Fahmi Reza dalam Forum Adam Adli, Kebebasan Akademik & Kebangkitan Mahasiswa

[thenonehustle]

lagi satu dulu "kita".............sekarang "aku" kalau kau student , x paham kau bodoh.....

[thenonehustle]

Ni aku bagi contoh la.....contoh.......aku msk rumah Fahmi Reza,bapak dia tengah tgk TV,aku kencing kat atas sofa tempat bapak dia duduk,kau rase ape yg bapak dia buat?

1.takan la bapak dia nk report polis,aku kecing je kot,salah ke kencing???

2.mesti bapak dia dah tak bagi aku masuk rumah dia,sebab bapak dia dah aim aku.

3.aku rase la lepas tu mesti bapak dia salah guna kuasa sebagai ketua rumah dengan cara tak bagi aku masuk rumah

kata nak bebas,ni la bebas....bebas x perlukan adabkan????

[kitatengok]

dulu dorang lawan filipina sebab pertahan kann negara...apa kena mengena dengan yang sekarang fahmi?merah boy lak...betul ke kita ade bayar kat filipina utk sabah?ni mcm zaman dulu ka ada bayar ufti2 ni? mana kau dapat maklumat tu?emilio aguinaldo bg tau ka?filipina pakai sultan ke kawan2?

[JaxMeridite]

You're not being profesional here. Instead of reading the whole text, you should have known your lines. Sepatutnya kau terangkan peristiwa pelajar menentang kerajaan Filipina tu, bukan membacanya semula macam kitorang semua ni tak pernah pergi sekolah. Additionally, you lack formality in your speech. It would be wiser for you to deliver your points in a more orderly manner. Kalau element formal tu takde dalam debat, orang akan naik menyampah. This is not a flame, rather, my two cents.

[sishisonson]

fahmi reza ni "bodoh"..ambik cth kebangkitan PELAJAR MALAYSIA MENENTANG KRAJAAN FILIPINA utk disamakan dgn demo plajar upsi menurunkan bendera najib. COME ON LA BRO.CERDIK LA SIKIT BG CONTOH PON.

[fastballslow]

aku rase Safwan Anang lagi pandai berhujah dari dia ni. cara dia bercakap macam lah kita ni bodoh sangat.

[armandreamsky]

dah la..mls la ak nk lyn klu stakat nk bedebat ....ko bkn sehebat ahli falsafah pon merahboy...ak nk kn kepastian je sbb ak da blajar care pemikiran org yg ak sebut2..klu ko xpasti or xtahu xperlu lah nk kua dr skop ptnyaan ak...xde mase ak nk kencing org ni der..ak blajar psal ni..bler ko bg stetment tuh ak pon ttarik gak nk tau..tp mende lain yg ko jwb

[adamzawahir]

macam ni ke pemimpin korang nak?? dressing tak matang langsung..

[gula2kapas89]

member tetap support member.. kalau dah mmber tu mmber jgak.

[pencintatuhan]

from the issue of philippines, fahmi reza want all of u to see how academic freedom work, even what the mahasiswa did that time will definitely disrupt public order, but tuanku abdul rahman can accept the mahasiswa way of thinking.. that's what academic freedom is.. if u blame adam because of the turun bendera issue, law is still law, why they didnt blame the mahasiswa of UM too.. the reason is, on that time, they respect academic freedom..

[daffodil2110]

@pencintatuhan but i think we still need to understand the context of the Philippines issue. what were they fighting for? though it was described in the book as disrupting the public order, the context of the issue might play an important role on how it was perceived by the public and TAR. the same goes with AA issue. It is said that it is not about the bendera. Its what they are fighting for that is important, right?

[pencintatuhan]

@daffodil2110 yes... it is what they fighting for is important..by any chances, did u think what adam do is not important? i think u should start think about how many university malaysia have..adam is just their representative. if all of this mahasiswa act back, what happen to your country? from what i read before this, g'ment didnt take it serious right? if the g'ment of Msia didnt take this issue as serious matter maybe they are wrong.. these young people have great ideology.

[korilda8]

salam..apa kamu dapat meyalahkan orang lain...??? belajar pun tempat gov...lagi mau tentang gov?? ohhh nak kata apa?? bayar cukai eh?? setimpal kew?? dah2...jangan kufur nikmat boleh x?

[daffodil2110]

ok now as a sejarawan, can u also explain to others here, the context of which the students were fighting for. latarbelakang hubungan malaysia dgn filipina semasa itu. apakah yg diperjuangkan oleh pelajar2 tersebut. maybe others could learn and compare the situation between before n now.

[merahboy69]

@daffodil2110 interestingly we are still paying rental to some sultan of the southern philippines for sabah. so are we really independent

[SuperKarandude]

ni adlin aman ramli ke ni?

[fastballslow]

ntah..tu Filipina negara lain...ko berbual ape...berbual pun ah ah ah...

[Act2Cool]

Fahmi Reza ko kene faham ... itu lawan filipina... ni lawan kerajaan sendiri... mahasiswa tahun 60an memperjuangkan negara... lagi pun tahun 60an tu baru lepas zaman perang dan 13 mei... perasaan radikal tu masih kuat... kite sekarang sudah jauh lebih maju dan bertamadun... ingat dulu lain sekarang lain... 

[Nazim88JimOthman]

In Malaysia we have the freedom of speech..but in the end you will create your own peril... Such a nice government we have here so sweet..awww . Well I know which party I will vote..enuff said

[fastballslow]

manusia boleh dibeli dgn :

duit

kuasa

perempuan.

enough said!

[merahboy69]

since when was a flag of a prime minister of such great importance. for gao'd sake its a flag. enough malaysian flags are hung around in dilapidated conditions...i don't see anyone repairing or replacing them. why no money in flags huh? carry on adam. liberty whilst its lies in the hearts of men, no court no law is needed to protect it. but liberty, once its is lost in the hearts of men, then no court and no law can ever protect it.

[armandreamsky]

@merahboy69 "liberty whilst its lies in the hearts of men, no court no law is needed to protect it. but liberty, once its is lost in the hearts of men, then no court and no law can ever protect it."...kpd yg buat statement ni...- ayat spe ko petik ni?hans kelsen?HLA HArt?aristotle?realism?sociolo­gist?john locke?karl marx?feminism?finnis?Austin?gr­otius?aquinas?augustine?...yg mane stu ahli falsafah yg support statement ko ni....tp klu ko reka sndiri xyah reply la comment ak ni

[merahboy69]

@armandreamsky don't throw names around like you have actually read these people. its a quote from learned judge Hand of the us appeals court. although unofficially it is sometimes quoted as the words of thomas jefferson. read up boy!!!!

[armandreamsky]

@merahboy69 hahah..funny..i don read them..i learned about them..thomas jefferson? alrite..did u know him? did u no whther he is naturalist?positvist?physiolog­ist?realist?..u should not only quote some word from him..u should know what their thinking..there is no logical thinking perse...most of US judges influenced by the realism...u shud read more baby..anything quoted by the judge will be based on jurist idea regarding law..im not talking some bullshit here..ive learned about them

[armandreamsky]

@merahboy69 previously i had asked u to answer wc one of the jurist support ur sttement regarding "liberty.."bla bla bla..i asssumed u hv the answer but then u blame me to read more?? get a life nerd.juz answer my question? quoting a superb saying does not make me satisfied, only the foolish will bow to u ..american court? the american jurist wc hd been rcognised were Holmes (1841-1935),Frank (1889-1957),Gray (1839-1915),Llewellyn (1893-1962)....thomas jefferson is not a jurist, boy!

[mnash28]

Kalau nak turunkan bendera dekat depan pejabat perdana menteri bolehlah baru boleh melambangkan ketidakpuasan hati terhadap kerajaan. Kenape turun dekat bangunan umno, sebab bendera najib tu sebagai simbol najib sebagai presiden umno bukan PM. Org umno tentu tentang.Org nampak tindakan sebegitu bagaikan org datang ke rumah orang lain lepas tu turunkan gambar tuan rumah dan letak gambar u sendiri or ape2lah tanpa kebenaran tuan rumah dan tuan rumah pun tak suka. Bukan tu maksudnye kurang ajar ker

[apisnano87]

student power

[armandreamsky]

watver dear...tok sah nk berintelek sgt laa..kbebasan bsuare kan kan kan...bkn geng2 pngikut adam ni duk membaruakan umno la, n mcm2 dpn UPSI?.. tp ak xkisah..lantak ler korg..cik adek aser berintelek gak ker membaruakan org mlayu sndiri

[alynnshasha]

kalau pun tak suka komen tu biar kasi intelek sikit boleh tak, tak payah nak panggil beruk ke, penjilat pkr ke, debat la elok elok. Phewww

[BADUTRAKYAT]

dari turun bendera baik belajar dan kejar cita-cita..tu lah padah nya kalau di racun dengan pakatan haram

[armandreamsky]

oit beghuk...ad g stu pbezaan dlu n skunk ko xsebut....dlu g demo kat kdutaan filipina ,,PM(TAR) memuji plajar...skunk g demo tentang PM negare sndiri...klu TAR idup lg tah2 mati tkejut plak

[Fakhruddin1991]

yeye la lu bro.... kreatif giler turun bendera ek....

[imanuelladida]

wow... tak habes studi pun bley dpt gelaran sejarawan.. wowwwwwwww.......

[alipgeli]

power ah!

terbaek !

lu nak ckp camni ke wahai penjilat umno? haa? meludah boleh lah !

rambot rare uh !