performance, i guess is too much rithm, the drumer make some arrangements that i just don't get, i know, the pompei version of this song, make me cry, but this mm, sorri.
malasnoticias2210 3 years ago
holy shit
Rick's ascending organ and Gilmour's smooth guitar gave me chills in the beginning..wow
SimMaster 3 years ago 5
Anyone know what fuzz pedal hes using on the Funk/Jam part? I think its a Big Muff but im not sure, definitly not the Arbiter Fuzz
kaidosraven 4 years ago
i love him
and i lov echoes
amazingggggggggg
izznicevideo 4 years ago 2
gilmour is god
petyomken 4 years ago 6
5:56 and what proceeds it...funk levels are off the charts. so funky i had to shut my computer down.
bostonrepresent 4 years ago 2
Unfortunately, I've never seen Pink Floyd live, but I was at the first night at the Royal Albert Hall with David Gilmour's concerts. One of the best nights of my life!
bujin1977 4 years ago
great video !!!
pink73floyd 4 years ago
I have seen Pink Floyd twice Live... they are the best in person... I always managed to get either 3rd row or 5th row.
You are in heaven when you see them!
cuteblanca 4 years ago
best day in my life was having my son born. second best was seeing P.F. together in the 70's...ah, yes, heaven for sure (and a lot less painful!)
lilRadRidinHood 3 years ago 6
Great video! This one is even better than the one which made it onto the DVD!
bujin1977 4 years ago 2
What a great concert it was! Lucky us who were there...
fede87f 4 years ago
Wow, wonderful to see this. is the man on keyboard and vocals richard wright?
JotheBytle 4 years ago
Yes, it is. Gilmour is great, but people shouldn't forget Wright.
Wroom90 4 years ago 6
Well I'm just surprised that people try to make somethin' outta nuthin'. All I can say, is that I enjoy the variety.. without the constant worry of what other ppl think! Fuck the critics.. enjoy the music.
hks20psi 4 years ago
Ok.. no Gilmour isn't better than Hendrix. No one is better than Hendrix. But I'd say Dave is #2! And for the ppl that claim Roger Waters is Pink Floyd... wtf?! Waters' lyrics are irreplaceable, but Gilmour is the sound you heard through the years! Nothin' compares to the original band, and it's something we all must get used to.. although it may suck immensely!!!
hks20psi 4 years ago
fuck ppl stop comparing guitarist! they are all great in their own ways and thats why we dont have one god of guitar on the radio or one person making albums. many ppl contribute to music as a whole and no one is superior over the next
rekcilkcid 4 years ago 2
You are 100% right...you can't say one guitarist is the best...you can't compare all guitarists against each other...how do you compare Gilmour to a Santana, or Brian May to Hendrix...they are each unique, hence their greatness...otherwise they'd just be technicians, good studio sessionists but ultimately forgettable
templar44 4 years ago
People are always gonna compare guitarists and so they should. I think Gilmour is the better guitarist although I do love hendrix too however Gilmour's sound is so clear, every note played with precision whereas sometimes I felt Hendrix could put too many notes into a space... less is more.
pwilkas 4 years ago
if anything lets put it this way.......theyre the best in their genre.....how bout that?
legalizepot2007 4 years ago 2
That's Hendrix's strap ;)
msurdin7 4 years ago
David Gilmour is the best guitar player ever. Even better than Hendrix himself!!!
Jahrackal 4 years ago 2
best....
bgss 4 years ago
aw dave
paula
hang in
paulayork 4 years ago
Look, as much as Roger claimed he didn't need the other 3, and vice versa, they were all full of shit. They needed each other to make that Floyd sound. Roger was the visionary and the other 3 were the vessel.
bol316 4 years ago
Bullshit, They were a barband until David took them to the next level!
kindsoul420247 4 years ago
A car isn't a car until it has wheels. David finally completed the band but that does not mean he carried them.
bol316 4 years ago
Yea, One member isn't Pink Floyd!
kindsoul420247 4 years ago
I would give anything just to hear Davids guitar live...
Gilmour3 4 years ago 2
rick is cute
marritdepp 4 years ago
THANKS A LOT!
I gotta see em live before they retire...
bonichorri 4 years ago 2
Great Sounds Great Vibes Still Makes The Hairs On The Back Of My Neck Stand Up! Pink Floyd Rock! ;o)_
homelif3 4 years ago
Great!
darkembracemusic 4 years ago
for all those people going against roger waters or david gilmour, they are all as good as eachother, rogers song writting and davids kick ass solo's, just because at one point in their lives they were at eachothers necks dnt mean you should pick sides, they are all great rock stars!
bollen91 4 years ago 2
hear hear. seriously though, waters IS (or rather, WAS), pink floyd.
ganpondorodf 4 years ago
wright sang the song with gilmour, waters played bass in this song. I dont know what your point is??
slick3xexx 4 years ago
i was taking the piss you absolute retard.
ganpondorodf 4 years ago
I agree, nicely put, very well indeed.
slick3xexx 4 years ago
Man they are not rock stars!!!!!!Stop saying this ridiculous expression!!they are rockers!theres a big difference between these two terms...
Gilmour3 4 years ago
david gilmour richards wright ,pinkfloyd ..love u all dont forget roger waters nick mason ,,and good bye syd....
masterofthenight0 4 years ago 2
Solo is so great. I only have two words, thanks for uploading this reminds me of pompeii
slick3xexx 4 years ago 2
;_; wonderful..I love youuuuuu
peaceandlotta1 4 years ago
Thanks for upload this video. Is amazing
rita1777 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Somehow watching Rock music played by gray haired old men becomes a parody.
Entropy56 4 years ago
roger is a chump gilmour rules.
newmorning7 4 years ago
Roger is an amazing writer and arranger of music, Gilmour is an amazing guitarist. People should learn to enjoy them both.
pwilkas 4 years ago 4
You0re right pwilkas, we should learn to enjoy them both.
But something more to say: Gilmour arrenged or wrote the music of the best Roger's creations in Pink Floyd (Dogs and Time for instance).
Anyway, we shouldn't speak about that. Enjoy the music.
jorkanmx 4 years ago 4
finally some one who gets it why must there be debates in vids where you cant debate or argue
Tangerinemustang 4 years ago 3
uhh... David Gilmour wrote Dogs of War if thats what you are refering to, Roger had nothing to do with that album wasn't with the band anymore at the time for near 4 years
LordEli 3 years ago
there's a Floyd song called Dogs from the album Animals..
SimMaster 3 years ago 2
You havent lived till you hear dogs, and more importantly, gilmours solo on it. Do yourself a favour and get the whole animals album.
ex0duzz 3 years ago 6
beautiful.
i liked the original one better tho still amazing
JD0x0 4 years ago
I was there the night before....
...only one word: AMAZING
aandreotti 4 years ago
I cant wait to get the dvd remeber that night. im alos goin to the movie theatre to see the preview. Gilmour is underated, clearly better than hendrix
derektm19 4 years ago
Was David and Rick, note that the band drummer looks like Mason where he was young at the 60's, jajaja, but he is an american new drummer (I don't know his name, but plays well the Nick's notes).
Great song, thank you bibirossa, I'm repeating the betotony88's words "blow my entire fucking mind, i love this song... ", (isn't sarcasm, really are the right words!!)
jorkanmx 4 years ago
The name of the new drummer which was in last David's tour is Steve DiStanislao. Great performer.
sydshines 4 years ago
david gilmour is just the best guitar player ever no more comments.
tatometal 4 years ago 10
be careful when you say that bc some little prick will say how good jimmy page is. but every1 knows gilmour is better=P
JD0x0 4 years ago 2
yes that's true! i said on one of his videos "SIR DAVID" and some idiot replied "he's not a sir cos he's not been knighted so don't call him SIR! but to me he is sir! and probably god! the man is truly amazing! i wish i could play half as good!
tomika1967 4 years ago 3
The guys who replied to you must be really stupid
qwerty09121209 4 years ago
yeah, you are right
Mahapurusalaksana 4 years ago
thank you VERY MUCH for this vid!!! =)
thecryingguitar 4 years ago
Like the 500th time I've watched this past few weeks, this here was simply said Awesome, personally I prefer Live version the best, because it put them to the teswt, and they walked it down easily, Some Bad crazy Awesome Mofo's up there playing this Masterpeice of Music!
LordEli 4 years ago
It kind of sounds like the Live in Pompeii version. Personally, I like the studio the best from the album Meddle. Personally if you want my opinion about PF's best album it would be Meddle. It rocks!!!
rdsieben 4 years ago 2
blow my entire fucking mind, i love this song...
betotony88 4 years ago
I will not need to press this as I am sure true Floyd fans will agree, Roger is still awesome as is the rest of Floyd, althoguh their not together, If you got an ear, every peice of new music they lay out still plays true to Pink Floyd of Old, Rogers got his thing Gilmour has his, as does Nick and Rick. they all rock, and all their music is Great, including solo albums
LordEli 4 years ago
the studio track of this song is one of the best songs ever, along with dogs, time, numb and marooned
prettyboy32 4 years ago 3
i knew iit!! :)
thanks Mahapurusalaksana
odguerr 4 years ago
Superb! Can`t wait for Gilmour`s new live dvd.
Antelope6 4 years ago
nu mames q bn toka!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
skamoso11 4 years ago
is gilmour touring with mason and wright?
i can't see well
odguerr 4 years ago
Wright is there, but I can't see Nick Mason.
Mahapurusalaksana 4 years ago
que pedazo de musico es lo mejor david el mejor por siempre
atop18 4 years ago
This gets a little crazy and strays a bit. When Floyd toured during the 70's they sometimes played songs completely losing any recognizable hint of the song as recorded on the album. Sometimes it worked. Sometimes it didn't. I heard a live recording of Brain Damage using guitars without any synthesizers believe it or not. It made me think the keyboards had broken or they lost the prerecorded loops at the last minute.
mstriple 4 years ago
He plays the first solo in the style of a MLOR or Divison Bell song. The original solo, especially the version on live at Pompeii, was much spacier. Other than that, this is a smokin version.
bleekblock 4 years ago
If you guys like this, watch live at pompeii, its sick.
Long live pink floyd, greatest band ever
kegster102 4 years ago
AMEN!! I watch that DVD everyday!
GeneralKenobiSIYE 4 years ago
To bad Waters is such a prick. The Floyd would be together right now. Wish they wouldn't have been such children about things.
GeneralKenobiSIYE 4 years ago
why do you think its just rogers fault you obviously know them personally
donorleone 4 years ago
The Best there ever was! Just list.............
Slippinginar 4 years ago
i suppose i shouldn't have said post pink floyd...what i meant was they came after pink floyd had already started my bad buddy
kennyscotten 4 years ago
yes guy is on bass...
jarretaderas 4 years ago
also wanted to point out that there is another video version of this i have on VHS...way older ..it was the Live at Pompei video! very hard to find..or at least it was several years ago
afroggie00 4 years ago
yeah..i've got it too afroggie. They released Live at Pompeii on DVD.
cgiuk 4 years ago
I have the dvd and vhs of the wall movie, live at pompeii and pulse
Videogametester 4 years ago
i gotta agree with the previous post..i gotta say Echos is a personal favorite..i think meddle was my favorite album..San tropez...another great...its so hard to decide....other albums had their greats too. dogs,pigs, sheep..LOL...pink floyd...amazing group..its funny, but when i attended my classes at Berklee, my music theory class actually harmonically analyzed alot of pink floyd songs as well as the beatles,but floyd is my fave.
afroggie00 4 years ago
hahahaha meddle 2k showed bolla what's up...tell people to think before they speak when you don't even know what you are talking about yourself...gilmours solo albums all came post pink floyd...he had a brief spell in jokers wild, as was previously stated...i enjoy some songs on all his solo albums but not all of them and division bell i think is stil his best work
kennyscotten 4 years ago
gilmour 's 2 first solo albums didn't come post floyd...
first one came out before the wall and second one before momentary lapse of reason....
and you say the other guy don't what he's talking about haha
gibijobi 4 years ago
best pink floyd song ever? i dunno, either this or dogs are my personal 2 favorites and i'm if someone comes on here who's only heard there radio hits and says what about comfortable numb and money i won't take you seriously...great songs but only say they are your favorites if they are your true favorties after you have heard all of which the phenomenal pink floyd has to offer
kennyscotten 4 years ago
Una magia irripetibile.
ssspaceman86 4 years ago
My first thought after leaving the concerts in New York was, "I hope to god he is recording one of these shows for DVD" I couldnt stand the thought of never experiencing those shows again. In the mean time its great that many people placed these recordings on UTube of all of us to enjoy. I would love to here some discussion on achieving great tone. Ive been a long time Gilmour fan and just recently started playing. Id be interested to know what other guitarists have to say.
HZimmern 4 years ago
just marvellous
fasomeno 4 years ago
yes i think the bas player is guy pratt - his father-in-law is a famous keyboard player
mikeplusplus 4 years ago
dave has such a kickass tone.
benerack 4 years ago
im pretty sure guy pratt is on bass, could be wrong
roflcopter804 4 years ago
OMG . . . I cannot wait for the release of the DVD "Remember that Night" slated for September 2007. It was recorded at Royal Albert Hall. Yes, "Echoes" should be included. Confirmed are also "Comfortably Numb" and "Arnold Layne," BOTH featuring David Bowie. The "Two Davids" should rock!!!
Rabidsenses 4 years ago
Geatest album have u seen the movie on ww.globalrapture dot com???
stoppedtrippin4u 4 years ago
To Mahapurusalaksana, the song is called Echoes, and it is from the album 'meddle'. There is an excellent version of it split into two parts on the DVD "pink floyd, live in pompei" if you're a fan, check it out. It was recorded just prior to Dark side... being released. This concert version is quite good, I hope it comes out onan offical release.
lucythedogg 4 years ago
I apologize for my ignorance. I thought the name of the album was "Echoes", not the song. Lucythedogg, thank you very much!!!!!:)
Mahapurusalaksana 4 years ago
what's the name of this fantastic music? and thx for uploading
Mahapurusalaksana 4 years ago
This song is such A unique masterpiece. Nice video, awesome to see A live version. Thanks for uploading!
CloudedFuture89 4 years ago
amazing
danielwerwolf 4 years ago
Its definately not Waters on stage, if only....
Superb song, Wright has really got his confidence back during this tour, playing some superb keyboards.
dinogaskill 4 years ago
No Waters, It's Dave Gilmour's solo tour..
wtonis 4 years ago
He he... I think rock n' roll died when these guys brought their coffee on stage. Look at 7.50 in front of Rick ;-)
Anyway... thanks for posting - great video
ninecows 4 years ago
It's water, they would never drink coffee on stage, if they did, it would be tea since English folk typically don't like American coffee...and they have to have water on stage...if you ever played live you would know that.
MoreGilmour 4 years ago
well... I did played on stage and water? yes... just never seen a thermobottle on stage befor ;-)
ninecows 4 years ago
Saw him do this at the Albert Hall and the only word to describe it is epic. Just blew you away.
Shame the lights didn't work. Marc Brickman, who designed the lighting on the Pulse tour did Gilmour's tour and they were out of this world!
cgiuk 4 years ago
amazing! i love this song!
abracadaver80 4 years ago
Really how far u think pink floyd would of got without gilmour.not sayin that they would of sucked by no means but...he added alot the the band..his guitar playin alone
finisherofconcrete 4 years ago
rick wright also added unique keyboard/piano/organ sounds to the band that make it pink floyd, as well as nick's drumming style. roger waters has average bass playing nothing special but really good songwriting talent.. in other words everyone plays an equal part in making this band what it is.. an awesome band
WatchingTheWheels 4 years ago
This is giving me chills. Freaking awesome!!
sjice69 4 years ago
In the 70's this song must have been really heavy!
I love and adore PF, they are my favouritte band!
And stop comparing Gilmour and Rogers. Rogers was good on guitar, lyrics and sound-experimenting while Gimour was a excelent player on guitar and ok on lyrics.
PF4LIFE <3
Evje89 4 years ago