Added: 5 years ago
From: LiveForLife
Views: 135,623
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (621)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • haven't seen this in about a year but this is still my all time favorite video. really great job

  • beautiful..... not to interrupt your star wars thing... but this song would go well with Zelda Wind Waker videos

  • Seriously you'd think this song was made for these films especially episode 3

  • Sad...but hauntingly beautiful. Well done!

  • thats kinda sad D:

  • What's the song that was at the very end?

  • Comment removed

  • @CreepStudios the song is called " iris " by the Goo Goo Dolls"

  • I love this video, so well done !!

  • Oh God, not really a fan of Episodes I-III, but this made me bawl hysterically. More than usual when watching a Star Wars mashup. Kudos.

  • really nice work, congrats ;)

  • luke was like kenobis son he never had

  • wow you're really good!!! i cried!!!

    "where did i go wrong, i lost a friend " part was amazing!

  • go annie best fight in the starwars series i liked anakin better than darth vader ya i said it 

  • im a bit of a geek and loves star wars and this song i almost cried so yah i LOVED this video

  • u need to do one with ani and padme

  • How can you NOT like this!?!?!?!

  • So tragic! But, I love it when Anakin is redeemed in the end!

  • Love this video and this song, the song makes me think about Scrubs such a beautiful song.

  • amazing is all i can think to say

  • I'm one of those who keep coming back to this video on a fairly regular basis over several years. One of the best I have seen on Youtube. Excellent, intuitive command of matching scene to lyric, and the timing with the music's tempo is spot on. Sure, the video quality could be better, but that's not always in the hands (or pocketbook) of the creator. Brilliant, brilliant work.

  • BEST VIDEO THUMB UP MY COMMENT AND THIS VIDEO SUSCRIBE TO US PLEASE please make a video and add me i need to ask you how you make a video without you recording it?????

  • it's a few gay...

  • @LikeAMacho...I didnt change my mind...In fact if you were paying attentinon you'd notice that I did not state my personal feelings on the project in my first post. My mind has not changed: it is a beautiful piece of work that, imho, requires 1 slight change at the end for continuity's sake. Now stop posting crap aimed at me on SOMEONE ELSE'S page. If you want to argue over nothing then at least have the cajones to send it to me directly. No more on this please, its a tired subject.

  • I am amazed at the quality of your work. This LikeAMacho retard obviously doesnt understand respectful constructive criticism when he sees it. I have been a musician for over 10 years and have worked with multimedia projects such as these for EVEN LONGER. Outstanding work LiveForLife!

  • @docgeri Maybe if you had put that in your original comment, (or in another comment) I wouln't of snapped.... I don't get how fast you changed your mind

  • Comment removed

  • 17 people are working for Satan

  • This is the best video For this song. At least the way you put it. Amazing Job :)

  • ....and why doesnt this have more views?

  • So...at the very end when you show the volcanic eruption when the chorus is repeated for the last time...you shouldnt stray away from that image. Previously you were showing a quick clip of Anakin in a much more innocent scene but at the end of your video you want the maximum emphasis on the fight at hand, not another reminder that he was a friend. You've established their friendship ad nauseum throughout but you really take away from the final showdown by doing quick cuts back and forth.

  • @docgeri whats your problem!! its of obi and ani.... this is a fan vid. So just shut up, and stop acting like you got all teh smarts

  • Love Anakin and Padme the best love story.

  • I LOVE ANAKIN!!!!!!

  • WOW this is REALLY good!!!!

  • u did an awesome job

  • 17 people are blind, deaf, have no heart and would be dead soon

  • Great Job!

  • absolutly the most amazing star wars video i have ever seen!! amazing job!!!

  • I agree with SandNin...When I hear this song in my head or on the radio I ALWAYS flash to this video. I suppose thats the hallmark of art.  Well done.

  • This video make my Star Wars adiction came back :). You really make it perfect!!! And also cause you make tha Anakin transition so perfect too!! love this!! :)

  • Every time I hear this song now I cry my eyes out! :'( You did such a fab job putting the clips together and its soo emotional :) and every single time i watch it i have to leave the room and go cry for about ten mins :)

  • I've seen all sorts of how to save a life's and yours is the best of showing a tribute to Anakin Skywalker :)

  • This video is just...I can't even explain. It's so amazing! It made me tear up, I can barely type because the keyboard is blurry. lol awesome job!

    Great now I'm sad. But in a good way!...if that makes sense. Anyways I loved it!

  • Fantastic

  • thank you :) for making me bawl my eyes out, i'm never gonna be able to listen to this song again without crying. that's how good you are.

  • I think that song is writing for this part of star wars 1.000.000 likes !!!!!!!!

  • Wonderful. Emotional. Brilliant.

    This amv has single-handedly given me a soft spot for Anakin.

  • i love this video so much! i'm a huge star wars fan, and i'm particularly obsessed with anakin and padme's love-marriage thing. i also love the song, and the clips match perfectly with it. i love how perfectly it's timed and edited - i officially fail at doing anything like this, so i salute you!

  • awsome

  • I think he said "he's just not the same" :) awesome video.

  • LOL after all obiwan does know best :D

  • You know, in the space of just under 5mins you've managed to achieve what Lucas failed to do in 7hrs; make me feel both attached to Anakin, convinced by the obi/ani friendship, and at once both saddened and sympathetic to Anakin's turn to the dark side.

    Bravo

  • Excellent choice of scenes, fantastic video.

  • ::::sniff sniff::::::: such sad lyrics but great video.... i think this song fits anakin best

  • God...this song fits perfectly.

  • man i still love this vid.. but now its not only a touchin vid but it brings back great memories from when i forst saw this vid in december hah..*cries* its so amazing!!!

  • really great! one of the best sw videos out there! congrats!

  • This made me cry

  • I saw this video for the first time three years ago. (It must have been shortly after you first posted it. Wow.) This is the first time I've rewatched this since then, but every time I hear the song, this video comes to mind. You did a wonderful job with the emotions and the clip selection. Even after all this time, it's still one of my absolute favorites. :)

  • @SandNin Thank you :)

    This is the last video I ever made with Windows Movie Maker before switching to Sony Vegas. I'm thinking about remaking this now that I have 3 more years of experience. I just finished university for the year so I'll have some spare time to make videos. Thanks again! :)

  • @LiveForLife Same here :) But i think i saw it 2 years ago, not 3. One of my favourite videos :)

  • @LiveForLife The only bad thing about this video is the quality, but I'm not blaming you for that.

    If you wait until after the September blu-ray release, maybe you could edit a HD version. XD

    Fingers crossed you will one day, because it's a great edit. :)

  • @LiveForLife Yeah right so delete that video!

  • @LiveForLife This is amazing, a remake with HD clips would be so awesome. Great Job!

  • @SandNin This is the same with me. I saw this video years ago -- maybe even 4 years ago -- wow. I would watch it all the time because it's damn good, and one day it was just gone. I don't know if it got taken down during all the youtube copyright tirades, or what, but it was just gone.

    Today I noticed it in my recommended video section and took a look at it again.

  • this is 1 of the very best videos i have ever seen.

  • Nc Video. :)

  • oh shit i just cried! this is...beautiful!

  • 3:33

  • i love this video

  • 1:34 Anakin's eyes look blue?

  • THIS VIDEO IS AMAZING GREAT JOB

  • ive never seen star wars but my ex bf and my current bf both want me 2 watch it so my bf put this video on his myspace so i watched it and its really sad i strtd cryin

  • I'm adding myself to the list of people crying. This is such a great video, portrays the struggle both of them go through perfectly.

  • Amazing video. It pains me every time to see Ani to go through this. The little Ani I used to love, to a power consumed villain.

  • this makes me want to cry..

  • The best video I have ever seen!!!

  • *sobbing*

  • i subscribed every one who likes this video should.

  • 20,0000000 stars

  • These lyrics plus these clips are probably EXACTLY what was going through Obi-Wan's head while they were fighting. Amazing. Just... just... WOW.

  • I'm crying now. ;( And if I wasn't, 3:08 - 3:18 certainly would've made me. *Favs*

  • this is incredible. those who don't get it....don't get it...;-)

  • I heard about a Star Wars film by 2011 true?

  • @AlexMcPwnr Theres a life action TV series in the works, but thats all. No more films.

  • TV show?... Live.. action? FFFFFUUUUUUUUUUCK!!!!!

  • its hard to beileve its been like 5 years since the last starwars film its a bitter sweet feeling. awesome video!!!!

  • Whoa! This was really professionally done. I give you props LiveForLife! Great song! Great vid!

  • I finally got this song and i was listening to it and remembered seeing a video for it! This is amazing, like it was written form them. You did an amazing job! Keep up the good work!

  • Hey Corni! Yeah, I agree! :)

  • плакать хочется((

  • awesome video

    5stars

  • Beautiful. This may sound wierd, but I cried the first 20 or so times i watched. Good job, and I hope to see more.

  • This video amazed me. I always remember it at random moments and think it won't be as good as I remember, but it's always better. This video is amazingly well made, and it might sound lame, but I cried the first ten or so times I watched.

  • This is very well done. I am impressed. Most ppl that make videos like this have no idea what they are doing and just butcher it. But this one is done very well.

    Powerful song, put together with a powerful story.

    Bravo.

  • I Agree, this is amazingly creative work, very well done!!

  • this is one of the best videos on youtube!!! i never thought this song could fit so much!! i know this sound lame but it really makes me cry

  • I live this video,I've been watching this video for 4day's now.

    Amazing Job ^_^

    Jedi Knights

  • Awesome

  • Omg, I've been thinking lately how greatly this song would fit Anakin and Obi-Wan, and picturing the video. Just decided to search it, and turns out I wasn't the only one.

    Great job!

  • I love how when it says "Where did I go wrong?" It shows a scene from the Obi-Ani fight. And when it says "I've lost a friend" it shows a pic of Anakin smiling or something. It is actually a sad video though. Best ever :D 5 *s

  • Fitting Song

  • the singer has a nice voice!

  • good song and to go with that tagic story of anikans and obi-wan friendship

  • Comment removed

  • i love this video

  • This is the best tribute to anakin and obi-wans relationship and should deserve a minimum of about 1 mil views!!! 5/5 =]

  • best part 2:14 to 2:30 =]

  • i completely agree... most epic and well made tributes i have EVER seen

  • i think both anakin and obi wan are the deepest characters. i like anakin but i like obi-wan too. he is also the main character in a shitload of star wars books. from the rising force series which focused on his temple training, becoming a jedi, his life and friendship with Qui-Gon, and books with him training anakin. Obi-Wan is an awesome jedi and he has an amazing story just like anakin but i like anakin too.

  • this really shows how much star wars is misread by most.

    Great Job.

    more?

  • I agree.

  • That was amazing. 5/5 The clips, the timing, the song ... EPIC WIN.

  • it wasnt her fult he killed her so ha

  • so sad how he turned to the dark side just because padmay was dieing SO ITS HER FAULT!

  • Great video. The relationship between Anakin and Obi-wan is one of my favorites in Star Wars, even though it breaks my heart, greatly owing to the archetypical nature of their relationship -- the theme of best friend turned enemy has been around since ancient times. I really did love the way you spliced the duel with flashes of their past camaradie -- you could imagine that this was Obi-wan's thoughts while he was fighting. A bit of OT Obi-wan right around the end would've been nice though.

  • f to the a to the i to the l

    wats that spell fail! with anakin and obi

  • wow man this is worth crying for

  • its weird to see a young boy like ani to go to the dark side

  • One of the most moving vids on youtube. it is like the song was written for them

  • Beautiful. Great job.

  • the music fits perfectly great job

    5 stars

  • SUPERB :D 5/5 I was very pleased to see how well the song played in :)

  • two friends the two best frends make a battle in fire

  • That ' s great!

  • Brilliant!

  • dude this is seriously well-done! five stars

  • true,

  • i love your desription in this video

  • awesome!!

  • Comment removed

  • Wow an amazing job! The song fit perfectly!

  • That was probably the best music video i've ever seen.

  • the author should look into doing flash back scenes for the OC on relationships.

  • great job =D

    would be even better in my opinion if you included some footage from the original star wars

  • This is one of the best videos on youtube.

    I love it

  • amazing video

  • The best star wars video on the internet.

  • agreed

  • true

  • Beautiful video; the song fits very well.  I especially like the transitions at the end of each chorus.

  • Awsome video! Wow the clips and the song its beautiful. It almost makes you cry.

  • Comment removed

  • that song goes great with the movies

  • I am awwed. Absolutely fabulous. Perfect. wow wow wow wow

  • Star Wars episodes 1-2-3 are the greatest movies EVER made...then the other three and LotR

  • Awkawardly Anakin story is just how my life is going ='[

    I hope I make the RIGHT decision at the end of my story...

  • i think we can all say that at some point

  • What? A man is asking you to join him so you can become the most powerful Sith Lord in the Galaxy? To save your significant other?

    I suggest you don't listen to that evil man.

  • Considering Anakin's mental state at that time, and the way that all the other options looked to him, such as revealing his secret to the council to ask them for help and more than likely being cast out and left with fewer resources, it makes sense that he went along.

  • This is wonderful!!! I love how you used each movie for the verses and then the fight for the chorus. It flows so well and is very well done! I love this!

  • Wow... awesome .... wow

  • by far my favorite star wars music video

  • fantastic very good one of my favourite song ...the fil is beautiful add to favourite

  • makes me cry :'(

  • Most impressive very good......I think me and my freind had a moment like tht at the end of the moive a epic fight

  • Better than the movie :P

  • Awesome! 500,000,000,000,000,000,000 out of 5!

  • Impresive....most impresive.....indeed...

  • Nice epic vedio.

    On a side note i see a lot of people like the origonle triligy better but on the commentyer of episode 4 (last hope) that when it first came out he already had the though of episode 1-3, and wanted to put episode 4 at the top. But some people said it would confuse the hell out of people saying the 4 is out and there is no 1-3. So at the end there the hole origonle trigliy.

  • so sad

  • i love it! best eva! i watched the 3rd 4 times in one day, 2 bad it ended so sad

    @_@ poor obi wan! 5, no 5millio stars

  • REALLY awesome!

  • Sigh... The Clone Wars really did end tragicly. Too bad, too. It was my favorite of the two trilogies. When George Lucas, re-releases the six films (as he's stated that he intends to do), he should create an alternate ending to Revenge of the Sith.

  • Comment removed

  • amazing really amazing ....

    5/5

    ^^

  • one of the best-no the best star wars amv ive ever saw...and ive seen alot

  • Totally amazing. Fits so perfectly. One of my favorite videos. :)

  • I luv the song and video....6 stars!!!

  • You really work hard on this video, excellent editing and song. 5 star.

  • So in the final end anniken was saved by Obi - Wan. After anniken seeing his son trying to do what he tried to do before his corruption lifted and he knew what he had to do, finish what he was supposed to do kill the sith.

  • Anniken was the best he turned evil with corruption of lost and despeption! He was still torn when his mom died. Then the sit currpted him into darkness. Obi-Wan did his best to teach this young pupil but like the song said he couldnt save ankien from the darkness that was filling his heart. He did save anniken though !! he saved his best work. His son that carried his good side into the light. His son was saved and in his was his good energy so in the end he ankien became good with his son help