Added: 5 years ago
From: fibreputty
Views: 787,086
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (724)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • They both sing this well.

  • RECEIVE/COPY A NEW BOOK (Donated)

    Topics: HOW TO HAVE NO SADNESS, NO FEAR, NO ANGER, AND NO WEAKNESS Or How To Be Happy At All Times; Neuroscience, Governance, Debated Issues, Others

    Websites:

    you free web.com balancedway

    announcements-balancedway.weeb­ly.com

    wix.com/balancedwaybalancedw/a­nnouncements-balancedway

    You Free Web.com/announcements-balanced­way

    See pictures at figure4etc3.yolasite.com , figure4etc2.yolasite.com , figure4etc1.yolasite.com , or figure4etc.yolasite.com

  • Charlotte's voice is so much better suited to r&b than opera. She can hit some nice high notes in head voice, but her voices really sits more comfortably in a lower range.

  • @Bbjenks She does, and she's released it on a couple of her singles. Google it. its better than the original IMO

  • Hey! I really like your channel you have a talent with making videos.

    Check out my channel and let me know what you think of my singing.

    Have a great day! :)

  • the portuguese descendent nelly furtado...

    from portugal

  • Nelly forgot the lyrics

  • I think Charlotte should move on to Cee Lo's "Fuck You". It would be a show stopper, and an instant classic (or something).

  • Have you seen this show before? Charlotte has never made adjustments to her dress or the stage in any performance .. What if she were to have sung Bob Marley? Or the Beach Boys? How about The Rolling Stones? Brittany Spears? She's not going to do anything more then present her voice and style to the song. It doesn't have to be "Performed" as you say, to be appreciated -just sung in beautiful harmony.

  • @linfinster AND .. I don't think if I heard Gnarles sing say, Tiptoe Thru The Tulips there'd be any expectations of a, "performance" accurately depicting it's meaning .. lol.

  • @linfinster Perhaps you might want to saunter over to the video of her collaboration with Amy Winehouse. You may want to also have a therapist on hand for that one! I'm still a bit shaken myself! Lol.

  • I am being real. I am an actual performer. I never said there voices weren't beautiful but rather the performance of the piece was not. Gnarles Barkely originally mAde the song so one could assume that they would have a grasp of it's meaning.

  • @DragonoftheGhetto Did you see Gnarles on the Billboard awards singing this song?

  • FREAKING AWESOME!!

  • What makes this song infamous?

  • Comment removed

  • WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­W!!! JUST SIMPLY AMAZING DUEO!!!

  • Class!

  • BE U TI FULLY done Ladies!! Blew my socks off!

  • This was really beyond the scope of the original. I mean that in the bad way; it becomes this grand show off fest that removes any believable emotion from the song. They both have nice voices but this is hardly as morose as the original was intended to be.

  • @DragonoftheGhetto ... uh, get over it buddy! You think the way Gnarles sings it give any more credence to it's original intentions?? ... and a show off fest?? It is actually two beautiful voices coming together .. they are PERFORMING .. so get real!

  • The best performance....

  • 122 missed the button

  • 122 viewers can sing better

  • very good

  • Yea!!! Great duet!!!! they rock!!!

  • wat a such performance..!! wow!

  • Two such different voices! I love this collaboration!!

  • This is ace

  • in my case definatley , lol

  • Turns out 123 people are crazy for not liking this!

  • 2:23-2:29 Madam Charlotte switches up the opera to some SOUL. I love it!!

  • NELLY FURTADO brandnew NIGHT IS YOUNG - LIVE by PIANO TEACHER !

  • Holy crappers this is good!

  • A very nice collaborative, harmonious duet by Charlotte, Nelly Furtado.

  • 1:54 - 2:13 - love this part. Nelly is so great.

    

  • nelly D: Fuchi

  • Amazing !!!

  • awesome

  • this was awesome. charlotte can make anyone sound frekkin good what a wonderful talent

  • @jezzabelle75 you're an idiot. Nelly's great!

  • @MrFrankygoestoboston hmmmm beg to differ IDIOT shes sounmds like a horses ass singing thru her nose rmeinds me of that silly tart fran dreshner

  • rock on babes !!

  • Nelly Furtado dances like Jim Carey.

  • Wow! They sound brilliant together! I miss TCCS.

  • charlotte is the opera singer isn't she? so she can basically sing anything....lool so this was a breeze! love bali hai by charlotte!! keep it up char!

  • wow wow fab

  • This is so brilliant - Charlotte Church and Nelly Furtardo are really great together on this song. Of course Charlotte shines more on it (sorry Nelly!) but anyhow, their version of this song is absolutely fabulous. :-)

  • Well sung.

  • amazin!

    Was Nelly's dress meant to be see-through :P

  • great duet :)

  • I wish this show was on in the U.S.

  • charlotte best vocal in uk!!!

  • I always think that charlotte hangs back. In a show of this nature, you never want to show your guests up...however, in this clip charlotte, your true voice slipped out on at least 2 occasions and put poor nelly in her place.

  • Infamous means that it became famous for something bad. I can't stand it that whoever posted this used the wrong word.

  • I just love Charlotte... CRAZY about her I´d say!

  • adorooooooooooooooo

  • Nelly and Charlotte rock this song !!!!

  • @TheFRiNgEguitars hell yeah, I'm speechless, especially the ending harmony...wow!

  • do u see live duets that are this damn good? i think not. huge kudos for their harmonization! <3

  • @harmoniaSINGS Yes, can do ya a million time better. Somewhere (Black Symphony) - Within Temptation with Anneke. You're welcome

  • THE BEST !!!

  • Woot (2:38) Ali G Show up next!

  • nelly arrasandooo!!!!

  • Fantastic

  • wow very very nice!!!

  • they are two sensationaly talented singers that dont need to be analyzed.

  • Who care's? lol i just can say both look hot and sing pretty good

  • does she ever let her sing on their own,or she always moving in on them?if that the jist of her show?

  • The band is led by Bob Knight - the drummer, he's also musical director for Charlotte. The weird loking bloke on sax is Bob'd brother James

  • "infamous Crazy" @ description o.O'''

  • sorry.

  • grandios!!!

  • and with a personality like that i dont think u can even get an average looking girl.

    ur gf probably looks like shitstain

  • Nelly looks so sweet cheeky pretty

  • Notice how tight the band is also the backup singers. great.

  • nelly foratrdo looks like a fit horse ( but i wouldent date a horse)

  • infamous?

  • Lol, I wondered that xD

  • great

  • Nelly is so sexy, although she looks like a horse with this hairstyle (a cute horse ;o)

  • brill

  • i love charlotte church she sings so well and is great singing with anyone!! she has an amazing voice better than most ppl shes ever sang with!!

  • "Wrong breathing," as some like to call it has never bothered me, I can't understand why it's such an issue for some people to hear singers take a breath. Over-reasoning makes it impossible to appreciate things.

  • love this <3

    Epic <3 x

  • Are you kidding?!! or just a bit deaf? Charlotte Church is one of the worlds best singers!

  • If you give me a good argument maybe I can discuss this matter with you. She does have a cute voice but she breaths at the wrong places in the song and it's to loudly. And her voice and Nelly furtado dosen't sound right together. Maybe she is not a "duet" kinda person

  • I can only belive that you are not English hense why you have made the comments that you have. Charlotte is an opera singer and a very good one albeit she did over do it as a child, she was very much taken advantage of and damaged her voice but still has an amazing voice. I love Nelly in her own right, love what she does but she sings through her nose and it is a pretty awful sound even though she is in tune. Charlotte has a much more stronger and pure sound and I think most people would agree

  • yeah but that's what makes nelly unique and interesting, different from most typical singers. it's not the greatest voice but it's deep..like from her soul deep.

  • are you sick ?

  • and if Nelly didn't sing through her nose it'd be good, too =]

  • AH! i loved this.

  • I LOVE NELLY FURATDO!

  • The band is so tight in this and both ladies can sing their butts off. Superb.

  • they go really good together andd they soundd great !!! x

  • bnlip

    what the fuck are you talkign about

    the british have amazing syle

    shes just not up to date with it yet

    its just like saying that coz one person doenst look good then the whole place that the perosn is from ahs bad fashion sence

  • i love it they compliment eachother sooo well!!!

    5/5

  • I think Charlotte is a better singer than Nelly- Nelly always sings through her nose

  • Charlotte is good. Definitely better than Nelly, but she's no Leona or Beyonce.

  • Ahhh right, that's why Leona & Beyonce were child prodigies?

  • @Lishahhh - Beyonce won countless talent shows in her pre teen years and was signed to a label by the age of 15 so know your stuff before you open your mouth. Furthermore getting noticed at an earlier age says nothing about their comparative talent as things currently stand. Mariah didn't get noticed until she was 18. Does that mean that "child prodigy" Charlotte is automatically better than her? By your logic it does. Fanaticism gets you nowhere. Beyonce and Leona sing circles around Charlotte

  • Charlotte was signed aged 11.

    "as things currently stand", Mariah Carey is only a shadow of her former self; she's no longer an amazing vocalist.

    Fact is, Beyonce and Leona cannot sing circles around Charlotte. I actually hate comparing singers, so why can't you just respect all of their talent?

    Is Charlotte's pop stuff as good as Beyonce or Leona's? No.

    Can Leona or Beyonce sing classically like Charlotte? No, meaning they can't sing circles around her.

  • @Lishahhh - Just because Charlotte was noticed earlier doesnt mean that she is automatically a better singer than someone signed later. Thats faulty, superficial logic. Beyonce has received opera training, once again if youre going to refer to someone in debate, KNOW YOUR STUFF. Opera is a style of singing. Just because someone sings in that style doesnt make them any better than someone who doesnt. What matters is range, power, versatility, agility and control. Beyonce is superior to Charlotte

  • This isn't a debate. I have acknowledged and appreciated their talents, whereas all you've done is prove you're a narrowminded Beyonce superfan.

    There is a very good reason Beyonce is not a legend, and it's because she's not as good as you think she is.

  • @Lishahhh - Im narrow minded? You've come in here and argued that Charlotte is a better vocalist than Beyonce and Leona Lewis with little knowledge of the capabilities or training of either artist. As clearly indicated in your ill informed responses. I can tell you why Beyonce is a better singer than Charlotte. She has a more powerful voice, a bigger vocal range and greater versatility (being able to cover multiple genres). No legend is formed in 5 mins. B has been around for 12 yrs. Try again.

  • The problem here is, Im acknowledging BOTH girls' talents, whereas you are not.

    Charlotte Church & Beyonce both have between a three and four octave range. Equal.

    Power? Charlotte could be heard very well when she sang with one of the three tenors.

    Versatility? Pop/ballads/classically is quite versatile.

    I'm not saying Charlotte can outsing Beyonce, but I am saying Beyonce can't outsing Church either.

    Leona cant even sing in a lower key. It's awful for a girl who also claims classical training.

  • @Lishahhh- Who's failing to acknowledge Charlotte's talents? To acknowledge her talent doesnt mean i cant have a preference for another artist. Fair enough if you prefer Charlottes material or the sound of her voice, thats opinion. But when comparing her voice to Beyonces and looking at it on a technical level, theres no way shes as versatile, she lacks B's range, power and agility. Opera inherently sounds impressive to the ear, but hearing Charlotte sing pop highlights her unremarkable voice

  • In octaves, they have the same vocal range..but Church still lacks Beyonce's range? Lol.

    I think we're gonna have to just agree to disagree between these two. They are both talented. End of.

    I could still name at least five singers (without giving it much thought) who are superior to Beyonce =P

  • @Lishahhh - They have the same vocal range? Ok Lisa why dont you demonstrate your point by referring to songs or performances on youtube where Charlotte has hit her lowest and highest notes in chest voice. Then go on to refer to her range within head and whistle if it extends that far. Im very interested to see your response :)

  • Firstly, my name isn't Lisa.

    Secondly, I'm simply saying they have the same vocal range in octaves; both have around a 3 and a half octave range. Yes?

    I suppose you also think Beyonce is vocally superior to Whitney, Mariah (early days), Jennifer Hudson, Patti Labelle, Aretha Franklin and Regine Velasquez? lol.

  • @Lishahhh- They both have around 3 and half do they? Well i know Beyonce does and i can prove my point by referencing multiple songs and videos here on youtube. Why dont you demonstrate this claim of yours by doing the same? We both know why. As for your last comment, dont try and paint me as some crazed fanatic as a way of detracting from the fact that youre all fantasy and crazy claims. My views on those other artists have nothing to do with this discussion we're having now. Try again :)

  • I don't know which song Church sang her lowest note in or which song she sang her highest note in. I know she was approached to play Christine in the 2004 phantom movie, which would indicate she can hit at least a high E (backed up by her stating she can hit it in an interview with the Kumars). Search "Charlotte Hotshots" and during the discussion, she states what her octave range is. She claims it's actually around 4 octaves.

  • @Lishahhh- If you dont know where to find Charlottes lowest note and her highest note then you have no evidence to back up your claims whatsoever. Charlotte Church laughing whilst stating she has the same range as Mariah Carey is hardly a credible source of evidence. It is in fact laughable. Unless you can reference live performances or studio tracks which prove your point then you have nothing.

  • Yep, of course, Charlotte Church doesn't know her own vocal range =)

  • @Lishahhh - Dont be so fallacious. Once again i will state that Charlotte LAUGHING and saying yeah i have the same range as Mariah Carey is far from a credible source of evidence. If she well and truly did have such a range then this would be common knowledge as such a range is rare. Furthermore if she did possess such a range it would be found in her material. So once again, please back up your unproven claims. :)

  • Charlotte is a joker, and by her saying, yeah, I have the same range, is her probably mocking herself and saying, yeah righto thus meaning, no she can not but, she does have a better voice than Mariah, just because you can hit the range, does not mean you have a nice voice and Mariah does not...

  • she is (in full voice) 2 notes short of 4 octaves (on a good day)

    there are 2 types of singers - lyrical & and declarative or declomatic - Church is a "declaring" voice, like Domingo the tenor

    like the difference between Tom Jones & Roy Orbison

  • tell that to '2scoopz' & refer to specific performances/recordings that show your point.

  • Is she pregnant in this video?

  • And just as they had in 1914 against the forces of Kaiser Wilhelm II, Canada and Great Britain stood lock-step in song.

  • nice collaboration

  • charlotte has an attitude..so sexy

  • charlotte is an amazing singer specially singing opera XD

  • WHAT?? WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN. If ur from Boston You should know who JoJo is.... and even if ur not she is extremely famous

  • Is JoJo a cartoon character or something ? Cuz this name seem like I knew it before...

  • pinks version is so much better!

  • Nelly and Charlotte look and sound amazing

  • Nelly just had a baby before this same as Charlotte. But Nelly is fit and Charlotte is fat.

  • Charlotte did not just have a baby before this performance. She was still pregnant.

  • She wasn't pregnant here. This is only series 1..she got pregnant at the beginning of series 2.

  • Very cool duet. . .

  • Dont ask me why i think this but Nelly has always remeinded me of a younger Demi Moore.

  • I agree with you! Nelly is so cute!

  • member the days wen legins with skirts was in fashion lol

  • shit nelly sounds awesome in this! they sound really good!!

  • good song

  • Know the ultimate match up? JoJo & Charlotte... That would be soo sweet!

  • that would be interesting, i agree.

  • I just listened to a cover version in the radio, it was a girl singing.. great cover, but I don't know who it was.. Any ideas??

    It was for sure not Nelly Furtado.. the voice was smoother...

  • Charlotte rules, however Nelly is the living queen

  • best version!!!!!!!

  • Charlotte is slightly out at times but its not bad i reckon. She aint exactlly singing much now days

  • This video is great. You all should check out Vthov. He's a nobody right now, but I think he's going places for real. Search "Vthov Let Me Clear My Throat". You'll see what I'm talking about.

  • wow! didn't thought they would sound good together

  • happy bday charlotte!

  • Happy Birthday Charlotte Church!

  • beautiful cover

  • LOVE THIS!

  • Fucking Ace ! brilliant !

  • Awesome cover. They are really tight with the harmonies. Talent all around!

  • Nice vid. I found this one dude that goes pretty hard. Search "Vthov Original Song" and you'll see what I mean. Fiyah, pure fiyah. I can't believe people are sleeping on this guy.

  • is it just me or does nelly furtado look like debbie dingle off emmerdale?? lmao!!! x

  • They both sing this song so well. Amazing vocals .