Carly Smithson - Crazy On You - Top 20

[malcolmlewis013]

I hated how they sabotaged Carly and Syesha...they were definitely finale-worthy if not top 3.

[cgf1972]

Not that I followed it much to begin with, but I completely quit watching at all after Carly was booted off. What a bunch of popularity contest BS! Simon Cowell is so fortunate to have a job. What the heck has HE ever done? Great performance!

[rodneythemodney]

her pitch!!!! amazing!

[NYYankess8]

AMAZING!!!!!!!

[liz20141]

she sings heart really good! she is just amazing

[ereh70]

Love her from Costa Rica...!!

[chinzebo]

This gal is grand!!!!!!!!

[emilia223]

great she has every single abilty that should of make her winn

[MRD95301]

mrs jackson here. and randy wus just not filling her for a long time on the show. he is always on point but not this season at all

[Maverick1130]

great cover but she could have practiced belting out some of those lyrics a little. i know she could have done it but not quite. still amazing

[OldCartoons2010]

in this video she reminds me of Wednesday from the Adams Family!

[delicatecutter]

Carly never got her props from the judges. She was AMAZIN!

[ohboyitskayla]

Shes amazzzzing!

[Oiraeket]

I just have visions when she hits some of those "crazy on you"s of the other contestants just being like...

"Crap."

[purplemkb]

shut up randy, you suck. it was awesome

[doggy2030]

idk why i <3 this but i do

[RohmeElfbater]

she has everything needed to win this competition: voice, stage presence, the look, charisma; she should've won

[Lawrence2525]

I agree, and she's humble too

[totallyawesome12121]

i wish she could have won...shes amazinnnggg...in my opinion..i think it should have been a carly-cook finale...now THAT would have been competition

[mikey6060]

Loved all of her song choices.

[FM897]

One of the best performances EVER on American Idol!!!!!! That is one TOUGH song and she sang the living daylights out of it!!!!! You go Carly!!!!!!!!

[elrynx2]

I'm Irish ( in heritage)

so no accent =[ haha

[Twihard05117fan]

i love irish accents

[Bookworm246579]

she's absolutely amazing!!! totally should have won

GO IRELAND!!!!!!

[HHGirls]

she gave me a hug

[curlingiron7658]

One of her best performances, and thats saying alot when you're talking about Carly!!!

[jrw0305]

ok so this was when i officially lost respect for randy jackson. there was absolutely nothing pitchy about this WHATSOEVER. clearly the producers decided to throw carly under the bus, and this was where it started...

[Bookworm246579]

That's how the song is supossed to be pitchy. Gosh. Everyone is criticized, even you!

[rjs5146]

a song is never meant to be pitchy. u obviously don't know that that word means. songs can be meant to be shouty like this one was supposed to be but when have u ever heard of a singer saying "oh, i wanted to go off key and hit the wrong notes!" never!

[jellwoodis]

@jrw0305 : In the second verse, on the word sang, in "I sang you a song I heard up above" was sharp. Also, the word crazy, in the second "crazy on you" was flat a quarter pitch.

Also, he was a bit raspy at the end when she was belting.

Otherwise, nice overall vocal quality, and I like her whole tone.

[arturesteve]

@jrw0305 I agree, I think it was the first time a non-American was by far the most talented vocalist and deserved to win, but after all...it is American Idol and that might not be completely good for the producers.

[oscarboy94]

she definetly should have been in the top 3 with the two davids

[who4i6am]

carly is the best..i agreed with simon