And while the soloist did change up the lyrics a bit, which was a bit odd, covers are all about taking a song and making it your own, not an exact replica. For example, any cover that Type O Negative did, they don't sound like The Beatles or Neal Young's original renditions. They sound like Type O Negative and it's great. And so is this.
Yea, i think i agree with the general consensus which is weird, although i gotta give them credit for trying a song that 95% of the ppl at the concert wouldnt know
interesting...not sure I liked the arrangement (which is by no means an easy task arranging a PT song) and I think the lead vocalist's interpretation wasn't the best...but not bad, a BOLD choice of a song, could use some more polish...
Very talented lads, but I really don't like this. My ears just say "wroooonnnnng". Only because it's, in my opinion, butchering an incredible piece of music. What was the word after "engine"? When I hear the engine...what? Here? And yeah mcnaughty, the "I'm tying you up" thing is pretty funny.
Not sure if I like it, but I guess that stems more from me not being into acapella singing. Honestly, I don't think they could have done any better job on an acapella version of this song. VERY impressive.
I really love 2:49. interesting cover..
MuziakFilms 6 months ago
very very cool:)
petwar83 6 months ago
greaat!!
ReleasingWeeps 8 months ago
nice ;)
andrejskaza 9 months ago
Needs a new lead.The backing guys were great.
TerrBerrUK 10 months ago
love it!
audient 10 months ago
And while the soloist did change up the lyrics a bit, which was a bit odd, covers are all about taking a song and making it your own, not an exact replica. For example, any cover that Type O Negative did, they don't sound like The Beatles or Neal Young's original renditions. They sound like Type O Negative and it's great. And so is this.
Niloc14 10 months ago
This version sounds like it should be called "Soul Trains".
Niloc14 10 months ago 4
AWESOME GUYS!
DiegoINSOMNIA 10 months ago
super job!
bigbluesky1968 10 months ago
This just seems off to me...doesn't feel like Trains.
darkwingppk 10 months ago
really, really amazing
skyseason 10 months ago
I was so shocked to find this. And that you were doing a PT song. Wow.
Xearf 1 year ago
For our last performance in year 12 we get to choose our own songs...we so have to do this , it's amazing
muntificator 1 year ago
Any reasonably explanation why I got shivers down my spine and goosebumps all over my body?
royohz 1 year ago
Just amazing...
greatchuck1 1 year ago
not bad at all :D
allinsecret 1 year ago
Surprenant. L'idée est bonne mais les arrangements sont ratés et le choix de la tonalité n'est pas adequat. domage.
PATSAMJU 2 years ago
wtf... shit ....steven wilson dont see this!!!
avanzoR 2 years ago
It takes some time of getting used to but now I love it. But I really think you need to know the original song to understand the rhythm thingy.
WalkofLife 2 years ago
why is the rhythm so different?
TheCrickette 2 years ago
OMG I love their dancing :D
WickedCrawl 2 years ago
Amazing. Love the song.
leepermastercow 2 years ago
The guy has a sick voice, but it doesn't seem to fit with the rhythms that are going on, maybe they are to over powering?
tandersn9 2 years ago
Go listen to the song they are covering. It fits.
leepermastercow 2 years ago
FUCKIN' RAD.
Deraek 2 years ago
What have they done to the rhythm :(
Septicaemia 3 years ago 3
well...try singing the original rhythm....you will se why ^^
TheVergile 2 years ago 5
one the greatest songs from one of the greatest bands well done!
SwapGomez 3 years ago 3
the lead vocals are impresive
adrian5b 3 years ago
THIS IS GREAT!
awesomeheid 3 years ago
Is there a drum being played in the background?
Xearf 3 years ago 2
Fantastic! Inspired to the maximum.
JKostogiannos 3 years ago
THIS IS AMAZING
cowchpotato258 3 years ago
That was AWESOME!
evoeight04 3 years ago
This is fucking insane. <3
natureconspires 3 years ago
omg this would rock steven wilson really hard
gatofristail 3 years ago
oh my god wat have they done!!!!!!
i cant beleive what i hearing!!!!!
devileyes06 3 years ago
wowzers!
i was listening to some porcupine tree today and wondered about a cappella versions....
glad i found this!
and a great song to arrange for an a cappella group would be mellotron scratch, seeing as it has an a cappella section at the end anyway
HIMstress666 3 years ago
I Like it :)
I wish i had singer's voice
emotivenextway 3 years ago
they look stupid heheh
Soint 3 years ago
all acapella groups look stupid.
Rapportus5 3 years ago
agreed
InsomniumX 3 years ago
u got wrong the lyrics, without taking that in account...GREAT JOB!
ReNjI10000 3 years ago
THIS IS A COVER!!!!good job
ratm4Lui 3 years ago
Sounds nice, never thought i would hear this song like this, it sounds cool, good job
Ordj86 3 years ago
hahahaahahahah..russian ballet and pavaroti in one
astraxan19 3 years ago
GENIUS
dileminn 3 years ago
Good job, the singer has a fine voice...
Red1k 3 years ago
far from being the best cover of this song, but hey nice try, I liked it...
Ragnagord 3 years ago
funny
schmil3 3 years ago
Yea, i think i agree with the general consensus which is weird, although i gotta give them credit for trying a song that 95% of the ppl at the concert wouldnt know
OpusDei1321 3 years ago 2
Wowee! 5 stars :)
Personally really love it!
kaiwinbot 3 years ago
This is a very interesting arrangement. Next, they should do "Heartattack in a Layby". Now THAT would be even more interesting.
jtrek154 3 years ago 2
That would be AMAZING.
twilight92 3 years ago
Or even Collapse the Light into Earth
twilight92 3 years ago
This is a very interesting idea, but not nearly polished enough. Work on it more!
kourinthellama 3 years ago
interesting...not sure I liked the arrangement (which is by no means an easy task arranging a PT song) and I think the lead vocalist's interpretation wasn't the best...but not bad, a BOLD choice of a song, could use some more polish...
wolvesevolve 3 years ago
this is really cool :) well done
primate05 3 years ago
cool! sw would like it
nickstuk 3 years ago
This is sad... LOL
iamsocool160 3 years ago
Hay que ensayar un poquito más ;)
toifelskrais 3 years ago
Comment removed
listerine666 3 years ago
Very talented lads, but I really don't like this. My ears just say "wroooonnnnng". Only because it's, in my opinion, butchering an incredible piece of music. What was the word after "engine"? When I hear the engine...what? Here? And yeah mcnaughty, the "I'm tying you up" thing is pretty funny.
xSlaveCalledShiverx 3 years ago
This performance needs more cowbell
GoddessOfSorrow 3 years ago 13
Really odd, different. but I got to say it's awesome. Nice job.
bassrocks745 3 years ago 2
Despite the lyric flub, I thought that was rather cool. I'm quite impressed! I wonder what SW would say upon hearing this...
aquadonia 4 years ago 2
He's supposed to say "your tying ME up" not "I'm tying YOU up." HAHAHHHA. This is really weird in general.
mcnaughty69 4 years ago
Interesting. It gets really weird when the drums (in the original) are supposed to come in. Lots of hopping.
The fat dude in the front row is distracting.
GravityEyelids 4 years ago
Wow..
Not sure if I like it, but I guess that stems more from me not being into acapella singing. Honestly, I don't think they could have done any better job on an acapella version of this song. VERY impressive.
CLFire 4 years ago