Elway because he was fun to watch, you never turned off a Denver game with Elway when it was 4th quarter with 5:00 on the clock and they were down 10 points because you would find out later that Elway pulled it off and won the game.
John Elway is a dick towards the Colts because if he wasn't traded he would have gone to the Arena Football League, but Peyton didn't care where he landed so he could just play football. So Peyton is better.
@IndyB25 I know its your opinion but how does that make him better than Elway cuz he didn't want to be drafted on that team and he was going to the MLB to play for the Yankees cuz he didn't like how the coach treated his players matter the fact the coach is not even memorble i think his name was Frank kush and the team sucked big time it would have took atleast 5-6 yrs for that team to be a contender thats the only reason he didn't go there and plus Elway Lagacy is just as good as Peyton's.
@IndyB25 And i know this is thing with comparing QB's with how many rings they got and that dies not matteuper bowl cuz of the great cabiler of the different players over the years but Elway is the only QB in history to lead his team to 5 super bowls with a shitty team against all the those super teams just like lebron james did with the cavs just a fact its your opinion i just wanted to know how he was better than Elway but Manning is a great QB but to me he's not Elway yet but he is close.
@Thekingpac2014 Yeah, true, but ya know, I mean come on, if your gonna be a true football player you shouldn't be a spoiled brat and want to be traded from the team you were drafted from....but Elway is pretty damn good.
@IndyB25 Yeah i get what your saying he did kinda cry about it he would been great with the Colts it may have took the same amount of time it did with Denver but who knows in another timeline he may had 2or3 rings with the Colts and i wasn't trying to be funny with you or nothing i just wanted to know why but i do get what you are saying 100% Terry Bradshaw was disliking him about how he didn't play for the Colts which is to me hating a little bit at first but he might have not handle it right.
Elway wins...right now, but there are chapters to play out. Manning must tie Elways wins and must win another Super bowl. I think he goes to 2 more bowls and wins one...but he won't match the career season wins. Manning will get the yards and TD's over Elway but it's all about the career wins to me. Why do they play the game afterall?
I give Peyton his credit. Great qb of his era. But stats are not everything. Elway was one of the best clutch qbs in the game. In a last min effort id go john all the way. He could always pull something out of the hat. Plus he had great leadership qualities and was solid as a rock. So my pick obviously goes to Elway.
This is nooo freakin comparison. John Elway dominates Peyton. NFL Network doesn't lie. Look at top 10 clutch quarterbacks. Manning is not even on the list. John Elway is number 2. We all know that number 1 goes to Joe Montana. GO BRONCOS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This is just stupid if you ask me first off comparing stats don't mean shit elway never had a good team untill the end of his career. Manning has much more talent around him. They are both great qb's elway is in the hall of fame and manning will also be someday. Neither one is better than the other they will both go down in nfl history as one of the best to ever play the game.
I like how everyone says Elway is better(not really). Manning is only 34 years old and he has surpassed all of Elway's stats. Including a superbowl. Manning was 30 when he won his first, Elway was 37. Manning has won 4 MVP's already, Elway only 1 in his career. Come one you do the math. Who is clearly the better QB?
@Thedearster Lived in different times. Elway lived in the time were football was actually a sport. What i mean by that is people played it because they loved it not for money. And Elway didnt have a surrounding team like Manning has had until the end of his career.
dat piece of shit mannjng aint got elway ability!!!!!elway wuz a very good scrambler.. good passer...n caught passes n blocked 2!!!!!!! aint no comparison!!!!!
Good team, I want Manning. So-so team, I want Elway. The Broncos became a perennial powerhouse in the NFL because of Elway, they never would have gotten anywhere without him. Both are awesome though, my top 3 are Marino, Elway, and Manning.
You rate quarterbacks by their Superbowl wins. Leadership is a part of being the best. So obviously, Peyton isn't the best. Elway was a magician, few quarterback are magicians. But to be honest, I think Montana is the greatest.
@courtneyfriel No you don't. If you do it that way, then you can say backup Qbs who were on Superbowl winning teams, who only for instance passed 1,000 yds in their career are one of the best Qbs in history. You don't judge a QB off of superbowls.
Elway because he was fun to watch, you never turned off a Denver game with Elway when it was 4th quarter with 5:00 on the clock and they were down 10 points because you would find out later that Elway pulled it off and won the game.
f00bar451 1 month ago
ELWAY ALL THE WAY!!!
redhead5150 6 months ago
John Elway is a dick towards the Colts because if he wasn't traded he would have gone to the Arena Football League, but Peyton didn't care where he landed so he could just play football. So Peyton is better.
IndyB25 6 months ago
@IndyB25 I know its your opinion but how does that make him better than Elway cuz he didn't want to be drafted on that team and he was going to the MLB to play for the Yankees cuz he didn't like how the coach treated his players matter the fact the coach is not even memorble i think his name was Frank kush and the team sucked big time it would have took atleast 5-6 yrs for that team to be a contender thats the only reason he didn't go there and plus Elway Lagacy is just as good as Peyton's.
Thekingpac2014 6 months ago
@IndyB25 And i know this is thing with comparing QB's with how many rings they got and that dies not matteuper bowl cuz of the great cabiler of the different players over the years but Elway is the only QB in history to lead his team to 5 super bowls with a shitty team against all the those super teams just like lebron james did with the cavs just a fact its your opinion i just wanted to know how he was better than Elway but Manning is a great QB but to me he's not Elway yet but he is close.
Thekingpac2014 6 months ago
@Thekingpac2014 Yeah, true, but ya know, I mean come on, if your gonna be a true football player you shouldn't be a spoiled brat and want to be traded from the team you were drafted from....but Elway is pretty damn good.
IndyB25 6 months ago
@IndyB25 Yeah i get what your saying he did kinda cry about it he would been great with the Colts it may have took the same amount of time it did with Denver but who knows in another timeline he may had 2or3 rings with the Colts and i wasn't trying to be funny with you or nothing i just wanted to know why but i do get what you are saying 100% Terry Bradshaw was disliking him about how he didn't play for the Colts which is to me hating a little bit at first but he might have not handle it right.
Thekingpac2014 6 months ago
@Thekingpac2014 Exactly. If he handled it like a true gent he'd be better.
IndyB25 6 months ago
@IndyB25 Yupp if he had done that he my have been higher than top 5 like in the top 2 next to montana atleast.
Thekingpac2014 6 months ago
yah i like elway.
Kenny42581 7 months ago
Elway aint got shit on peyton
samscreed 8 months ago
@samscreed Other than one more Super Bowl ring and the ability to perform in the clutch.
JBott7 5 months ago
@JBott7 that sounds like everything to me.
Intellijosh 5 months ago
Elway wins...right now, but there are chapters to play out. Manning must tie Elways wins and must win another Super bowl. I think he goes to 2 more bowls and wins one...but he won't match the career season wins. Manning will get the yards and TD's over Elway but it's all about the career wins to me. Why do they play the game afterall?
TheBrevo 9 months ago
not a good contest. sorry
Deovindice2001 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
John Elway is better because he was one oft he best qb in history
TheSuperbroncos4life 1 year ago
John Elway is better because he was one ofthe best qb in history
TheSuperbroncos4life 1 year ago
John Elway for sure!
caspianb132 1 year ago
I give Peyton his credit. Great qb of his era. But stats are not everything. Elway was one of the best clutch qbs in the game. In a last min effort id go john all the way. He could always pull something out of the hat. Plus he had great leadership qualities and was solid as a rock. So my pick obviously goes to Elway.
Pyrian12 1 year ago
Ridiculous comparsion, John Elway always!
adrmaieski 1 year ago
This is nooo freakin comparison. John Elway dominates Peyton. NFL Network doesn't lie. Look at top 10 clutch quarterbacks. Manning is not even on the list. John Elway is number 2. We all know that number 1 goes to Joe Montana. GO BRONCOS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
gmoney0596 1 year ago
@gmoney0596 No number 1 goes to John elway. he has more comebacks. 34.
wDoucheCanoe 1 year ago
PEYTON MANNING
Dgenerationxboyz 1 year ago
This is just stupid if you ask me first off comparing stats don't mean shit elway never had a good team untill the end of his career. Manning has much more talent around him. They are both great qb's elway is in the hall of fame and manning will also be someday. Neither one is better than the other they will both go down in nfl history as one of the best to ever play the game.
HunterCO1 1 year ago
I like how everyone says Elway is better(not really). Manning is only 34 years old and he has surpassed all of Elway's stats. Including a superbowl. Manning was 30 when he won his first, Elway was 37. Manning has won 4 MVP's already, Elway only 1 in his career. Come one you do the math. Who is clearly the better QB?
Thedearster 1 year ago
@Thedearster Lived in different times. Elway lived in the time were football was actually a sport. What i mean by that is people played it because they loved it not for money. And Elway didnt have a surrounding team like Manning has had until the end of his career.
wDoucheCanoe 1 year ago
TD : Interception ratio for Elway wasn't too flattering. I say Manning.
sharktrinity 1 year ago
@sharktrinity Win vs. loss ratio for Elway was very flattering. I say Elway
JBott7 5 months ago
dat piece of shit mannjng aint got elway ability!!!!!elway wuz a very good scrambler.. good passer...n caught passes n blocked 2!!!!!!! aint no comparison!!!!!
NASTYMUTHAFUCKA303 1 year ago
Good team, I want Manning. So-so team, I want Elway. The Broncos became a perennial powerhouse in the NFL because of Elway, they never would have gotten anywhere without him. Both are awesome though, my top 3 are Marino, Elway, and Manning.
tiruoygat2424 1 year ago
regular season manning stats wise was good.
post season elway is greater.
mastshke 1 year ago
well before the broncos john elway was originally the colts quarterback... so impossible. but im more of a colts fan... GO COLTS!!!
mindycoll3278 2 years ago
@mindycoll3278 yeah ur team drafted him.....but elway wanted 2 be a stallion not no mare!!!!!!!! go broncoz!!!!!!!!
NASTYMUTHAFUCKA303 1 year ago
thats right ... manning is better than the stinky old nonno
greatone55 2 years ago
sorry but you left out the greatest DAN MARINO but 2 choose between them John Elway
JtownCobrasBRan 2 years ago
im a denver fan myself, go denver! both of these quarterbacks are my faves, top 2 qbs hands down. cant choose between them
mitchgz123 2 years ago
You rate quarterbacks by their Superbowl wins. Leadership is a part of being the best. So obviously, Peyton isn't the best. Elway was a magician, few quarterback are magicians. But to be honest, I think Montana is the greatest.
courtneyfriel 2 years ago
@courtneyfriel No you don't. If you do it that way, then you can say backup Qbs who were on Superbowl winning teams, who only for instance passed 1,000 yds in their career are one of the best Qbs in history. You don't judge a QB off of superbowls.
Thedearster 1 year ago
ELWAY R U KIDDING peyton got game but elway comes out to the top
nuggetsfan1507 2 years ago 3
they are both amazing and top 10 all time but peyton is better
steelerfanrocks 2 years ago
Manning is Great, but Elway was the best
icarusxx7 2 years ago 4
ovisouly peyotn manning he is the bestqb of all time
anujaphilip 2 years ago
i am a colts fan, but im not sure who. GO COLTS!
TheCBCStudios 2 years ago
i am a huge colts fan sice i was 3 so im going to pick the best qb of all time peyton manning
kniyjfg 2 years ago