This is embarrassing... I'm in high school, and one of the best high school orchestras in all of Virginia, and our orchestra class can't even play this as well as a bunch of middle schoolers. And we're playing this for festival in two months. fml.
this is a bit too slow and it would be better if they put more accents into it..im playing this for my youth symphony orchestra in Barbados and we have the winds included but this version is not bad good effort !!
notice how it is a junior high orchestra. there must be something wrong with you if you think you have to critique junior high orchestras to feel good about yourself.
Hell of alot better than my orchestra. Also Alot bigger. I like how the bass players are in a line around the back. We dont even have enough bass to do that xD
This is awesome though. Our Highschool played this song.
I'm sure the conductor could have arranged his own music that was more age appropriate than this war horse. The trumpetless chorale feature after the intro was indeed bizarre.
The irritating thing is that for a school orchestra it's played really well, but if I was the headmaster I would have used school funds to brin in some brass and woodwind. It's just so disappointing.
big bass section.... nice song though. my orchestra has to play it soon. I'm concert master so i have to actually know these songs waaaaaaaaay too much before the concert. '~'
I'm a cello player for Katy Junior High and first chair.You guys have a great big sound for all of you people. There are some tuning issues in the 1st Violin's.
holy crap!!! wow... our high school band just played this and they sucked compared to this! i've heard the beginning of this song before (even before their concert) but i CAN'T remeber where! it's sooo annoying!!! oh well... awesome job! =D n WOW! u guys r middle school... WOW!! amazing for ur level! high five!
really of slow, but you are very lucky. my high school orchestra would have mauled this piece. we cant even play the brandenburg concerto thing. i think that your orchestra should try debussy's La Mer.
also did anyone notice that the conceret master cant do vibrato but 3rd chair can!?!? not tryin to sound prjudiced but prob 1st just cus hes asian and asians usually r amazing at orchestra. actually iv only had one concert where there wasnt an asian concert master. and even then second chair was asian
ugh they kept rotating our concertmaster/mistress (we have 3, because clair from my old school, that redhead from emerson, and jeffrey from harper). so this was, like, our ONE concert with jeffrey as concertmaster.
o. yea that kinda explians it i guess. even tho i hav no vlue what schools u r talkin bout but im assuming feeders. and i just realized that was a middle school. that was rly good for middle school. were playin this in hi scholl. its easy to me but my school isnt the greatest.
out of tune, unpolished, the technique and expression is terrible. and no winds and percussion? what the hell? i agree with one who calls this orchestra a "noob"
its one of the best...hopefully we can still achieve that this year, although im not sure
by the way mr.hobby there a way to bypass youtube's 10 min limit...ive done it b4, posting anime, although i messed up the episode by converting it to mpeg4 first (ipod)
and i deleted it...it takes too long to upload though. can i request the russian sailors?
i was listening, and after 30 seconds i finally realized why it sounded strange to me: it's an arrangement for string orchestra lol
we're currently playing this as well (i'm the principle cellist of the west australian youth philharmonic orchestra) though i don't like the arrangement, i congratulate you for playing this piece
re: to the lack of vibrato:
i've been listening without watching the video, and i have to agree the melody seems to lack lustre,
I plan to do that for this coming year. There is a video page on the new web site (with nothing in it....yet) Unfortunately they did not video the Finale Concert from last year. I could do something from the Wennberg Festival. Any request for a specific piece? (Remember there is a 10 minute limit for YouTube)
Thank you for posting a video of this song. It reminds me of national academic tournaments from High School. Even without the memories, the piece is beautiful.
um, is it me or the violins are NOT moving at all. plus you cant just always stare at the part wen ur playing, u have to look at the conducter, i mean check out the posture!PLus theres no vibrato, no nothing.
Which part are you commenting on? (what time on the video?) During the quiet parts they are not moving their bows much. You are right about them not looking at the conductor enough. They got yelled at about that all year! Many of them have not learned vibrato yet. It is still Jr High. A number of them have though, particularly in the 1st violins and cellos.
i have to admit my comment was quite harsh. About the moving part though, i meant that sometimes you should use the hole bow so u can get a richer sound, right? well i think so. Maybe i shouldve taken in consideration that these guys are in junior high.
I assume that you mean other than the strings? In this school district orchestra is stings only through Jr High. When they get to High School there is a Symphony Orchestra with full instrumentation. They also have a Chamber Orchestra that is strings only.
This is embarrassing... I'm in high school, and one of the best high school orchestras in all of Virginia, and our orchestra class can't even play this as well as a bunch of middle schoolers. And we're playing this for festival in two months. fml.
hcb196 1 month ago
i played this in my middle school class today!!! X)
petco64 2 months ago
this is a bit too slow and it would be better if they put more accents into it..im playing this for my youth symphony orchestra in Barbados and we have the winds included but this version is not bad good effort !!
ronziifiable 4 months ago
WHY CANT WE SOUND like this??!?!?!?! oh wait we use winds nvm. see winds this is what you supposed to sound like -.-
alolego 9 months ago
i am Chinese
27255530 9 months ago
Thanks for posting! Really helped with my Symphonic Orchestra Placement excerpts! :]
asianppl168 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my middle school chamber orchestra is playing this and they are doing it better
tylerspiro1 11 months ago
my middle school chamber is playing this and they are doing it better
tylerspiro1 11 months ago
the conductor is conducting so fast but the band is playing so slow
twoscoops444 1 year ago
hehe. i'm playing this for IMEA tomorrow. except the real version. it's haaard. i love the bass section though!! so many of them!!
12saramore12 1 year ago
it's an army of basses!
bass power!
Jakelolx 1 year ago
Cellos are WIN.
figfewdisgewd 1 year ago
Im doing this in a orchestra i go to its pretty fun to play i like it
fat21s 2 years ago
the orchestra im in is workin on this
it just sounds much more complete if there were woodwinds, brass and percussion
alexkang777 2 years ago
Comment removed
xnickyoranyx 2 years ago
they play behind the beat.... bahaha.... wayyyyy slow as well....
but i do enjoy this arrangement..
xXPeachTreeXx 2 years ago
notice how it is a junior high orchestra. there must be something wrong with you if you think you have to critique junior high orchestras to feel good about yourself.
trailerjazz11 2 years ago
>.> I'm on auto login, so that was my sister, she's all stuck up because she's first chair chellist in varsity, I tell you said that though.
xXPeachTreeXx 2 years ago
Strange. It should be played in full orchestra. The original is much more difficult.
cjh37878 3 years ago
Hell of alot better than my orchestra. Also Alot bigger. I like how the bass players are in a line around the back. We dont even have enough bass to do that xD
This is awesome though. Our Highschool played this song.
crusnik1323 3 years ago
Oh crap! I have to play this for my school orchestra. LOL they don't have any brass or woodwind instruments.
gr8testjojofan 3 years ago
Neither Percussion
StanleyKSCBP 2 years ago
great sound :)
fionaangelina 3 years ago
Very well done. Bravo on bringing great literature to such a young group. Well rehearsed and well taught.
darthmaxo 3 years ago
101 Strings plays Brahms!!.....just kidding...
I'm sure the conductor could have arranged his own music that was more age appropriate than this war horse. The trumpetless chorale feature after the intro was indeed bizarre.
Oh well. Good effort on the students' part.
novisibersk 3 years ago
Omg lol. So many basses.
Penguines 3 years ago
great coducting!
hoopsmaster13 3 years ago
All of the double basses...
Soreo8 3 years ago 2
If you want to listen to another great concert, search for "Queen Noor Suite"!!!! It's really worth it...
JEROyROSA 3 years ago
sound very good
i'm playing this piece in my orchestra..
notes are quite hard..
hoho428 3 years ago
wow
very very good
g3rb3r15 3 years ago 2
The irritating thing is that for a school orchestra it's played really well, but if I was the headmaster I would have used school funds to brin in some brass and woodwind. It's just so disappointing.
FILIGREE1 3 years ago
no winds... you cant/should NOT do full orchestrated pieces WITHOUT the correct instrumentation.
1337evan 3 years ago
shut ip, its fine
mariothecellist 3 years ago
dang thise triplet 16th notes are hard, and you guys pulled em off! 10th and 11th graders are having a hard time with them!
mariothecellist 3 years ago
big bass section.... nice song though. my orchestra has to play it soon. I'm concert master so i have to actually know these songs waaaaaaaaay too much before the concert. '~'
Salokin98765 3 years ago
Excellent. Your bass section is thumpin', yo.
jbarbri 3 years ago
that's a big orchestra
petubelalife 3 years ago
hmm not bad for a junior high. whats up the ppl not playing in the back? x.x but hey nice large bass section, my hs orchestra has 12...viola power!
ad0rkkablejoey 3 years ago 4
@ad0rkkablejoey AHHH I play the viola too!! They did great hear, this is the first youtube orchestra where the viola section didn't suck!
jaimemusique99 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ad0rkkablejoey AHHH I play the viola too!! They did great here, this is the first youtube orchestra where the viola section didn't suck!
jaimemusique99 1 year ago
'no I shall not look up from my music, never!'
I think you lost your wind section
Topeni 3 years ago
ummm there is no wind section
volturrachick 3 years ago
hahahahhaha
ad0rkkablejoey 3 years ago
OMG sooo many basses.
Ah, it's cool, we have about nine in our festival orchestra.
xD
yppahJoy 3 years ago
I'm a cello player for Katy Junior High and first chair.You guys have a great big sound for all of you people. There are some tuning issues in the 1st Violin's.
bearhunt11 3 years ago
this is actually pretty good for a jr high, too bad no winds/percussion though.
th0ma5laxc 3 years ago
Yeah I agree you can't play brahms without the full orchestration (my opinion)
fiddlinmatt 3 years ago
o.O SOOO mmannnnyy ppl!!!...ssssooooooo goodd!!! and ALL of the bases!!! GO CELLOS!!!..and violin?
natterLUVSu 3 years ago
GO BASSES!
AdioBlackMentality 3 years ago
dayum, alot of cellos! YAY CELLO!
Sk8erKunoichi 4 years ago
amazingg. My orchestra isn't nearly as good as yours. hopefully we'll play as well!
Uhhxhi 4 years ago
GREAT GROUP! Nice Sound! Are group wasn't as big as yours!
DoGz1121 4 years ago
wow there are like 10 basses! wowza
sacredcricket 4 years ago 2
is this the simplified version for strings??
thiscowsgotmoo 4 years ago
Yes, this arrangement is for string orchestra and is available from FJH Music Company
rdhobby 4 years ago
i was saying no...to that it wwasn't a private school...
natterLUVSu 3 years ago
hey what song is this called?
hocali93 4 years ago
Academic Festival Overture by By Johannes Brahms, arrangement for string orchestra by Robert McCashin
rdhobby 4 years ago
thanks!
hocali93 4 years ago
wow, you guys kick but. My orchestra is playing this soon, Hope we sound as good as you guys!
Zeldafoo9 4 years ago
I have played this in a full orchestra its amazin, played the trumpet choral in the middle.
but this is awesome well played especially for how old you are.
Murray16 4 years ago
Amazing for junior high. :)
fortuneismymuse 4 years ago
I know, it's PERFECT for junior high. Private school no?
Kuzya3k 4 years ago
nope
natterLUVSu 4 years ago
holy crap!!! wow... our high school band just played this and they sucked compared to this! i've heard the beginning of this song before (even before their concert) but i CAN'T remeber where! it's sooo annoying!!! oh well... awesome job! =D n WOW! u guys r middle school... WOW!! amazing for ur level! high five!
xxgracie38xx 4 years ago
really of slow, but you are very lucky. my high school orchestra would have mauled this piece. we cant even play the brandenburg concerto thing. i think that your orchestra should try debussy's La Mer.
ipwnthecello 4 years ago
Your orchestra is really big. You are good but kinda slow.....
mrbluebird3939 4 years ago
nice job.
your orchestra is HUGE!!
O_O
my school's only has like 25 violins, 10 violas, 7 cellos and 3 basses.
whatfreshhell121 4 years ago
Same with mine! But our middle school orchestra has a lot more, so...
fortuneismymuse 4 years ago
interesting arrangement, I was wondering how the Maestoso (the ending) would be played =P
Very good for a middle school orchestra, though! If you could have picked up the tempo a bit, it would have been nice, it was almost painfully slow.
greenmonkey125 4 years ago 5
also did anyone notice that the conceret master cant do vibrato but 3rd chair can!?!? not tryin to sound prjudiced but prob 1st just cus hes asian and asians usually r amazing at orchestra. actually iv only had one concert where there wasnt an asian concert master. and even then second chair was asian
Quasata 4 years ago
ugh they kept rotating our concertmaster/mistress (we have 3, because clair from my old school, that redhead from emerson, and jeffrey from harper). so this was, like, our ONE concert with jeffrey as concertmaster.
lixinxin 4 years ago
o. yea that kinda explians it i guess. even tho i hav no vlue what schools u r talkin bout but im assuming feeders. and i just realized that was a middle school. that was rly good for middle school. were playin this in hi scholl. its easy to me but my school isnt the greatest.
Quasata 4 years ago
I wouldn't assume that all Asians are amazing at orchestra. It's not something in their genes. It takes hard work.
fortuneismymuse 4 years ago
holy crap basses *drool * my current school has one. my last school had four divided among two orchestras now i think it has 2 or 3
Quasata 4 years ago
XD Yay, bass section!! God, how many are there?!
fallingembers666 4 years ago
6. *smirks*
lixinxin 4 years ago
be nice to the kids...
fehldruck 4 years ago
not bad for a JH orchestra
NonDairyYogurt 4 years ago
Realmente uma grande obra, e uma belissima execução.
Giomarferreira 4 years ago
I think it sound better if they have woodwind and percussion play together
theonlysin 4 years ago
jr high splits the orch and band/percussion. no symphony setup..
lixinxin 4 years ago
noobs
tyrooooone 4 years ago
not quite bad for a junior high school though.
racerxfanfrenzy 4 years ago
also, all the phrasing is painfully elongated. articulation and attack are very bad
ayuprnkcller 4 years ago
out of tune, unpolished, the technique and expression is terrible. and no winds and percussion? what the hell? i agree with one who calls this orchestra a "noob"
ayuprnkcller 4 years ago
yeah way too slow. i played this with LIYO (long island youth orchestra) when we went to Europe this past summer.
ajm909 4 years ago
Im,soo sorry to make this comment, but its true,
This piece sounds like crap when reduced down to string orchestra, it sounds much better with full orchestra.
Not to mention the tempo was too slow and dragged in some parts, and the intonation could have been better.
Brahms already makes things thick, and in this performance, you just made it sound Obese, and thicker.
hsgualekili 4 years ago
nvr mind, i see the russian sailors already
srry
l3m00c0w 4 years ago
lol
im in this orchestra
and its not n00b
its one of the best...hopefully we can still achieve that this year, although im not sure
by the way mr.hobby there a way to bypass youtube's 10 min limit...ive done it b4, posting anime, although i messed up the episode by converting it to mpeg4 first (ipod)
and i deleted it...it takes too long to upload though. can i request the russian sailors?
i like that one..
and chevrontruck, its not nice to swear
l3m00c0w 4 years ago
for a junior high/middle school orchestra this is actually pretty good
th0ma5laxc 4 years ago
i was listening, and after 30 seconds i finally realized why it sounded strange to me: it's an arrangement for string orchestra lol
we're currently playing this as well (i'm the principle cellist of the west australian youth philharmonic orchestra) though i don't like the arrangement, i congratulate you for playing this piece
re: to the lack of vibrato:
i've been listening without watching the video, and i have to agree the melody seems to lack lustre,
but hey, everybody has their own way.
direngrey2143 4 years ago
Who ever the fuck said we don't have vibrato your fucking blind. And sorry we're not into the fucking music. We just don't really like it.
It's not our fault the seconds learn slower. That's why they're in the seconds.
chevrontruck 4 years ago
n00b?
chevrontruck 4 years ago
Dude, I'm in this.
rosemont419 4 years ago
if u r in this u must be n00b
chevrontruck 4 years ago
Why would I be a newbie if I'm in this orchestra?
rosemont419 4 years ago
because you suck
ayuprnkcller 4 years ago
is this n00b?
chevrontruck 4 years ago
I beg you to post videos of the highschool symphony orchestra
especially since i'm a member.
rlgrunge 4 years ago
I plan to do that for this coming year. There is a video page on the new web site (with nothing in it....yet) Unfortunately they did not video the Finale Concert from last year. I could do something from the Wennberg Festival. Any request for a specific piece? (Remember there is a 10 minute limit for YouTube)
rdhobby 4 years ago
darn
so the cello concerto is out of the question?
rlgrunge 4 years ago
Thank you for posting a video of this song. It reminds me of national academic tournaments from High School. Even without the memories, the piece is beautiful.
saladin435 4 years ago
um, is it me or the violins are NOT moving at all. plus you cant just always stare at the part wen ur playing, u have to look at the conducter, i mean check out the posture!PLus theres no vibrato, no nothing.
screwdriver33 4 years ago
Which part are you commenting on? (what time on the video?) During the quiet parts they are not moving their bows much. You are right about them not looking at the conductor enough. They got yelled at about that all year! Many of them have not learned vibrato yet. It is still Jr High. A number of them have though, particularly in the 1st violins and cellos.
rdhobby 4 years ago
i have to admit my comment was quite harsh. About the moving part though, i meant that sometimes you should use the hole bow so u can get a richer sound, right? well i think so. Maybe i shouldve taken in consideration that these guys are in junior high.
screwdriver33 4 years ago
maybe no vibrato in the violins, but there is in the cellos
mariothecellist 4 years ago
true
screwdriver33 4 years ago
so wht happened to the rest of the orchestra lol
GunzTheDuel 4 years ago
I assume that you mean other than the strings? In this school district orchestra is stings only through Jr High. When they get to High School there is a Symphony Orchestra with full instrumentation. They also have a Chamber Orchestra that is strings only.
rdhobby 4 years ago