Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (576)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Oi he's HOT

  • The bloody hands are because she has killed the on she loved.At 3:06 you see the pool of blood beside his back.At 3:12 she covered in his blood but at 3:40 she is coverd in his and her blood from killing him cutting herself.

  • @lovemeloveme12100 No, she hasn't killed him or hurt herself, it's a metaphore, she's stabbed him in the back (no literally, as in the figure of speech) by cheating on him, there's no actual physical hurting it's all symbolic.

  • Comment removed

  • Why are all her dresses so pretty? I want the white one!

  • 2:37  HAHAHA nice nipples !

  • Guys you cry in the other music video because the guy in the other video dies but this is more from real life. It's called moving on. When there's no way to come back to the one you love the most you have to move on no matter how much it hurts.

  • i don't get this video at all? does she kill the one that she actually loves? what the hell?

  • @happinesscounts100 No, she hurts herself bc she's disgusted how she's jt sleeping around with ppl she doesnt love.

  • @happinesscounts100 She's "stabbing him in the back" by cheating on him.

  • ok... so i've watched this tons of times and I've never noticed the bloody hands... What's that about??

  • @dlovesrcdr Wait So u Never Seen 3:40 - 3:42 ? o.O

  • @IxOhMyLocaBabexI Idk man, idk! I was so confused! How have i never noticed the end? It's not like it's only a little bit of blood. It's all over her and the knife on the floor is clearly visible. Wow, idk what was wrong w me to have missed that...

  • i like the other one much moreee i just don't under stand this one that much but the other one came alot easier and it actually made me cry so it had more feeling to it

  • I wanna see she killer he

  • yeah i like this one alot but the war one works better but they both are good :)

  • yeah war video gives me the chills i love her, but this one was all wrong

  • I like the war video A LOT better!

  • i miss her old songs !

  • that is scary

  • Katy Perry looks so young and cute in this mv. :D

  • Omg , i like this version more then the other ! <3 but i still love them bouth !

  • yeah the other video was SO much better

  • I love Brunettes with Blue eyes <3

  • i love this song. i like this one more then the war one, it might be that i watrched this one first, idk, i just love it.

  • She looks like if she's sick on this video .

  • very nice video, but i like the other version better...

  • Dont like it

  • did she kill the guy?

  • it`s the best break up song for me.....ever.....

  • Que medo...

    Ainda bem q tem a outra versão kkkk

  • i love her EYES :)

  • that boy on the bed...Damn..

  • her eyes are really pretty :)\

  • Comment removed

  • hmmm red wine girl... like it :)

  • perfect , i love you Kate , s2 .

  • literally stabbing in the back..i like how they like the people to suprisingly focus the backstabbing by its camera movement in 3:05 - 3:09...very nice indeed!

  • Why, hullo STDs :D

  • sometimes am felt this way :(

  • Wow........ que tiempos

  • 3:32- 3:33 i love that smile! it's so dark :)

  • Love her eyes at 1:09 <3

  • Comment removed

  • I like the 2nd version better...

  • Blood(: lol.... this video is better then the viral one.!

  • amazing.

  • @gfisher270 yeah I like her

  • why was blood there??

  • @katerina751996 I'm going to guess the guy was murdered thats why she isn't with him anymore not because they broke you. you know? yeaaa just telling the story with BLOOD >:D

  • @ClashOfStars actually it symbolizes the fact that she "stabbed him in the back" by cheating on him with the guy in the black room...

  • The second video is so much better and more beautiful.

  • My favoritest song by her:)

  • OMG, HER EYES AT 1:04 <3

  • lol watch out russell brand.

    she might be thinking of someone else. xD

  • i like the color of her eyes

  • this was so confusing to me

  • freaky

  • So, she killed him at the end? lol

  • this vid showed a diff side to katy, i love it, she could make her videos as scary as gagas! lol

  • but seriously if u want to question a video because it was "wierd" or "scary" i think i would question any one of lady gagas songs...im not hateing, im serious, her videos scare me, especially born this way. but they are good songs, just really creepy videos and wierd random outfits, or just bras and panities O.o but tht make lady gaga, lady gaga. but really this video is not as creepy as her vids

  • btw she didnt kill him, she "stabbed him in the back" because she was with the other guy and lost the one she really loved. but she betrayed him. she didnt really kill him. but i liked the scary side of katy...it make me do this evil laugh 3:)

  • i kinda liked this video, showed the "im not all glitter and make-up" in this one. the other one she gets outta bed with a crap load of makeup on and a long hair wig. this one is natural. but both of them are good.

  • y did they make 2 vids??

  • @alessiabonv this one wasnt good enough for her ppl, so they change the whole meaning of the song and maade her wear more make-up.

  • @therandomshowfully i prefere the other one

  • @alessiabonv ok, well i like both, they both have differnt meanings, this one is more natural, more katy, the other one is katy under layers of make-up and a wig. this one might be wierd but it has a good point and either way its a good song.

  • OMG!! what the hell is this video? It scared me to death!

  • Did she kill him ?

  • i do not understand this at all she kills him but she loves him and wants to stay in his eyes but shes the one that killed him"?"

  • @teamedward1451 It's showing how she feels like she "stabbed him in the back" by being with the other guy.

  • @gapgirlxxii ohhhhhhh i seeeeeeee thank yew for explaing it

  • i cant understand this one...

  • The other one is way better!!

  • i like the war video better because it has deeper and more beautiful meaning and it fits the song better

  • This one doesn't make me cry the way the other does. I like the other one better

  • this one is amazeing... just because she is in it.... duhhh,,, idc if the video isnt good,, i like that she is in it... thats all tht matters right?

  • @therandomshowfully I almost commented something like this and then i said i want to see what people wrote before i commented. Well Said. :o)

  • @Isobel1142 thank you lol

  • oh? is this for real? when was this released?

  • love realy gets you crazy,and u will expect to kill someone if ur crazy than insomia

  • The Katy in the white was the current Katy; see, she was with him, but even in bed with him, she was always thinking of her ex, the man in the suit. (Katy in the red dress) but you see a woman climbing into bed with him; he's found another. So in the end, they show a literal representation of her stabbing him in the back, because no matter what, she will always be thinking of the other man.

    Easy to understand :)

  • @mjf3140 me too and now she killed the boy how interesting

  • @kerlyneedrake68 Nah, she didn't really kill him, it was metaphorical for her stabbing him in the back. :)

  • @mjf3140 then wts up with the blood?

    

  • @kittykatannie The blood is just evidence showing of how she stabbed her current lover in the back. They showed it in the literally way instead of the metaphorical way.

  • @mjf3140 You have it backwards actually... the man in the white room is the one she misses and she stabbed him in the back when she left him. You can see how distraught she is while she's in the dark room. It wouldn't really make sense if the man she stabbed in the back was the new man.

  • @sreevz The man in the white room is who she is with now.. do you see how in the dark room,the man there doesn't pay any attention to her, and is with another woman? It's because he's moved on from their relationship, and while she has physically, she hasn't emotionally, she's always thinking of him. So, towards the end with the blood and knife, it's showing the literal sense of her stabbing her current lover in the back because she's always emotionally cheating on him with the other.

  • @mjf3140 Maybe he doesn't pay attention to her because he's just a hookup and the guy in the white room actually loved her and cared about her. The white is supposed to represent pureness and innocence because that's how their relationship was before she betrayed him. There are red roses representing love. In the dark room she has dark makeup, she's smoking a cigarette and pushes the girl away because she's disgusted with herself for the things she's doing. The one she stabbed in the back was

  • @mjf3140 I thought the white was the old Katy, and that she was stabbing him in the back by being with a new guy/cheating on him. When she's in the white, she looks more complacent, but the other looks more run-down, second-best like. That's the way I always interpreted it.

  • So She Killed The Guy And What's With The Red Katy?

  • i think she is saying he made her have a 3 some and then killed some one

  • this isnt half as good as the other!

  • @LizzieColbourne this video too has a lot of meaning, but i cried while watching the other one, which i totally LOVE

  • I bet if this was the 2nd version, the people would want the other one better. ;)

  • I liuke this one better

  • i like this one way better

  • I LIKE THE OTHER VIDEO BETTER. I SWEAR THIS ONE IS A LITTLE BIT DISTRACTING. I like the sweet katty perry not this one. i was actually touched with the other one and cried. but this one, piff! ew!

  • i like the other video better

  • The Girl that katy perry characterized is "CRaZY"!!!! by stabbing the guy !!! 3:32 killing looks V^_^V actually it's a reality ...

  • OMG!! she killed the fit guy ;0

  • Personally, I like this a lot. Cuz she lost the guy she loves and loses control by drinking, smoking, fucking around with ppl (the guy and girl) and has the urge to hurt herself (stabbing). I almost lost the guy I really love and during the period I wasn't with him, I couldn't think straight. I would see what Katy was trying to portray in this video.

  • @kiramay513 ...i agree

  • i think if katy perry made this one the official one she would get a bad reputation

  • Lets just say this version never existed...

  • the songs about him dumping her, "you say theres tons of fish in the water", she killed the guy for not loving her lke she loved him.i love katy perry

  • and y did she kill herself and it looked like she killed the guy in white and SOME PLZ EXPLAIN

    

  • im so confused which one is she thinking of when shes with him

  • @webkinz444444 bogoooooooooooooooooooooooooo

    

  • I wonder how this would do as the official video

    shes doing a little too much with her eyes but i kinda liked it.

  • I wonder how this would do as the official video

  • she soooooooo diffrent now 

  • She isnt cutting her hands she has killed the man...... for not being with her.

  • im speechless -

  • she is the most sexxy womon in the whol world!

    i love you katy

  • W..T..F... Did I just see?

  • she killed the man on 3:22

    

  • Why does she have Blood on her hands???

  • @Sadie14Crazy  She is cutting her hands

  • @Ieva698 Ohh

    

  • am the only one confused??? idk what happend?

  • I like to think she wrote this about a girl

  • this is Me right now ' :/ i cry each time i hear this sonq

  • this song is soooo me!! :(

  • why would anyone dislike this???? :(

  • i prefer the other video with matt dallas :S

  • what is the blood on her hands?

  • ILOVE THIS SONG SO REAL!

    

  • like it!

    

  • i like the other version bcause its sadder, but i like this one cause theres more going on...more interest

  • She has very beautiful eyes (: and I like both versions (:

  • i don't care what everyone else thinks, i like this version better

    it is way more interesting than the 2nd version

  • woah wtf

  • wouldnt the guy wake up if she was screaming like that :)

  • OMG! at 0:17 i almost fainted. i thought i was gonna get to see her vagina  :'(

  • @ItsUponaBurningBody LMAO....thumbs up for you !!!

  • @ItsUponaBurningBody what the heak perverted?!?

  • @jesuslover812 yeah this is a different vid. i was searching for that one but all i could find was this vid and it had a different story. i liked that "military story" better but this is okay i guess. :)

  • i like the second version than this . . . .

  • her eye are huge at 1:09

  • i dont get the girl in the bed with her and the other guy...o.0

  • Ohhhh, At 1st I dident understand why she had blood on her hands(:: She killed themD:

  • lol how can you smile with blood on your hands, but katy can

    and she has ruined her pretty dress

  • lol how can you smile with blood on your hands, but katy can

  • after seeing this the lyrics make more sense

  • she can look pretty smoking fag, i envy her

  • the end is really disturbing, but good , i think they should have kept this one as the original

  • This song is sooo sad, it always gets to me.

  • i like the other one better then this one i dont like this one

  • i seriously love the other version than this one...i think him being killed in war is way better that katty killinjg him??

  • @chepito285 me too-i dont understand this video but i understand the other one

  • Katy looks like wasted in this vid. She's better on the other version. and I think the other video of her with the same song is more beautiful, meaningful and heart-felt.

  • feel like this video is SO EMO..

  • lolololololololol, fail

  • Try to pause at 2:37. :)

  • ...nobody does it better! :)

  • i still like the one that she got popular with this song's video.....

  • i hate this.

  • so she killed him?

  • Thumbs up if you were lost in her eyes .

  • I'M SO CONFUZZLED!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • she looks so much more natrual<3

  • I think the white room is just a "dream",she was dreaming (or imagining) with the man she loved,and he was dead in real life. o_o

  • i dont even get this!:L

  • @Justinbieberftwx Same lol.

  • nice boobs

  • She is God.

  • She has extraordinary beauty..!

  • i think the story behind the video is that in the white room she has her perfect guy but she "stabbed him him in the back" by sleeping around with the guy and the girl in the dark room and now the guy in the white room left her and she's regretting things and all that. :))

  • @landangel26 No, her lover was in the military and was killed and she has finally dating someone else but she is missing him.

  • @landangel26 No, her lover was in the military and was killed and she has finally dating someone else but she is missing him. But this isn't the right video I don't think.

  • I don't know why she killed that hot guy.