Added: 4 years ago
From: elaine81192
Views: 86,225
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (248)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I would make the choice she did too. To live on earth forever? No. Heaven.....would be sooooooo much better

  • I love this movie<3 aand the book<3

  • eu adoraria se este filme fosse em portugues

  • Its sort of like the Secret Garden, but sexier!

  • i really, really liked this film.<3

  • so what if the movie isn't like the book? A teenage love story beats a freaky child who talks to a frog any day, in my eyes! I love it. Makes me happy :)

  • i would drink

  • Everyone wants that forever life. If it was all romance and beautiful forests then fine, lol. But it wouldnt be. Plus things get old. You would watch your family grow old and die. Things would change around you. You would always have to keep moving and running. Forests get torn down. You would never know what happens when you die. Part of life is death. No matter how scary it is. I wouldnt drink the water. I mean I cant say for sure but I dont think I would. What if Earth explodes?

  • i really hate the movie but love the book

  • they changed it so much! in the book winnie is a 10 year old girl that talks to a frog!

  • she's 11 years old!

  • i love this movie

  • Comment removed

  • think of if you didn't die- living forever. to me tht would be a curse! being stuck until the world ends? no way- but this movie was so sweet :]

  • I love how everyone watched this movie in school. I was in the 5th or 6th grade (which is apparently when everyone reads this book) when the movie first came out, and my whole class went to see it.

  • i love this movie!!!!!!!!

  • i watched this movie today in class, i didnt expect it to be that good

  • im watching this movie in school.

  • question ; does she fall in love with jessie in the book?

  • ya she does, they both do.

  • Ya, in one of the chapters Jesse tells Winnie to drink from the spring when shes 17 so they could get married

  • but in the book they don't kiss or anything

  • @lll513x nope shes only ten in the book

  • @lll513x In a way. She WAS only ten, so there wasn't any big romance. When she first met him, it stated that she lost her heart though and he did propose. It's difficult to say. You'd have to read the book

  • @lll513x Well its really weird. Winnie is 11 in the book. And Jesse kept trying to get her to drink the water. She didnt....But you could say she liked him, even though it was never really mentioned in the book. And instead of Jesse coming to town, Mae and Tuck(his name is Tuck Tuck :P) did. And i dont know if this happened in the movie but instead of drinking the water Winnie poured it on a toad. Because like i said shes only 11.

  • @lll513x Yes she does. You probably already know cause your comment was 2 years ago...

  • @lll513x Well, sort of. In the book, she was 11 and Jessie proposed to her, saying that when she was 17 like her, she could drink from the sprong and join him. I don't know if it was love but she definitely LIKED him a lot.

  • she's such an angel...!

  • so is he!! :)

  • I am to and she is ten

  • 17 lol

  • ya 17 WATEVER same difference

  • no winne is 10 turning 11 and jesse is 104 but look like hes 17 i did a report saw 2 movies and read the book you dumb ass

  • but rebeca , she wouldnt just exsist! she would be with jesse , for ever <3 but oh well... thats her choice....

  • but thats not life, is it? just staying the same age forever. (: people are meant to move on, and thats what the author was trying to get through. that you might meet someone who loves you more than words can say, but life has to move on, even if it means you don't get the boy. its sad; but its life! and life is wonderful.

  • that what i have been tring to explain for everyone and thank you

  • love this movie

  • omg!!! I LOVE THIS MOVIE SOOO MUCH!!!! :d

  • i liked the movie until i saw the endd!! :(:(:(:( WHYYY COULDNT SHE JUSTT DRINKK THE WATERR??

  • Because she needed to live. Live and not just exist.

  • life isn't life if it doesn't change

  • i freaking hate the end of the movie she freaking gets married to another guy!!!!

    then she has kids, EWWY x 10!

    i cant belive her and then she dies

    have some of the water retard!!!!!

    she could of lived 4ever w/ jesse!!

  • What a beautiful movie. I was totally blown away when I saw this for the first time.

  • omg how was that freaking beatiful

    she died!!!

    its VERY wrong 4 u to like that!!!!

    she luved a guy then freaking left him 4 another 1 and forgot him

    why would u do dat??

  • It was her decision. She knew it would be hard to live her life forever, even if by side of Jesse. How would you spend the eternity? I agree w/ father Tuck.

  • Just because she loved him doesn't mean she couldn't move on, as pessimistic and unromantic as it sounds. I believe that there may be true love, but that we can love others. Sometimes, we have to move on and I'm sure Winnie had her reasons.

    I haven't seen the movie yet, though. I'm going to soon and hopefully, she does have reasons, because right now I half agree with you. I don't understand why she left him. It's kind of like she abandoned him and left him to suffer an unceasing life alone.

  • Excuse me? This was set in early America. It's not as if there were other races living lives like these characters during that time. It's more realistic and adds to the greatness of the movie this way. Besides, there are plenty of fairy tales with other races, like the Disney Classics. Also, my version of Cinderella has an Asian and an African American as the Prince and Cinderella. And there's like a billion different versions of Pocahontas, the role being a Native American.

  • OMG im in 6th grade and we watched this in ELA and like omg....it sucked! i mean i LOVED it but seriously eww we dnt need to be watching kissies and like stripping in da pool....lmao

  • wow, you are definitly in the 6th grade.

  • yaaa i no. if it was just me and my friends watching it we would have been fine but it was kinda awkward with two immature classes of sixth graders watching lol

  • I love this book. Forever. :)

  • i just finished reading this book at school too!!!

  • i like this movie alot!

  • How old is hse in the movie cause I know in the book she is ten but she doesn't look ten

  • She's 15 in the movie.

  • in the book shes 11

  • Nope, she's ten.

  • I've the book and seen the movie its awesome!

  • i have to read this book for da skwl project i hope da book is niceee =)

  • im reading this book in school i go to liberty school

  • im readng this book at school lol

  • i read the book. its so awesome.

  • I'll be uploading the whole movie in HQ in a day or two here on Youtube.

  • will love u forever if u do!

  • i'm pretty sure you might be able to by just typyng in "tuck everlasting part 1" on youtube if not i'm sorry i have the same problem with the sisterhood of the travelling pants 2 as i'm from england!

  • waaaa i wanna watch this moviee!!

    i hvnt watched it since it came ouuutt!!!

    anyone know where i can watch ALL of it..¿?

  • same here!

  • I have the entire movie uploaded. Just check my playlist. ^__^

  • I have the entire movie uploaded. Just check my playlist. ^__^

  • does anyone know where I can watch the whole movie online? I used to have it but I don't know where it is and I wanna watch it again :((

  • no i get whad the wood is. i thought it was the road. oops!:P

  • hey is the toad winnie talks to gonna be in the movie there too?

  • noper sorry

  • I just finnished the book and i'm gonna watch it in school on tuesday (no school mon. XD)

  • Does anyone have the music from this scene?

  • im reading this book its good but she died for mae tuck:(

  • dude winnie suppose to be 10 years old. that other lady is like way too old. but she is pretty...

  • in the movie shes 17 but in the book shes 10. i guess disney didnt want to confuse people with the age difference.

  • Actually she's 15 in the movie. ;)

  • It reminds me of Twilight

  • It doesnt, but i dont get y ppl are marking the comment down

  • oh i remember this movie

    the book was amazing as well

  • Will someone please post the whole movie? Both versions <X( I've been searching for it for a long time.......

  • They almost went with the other title. The one that starts with an F.

  • i only saw part of this movie like twice (i never saw the beginning) on a cruise i went on (i got sick..so i was in bed all morning) and it was soooooooo sad...i cried for three days afterwards...(i am an emotional person as u can tell) in school...i would just burst into tears and the teach would ask wut is wrong and i said 'he came back 4 her...but she was dead!!' and cried like all day..i know i sound very stupid and probably am..but I LOVE THIS MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!

  • you pretty funny so you mean whinnie dies!!!!!??????????

  • yes she dies and the book is also cool 2 u should read it

    its sort of different i loved the book

  • yes my class finished the book she was 78 when she died i sorta cried 3 tears:D

  • dw hunnie, I cried and cried in the bathroom...i was just the same! he came back for her...and it broke my heart...but thats what made the story...I guess. It shows that you need live and get on with life.

    Winne was the hero, she lived. :)

  • sad movie :( i luvd it da ending was soo sad *crying* but wut wud u choose living 4 ever nd not die 4rm anything not ageing da only way 2 be dead is 4 da world 2 end??or living a regular life dying 4rm age or other things

    poor jesse :''(

  • anybody know about the first movie, 1982 i think. I watched on tv when i was a child. I think it`s better than new film. The final image, the turtle crossing the road....just in the old film... If you watched this 2002 version you just have to search for this old version. I assure you it amaizing and perturbing. Search for it. If somebody have a copy just share please.

  • i like this movie

  • i got a test on teh book 2day and i dun study

  • wait hold up i thought winnie foster was 10 in da book wtf? this women in the movie is like 50yrs old x.x

  • actually in the movie she is supposed to be 15 but the person playing her is 19!

  • 19 lol? dosnt look abit like shes 19

  • i tought she was like 13 or 15.

    But yeah i have the book and i just noticed that.

    Lol.

    It says she is 10 going to 11.

  • i memorized every word

  • In the book Winnie does not live to be 100 only 78. I know i just finished the book yesterday.

  • we only read the book.

  • im reading the book for my class we are going to have a test on this well a cheat its not gonna hurt ^_^

  • I LOVE THIS MOVIIEEE <33

  • does anyone else think alexis would've made an amazing bella (twilight) ?

  • exactly yes i do agree!

  • me too. but now she's too old (26) to successfully portray 17. well actually... she does still look pretty young for her age. idk...

  • @foxiao thank you i have been saying that for the longest time and no one agrees with me

  • i love this movie! its the best

  • i saw this movie last night, it was sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­o sad i <3 it its a fantabulose movie and sad, but sader than the book. im glad winnie lived to be 100, but she wanted to stay with jesse and she decided not too its a great ovie and book i <3 it my mom almost cried.

  • Hey!!!

    I Just Saw This Movie At School!

    Right After We Read The Book.

    I Was So MAD That Winnie And Jesse

    Didn't Marry Each Other!

  • but u can break it up.

  • Omg jesse's cuter than he is in the book they make a cuter couple than in the book when shes 11 and he's 17 WUV...WUV...

  • how would u know how he look in the book?

  • he had curly hair and it said that winnie thought he was beautiful and i think it said he had brown eyes. OOOOHHHHHH WAIT I MENT THEYM MAKE A CUTER COUPLE I THE MOVIE THAN THE BOOK OPPS, I SHOULD'VE BUT THEN INSTEAD OF WHEN %) (OPPS)

  • hes on the front cover

  • i want to seee the movie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i love this movie..its so sweet

  • is there any more of this film??

    I love this movie it's so kwl

  • can you upload the whole movie?

  • I dunno how to upload it.

  • Is the entire movie on youtube?TELL ME WHO HAS IT PLEASE!

  • I want to see the whole movie too!

  • i love the book

  • she soposed to be 10 years old??

  • yup

  • but not in the movie, only in the book

  • i read the book already. i liked it! :D

  • Is Winnie still 11 in this movie or did they make her a different age? cause in the book she is 11

  • She's 15-they probably changed it to make it more realistic between Jesse and Winner

  • is this not the best film ever!!

  • me to

  • OMG Im readin dis in class:p its soo cool!

  • same here!of course we read already...saw movie today

  • u in AIS

  • i read this book so many times! its a great book and a great movie

  • whos class are you in. we are reading to. maybe we r in the same class.

  • Ya im reading it in class to

  • im reading the book with my class and i think its good so far!! we're going to watch the movie when we finish the book but i just wanted a little peek of what Jesse looks like. lol. dont tell! shh! =P

  • dayumm

    im reading it too

    lolz

  • *Spoiler*

    Please don't read if don't want a spoiler...

    I've read the book and I thouht it was absolutely amazing.....until I got in the end part.....I mean dude.....A Frog?...A frog ruins it all??...can you believe that....

  • no it has something to do when tuck says that frog must think it can live forever

  • i read the book too

  • i read the book with my class, i fckin hated it! it was boring as hell! i even fell asleep reading it like three times!

  • I made Treegap in SimCity 3000, if anyone be interested.

  • cool!Im reading the book with my class and we are going to watch the movie so I wanted to see a little bit^^

  • I luv this movie! <3

  • where is the whole movie i REALLY WNT TO KNOW PLEASE ANYONE???????

  • where can i find the whole thing on youtube?! or any other movie hosting website? ):

  • I cant help but wonder if the man in the yellow suite was miles's son .

  • I read the book!

  • Me too!

  • me threee!!!

  • OMG! i luv this movie!

  • i cried when i read the book =[

  • i liked the book should i get the movie is it good?

  • its pretty good..but the book is more interesting =]

  • As good as the book may be, the movie is wonderful. (Well, sad, as you know, but wonderful still.) I'd at least rent it so you can see.

  • nick lachey and jessica simpsons was seven yaers apart while winnie and jesse were only six

  • nick lachey and jessica simpsons was seven yaers apart while winnie and jesse were only six

  • i read the book:)

  • i just bought this movie today!!!

  • she does not loook ten at all!

  • she is 11

  • well she doesn't look 11 either. she looks like she would be 15 or 16

  • she was 15 or 16 when she filmed this. In the book shes supposed to be 10 but they made her older in the movie.

  • well shes 10 in the book

    but they had to make her older in the movie because they had to make the love story cuz if not you wouldn't understand what shes thinking the whole way through

  • okayyyy,

    in the book, winney is 10, and jesse is 15

    and in the movie winney is 15 and jesse is 17

  • winnie, my bad!

  • no in the book jesse was 17 also

  • yea trust me whinne is 11 in the book and jesse is 17

  • I really want the book I loved the movie jess'es gorgeous <3