Very powerful. Attention grabbing. Intense. Beautiful beyond words. Thanks for posting this. The choir director needs to be commended for a great version.
I am in an university choir in dominican republic and i have tried to include this song and this very same arrangement and version in our repertoire without much success because of my director, but now i succeeded we are currently rehearsing this and other songs for a choir festival, and we have only three months to perfect it. And this is by far the best arrangement of this wonderful song. and this is a hell of a nice choir!! congratulations!! from dominican republic
This is a gorgeous arrangement. Does anyone know who arranged this one? And I agree with ShadowKitten13, the emotion makes you want to cry. My chamber choir is singing Paul Basler's arrangment, and it's the most beautiful song we've ever done.
Me too, smallersah. It was 27 years ago, and I am here looking for versions. Remember how awesome the harmonies sounded in the choir room? 'That was always a song we would happily stay late to sing...you?
Although scooping can be an issue in choral music and singing in general, scooping can also be appropriate stylistically-speaking in folk music or gospel music (and more of course). I was impressed by the timbre and intonation of the choir as a whole and especially the little guys. Very bright sounding... and I loved the little bass punch in the end. BTW I am not saying you are wrong, just thought I would throw that idea out there.
Yes, I agree, but in the unison part of the piece at the beginning, I don't think it's very appropriate. They just need to be more careful about the liquid consonants. That's where they're scooping.
watch nyo po ang bago ko'ng upload na video ng lipa choral ensemble sa 2nd Rotary Kantahan sa Pasko 07...mas malinaw po yon at mas maganda ang tunog non...tnx
Bravo! Very, VERY nicely done of the Erb...which I consider the best setting of this folk song. Vocally you are top-notch, and I especially like the sensitive phrasing, and even tone quality, throughout the parts' ranges. Sopranos are just a bit bright, but that's just a personal taste. I'd prefer just a bit of "cover" on the the e's. Your pitch is exquisite, though. Marked this one as a favorite. THANKS!
i love this song. ive played many different arrangements of it as a complete work and as an excerpt in a larger work. every time it brings me goosebumps when we hit the huge minor chord impact point (1.53) in this arrangement. beautiful song....well sang
Beautiful job. This song is supposed to be song with feeling and heart. No part should over power another part. The basses carried the line very well. I could listen to this song all day from its many arrangments.
Acctually in the Jamesa Erb Arragnment...which this one is...the count is only 58-60...which puts it at the right tempo. My concert choir has been performing this since the beginging of the year..and this is actually a little faster then the arrangment calls mor...this is about a 68 count.
Theres like 50 Bajillion arrangements of this song, my chior sang one last year, and were singing tis one this year. im SO happy. its such a pretty song
the de la salle college choir waterford, ireland did this too. it's a different version, its the one that starts off with the 'loo' in two octaves, brilliant.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
beautiful tone, but your filipino accents are showing through, and its a bit distracting. I'd work on grammar and vowels a bit more. Still- very very good tone, especially the men
i think the persons talking about the accent of filipinos.. eventhough we can pronounce the word cleanly.. unlike some races not born in the USA, then eventually learning english, they cant speak english well.. anyways.. the accent.. even in latin songs, you can distinguish if its Filipino.. because of the incorporation of "y" in some words.. like, JUbilate Deo.. Jubilate Deyo.. thats how filipinos would normally sing the song.. i think thats what he's referring to..
My choir sang this last year, and it's an amazing song to sing, it was the first year in a long time that we had more than 2 boys in our class, it was so beautiful and i loved it! great job
Thanks you very mcuh! This is my choir and i am very proud that i'd been singing with them for 4 years. I miss you guys. Hope we can sing this song together again ONE HEART, ONE MIND, ONE VOICE! ANIMO DE LA SALLE VOICES!!
huhuhu... kakamiss tuloy mga choirmates ko... we also sung this song... gentong gento din ung arrangement.. tenor 1 ako nun... saya talaga pag choir member kakamiss
Wow the voices are the greatest!!! They are the official choir of our school... i always hear them everytime we have our mass... they really are phenomenal... Animo LA SALLE!!!
My high school choir is performing this song in a few weeks. You guys did a fantastic job on this song, and this is by far the best version of the song out there :-)
Honnêtement, j'ai pleuré quand j'ai entendu la première fois cette chanson, il est très joli, les types ai retenti si rêveur, mêmes avec les filles, comme une voix de ciel.
With voices from across the wide world!
Maritimer2009 22 hours ago
Very powerful. Attention grabbing. Intense. Beautiful beyond words. Thanks for posting this. The choir director needs to be commended for a great version.
huskyjerk 8 months ago in playlist classical music
Magnificent! Kudos all!
cottonswoods 1 year ago
So great, thank you.
califlover49 1 year ago
I am in an university choir in dominican republic and i have tried to include this song and this very same arrangement and version in our repertoire without much success because of my director, but now i succeeded we are currently rehearsing this and other songs for a choir festival, and we have only three months to perfect it. And this is by far the best arrangement of this wonderful song. and this is a hell of a nice choir!! congratulations!! from dominican republic
ecornelio 1 year ago 6
pag pinoy talaga ang pronounce ng "we're" ay "where"... ganyan din ung sa version namin eh... hehehe...
clicheisticSPAZZ 1 year ago
You're relly good guys!!
Thanks for giving us a beautiful performance!!
I enjoyed it veeeeeeeeeery muuuuch ^_^
RoChaEsq 1 year ago 2
just beautiful
Njabuloable 1 year ago
this is a marvelous rendition, well done ")
juvserr 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
our choir is better
and we are in high school
lilloserlindz 1 year ago
@lilloserlindz
Ok Would you post your video please??
Then we can tell you if you guys are better!!!
RoChaEsq 1 year ago
this is the arrangement my high school all state chorus sang. it gave me shivers then and still.
rightbraind77 1 year ago
ang taas ng pitch.
clicheisticSPAZZ 2 years ago
de la salle voices really sang it with magic...
kentz20 2 years ago
This is a gorgeous arrangement. Does anyone know who arranged this one? And I agree with ShadowKitten13, the emotion makes you want to cry. My chamber choir is singing Paul Basler's arrangment, and it's the most beautiful song we've ever done.
BassBunnieGirl 2 years ago
Me too, smallersah. It was 27 years ago, and I am here looking for versions. Remember how awesome the harmonies sounded in the choir room? 'That was always a song we would happily stay late to sing...you?
MommeeMadre 2 years ago
I have never heard this song sung so beautifully, with so much feeling. It is a joy to listen to.
tepenga1 2 years ago 12
wow...pretty amazing
barnsroybarns 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
I hear scooping into notes and not open vowels. x.x
InKeepingSecrets4 2 years ago
By far, the best of the many versions of this song. These singers really convey how it feels to love the land.
4Topwood 2 years ago 19
Thanks for the appreciation!
tattibz4lyf 2 years ago
me gusto buena interpretacion
vazco86 2 years ago 4
aww it brings instant tears to my eyes
ilovewaltdisney 2 years ago 8
we sang this last in our school choir- it was the best song we ever performed!
smallersah 2 years ago
It's nice to hear non-Americans (this group Filipino's) singing and putting much emotion on an American folk song.
alwilliam 2 years ago 22
lol
smartiipantze 2 years ago
I agree, it's beautiful not only because the SONG is beautiful but because you can feel their emotion in it.
ShadowKitten13 2 years ago 11
@alwilliam YES! I agree! Beautiful performance ripe with the longing of everyone to be free!
Maritimer2009 22 hours ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sopranos stopped and the beggining before "and" becuase they cant make nessery space on the breath before singing
jacotubes777 2 years ago
im 12 and im singing this for my grade 2 singing exam next week but in a higher key
JoBroMiley4Evax 2 years ago
Im singing this for festivle this year!
ShikaMatsu1 3 years ago
this is amazing.
So melancholy and beautiful.
ilovemutemath 3 years ago 4
its my first year in middle school and im 11. I'm singing this song for my choir group. this sets very good example for me. thank you
issyme33 3 years ago
wow ive sang this song my senior yr in high school and you guys are amazing the sopranos are awsome and the guys really make the song pop
fatmexican66 3 years ago
I absolutely LOVE the sound quality and the purity of the sound that the Sopranos are producing. It carries the melody so well
TheHappyBunny91 3 years ago
This is one of my absolute favorite pieces of all time. The harmonies are well balanced here and it sounds superb!
BornOfADragon 3 years ago
I wish that they play this at my funeral
it expresses my love the best
BradBaldwintheDrumm 3 years ago
Animo La Salle! We never had this in my time in Taft.
062950 3 years ago
amazing.
AmandaToole 3 years ago
Sang this once in the choir.
hell1to10 3 years ago
I played this in band
countrygurl1992 3 years ago
i love this song!
it's amazing!
Beckamauz 3 years ago 4
wOw!!
it's really amazing..
i'm lovin it!!
yin06281 3 years ago 2
SUSTINE HEFALU
hefalu 3 years ago
Comment removed
utakberde02 3 years ago
Beautiful... I don't know why I'm crying...
LuckyCoyotes 3 years ago 3
our band is playing this..
its amAZING!
heywhatsername92 3 years ago
it so is.
anythingrandom22 3 years ago
it´s just...wOw !!!
supergirlola 3 years ago
my choir is singing this now,
it's the whole classes favorite.
it's amazing.
discopartyditz 3 years ago
i sang this song when i was in 8th grade for a solo. its a great song!
thugnladyj 3 years ago
they need to watch their scooping in the unison parts. But it's pretty well done.
ma3m33 3 years ago 2
Although scooping can be an issue in choral music and singing in general, scooping can also be appropriate stylistically-speaking in folk music or gospel music (and more of course). I was impressed by the timbre and intonation of the choir as a whole and especially the little guys. Very bright sounding... and I loved the little bass punch in the end. BTW I am not saying you are wrong, just thought I would throw that idea out there.
JayCharlesLander 3 years ago 3
Yes, I agree, but in the unison part of the piece at the beginning, I don't think it's very appropriate. They just need to be more careful about the liquid consonants. That's where they're scooping.
ma3m33 3 years ago
I absolutely 100% agree, especially about the bass part. It makes the end of the song.
AdmiralAckbarX2 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
watch nyo po ang bago ko'ng upload na video ng lipa choral ensemble sa 2nd Rotary Kantahan sa Pasko 07...mas malinaw po yon at mas maganda ang tunog non...tnx
mjulius 3 years ago
This is one of the very best songs ever written!
huskyjerk 3 years ago
Were singing this in Choir Class!
doomjr13 3 years ago
Girl need to watch their vowels getting too bright. Even so, this is one of the most beautiful choral performances I've ever heard.
AdmiralAckbarX2 3 years ago 4
thanks!
tattibz4lyf 3 years ago
Bravo! Very, VERY nicely done of the Erb...which I consider the best setting of this folk song. Vocally you are top-notch, and I especially like the sensitive phrasing, and even tone quality, throughout the parts' ranges. Sopranos are just a bit bright, but that's just a personal taste. I'd prefer just a bit of "cover" on the the e's. Your pitch is exquisite, though. Marked this one as a favorite. THANKS!
Bmackkc 3 years ago 3
wow thanks!
tattibz4lyf 3 years ago
galing nyo grabe.... mga idol..
aztig........
especially my teachers......
Ms. Castro and Ms. Pernez
peacheshaha 4 years ago
I absolutely love this arrangement. It is the one I first heard it in, and the one I am currently learning in choir.
I positively love 1:57 to 2:19. My most favorite part.
Onirayushizobura 4 years ago
i love this song. ive played many different arrangements of it as a complete work and as an excerpt in a larger work. every time it brings me goosebumps when we hit the huge minor chord impact point (1.53) in this arrangement. beautiful song....well sang
joshsize89 4 years ago
Beautiful job. This song is supposed to be song with feeling and heart. No part should over power another part. The basses carried the line very well. I could listen to this song all day from its many arrangments.
marchingguy 4 years ago
they made it 2 slow it shud have been up ,ore up beat
markeenanovembre 4 years ago
you're right...but who asked you.............
williewillnick 4 years ago
Can't agree. "Shenandoah" is open to a variety of interpretations and tempi.
The lyrics and minor chords definitely support a slow, melancholy take such as we hear here.
This choral group not only has nice voices but puts a lot of heart into this song.
ElizabethTalbot 4 years ago 4
i agree but they should have made it a little enjoyable im singing dat song in my HONORS CHOIR
markeenanovembre 4 years ago
Again, can't agree. I don't think there is a more enjoyable interpretation of this beautiful song.
ElizabethTalbot 3 years ago
yes we surely put a lot of heart in every song we sing.. thank you very much for appreciating our rendition.
tattibz4lyf 4 years ago 2
thats the way this particular arrangment is made. If you dont like it, stop complaining and go listen to a different arrangment
frubalover112 4 years ago 3
Acctually in the Jamesa Erb Arragnment...which this one is...the count is only 58-60...which puts it at the right tempo. My concert choir has been performing this since the beginging of the year..and this is actually a little faster then the arrangment calls mor...this is about a 68 count.
PsychopathicClowns 4 years ago
Theres like 50 Bajillion arrangements of this song, my chior sang one last year, and were singing tis one this year. im SO happy. its such a pretty song
frubalover112 4 years ago
the de la salle college choir waterford, ireland did this too. it's a different version, its the one that starts off with the 'loo' in two octaves, brilliant.
BrianCr 4 years ago
we're singing this in my choir :)
ddrchick087 4 years ago
Absolutely beautiful--well done!
slatsandflaps 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
beautiful tone, but your filipino accents are showing through, and its a bit distracting. I'd work on grammar and vowels a bit more. Still- very very good tone, especially the men
shortbus90 4 years ago
"Work on grammar"? What are you talking about?
They're singing the lyrics of the song...
lichtarbeiter 4 years ago 5
i think the persons talking about the accent of filipinos.. eventhough we can pronounce the word cleanly.. unlike some races not born in the USA, then eventually learning english, they cant speak english well.. anyways.. the accent.. even in latin songs, you can distinguish if its Filipino.. because of the incorporation of "y" in some words.. like, JUbilate Deo.. Jubilate Deyo.. thats how filipinos would normally sing the song.. i think thats what he's referring to..
guayaboso815 4 years ago 2
i love this song. my school choir sings it all the time and our director always cries
georgebaggy 4 years ago
i have sing this here, in Chile
it was great hear this again..., and be the public one time at last
Thanks ^^
Krolinkko 4 years ago
My choir sang this last year, and it's an amazing song to sing, it was the first year in a long time that we had more than 2 boys in our class, it was so beautiful and i loved it! great job
carmenriots 4 years ago
el trabajo realizado es muy bueno las
voces suenan bellisimas
monoGTmaster 4 years ago
*woops i meant..
"great job!"
KelseyTYo 4 years ago
this is beautiful!!!!! great good!! :)
KelseyTYo 4 years ago 3
this is a gorgeous rendition of the song. Drop a tear to my eye!
bbwaloha83 4 years ago 3
my choir did this song last year .. it was really cool .. it took us forever though cuz it was an 80 person choir but it turned out really good
BrItTaNeEe 4 years ago
i love singing this song
it is just so beautiful
ShahiFriend 4 years ago
Thanks you very mcuh! This is my choir and i am very proud that i'd been singing with them for 4 years. I miss you guys. Hope we can sing this song together again ONE HEART, ONE MIND, ONE VOICE! ANIMO DE LA SALLE VOICES!!
mehdeh24 4 years ago
My choir is learning this song right now. I love it. ^.^ Unfortunately we only have one guy in our choir, so it's only a two part...but still pretty.
Anyways...nicely done. =]
xforeverx 4 years ago
nice performance
see my videos!!!
valiente17cl 4 years ago
huhuhu... kakamiss tuloy mga choirmates ko... we also sung this song... gentong gento din ung arrangement.. tenor 1 ako nun... saya talaga pag choir member kakamiss
khaoz07 4 years ago
Oh man I first heard this by another choir at a competition, it's so beautiful
rahudude250 4 years ago
I first heard this song in one of my uni's choir performances. I got hooked on immediately..
jamesjiao 4 years ago
Great job guys! We performed this in college (a billion years ago) using the EXACT arrangement.
jgaonjr 4 years ago
Was this performed in the Philippines and sung by Filipinos?
paulroman13 4 years ago
this was sung by filipinos but performed in hasselbach, germany...
mintxmark 4 years ago
This past December I did this for a recital, and I sing "second bass."
There are quite a few verses to the piece "Shenandoah."
lonewolf379th 4 years ago
we are playing this in my middle school band class
diggyj 4 years ago
its to friggin easy
froggiekate88 4 years ago
hey no its not its even hard for some collage bands to play!!!!!
diggyj 4 years ago
I sang this for our choir performance.
Zoeoeoeoe 4 years ago
wheew... i really love this song... NICE ONE!!! miss you guyz...
chrisdee1001 4 years ago
one of the greatest spirituals of all time.
thanks.
lenbenhear 4 years ago
I cry EVERY time I hear this song! Very excellent singers, and I love this song! I need to go to the Shenandoah now...
jtinva 4 years ago 2
Shenandoah is a really beautiful piece. This year, we are singing it for our own choir at SHS and it is stuck in our heads!
yoshiroolz2 4 years ago
Amazing!
makuyi 4 years ago
Wow the voices are the greatest!!! They are the official choir of our school... i always hear them everytime we have our mass... they really are phenomenal... Animo LA SALLE!!!
Zen0x 4 years ago 2
wow!!! the sound of the melodic voices took me to the scene of the shenandoah river
Pleshay 4 years ago
My high school choir is performing this song in a few weeks. You guys did a fantastic job on this song, and this is by far the best version of the song out there :-)
ThatguySteveO 5 years ago
thank you very much!
tattibz4lyf 5 years ago
I am Blown away
babs2k3 5 years ago
Very
Very
Very
GOOD!!!!
astig!!!!
gerald031790 5 years ago
Very Good!
shavone1 5 years ago
LilZuela11 said: (in English)
In English:
Honestly, I cried when I heard the first time this song, it is very pretty, the types resounded if dreamer, same with the girls, like a voice of sky.
mintxmark 5 years ago
¡El dios esto es triste y bastante!
LilZuela11 5 years ago
Honnêtement, j'ai pleuré quand j'ai entendu la première fois cette chanson, il est très joli, les types ai retenti si rêveur, mêmes avec les filles, comme une voix de ciel.
LilZuela11 5 years ago
i sang this song with my choir 8 years ago, and i never heard of it again. Thanks for posting this!!!
krazy05 5 years ago
My own choir is singing this version of the song, but even as the best in our school, we are NOTHING compared to this group. Great interpretation!
linsungo 5 years ago
'kay, I had no idea this was a professional group :P Of course they'd be so much better :P
linsungo 5 years ago
we are not a professional choir. we just sing from our hearts!
tattibz4lyf 5 years ago 2
I love this version, it's so beautiful!
JogaOhio 5 years ago
Thank you very much!
tattibz4lyf 5 years ago
this is beauitful, my choir sung this song a few years back but i must admit you all are better.
tooterada 5 years ago
thanks for your comment.
tattibz4lyf 5 years ago
I went to Shenandoah every week with my Hiking Group. Singing cardinal bird! Sound of Waterfalling! It is a beoutiful mountain. I hear you....
simonleevideo 5 years ago