Not to be a heartbreaker, but if you look at the descriptions it says, "Audio - CD not from the live performance" therefore I think this recording was taken from the CD. This is not a live recording of 'By Myself'. The MR Removed was put with a video of a performance of 'By Myself'. Truthfully, I'm a big fan of Tiffany, and I am 100% sure she can sing like this, but this is not a live MR Removed.
@97FunBun actually it went from "longer or shorter training depend on when u join company sooner or later than the others"...cause Im not arguing whether or not you should prefer Tif voice over Jess voice, cause I respect that. (actually I also prefer Tiff voice over Jess voices just like you do haha)
I'm like listening to the original version..I really love the voices of SNSD..though others can't really sing like how the vocal group can, they have charms in their voices
@97FunBun I think why Jessica is the main vocal is because she's trained for 7 years and her vocal techniques are a lot more advance than the others ~ I know a lot of people who like Tiffany or Seohyun's voice more, or even sometimes Sunny's voice, but if you examine and analyse carefully, Jessica's vibrato and control of her vocals are a lot more advance than the other vocalists in SNSD.
@xocute4evaxo really? because listening carefully tiffany seems more in control. when you listen to jessica's solo her voice seems to go off pitch some of the times and she doesn't put as much power in her voice as tiffany does. tiffany's voice is more clear than jessica in my opinion as well. training for 7 years could also mean she was a slow learner... (don't take me wrong. i don't hate jessica and i think after taeyeon and tiffany she has the next best voice)
@97FunBun Its true though ~ Jessica's vocal techniques is really more advance, she has the best control of her voice in SNSD along with Taeyeon, but one thing about her is that she gets tired really easily, which is why her full potential isn't shown at times, but when she does, hell she's good. Tiffany has a really nice sounding voice, appreciated by many people as it sounds husky and clear ~ i love it too. Its just that sound of voice =/= vocal techniques.
@97FunBun and same with me, i'm not hating on Tiffany either, she's my top biases in SNSD and i think she's improved tremendously ~ She was already this good back then, and now, she's even better. One thing about SNSD, is that all their main vocals are amazing, even Sunny, as a 5th main, she's already really good. So i think we shouldn't worry too much about who's better than who, all i know is that each of the main vocalists have their own advantages, disadvantages, texture and style.
@xocute4evaxo btw tifanny isnt a main vocal, neither is sunny or seohyun. their all lead vocals while jessica and taeyeon are main vocals. jessica and taeyeon have more lines in songs + adlib parts. rarely will those three get to adlib
@97FunBun Yeah i know ^^ Its just that when talking overall in vocals in SNSD, i just refer them as 5 main vocalists ~ but yeah i do know that Tae and Sica are mains, Tiffany and Seohyun are lead ~ and so on ^^
@97FunBun You have to listenm to more Jessica's performances/ She has the second best vocal techniques and control in SNSD. Even Tiffany herself said that she lacks of control and that she had to learn from Jessica to improve her voice control. I only heard Jessica going off-pitch 2-3 times which isn't a big deal. and she's definitely not a slow learner. why do u think junsu trained for more than 10 years? is he a slow learner as well?
@hzgg12 could be... why else would they train for so long before debuting? But their longer training period did give them a chance to perfect and train more on their voice. Besides it's only what i think. your opinion could be different. fine. but in MY opinion tiffany has a better voice than jessica.
@97FunBun I respect your opinion but I'[m just correcting you for saying that she's a slow learner. Because Jessica became a trainee in 2000 and SM didn't plan on debuting a new girlgroup until 2007 and Tiffany and the others debuted later in 2005 so Jessica had a longer training while Fany had a shorter one. But I conce heard that Jessica was going to be the second BoA but because of her rumours, SM cancelled the plan :/
@sharonkai1010 not true. there were other trainees who trained longer than some of the members yet they weren't chosen to be apart of girl's generation and either transferred company or continued training. their's alot to take in consideration.
@97FunBun whats your point=.=??? Im talking about who did debut. Among the members, if you are join later but you have potential, you debut, so your training is shorter. Its just Jess joined SM so early that you think she might be a slow learner. ok...train 2 years, than she 13 if she debuted, SM already have Boa who is the solo artist, so they wouldnt let Jess debuted as a solo singer, when they had bigger plan. After that, suju debuted, so Jess couldnt debut when she 14, 15 or 16 years old.
@97FunBun after suju debut, SM had to wait at least 1 year for another group to debut, so 2007 is perfect for SNSD and Jess debuted. And consider the way SM artists debut: CSJH ~> DBSK (4 or 5 member a group); Suju ~> SNSD (large groups); SHINee ~> f(x) (like mini versions of CSJH and DBSK); SM tried new way every time they let their artists debut, so its not Jess fault if she had to wait for the others to join SNSD(pre-debut) to form their group and wait for their big day
@sharonkai1010 yeah. i cant understand how it went from me stating I preferred tiffany's voice over jessica to you explaining the debut of other SM groups. don't you think that's a bit off topic?
@97FunBun Just because she has a better voice than Jessica does not mean that she is a better singer than Jessica. People need to understand that a better voice =/= better singer
I dont think this was the MR for this performance though? It's just for the recorded song. Her real live performance ----------> sounds different in this one.
She was not like a normal girl out there. She was grew up without her mom + go by herself to Korea without family to be single even her dad didnt want her to be a single. And it's make sense that why she sang the sad song so good :)
She has a really melodious voice ..... It will make guys fell head heels over her ......
zzz94191 1 week ago
Dude,she doesn't sing this well live =_= obviously the music was taken from a official soundtrack
xinxinlovesudrogoth 1 month ago
Fany's beautiful voice without music interference <3 but she looks like she's going to cry at the end! :[ don't cry, Fany!
MagicklessSorceress 1 month ago
@Flytothesky8595 I know, I CAN'T agree with you more! Fany-ah fighting!
MagicklessSorceress 1 month ago
♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥Tiffany ♥
iTzLisax3 2 months ago
for tiffany no need she have loud voice though..kekkekeke i really love her voice...
MrSnsdforever99 3 months ago
This is so not MR Removed, It's from the studio version without background music! :( Shit! Tiffany don't need this! She already have a great voice!
Tamaki2909 4 months ago
well the MR doesnt really matter cuz she isnt dancing so your didnt really need to do this.but we all know she has a very good voice
yoesop 4 months ago
listen to an angel singing!!!!!!!!!best!!!right???
peheocute1502 4 months ago
สวดยอดดดดดดดดดดดด
arisaraprasert 5 months ago
TaeNy doesn't need MR removed!! They're have a great voice ever. Fany Unnie~I lOve U
GenieS99 5 months ago 25
Not to be a heartbreaker, but if you look at the descriptions it says, "Audio - CD not from the live performance" therefore I think this recording was taken from the CD. This is not a live recording of 'By Myself'. The MR Removed was put with a video of a performance of 'By Myself'. Truthfully, I'm a big fan of Tiffany, and I am 100% sure she can sing like this, but this is not a live MR Removed.
jujubee061097 6 months ago
tiff is the only reason I like SNSD till now :)
AgentBluvAgentJ 6 months ago 7
Sooo.. Haters where you be at
IJUSTNEEDITify 6 months ago
I want her on Immortal Song 2!!!!!
JSoo69 6 months ago
Wow.....Fany
0870105098 6 months ago
After watching this I now believe that every time i'm hearing taeng's voice or fany's voice im in heaven !
TaeNy my angels <3
supportjayparkjaebeo 6 months ago
liza15793: yes! that' s live...
kimmaihl 6 months ago
live ???
liza15793 6 months ago 2
wow...so pretty♥
kimmaihl 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@97FunBun actually it went from "longer or shorter training depend on when u join company sooner or later than the others"...cause Im not arguing whether or not you should prefer Tif voice over Jess voice, cause I respect that. (actually I also prefer Tiff voice over Jess voices just like you do haha)
sharonkai1010 7 months ago
AWESOME MR REMOVED
ANTIS, IS TOO SHOCK TOO SPEAK
AnnieeTi 7 months ago
Any difference ^^?
hung8h 7 months ago
I just realized Tiff has a similar voice to her sunbae Zhang Li Yin :)
happystar176 7 months ago
this is just a mr removed of the audio but it fits the performance well. Tiffany has a really nice, soothing singing voice.
reminiscencently 7 months ago
I'm like listening to the original version..I really love the voices of SNSD..though others can't really sing like how the vocal group can, they have charms in their voices
carylthebest 7 months ago
husky voice fany unnie~♥
mymariiahh 8 months ago
lovee her fany hwating
lollipopcandygal 8 months ago
i don't know why she isn't one of the main vocalists. I much prefer her voice over Jessica's...
97FunBun 8 months ago 5
Shes consitered a Main vocal but isnt
BoatBubbly 8 months ago
@BoatBubbly i know, but officialy she is a lead vocal. Jessica and Taeyeon and Jessica are main vocals.
97FunBun 8 months ago
@97FunBun I think why Jessica is the main vocal is because she's trained for 7 years and her vocal techniques are a lot more advance than the others ~ I know a lot of people who like Tiffany or Seohyun's voice more, or even sometimes Sunny's voice, but if you examine and analyse carefully, Jessica's vibrato and control of her vocals are a lot more advance than the other vocalists in SNSD.
xocute4evaxo 7 months ago
@xocute4evaxo really? because listening carefully tiffany seems more in control. when you listen to jessica's solo her voice seems to go off pitch some of the times and she doesn't put as much power in her voice as tiffany does. tiffany's voice is more clear than jessica in my opinion as well. training for 7 years could also mean she was a slow learner... (don't take me wrong. i don't hate jessica and i think after taeyeon and tiffany she has the next best voice)
97FunBun 7 months ago
@97FunBun Its true though ~ Jessica's vocal techniques is really more advance, she has the best control of her voice in SNSD along with Taeyeon, but one thing about her is that she gets tired really easily, which is why her full potential isn't shown at times, but when she does, hell she's good. Tiffany has a really nice sounding voice, appreciated by many people as it sounds husky and clear ~ i love it too. Its just that sound of voice =/= vocal techniques.
xocute4evaxo 7 months ago
@97FunBun and same with me, i'm not hating on Tiffany either, she's my top biases in SNSD and i think she's improved tremendously ~ She was already this good back then, and now, she's even better. One thing about SNSD, is that all their main vocals are amazing, even Sunny, as a 5th main, she's already really good. So i think we shouldn't worry too much about who's better than who, all i know is that each of the main vocalists have their own advantages, disadvantages, texture and style.
xocute4evaxo 7 months ago
@xocute4evaxo btw tifanny isnt a main vocal, neither is sunny or seohyun. their all lead vocals while jessica and taeyeon are main vocals. jessica and taeyeon have more lines in songs + adlib parts. rarely will those three get to adlib
97FunBun 7 months ago
@97FunBun Yeah i know ^^ Its just that when talking overall in vocals in SNSD, i just refer them as 5 main vocalists ~ but yeah i do know that Tae and Sica are mains, Tiffany and Seohyun are lead ~ and so on ^^
xocute4evaxo 7 months ago
@97FunBun You have to listenm to more Jessica's performances/ She has the second best vocal techniques and control in SNSD. Even Tiffany herself said that she lacks of control and that she had to learn from Jessica to improve her voice control. I only heard Jessica going off-pitch 2-3 times which isn't a big deal. and she's definitely not a slow learner. why do u think junsu trained for more than 10 years? is he a slow learner as well?
hzgg12 7 months ago
@hzgg12 could be... why else would they train for so long before debuting? But their longer training period did give them a chance to perfect and train more on their voice. Besides it's only what i think. your opinion could be different. fine. but in MY opinion tiffany has a better voice than jessica.
97FunBun 7 months ago
@97FunBun I respect your opinion but I'[m just correcting you for saying that she's a slow learner. Because Jessica became a trainee in 2000 and SM didn't plan on debuting a new girlgroup until 2007 and Tiffany and the others debuted later in 2005 so Jessica had a longer training while Fany had a shorter one. But I conce heard that Jessica was going to be the second BoA but because of her rumours, SM cancelled the plan :/
hzgg12 7 months ago
@hzgg12 i was just saying she MIGHT be a slow learner. at the same time she might not be.
97FunBun 7 months ago
@97FunBun longer or shorter training depend on when u join company sooner or later than the others
sharonkai1010 7 months ago
@sharonkai1010 not true. there were other trainees who trained longer than some of the members yet they weren't chosen to be apart of girl's generation and either transferred company or continued training. their's alot to take in consideration.
97FunBun 7 months ago
@97FunBun whats your point=.=??? Im talking about who did debut. Among the members, if you are join later but you have potential, you debut, so your training is shorter. Its just Jess joined SM so early that you think she might be a slow learner. ok...train 2 years, than she 13 if she debuted, SM already have Boa who is the solo artist, so they wouldnt let Jess debuted as a solo singer, when they had bigger plan. After that, suju debuted, so Jess couldnt debut when she 14, 15 or 16 years old.
sharonkai1010 7 months ago
@97FunBun after suju debut, SM had to wait at least 1 year for another group to debut, so 2007 is perfect for SNSD and Jess debuted. And consider the way SM artists debut: CSJH ~> DBSK (4 or 5 member a group); Suju ~> SNSD (large groups); SHINee ~> f(x) (like mini versions of CSJH and DBSK); SM tried new way every time they let their artists debut, so its not Jess fault if she had to wait for the others to join SNSD(pre-debut) to form their group and wait for their big day
sharonkai1010 7 months ago
@sharonkai1010 ok.... now this is going way off topic.
97FunBun 7 months ago
@97FunBun if you cant understand its ok
sharonkai1010 7 months ago
@sharonkai1010 yeah. i cant understand how it went from me stating I preferred tiffany's voice over jessica to you explaining the debut of other SM groups. don't you think that's a bit off topic?
97FunBun 7 months ago
@97FunBun Just because she has a better voice than Jessica does not mean that she is a better singer than Jessica. People need to understand that a better voice =/= better singer
hzgg12 7 months ago
ha! those people who keep saying Tiffany cant sing obviously have not heard this
BlackjackVIPElf 8 months ago 3
do u have mp3 download for this? i love it.
ryanluvme 8 months ago
perfect live :x perfect voice
cherryxinh2pm 8 months ago
could you do an mr removed on tiffany's banji from the haru ost? kamsahamnida^^
kathleenjoy03 9 months ago in playlist Tiffany (SNSD)
Tiffany is the best! ♥
pamii1992 9 months ago
its princess ja myeong go ost...
Please hear my cover's song ya..
Thx
taramjwi2 9 months ago
why!!! dislike
I love tiffany >:)
milk36268 9 months ago
why!!! dislike
I love tiffany >:)
milk36268 9 months ago
sorry, but is this a ost of any drama? or has the whole snsd sang this song before? i find this very familiar :p
Chermainetzy 9 months ago
@Chermainetzy Yup, it is the OST of a drama. But i forgot the name of it :/
cherian821 9 months ago
@cherian821 The drama's name is Ja myung go .. it's an amazing drama.. but it's incredibly sad especially the ending :/ Spoiler !
KpopChannelOnly 9 months ago
that was perfect! no flaws at all! i love you tiffany unnie! she is such a great singer <3
C00kiesLUV 9 months ago
and people say she cant sing TT.TT
spasztikunited 9 months ago
her husky voice give me goosebump. fany jjiang
zwei90 9 months ago
Tiffany has such a nice voice! Hope she can reach the level of clean and clear of the MR audio version! Hwaiting!
gunzcoolest 10 months ago
Her voice is More than awesome!!! Fany ah, you r the best!!!
tiffanysnsd4ever 10 months ago
The MR remove is not the live performance in this video. The MR Removed audio was edited into the performance
Onimusha2nd 10 months ago 24
I dont think this was the MR for this performance though? It's just for the recorded song. Her real live performance ----------> sounds different in this one.
MySungminOppa 10 months ago
who's say tiffany can't sing!
lovetiffmushroom 10 months ago
@lovetiffmushroom i think stupid pigs said that
^^ in our hearts, Fany's voice 's best. fany 5ting
taeny1989 10 months ago 2
her voice is amazing!great
peheocute1502 10 months ago
Tiffany is awesome!!! Not to mention she was already suffering from vocal cord nodules at the time of this performance. <3
pvan57 10 months ago
FANY YOUR VOICE IS FREAKING AMAZING!
ShineCassioELF 10 months ago 5
one of the best vocals ever
siux07 11 months ago 5
This girl is just amazing who the fuck said she can't sing
piercejhunter 11 months ago
so anyone knows where i can find Tiffany singing the full song LIVE???
gr33ntube 11 months ago
even if the MR won't be removed , there still doesn't have difference... this proves that Tiffany's voice is awesome especially SNSD
angelreas143 11 months ago
I love so much how Fany sing =*
Biskuit12 11 months ago
fany fany ah! <3<3 Jjang!
3allOonz 11 months ago
can hear the emotions in this song, fany, you're not by yourself anymore (: ugh i love you :D
xPlasticRomance 11 months ago
wow!!!! it seems like she singing infront of me!! so clear!! love it!
haverinetaeyeon 11 months ago 5
She was not like a normal girl out there. She was grew up without her mom + go by herself to Korea without family to be single even her dad didnt want her to be a single. And it's make sense that why she sang the sad song so good :)
emmaS1S 11 months ago
I love her voice.
YuKiY1 1 year ago
aww,her voice brings me to tears,don't get me wrong,i meant tears of joy ^ ^
you could see the effort and passion in her eyes,i love you, fany <3
deebadestinyhope 1 year ago
wonder hus e buggy tat dislikes it-_-
gr33ntube 1 year ago
beautiful voice frm a beautiful lady:)
gr33ntube 1 year ago
wonderful voice!!!!!!
nhoxkunby 1 year ago
perfectly mr removed!! you are jjang!! *fany also* (^_^)
outlaws2710 1 year ago 98
Wow!
It's beautiful voice.
Crush9718 1 year ago
ahh Fany ah!!! Awesome perf!!! Her voice is just too awesome ><
rommama 1 year ago 75
how do you do?
help me!!!
zoruyul151 1 year ago
Comment removed
daladida97 1 year ago