Added: 5 years ago
From: simpleutopia
Views: 62,615
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (136)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • What an excellent song! Sting is a great artist.

  • Wow. As a fan of the series, I remember how sad it was when Rose and the Doctor were seperated. This vid captured that sense of loss very well. Truly well done.

  • The song is most bueatiful, but I do prefer Fields of Green! We have plenty of green here in Lotusland (Vancouver),Canada...where (rain)clouds are always around, and that is for the better part of the year too. The summer is short(2 months), which usually means we don't see fields of gold anywhere, be it a grassy park or the pasture out in the valley. Everything stays green around these neck of the woods and that's the way I like it!!! Thx4 the bueatiful song nevertheless.

  • Oh, marvelously done!!!

  • Really great job!

  • I love how you (simpleutopia) address the copy right issue. I have found more music and shows to watch because of YouTube. It's free advertising for Doctor Who and Sting; I love both. These kind of short music videos on here have replaced the old MTV when they used to play videos to promote their music. This is far better. And this video is fantastic!

  • Absolutely gorgeous!!

  • david tennant is the best better than the cardboard sets online at justdoctorwho-dot-com

  • This is such a good video. Well done :)

  • Hi, in answer to your response about the worrying aspects of folk's utilization of others artistic productions-- Of course in regard to sampling there are copyright issues which are arcane as I am not a scholar of copyright,I really cannot speak upon. I was pointing to wider concerns--including of misappropriation of intellectual and cultural materials--for example the Russian Ice Dancers use of "aboriginal" cultural artifacts in the construction of their competition piece-a problematic use.

  • I really appreciated this work . The folks born after 1976 have a different way of thinking about the use of other people's artistic production, which I do sometimes worry about. However my love for the Doctor and appreciation of this character--in this instance outweigh those concerns.

  • Hi there,

    Thanks for the kind words... I think. When you say "use of other people's artistic production" - do you mean that people shouldn't make fanvids as they're a breach of copyright? When, in fact, my making this video is really not ONLY an ad for Dr Who, but also for Sting's Fields of Gold, both of which are not only acknowledged in the vid, but there's also a link on the vid placed by Youtube, for people to buy the song if they want to.

    Where's the worrisome aspect, i ask myself?

  • Oh yeah, there is such a thing as "fair use" which allows folks to use a specified amount of an original work within another piece, if (as you seem to have done the work is properly attributed--So my comment was a general one, but I just wanted to explicate some to the issues that are currently within the discourse of media/performance studies and practices. Once again I did enjoy this peace..Long Live the Doctor!!

  • Lovely...well done

  • Watch TVShows like Doctor Who - FIELDS OF GOLD - Sting at W W W . TV-Vide . NET

  • I adore this song, and this is a sweet and fitting tribute to one of the most awesome companions ever.

  • The song is perfect for this Excellent and Beautiful video. Thanks for sharing.

  • This is drop dead wonderful!

  • But, your going to have to wait because I have to get them for my brithday/christmas presents XD

  • oh, it's not your fault. It's just that most of my good ideas get taken XD

    But, I still got a few ideas up my sleeves!

  • hehe... I look forward to seeing them! Make sure you post your vids as a response to this one so i get to watch!

  • It's not fair, all my ideas get stolen :(

    Maybe I should just give up :(

  • Hehe... I'm SO sorry that my vid of *three years ago* stole your ideas. ;-) How dare I reach into the future and steal thoughts from your brain?!

  • That was beautifully done. Wonderful song choice and fantastic editing. It brought tears to my eyes.

  • To be honest i really expected this to be crap, as loads of people do this type of thing and it's really badly edited or really cheesy. You did an amazing job, honestly the best one of these ive ever seen. xxx

  • Hehe... Yeah, there are an awful lot of really badly cheesy ones out there. If you're looking for other really high quality fanvids, look up a user called Golly Felix - she pretty much inspired me to do what I did.

    I'm still waiting for inspiration for the next vid, 3 years later. Can't wait for Russell T Davies to hand the reigns over to Steven Moffat - I think the stories will get much better from then on in.

    Thanks for the kind words!

    Cx

  • Wow. It`s very WONDERFUL M/V. Thanks to make it.

    For myself, I prefer the Lute ver. in studio 60 on the sunset street(NBC Tv show) by Sting. but unfortunately, that song is only 3:06.

    If you have chance. you have to listen that version. Maybe You can search in here. It`s slow. and more sorrow and beautiful. Thanks again.

    This M/V is very toched. I love Rose, and both Doctor, too.

  • I LOVED the lute version. I also loved that show, and mourned it's cancellation deeply.

    Good taste mate!

    Cx

  • eva cassidy is better

  • I like both versions - and was prepared to use either of them before I saw the final episode of this season of Dr Who. If Rose really DID die, then I'd have used the Eva Cassidy version, but I thought it was just a bit too morose given that she lived. Besides, Sting wrote this song, I think we should let him decide how it should be played, don't you? ;-)

  • yeah ur right :)

  • the episode when she left was so sad, I cried!

  • I am glad I came across this version. I have been listening to yuggy renditions on other tubes.

    Billie Piper is so beautiful. I only came across this program when I moved to the States.

  • Wonderful

  • I love how you included Doctor #9 and #10 in your video. I love when they hold hands watching the earth die, and the ending is so sad. You did such a lovely beautiful job! This is one of my favorite Sting songs too so pairing it with Doctor Who, one of my favorite shows, is so spectacular!

  • I never liked this song....untill now

  • Great video

  • i love this video ito cute and sweet

  • 5* I liked it very much. Now there needs to be another version for David Tennant.

  • Beautiful vid.....and I love this song by Sting....

  • Great Video, I Loved It

  • i love this!

  • favorite musician+favorite musician= excellent video! KEEP IT COMING!

  • Aww that was just lovely-well done fab video :).

  • well you have made a growen man cry at a very old age i found i still have a soul THANKS tony

  • LOVE IT!

  • That was gr8. It was very well made. Well done

  • dont worry ppl rose will be back on dr.who this sataday

  • And I have a new fanvid planned! ;-)

  • That was really lovely, well done.

  • Congratulations. This is magical. The scene where Rose realises she is in love with the Doctor is wonderful. Look at the expression on her face! (He is working on the Tardis; she is weraring a blue T shirt. In case anybody dosn't recognise the scene)

  • Nice parody music video :-)

  • *grins* not exactly meant to be a parody, but whatever floats your boat... ;-)

  • Very sad, but very good! Loved the feel, and you matched the music and clips up nicely. Awesome video ^__^

  • You cant show her face too much....too pretty.

  • So sweet!!!!

  • I just re-watched this, and I actually teared up a bit. I haven't even seen very much of this show, and this video just touches me. I really need to see all the episodes.

  • Oh, I'm glad you like it. You definitely need to see more eps of the show - the ones which prompted this vid were Army of Ghosts, and Doomsday. Last two episodes of the second series of the new productions, aired (in the UK) in 2006.

  • Thank you for getting me up to speed. The more I watch this video, the more I love it. Even not knowing everything that has happened, this song fits what you are showing so well. Great work on this video.

  • I don't want you to think that I don't enjoy the video. I really do. Every scene you put in here goes with the song great. Guess my problem is that I don't understand the video.. did Rose leave the show? Or was it just the actress? I have only seen a few episodes of the new Dr. Who.

  • Aaaah, see there's the thing... Rose "died", but was in actuality was trapped on the other side of the Void - it was this big heroic thing that she did, which meant that she was forever trapped in an alternate reality, away from the Doctor - her true love... The actress left, though apparently will return - but this wasn't known at the time of putting together this vid. It's kinda a tribute to Rose, and the time she spent with the Doctor.

  • It's good, but you use that shot of just her face way too many times.

  • *Grins*

    I'm sorry you feel that way - it was all about her looking back and remembering - kinda the point of the vid. ;)

  • I love it!!! out of all the vid"s saying goodbye to rose it's the best.

    I can't wait for the new season when she comes back!

  • Thankyou! Loved the video!

  • thats so sad... :'( so touching lol

  • this song always makes me cry...especially with Rose and the Doctor...

  • Rose is coming back to Doctor Who! YAY

  • Wow this was wonderful. I've seen that episode so many times, I am dry-eyed now. But this video brought out the tears again.

  • This song makes me cry...especially mixed with "Doomsday" *sob*

  • it makes me cry also

  • This song makes me feel better.

  • sign a petition to bring rose back!!!! w-w-w dot petitiononline dot com / rosie111

  • it's a shame the doctor and rose only kissed when she was possessed...they were definitely in love.

    vid made me cry...:(

  • I wasn't crazy about Rose--I don't dislike her, but I'm not crazy about her--but this AMV made me cry my eyes out. It's really, really beautiful, and I especially like the editing at the end. (It helps that I'm a sucker for that song!)

  • vielen dank

  • that was amazing! fantastic choice of song and very emotional, like sum1 else said, one of the best and most emotional doctor who vids i seen and edited to perfection! well done! doomsday still brings a tear to my eye hehe!

  • We want Rose back! Sign the petition for a Doctor Who movie with Rose and the Doctor (we'll be sending it to the BBC when we get enough signatures):

    w-w-w dot petitiononline dot com / rosie111

  • What episodes from the 10th Doctor who did you use?

  • Oh gawd, it was such a long time ago... Possibly all/most of them! Except perhaps Love and Monsters, and possibly Fear Her - those didn't really resonate emotionally with me, so I didn't fancy going through to find clips which I could use.

  • you did yous fear her :D lol

    a little clip, with the cake thingy lol

    :D just thought i'd say. :) x

  • Sorry, you're right - I did use Fear Her... I always get that end scene mixed up with the end of The Idiots Lantern - it's that whole street party thing... ;-)

  • In her first passion woman loves her

     lover;

    In all the others, all she loves is love.

    -- Byron

  • One of the most touching and beautiful doctor who mvs I've ever seen.

  • Really good.

  • Classic

  • Beautiful!

  • *sniff* it made me cry! Even the happy bits..

  • Brilliance! my heart breaks everytime I see that Doomsday finale. Never fails to make me cry x

  • Oooh, no! Can't give companion status to GitFace (as my friends and I call her.) Besides, Sophia Myles is dating David Tennant now, so that would make things difficult.

    Personally, I'm all for Sally Sparrow being the next companion - she was BRILLIANT! And had more pathos.

  • Hell yeah - that's the exact same thing I thought! She was fantastic. Nice video also. :D

  • This was so beautiful- only vid that has made me cry! love the song too- I always thought of it with these two, too. that and 'if i ever lose my faith in you'. hint hint!!! well done, and THANKYOU!!!

  • *smiles* thanks so much for the kind words. I was really looking forward to a new season of Doctor Who, and more material to work with but I have to admit, Martha as the Companion just leaves me cold. There'll be no more WhoVids from me till it's inspired me again... :) But I'm thinking about a Firefly Vid!

  • OMG I love this song

    Joins in with davidtennantmad:

    PLEEEASSEEE COME BAAACKKK!!!

    *sniffle*

    Thanks for this vid...it made me cry...not sure if thats a good thing... *shrugs*

  • *sobs*

    ROOOSEEEEE COME BAAAACK!!!!!

  • beautifully & tastefully done .. even better than my video on the same song by sting...

  • whenever i listen to this song i think of those two :)

    beautiful vid

  • amazing! Very well done!

  • Beautiful! and excellent song choice, it really gets the tears going!

  • magnificent

  • I actually created an account to say how much I loved this - you made this amazingly well. And yes, as with everyone else I'm sat here with a tear in my eye!!!

  • Wow, that's high praise indeed! I feel so honoured that my little piece of Rose Love brought you a little closer to The Tube! ;-)

  • This is so lovely....thanks for posting it...

  • This is gorgeous - really excellent edits. Nice job!

  • aww, that was lovely , that song makes me sad

  • This is one of the best tribute videos I've seen for Doctor Who. Excellent choice of music with the right clips at the right time. Good job!

  • Thanks so much! That's very kind!

  • I love o so video it so cute I love it

  • omg this is such a gr8 vid

  • Very moving video! I love it, and the music fits perfectly!:)

  • Thats nice, a different feeling from other vids, its not really sad or really happy look back.

    A nice contemplation, good having rose looking and thinking all the way though and a nice bit at the end.

  • Wow.  Nice job! Thank you!!

  • Thank you for this video. It does The Doctor and Rose's special relationship justice. Lovely!

  • OMG! Thank you for posting this video! I LOVE YOU!

  • Aww! Thanks for the kind words, and the subscription!

    Charlotte x

  • Oops, posted under my alter-youtube-ego... MissCarlotta is my directors account for my more original content vids, simpleutopia was more for fanvids and stuff! ;) But still, thanks for the kind words!

  • oh...so nice

  • This made me cry a lot. Thanks, though - it's beautifully done.

  • Aw, that's beautiful! And now I'm crying again.

  • Oh, my, this was absolutely lovely.

  • That was beautiful! *sob*

  • That was beautiful, I was sobbing by the end :( Rose Tyler will be missed

  • Wow, beautiful video. I love it so much!

  • I've never seen dr. who, nice show in england? Sadly not in Germany. Billie Piper: What a girl! Her smile...and of course the music of Sting. Great!!!

  • David Tennent Is the BEST Dr who!

  • Gah! *chokes up* I've never even seen Doctor Who, and this practically made me cry! I'll certainly share this with my friend who's a fan. Great job!

  • Oh my God, I actually started to tear up by the end. Beautifully done.

  • aawwww... Thanks! Imagine me as I was making it - almost shorted out my keyboard!! ;-)

  • wow totally original all i ve been hearing is goodbye to you but this is fab *adds to favorites*

  • Aww it's so beautiful

  • That was ....FANTASTIC!!!!

  • Tell me..The man who she is travelling with..Dr Who..

    Thats not the same one as the one we see in this clips?

    Who is that?

  • That is the Doctor. Not sure what you are confused about, you have to remember that he can regenerate, so although its two different bodies its the same person. Confusing but thats the best I can explain.

  • They are sending the show Here in Denmark

    But its not popular at all..Dont think many people are watching it .

    So I was surprised that It actually is a wellknown show.

  • In England, Doctor Who has a cult following. Beforehand, there were multiple series of the show. This is the newest series, put forward after a long, long break.

  • Im going to ditto most of what has been said here It is one of the best vids I have ever seen it any fandom. Pefection, well done!

  • Just completely amazing.

  • Amazing song for this storyline! It was so sad.. Still makes me cry..But yeah the video is awesome the right clips from episodes...Good Work.Tis in my favourites xD

  • Oh my god, it's brilliant!! I love the ending!!! Definatly one of my favourites! :)

  • a girl made this? or? well, wow nice work!

  • Ha!  yes, a girl made it, what, couldn't you tell from the angstiness? ;-)

  • Yeah, this could be the best Who fanvid made. Great balance on 9th and 10th and nive work with the narrative and then summary at the end. Song choice was brilliant.

  • Beautiful. Sad. Lovely. Bittersweet. PERFECTION! This is absolutely one of my favorite videos ever (in any fandom). *pretends she didn't tear up* I have allergies!

    PS On another note (from the little aspiring vidder in me), I think I kinda want to kick you for making such wonderful videos. Stop it, you fiend! ;-D

  • You are a genius!

    Luv guess who! xxx;D

  • Excellent vid to great song!

  • Oh I LOVE this. So beautifully done. Excellent job.

  • omg this is sooo sad but beautiful i lluv it

  • *is bawling like a baby* Sooooooooooo sad! Sooooooooo beautiful!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more