i think tom waits has done the definitive cover version of this song no one can do a better cover there is more emotion and realism in his version i think
Josh, thank you for sending these videos. I do not know if I will ever get to see one of your concerts, but I can see some concert photage on youtube I am happy. You really seem like a very nice man. Perhaps if someday I could see one concerts, I might actually get to meet you.Your music helps me out during the day. It is nice to know that there are friendly people in the world who would be kind to you. You seem like one of these people. Thank you. :). Mona
I love Josh 4 two reasons. His simplicity and voice. And because even though he is now 30, he is still very youthful. And I love Church for calling the Pope a Nazi. <3
absolutely stunning, i love West Side Story and thats one of my fav songs from the show and they did it more than justice, i dont think theres a pair in the world who cud sing it better
Such a delicate balance of two great vocal talents at play, in balance.. Hard to imagine that they are both in their early 20's with such great gifts at such a young age. Thouht you might enjoy this.
I was searching for the best performances of this song.. and I didnt like any besides the original one.. But this....Josh...He is perfect... This is what brings tear to my eyes...
yes rosie your right,she can do a good screech lol,and he is way more advanced in vocal ability.....but ive heard many duets with him and she is the only 1 that matches his baritone with a mixture of thier voices (later in the clip) which is perfection.
She never belonged on the same stage with him, with her undeveloped, thin, screeching voice. Nothing against her, and I wish her well, but she's not a singer.
I have a theory and I wish someone would tell me im nuts. Has anyone else noticed that Josh Groban looks a lot, too much in fact, like Jason Gould, the son of Barbra Streisand?? It is possible they are the same person? He sorta sounds like what you would expect a son of Streisand to sound like. Same initials?? JG?? Maybe he wanted a musical career that wasnt connected to his mother's? Discuss it!!!
@harolddoza Well, she has two kids with boyfriend Gavin Hensen, and has a talk show in the UK called The Charlotte Church Show. She has been criticised for being overweight and a chain-smoker, which many believe has ruined her voice. She concluded her "classical" music career in 2002 and since released a pop album, but it hardly equaled her previous successes. She can also be very outspoken and is an infamous potty-mouth.
@harolddoza Well, the upside is that she seems to be very happy and content. Her show has done well, and she's now a judge on a Americal Idol-type show geared towards finding a new West End star (their Broadway).
discovered by mistake. my good fortune they are both great singers. great arrangement!!!!*********ROGHARM thank you very much for posting i really enjoyed this clip. i practice sing with these posts. i am getting better cannot get any worse.
Wow....kinda forgot how little he was when this all started. I remember when he was still relatively unknown and I heard his first single, before I knew what he looked like or how old he was. Then I saw him sing and realized he was about my age, and wondered how that voice could come from that body! Methinks he's finally grown into his voice :-)
Charlotte could sign like this until she started partying/drinking/smoking. That ruined her voice although she is starting to get it back. Josh is just a natural talent with a unique voice. Can't think of a male singer of this generation that can match him vocally.
Well its a lovely duet. they are both so young in this clip. Josh makes every note look so easy and effortless. I know the technique that Charlotte is using and she sounds wonderful. lovely notes. very high. try it yourselves critical people, its not easy. I think they are lovely together. Josh is just not fair on everyone else. Perfect as always. sigh. I like Charlotte she is sparky and natural. You go girl :-)
i would only say she needs to copy josh and open her mouth alittle more than it wouldnt sound as strained, shes very good tho its just josh groban overshadows everyopne
Hi, what a great job. Hey, I've heard that Josh has a brazilian girlfriend, do you know if it's true? Patricia Evans I guess and I found a Patricia Evans here (youtube) who's a brazilian singer, actress and singing teacher and I'm trying to get some info from her... but how to ask her without doing it directly? hard thing to do... If you know something, would you please tell me? Dying to know...
It's so unfortunate that there are so many critics. Yet, I don't see any of your videos that showcase your level of talent. It seems very easy to sit back and post a negative comment. Isin't it? But again I wonder, where is your performance? Though you may not appreciate her talent/voice, strangely enough she has produced several CD's. Where is your work for us to evauate your skill level? There is no reason for a statement as strong as, "She has no technic." Your post is in poor taste.
I have made my comments with respect. I´m not trying to ofend anyone. So, what i said is my personal opinion about something i know very well. I see many people agree with me, If you don´t, I´m sorry.
Those who "love his voice and 'hate' hers" are just WAY off the mark! Charlotte Church and Josh Groban BOTH have voices that are not just "talent", they are GIFTS! One doesn't "develop" such a voice...you're either BORN with it, or you're not!
What I think would be fantastic would be if they would do an album TOGETHER, as their voices blend and harmonize incredibly well!!!
children this was done 8 years ago C. Church is a very big deal in Britian.......she was selling CD's when she was 14 . I think many would disagree that her voice is not excellent.
Aw, he was only 20 years-old in this! He went from a slightly awkward young man with an incredible voice to a handsome gentleman with an incredible voice. What a big difference 7 years makes!
So young! And....his sound is better HERE then it is NOW! I love Josh so much; I have since his began. But I hate the fact that he closes off his sound and keeps it in the back of his throat when he should be letting it out. It can soar, like it begins to here! I know he's classically trained, but the stupidity of popular music and the sound that people like to hear nowadays is not that classical, robust, vibrato sound that he IS capable of.
Okay, he didn't do such a hot job on Maria. But he has redeemed himself on this one. Beautiful.
gloriafiona3 3 weeks ago
@earendilstar89 No I am
lotrforeverandever 3 months ago
i think tom waits has done the definitive cover version of this song no one can do a better cover there is more emotion and realism in his version i think
sinokman 3 months ago
He is nice, and amazing in concert. And any other time he sings!
DravenGal 3 months ago
Comment removed
DravenGal 3 months ago
Josh, thank you for sending these videos. I do not know if I will ever get to see one of your concerts, but I can see some concert photage on youtube I am happy. You really seem like a very nice man. Perhaps if someday I could see one concerts, I might actually get to meet you.Your music helps me out during the day. It is nice to know that there are friendly people in the world who would be kind to you. You seem like one of these people. Thank you. :). Mona
TheAlinaLopez 3 months ago
Josh makes this song HOT! he gives me chills every time he sings :)
meggiesmiles27 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please visit my channel to find a very talented artist with a really amazing voice!
talentlover 4 months ago
can i buy this somewhere??
singingchickk8 4 months ago
My dream is to play my viola while he's singing <3
crawfordphan 5 months ago in playlist Liked
I love Josh 4 two reasons. His simplicity and voice. And because even though he is now 30, he is still very youthful. And I love Church for calling the Pope a Nazi. <3
mikewill9511 5 months ago 2
@mikewill9511 you LIKE her calling the pope a nazi? Whats wrong with people like you
fbodkin1 2 months ago
absolutely stunning, i love West Side Story and thats one of my fav songs from the show and they did it more than justice, i dont think theres a pair in the world who cud sing it better
SCOGANHORSE 5 months ago 2
Only a word, FANTASTIC!!!
Kuramochi0214 5 months ago
Such a delicate balance of two great vocal talents at play, in balance.. Hard to imagine that they are both in their early 20's with such great gifts at such a young age. Thouht you might enjoy this.
Mark
markkarnett 6 months ago
I can't understand much of anything she's saying but I like her voice.
starshine428 6 months ago 2
Comment removed
pinkydogbear 7 months ago
Comment removed
pinkydogbear 7 months ago
just to say/ OH MY GOD this guy is marvelous
dyronlove 7 months ago 10
@dyronlove I agree..................
pinkydogbear 7 months ago
I was searching for the best performances of this song.. and I didnt like any besides the original one.. But this....Josh...He is perfect... This is what brings tear to my eyes...
morghechagh 8 months ago
Comment removed
pinkydogbear 7 months ago
Comment removed
pinkydogbear 7 months ago
Comment removed
pinkydogbear 7 months ago
hey i have uploaded a video of myself singing this song, please listen to it and let me know what you think :)
star15615 9 months ago
OH WOW.
her voice & his are.. so amazing.
OhreallyGolly 1 year ago
@OhreallyGolly I read that as "her voice and his arse" ;-)
yemieko 10 months ago
Comment removed
pinkydogbear 7 months ago
Oh, God, if I were her I wouldn't let him go out of the stage without some kisses and hugs or at least I woud run after him to backstage! :))
lillyfeeling 1 year ago
this song would be better with katherine jenkins and josh groban
supersevz 1 year ago
I'm not a fan of Church but I love this song!
goldengal1989 1 year ago
two magnificent voices together singing one of my favort songs in this world, amazing
EnchantedMind0 1 year ago 2
@EnchantedMind0 My favorite song and singers!
pinkydogbear 7 months ago
Ma dove hanno tutta quella voce?
Meravigliosi !
Ps: I love Josh Groban...
titta49 1 year ago
Love her accent! Their voices compliment each other so well.
I so love this song.
lonegull 1 year ago
This was freakin' 10 years ago! He really looks younger! Cute! ^^
forevermalena 1 year ago
Charlotte and Josh singing together-how perfect and lovely!
tessakib 1 year ago
Fantastic Duett , I love that .
berlinsmiler 1 year ago 2
Always loved this song: meaningful for me.
This is a great version.
bookkeeper57 1 year ago
Love this song!
hoangnguyenct 1 year ago
I love it!
hoangnguyenct 1 year ago
I love it when these two sing a duet together!
WI24LDS 1 year ago 2
When u hear Josh Groban sing, you can't help but fall in love with him. One of the best male singers ever!
rebarox85 1 year ago 3
yes rosie your right,she can do a good screech lol,and he is way more advanced in vocal ability.....but ive heard many duets with him and she is the only 1 that matches his baritone with a mixture of thier voices (later in the clip) which is perfection.
locoonutt 1 year ago 3
One of my favorite songs
david3214zz 1 year ago
both gifted musions ( cant spell)
smileykisses420 1 year ago
how I love him!
modern1981lyuska 1 year ago
not if i marry him first! :p
herzgebrochen 1 year ago 2
@herzgebrochen Marry me Heather, i can sing it too.
maskcdesign 1 year ago
wow!! I love it.
woodenshoes123 1 year ago
wauw what voices...
Ragebol1 1 year ago
She never belonged on the same stage with him, with her undeveloped, thin, screeching voice. Nothing against her, and I wish her well, but she's not a singer.
Josh, on the other hand, is flawless.
PochiesRosie 1 year ago 2
@PochiesRosie totally disagree shes great
arniemonkey 1 year ago
@PochiesRosie Charlotte Church is not a singer and she has a screeching voice? You clearly don't understand anything about music...
aerdna14 11 months ago
I have a theory and I wish someone would tell me im nuts. Has anyone else noticed that Josh Groban looks a lot, too much in fact, like Jason Gould, the son of Barbra Streisand?? It is possible they are the same person? He sorta sounds like what you would expect a son of Streisand to sound like. Same initials?? JG?? Maybe he wanted a musical career that wasnt connected to his mother's? Discuss it!!!
RRIDLEY100 1 year ago
@RRIDLEY100 Not even close. Josh Groban is 29, Jason Gould is 43. Josh likes the women, and Jason is openly, proudly gay.
divinehumanism 1 year ago
lovely! ;)
faithfulfaye 1 year ago
ihr seit unglaublich....so incredible....i give you all my love...
lilasonnenschein 1 year ago
What has become of Charlotte Church? She was amazing, hope she still is.
harolddoza 2 years ago
@harolddoza Well, she has two kids with boyfriend Gavin Hensen, and has a talk show in the UK called The Charlotte Church Show. She has been criticised for being overweight and a chain-smoker, which many believe has ruined her voice. She concluded her "classical" music career in 2002 and since released a pop album, but it hardly equaled her previous successes. She can also be very outspoken and is an infamous potty-mouth.
divinehumanism 1 year ago
@divinehumanism That is a sad story. What a waste. Thanks for the info.
harolddoza 1 year ago
@harolddoza Well, the upside is that she seems to be very happy and content. Her show has done well, and she's now a judge on a Americal Idol-type show geared towards finding a new West End star (their Broadway).
divinehumanism 1 year ago
Wow, that was phenomenal. I got goosebumps.
remonalisa87 2 years ago 4
Josh is Fabulous and so was Charlotte at this point--- hope she regains this purity of voice some day
fourleggedbudgie 2 years ago 5
I'm going to marry him.
earendilstar89 2 years ago 63
@Eardendilstar89:
Me too! :P
Hey do you like Tolkien? I'm guessing by your name.
LuthienofOssiriand 2 years ago
@earendilstar89 no u re not..
saarahkhan 1 year ago
@earendilstar89 who isnt?!
Haler13 8 months ago
@earendilstar89 Not before me :) lol
JainaSkylar 6 months ago
@earendilstar89 as Josh himself would say: 'Good luck with that!'
siobanethier 5 months ago
senza parole
querzola1946 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please check my page out , me singing Josh Grobans "Believe"
Nicktranquil 2 years ago
Does anyone know if there is a recorded version of this that they did that I could download?
Kiesa4 2 years ago
go to V I X Y . N E T
and you can convert to mp3 and download :)
ColleenAIMusic 2 years ago
Josh is amazing!
no words!
really! he has the voice of an angel!
it takes my heart everytime I listen him!
calliope92 2 years ago 5
discovered by mistake. my good fortune they are both great singers. great arrangement!!!!*********ROGHARM thank you very much for posting i really enjoyed this clip. i practice sing with these posts. i am getting better cannot get any worse.
rogharm 2 years ago
How Old Is She Here???
MissWay100 2 years ago
She's 20! Crazy isn't it? Josh is 25 here.
jadedkiwi23 2 years ago
Comment removed
Claudje1000 2 years ago
Comment removed
Claudje1000 2 years ago
Wow....kinda forgot how little he was when this all started. I remember when he was still relatively unknown and I heard his first single, before I knew what he looked like or how old he was. Then I saw him sing and realized he was about my age, and wondered how that voice could come from that body! Methinks he's finally grown into his voice :-)
meganAbMt 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
How is it that I just found this video now? Love-love-love it!
jferrante42 2 years ago
West Side Story by LEONARD BERNSTEIN... let's not forget the composer -- this is their life and blood, their soul, their music.
cageynerd 2 years ago
Josh was sorta skinny when he was younger xD
teenCSIagent 2 years ago
Charlotte could sign like this until she started partying/drinking/smoking. That ruined her voice although she is starting to get it back. Josh is just a natural talent with a unique voice. Can't think of a male singer of this generation that can match him vocally.
vernieistooold 2 years ago 2
Josh simply opens his mouth and the melody pours out, amazing.
dugger80 2 years ago 7
I totally agree!!!!
calliope92 2 years ago
....incredible....
MissmSpieker 2 years ago
Stunningly beautiful.....words can not describe...Like angels....
LisaJMoore 2 years ago
JUst beautiful
Neuweier 2 years ago
they have amazing voices <3
LindesGirl666 2 years ago
Josh's voice is like warm velvet chocolate ...... just delicious x
lilbeth38 2 years ago 68
Yes ... like a velvet warm chocolate ... and like a velvet breeze and like the timeless memory ... just miracle x ... he is a miracle x ... :))
Liz::):)
Mistral0307 2 years ago 7
haha yeah i'm so jealous of charlotte. but they sing amazingly! <3
CjRoCkZPR 2 years ago
I will agree that there is nothing like hearing Josh live! I love Josh. Anyone notice though that she sings the guy part and Josh does the girl part.
cbgflygirl 2 years ago 2
charlotte church just doesn't do it for me.
i don't get the hype.
iago07 2 years ago 2
I really like josh Groban, but nobody can sing this like Barbra Streisand...
Alecssei 2 years ago 2
He IS amazing live, nothing like it!
steppedonalego 2 years ago
Beautiful done!
JonasBrothers4vrfan 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They sing so beautifully together, and they are so adorable. Can you imagine if they were married?
1sweetnuthing 2 years ago
wow...nice...
raixle 2 years ago
Very good!!!!
Detacheeventos 2 years ago
You haven't heard anything until you've heard Josh Groban performing live! I didn't know he was so young though... :)
doomspell179 2 years ago
I LOVE JOSHIE!!!
eava123 2 years ago
I have the chills, I love Josh! :)
Luthienk 2 years ago
Groban sings this very beautifly
besart100 2 years ago 3
One of my favorite songs, beautiful voices. What's not to love?
BelindaKyle 2 years ago 3
They are wonderful ande feely !
Jamilla0731 2 years ago
What an amazing pair of vocalist! Brilliant performance! I found this version even better than that of Barbra Streisand.
canyout 2 years ago 2
what no holding hands? not lyrical interpretation lmao
cinedreams 2 years ago
And I've found my Tony :)
Te adoro Josh haha :)
OnceUponAWaltz 2 years ago
She's awfully fidgety, and touchy feely
dechetsdailybs 2 years ago 2
i know!! but i would be too if i were seeing him in person!!!!lol!!
MTwannaB4jesus 2 years ago
I want to hear Josh sing the whole thing!
scramasboy 2 years ago 5
all around brilliant song by two awesome vocalist
invictusmonkey 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Don't stop reading this just because u just now realized this is a forward :)
1.put your hand in your mouth
2. Make a wish
3.Close your hand (fist)
4. Hold your hand at heart for 5 seconds
5. Send this to 3 more videos
6. Tommorrow will be the best day ever
it actually worked
Money- you will find a wad of $200 in cash
Love- Your crush or lover will kiss you or ask you out
cheergirl233 2 years ago
i cant the # of times i repeated this song
i ab-so-lute-ly loooove it!!!!!!!!!!
librastar16 2 years ago 3
They are both very classy and josh's singing...wow!!!!!!!!
CulturePeaceForever 2 years ago 4
Josh is perfect.. the girl's voice s annoying
Dido225 2 years ago
lol
riley675 2 years ago
charlotte's voice is so pure...very piercing....love it
brandykody11 2 years ago 4
Josh has quite a voice!
noaj8121986 2 years ago 4
Beautiful!
Nimbus2000 2 years ago 2
Lovely!
toastypineapple 2 years ago 3
Wow! Brilliant! Beautiful! Fantastic! wow!
AngelEyesMuse 2 years ago 7
Well its a lovely duet. they are both so young in this clip. Josh makes every note look so easy and effortless. I know the technique that Charlotte is using and she sounds wonderful. lovely notes. very high. try it yourselves critical people, its not easy. I think they are lovely together. Josh is just not fair on everyone else. Perfect as always. sigh. I like Charlotte she is sparky and natural. You go girl :-)
tjhungary 2 years ago 4
Josh Groban has amazing voice.
ritaromi 2 years ago 6
i would only say she needs to copy josh and open her mouth alittle more than it wouldnt sound as strained, shes very good tho its just josh groban overshadows everyopne
tiemedown 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Hi, what a great job. Hey, I've heard that Josh has a brazilian girlfriend, do you know if it's true? Patricia Evans I guess and I found a Patricia Evans here (youtube) who's a brazilian singer, actress and singing teacher and I'm trying to get some info from her... but how to ask her without doing it directly? hard thing to do... If you know something, would you please tell me? Dying to know...
musicalresearch 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i sing go on to mysapce and search for joeyfreckles and add me and lets chat :)
funkyfreckles 3 years ago
Wow, he's so young here. And his pants are so high. But he's still the perfect man. Bravo!
nayzany 3 years ago 5
I love him.
Kaitlynshh 3 years ago 7
apologies, her ex has been caught.
scaryjames 3 years ago
how c.church has changed though. shes just been done for the possession of a load of herorine if im not mistaken?
scaryjames 3 years ago
Charlotte Church has lost her touch. plus she keeps singing over him. OMG HE"S SO AWESOME
soccerchic331 3 years ago
She has no technic.. she should take singing lessons.! her voice has too much air!
And Josh has a very nice voice.
AminaBellini 3 years ago
Finally somone who is with me on this!...she sucks.
sweden92 3 years ago 3
It's so unfortunate that there are so many critics. Yet, I don't see any of your videos that showcase your level of talent. It seems very easy to sit back and post a negative comment. Isin't it? But again I wonder, where is your performance? Though you may not appreciate her talent/voice, strangely enough she has produced several CD's. Where is your work for us to evauate your skill level? There is no reason for a statement as strong as, "She has no technic." Your post is in poor taste.
Subass32 3 years ago
I have made my comments with respect. I´m not trying to ofend anyone. So, what i said is my personal opinion about something i know very well. I see many people agree with me, If you don´t, I´m sorry.
AminaBellini 3 years ago
Wow, that's GREAT!!!
Svetnoy 3 years ago
Those who "love his voice and 'hate' hers" are just WAY off the mark! Charlotte Church and Josh Groban BOTH have voices that are not just "talent", they are GIFTS! One doesn't "develop" such a voice...you're either BORN with it, or you're not!
What I think would be fantastic would be if they would do an album TOGETHER, as their voices blend and harmonize incredibly well!!!
Note to producers: THAT ONE WOULD SELL!!!
jammies3 3 years ago 2
I agree. Both have remarkable talent.
Subass32 3 years ago
children this was done 8 years ago C. Church is a very big deal in Britian.......she was selling CD's when she was 14 . I think many would disagree that her voice is not excellent.
kurtjmartin 3 years ago
who is she ?????
cshamans 3 years ago 2
wow..he blows my mind every time he just opens his mouth :)
west side story is one of my favorite musicals! i nearly died when i found out josh sang this
jgtrta 3 years ago 3
He was awesome then and more awesome now. Makes you wonder what he sounded like when he cried as an infant? :p
mainepatty08 3 years ago 2
wow, I think he used to be a better singer than he is today. I still love him, but his voice seems much less affected here and just more natural.
ddviolinist 3 years ago
yep! Im agree!
cesardario 3 years ago
thats amazing
XXHTOO 3 years ago
Aw, he was only 20 years-old in this! He went from a slightly awkward young man with an incredible voice to a handsome gentleman with an incredible voice. What a big difference 7 years makes!
gapsofluminosity 3 years ago 4
this is just soooo good
LeahAGrobanFan 3 years ago
So young! And....his sound is better HERE then it is NOW! I love Josh so much; I have since his began. But I hate the fact that he closes off his sound and keeps it in the back of his throat when he should be letting it out. It can soar, like it begins to here! I know he's classically trained, but the stupidity of popular music and the sound that people like to hear nowadays is not that classical, robust, vibrato sound that he IS capable of.
carolinelinnae 3 years ago
Wow. Really?! He was in this show with her?! I never knew that. Go Josh. Aww. their so cute. Hes taller than her hehee.
MichaelCrawfordsFan 3 years ago
I love Josh!
musicforeverlove4 3 years ago 2
I love Charlotte Church, but I think she sounds like she needs a little more breath support in places....
But Josh Groban blows my mind...
BonneNuitMonCheri 3 years ago 2
Oh god she has an awesome voice !!!
Stpa1418 3 years ago
they are perfect duet ever !!!!!!!!!!!
they are angels,such an amazing voices in industry today !!!!!
phoinix143 3 years ago
y dosen't he sing this song alone??i LUUUUV HIM
LeahAGrobanFan 3 years ago 3
urm cause the song is meant as a duet with overlapping verses and sung in two different keys? lol ;D But I totally agree!!
funkycherrygirl 3 years ago 2
josh grobans voice is so amazing
gives me goosebumps! ;)
Happyduck1010 3 years ago 2
Forever Josh!
HaimBehar 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Charlotte you fucking cunt, why the fuck did you chose to imitate Britney?
TheBlackTurd 3 years ago
is there really any need to call her a cunt?
Lishahhh 3 years ago 7
Yeah, you got that right you're the black shit!
Diane579 3 years ago
Goosebumps!
mdkbdshan 3 years ago
too much falsetto on the part of Charlotte...
MoreEvilThanNorman 3 years ago 2
I agree with that statement. But he did a wonderful job. Well done to the both of them.
iamearl1993 3 years ago
nakakainlove naman sila...sana maka-duet ko din si josh
angelsend80 3 years ago
Josh is great!
HaimBehar 3 years ago 4
What wouldn't I give to see Josh play Tony in West Side Story.......
markcohen6969 3 years ago 3
would be much better than the guy that play got stuck with first time around, richard beymer. nat wood didn't want him, but got stuck.
WERTY317 3 years ago
i love west side story!!
benfamb 3 years ago