The Bad: Looks like all work was put into syncing and nothing else. No noteworthy editing, nothing that'd make you remember the AMV except maybe for the song.
The Ridiculous: Narcism should best be kept to oneself and your description oozes of it. If this was a true piece of art it might be overlooked, but uploading a "good to okay-ish" AMV and acting like a prodigy is just weird. Still not thumbing down since the vid itself wouldn't deserve it though.
I like the way this amv flows, though I personally could see a few more transitions in some areas. I'm more inclined to the over-used crap you spoke of, just because I like amvs that seem like someone really thought about all the possiblities that could be placed in a single measure of music, but that's my opinion. You accomplished the story you wanted to tell, but I could have done without your ego. Yes there are a lot of crap amvs out there, but not every one that uses an over-used song is bad
Great song choice. This was emotional and well done. My favorite part was when you cut back and forth between Spike and Julia both falling. I like that duality a lot. Very meaningful and foreshadowing. Props for making this about a few characters and not all of them. It made it more effective.
why would i mix the episodes that much? it tells a story from those 4 episodes. my purpose was to not be a mishmash of clips like everyone else does. it was to showcase the love story with a song that fit. and draw on the parallels of spikes downfall, with him falling out the window and accepting his own fate confronting his past. I mixed accordingly with what i wanted to do.
@jbc429 to make it your creation. all you did was tell the exact same story Cowboy Bebop already told. but no biggie, just two editors with differing opinions lol
really well done, along with some music that makes you actually want to see the video. nice timing, and as said before, a good story. all of this comes together is a really awesome amv! congrats on such a great video!
yes, "certain anime", but not this. a majority of fans clearly misunderstand this to be more of an "action blow em up series" but its truly nothing but a heavily developed drama incorporating incredibly detailed backdrops, foreshadowing & resolution on each of it's independent members of the cast as a "whole story/epic". further review of watanabe's influence on the series and cast even describes it as such. to tag any piece of this with a "linkin park style" would, truly, be a slap in the face.
these are some overused clips. i've never made an AMV, but i didn't even WANT to like this one from the beginning just because your info comments seem kind of egotistical and smug.
all the clips i used were to help tell the main story between the three characters. i dont just throw them in cause they look good like other people do. i wanted it to make sense on its own and pay tribute to the series as opposed to just showcasing clips with a random shitty song. not only that, i tried timing it with beats, snare, crash, and toms the best i could with what was playing in each clip. if it comes off smug its cause i hate shitty AMV's and youtube is cluttered with them.
Mainly I think it comes across as smug because you are kind of a prick, but who am I to argue with results. The amv has depth, but it doesnt really hook the viewer. Someone has to be in the mood for this kind of amv for it to be enjoyable. I do, however, have to respect the fact that you didn't limp through a poor quality production with the typical flashy content that is flooding the Tube. Just as an after thought, dont bash a band in the info tab, it's pretty tacky, your amv speaks for itself
thanks man. i watched the two you made as well. They're awesome. It's good to see others not just slap music and clips together and not put effort into it.
This is the worst AMV that I've ever watched. I watch AMV's all day long, and the one's with LiNkIn pArk are the sicccccest. As tall as tigers?! who the eff is that shitty band? The timing is so off, you should make it look like they're singing the words. You're probably some long haired comic reader who games on wii in his parents basement!!!!!!!!%#%#@%@
u just said u watch amv's all day long so you must be some fat fuck, pale faced douche who's got chapped dick from jerkin it all day & night in a locked, dark ass room to anime chicks. if you have any idea what your even talkin about, which u obviously dont, you'd know that the entire storyline backdrop behind the cowboy bebop saga was more sad than happy. song fits perfectly and its a creative twist to the gay cliche of linkin park bein added to every fuckin amv out there! ur an idiot.
uh yeah, dude, im a concept artist/animator, thats what i do for a living. ive seen thousands of kids vids like this and all and this one is great. that shit the kids spitting isnt sarcasm. i hate when punks try to douche out on peoples vids. u dont like it, fine, fuck off. otherwise respect the amount of effort this kid put into this. u know that kid? u know that was sarcasm? looks like an asshole to me....plus i left that comment a month ago. was done when it started man.
Well, I'm a filmmaker, but I don't jump the gun like that. It's obviously Sarcasm. Maybe it's done too well for most to see, but it's kinda obvious. I like this video alot. But that guy is getting exactly the kind of reaction he wanted out of you. Chill. It's no big deal.
then u know what i mean when hard work gets shit on by ignorance. ive struggled to get to where i am today hearing the same kind of shit from older people and when i see someone even younger being creative, its amazing. and if the criticism isnt constructive just diminutive, then it shouldnt be here. but like u said its whatever, im not trying to spit some sad story on this guys page. i just hate little punks like that. but yeah, ur right, oh well.
This was incredibly well done and well timed. Nice choice of clips and song. I love how you concentrated on the clips content rather than trying to make the lips match up which would have ruined the videos integrity. 5 Stars and a Favorite for you.
AMazing it was really a pleasure to watch this video. I enjoyed a whole lot. You made the scenes fit the songs perfectly and i'm very impressed. Good job def a favorite.
Great work! This was a beatiful song, and the clips matched perfectly. I love these sad songs no one seems to know about. Going in my favs. Great one!
well ive never herd this song b4 but it really suited the amv. Scenes matched very well with the music and i love the clips you picked for the amv - they really complimented eachother well. Expresses the drama of the song ^^ Looks like all that hard work really paid off hm? 5* I look forward to more vids from you ;)
that was fuckin awesome! your right, their so much shity amvs on youtube that should just be taken off...well anyway that was really good!! *subscribes*
isn't that Julia a piece of hot woman... an angel from the underworld that you just can't leave alone. Question how do you always find inspiration to make Amv this good?
Everyone that made an amv less than or not even half as good as this should just take it off or take a lesson. wow! this is insane skill done with great fucking style & taste, incredible work!
Truly a work of art. I watched it 3 times in a row and you can bet I'll watch it more. Thanks.
Saigo2008 2 months ago
The Good: Nice song choice, good syncing
The Bad: Looks like all work was put into syncing and nothing else. No noteworthy editing, nothing that'd make you remember the AMV except maybe for the song.
The Ridiculous: Narcism should best be kept to oneself and your description oozes of it. If this was a true piece of art it might be overlooked, but uploading a "good to okay-ish" AMV and acting like a prodigy is just weird. Still not thumbing down since the vid itself wouldn't deserve it though.
SealOfHatred 2 months ago
This was so gorgeous, I could not take my eyes of this video and I was touched by it's beauty & sadness. Great song, great video, well done. x
LegalVampire 7 months ago
good choice of music (y)
kidgafanhoto 9 months ago
I like the way this amv flows, though I personally could see a few more transitions in some areas. I'm more inclined to the over-used crap you spoke of, just because I like amvs that seem like someone really thought about all the possiblities that could be placed in a single measure of music, but that's my opinion. You accomplished the story you wanted to tell, but I could have done without your ego. Yes there are a lot of crap amvs out there, but not every one that uses an over-used song is bad
sorcerousfang 1 year ago
terrible editing
acerunner007 1 year ago
you told the spike, julia, vicious story well through this video
chillpillvi22 1 year ago
Is it me.. Or did those 8 dislikers did not Understand What's going on in these flashbacks? D:
God you dislikers. GO AWAY. :[
VirtuaIReality 1 year ago
can i get the download of this song plz? thnx
kage4567 1 year ago
Great song choice. This was emotional and well done. My favorite part was when you cut back and forth between Spike and Julia both falling. I like that duality a lot. Very meaningful and foreshadowing. Props for making this about a few characters and not all of them. It made it more effective.
lionwingsltd 1 year ago
hey i really respect you for this amv you made. you're so right when you say the other videos are full of shit with the most generic music ever.
Resistance71 1 year ago
Nice job. Though its not all mixed up like most AMVs I actually preferred it since it all flowed together with the song perfectly. Good work.
eferhilda 1 year ago
wow harsh croud. It sound great and looks great to me.
ffffleet 1 year ago
i love the part where he says bang at the end and you hear a little chime
MoonLightRoses 1 year ago
Just Perfect.
VirtuaIReality 1 year ago
jbc429 I loved how you didn't mishmash it like everyone does. I feel your right; it does tell a story. Great job.
fullyloaded2004 1 year ago
i love how the last kinda of ding or ting of the song match perfectly to spikes bang
hoshigenu 1 year ago 2
beautiful, the ending was a great touch.
BattleRoyaleChampion 1 year ago
I like how u made it all flow. Good job buddy
Desoloano1 1 year ago
Pretty good. I like the song too.
AdonaelHarper 1 year ago
i love as tall as lions much better than most stuff on the radio and with cowboy bebop even better :)
tf233 1 year ago
pretty much all of your sequences aren't even mixed. they are exactly how the episodes progress. i did like the song choice.
Blakestefer 1 year ago
why would i mix the episodes that much? it tells a story from those 4 episodes. my purpose was to not be a mishmash of clips like everyone else does. it was to showcase the love story with a song that fit. and draw on the parallels of spikes downfall, with him falling out the window and accepting his own fate confronting his past. I mixed accordingly with what i wanted to do.
jbc429 1 year ago 17
@jbc429 to make it your creation. all you did was tell the exact same story Cowboy Bebop already told. but no biggie, just two editors with differing opinions lol
Blakestefer 1 year ago
this is a great video,
5/5
Jackie
brooksfostercare1 2 years ago
Description? Amen brother AMEN!
xXStefanMcDohlXx 2 years ago
really well done, along with some music that makes you actually want to see the video. nice timing, and as said before, a good story. all of this comes together is a really awesome amv! congrats on such a great video!
suprememasterp 2 years ago
yes, "certain anime", but not this. a majority of fans clearly misunderstand this to be more of an "action blow em up series" but its truly nothing but a heavily developed drama incorporating incredibly detailed backdrops, foreshadowing & resolution on each of it's independent members of the cast as a "whole story/epic". further review of watanabe's influence on the series and cast even describes it as such. to tag any piece of this with a "linkin park style" would, truly, be a slap in the face.
Cronominite1 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
This band sucks, this song sucks
Tofu4Dinner 2 years ago
love this band, definitely agree with u, i just think its more common to see linkin park and stuff cuz it seems easier to match with certain anime.
tharbk01 2 years ago
I have to say August Moon, a tribute to spike is another amazing one.
Kalamuzud 2 years ago
don't hate on other bands it makes you look like prick.
froobcakes 2 years ago 2
I have to say this is in my top 10 AMV's
Kalamuzud 2 years ago
I agree. This video, Eden for Trigun, Smooth Criminal (trigun and Bebop), Iron Lung (FLCL) to name a few.
Kalamuzud 2 years ago
f'n sad stuff
dapadawan 2 years ago
I'm with you! ^^ I hate amv's with that shitty industrial music ! xD
you've done a good work with this one!!
IntegraFWH 2 years ago
The amv is good for what it's supposed to be. AMV's don't need to have hardcore music and action that's just what most of you are used too.
THxJewSoldier 2 years ago
Dcrcjoo Stfu if you dont like it get over it ya Faggot Bag of Faggots they are inside you lol
PureToxicYouth81 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
OMG this video sucks what gay song this is. begin the hating.
dcrcjoo 2 years ago
Shut up!
Damatris92 2 years ago
favorite bebop ep, great job on the song
twocementshoes 2 years ago
these are some overused clips. i've never made an AMV, but i didn't even WANT to like this one from the beginning just because your info comments seem kind of egotistical and smug.
RinnyHeartilly 2 years ago
all the clips i used were to help tell the main story between the three characters. i dont just throw them in cause they look good like other people do. i wanted it to make sense on its own and pay tribute to the series as opposed to just showcasing clips with a random shitty song. not only that, i tried timing it with beats, snare, crash, and toms the best i could with what was playing in each clip. if it comes off smug its cause i hate shitty AMV's and youtube is cluttered with them.
jbc429 2 years ago 6
Mainly I think it comes across as smug because you are kind of a prick, but who am I to argue with results. The amv has depth, but it doesnt really hook the viewer. Someone has to be in the mood for this kind of amv for it to be enjoyable. I do, however, have to respect the fact that you didn't limp through a poor quality production with the typical flashy content that is flooding the Tube. Just as an after thought, dont bash a band in the info tab, it's pretty tacky, your amv speaks for itself
LuckyLokiLuko 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
froobcakes 2 years ago
need more atal amvs
Psdub 2 years ago
good stuff dude.....
trinifishstix 2 years ago 2
Good video good song. Thanks!
Soobleej 2 years ago 3
i bought the album thanks for introducing us
dapadawan 2 years ago 2
I litteraly cannot quit watching this. Its realy realy realy good X-Infinity. You need to do more like this.
dcrcjoo 2 years ago
Comment removed
dcrcjoo 2 years ago 2
i want all of this stuff on my ipod
dapadawan 3 years ago 2
This has to be one of the best Cowboy Bebop amvs I've ever seen. The song is beautiful.
xXBloodyRoseXx 3 years ago 12
I have never watched even heard of this anime before and have recently started watching it after seeing this AMV. Your video is incredible.
THxJewSoldier 3 years ago 2
dude ur amazing dont listen to dat asshole this song fits perfectly
jesse4eve 3 years ago 3
Love the song amazing video.Comboy bebop is my favorite anime of all time so thnx man.I met the guy who made comboy bebop
jesse4eve 3 years ago 2
nice vid, great choice of song
almostotherly 3 years ago 3
thanks man. i watched the two you made as well. They're awesome. It's good to see others not just slap music and clips together and not put effort into it.
jbc429 3 years ago
Good job. Nice band too....
rmader989 3 years ago
This was amazing i loved it never heard of the band before but im limewiring them as i type
Domon1106 3 years ago 3
best choice of your life
Psdub 3 years ago
dude linkin park sucks ass its allbeen used too many times
Ninjuri 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
This is the worst AMV that I've ever watched. I watch AMV's all day long, and the one's with LiNkIn pArk are the sicccccest. As tall as tigers?! who the eff is that shitty band? The timing is so off, you should make it look like they're singing the words. You're probably some long haired comic reader who games on wii in his parents basement!!!!!!!!%#%#@%@
nickbenziger 3 years ago
u just said u watch amv's all day long so you must be some fat fuck, pale faced douche who's got chapped dick from jerkin it all day & night in a locked, dark ass room to anime chicks. if you have any idea what your even talkin about, which u obviously dont, you'd know that the entire storyline backdrop behind the cowboy bebop saga was more sad than happy. song fits perfectly and its a creative twist to the gay cliche of linkin park bein added to every fuckin amv out there! ur an idiot.
Cronominite1 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dude...SARCASM. It's heavy as fuck. Can't you see it?
zeynoon1 3 years ago
uh yeah, dude, im a concept artist/animator, thats what i do for a living. ive seen thousands of kids vids like this and all and this one is great. that shit the kids spitting isnt sarcasm. i hate when punks try to douche out on peoples vids. u dont like it, fine, fuck off. otherwise respect the amount of effort this kid put into this. u know that kid? u know that was sarcasm? looks like an asshole to me....plus i left that comment a month ago. was done when it started man.
Cronominite1 3 years ago
Well, I'm a filmmaker, but I don't jump the gun like that. It's obviously Sarcasm. Maybe it's done too well for most to see, but it's kinda obvious. I like this video alot. But that guy is getting exactly the kind of reaction he wanted out of you. Chill. It's no big deal.
zeynoon1 3 years ago
then u know what i mean when hard work gets shit on by ignorance. ive struggled to get to where i am today hearing the same kind of shit from older people and when i see someone even younger being creative, its amazing. and if the criticism isnt constructive just diminutive, then it shouldnt be here. but like u said its whatever, im not trying to spit some sad story on this guys page. i just hate little punks like that. but yeah, ur right, oh well.
Cronominite1 3 years ago
lol, yea that guy sucks. thanks for the support dude!
jbc429 3 years ago
ha people are crazy! anytime man
Cronominite1 3 years ago
haha thats funny as heck... so true about evey comment on every amv haha... but seriously dont fucking say shit about the lions dude..
Psdub 3 years ago 2
that's a really good amv!
but linkin park and staind arent bad.
:)
just had to put that in there.
lol.
but yeah, its a pretty good song.
animekid414 3 years ago 2
Pretty sick. Should be in the damn show.
MeplusYellow 4 years ago 5
Great choice of song. It fit the anime very well.
SpikeTheGorgio 4 years ago 7
bad ass
s2k9k 4 years ago 3
That was awsome, great job!! ^_^
Keep it up!
hinata813 4 years ago 3
incredible timing and great use of all action shots, gives it an easy-flow feeling. i love it, 5 stars :)
cael87 4 years ago 3
This was incredibly well done and well timed. Nice choice of clips and song. I love how you concentrated on the clips content rather than trying to make the lips match up which would have ruined the videos integrity. 5 Stars and a Favorite for you.
zeynoon1 4 years ago 4
AMazing it was really a pleasure to watch this video. I enjoyed a whole lot. You made the scenes fit the songs perfectly and i'm very impressed. Good job def a favorite.
lookingforbestamvs 4 years ago 3
Great work! This was a beatiful song, and the clips matched perfectly. I love these sad songs no one seems to know about. Going in my favs. Great one!
Aerodiablo 4 years ago 3
great job!nice editing and nice suitable song!congrats ciao from italy
ps..spike....live!!!
spikelive 4 years ago 2
well ive never herd this song b4 but it really suited the amv. Scenes matched very well with the music and i love the clips you picked for the amv - they really complimented eachother well. Expresses the drama of the song ^^ Looks like all that hard work really paid off hm? 5* I look forward to more vids from you ;)
summerisonfire 4 years ago 2
beautiful
fugnuggets 4 years ago
Nicely done, much better than those shitty-ass linkin park AMVs
RaizerZ 4 years ago
Amazing vid, very different and creative, check out some of my vids.
rw10x 4 years ago
that was fuckin awesome! your right, their so much shity amvs on youtube that should just be taken off...well anyway that was really good!! *subscribes*
astrozombiie 4 years ago
Looks good! You say this is your first? It's really impressive! A+, man! ;D
PikachuProductions 4 years ago 2
Its a work of art really!
jebril 4 years ago
ah I like the music! The amv is amazing. :] Great job. I agree with you on bad amvs. (but, I admit I don't make the best amvs...-shrugs-)
alchemykam41 4 years ago 2
eh, as long as your inspired! ;) ...this is just the best one ive seen in honestly like a year lol.
Cronominite1 4 years ago
isn't that Julia a piece of hot woman... an angel from the underworld that you just can't leave alone. Question how do you always find inspiration to make Amv this good?
SoulAmvRE 4 years ago
for some reason i actually love this AMV, it suits Cowboy Bebop. Great Job n Keep it up.
Anime Forever!
anewgenre 4 years ago
Everyone that made an amv less than or not even half as good as this should just take it off or take a lesson. wow! this is insane skill done with great fucking style & taste, incredible work!
Cronominite1 4 years ago
thank you so much, it means a lot!
jbc429 4 years ago
That was extremely awesome and utterly brilliant.
Don't hesitate to make more.
5*
Guduguv 4 years ago 2
thanks so much, ill make another one only if i know i can do a good job like this one.
jbc429 4 years ago
WOW!!
That was amazing
and that was your first time makeing and amv?
DAMN!
I loved every minute of it
perfect timing
perfect transitions
great picture quality
the song fit perfectly
i give it a 5/5
NoahLD 4 years ago 3
haha thanks, feels good to know people like it that much
jbc429 4 years ago
nice job matching up whats on screen with the music. Obviously I don't know shit about cowboy bebop, but, it's good none the less!
nickbenziger 4 years ago 2