Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (6,224)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @AnnieThelen14 :No,i don;t agree,they just love her !!! she's one of the bests!

  • I <3 FERGIE

  • miley suckss point blankk like qottah say anythinq??.

  • considering these artists are all singing for a cause, i respect each of them, regardless of my personal opinion on their talent level.

  • darn! i wish alicia keys had miley's part... i dont like her =p

  • shut up stop talking about miley guys

  • Miley has no talent, she should have switched with Rihanna, but Rihanna should have sung the entire chorus part. So Miley never should have been part of this.

  • Leona Lewis' voice is beautiful...it really highlights the song!

  • keyshia cole was gd jus like every1 else.

  • beyonce,fergie ,mariah carey are old artist ,miley is a recent artis, but i think she's ok,so SHUT UP !

  • miley sucks !!!

  • haha she as a terrible voice

  • if only alicia keys had miley's part then it would have been better...

  • Aww dis song is sad , my uncal died of cancer and we wnt in to c him every day and he got really skinny and he couldnt move and then afta a few weekz he died =[

  • did ciara sing a little solo

  • Love the song!!!

    MC,Rihanna,beyoncé,mary J Blige..!!!!

  • seriously ppl this is so stupid ... my aunt died of cancer and this song reminds me of her so much cuz she faught for her life till her last breath who the fuck cares if miley can sing.. the point is she is doing ti for a good cause sometimes you cant just think about urself .. listen to the words next time and im sure it will touch ur heart. give up on bashing her... let the song be and do what its supposed to do

  • It doesnt matter if miley isnt as powerful as the other singers. she is still good and its not about how people can sing. its about giving money for cancer.

  • oh guys seriously, shut the hell up about miley. shes a recent artist - get the hell over it.

    if anything, why is natasha bedingfield there, bcus shes an older artist? fight about that one or something else ffs!

  • to be honest why do you bother Dising Miley cyrus its not like you know her personaly ???

    So please just shut up !!!

  • Yep i agreee

  • Same :(

  • this is a really encouraging song! they should play it for people in the hospitals :) i'm sure everyone would love it

  • what the fuck... amazingsong except for miley.. what was she thinking? she sounds horrible in this!

  • Shez wayyyyyy beta than yhuu whore

  • i love how everyone stood up for fergie

  • someone else can be in the place of miley someone with an better voice there are so may more poeple that can sing better.Miley is fake she has a witchevoice

  • dude, hard it maybe to accept but sweet young miley doesn't have that really good voice! but yes perhaps she is among the best and most famous performers and even the richest this days but not necessarily among with the best voices.

  • I LOVE NATASHA!!!

  • yes, but miley is invited to do this right?

    so she is one of the best performers.

    deal with that

    and leave your opinion somewere els

  • I love this song its so sad

  • carrie is short and li ove how every one stood up when fergie sang.

  • she tried. You who are here to say that children seem to sing if they are jealous of you to be in front of millions of people on top of a stage I wanted to see ... no longer so she has a very cool voice and we must accept it ..

  • we are not so you have to see that Miley is only 17 years and say that her voice is even a sweet voice ... let the monkey business of music is spectacular has great voices finally be congratulated for pulling the people ..

  • i think fergie is the one who messed up.

    love miley

    so don't do that childisch

  • you see, when fergie sang, everyone cheered. and not to miley. :)

  • I know everyone is dising miley... but you dont need to make fun of fergie... she got a great voice.. so does miley... tbh.. i would like to see all these ppl that are being rude, get up and sing infront of a 100,000 crowd ...

  • Comment removed

  • Please, why is Miley there?? She can't sing like them, she shouldn't be there.sorry

  • Yeah,and that is the most important thing - do you like her or not,please...

  • I'm sorry if you don't like my comment. I think Miley is OK, actually I like some of her songs, i'm just saying that this is not one of her best performances.

  • miley never does good performances tat would require her to have talent lol

  • Listen, as long as you appreciate what these people are doing, it doesn't matter if they sound good or bad. If they pulled out someone from the audience who had the confidence to sing, people still cheer the guy because he had the confidence and the courage to do it. He may be a bad singer, but who cares? he tried! And that's what really matters.

  • OK, personally i dnt like miley just her music call me mean but i dnt like ugly people and her face pisses me off but other than that she'z not that bad her shows funny n her songz aren't THAT bad there still bad but not that bad BUT I STILL DNT LIKE HER!!!!!!

  • miley ruined it.

    she can't sing like them.

  • Well until you can get up and sing infront of at least 100,000 thousand ppl... i wouldnt be the one judging okay...

  • I personally think they ALL did qood ! I love this video and I listen to it ALOT . And i'd love Just Stand Up To Cancer and this video made me. My prayers qo out to anyone who has it . And once aqain i ♥ this video & all the ppl who sanq in it !

  • People are saying she sounds childish She is a child that took courage and it was for a good cause it wasnt about the voices

  • ley and Rihanna's part i like the whole thing

    I Like Miley, but why dont you to she is young talented and has a nice voice

    Plese respond

  • everyones voice is so smooth and graceful and then when miley sings its just.. childish. she hardly had any lines but the badness still stood out. great song for a great cause but miley should have been left out

  • Truthfully, everyone needs to stop. Your allowed to say who was your favorite, but its not fair because everyone worked really hard on this song, and that is not what this song is about. This song is amazing. Just leave it at that. Don't hate.

    (:

  • Yeaaa...Miley Doesnt Sound so Hot In This!

    [Hate Her!!!]

    xD

  • Charity work aside this song was amazing! Together these woman (and miley cyrus) sound incredible. When we go into individual is where we find some people (miley cyrus especially) should just stand there until the chorus. Best single performance Mary J, Natasha Bedingfield, Leona Lewis, Beyonce, Mariah Carey and Carrie Underwood.

  • wtf miley??

  • damn you Miley!!!

  • damn i cry everytime i hear that song!

  • I am a Mariah fan and I think she did fantastic. But I think she lipsynced the whistle register part. you can see her mouth doesn't match starting at 3:30. But except that she did all live .

  • this is a great song and video and most important its a great cause!

  • go mariah!!

  • omg my favorite singer ciara didnt even sing!!!!!!

  • 3:54 - 3:56 - I love that part. :-)

  • @ScorpioBabyy

    : da song part or their reaction or sumtang

  • @ratfacedmonster2 The little dance Beyonce and Miley did. That was so cute.

  • what really talented women, this is one of the best live performances on tv, and it's great that they all agreed to do something like this, AMAZING!

    cheers

  • I live this songit tha best

  • why do they stand for fergie?

  • hasnt fergie suffered from cancer?

  • i was wondering the exact same thing when i watched it again, I think they stand because someone in the front row stood and the rest just follows. It just a coincidence that fergie sang at that point. Im sure if they stand up at another part of the song, we would be wondering the same bout other artist.

  • This is soooo positive. I have a lot of respect for all of the artists who used their talents to do something so positive and all of them are soooo talented. I agree with some of the other commenters;although you have the right to your opinion, it's not necessary to make negative comments.If you want to express your opinion about the artist, you should consider doing it in a manner that doesn't offend anyone. Just a suggestion.

    Just Stand Up!!!!

    Smile=)

  • incredible.

  • is melissa etheridge in this?

  • THis song is very inspirational it inspires me everyday Miley has naturally a great voice just not live when she sings live she tends to crackle its true but i appreciate her n the rest of those amazing artist for taking a stand. Leonas voice is so beautiful as with beyonce i mjb stepped it up man thats my gurl plus mariah wither her power took over the song I dont know y people stood up for fergie i felt that was rude she dosent even have the best voice nicole amazing same as ashanti keyisha

  • this isn't a contest, on who is the best this is for the benefit for all the little girls and boys who's lives are being messed up by cancer! this is for them and to honor them because us as normal healthy people take everything for granted when those little girls and boys push out the energy just to smile, so stop taking about who is better, be thankful for what they're standing up to and join them in standing UP for this cause....

  • I think Miley shouldn't sink she'll break earth in pieces

  • miley shouldn't be up there

    she doesn't earn that

    and the same for fergie

  • miley and fergie both earned that, and your no one to be judging

  • @blakerocks97

    and they earned that because? because they're SUCH good singers? :')

  • Fergie!!!!! THE BEST!!!

  • Miley sucks here.

  • rihanna shuld hav sung mileyz part

  • Does It even matter wat miley or who ever sound's like this song is for such a great cause :) <3

  • Miley is a great choice yu ppl have nothing better 2 do than 2 put others dwn she was great they all were

  • im 15 and i was jsut recently diagnosed with papillary thyroid cancer, this song is keeping me going threw all the pain. amazing song

  • wow thats sad, just keep pushing and u hope your okay

  • Mariah went higher then them all !!She wins forsure and second mary j blige and beyonce than leona!!!

  • homenagem muito linda, parabéns a todas as cantoras!!!

  • *things get betteh* ooh *wateveh* omg miley ruined it rly shes tryin 2 b a role model 2 like stand up 4 cancer and tell ppl 2 but shes goin out and takin wet shower pix and other obsurd 1s... plus at that time she was waaay 2 young 4 a performance with all those great artist like that i mean carrie underwood,mary j,beyonce, rihanna and whoop dee do miley cyrus..wooooow! i give this a thumbs down 4 miley and a bllion thmbs up for the rest :D

  • miley is such a lovely girl its just her voice is very different and powerful and loud as well so i guess it stood out. But she did put energy into her performance - think demi lovato should have been there, beyonce mary J mariah leona carrie are all exceptional x

  • I love how Mary J Blige sang her part, she's super and she's got a very very powerful voice!. And Fergie, Carrie Underwood, MC, and Beyonce too. Miley's a wrong pick, eh?

  • its not about who u like the reason theese artists did this song is because its for charity not a promotional stunt. so just apreciate the song and the artists.

  • ugh !!!

    fuck miley she cant be compared to these great artist and Leona clam down bitch yew at all that !!!!

  • MARIAH && Mary j blige !!! :D

    i loved them they did the best

  • ya your right she can do what she wants but that doesnt mean she should!! I love miley i watch the show, been to three of her concerts, love,love love her but really she sucked it up in this song!!!

  • leave miley alone she can do and b what she wants i thought she was amazing

    luf you milzz

    xox

  • jusut becuz you dnt like miley does'nt mean that othaz dont

  • this song and video is amazing

  • miley is tryin to hard

  • I Just Love Carrie's Getho Dance

    She Is So Cute =]

  • I love them all! Except, of course, Miley. Who in so few words managed to sound so laughable. I admire her for her charity work, but really? She shouldn't try to sing with the masters, for her own sake.

  • i love this song

    my cousin had cancer too

    i am soo happy that my cousin is olready better!!!!

  • Beautiful! Look at the cause rather than who sings better or fashion. Cancer is serious every1 at some point has been affected by it directly or indirectly. I lost my best friend/first cousin to cancer. She was diagnosed at the age of 24. She had breast cancer won that battle, later it was found in her brain and through out her body. She was so strong, not once did she complain. She just lived her life, was a good mother and wife until the end. RIP Tasha, you will always be remembered!

  • Beyonce and fergie also natasha bedingfield were so fucking awesome and miley sucked ass

  • no offense but miley ruined the song... awesome song thou!

  • it's true

  • cuz' she have a shitty voice even if it's for a second, is still a shit

  • Leona, fergie, mary j blidge and mariah all sung really well :)

    nice song.

  • best performers !

  • I really, like, hate Miley, she ruins a perfect song. But I think what they want to reach with the song is really good

  • leona beyonce and mariah did best

  • I really don't understand why you all keep complaining on Miley .... the singer is chosen by the producer of this song ok .......... I think Miley is great ........ cause she appears for the original and live version !!! Well Melissa, Sheryl and Leann rimes only record studios part ... for live version been change to Nicole PCD.

    Pls don't judge cause all is producer the 1 whom chose.

  • wow miley failed...I agree, replace miley with BS and throw madonna in the mix

  • @eleganz naw miley is betta she may sound like and old women sometimes but dont put madonna old freaky self in there she will be humpin stuff and dey talkin bout cancer

  • miley ruins it

  • @tiannakaye123 miley didnt even say dat much stuff so how did she ruin it

  • @zahira1254 she sounds decent in the part where everyone's singing together, but the part where her and Rihanna are bouncing back and forth? Yeah. No.

  • I think it's unfair that Ciara didn't get any solos. And Miley keeps trying to out sing Rihanna. Taylor Swift should've been here.

  • this song is so wonderful!!!!

    5 stars,  but why everyone stand up when fegie starts singin?

    justin are fuckin hot there, i love him

    btw you are a bunch of dumbasses.

    no one gives a shit why taylor Bitch is not there, her voice is weak and she would have ruined it.

    all the girls did good job(includin that disney girl miley cyrus) if u dont like it, fuck off, check another video and shut the fuck up.

    what a annoyin people...

  • Where is Melissa Etheridge says she was part of this song MILEY sux donkey !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • hey no offence but miley carnt sing she sings threw her noes lmao but i guess we carnt realy mock her cuz shes famous and were not and shes doin it for a gurd cause

  • Great SONG!!!

  • miley is awuful..her voice like shit..

    justin temberlake is damn hot!!!!

  • it definatly proves that Miley cant sing...

  • where's BRITNEY SPEARS :((

  • theres no doubt about it

    Mariah Carey && mary j blige did the best job !!!

  • wherees taylor swift

  • all those women and they sang in unison almost the whole song

  • aw! i LOVE this song:D it's such a positive thing they are all doing. they are all so beautiful and talented and such a good mix. stop bashing Miley, we all know she can sinq and its so cute cuz shes like the youngest and i love it cuz im young too =] and id love to be around all those older, talented people. she is still young. its cute what she did the song is talking about standing up to cancer. stop breaking down mileys part and think about the cause of the whole song.

  • stop insultin miley cyrus at least she tried

    & if u think u can say all dat stuff on utube den try sayin it to her face

  • I like this song but I think Miley Cyrus ruined it when she sang.

    I think Mary J. Blige was the best out of all of them.

  • yea Miley made me cringed wen she sang....but all of them were very good not just Mary J Blige

  • omg poor ciara what part did she hve

  • Why did everyone get up when fergie sung?

  • shes cool

  • i was wondering same thing

  • probably because the camera was panning in..atleast thats what it seems like..

  • this song is amzing and what they stand for is even more amazing

  • Really nice, uplifting song. I really think they should have given Natasha Bedingfield a bigger part... i mean she deserves it and she has by far the best voice of all of the singers!

  • ohh this is suj a cool song

    i do like miley cyruses voice buh hur tone is just different to the others

    buh ow its suj a cool song

  • This is such a powerful song. It gives me a feeling of hope for the future every time I hear it!

  • I Really Love This Song

    It Sends Shivers Up and Down My Spine

    and miley sings great i just love her!!

    and beyonce is amazing too !! <3

  • hey got itgoing on keep doing wat ur doing ladies

  • just shut up this is not about the artist its about to stand up to cancer so it is great that the artist are helping;;

  • some of these ladies could have done better.

    and some actually sounded great. really shows how much talent they have...

  • beyonce, mariah, and leona are my favs!!!

  • beyonce and mariah rocks..

  • Miley really was the worst!

    but except that its super!!!!!

  • its also because shes no where near the same level as the others

  • the studio versian is better and miley probably had a sore throat or something she sounds better on the studio but she wasnt tht bad i thought leona's part sounded jst like mariah carey on the studio and they all sounded fine

  • NATASHA RoCKS

  • 1:53 fergie baby

  • leeonaa :)

  • yay carrie, miley and rihanna!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • good song, but i think miley can do it better, but i think she was sad cause' her grandpa was died of cancer, fergie sound is kinda weird too hard, beyonce,always the best, mariah, i love her high key! other, good!

  • my aunt has three types of cancers, she may never live to see Christmas!

  • bless her heart! I pray for you!

  • i think its natasha bedingfield :) x

  • Who is the one with the white pants?

  • to me they all did a great job! i dont care who was and wont there! it was for cancer so they did something good for everyone!

  • i think its miley..

  • Comment removed

  • i agree that Shakira and Christina should've been there. Miley's voice is great, but her part wasn't so great i agree. she still rocks imo!!

  • totally agree. Miley's voice killed the song completely

  • but you can tell she was having a hard time, her grandpa died of cancer

  • the song was amazing...except for one little flaw..can you guess who the the scratchy voice is?:P

  • who?

  • ok. all these singers are AMAZING vocalist, cept for Miley. She's just good, but in a song like this, she totally ruined it..

  • love this song~ Shakira should have been here too..

  • ohh i love mariah's high part at the end i wish i could hit notes like that :)

  • Christina Aguilera should have been here :O

  • lilbitsugar you go girl i totayaaally again !!

    fuck you you mutha fucking bitches who hate miley!

  • They sang too good together. They should all sing together more often.

  • i love song and miley was so good! i love her part!