all is ash or the light shining through it, the way they played it, and the way they looked when they played it, would be the sole purpose of going to see this show...well, all of their songs are awesome, but the performance along with that song was off the charts.
Aren't all lyrics technically... improv? I mean they just come to people, and it seems hard to put together such great and powerful pieces just off the top of your head in one blow.
Fighting over which member of TSOAF is best, is like asking which member of The Beatles was better.
They are all amazing. They all bring their own special thing into the group. They are part of the only bands so far in the 21st Century to treat music as true art.
And myself as a musician would commit mass genocide for a small amount of creativity that they have.
Don't argue, just enjoy the music. And "Let the music change your mind."
this band threw me to my drums and notebook more than just about every band outside of king crimson, frank zappa, hella and jeff buckley, and a few select others. seeing RX Bandits with h2o in 2000, I would have never expected this. so refreshing to know there are still actual human beings out there expanding their minds and emotions still.
why is this band not known to the rest of the world???? This music is absolutely phenomenal. hands down one of the best performances I have seen by a group of musicians.
@MyWishResigned yea dumb comment. Anthony Green is sweet and all, but RxB is what tears the house down in this band. So I lol of you think Anthony Green is what makes this band teh bomb.
Goddamn...every singer was fucking perfect...drums were so raw...guitars blew my mind more than any other show ever...perfect amount of effects...i wish i could do more than just like, favorite, and comment
Thank you so much for posting this. I was at this concert and didn't even realize they made a dvd. It feels amazing to relive it by watching this. Truly one of the best concert experiences of my life.
craig owens and anthony green. thats great! i dont understand how someone can put that down. this right here is stuff that should be put in a tube and buried for people in the future to listen to.
@burymeinmemoryfob how does this not make sense? simply put: its the greatest performance in fucking history. no show WILL EVER top this. im convinced.
@ivoryline13 idk where you got that from. they aren't improvisation, they have three albums with the same lyrics they sing on here. my guess is anthony green wrote a lot of the lyrics, he seems to be the mastermind of a lot of this
seriously ... craig ruins this almost. he prances around the stage like a self absorbed two year old. and whats with the random hair shake? what the fuck is that? and i mean.... he is seriously flat with his "singing"
I've been watching this video for about six months now, and everytime I come back I expect the viewers to sky rocket, yet it is still so underviewed. I love it. Great DVD. Appreciate it ivory.
@paulerxx 1. "The Heretic (a cappella)" 2. "Act I: Chasing Suns" 3. "Act II: All is Ash or the Light Shining Through It" 4. "Act III: Modulate Back to the Tonic" 5. "Un'aria" 6. "Skullflower" 7. "My Horse Must Lose" 8. "Horses in the Sky" 9. "Stockhausen, es ist Ihr Gehirn, das ich Suche" 10. "This Heat" 11. "Act IV: You Don't Need A Witness"
just bought this bad boy....I wish i could have seen a live show. The DvD is still amazing. One of the best live bands i've seen. It's tough to fine bands that have amazing lyrics and still know how to play music. Their songs have a whole lot of meaning and are amazing. Tryin to figure out what lyric i want tatted on me....hero's
ahh thank u so much i was thinkin about watchin it on youtube but i thought hmm i dont think ne one would upload this an dam i guess u did thanks so much once again
I think people misunderstand this group.. if you come expecting to hear the verse-chorus-verse-chorus bullshit you hear on the radio, then you will of course be disappointed..
I dont even consider this a band.. i consider it a group of ARTISTS.. truly open, free, creative and inspiring artists, coming together to produce a colorful canvas of sounds..
@TOOLaree I come to this video to get away from the ABABCB form of most bad music. (Not that all music played on the radio is bad). It's a great, inspirational forum for songwriters and musicians and artists in any form of the word.
@TOOLaree the thing that i think that you dont understand is bands like tool and the mars volta and this band and rush or pink floyd. all of those bands basically are using ABABCB structure, theres just a lot of little tid bits to throw the listener off. and of course the C changes. but if you are truly analyzing any piece of music im aware of, thats all it is.
@chrisdawg002 Id have to say that it is all in how you listen and respect the music. I am NOT a musician, I am a visual artist. I know very little about the technical aspects of music, and I don't have a great desire to learn. I, however, was RAISED on music. My parents "religion" is music (1000's of albums, 1000's of tapes and almost a 1000 CD's and they've only started collecting them a few years ago. Obsessed, with all genres of music) I have a deep respect for lyrically rich music,
.... and music with metaphor, imagery, and especially music that incorporates visual art. This music goes way beyond ABABCB and has a conceptual and imaginative approach to it. You could pick up a green day song and say its a bit lacking, but this is music made by artists and poets, not by corporate made stars who sing pre-made songs. And if you haven't researched Tool's technicality in its music then you need to freshen your mind, they use Fibonacci's sequence and mathematical
this is possibly the most ignorant comment ive ever read on youtube. your a disgrace to any fan of music. not just this music. i can't even begin to comprehend your stupidity much less lack of musical understanding. If you had any type of a brain cell you would notice what great musicians this group is comprised of instead of wasting my time. next time you even have a thought in that tiny head of yours you should let it go because its not even worth the effort it took for you to come up with it
so little comments cuz no one can believe this shit is up. fuck yeah!!! this is fuckin talent right here. real music. no fake shit. just playing real shit that you made up. nocopy cat crap
The Sound of Bert And Ernie. <3
Walesasync 5 days ago 2
can anybody tell me which rich is reading
SDNBOfficial 1 month ago
@SDNBOfficial
In ACT III: Modulate Back to Tonic, Rich reads an excerpt from "Peter Pan". Chapter 4, if I remember correctly.
MsMchance 4 weeks ago
the other singer for the first song is craig owens or..?
hardyrulez96 1 month ago
how do i get the download to work?
hardyrulez96 1 month ago
@hardyrulez96 kill SOPA
Hernandezzy09 1 month ago
Matt Embree can fucking shred. Holy hell.
FondlingReply 1 month ago
HOLY MOTHER OF GOD....this is the most amazing live show i've every seen
KY4MTB 2 months ago
Just watched it again for what must be the 50th time.. Just as mind-blowing as the first!
TOOLaree 2 months ago
11:01 BERT AND ERNIE.
attheparadox 2 months ago
Thanx for posting ha. Yea that bert always stands out to me. I can't decide if its the coolest or lamest thing ha
Ramontf3 2 months ago
@Ramontf3 Coolest. Easily.
terps10892 2 months ago
anyone else see bert?
tsmap88 3 months ago
Comment removed
henriquelaterza 4 months ago
Thank you for posting this! This performance is amazing.
chrismonte8 4 months ago
The guy with the cane is rich balling right? I'm curious. has he always had it?
2113TheCrowing2113 4 months ago
@2113TheCrowing2113
He doesn't actually need the cane, it was just for theatrics I think, haha.
TheChexer1231 4 months ago
@2113TheCrowing2113 Coheed fan? ;) I kid, long live The Fence.
jaket32025 4 months ago in playlist jaket32025's favorites
@jaket32025 once a child of the fence always a child of the fence :)
2113TheCrowing2113 4 months ago
Thanks for uploading! The DVD is kinda hard to find & expensive as shit, on top of that. Thanks again!
ajandairwaves 4 months ago in playlist The Sound of Animals Fighting
craig's shirt says "mr. perfect" but he's half a step flat on every note he sings
TheChexer1231 5 months ago
@TheChexer1231 Heresy.
jaket32025 4 months ago in playlist jaket32025's favorites
all is ash or the light shining through it, the way they played it, and the way they looked when they played it, would be the sole purpose of going to see this show...well, all of their songs are awesome, but the performance along with that song was off the charts.
TheChexer1231 5 months ago
What's with this dude having a Chelsea girl haircut
chriswrigley 5 months ago
is the guy with with the cain bon iver ??
zjblair 5 months ago
I totally had tickets to this show that they recorded this at and my F**king work screwed me over and I couldnt attend. I was so upset!
emoufyourlife 5 months ago
My face melted for like the 8th time at 37:05-37:50
YonatanWeiss1 6 months ago
who is the guy reading from the peter pan book and what band is he from?
XxStayXPositive 7 months ago
Comment removed
TheChexer1231 7 months ago
Comment removed
TheChexer1231 7 months ago
Now THAT is a fucking musical!
Kevron81 8 months ago
So this group shows how great these musicians are? Si o si lol
Faoshao 8 months ago
i saw this dvd going for 100 bucks,
everymoss09 9 months ago
@everymoss09 i bought this dvd for 5 bucks at warped tour 07 lol
WradProductions 7 months ago
@everymoss09 lol wtf i bought it online for 10 dollars like 2 months ago
Juturna67 5 months ago
@Juturna67 can you send me the link? i got mine from ebay for 35 bucks with shipping
everymoss09 5 months ago
@Juturna67 I bought it from interpunk. I can't post links so just google interpunk and it should be the first website
Juturna67 5 months ago
Anthony Green could kill my family and I would still love him so much.
Phabulouso 9 months ago
the best i've ever seen anthony perform, for sure (although he's always amazing). the bandits went crazy here too.
canthinkverywell 9 months ago
Rx bandits broke up:( If you love these guys go buy some RX Cds and see them this summer for their last tour.
acidsould 10 months ago
@acidsould Not yet! They still have some soul left in them damn it!
TwigPunter 9 months ago
Now that you like this band... Buy the DVD.
BG2071 11 months ago
Is that Keith Goodwin at the 22 minute mark?
SunBrother89 11 months ago
i need the dvd NOW
SUMM3RSN0WFL4K3 11 months ago
me da piel de gallina, no contengo las ganas de ponerme a tocar cada vez q los escucho son bestias hermosas
diegoallimite10 11 months ago
I NEED THIS FUCKIN' DVD
AND ALL OF THEIR FUCKIN' ALBUMS GOD DAMMIT
MelodicParanoia 1 year ago
Aren't all lyrics technically... improv? I mean they just come to people, and it seems hard to put together such great and powerful pieces just off the top of your head in one blow.
ANYWAY this is great!
frigginidiot 1 year ago
what are the effects they are using from 18:00 through about the start of Act III?
glassarrows09 1 year ago
Does anyone know what book he is reading from at around 21 minutes? id appreciate if someone could get back
XxStayXPositive 1 year ago
@XxStayXPositive peter pan
glassarrows09 1 year ago
@XxStayXPositive it's Peter Pan
shaneb4200 1 year ago
@XxStayXPositive it's Peter Pan
shaneb4200 1 year ago
Man, you're the only one who has the whole thing...why!? :O And for this reason, I subscribe to you good sir/lady!
jomak222 1 year ago
Fighting over which member of TSOAF is best, is like asking which member of The Beatles was better.
They are all amazing. They all bring their own special thing into the group. They are part of the only bands so far in the 21st Century to treat music as true art.
And myself as a musician would commit mass genocide for a small amount of creativity that they have.
Don't argue, just enjoy the music. And "Let the music change your mind."
R0bbieR0tton 1 year ago 2
orgasmic!
DE0DOX 1 year ago
Whose the guy in thebeginning?
DisasterCode 1 year ago
@DisasterCode
matthew kelly
ivoryline13 1 year ago
@ivoryline13 wait if thats mathew kelly, then whose the guy with the cane?
NerfJr 3 months ago
@NerfJr Rich Balling
SuckerpunchHilstrand 3 months ago
@NerfJr Rich Balling originally of the RX Bandits. He quit due to I beleive spinal degeneration and then started this project up.
Bhillbo 2 months ago
Comment removed
starpinkjanet 4 months ago
hahaha 10:30 anthony green. lmfao
TDSNinja 1 year ago 2
This is the best concert video ever. I feel like someone just had sex with my mind.
squarefred1983 1 year ago
I actually watched this whole thing in my iPhone. :P
Loved it.
Anthony Green and Keith Goodwin are the shit. :)
SenOnerCTK 1 year ago
@MyWishResigned whatever floats your boat yo. I personally like keith goodwins voice
hackskillz1 1 year ago
this band threw me to my drums and notebook more than just about every band outside of king crimson, frank zappa, hella and jeff buckley, and a few select others. seeing RX Bandits with h2o in 2000, I would have never expected this. so refreshing to know there are still actual human beings out there expanding their minds and emotions still.
stevestjamesprogram 1 year ago
why is this band not known to the rest of the world???? This music is absolutely phenomenal. hands down one of the best performances I have seen by a group of musicians.
bgreen280 1 year ago 2
@bgreen280
Anthony green is what make this so phenomenal
I'd like you better if you were related to such a sexy Green <3
MyWishResigned 1 year ago
@MyWishResigned yea dumb comment. Anthony Green is sweet and all, but RxB is what tears the house down in this band. So I lol of you think Anthony Green is what makes this band teh bomb.
hackskillz1 1 year ago
@hackskillz1 i hear that homie. i just think he's sexy.
MyWishResigned 1 year ago
@hackskillz1 sexy.
MyWishResigned 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheChexer1231 8 months ago
"you'll be the last people to ever see this" :,(
not cool Anthony not cool
PLAY MORE SHOWS!!!!
crago121 1 year ago
this is the first time i watched the whole thing..fucking amazing. i wish they'd play again i'd rather go to that show than any other.
stormydaykids 1 year ago
21:50 Is my favorite TSOAF part in any song. RX Bandits are da shit.
hackskillz1 1 year ago
this is maybe the most brilliant thing i have ever seen
though craig owens doesn't sing that well
i've been thinking about doing creative stuff like they do with my band, that would be awesome
you guys are my inspiration
jakkefriet 1 year ago
27:35
drummer is chiilllin
GraffitiAmerica897 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you like this, than check out THE SOUND ARCHIVES, they have a similar vibe...
LGfreak555 1 year ago
lol @ 10:30
h003jmx 1 year ago
Goddamn...every singer was fucking perfect...drums were so raw...guitars blew my mind more than any other show ever...perfect amount of effects...i wish i could do more than just like, favorite, and comment
BRADvsBR4D 1 year ago
Oh, i didnt think i was about to watch a mars volta concert with fringed indy kids.
666TWeeK666 1 year ago
Just under 5k views? What's wrong with people?
AgowTisro 1 year ago
i cant believe it took me this long to find this group. turned my head around...& then chopped it off haha
slowVybe 1 year ago
24:22 is seriously frightening, and not in a good way. However, 36:21 is pure gold. :)
matttattack 1 year ago
Thank you so much for posting this. I was at this concert and didn't even realize they made a dvd. It feels amazing to relive it by watching this. Truly one of the best concert experiences of my life.
lachkinazi 1 year ago
craig owens and anthony green. thats great! i dont understand how someone can put that down. this right here is stuff that should be put in a tube and buried for people in the future to listen to.
bigtpackersfan 1 year ago
omg .. i don't really listen to craig owens that much, but dude, he is like really over-the-top .. and he has a feminine frame!
miraclesunx3 1 year ago
this is gold:D
beerisyummyyumyum 1 year ago
theres a reason nobody watches this. it doesnt make sense at all
burymeinmemoryfob 1 year ago
@burymeinmemoryfob how does this not make sense? simply put: its the greatest performance in fucking history. no show WILL EVER top this. im convinced.
rocktheflare 1 year ago
btw curious question?? who do ya think wrote all these lyrics?
05ilikepie 1 year ago
@05ilikepie
No one wrote them. All lyrics from this band are improvisation, excluding 'The Ocean And The Sun.'
ivoryline13 1 year ago
@ivoryline13 idk where you got that from. they aren't improvisation, they have three albums with the same lyrics they sing on here. my guess is anthony green wrote a lot of the lyrics, he seems to be the mastermind of a lot of this
dropdeadjoe 1 year ago 6
@dropdeadjoe
The show isn't improv, but in the making of the album, it was.
And Rich Balling is the mastermind
ivoryline13 1 year ago 13
@ivoryline13 genius mastermind. good lord, i could listen to these songs forever
AckAttack77 1 year ago
@ivoryline13
you're both wrong.
the group is entirely made up of masterminds
TheChexer1231 5 months ago
@dropdeadjoe this is such a large collaborative effort. no one is really the mastermind dumbass.
keatonious 1 year ago
@dropdeadjoe
thats for sure...
OspinaPhotography 10 months ago
Comment removed
xbrandati0nx 5 months ago
@05ilikepie its collaborative. songs are written by different people on different songs
rocktheflare 1 year ago
seriously ... craig ruins this almost. he prances around the stage like a self absorbed two year old. and whats with the random hair shake? what the fuck is that? and i mean.... he is seriously flat with his "singing"
sothisisakward 1 year ago
@sothisisakward couldn't agree more. This also isn't the group of guys you should try to act 'cool' around.
matttattack 1 year ago
this dvd is like, the most epic shit i have ever seen.
everyone's a badass and loving the shit out of the show,
the crowds so calm and quiets down for them.
they make such a great atmosphere..
made. :(
sputniksicles 1 year ago 2
one of the few bands to give me goose bumps listening to them. this is excellence.
shortys2004 1 year ago
Thank you so much.
YoungKizzy28 1 year ago
Who's the guy with the cane?
xian67 1 year ago
@xian67 Rich Balling; former member of Rx Bandits
ivoryline13 1 year ago
@ivoryline13 Why does he need a cane? What happened to him?
xian67 1 year ago
thanks for uploading this, pure magic. This has given me so many ideas!
richiebarr 1 year ago
Thanks for uploading this :)
Jamesastonn 1 year ago
pure gold!
wtelmark 1 year ago
Comment removed
lukedemers 1 year ago
I've been watching this video for about six months now, and everytime I come back I expect the viewers to sky rocket, yet it is still so underviewed. I love it. Great DVD. Appreciate it ivory.
7hrice 1 year ago 15
who is the singer in the begining?
05ilikepie 2 years ago
Matthew Kelly (from The Autumns)
ivoryline13 2 years ago
can someone plz list the songs names in order for me?
paulerxx 2 years ago
@paulerxx 1. "The Heretic (a cappella)" 2. "Act I: Chasing Suns" 3. "Act II: All is Ash or the Light Shining Through It" 4. "Act III: Modulate Back to the Tonic" 5. "Un'aria" 6. "Skullflower" 7. "My Horse Must Lose" 8. "Horses in the Sky" 9. "Stockhausen, es ist Ihr Gehirn, das ich Suche" 10. "This Heat" 11. "Act IV: You Don't Need A Witness"
SafiLevina 2 years ago 6
thanks
paulerxx 2 years ago
i love you for posting this<3
S1W2E3D 2 years ago
anyways, how'd you upload the whole thing
stratocastermaster2 2 years ago
I have a director's account.
ivoryline13 2 years ago
i love this dvd
stratocastermaster2 2 years ago
just bought this bad boy....I wish i could have seen a live show. The DvD is still amazing. One of the best live bands i've seen. It's tough to fine bands that have amazing lyrics and still know how to play music. Their songs have a whole lot of meaning and are amazing. Tryin to figure out what lyric i want tatted on me....hero's
momace2005 2 years ago
where did you buy this at cuz i cant find it anywhere
chucker2131 2 years ago
whats the name of the first song or intro???
arasgeme 2 years ago
The Heretic (A cappella)
ivoryline13 2 years ago
love it :D
just finished watching it
was awesome!
davidc182 2 years ago
the amount of times i've watched this dvd in my life can compare to the amount of times i have blinked. yes. very yes.
CaptainAwesome4458 2 years ago
I love you.
Bassmastajazzyj 2 years ago 2
Omfg! amazing
Lmao... Bert and Ernie join Craig in the crowd at 39:40.. I was busting up
NickJungle 2 years ago 4
as always
ivoryline13 2 years ago
ahh thank u so much i was thinkin about watchin it on youtube but i thought hmm i dont think ne one would upload this an dam i guess u did thanks so much once again
AMPS1999 2 years ago
I think people misunderstand this group.. if you come expecting to hear the verse-chorus-verse-chorus bullshit you hear on the radio, then you will of course be disappointed..
I dont even consider this a band.. i consider it a group of ARTISTS.. truly open, free, creative and inspiring artists, coming together to produce a colorful canvas of sounds..
<3
TOOLaree 2 years ago 45
@TOOLaree couldn't have said it better myself.
EddietehFace 1 year ago
@TOOLaree I come to this video to get away from the ABABCB form of most bad music. (Not that all music played on the radio is bad). It's a great, inspirational forum for songwriters and musicians and artists in any form of the word.
AgowTisro 1 year ago
@TOOLaree the thing that i think that you dont understand is bands like tool and the mars volta and this band and rush or pink floyd. all of those bands basically are using ABABCB structure, theres just a lot of little tid bits to throw the listener off. and of course the C changes. but if you are truly analyzing any piece of music im aware of, thats all it is.
chrisdawg002 1 year ago
@chrisdawg002 Id have to say that it is all in how you listen and respect the music. I am NOT a musician, I am a visual artist. I know very little about the technical aspects of music, and I don't have a great desire to learn. I, however, was RAISED on music. My parents "religion" is music (1000's of albums, 1000's of tapes and almost a 1000 CD's and they've only started collecting them a few years ago. Obsessed, with all genres of music) I have a deep respect for lyrically rich music,
TOOLaree 1 year ago
.... and music with metaphor, imagery, and especially music that incorporates visual art. This music goes way beyond ABABCB and has a conceptual and imaginative approach to it. You could pick up a green day song and say its a bit lacking, but this is music made by artists and poets, not by corporate made stars who sing pre-made songs. And if you haven't researched Tool's technicality in its music then you need to freshen your mind, they use Fibonacci's sequence and mathematical
TOOLaree 1 year ago
combinations and intricate idealism when creating the music, its not as simple as it may seem, it has FORETHOUGHT.
TOOLaree 1 year ago
THANK YOU FOR POSTING THIS
Diepzeetegel 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Biggest group of cocksucking posers i have ever seen, This band is disgraceful to musicians worldwide.
abbsman 2 years ago
They definitely are posers, cause there's SOOO many bands that sound just like this and all...
You're not an idiot for not liking them, just for completely wrongly insulting them.
ivoryline13 2 years ago
yeah dude your fuckin wack as shit
kturn757 2 years ago
this is possibly the most ignorant comment ive ever read on youtube. your a disgrace to any fan of music. not just this music. i can't even begin to comprehend your stupidity much less lack of musical understanding. If you had any type of a brain cell you would notice what great musicians this group is comprised of instead of wasting my time. next time you even have a thought in that tiny head of yours you should let it go because its not even worth the effort it took for you to come up with it
Circafade777 2 years ago 5
THANK YOU!
ProAmPiano 2 years ago
so little comments cuz no one can believe this shit is up. fuck yeah!!! this is fuckin talent right here. real music. no fake shit. just playing real shit that you made up. nocopy cat crap
immasokoo 2 years ago 6
Comment removed
leosforlife 2 years ago
dude, fuck yeah for posting this shit. i never expected to find this, thanks a lot.. this is more than just music
jrf021 2 years ago 3
no problem.
had on my computer for a while
noticed not all the songs were uploaded.
decided to upload the whole thing instead of cutting it up
ivoryline13 2 years ago
absolutely, fucking, amazing. i thank you so much for this.
AV1213 2 years ago 2
why 1 comment?
this shit is fucking beautiful
ivoryline13 2 years ago
thank you so much mate ;)
ViNe2k 2 years ago