you have a good voice, but i don't think this is the right song for you to be honest. i mean this song is supposed to be sung more gently, without trying so much, just let it come to you. i think this song's better if you don't sing it with like attitude if you know what i mean. it's not a pop song, it's supposed to mean something. good voice though :) #nohate
beautiful!!! i love this song and ive been listening to all the girls on here trying to sing it as good as amanda does... u got it girly!!! great job ;)
First of all you sped up the song wayyy fast lol. Your pushing a little hard with your voice and not letting your natural notes come out. Like someone else said, you do good with high pitches, so id stick with those. But i applaud you for having the courage to put this up on youtube :) you did pretty good
Why are you rushing? This song is a mild rather slow song. You sound like you have a good voice but i think you rushing spoiled the beauty this song carries. Now i am not saying you that you should sound like Amanda. Its impossible. I mean she is just amazing. But you could ve atleast reached somewhere near. Consider this a constructive criticism. CHeers :)
people have said it before but don't sing this type of songs. I know, I also love this type of music but it doesn't fit my voice. try something else and you'll see it sounds better and feels better. PS. just sing from you're heart <3
you have a nice voice but you have clearly picked up a few tricks from your favourite r&b or pop singers ! It doesn't work it sounds unnatural! I am focusing more on the end of each line when you make the notes sound longer and force out your voice to quiver in ways you like. It is good however, just sing from the heart not the head <3
You strike the right notes and your voice is pretty good, but you don't feel the song at all. You sing it way to hard. Its not only about the lyrics but about the deeper menaing hidden inside them. Watch the movie, "Dear John", and try again when you finished it, maybe you'll get the feelings inside your voice then
Sounds great. Funny, I was listening and thinking u are doing a good rendition, then I read the comments, many unkind with feable attempts to be instructive. Basically, with music and performance we are all where we are with our creativity, ability, performance. Each day, if you keep doing it, u expand, u learn, u enjoy. U may not see change in shorter periods, but then after a while u look back and see how far you've come. Just keep doing it, love it. share it, for u and us.
a tip, try to open your maouth when you sing, so the air go through your mouth instead of you nose ^^ it will also help your listeners too actually hear what you sing! so keep up the good work!
Helemaal niet verkeerd. Wel moet je nog werken aan je presentatie, duidelijk verstaanbaar zingen en het allerbelangrijkste: je , hart' erin leggen. Dus dat de vibratie overkomt. Succes!!
I get that you understand the meaning of the song but... your trying to hard... close you eyes and and sing with all the soul you have left in your heart...
@roseysmusic You're trying to hard to sing pretty in stead of focusing on the meaning and beauty of the song. Keep it pure, you've got a good voice :)
@roseysmusic It depends. If you close your eyes and concentrate on sound or whatever than it's trying to hard. Just letting the music take over isn't trying to hard. I don't know if that even makes any sense aha.
honestly, choose one song for you and camon, you have to know the song, exists parts of the music that you last the rytms. more one thing congratulation for te 54 thousend of views.
And greekbaby94 the people have their opinion, and if you don't like so, you go to hell (a)
Just being perfectly honest. The strumming pattern of the guitar is horrible and not at all even. And you're voice is alright, but there's something really quirky about it, and no in a cool way either.
i adore this song, and i admire you for posting this. im sure whoever watches this and posts rude comment is jealous and no where near as good of a singer as you. given, everyone has the right to their own opinion. but with that, you do have a lovely voice. and you're a very pretty girl! :)
@kooofan rude. first watch her other videos, then upload some real videos, then try singing as good as her, and THEN you can talk. but not til then. k bye.
you try to hard, your not singing naturally. It doesnt sound good because your forcing yourself to sing something you can't sing. Trust me i've been singin for 9 years now both publically and privately. Good luck x
@roseysmusic that's very diffrent! I had the same problem. I almost lost my voice because I sang wrong. Maybe it is good if you also do pop. I did it and now I sing better as before.
@roseysmusic honey. its very obvious you weren't trained by anything but the radio. good song. not a horrible voice but a very poor presentation of it.
@defu6 well my view of music on youtube is that it gives you a place to add a little bit of your own to a song you like. sorry that its not a replica, that would be a little boring, right?
I liked it :) how long have you been playing for? And do you need a capo for this song? sorry i cant tell if you are using one or if thats just your strap :D
you have a fantastic voice. i don't know whatsome of the other people are talking about... i have been singing for a while and i wish i had your voice! mine is.. different.. hahaa. well, i loved your version a lot. and i don't think you ruined the song.. at all.
my burf is the 13 day before valentines lol. u have a strong controlled voice. its awesome. you did a good job. i like how u changed it up. Grool! lol
hey gurl
MrClydeTV 2 weeks ago
Not the right song for your voice, you did a good job but you should try something with a different sound to it. :)
SarahPeachful 1 month ago
whats with the heart on your cheek..
KKMLProductions 1 month ago
de todas las queescuche es la que mas se asemaja al rimo y a la vos
jona29111 1 month ago
i give you a maybe 3 3/4 not quite 4 outta 5
AngelsOfTheGarden 1 month ago
you have a good voice, but i don't think this is the right song for you to be honest. i mean this song is supposed to be sung more gently, without trying so much, just let it come to you. i think this song's better if you don't sing it with like attitude if you know what i mean. it's not a pop song, it's supposed to mean something. good voice though :) #nohate
honeyicecreamcrush 2 months ago
Superbe !! Sa donne des frissons, magnifique voix
17tutur17 2 months ago
This is beautiful! I also have done a cover of this so please check it out on my channel!
SamanthaShin 2 months ago
im really jealous of your guitar
MrAlekiRogers 2 months ago
Oh my god! You are amazing! (:
ItsGillayyy17 2 months ago
LOVE.
This song is the best!
OGJify 3 months ago
beautiful!!! i love this song and ive been listening to all the girls on here trying to sing it as good as amanda does... u got it girly!!! great job ;)
sexEamber 4 months ago
i like this .... sounds love
namwarniiz24 6 months ago
woow your voice it's like sugar on my cake :) very good :)
tamaraabrantes 6 months ago
That was really good :) better singer than me haha !
IloveBunniez21 6 months ago
First of all you sped up the song wayyy fast lol. Your pushing a little hard with your voice and not letting your natural notes come out. Like someone else said, you do good with high pitches, so id stick with those. But i applaud you for having the courage to put this up on youtube :) you did pretty good
saraelise17 6 months ago 2
love it (: you are gifted!
KylieJoevideos 6 months ago
you are amazing, your voice is beautiful...brave
RogerAlegriaC 6 months ago
no offense but you are not the best singer. but keep trying
MyTweetybird2012 6 months ago
You sound very good
But I can sense a little bit of you pushing the air too hard out of your head and not letting it flow from your chest.
ramiahred12 6 months ago
When u sing high ure very good.
babaganushtian 6 months ago
For those of you saying she does bad, shut up. it's a COVER. which means its her representation of the song and I think it sounds great
chobitbunny7 7 months ago
i like the original better, this just isnt your song.
angelkarre 7 months ago
i like it
steffimammamia 7 months ago
hun, i don't see what everyones complaining about. i dont see the problem here? i think your great! x
hannahwynd 7 months ago
Great voice :)
MegaKayla1993 7 months ago
Why are you rushing? This song is a mild rather slow song. You sound like you have a good voice but i think you rushing spoiled the beauty this song carries. Now i am not saying you that you should sound like Amanda. Its impossible. I mean she is just amazing. But you could ve atleast reached somewhere near. Consider this a constructive criticism. CHeers :)
tdipen2 7 months ago
love your voice!
1103anamedina 7 months ago
You have a great voice.
starfire56500 7 months ago
I think you're great.
hiscrybaby 7 months ago
Keep practising... you'll get there eventually :)
Richjack3 7 months ago
people have said it before but don't sing this type of songs. I know, I also love this type of music but it doesn't fit my voice. try something else and you'll see it sounds better and feels better. PS. just sing from you're heart <3
Evilevilina 7 months ago
jenna anne sing this song wayyyy better..just sayin
rula4ever1 8 months ago
... Das ist soo gestellt
MrsLuckySweet 8 months ago in playlist dear john music and clips etc.
Dont try so hard, just sing.
nikkilovesriots 8 months ago
I think you're good, and to those who comment rudely, shut your mouths up... No one wanted to know what you think anyways.
Keep it up!! (:
sadaf555imani 8 months ago
you sound like someone who would be in a musical :)
LegendaryStory 9 months ago
i dont care what all these people say i loved it you sounded great to me
SiercksRacing787153 9 months ago
not so bad! :D
maarko10 9 months ago
You did great :) Keep it up and don't let anyone get ya down. It's just their way of saying they're jealous ;)
americanferever 10 months ago
you have a great voice. keep it up.
TheBabysomar 10 months ago
cute
SamizGlam 10 months ago
I think it's really good. You have a nice voice. People are pretty dumb and tone-deaf for saying otherwise.
SummerWine00 10 months ago
@nicklollen22 classy.
roseysmusic 10 months ago 7
@nicklollen22 She isn't THAT bad.
Fa6maTutu 10 months ago
i love your voice, so unique:))) + i love your hair, hehe <333
samalanah 11 months ago
great voice girl... i would go deep in the music business if i were you
wuckingforries 11 months ago
well, i like it.
danceeerrr 11 months ago
wow your amazzing! :)
LILMiSsMIsSy44 11 months ago
you have a nice voice but you have clearly picked up a few tricks from your favourite r&b or pop singers ! It doesn't work it sounds unnatural! I am focusing more on the end of each line when you make the notes sound longer and force out your voice to quiver in ways you like. It is good however, just sing from the heart not the head <3
HanghojLisa 11 months ago
nice... i love "dear john"... good song...and good performance...
GIAN1128 11 months ago
You strike the right notes and your voice is pretty good, but you don't feel the song at all. You sing it way to hard. Its not only about the lyrics but about the deeper menaing hidden inside them. Watch the movie, "Dear John", and try again when you finished it, maybe you'll get the feelings inside your voice then
kaddikaddi2 11 months ago
Sounds great. Funny, I was listening and thinking u are doing a good rendition, then I read the comments, many unkind with feable attempts to be instructive. Basically, with music and performance we are all where we are with our creativity, ability, performance. Each day, if you keep doing it, u expand, u learn, u enjoy. U may not see change in shorter periods, but then after a while u look back and see how far you've come. Just keep doing it, love it. share it, for u and us.
Andro1 11 months ago
you're trying WAYYYY too hard. It's horrific. It scares children. Please stop. I'm begging you. please.
bluiedgurl 11 months ago
open your mouth more and you'll be fine :)
Lisaslippers 11 months ago
oui je veux être ton valentin
translate in english for you : yes i wolud be your valentine :D
lombre81 1 year ago
you can sing, but not this song! it's to difficult for you... it is false..
Princess6049 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hi everyone ! go to my channel to watch my cover of this song <3 :) thanks xo
nicolegeary123 1 year ago
great! i too was inlove w/ this song...
nice work
raymundie08 1 year ago
Thank you for this video. ありがとう!
hannahope19 1 year ago
sing is okay, the guitar playing is not very good at all.
twoodgurl31 1 year ago
a tip, try to open your maouth when you sing, so the air go through your mouth instead of you nose ^^ it will also help your listeners too actually hear what you sing! so keep up the good work!
thebestthess 1 year ago
Helemaal niet verkeerd. Wel moet je nog werken aan je presentatie, duidelijk verstaanbaar zingen en het allerbelangrijkste: je , hart' erin leggen. Dus dat de vibratie overkomt. Succes!!
MrMoviesmaker 1 year ago
i thought she was Amanda...ohm mannn!!!
nhhn7sisk 1 year ago
wow.... really awesome!! ...
Eric23Ger 1 year ago
you're aren't terrible like i thought you would be
joleybabex3 1 year ago
wow thats good sonds really good hun love it you sond like amanda seyfried
outlawsteveo19 1 year ago
this is soo good
koeshlisa 1 year ago
I get that you understand the meaning of the song but... your trying to hard... close you eyes and and sing with all the soul you have left in your heart...
mrslover842 1 year ago 51
@mrslover842 i'm a wee bit confused... wouldn't that be considered trying to hard to get into the song as well?
roseysmusic 8 months ago 4
@roseysmusic You're trying to hard to sing pretty in stead of focusing on the meaning and beauty of the song. Keep it pure, you've got a good voice :)
Nischna 4 months ago 2
@roseysmusic It depends. If you close your eyes and concentrate on sound or whatever than it's trying to hard. Just letting the music take over isn't trying to hard. I don't know if that even makes any sense aha.
IAmAFighter9 2 months ago
I dont know why some ppl are hating, i think u nailed it and sounded amazing!!!
AcousticFiftyfive 1 year ago
honestly, choose one song for you and camon, you have to know the song, exists parts of the music that you last the rytms. more one thing congratulation for te 54 thousend of views.
And greekbaby94 the people have their opinion, and if you don't like so, you go to hell (a)
Gaaraporto 1 year ago
não ligue para os comentários destrutivos, você é muito boa garota! vou te contratar para cantar quando eu fizer um lual XD arrazou!!!!!!!!!
TheMortifera 1 year ago
FUCK ALL OF YOUUUUUUUUUUUU!!!! WHAT THE HELL ROSEY IS FUCKING AMAZING SO YOU CAN ALL GO AND SUCK YOUR CHODES. k thanks bye:)
greekbaby94 1 year ago 2
i want to play it where did you get the tabs?
Kennyfromusa 1 year ago
i dont like...
CataRock6 1 year ago
@CataRock6 fuck you
greekbaby94 1 year ago
awesome
americangirllover300 1 year ago
not a good song for your voice.
dulcefantasia15 1 year ago
nice
balaajify1 1 year ago
Can I get the guitar chords? :) Thanks!
tragicbeatdown 1 year ago
Not the best cover I've heard, but good (:
TrinneLovesAll13 1 year ago
Just being perfectly honest. The strumming pattern of the guitar is horrible and not at all even. And you're voice is alright, but there's something really quirky about it, and no in a cool way either.
jennykinsss 1 year ago
:) :) :) you loook like her and you can sing.
i like it i like iiit =D
joujouNW 1 year ago
wow gurl u got it goin on!
mctazz14 1 year ago
Beautiful! :)
Misshottstuff92 1 year ago
what were the chords and the strumming pattern you used?
KiteyJ 1 year ago
that's actually very good, just a little professional advise and lessons and that would be SOOOOOOOO GOOD! :)
Channel076 1 year ago
you sang great. i dont know why some people are saying they dont like it..
tink62795 1 year ago
You have a pretty voice!
danyellewelsh 1 year ago
Not bad at all.
Criticalt3 1 year ago
Very talented luv it:)
skyyluvable 1 year ago
Parabéns adorei a musica e o video !!!!!!!!!!!
Bjssssssssss do Brasil
airondelima 1 year ago
keep practicing!! and don't let anyone get in your way...
yoh1954 1 year ago
no feelings. i dont like it.
CelineLovesJoline 1 year ago
you sing with your feelings that's very....Beautiful
I love the heart on the Cheek :)
phillipoph 1 year ago
hey, you're wonderful! check out my version!
Katie0813 1 year ago
Thought it was a pimple on your cheek, but it's a heart so nevermind. prettygood!
MONSTERisa 1 year ago
i adore this song, and i admire you for posting this. im sure whoever watches this and posts rude comment is jealous and no where near as good of a singer as you. given, everyone has the right to their own opinion. but with that, you do have a lovely voice. and you're a very pretty girl! :)
mrs6531 1 year ago
Great Cover :)
BellaSorriso 1 year ago
you are so good at singing btw.. i wish i could sing like you :D xx
oliviaelwell 1 year ago
Very nice voice (;
Daanieelitaaful 1 year ago
gee she aint that bad
tomt12d 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you cant sing. plz delete this. my ears bleed.
kooofan 1 year ago
@kooofan :P
roseysmusic 1 year ago
Comment removed
carl11jones 1 year ago
@kooofan Harsh much?
chunkyxsushi 1 year ago
Comment removed
ThePoquitooo4 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kooofan rude. first watch her other videos, then upload some real videos, then try singing as good as her, and THEN you can talk. but not til then. k bye.
ThePoquitooo4 1 year ago
Comment removed
carl11jones 1 year ago
@kooofan your an idiot mate.
carl11jones 1 year ago
@kooofan She CAN sing. Very good. I love it. Don't say she can't sing. (or was it a joke??)
karlijn1997 1 year ago
I think you are very beautiful. :) in a non creepy and weird way lol
sirchristian12 1 year ago
just some constructive criticism:
you try to hard, your not singing naturally. It doesnt sound good because your forcing yourself to sing something you can't sing. Trust me i've been singin for 9 years now both publically and privately. Good luck x
GawgGyal2 1 year ago 59
@GawgGyal2 didn't you say this on someone else's cover of the exact same thing? just sayin.
hayjayjay 1 year ago
@GawgGyal2 i agree. good voice. wrong song
sweetnsassycutie29 1 year ago
@GawgGyal2 i'm musical theater trained so its probably jsut a different style :)
roseysmusic 10 months ago 2
@roseysmusic that's very diffrent! I had the same problem. I almost lost my voice because I sang wrong. Maybe it is good if you also do pop. I did it and now I sing better as before.
mikatoen 8 months ago
@roseysmusic we'll wait to see your videos posted GawgGyal2.. she's doin it.. what about u?
drum2liv4 8 months ago
@roseysmusic honey. its very obvious you weren't trained by anything but the radio. good song. not a horrible voice but a very poor presentation of it.
AllAmericanDollyrot 7 months ago
@GawgGyal2 get off your fuckin high horse love
YDKmayyaaaa 10 months ago
your a really good singer and guitarist, but you just need to work on the strumming pattern
really good though xx
xxkatie2804xx 1 year ago
you have a cool voice!! I have also made a cover of this song, please check it out!! :p
Therastic 1 year ago
you're very good :) beautiful voice :)
MarcoMovies94 1 year ago
@RegalMommy....I AGREE!!!
clairebear112995 1 year ago
@clairebear112995 sorry! i wouldn't recommend looking at youtube covers if just one rendition causes you so much misery :P
roseysmusic 1 year ago
o my god... :/ please don't do this again.. ever... I really liked this song - likeD.
defu6 1 year ago
@defu6 well my view of music on youtube is that it gives you a place to add a little bit of your own to a song you like. sorry that its not a replica, that would be a little boring, right?
roseysmusic 1 year ago
that was really good(=. lol i personally think you should have more view and stuff.
XxWeLiveByMusicxX 1 year ago
@XxWeLiveByMusicxX thank you! you're awesooommmmee!
roseysmusic 1 year ago
That's very greeeaat ! :)
Alicounette92 1 year ago 2
@Alicounette92 you're very greeeeaaatt! :)))
roseysmusic 1 year ago
It's only me or this is the greatest cover ever?
MarquesZero 1 year ago
@MarquesZero awww thank you :))
roseysmusic 1 year ago
so cute !
marquitotltc 1 year ago
@marquitotltc thank you :)
roseysmusic 1 year ago
i didn't like the rhythm.. but you have an spectacular voice !
Joseesongs 1 year ago
@Joseesongs hmm by rhythm do you mean the strumming pattern or the pace?
roseysmusic 1 year ago
you are horrible. PLEASE don't sing anymore.
petrushka123 1 year ago
@petrushka123 haha i love it waaaay to much to stop. i'd recommend just not listening :P
roseysmusic 1 year ago
not just the pretty face =)
irmutis26 1 year ago
@irmutis26 aww thank you :)
roseysmusic 1 year ago
I liked it :) how long have you been playing for? And do you need a capo for this song? sorry i cant tell if you are using one or if thats just your strap :D
SorrelBeya 1 year ago
@SorrelBeya yeah its a capo on fret 2
skillzzd 1 year ago
@SorrelBeya hmmm maybe about a year and a half? and yes cappo on the 2nd fret.
roseysmusic 1 year ago
I'll admit it wasn't one of my favorite covers, but I like the way you changed the song a bit...made it your own (:
laurenlimegreen111 1 year ago
@laurenlimegreen111 thanks :)
roseysmusic 1 year ago
you have a fantastic voice. i don't know whatsome of the other people are talking about... i have been singing for a while and i wish i had your voice! mine is.. different.. hahaa. well, i loved your version a lot. and i don't think you ruined the song.. at all.
hjfroxx123 1 year ago
@hjfroxx123 thank you so much!!
roseysmusic 1 year ago
which chords did you use ? Not bad:)
IhfAmerika1011 1 year ago
my burf is the 13 day before valentines lol. u have a strong controlled voice. its awesome. you did a good job. i like how u changed it up. Grool! lol
RobertBustamante 1 year ago
@RobertBustamante YES! mean girls reference! i love it :) hahah thank you!
roseysmusic 1 year ago
@roseysmusic :)
RobertBustamante 1 month ago
Wow, you have an absolutely gorgeous voice :)
you might want to work on the guitar playing a little bit....more on the strumming
other then that, i loved it! your great :D
ViviandRennOfficial 1 year ago
I think thats great!
basarbovo 1 year ago
luv it!!! screw u haterz!!
edwardsonlyangel 1 year ago
you have a really original voice :)
check out my cover of the song... :D
good work :D
alyvony10 1 year ago
Wonderfully done!
KimberlyClarke24 1 year ago
I love this song! Oh, all the covers you did are all my favs to sing, ;) Keep it up, love.
Your voice is :O amazing, ♥. Rosey :D
rosesmelly 1 year ago
really good you even kind look like her well the hair at least :D
JJhypa3 1 year ago
i think you have an amazing voice and i love your vibrato i want to sing with you!!!lol no i really do tho...i love singing...!!!!love it
sarahmarie1450 1 year ago
Its..ok, pretty good :]
americangirllover300 1 year ago
i really like this :D i subscribed x
xxxJodyCourtxxx 1 year ago
you have an awesome voice! keep up the good work.
musicgirl59 1 year ago
i can't believe what some people have said here!
you are a fantastic singer, and you did such a good job there, don't let anyone put you down :) x
keepondreamingx 1 year ago
You have a great voice. But I think it sounds more than a pop voice. For this song it's to much.. pop.
Your voice is very strong and I think for this song is a voice better, which has not so much power. :D
SophieLikesCakes 1 year ago
i really like it. :-)
mathildebengtsson 1 year ago
Amanda is much better
Supernathje 1 year ago
wow, some people are such haters, only because they wish they could sing as well as you. great job!
xtinasexsmith 1 year ago
errr i don't want to be rude your voice is good but you should have more practice i think
wycka001 1 year ago
Pretty guitar, you did a great job. You kinda sound like your holding back on the high parts though. Just let go! Sing it loud! :)
guitargirl70 1 year ago
@guitargirl70 thanks haha i was trying to sing it in my mix lol.
roseysmusic 1 year ago
not that bad.
insaneOCD 1 year ago 8
NICE but whats the strumming like ?
slangvibe